Kingsblood VII: Sphinxes, Chimerae, Gargoyles, and Dragons
We examine Maester Aemon's comment to Samwell Tarly that "the Sphinx is the riddle, not the riddler."
Hello, and welcome to the Bard’s Truth, with your host, the Green Bard. This is Kingsblood VII, Sphinxes, Gargoyles and Dragons. In this episode We examine Maester Aemon’s comment to Samwell Tarly that “the Sphinx is the riddle, not the riddler.” I think this is presented to us as an obvious riddle, one we are invited to solve: Who and what are the sphinx(es) the Aemon is talking about?
Here’s…
View On WordPress
0 notes
The final episode and culmination of the series, presents my signature theory on what we all think is to come in Jon and Ghost's story in the forthcoming "The Winds of Winter." Fitting that I release this on Easter!
This is the most important theory I have. You can watch the vid or read it here below the line. I look forward to your comments.
Thx to the artists
@minuiko
@mylestoyne
@shebsart
@yvyb
@sir-heartsalot-blog
@chillyravenart
and many more!
__________________________________
The Direwolves of Winterfell Episode 6-17 - Epilogue: Jon's Second and Third Life
Now we’ll turn to what everyone seems to think will happen next: Jon starting his “second life” inside Ghost, before eventually being resurrected back into his own body. It is foreshadowed in Melisandre's POV:
His long face floated before her, limned in tongues of red and orange, appearing and disappearing again, a shadow half-seen behind a fluttering curtain. Now he was a man, now a wolf, now a man again. But the skulls were here as well, the skulls were all around him.
A Dance with Dragons - Melisandre I
So Mel says he'll be a man, then a wolf, then a man again. I, like many that that passage combined with the information about the "second life" from Varamyr's prologue chapter together hint that Jon's becoming a wolf happens when he speaks the name "Ghost" while his body is dying in his final POV chapter. From the Prologue:
Haggon's rough voice echoed in his head. "You will die a dozen deaths, boy, and every one will hurt … but when your true death comes, you will live again. The second life is simpler and sweeter, they say."
A Dance With Dragons - Prologue
... later ...
Varamyr could feel the snowflakes melting on his brow. This is not so bad as burning. Let me sleep and never wake, let me begin my second life. His wolves were close now. He could feel them. He would leave this feeble flesh behind, become one with them, hunting the night and howling at the moon. The warg would become a true wolf.
A Dance With Dragons - Prologue
There is one other thing that ties the passages of Jon and Varamyr's deaths: In the Prologue, as Varamyr leaves his body, he “was rising, melting, his spirit borne on some cold wind.” This seems a parallel to the last line of Jon’s story as he presumably also leaves his body. When as he’s stabbed for the fourth time, he doesn’t feel it, "only the cold." If you didn’t catch that, the cold is what their deaths have in common.
We also see a parallel in Jon and Robb's deaths, where both speak their wolves' names as their last words. Again, like many, I consider the use of the boys’ wolves names to be evidence that they are about to spend their “second life” in those wolves. While Robb's second life would have been very short, since Grey Wind is immediately killed, Jon's soul will travel into Ghost, where he will remain for a quite a while before eventually being resurrected.
There are a myriad ideas as to how he is resurrected and what he will be like afterward. Some think he will be changed a lot, like how Lady Stoneheart is only a shadow of her former self after Beric brings her back. Other people think that his magical experience will cause him to transform into a more magical being, sort of "level up" to use gamer talk. Some also think he'll be more "wolfish." I believe more in that latter 2 ideas to a certain extent. We know from out study of Bran and Summer that extended periods of time in the wolf help the warg to embrace the magic, but also to think more like a wolf.
I'll also note that there is a similar resurrection in the Farseer series by Robin Hobb, a fantasy author that GRRM greatly admires. In that book, after spending several days in his wolf, the character is returned to his body, which had been buried earlier that day (disinterred the same night). In that book, it takes the hero many months to feel again like a human. and he never was the same. Jon may experience something similar.
I do think that Jon will pay some price for this initial death, in any case; he will certainly not be the same exact character upon his return to his body. Perhaps his body will also have some debilitating issues. We know that cold wights and fire wights don't really have flowing blood, so they don't really respire like true humans. It is my firm hope that Jon's body will be something more after his resurrection, truly a living body, somehow restored of his lost blood, flowing again. The only mechanism for this is transfusion (blood sacrifice?) after his body is warmed following being frozen quickly upon his death. "Cold preserves," as we know. All of this is potentially feasible... The stab wound to the gut sure is a problem though... oof... maybe he got lucky and nothing critical was punctured?
Setting that aside, there is also the complication of whether it is possible for Jon's soul to escape Ghost's body back into his own. I believe that our study of Ghost and his actions throughout the story give some pretty good clues to that, but first, let's study Varamyr's thoughts related to that concept.
He thinks his “second life” will be the limit, that once he goes into that vessel, he'll die for real once it dies. Note that the vessel Varamyr finally goes into is his wolf One-Eye, but prior to that, he tries to take over the body of the wildling Thistle. While it would be cool for a skinchanger to flip from one body to the next, and then to the next endlessly, I think our author has set bounds to limit this from happening, save in a few special cases. The key passage to understanding the limit to second lives is when he contemplates taking Thistle's body:
His gift would perish with his body, he expected. He would lose his wolves, and live out the rest of his days as some scrawny, warty woman … but he would live.
A Dance With Dragons - Prologue
Note that he explicitly ties the gift (his ability to skinchange) to his own body, not to his consciousness. Well... that makes me think that in cases where a skinchanger starts their second life in a body that also had “the gift”, that a third life is possible. In Jon's case, I believe that this third life would be in his own resurrected body, after having spent a short second life inside Ghost. Some in the fandom, like David Lightbringer, suggest that Ghost needs to be sacrificed for Jon to escape the vessel of Ghost's body. I firmly reject this, nor do I expect it (although I wouldn't put it past the author to have Mel do this misguidedly, tragically, and ironically).
I believe I’ve made a very strong case in this series that Ghost possesses a body that has, in Varamyr's terms "the gift," or in Mel's terms, kingsblood." Ghost, is more than just a direwolf, he is a creature of magic. The red eyes gave it away; the telepathic communication at his first contact with Jon gives it away, and myriad other examples we have covered give it away. That’s right. One of the keys to Jon becoming wolf, then going back to being a man is that Ghost is the equivalent of a greenseer direwolf. Jon can jump back to his own body using Ghost’s gift.
I’ve been working toward this moment through 6 essays and 124,829 words to tell you this one thing... that Jon can have a third life because he is living his second life in the telepathically gifted Ghost, who is capable of his own second life. <<drops mic>>.
Now, that was not the only reason I wrote all these essays, and it certainly was not the only thing I learned about direwolves and skinchanging while on this exploration. I know some things. But to prove that Ghost has a greenseer level of the magical gift was the most important part of this whole adventure. I think that we’ve learned that Ghost is definitely much more capable than his siblings (with the possible exception of Shaggy, for whom we have such limited information) in telepathic ability. As to my hypothesis that it is because of his eyes, I can’t say for sure. I can say that it was either a genetic gift tied to his eye color or a genetic gift that is tied to him being an albino. We don’t have enough information to discern the genetic cause.
Either way, we’ve proven Ghost can communicate telepathically much more strongly than Summer or Nymeria. I think the evidence shows that he can reach out telepathically to humans in the same way that human skinchangers reach out telepathically to other beasts. While Bran and Summer’s bond is currently the strongest pair studied, seemingly because of Bran’s gift being stronger, Ghost’s power leaves open the potential for his bond to Jon to rival Bran and Summer’s as the story continues to develop.
Other than Ghost’s telepathic gift being stronger, he exhibits all the same direwolf themes as the others, mirroring, shadowing, obedience, ferocity and inspiring fear, bad things happening when away from his Stark, and affection when near. Specific to Ghost, we saw his theme of silence over and over again and some evidence that he may to be prone to manipulation by 3rd parties. We did not uncover a lot of evidence of this in his packmates, although maybe we would if we had looked more closely for it.
The only thing that is left to discuss in this episode is to contemplate how Jon will be resurrected. The fandom has various theories on this. Most probably think Melisandre will resurrect him one way or another. Some have suggested that the others also might also be part of reanimating his body as a cold wight. Some also think that Bran or someone might be part of it. I can't be sure, but since I want Jon to have flowing blood, I favor the latter, knowing the examples we have for cold and fire wights not having flowing blood. My own personal speculation is that Mel might try some kind of sacrifice, and Jon, as Ghost, seeing this, might willingly return to his body to try to avert her plan (iespecially since ghost can't speak..., his theme of silence returning).
And with that that we are done with direwolf bonds!
TL;DR I discuss parallels between Jon's death and that of several other dearly departed & not quite departed in #asoiaf, including Drogo, Cat, Robb/Grey Wind, but especially Varamyr. His exposition re: "the gift" and the 2nd life are keys to my theory on Jon's 3rd life / resurrection. Basically Ghost has the gift, so Jon can escape his body back into his own when it is resurrected.
0 notes