All Too Well (Spencer Reid x Reader)
summary: reader sees spencer years after their college relationship wearing their scarf. they remember how everything ended and how they both have learned to exist without each other.
series summary: a series of oneshots to celebrate the release of red (taylor's version). 19 songs, 19 fics.
pairing: spencer reid x gn!reader
category: all too well levels of angst. all too well levels of no happy ending.
content warnings: language, discussions of bullying and abuse (spencer’s past), insecurities, breakups, sexual reference (it’s implied what they do)
word count: 10.4k for the 10 minutes of all too well that’ll crush our hearts in two weeks
a/n: we made it!! this is easily one of my favorite songs on the album and i think it’s easy to tell since this is double the length of all the others. so, um, sorry about that. i picture this being s5 spencer, at least in the present time of the fic.
series masterlist
masterlist
send me a request!
“I forgot about you long enough to forget why I needed to...”
There was a time when you wished for an eidetic memory. It would have helped during those long nights spent studying in college or when you inevitably forgot the birthday of someone you knew. Now, years down the road, you were grateful that wishes on shooting stars didn’t come true.
Six years after the breakup, you had nearly forgotten how Spencer Reid broke you to pieces. It had once felt like an irreparable break, a deep scar that would constantly leak life-blood no matter how much you tried to stop it. Maybe it was because you stayed in Pasadena, the city you’d met and fell in love with the beautiful genius, or maybe it was because he’d been the first person you truly loved. It felt impossible once upon a time, but now you woke up and went to bed without once thinking of him.
That is, until life decided that was just too easy for you.
The day itself started out strange. You’d made your way down to the CalTech campus, dropping your bag off at your office only to find a voicemail from your boss telling you to meet him first thing that morning. It wasn’t like you were apathetic toward the situation; it was horrifying what the recent serial killer was doing to those poor women. Still, you couldn’t help but be annoyed that the FBI would be interrupting your lecture. They promised your boss they wouldn’t disturb the learning process, but you knew college students. It would absolutely take over their attention as soon as the agents walked through the door. That was the only reason you hated the idea, not at all because you had a bad history with the FBI.
You were determined to not let this ruin your lecture, the FBI could not take anything else from you, consequences be damned. It was a determination that remained fiery and warmed you through the cooling Autumn walk from your office to the lecture hall. It kept you moving quickly around the room, organizing and writing all of the information you’d need on the blackboard, proud when you kept your hands steady enough for the words to be legible.
Then your students began filing in. It was only the ones who showed up far too early to everything, much like you’d done in school. Then you saw the first person you didn’t recognize slipping through the door; a blond woman with such bright blue eyes you could see them from where you stood. Then an absolutely gorgeous man who was clearly teasing the guy next to him, who was-
No, absolutely fucking not. You spun on your heels quickly, feeling your sense of fight-or-flight kicking in. Eyes darting around the room, you searched for another exit, a way to get out of this room because you hadn’t been this close to him in six years and he was still capable of taking your breath away. Your body still remembered what it felt like to be held by him and even now yearned to slot itself perfectly into his arms as if that was the place you were meant to be. Your hands gripped the edge of the desk tightly as though that were your only lifeline left in the middle of the fucking ocean. Maybe it was, because your legs shook and you weren’t sure they could carry your weight if you let go.
You would find out though because that familiar voice was calling out your name. Feeling like you shouldn’t have gotten out of bed this morning, you pulled as genuine a smile as you could manage and turned back to face the trio of agents. At least he seemed as shaken as you did, amber eyes comically wide and lips parted in shock. He looked different than when you’d last seen him, of course, he had. His hair had gotten longer—before, you would have been overjoyed he listened to your advice on the matter—and he no longer wore the glasses you knew him to always have on.
That wasn’t the worst part of it all though. No, you could handle the fact that your ex-boyfriend, the man that destroyed your heart in a way you hadn’t thought possible, somehow got more attractive. What you couldn’t handle was the purple scarf hung loosely around his neck. Memories of you wrapping that same scarf around him when he was cold flooded your mind, making you wish you had amnesia. He’d always been much colder than you, not used to the chill but still protesting taking any of your warm clothes. You hadn’t known where that scarf went, but now you were staring at it still wrapped around him and you understood how some people literally died of a broken heart. It burned in your chest, filling you with an urge to reach in and discard it because how could this much physical pain exist just from seeing someone?
“Dr. Calwell told me why you guys were here. I just ask that you try not to distract my students too much,” you spoke, and any other time you’d wince at how robotic your voice sounded. Now it was a victory because it didn’t show him the pain taking over your body now.
The other two nodded, giving you quick platitudes and promises not to be a disruption before finding seats in the back of the room. Spencer didn’t move, still just looking at you with an unreadable expression. That hurt more than you’d like to admit; there was once a time when you knew every one of his microexpression but now he was little more than a stranger.
“Y/N,” he spoke again and this time your resolve cracked in a way that infuriated you. How dare he still have a hold on you after all these years?
“Dr. Reid, I have a class to teach,” you spoke dully, turning again to gather the lecture plan you had in your bag.
“Do you remember anything about us?”
You mourned the crinkles that formed in your lecture plan as your hand curled around it. Strangely the now crumpled paper now looked a lot how you felt, irreparably changed and easily discarded by the man right behind you. He wore your scarf like a trophy, a reminder that he’d had you and chose to give you up. You could’ve had me, Spencer, you could’ve had more than a scarf.
“I was there, Spencer. I remember everything, all of it,” you spat as you turned to face him again, thankful it was still early enough that there weren’t more students in the room. “I remember all too well what you did to me.”
“What happened wasn’t all my fault, Y/N,” he tried again and you couldn’t help but disagree. This man had broken you, left you with once-happy memories that were now tainted and poisonous. “I miss you.”
It couldn’t be anything but Spencer’s fault that you two were standing together for the first time in six years.
“Autumn leaves falling down like pieces into place, and I can picture it after all these days...”
Autumn was always one of your favorite seasons. Back home you could see visible signs of change; leaves melting into warm colors and falling like snow to the ground. Sunrises would come later and would be more vibrantly pink and orange, bathing the entire sky in the colors of the leaves. It was your second Autumn in Pasadena and you were beginning to think you would always miss the way your hometown embraced the full swath of the season.
With Autumn came midterm exams and so many papers due that you were sure you’d never sleep again. As time went on, your hours of sleep decreased and the number of coffees you drank increased until there was a good chance your bloodstream was nothing but caffeine.
It was impossible to forget that day, though. After staying up nearly all night studying for your midterm, you’d managed to fall asleep at your desk and sleep right through half of it. With panic surging through your body, you got dressed and sprinted through the chilled Autumn morning to make it to the lecture hall.
“I’m sorry, Y/N, you’re too late. You’re going to have to take the fail,” your professor told you, practically stabbing the words straight through your chest.
“I can’t take a failing grade for this, Sir. Please, is there anything else I can do?” you begged, thinking of how you would tell your family about this. They always expected so much out of you, how could you possibly tell them about a failure of this magnitude?
“Your only other option is to go through a remediation course with one of our TAs,” he explained, “It will be a couple of weeks outside of class, and at the end you will have a chance to take the midterm. Keep in mind that remediation is meant to be intensive, this would be a lot of extra work on you.”
There was no other option in your mind. If it added onto your stress, so be it. You could have time to relax after you graduated, but until then you would do what it took to keep your grades high. CalTech had an amazing doctorate program for chemistry and it would take a nearly perfect portfolio to land a spot.
That was how you met Spencer Reid. All of the TAs were graduate students, but with slicked back hair, large glasses, and an adorable button-nose, you couldn’t help but think he looked younger than you. Of course, you already knew about Spencer. He was a living legend at CalTech, having started when he was 12 and having gotten a PhD by 16. The man was your age and already working toward his second doctorate. You assumed he’d be a pompous asshole.
So while everyone else in your class was finishing up the midterm, you walked alongside Spencer Reid to a portion of the library where you could talk. You should’ve been the nervous one, but his long fingers shook as he pulled out the necessary books and worksheets. He licked his lips a little more than normal and his eyes continuously flitted up to meet yours before immediately looking back down. The poor kid, you had to put him out of his misery.
“Hi, I’m Y/N L/N,” you introduced, waving a little from across the table.
He smiled, a little one with so much tension around his lips it looked like he might’ve been stifling it. “I’m Spencer Reid.”
“Well, with you at the reins I have no choice but to pass,” you joked and were pleasantly surprised when he seemed more bashful about it than arrogant. “I do feel confident about the material though, so I’m not sure the whole remediation thing is necessary.”
“Dr. Calwell said you failed the midterm.” Ouch. For some reason, you didn’t want him to think of you as anything less than brilliant.
“I didn’t show up to the midterm. I would’ve passed if I had, maybe even have gotten the top score.” You didn’t truly believe that; you knew better than to think you were always the smartest person in the room.
“Could I test that theory?” Spencer immediately blurted out, then his eyes widened and he added, “Not that I don’t believe you, but I want to stay on Dr. Calwell’s good side before my thesis defense.”
“So what’s it like being a genius?” You hadn’t meant to ask the question, but once it was out in the open you couldn’t help but want an answer.
“What?”
“I mean, it’s gotta be a lot of pressure, right? Practically everyone on campus knows your name.”
“Are you stalling studying chemistry?”
A laugh slipped from you then and you shrugged, leaning forward in your seat. “Maybe a little. I am curious, though. I don’t know if I could handle it.”
Spencer was quiet for a moment then, eyes taking on a faraway look as though he’d never actually thought about this before. Then his gaze snapped back to yours, his honeyed eyes taking in everything about your expression. “I guess I’m worried I won’t live up to everyone’s expectations of me. School’s been the only thing I’m good at for so long that I’m scared to try doing anything else.”
“Well, you could always be a professor,” you tried, immediately laughing at the way Spencer’s nose crinkled at the idea.
“I don’t think I’m cut out for constant public speaking. I don’t do well talking to strangers.”
“You’re doing just fine with me,” you pointed out, trying to help the cause.
“I guess you’re right,” he admitted softly, and damn did you love that smile. You hoped in your couple of weeks together that you could elicit more of those smiles.
“If we’re going to be working together, Spencer, you’ve gotta know that I’m always right.”
“It’s statistically possible to get 60% of questions correct on an exam if you guess on each one,” he answered, and the blunt honesty was enough to pull a laugh from you loud enough that the students at the table next to you flashed you an annoyed look.
“Okay, I like you, Spencer Reid.”
“And there we are again on that little town street, you almost ran the red 'cause you were lookin' over at me...”
“Hey, Wonder Boy,” you greeted, plopping down in the hard library chair and wincing at the sting of impact.
“You’re in a good mood,” Spencer noted, looking up from his notes and smiling at you. A month later, you had successfully saved your grade (and learned a thing or two from Spencer) and made a new friend in the Caltech resident genius. The pair of you often studied together, you with your undergrad chemistry work and him typing up his chemistry doctoral thesis. Sometimes you could help him with the wording of things, or he could help you with a particularly brutal problem, but most of the time you sat in each other’s company, ankles tangled together under the table.
That wasn’t what you wanted to do today, though.
“Remember how you saved my life?” you began, watching the pure confusion melt over Spencer’s expression.
“I have an eidetic memory and I don’t recall any such occasion, Y/N.”
“You’re mistaken then, because I definitely remember you saving my organic chemistry grade thus saving my college career, allowing my hopes and dreams to still come true, thus saving my life.”
“Then yes, I remember saving your life,” Spencer chuckled.
“I want to do something for you in return.”
“Y/N, you really don’t have to. It was literally my job to help you.”
“You’re right, as always, but I want to,” you answered, deciding then that the word ‘no’ wasn’t on a list of words you understood for the time being. “You know how you said the only reason you don’t drive is that you don’t have anyone to teach you?”
“Yes?”
“Well, I want to teach you.”
“I don’t want to make you do something like that for me,” Spencer protested, but he shut his book anyway. “I don’t even have my temporary permit or a car.”
“That takes an hour to get especially since I know you know the info on the test. You can use my car, and does it really look like you’re making me do it? C’mon, Spence. One driving lesson? And if you hate it I’ll never bring it up again and you can keep biking to campus.”
That was how, three hours later, you sat in the passenger seat as Spencer drove your car around a small neighborhood you’d found.
“How’d you know where to go?” Spencer asked, not daring to take his eyes off the road. “This is the perfect spot to practice, but it’s so far from campus. How did you find it?”
“Don’t you ever just explore the city?” The silence was a resounding no. “I love to just drive or walk around Pasadena, sometimes even LA if I have enough time. It’s fun to get lost in a part of the city you don’t know, then you get to explore more of it trying to find your way back.”
“Isn’t that terrifying? What if you really get lost?” Spencer dared a glance at you as he turned onto a road just outside of the neighborhood; not busy but still having enough traffic to be a challenge.
“Then it takes me a bit longer to get home.”
“Y/N, you have to know how dangerous that is.”
“Of course it is,” you answered, and Spencer really didn’t like that one.
“Y/N!” he protested, lips parted in horror.
“What’s life without a little risk?” you countered. “The chaos of the universe is so beautiful sometimes, you know? Two people can do the exact same thing and still end up with wildly different outcomes. I can take the same risks as someone else and end up okay, and I’d like to think it’s because the universe wants me to be okay. I don’t know,” you punctuated the phrase with a shrug, “maybe it’s a little silly. Maybe I’m just putting myself in danger for no reason like an idiot.”
Spencer turned his head to fully look at you then, eyes alight with sudden anger. “You’re a lot of things, Y/N, but you’re not an idiot.”
“What am I then?”
Spencer’s gaze softened to something you’d never seen on him before. If you didn’t know any better, you might’ve called it love. All you knew was that one look from him made you feel like a comet, a beautiful phenomenon for him to gaze upon.
Until out of the corner of your eyes you noticed the quickly approaching red light. “Spencer!” you squealed, hand reaching forward to grip the dashboard as he slammed to a stop. Your heart was racing, suddenly breathless at the thought of how badly that could’ve turned out.
He seemed breathless too, his usually perfectly slicked back hair falling into his face a little. He was still staring at you, and you wondered if he was speechless because of the danger or because of you. Reaching up, you brushed a lock of hair away from his face, tucking it back behind his ear and restoring his always pristine look.
“See what I mean about risk-taking?” you spoke, each word breathy as you found yourself unable to tear your gaze away. You thought of the chemistry notes sitting in your bag, about how certain particles were meant to come together. They would try whatever it would take to come together, constantly pulled together by an unknown force. That was what you felt now with Spencer, your head leaning forward until your lips touched his. It was gentle; a kiss filled with so much care you wondered if he thought of you as something to be treasured.
“I do see what you mean,” Spencer told you, a smile lighting up his entire expression. This was happiness in its purest form.
Then a car’s horn blared from behind you, causing your body to jerk and twist forward again. Oh, the light was green. How long had it been like that? Spencer continued driving, the two of you in comfortable silence for a couple of minutes. It hadn’t even been obvious before that you felt this way for him, just now did you realize how happy it made you that you knew what Spencer’s lips felt like on your own.
“That was my first kiss,” Spencer admitted, maybe feeling more confident now that he could focus on the road instead of on you. His cheeks were flushed pink, though, and you reached out to squeeze the crook of his elbow once, light enough to not interfere with his driving but enough to let him know you were there.
“Really? I hope it was everything you thought it’d be.” The idea that you were the first person, the only person, who knew what it was like to kiss Spencer Reid sent a thrill through you.
“All and more.” You wondered if this was how you looked after your first kiss too; trying and failing to suppress the wide smile, eyes shining and cheeks pink. It made you want to experience so much more with him. Before today you hadn’t thought about what it would be like to share your life with him, but now sitting in a car beside Spencer it was all you could imagine.
“'Cause there we are again in the middle of the night, we're dancing 'round the kitchen in the refrigerator light...”
It was the happiest year of your life, that first one you got to spend with Spencer. It was a whirlwind of smiles, laughter, and kisses that grew more confident than the first. It was the kind of love that belonged in a fairytale, the kind that made you wake up in the morning and hope that it wasn’t all a dream.
By November of the following year, the two of you had decided to take the next step. A friend of yours was unexpectedly leaving the city and needed someone to finish out the lease on their apartment. You’d mentioned it to Spencer, thinking he might’ve known someone who needed a new place to live. Turns out he did; it just came in the form of asking you to move into said apartment with him.
“How many books do you have?” you groaned as you picked up a box labelled as such, already feeling the way your arms would be gelatinous by the time everything was moved into the apartment.
“Fifty-seven,” Spencer piped up from the van, picking up a small box because he needed a free hand to unlock the door.
“Of course you know the answer to that.” You were no longer surprised by what Spencer knew, having learned a long time ago how impressive his mind was.
“You don’t?” The words were so innocent and genuine that you couldn’t help but pause on the stairs to look at him.
“No, Spencer, I don’t know off the top of my head how many books I have. I love that you do, though,” you spoke before realizing what you’d said. Spencer realized though, he always did.
“Love?” he’d practically squeaked the words out, surprise written all over his expression.
You considered it for a moment, head tilted in wonder. Every morning you would wake up and look forward to going to class every day because it meant seeing Spencer in the library. He would walk you home at the end of every day even if he hadn’t needed to be on campus that day, at first citing the dangers of walking home alone at night and then admitting he wanted to have more time with you. Dates spent in one of your apartments when he got too overwhelmed to be in public crowds, or picnics in the local park where you got to show off your cooking because—while he’d never admit it—he adored that you cooked for him because no one really had before. Sticky notes clung to nearly everything you had with little doodles or sweet words he’d thought of in the moment but had been too nervous to say aloud.
“Yes, Spencer, love,” you told him, “I love you.”
It was possible you broke your boyfriend. He stood there on the stares, hands curled into the box he was holding and face frozen in shock. Then the familiar lower lip quiver and his eyes glassed over. “Hey, hey, hey, why’re you crying?” you exclaimed, setting your own box down in favor of backtracking on the steps until you were the same height as him. You reached up, gently wiping the escapee tears away with your fingers before resting your hands on his cheeks. “Talk to me, Spencer. If that was too much, or you don’t feel the same way, it’s okay, alright? We can forget I said anything. It’s okay, Spence.”
“No, I don’t want to forget,” he forced out, a small embarrassed pull of his lips came as his voice came out wet with the unshed tears.
“Then talk to me.”
You waited patiently as he gathered himself. It was lucky the apartment complex didn’t seem to be busy because you two stood on those main stairs for a while as he got his thoughts together. Being open about his feelings had always been tough for him, so you could wait here all day if you needed to.
“I didn’t think I was meant to be loved by someone like you.”
The words burned through your chest; a hot poker shoved deep and twisting for maximal pain. You’d known Spencer was insecure about a lot of things. He’d always look down when people mentioned his intelligence as if waiting for a blow that didn’t come. His shoulders would curl forward and he’d keep his hands up in front of his stomach, physical measures of protecting himself in the only way he knew how.
“C’mon,” you finally forced out, having a plan but also needing the rest of the walk up the stairs to compose yourself. It wouldn’t do to let him see you cry, not after he’d been so open with you finally. If he saw you crying, then Spencer would shut down the entire conversation about himself in lew of making you feel better. So, you picked the box back up with one arm (even though it killed your arm to do so) and took Spencer’s open hand in the other, guiding him up to your new apartment.
You took the keys from him and unlocked the door, walking inside first and setting the box down wherever you could. The apartment was beautiful; a clear step up from your own previous space. You left the lights off, knowing sometimes all of the bright lights could make a person feel more exposed than anything. The darkness was a comfort, but you also knew Spencer was uncomfortable with total darkness.
The only solution you had was guiding him into the kitchen and flicking open the empty fridge to bathe the small room in the dull light.
“What are you doing?” Spencer asked you, eyes narrowed and eyebrows pushed together in his confusion.
Instead of answering, you guided his hands to your hips and wrapped your own up around his neck. “Dance with me?” you whispered in his ear.
“I don’t know how to dance,” were his soft words back.
“Yes, you do. Trust yourself,” you whispered back, helping him out by beginning to sway. He caught on and joined you, the two of you swaying and stepping around your new kitchen.
“There’s no music.”
“Who needs music when we have each other?” you countered and it seemed that was enough for Spencer because he didn’t answer again. Finally, finally, you dared touch the statement he’d made on the stairs. “You are so unbelievably worthy of love, Spencer. I hate that anyone made you feel like you weren’t because I feel so lucky to get to love you.” You tucked your head against his neck in the hopes of hiding the tears sprouting unbidden from your eyes, though were sure he could hear them in your voice. “I’ll tell you every day if that’s what it takes. I love you so much, Spencer, and you are meant to be loved.”
“You’re so cheesy,” Spencer laughed wetly over his own tears, arms squeezing you closer to him if that were even possible.
“I know, it’s my specialty. I do mean it though. You’re remarkable, Spence,” you answered and you could feel the inhalation in his chest from his practiced response. “Not just because of your brain, silly. I love everything about you. You’re sweet, you’re so kind to everyone even strangers. You’re so funny it catches me off-guard sometimes and you are so determined to help the world that I have no doubt you’re going to someday.”
“Y/N.” No one had ever said your name like that before. No one would say it like that again for years after him. His fingers were curled tightly into the fabric of your shirt, you two still swaying in the dull refrigerator light but not moving much beyond it.
“Yeah?” Your voice was small, unsure. What if it was too much? You’d said the word so many times, what if he didn’t feel the same way back?
“There are approximately 171,146 words in the English language, and yet there are none good enough to explain how much I love you, Y/N.” A short, surprised laugh slipped from you as the words registered in your ears. Spencer loved you. He loved you, and you were living together, and maybe that fairytale ending could happen after all.
Eventually, you’d go back to finish moving the rest of your belongings into the apartment. For now, though, both of you were content with dancing around your kitchen and whispering the words back to each other in as many ways as you knew how.
“Photo album on the counter, your cheeks were turning red. You used to be a little kid with glasses in a twin-sized bed...”
“What if she hates me?”
The question had sounded in the car so many times that Spencer already had an answer ready for you. He rolled his eyes playfully and squeezed the hand resting on his leg, saying, “She’s going to love you.”
“But what if she doesn’t?” Currently, you were driving you and your boyfriend to Las Vegas, where you would eventually meet his family. The two of you had been talking about going on a roadtrip for winter break, and somehow it turned into him asking you to meet one of the most important people in his life: his mom.
You’d never dated anyone long enough to meet their family before. Even then, you never pictured meeting them like this, with careful words on what to do if she had a bad episode while you two were there. Spencer had been so cautious with even telling you about where his mom was living that you’d never expected the hurried question to come, telling you that he wanted his mom to know about you.
It was safe to say you were terrified, desperately wanting to make a good impression on the woman who’d gone through so much while raising Spencer.
“Y/N, she’s going to love you because she’s going to see what an amazing person you are. She’ll see how happy you make me and she’ll have no choice but to love you,” Spencer reassured you, drawing little patterns on your hand from the passenger seat, keeping it resting in his lap.
Time flew in a rush until suddenly you were walking into the Bennington Sanitarium with Spencer, following one of the nurses over to where Spencer’s mom was currently in her room curled up with a book.
The relationship between a mother and son was a special thing, especially when they only had each other for so many years. You watched from just inside the doorway as both faces lit up. His mom hugged him tightly, immediately commenting on how thin he still was. “I always knew it was all that coffee you’re drinking, Spencer. You need to eat some real food,” she admonished and Spencer only laughed, shrugging and tucking his hands into his pockets.
“I tell him that almost every day,” you couldn’t help but pipe up, watching how the bright expression never once dulled as she turned her attention over to you.
“You must be this Y/N I keep hearing about,” she spoke up, waving you further into the room.
You reached out for a handshake but just as quickly Spencer’s mom was pulling you into a hug; you could understand now where Spencer got his hugging skills from. “It’s so nice to meet you, Mrs. Reid.”
“Please, only the pushover nurses call me that. It’s Diana.”
“Mom,” Spencer groaned, looking like he wasn’t sure whether to be embarrassed or surprised by the words, “you can’t say that about your nurses. They’re taking care of you.”
Diana only ignored him, keeping her gaze focused on you. If you thought Spencer had a look that pierced right through you, then Diana’s stare didn’t even need to pierce, just floating right through you as if she already knew everything about you. You knew Spencer wrote to her daily, maybe she had heard about you from him before? “I’m happy Spencer finally brought you around to meet me. I wanted to see the person who was taking care of my boy so well.”
“Mom!”
With as much heat rushing to your face, you were sure your cheeks were bright red. “He takes care of me too,” you returned as Diana guided you over to the empty seat beside her chair, leaving Spencer to sit on the end of the bed across from you two.
“He better. He knows better than to throw away something so good for him.” You laughed, smiling wide at the embarrassed look only deepening on Spencer’s face.
It would grow worse when he realized what Diana had grabbed. “Mom, no,” he tried, hands covering his face for a moment but dropping uselessly to his lap when that didn’t stop what was happening. “Y/N doesn’t need to see that.”
Finally, you looked to see what Diana was holding in her hands, and you felt a playful smile pull on your lips. It was a photo album. “Oh, yes I do.”
“Y/N, please,” Spencer tried, but it was too late. Diana was already flipping open the book (thankfully for Spencer’s sake skipping over the baby photos).
“Wait, is that Spence playing baseball?” you gasped, your finger pointing to a picture in the top corner of a page.
Spencer groaned and flopped back on the bed, keeping his hands firmly planted over his face. Diana’s expression took on a fondness as she brushed her fingers over the image. “His father made him play T-ball when he was a kid. My Spencer is good at a lot of things, but baseball’s not one of them.”
You tried to picture this little Spencer playing baseball. His hair was cut not too dissimilar to how it was now, clunkier glasses perched on his nose. All of the dirt, and sports in general, no you couldn’t see it. “I played soccer as a kid for a while,” you added to the story, causing Spencer to sit up and watch you, “I quickly realized I had a greater affinity for the library than the soccer pitch.”
“Crash could’ve used you growing up, I think. You would’ve been good friends.”
You watched as Spencer’s expression tightened. The smile never left his face—though you could guess this was more for his mom’s benefit than anything else—but you saw the signs of his mind drifting off somewhere else nonetheless. You didn’t know the details of Spencer’s childhood, but you recognized the leftover habits from a person who’d been bullied.
Maybe he needed a break from reminiscing about such a painful time for him. He might also appreciate some alone time with his mother. So you stood, telling him, “I think I’m gonna find a bathroom. Stay here with your mom, I’ll ask someone on the staff for help.”
You took your time in the bathroom, stalling by fixing your already perfect hair in the mirror and washing your hands for longer than normal. When you made your way back to Diana’s room, you really hadn’t meant to overhear their conversation. Still, the door was propped open so there was no way not to hear when Spencer said, “I want to marry Y/N, Mom.”
Your hand covered your mouth, desperate not to make a noise and reveal what you’d heard. He wanted to marry you? Suddenly it was easy to picture the two of you having a small wedding just with close friends and family. It would be here in Las Vegas so his mom could be there, and it would be just like the wedding you’d always dreamed of.
When enough time had passed and you successfully schooled your expression back to normal, you walked back into the room. You took in Spencer’s bright smile when he noticed you returning, trying not to picture how he’d smile when he saw you walking down the aisle.
You two stayed with Diana until visitor hours were over. You talked about anything and everything with her. She seemed especially fond of bragging about her son, and you found you also enjoyed that subject. When you two finally got back to the hotel, you laid in bed curled up with Spencer trying not to imagine when he’d propose to you.
“You told me 'bout your past thinking your future was me...”
You only broached the topic of Spencer’s childhood once you were back in Pasadena. It had been a casual night in for the both of you, still on winter break and having minimal responsibilities to tend to. You ended up curled around Spencer for most of the day, talking about anything from your favorite books to what superpower you’d have if you could pick one (barring the obvious ones, it had to be something unique).
And when the conversation lulled into that comfortable silence you found peace in, you propped your chin up against him and asked the question. “Spencer?”
“Y/N?”
“Who hurt you so badly?”
His hand paused its movement against your face, dropping to hold your own hand instead. He didn’t look at you and instead stared at your intertwined hands. You could feel the way his heart began to race and you wondered if now wasn’t the right time to ask.
Then, he sighed, swallowed thickly, and asked a question of his own. “Do you know why my mom calls me Crash?”
“She said because you’re clumsy.”
“That’s true, but it’s not...” Spencer winced, clearly struggling for the right words.
“Take your time, I’m not going anywhere,” you whispered, needing him to know that he would always have you there to support him.
“She used to get confused a lot. It didn’t happen often, but sometimes she accused me of working for the government against her. She’d...” Your heart broke as Spencer snapped his lips shut, unable to say the words aloud. “She never remembered how I got the bruises. I didn’t want to hurt her, so I said I fell or ran into something. She’d laugh and tell me to be more careful with myself.”
“Spencer,” you gasped, trying to reign in the tears but watching your vision blur anyway. You tried to picture that little kid with glasses, dutifully protecting his mother by hiding the fact that she’d been the one to hurt him. You hated that it was so easy to imagine; Spencer always tried to put his loved ones above himself, of course, he’d learned that behavior so young.
“The kids at school gave me plenty of bruises too,” he continued, and as much as you wanted to comfort him you knew better than to interrupt now. “I don’t know if they were jealous about the attention the teachers were giving me, or if they thought a twelve-year-old in high school was an easy target. They’d beat me up whenever they had the chance. Teachers saw it, of course they did but to them, it was just high school kids being kids.
“The worst was in my senior year. This girl, one of the prettiest girls in the school, told me to meet her under the bleachers. That was where kids went to kiss, and I thought that’s what she wanted. Half the football team was waiting for me. They, uh, they stripped me down to nothing, tied me to the goalpost, and left me there.”
Never once did you imagine kids could be so cruel. You thought of your own high school experience, how there had been rough moments but nothing ever so cruel and horrific as that. You thought of the loner kid of your school, the one the popular kids picked on the most. Suddenly when you thought of him, it was Spencer’s face you saw. Your tears were pooling on his chest but you didn’t dare move to wipe them away.
“Did someone find you?” You were scared of the answer.
You were right to be scared of the answer. “I was out there for hours until I managed to free myself. They’d taken my clothes but it was the middle of the night so no one saw me when I was walking home.” One singular laugh ripped out of Spencer, but it was more sad than anything else. “My mom never noticed I was gone, she was having one of her episodes.”
Everything Spencer had ever said or done made sense. You thought of the day you first told him you loved him, how he didn’t believe you at first. How it had been so easy for him to declare that he didn’t deserve your love. Finally, you moved, pulling Spencer closer and brushing over his hair. You kissed every inch of him that peeked out of his pajamas, needing him to know how much love was in store for him.
You hated every single person that had a hand in breaking Spencer. You didn’t say anything for a while, focusing on holding Spencer as he worked out the rest of his cries. What was there to say to that? What could you say to a young man who had been tortured by his peers, who had been abandoned by the very people meant to protect him?
“No one is ever going to hurt you again,” you whispered against him when the tears finally ebbed away and dried sticky against both of your bodies. “I promise, Spencer, I’ll never let anyone hurt you, not like that. You’ve had enough pain for a thousand lifetimes.”
“I’ve never told anyone about that,” Spencer admitted and those words only served to break your heart more. He’d gone years walking silently through the world, clinging to all of that pain he’d been forced to deal with as such as young kid. It wasn’t fair, you decided, and you wished there was a way for you to go back in time and be that friend he needed.
“Crash could’ve used you growing up, I think. You would’ve been good friends.”
The easy words Diana had spoken to you took on a new weight now.
“Thank you for telling me,” you responded, drawing circles over his chest and trying to force images of the deep bruises out of your mind.
You would hold each other for the rest of the night, both of you unable to sleep but not having the energy to discuss much of anything else. Every once in a while he’d ask you something about your own childhood, and you’d try to come up with the happiest memories you had. He deserved to hear something happy after all he’d been through.
You wished you could’ve been the light for him sooner, but you would be that now.
“After plaid shirt days and nights when you made me your own...”
It was the night after Spencer earned his second doctorate that the two of you decided to give each other every part of yourselves.
You’d dutifully gotten dressed up that day, trying to soothe Spencer’s nerves because he was a literal genius, of course, they would support his thesis. You’d read it too, and while some of it you didn’t quite understand you recognized the skill there. You’d walked hand-in-hand with Spencer to campus, never letting go until he walked into that room to be judged by a panel of faculty members.
It felt like forever until he emerged from that room again, a wide grin on his face. He’d scooped you up into the tightest hug he’d ever given you, pressing light kisses across your face and thanking you for being his support through all of it. He told you then he was thinking of going back for a third, to which you told him he had to wait until you got your first.
The two of you opted not to go out to dinner, rather making a meal together and sharing it at the kitchen table that you’d bought together when you took him to a flea market for the first time.
After dinner was cleaned up, the two of you ended up curled in bed together again. You’d kissed him, sweet at first and then with growing intensity. It wasn’t long before you were straddling his lap, hands pressed to his chest while his own wrapped over yours.
“I love you, Y/N,” Spencer told you, and the words never failed to make your stomach flutter, “I want you, all of you.”
“Then have me,” you whispered. It was sweet in the way only Spencer could manage, taking care of you with such gentleness that had you completely melted in his arms. And when it was over, you laid tucked into his side, his arm wrapped around you as though to protect you from the world.
“Have you thought about the future?” Spencer asked quietly, face still flushed and eyes shining as he looked at you.
“What about it?”
“Do you want kids?”
The question surprised you. Never once had this conversation ever been brought up, but it was just a testament to the closeness you had with Spencer. “One day, I do,” you answered, “What about you?”
“I think I do. I never considered it before, there was so much to worry about.” You knew he was talking about his mother’s schizophrenia. Spencer had mentioned it before that his greatest fear was his own mind turning on him, how he hadn’t wanted to pass that weight on to anyone else. “I can picture it now. We’d have to have at least two, I don’t want them growing up an only child.”
He’d said ‘we’. As much as the thought scared you, it was easy to sink into this fantasy with him because you could picture having kids with Spencer too. “Our two baby geniuses. A boy and a girl, for good measure,” you supplied, all too ready to continue the fantasy.
“I’d love to have a daughter.”
“She’d be such a daddy’s girl. You’d be wrapped around her finger from the very start.” It was easy to imagine this future with him. It was so easy that it almost hurt, your entire being aching to be able to have this with him someday. “We’d never pressure them to be anything more than happy. They’d be absolutely brilliant but they could just be kids.”
“You’d be the best parent, Y/N,” Spencer spoke, voice wet again from new tears. These were lighter though, matching your own as you pictured the most perfect future for you two. “They wouldn’t ever know pain like we did. They’d have so many friends, and they’d be there to protect each other.”
“Tell me we’ll have this someday, Spencer.”
“I promise, Y/N, this is our future.”
“You call me up again just to break me like a promise, so casually cruel in the name of being honest...”
When Spencer woke you up on the morning of your three-year anniversary with gentle kisses and promises of something important to talk about, you knew what was coming. It was the perfect timing for it too. Spencer had just completed his third—and supposedly, final—PhD in record time. You were on track to graduate with your undergraduate degree and, though you hadn’t told him yet, had gotten your acceptance letter to the chemistry doctorate program here at CalTech. You both were starting new phases of your lives, it only made sense that he planned to propose now.
“Can we talk about it now?” you’d pleaded, trying to pull him back into bed despite the fact he was already dressed for the day.
“We can’t, I have a meeting with someone,” Spencer told you, laughing brightly at your antics anyway. “We’ll talk tonight, I promise.”
So you’d tried to busy yourself all day and not picture what it would be like to wear a ring on your left hand. You’d ended up running errands for the day to get out of the apartment and calling one of your old friends because someone else had to know what was going on.
You were so sure.
You were sure until you got home at 7 and he still wasn’t home. 8 pm passed and you hadn’t heard anything from Spencer. 9 passed and finally, he called. It would be the call that would absolutely ruin you.
“Hey, Wonder Boy, when are you coming home? I miss you,” you greeted as soon as you answered the call, pressing the phone against your head and shoulder as you went about fixing your outfit. You had to look good for when he proposed.
“We need to talk, Y/N.”
“Yeah, I know. That’s why you need to get home so we can talk.” The smile was impossible to wipe from your face, permanently etched in with a chisel.
“I wanted to do this in person, Y/N, I did. I can’t though, I know if I saw your face I couldn’t say it.”
Oh? Was he going to propose over the phone? You had to admit it wasn’t what you were expected, and you had to admit you were a little disappointed. Still, you would have Spencer any way he would give himself to you. “I can’t believe you’re doing this over the phone,” you teased.
“I know, I’m so sorry, Y/N.” A sigh and...was that a sniffle? It sounded a little like a hiccup; like Spencer might’ve been trying to reign in the tears. “I’m at the airport.”
“Why’re you there, silly?”
“Y/N.” The smile was erased from your face as he said your name. He’d never said it like that, filled with so much pain and guilt that you could practically feel through the phone. With a sinking feeling, you realized this wasn’t a proposal.
“Why are you at the airport, Spencer?” you tried again, voice considerably smaller. Did you even want to know the answer?
“I got recruited by the FBI, Y/N. I started training at the academy in Quantico tomorrow.”
“What the fuck?” The words slipped out before you could even process what Spencer had said. Was this some kind of cruel joke? Your hand shook as it grabbed the phone again, dropping onto the floor when your knees could no longer hold you up. “This isn’t funny, Spencer.”
“It’s not a joke, Y/N. It’s called the BAU, the Behavioral Analysis Unit. They hunt down serial killers by psychologically profiling them, and they want me to be on the team.” Under any other circumstances, you would have been so happy for him. You would’ve been thrilled. Instead, now you were picturing Spencer at the airport ready to leave you without so much as a goodbye.
“Why are you at the airport, Spencer?” Maybe you were a broken record now, unable to say anything but the question that had chipped at you. The words were considerably harder now, desperate for the answer he wasn’t giving you.
“I told you why. I got recruited by th-”
“I know that part, Spencer, I’m not a fucking idiot. I mean, why are you saying goodbye like this?”
Your anger stunned him into a rare silence from him. Maybe later you would feel bad for the harshness, but for now, all you could picture was the future he’d promised you.
“This isn’t a goodbye.” Spencer sounded so innocent, so genuine that you wanted to believe him.
“You’re flying to the other side of the country.”
“You could come with me. Come with me, Y/N. We can find an apartment together in D.C. Georgetown’s a great school, you can take a gap year and apply next year.”
“You want me to uproot my life just like that? Everything I have is here,” you spoke incredulously. You finally got into your dream doctorate program at your dream school, how could he ask you to give that up when he knew how much it meant to you?
“I won’t be there.”
“I know, you’ve made that very clear,” you snapped, angrily wiping at the tears pouring down your face. They dripped onto your outfit, a bitter reminder of what you’d thought tonight held for you. “I can’t do this, Spencer.”
“You can’t do what?”
“I can’t say goodbye like this. Don’t leave me behind, Spencer.”
“I’m not, Y/N!” It was his turn to sound angry. There weren’t many times Spencer truly got angry, but it was scary when he did. His genius mind always knew the right thing to say to cause the deepest pain. You hadn’t been on the receiving end of that calculated blow until tonight. “I’m asking you to come with me. What do you plan to do in Pasadena? You could hardly get through your undergrad even with my help, do you actually think you can get your doctorate? What are you without me?”
You gasped as if he’d reached through your phone and smacked you. It felt like it too; your chest was stiff and unable to take in another desperately needed breath. It was the final blow that shattered whatever was left of you. You choked on the sob that tore through your throat, hand smacking against your mouth to try to stifle the rest of them. After so many nights admitting it was your worst insecurity, your worst fear, he’d used it against you. You were so afraid of not being good enough for him, of not living up to anyone’s expectations for you, and here he was telling you that you’d done just that.
“I’m sorry, Y/N, I didn’t mean that.”
“You said it though. You said it, Spencer.”
“Please, Y/N, let me explain. Listen to me, and I-”
“I’ve done enough listening.” You don’t know where this strength came from, but you knew it wouldn’t last. You couldn’t speak to him anymore. “I wish you luck with the FBI. Stay safe, Spencer.”
“Wait, Y/N, pl-” but you hung up before he could finish his pleas, having heard enough.
Once he was gone, you allowed yourself to cry. You mourned the loss of the man you thought you’d love forever. How could he have possibly been so cruel? The sobs wracked your entire body, forcing you to fold over on the ground so your hands could brace your upper body. It felt like the kind of pain that would never end, that would follow you until the rest of time.
Spencer Reid had well and truly broken you like he’d broken his promise of forever.
“I'd like to be my old self again but I'm still trying to find it. Now you mail back my things and I walk home alone...”
Picking up the pieces of a broken heart doesn’t happen all at once. It’s a painstaking process that ends up with you cutting yourself on the sharp edges of the heart someone else had dropped.
After three years, you didn’t know who you were without Spencer Reid. It hurt in more ways than one as you desperately wanted to prove him wrong. What are you without me? You hated that you didn’t know. So you stayed in the apartment that was meant for two and you focused on school. You were a ghost of yourself, but that was okay.
You would find yourself again one day.
A year after the phone call that broke your heart, you got a package delivered to your door. You recognized the handwriting right away; the shaky scrawl and random capitalized letters. You almost didn’t want to open it, but a morbid part of you carried it in with shaking hands and tore open the box.
It was like a memorial to what you’d lost that night. The pictures were unbearable to look at so you stacked them neatly and shoved them into the first drawer you could find. You hold the flannel shirt up to your nose, hoping it’ll still smell like him but throwing it into your dirty laundry pile when you found it just smelled like generic detergent. It was a shirt of yours he’d worn around the house several times, stating that he wanted to wear things that smelled like you too in the same way you stole his sweatshirts. Maybe you should send him the CalTech sweatshirt you’d still hung onto after so much time had passed.
There were other things too, memories that Spencer was so cruelly tossing away. Ticket stubs to super artsy films he’d adored and you watched because of how happy it made him, the little plush elephant from when you took him to the San Diego zoo after finding out he’d never been to a zoo before. Your hands ran over each little memory, allowing yourself to cry for the way they were now tainted.
Spencer was giving you up, it was time you did the same.
Eventually, you moved to a new apartment that didn’t still echo Spencer’s laughter. You successfully defended your thesis and only cried a little when Spencer wasn’t waiting for you outside like you always imagined he would. You began teaching at the same university that had changed your life, and one day years down the road, you figured out the kind of person you were without him. You could finally say with absolute surety that you were okay. Time began moving, and life finally moved on without Spencer Reid.
“I know it's long gone and that magic's not here no more, and I might be okay but I'm not fine at all...”
Six years after Spencer broke your heart, and he was standing in front of you. He looked good, and you didn’t know how to feel about it. His outfit choices were a little more grown, and he carried himself with more confidence. You hoped that a part of that change was because of you.
“I miss you too, Spencer,” you admitted, surprising both of you at the sudden admission. It was clear he was expecting anger, and maybe you were too, but you didn’t have the energy for it anymore. “You still have my scarf.”
Spencer’s eyes widened and he glanced down to the purple fabric hanging from his shoulders before meeting your stare again. “I was packing up your things, and I couldn’t give this up. It reminded me of you. You can have it back if you want,” he offered, already reaching up to take it off.
“No, no, keep it. It suits you,” you answered, wondering if this was the closest thing to a peace offering you could give him. The old scars that finally had begun fading were opening again, bleeding and mourning the way you were so close to him now and yet feeling like you couldn’t be further apart.
“I’m proud of you, Y/N. You did everything you said you would, I should’ve had more faith in you.” You didn’t dare correct him, thinking that there were a couple parts of your perfect future that you’d never get to accomplish.
“So have you. That job’s perfect for you, Spencer,” you sighed. Of course, you’d kept tabs on him as best you could. You’d find clips of the BAU while discussing their cases to see glimpses of Spencer. You’d make sure he was happy in the life he’d chosen for himself, the life he’d chosen that didn’t have you in it. “I have to start class.”
“Can we catch up? Y/N, I want to try again. I don’t want to lose you twice.”
You wanted to believe Spencer. That future you’d longed for was right there in front of you, waiting for you to reach out and grasp it. Spencer was asking you to stay, and this time you were in a place where you could say yes.
And yet. It had taken you six years to put yourself together after him. He’d damaged you in a way you weren’t aware another person could. Honestly, you were scared of what would happen if you tried again, if you let yourself hope for another future with Spencer. If he hurt you again, you were sure this time it would be irreparable.
“I can’t, Spencer. Maybe someday down the road, if both of us still remember. I just found myself again, I’d like to enjoy who I am a little longer before I risk falling for anyone again,” you admitted, looking away as his shoulders slumped. “You told me once we were destined to be together. If that’s true, then we’ll meet again in the future, when both of us are ready. Until then...”
“Until then it’s goodbye,” Spencer finished, face crinkling as he tried to hide his disappointment. “I’m sorry I hurt you, Y/N.”
“I’m sorry too.” So you watched him return to his coworkers, both of them with clear concern in their gazes. It comforted you that he’d found a group to love and care for him like you once had.
It comforted you to see him still wearing your scarf after all this time.
You sighed, allowing yourself only a minute to compose yourself before beginning the lecture. It would be a lie to say you never once looked at Spencer and imagined what would happen in that figmented future you’d created with him.
A few years down the road, when both of you were older and wiser, you’d apply for a position as a professor at Georgetown. You’d pack up your belongings and drive to D.C. without telling anyone. One day, you would reach out to Spencer and tell him you were ready.
He would be ready too. Spencer would meet you at your apartment and would hold you like he used to. He would promise that the heartbreak was over, that the two of you could finally be happy. He’d propose like you once thought he would, and one day you’d have the family you’d dreamed of once so many years ago.
In your dream, you could be happy together.
“It was rare, I was there, I remember it all too well...”
SERIES TAGLIST
@samuel-de-champagne-problems @alexlovescriminalminds @reidsbookclub @givemeth @fightingdragonswithreid @girloncorneliastreet @silverhetdanes @just-a-human-witha-pen @eurydice-but-gay @shemarmooresfedora @rexorangecouny
156 notes
·
View notes