The BBC news just used a soundbite from an MP (Catherine Fletcher, conservative) saying "In 1930s Germany they were citizens of that country who were residents there… to draw the comparison with people who were seeking to come to our shores, it almost invalidates the fact that they had a right to be in that country in the first place." This is a cruel, duplicitous reading of the history and the current policy. I'm not a historian, but I don't want people to hear this and accept it as "fact" when it is... well, it's not. I'm sure everyone reading this is smart enough to be able to do their own research, and compassionate enough to be horrified by what's happening, but a couple of quick points below, and suggestions of further reading.
In 1930's Germany, the Nazis identified Roma as having “alien blood." They were arrested, deported, sent to concentration camps, forcibly sterilised. Historians estimate that between 200,000 and 500,000 Roma and Sinti people were murdered by the Nazis and their collaborators. Laws were made to remove their right to live in that country.
The 1951 Refugee Convention (take a guess what that was signed in the aftermath of) states that:
everybody has the right to apply for asylum
anyone has the right to apply for asylum in any country that has signed the 1951 Convention and to remain there until the authorities have assessed their claim
people fleeing persecution may have to use irregular means in order to escape and claim asylum in another country
ie - refugees seeking asylum, EVEN IF THEIR CLAIM IS ULTIMATELY REJECTED, have a right to do so.
I highly recommend reading some of the resources on the holocaust memorial day trust and the refugee council webpage.
Is there an elder queer or trans person that has any hope? Or anything I should know? Because the USA is turned against us and other marginalized groups to the point we're all going back in time and I worry I wont be allowed to exist soon... And not to be dramatic but its looking pretty grim
Ida and Louise Cook were unmarried sisters in their mid thirties who lived with their parents. One wrote romance novels for Mills and Boon (England’s Harlequin equivalent) and the other commuted from their sleepy London suburb to work as a secretary for the civil service. They wore home made clothes and shared a love of opera. They loved opera so much, they would go to Germany for the weekend just to see the opera there. In the 1930’s.
No one paid attention to them crossing the border, a couple of dowdy women in their homemade clothes, nor on the return trip with their furs and jewels. What Ida and Louise were doing, in addition to going to their beloved opera, was collecting valuables from would be refugees to help them in their new lives. The sisters would find people who would vouch for the refugees, find people willing to home them, assemble papers for them, and even rented an apartment as a temporary space for refugees just arrived. The sisters used their own money for this, so the refugees could sell their valuables for money to help them settle in.
The women entered and left through different checkpoints, so the same guards wouldn’t be able to notice their sudden acquisition of too much jewelry, and created a lie about the valuables in their purses as ‘we can’t trust them in our apartment when we aren’t there!’ They acted simple and foolish and were never caught. They did eventually halt their visits over the border, after directly rescuing 29 people (mostly families), but they did not stop working. They continued to raise money and awareness, and to help refugees in England.
The sisters were honored as Righteous Among the Nations by Yad Vashem, the World Holocaust Remembrance Center, in 1964.
Ida wrote a memoir that was republished as “Safe Passage” in 2008. In it she plays down their role, saying that what they offered wasn’t much. In exchange for saving lives, they only needed “some trouble, some eloquence, and some money.”
Five thousand New Yorkers gathered in Columbus Circle in a mass demonstration against the persecution of Jews and Catholics by Germany, November 16, 1938. The crowd heard denunciations of the Third Reich from several speakers, including Nathan Frankel, Labor Advisor to Mayor La Guardia, and Orson Welles.