I'm genuinely convinced the thought process goes:
> people who abuse children are horrible, irredeemable monsters who deserve to have their human rights stripped away and burn in hell for all eternity, no good person would ever hurt a child
> *tons of scientific evidence comes out showing that hitting your kids is basically abuse and does immense harm with absolutely no good to balance it out and in the worst cases it leaves lasting psychological damage those kids carry for life*
> but wait...my parents spanked me as punishment, but they aren't horrible evil people who deserve to die! I love my parents and they loved me, they're good people and good people would never hurt a child, and I surely don't have issues as a result of being hit, so that must mean hitting your kids isn't abusive
> the cycle continues, nothing changes, kids keep getting hit
and like I get it, I get it, but I just want to grab these people and be like "welcome to the complex reality most actual abuse survivors have to contend with every single day of our lives, it sucks, but since I've been through it I can give you the answer I had to work out over years of therapy for free; you are still allowed to love--and even FORGIVE--people who hurt you"
41 notes
·
View notes
My opinion on billy hargrove as a character is so complicated but I think I can boil is down as: he is one of the few realistic interpretations of an imperfect abuse victim where his actions make you uncomfortable and it can be generally agreed he doesn’t take Good actions, but even just the slightest bit of thinking can make you understand why he does what he does. Why it makes sense to him.
You can look at him and go “I empathize with you, I understand you, I could’ve been you if I didn’t have a support system” or even “I WAS you” or “I AM you” and I think the reason he is so controversially liked/disliked is there is some inherent belief that somehow despite the way you were raised, you’re supposed to just inherently know what’s right and wrong. And yeah, once you’re in recovery you tend to learn what’s right and wrong, but nowhere in Billy’s story does anyone ever tell him the way he’s being treated is wrong. No one tells him the actions he’s taking because of it are wrong. Or on the other hand, he is punished so universally for his behavior it is hard to discern when his actions are actually wrong, or if he’s being treated unfairly. He is never shown empathy or understanding until quite literally, the moment he dies.
The message of his story is that when you are isolated, abused, and angry, no one tries to help you until it’s already too late. So yeah, I think anyone can dislike a character for any reason they want, but writing him off as an abusive racist when the quite literally Point Of His Character is “this is what can happen to a person when they are never given kindness/empathy/support and it warps their morals and actions to be violent and/or prejudiced” is just. Wrong. Especially when that includes attacking people who empathize with his character.
Regardless of if you like it or not, there are real people who were like that, are like that, and they deserve love, support, and empathy as much as any “‘perfect’” abuse victim that never perpetuated the cycle. Anger is simply a product of the fear that comes with abuse. Redirecting that anger at others is a learned behavior that comes with coping with that abuse, it’s not right, but you can’t unlearn it unless you’re given a chance to heal. Every abuse victim deserves support and a chance to heal and learn from their past actions and mindsets. Understanding a mindset is not the same thing as condoning it.
So please for the love of god, leave people alone when they write a happy ending for someone they see themselves in.
230 notes
·
View notes
kind of obsessed with how fukuchi's line about "if you attack me one by one, i will kill you one by one" has held true through this entire arc. tachihara fought him alone, and he failed. jouno attacked him alone, and he failed. even when ranpo and fukuzawa went to confront him, they did it one by one (ranpo first with poe's book page, and fukuzawa second with his sword), and fukuchi eliminated them from the fight one by one. the only time anyone even escaped a confrontation was when atsushi and akutagawa finally worked together, fully and entirely trusting each other. it was when they finally attacked him as a combined force. if characters keep fighting against fukuchi one by one, they are going to continue to be defeated one by one.
35 notes
·
View notes
I know that people talk a lot about breaking generational trauma, but there's not enough discussion around parents who try so hard to break that generational trauma and end up going into depression because they can't be that perfect parent who will always make the right parenting decisions & will never expose their child to trauma at all.
You're traumatized! Sometimes you'll impulsively make bad parenting decisions because it's literally what you've been used to growing up!
However, it does NOT excuse abusive behavior towards your child. You can't just be like "well this is what I went through, so you need to suck it up and deal with it too."
The best way to actually make progress is to apologize to your child, explain where your behavior comes from, and tell them that IS IT NOT THEIR FAULT that you are making those mistakes. Ask them what hurts them the most and what you can do better, then try to stick to that.
But You also need to learn to forgive yourself for your mistakes.
Because if you don't, the guilt will eat at you so much that it negatively affects your mood, which negatively affects your actions, which negatively affects the way you treat your child(ren).
(the same could be said about any relationship, honestly.)
One thing I realized about my own parents is that even though they made mistakes, they didn't put me through the same trauma they went through. At the very least, they recognized that a lot of the things that were done to them were horrible, and kept my brother and I from experiencing even half of what they went through. I'm definitely still traumatized by their behavior, but not nearly as much as they were traumatized. My mom was abused by her father, and my dad lost both of his parents at 14 and had to take care of his younger siblings on his own at that age.
I mention that because that because it's an example of how you can't break all generational curses by yourself. It might still take a couple more generations. But you're still making that progress, and in time, your grandchildren, great-grandchildren, etc will have less and less trauma throughout each generation.
It sucks that you can't immediately be that perfect parent that will never make the same mistakes as your parents. But you're doing a better job than you think.
14 notes
·
View notes