Tumgik
#but i feel like theres so many overlapping traits between like
surplus-of-sarcasm · 7 months
Note
ive tried to write women so many times but have failed to the point theres barely any female characters in my stories. and im very aware this is a flaw in my writing because i dont hang around women often and the only long term contact with a female i have is with my family members i dont know how to write female characters on a personal level because i can never relate to them. this sucks ass but correct me if im wrong i think its better to not write female characters at all than write a shitty possibly offensive one even if i dont realize it
Hi.
Okay, here's my take on what you're saying. I know for a fact that the most difficult things to write are things/situations/environments we know so little about. And it's even harder to get it right when it's a more sensitive thing, if yk what I mean. A huge perspective shift like this is definitely a challenge because men and women are quite different.
Here's the thing. I'm not trying to pressure you into writing them, but I'm telling you that even if you have problems with them now, doesn't mean you have to give up on writing them completely. If not writing them at all is your final decision, then that's still okay, still your call in the end, but if you do want to write them, it's very possible.
I know I write both male and female characters, but the first time I ever officially wrote smth that wasn't for school, it was with a female protag because ultimately, I see the world from the eyes of a woman. When I decided to write a male character for a more serious project, I realised I needed to research it. And lemme tell you that again, not every piece of advice in a writing help article is always applicable. It's largely based on the author's own personal experiences. They're more like tips than rules you must adhere to.
Please note that I've spent considerable time around men I'm close to in my family, I had male classmates and currently have a friend who's a guy, so that definitely helps. And it's completely understandable that you haven't spent enough time around women to grasp more about them Ig. My male characters are not exactly copy-paste of these men/boys either, but some of their traits and mannerisms may be connected.
And you not relating to them is completely okay. I'm not very likely to relate to parts of my male character's life that come with him being a man, but what I can relate to is what makes him human. There is definitely an overlap in several traits between men and women. For example, the way I would feel angry abt smth would be different from how a guy Ik would feel angry about the same thing. The key is simply to avoid bad cliches.
Again, I'm not trying to get you to write them if you really don't want to. Forcing yourself to write smth you don't want to definitely won't help, and won't create good pieces of writing. But just in case you wish to in the future, you can practice and research and test it out, and fun fact, part of it involves a little bit of winging it. I've done this for like genres/ideas I haven't tried before, and surprisingly it actually works. But, tbf, it's a lot more difficult when the issue at hand is the opposite gender.
And answering your last question, while it doesn't mean you must give up completely and you will never be able to do it, I can agree that no representation is better than a poorly represented character. Though, there is a chance you might be too harsh on yourself, since Idk exactly what any female characters you've written are like.
And about my reblog on that post abt writing women, Ig it was more aimed at people who've never tried or misrepresent women by applying a crap ton of harmful stereotypes to them. You seem to have made a genuine effort, so that's a pretty good thing.
Sorry for the long post, and thank you for the ask.
2 notes · View notes
welcometogrouchland · 3 years
Text
WAY too tired for meta and nowhere near S4 in my relisten but like. First time round I kind of hated the season 4 archives lineup because nobody liked each other, but after thinking about it? I love exploring that lineup because it's just a bunch of people going through the whole Self Recognition Through The Other and being VERY UNHAPPY with what they see
(read tags if you want my expanded thoughts. They're also very incoherent but slightly more thorough)
#the magnus archives#tma#idk?? idk if this is meta I'm very afraid to tag it as such#i don't know if this makes any sense??? or if it has any basis in canon I could just. be completely fucking wrong here#but i feel like theres so many overlapping traits between like#jon and melanie. jon and daisy. daisy and basira. basira and jon. jon and martin. martin and georgie. etc etc#and on some level they're all aware of that but they're all incredibly fucking mad about it and in denial#like#melanie Maybe knows she and jon are similar! she's Definitely not happy about it! martin maybe understands Georgie. doesn't like that fact!#like they're all... just different enough that every similarity is this horrible aching itch instead of a source of solidarity#Jon's like. I share stuff in common with daisy and basira. but daisy traumatized me and basira doesn't see me as human. don't like this#i don't think I'm making any sense but also i am????#also even with like. the villains and avatars#iconic moment of jon being like 'damn i kinda get where jane prentiss was coming from. a troubling moment'#idk this is a little unhinged? and also I'm always scared to post meta because mortifying ordeal of being known and whatnot#but I've just been wondering why. so much of the time i find myself drawn to the post unknowing era of the archives??#whether that be exploring the months where jon was in his coma or setting things during season 4 and like#i think this is it?#but also i don't think this makes tons of sense#but hey thats how it goes sometimes#c'est la vie#ramblings of a lunatic
42 notes · View notes