Tumgik
#but i think paige esp being like a Social Worker whitelighter blah blah blah she gets it she's not gonna give phoebe too much shit
phoebehalliwell · 3 years
Note
with all of Phoebe's baby crazy, I wish they'd revisited her first baby. in "womb raider" at the beginning, she genuinely cared for her baby, was excited to see him in her dream/vision, defended him to her sisters, etc. but at the end suddenly it's "the baby was never mine, it was always the Source" which is a major tone shift. I would have liked to see Phoebe exploring her feelings about her previous pregnancy, or even finding a way to see an alternate version of the baby she lost.
it’s like. ik the original plan was to have queen of hell phoebe extend into like s5 which like. tg it didn’t i’m not a big fan of s5 as it stands but like at least the charmed ones were still the charmed ones y’know. but yeah. phoebe’s kid. like. i mean okay let’s start with the beginning of season four phoebe isn’t even sure if she’s ready to get married. she has the vision of herself as this wild free spirit, to get married is together herself to the earth and become a more grounded woman, someone less like herself. and she is genuinely unsure if she can make that commitment, she doesn’t know if she can become that person. if she even wants to become that person. and for all the mess phoebe went through in s4 i think we do see a lot of character development from her i mean this is the season where she gets a steady job and starts to build the career she will have through the rest of the show she had been in a committed relationship for like a season and a half she is far from the flighty ditzy spirited phoebe we met in season one. like s1 phoebe was not ready to be a mother. hell s4 phoebe wasn’t even sure if she was ready to be a wife. but we was her grow we saw her finally start to plant roots and grow and she was ready to have a child she was excited to have a child and this really was like a marker that pushes her to like her s6 manic state like you can’t jump from s1 phoebe to s6 phoebe you need a bridge s4 was that bridge the only issue was that bridge is a bit of a dicey subject so like we pretend it just doesn’t exist. but like. phoebe was going to be a mom. and yes the whole thing was a really traumatic experience yes she was being fed a concentrated dose of pure evil to keep her source baby insane but it being traumatic doesn’t mean it didn’t happen in fact as it goes it usually means it was more of an impact. i mean even with piper’s pregnancy as baby wyatt started to do wild tricks from the womb we got nothing from phoebe nothing like idc if the seer masterminded u getting knocked up you were going to be a mom!! u were looking forward to it!!!! and to see a baby of good magic kinda pulling the same stunts your “abomination” quote unquote did like does that not get the gears turning? does that not get you caught in the what-ifs?? and it wouldn’t be the first time we see phoebe turn to magic to get the answers to her own personal problems hell she does it all the time but i think the source’s heir will always be one of her biggest what ifs. even after she’s found coop and settled down and had three beautiful daughters of her own what if. what if cole never became the source. what if i had stayed the queen of hell. what if i got to keep my baby. what if i got to see him, to hold him in my arms, to raise him. what if pj parker and peyton had an older half brother. what if it doesn’t matter what your born from but rather who you grow to become. like it doesn’t matter where you are now is where you always wanted to end up. scars don’t heal. they’re there forever. and i think this really could have given phoebe a great new depth and introspectiveness away from the more impulsive behavior she seems to indulge in
#anyway i think it would be funnie if phoebe did cast a spell to go see how her could would have ended up#between you and me i think she would actually be hoping for a world of destruction#just so she can feel okay about never having that kid#seeing that the kid was just evil#and it wasn't on her#of course that's more surface#deep down she wants to see somebody who is the source but who is still charmed#even if she couldn't save cole she could save her son#and i think this would be best done if she was like#like imma do this real quick but i don't wanna anyone to know or come along bc this is embarrassing also this is a me problem#so she waits til everyone's left the house but unbeknownst to her paige has just orbed into the kitchen to grab her lunch real quick#and she and paige both get knocked into a world where the source's heir lives and paige is like hi phoebe where are we & what did u do#and phoebe's like oh hhahha lmao nothing major i just wanted to um. see my son.#and paige is like when u say son you mean the sources heir who tried to throw me out a window right or is there another kid ur talking abou#and phoebes like no yeah that's the one#but i think paige esp being like a Social Worker whitelighter blah blah blah she gets it she's not gonna give phoebe too much shit#she'll go along on this adventure#and u know they're looking around paige is like well this isn't a post apocalyptic hellscape so like dub#blah blah blah they bump into dency in some unknown circumstances where they dont recognize each other they chat yadda yadda yadda#& phoebe's so focused on finding Her Son that she misses the obvious right in front of her and paige is just looking at dency like wait#and dency leaves and phoebe was like that was nice but lets go find my kid#and paige is like did u ever get a sonogram or r u projecting gender roles onto ur unborn baby#and phoebe's like what. wait. and they run after dency just in time 2 see her flame out#charmed#phoebe halliwell#💌
5 notes · View notes