Our Little Secret - Chapter 4
Series Masterlist
Pairing: Eren Jaeger X Female Reader
Genre: College AU, Spider-Man/Spider-Girl AU, Fluff, Slow Burn, Mutual Pining, Eventual Smut
Series Summary: Eren Jaeger, a 21-year-old virgin college student who loves his camera a little bit too much, has a crush on you. Every night, he switches on his camera and talks about you but he never could find the courage to speak to you in real life. Strangely enough, he finds it easy for him to befriend Spider-Girl, the crime fighting vigilante, not knowing that you both share the same identity.
Chapter Summary: Forced by his best friend Spider-Girl, the time has come for Eren Jaeger, self-proclaimed campus' hottest nerd, to ask you out on a date and honestly? He's scared shitless. Thankfully, or unfortunately, for him, his best friend Armin Arlert comes to the rescue.
Content Warnings: explicit sex scene (happens at the end of the series, can be skipped if you want), swearing, mentions of characters going through depression, traumatic past events
Word Count: 8k
Poster art by the most talented @rainbuniart on Twitter
Twenty-one-year-old Eren Jaeger has been gazing at the same crack of his ceiling for the last two hours. It’s four in the morning, his body is begging him to sleep, and yet there he is, half-lidded eyes staring blankly into the darkness of his bedroom, his brain running across the universe, thinking:
What the fuck am I going to do?
Times like this make him wish that he had a superpower he could rely on—not to swing from one building to another, not to fly, and definitely not to check out girls’ panties with his X-ray vision (though honestly, if he had one, he’d definitely try to get a tiny, tiny peek of your bra, for, umm, scientific reasons). But no. Eren doesn’t want that. He wants to be able to communicate with God, or Jesus, or literally any deity out there that created him, and ask them, why, God, why am I such a fucking virgin?
Being a virgin isn’t bad. It’s not a sin, not at all. Some would even find him admirable for being able to refrain himself from getting his dick wet because he’s waiting for the right one. It’s the way he thinks like a fucking virgin that he is that’s bad. Because how in the world is he going to be able to ask the most popular girl on campus to go out with a giant nerd like him who hasn’t even had his first kiss yet? Who hasn’t had the pleasure of holding a girl’s hand for more than three seconds long? The last time he did that was during last year’s Christmas party when his aunt Dina took his hand in hers and gave him twenty bucks to get himself a new shirt (only because the one he was wearing looked absolutely horrendous). It also doesn’t help that you happen to be the cutest person in the world—or in his world, at least—with the prettiest smile, with such a pleasing vanilla and strawberry scent that Eren wishes he could smell on his pillow every day.
So, what’s going to happen now? Let’s say, by some miracle, you agree to go on a date with him, then what? What kind of conversation would he have with you? What if he says something stupid? Does something stupid? Knowing him, he will definitely do. Or worse, what if the date actually goes… well? What if you realize how much he wants to kiss you? What if you also want to kiss him, but you’re waiting for him to make the first move? WHAT IF YOU WANT TO KISS EACH OTHER WITH TONGUE AND EVERYTHING, BUT WHEN YOU BOTH LEAN IN, HE ENDS UP KNOCKING HIS TEETH AGAINST YOURS AND–
Eren can’t breathe.
Should I just walk up to her? He thinks, fingers tapping restlessly against the ridges of his abs. He never wears a shirt when he goes to bed, his sweatpants always hanging too low on his hips—which is already an improvement, at least, since he used to sleep completely naked. He was forced to change that habit ever since his sibling, Zeke, barged into the room at two in the morning with his phone in his hand, trying to catch him in the act. “AHA! I HEARD SOMEONE MOANING! YOU MUST BE HAVING SEX!” Zeke yelled as he kicked Eren’s bedroom door open. Eren had it locked, of course—he’s an idiot but he’s not that much of an idiot—but Zeke had conveniently duplicated his room’s key without him knowing for this sole purpose of humiliating his little baby brother.
And no, Eren wasn’t having sex, but he was watching someone else having sex through his computer screen. And yes, he had one hand around his cock, his pants pooling around his thighs, the hem of his shirt tucked between his teeth, and his own moan caught in his throat. It was so stupid that Zeke had to barge in right at the exact second he was cumming all over his hand, which made everything super weird ‘cause it looked like Eren came because he was aroused at the thrill of having someone else watching him masturbate and that was really not the case.
“ZEKE, WHAT THE FUCK, MAN?!”
“EEEWWW OH MY GOD PUT THAT TINY DICK AWAY—”
“PUT THAT CAMERA AWAY—AND IT’S NOT TINY!”
“DINAAAAA, EREN IS JERKING HIS LITTLE TINY DICK OFF!”
“I’M GONNA FUCKING KILL YOU, ZEKE!”
“BOTH OF YOU, BE QUIET—IT’S TWO AM!”
It was one of the most—if not the most—humiliating experiences he had ever had in his life. Especially after Dina spent an hour lecturing him the next day about, and Eren quoted, “Maintaining high self-esteem even if I am secretly insecure about… a certain part of my body. Small is more. Small is better,” with Zeke standing in the background, shaking his head and mouthing, “No, it’s not. You got a tiny dick.” For the record, Eren does not have a tiny dick, though he doesn’t have a witness that could testify on his behalf. Armin knew, but he’d rather swim in hot lava than admit it out loud. Anyway, knowing how he’s going to ask you out tomorrow, he’s sure as hell he’s going to break his own record in a matter of hours.
He’s scared. He’s so scared of talking to you first and getting rejected second. But his friendship with you—Spider-Girl—is in jeopardy right now. And honestly? This is the kind of push he needs because otherwise, he would never have the courage to ask you out. But it still feels so nerve-racking. Eren would rather jump inside that burning building once again—hell, let him set a fucking camp over there and it would still feel less horrifying than this.
He switches on his phone. The selfie you took with his camera has been his wallpaper for weeks now, and Eren doesn’t want to even think about how many times he has kissed his phone screen good night. “Look at that smile,” he murmurs to himself, sighing in bliss at the sight of your little grin, so cute and naughty at the same time. “Are you really going to say yes tomorrow? To someone like me?”
Great, now he’s talking to himself as if the last two hours he spent talking to his monitor wasn’t enough. Feeling anxious and knowing how he’s not going to be able to catch a wink of sleep tonight, Eren slides his thumb along the screen, going through his contact list.
“Armin,” he breathes out in relief the second his phone call is connected. “Dude, sorry for calling you at three—fuck, four AM, but I can’t sleep. I need to talk to someone about this.”
For the first three seconds, there’s only silence. And then—
“Eren, I’m gonna fuck you up.”
***
“Armin—Armin, wait—”
You have memorized how Eren’s voice sounds by now—how deep it is, how husky, and how it gets just a little bit high-pitched when he whines after losing an argument. Even when he’s still on the other end of your campus hallway, you can hear it echoing through the room. It’s gradually turning louder as he makes his way toward you. Your heightened senses can tell but you pretend you don’t hear anything, busying yourself by replacing the books inside your bag with the other ones in your locker.
You can sense someone walking up to you a moment before you feel a light tap on your shoulder. Snatching your textbook, you close your locker with one hand, whirling around to see a young man sporting a bowl-cut and black-framed sunglasses. “Oh, hello. You’re–”
“You don’t know me,” Armin says, his face blank and unimpressed—almost similar to Annie, though his hair seems more golden and greasier than hers. “And I don’t plan on knowing you either. We’re not friends.”
“O… kay,” you respond, both surprised and amused at his quirky attitude. Before you can speak anything else, Eren arrives at your spot with a little “Fuck,” under his breath. You cast him a smile, greeting him with a little, “Hey,” and he panics.
“S-sorry, this is, uh—” Eren lands both hands on the blonde man’s shoulders, trying to escort —haul—him away. “This is Armin and we’re—we’re leaving.”
“Get your hands off me, peasant.” The shorter male harshly slaps his hands away before he returns his attention to you. “I have a bone to pick with you, young lady.”
“Oh, no,” you say, feigning concern. “What did I do?”
Eren whines, desperately pulling on his best friend's backpack now. “Armin, goddammit, let’s just go—”
“Now, you listen to me, woman.” Armin is unstoppable. “Ever since you came into his life, my best friend has been losing his mind.” He has one finger pointed at your face as he speaks, not caring if he’s being rude or causing a scene in the hallway. “Which is concerning ‘cause he doesn’t have much of that to begin with.”
Eren, with a groan filled with shame, rubs a hand over his face. “Oh, God.” He can try and take Armin away by force, of course, but they’re already garnering other people’s attention as it is. Also, the last time he tried to haul this little chipmunk away, Armin bit his hand so hard, it’s a wonder he didn’t have his limb amputated.
Plus, Armin is supposed to be doing him a favor, right? Right?
You have a hunch on where this is going but you act clueless to get the most out of your entertainment. And by entertainment, you mean watching Armin embarrass the hell out of his friend. “I’m sorry, Armin, I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
“Eren has a crush on you,” Armin explains, grabbing his friend by his wrist, and raising it in the air. “This is Eren.”
“I’m actually gonna kill you when we get home,” Eren murmurs through gritted teeth, harshly pulling his hand away. He can’t meet your eyes, too mortified to do so. All he wants right now is to be turned into dust and be carried by the wind.
“Nice to meet you, Eren,” you say, almost crooning even, and the said boy gulps, turning crimson from his neck to his ears as he responds with an awkward, “H-hi.”
“Dude, pull your shit together.” Armin elbows him on his side. “Anyway, Ma’am, Lady, Miss, whoever the hell you are. I’m trying to make sure that you take responsibility for this because I want my best friend back. He’s already a giant idiot who can’t even survive the first half of The Witcher without spending all of his potions, okay? Now I don’t even want to add him to my team because he keeps thinking about you during battles and he sucks so much ass, it’s embarrassing!”
You nod, biting your lip to contain your grin from breaking. “You suck ass?” You ask the brunette and he nearly faints from the innuendo. That little twinkle in your eyes… It’s as if you’re asking him what else do you suck in your spare time?
Armin, not knowing when to stop, adds, “He literally called me at four in the fucking morning today just cause he couldn’t sleep, thinking about how to ask you out!”
“ARMIN OH MY GOD–”
“So please,” Armin begs as he pushes Eren away by his face, “Please just do something about it for me, will you? Talk to him. Knock back some senses into him before I do it myself, and I swear to God, I’m ready to get blood on my hands.” Pivoting on his heels, he says, “Now that I’m done, I’m gonna return to my wife and I’m gonna pretend you two don’t exist in my life for the next two weeks. Adios, fuckers.”
Armin walks away with his middle finger pushing back his glasses. You titter, immensely pleased by how theatrical he is. “Has he always been that eccentric?” You ask Eren, who looks just as pasty as the white shirt he’s wearing underneath his hooded peacoat.
“Honestly, I don’t know why I’m friends with him in the first place,” Eren says, mirroring your faint laughter before he turns to face you, his body turning rigid once again as he tries to get past his awkwardness. “So, uh… Armin wanted us to talk.”
“That he did.” You smack your lips, hugging your textbook close to your chest with both hands. “What about you?”
“Huh?”
“Do you want to talk to me?”
There’s something in your voice that makes his stomach act up on its own. “Yes, I would love you—to! I would love to! I’d love to talk to you!”
There’s literally nothing more adorable than how he looks right now. “What should we talk about, then?”
You’re so pretty. “Umm…” I love that dress on you, you look amazing. “I don’t know…” I love you. I think we’re meant to grow old together and have three kids running around in our backyard. “I’m wondering if someday you want to, umm…”
You’re waiting for him to say the words, tilting up your head just slightly to the side at the perfect angle that makes you look ten times cuter than before. “Want to what?”
Eren takes a deep breath. His shoes are squeaking against the floor as he drags and shifts his weight from one foot to another. “I don’t know, just, uh…” He turns his body slightly to the side, doing this little lip bite as he lets his gaze travel up from your lips to your eyes.
The way he’s so nervously awkward is both amusing and endearing. You’d think that a man who owns a face like that would be all smooth and suave with girls but Eren has zero experience in dating and it shows from how anxious he is. Funny how he doesn’t act like this at all when he’s with Spider-Girl. He’s so chatty when he’s with that alter ego of yours, spouting out lines after lines, stories after stories. He got embarrassed sometimes too, sure, but he’s never like this. Maybe he really does like you. He likes you so much that his brain just stops functioning when he’s around you.
“I don’t know, maybe we could—” Eren gesticulates, jittery hands moving all over the place from fixing his jacket, scratching his nape, to rubbing the shell of his ear. He literally can’t stand still, eyes going everywhere but yours. “Or, you know, we could do something else or—if you’d like, we can—”
“Yeah.”
“—go and—” he stops, gaping, probably thinking that he imagined your answer. “Sorry, what?”
“Yeah,” you repeat, your smile reaching your eyes and turning them into a beautiful pair of half-moons.
“Y-yeah?”
“Yeah, either one.”
Eren stops functioning for a second, his mind completely blank. He just stares at you, unblinking as if his soul just went on a world tour, leaving his body behind. “Really?”
“Sure.”
He swallows. “Umm, okay…” It still feels surreal to him that you actually said yes to whatever it was he was offering (he’s not even sure what he just offered you). “Yeah, that sounds—that sounds great.” He can finally smile now, his lips curving up ever so slightly but his eyes do more than his mouth could ever convey. He can only stare at you for a while, transfixed with his mind completely blanked out as he’s suffused with so much joy. Then he remembers something and he panics again. “Shit, actually, I can’t right now, since I have—I’ve got classes to go.”
“Yeah, of course, me too,” you laugh lightly. “It’s only nine. Obviously, we have morning classes to attend.”
“Yeah…” He turns sheepish. “I was planning to ask you out after you’re finished with your Astrophysics class, but Armin couldn’t wait until then.”
“You knew I’m taking Astrophysics?” You tease, smirking. “What else do you know about me?”
Why am I such an idiot, Eren ponders as he feels himself dying little by little. Every time things start to get better, he always finds a way to screw things up. “I’m sorry, I… I didn’t mean to stalk you and be such a creep.” What am I going to do? She’s going to hate me now… Perhaps even disgusted. “You know what, I’m sorry for being so weird. I can understand if you don’t want to go out with me.”
You blink. His posture, the way he looks like he’s losing all his strength at once, and that little pout on his lips. Why does this look familiar? Then, it clicks. “You don’t want me to go out with you?”
“I do!” He exclaims a little bit too loudly. Thankfully for you, there’s no one else in the hallway right now but you and him. “Of course I do, but…” He drags his eyes to his feet, his heart beating a thousand miles per hour, his teeth sinking into his lip.
You feel mischievous. For a superheroine who’s supposed to lie ninety-nine percent of the time to keep her real identity covered, you’re doing such a bad job at it because you want him to know that you’re the same girl he’s been sharing intimate sessions with on the rooftop. So you do the same thing you did the night you dropped him off on his porch. You reach out a hand, cupping his cheek and trapping him there so he can’t look anywhere else but your eyes.
Eren stiffens, emerald eyes shining brightly underneath the sunlight that seeps inside the room. “W-what are you doing?”
“Do you want to go out with me or not?”
His breathing tatters. “Yes, Ma’am, I do.”
“Then why are you telling me you don’t want to go out with me?”
“I wasn’t—I’m not saying I don’t want to go out with you. I’m saying that I’m okay if you don’t want to go out with me.” Wait, I feel like I’ve gone through this situation before, Eren thinks, feeling strange. Is this what Deja Vu feels like?
“Why do you think I don’t want to go out with you?”
“Cause I’m…” He wets his lip, nervous. “Creepy?”
“Why, because you know I’ve been taking Astrophysics? Or is it because you’ve been taking pictures of me in secret?”
Eren’s not sure if you’re trying to calm him down with your words or make him feel ten times worse. “B-both?”
It’s funny how he unconsciously admits that he has been snapping photos of you like the stalker that he is. “Well, I still find you cute, so I don’t think we have problems with that. Would love it better if you could stop taking pictures of me, though. If you want my picture, you just need to ask. We can take some photos together this time.”
This is it. He’s in heaven right now. This is what paradise feels like. “I… I can?”
“Of course.”
His heart is thrumming so clamorously in his ears that it’s a miracle you haven’t heard it already. “And you… Are you saying you still want to go out with me?”
You playfully roll your eyes, giving him a light pat on his cheek before you release him. “If you want to, sure. Just ring me up or something.”
He’s in a haze, thick fog clouding his thoughts. “Okay… I’ll—I’ll call you.”
You wait for him to connect the dots, but when he remains in silence, just gazing at you with droopy eyes, you have to be the one who asks him. “Do you need my phone number or should we do it the old way with you sending a pigeon to give me my letters?”
“Shit, yeah—that’s right.” Snapping out of his reverie, Eren sticks a hand inside the pocket of his jeans. He’s about to take it out when a thought hits him like a train. Shit, fuck, I have her photo as my wallpaper. I also have her pictures in my gallery, what if she finds out? Should I delete them now? No, there are too many of them. I don’t have time for this. Even if I do, what if I haven’t backed them up? Oh my God, what to do, what to do, what to do—
“Eren?”
He pushes back his phone into the bottom of his pocket, his stomach in knots. “You know what, I think I left my phone at home.”
I literally can see the shape of your phone in your pocket, but okay. “Oh, no,” you fake a pout. “Then, I guess, we can’t go on a date then.”
“I can write down your number on my palm!” He takes off his backpack in a rush, going down to his knees to make it easier for him to look for his pen. “Wait, let me just—Fuck, where’s my pen—”
You thank the lord that most guys don’t usually take this long to make advances on their crushes, because if it takes him this long to ask you out on a date, humans will go extinct before they can repopulate the earth. “Or you can just add your number to my phone?” You offer.
“Of… course, yeah.” He returns to his feet, face flushed. “Sorry, I’m an idiot.”
“I think you’re adorable.”
“P-please don’t say that. I’m already dying here.”
“Don’t die on me just yet. You haven’t bought me dinner.” You hand him over your phone and it nearly slips off his grip from how shaky his hands are. If it wasn’t for your fast reflexes, you might have to spend some of your savings to buy a new phone. “Careful, big boy.”
“Sorry,” he winces, being much more careful this time. He taps his quivering thumbs on the screen, adding his number on your contact list and re-typing his name several times because he keeps missing the right letters. “Here,” he says, offering you back his phone. You intentionally let your fingers brush against his, even let them linger for a second too long and Eren noticeably gulps at the minimal contact. “So, uh… I’ll wait for you to call me?”
Your mouth twitches into a smile. “I won’t make you wait too long, I promise.”
***
It’s been thirteen hours, eleven minutes, and forty-three seconds since you said, I won’t make you wait too long, and Eren is lying down on his bed with his eyes glaring at the clock that’s strapped to his wall as if he’s trying to make it burst into flames.
Why hasn’t she called me yet?
What’s taking her so long?
Did she lose my number? Wait, have I clicked ‘save’ when I typed down my number? Fuck, I can’t remember.
He’s going insane in every way possible. He turns around to scream against his pillow before jumping from the bed. “I’m gonna get some fresh air,” he decides before he becomes the one who combusts into flames. Right before he grabs his hoodie, his phone rings.
Eren runs to grab it like his life depends on it, accidentally bumping himself against his swivel chair, hard enough for it to topple over and knock him off his balance. Groaning in pain, he reaches out one hand to blindly locate his phone on the desk. It’s an unknown number. This must be her.
He takes a deep breath, repeating two times more before he clears his throat and answers the call in the deepest, manliest, sexiest voice he can produce. “Hey, there.”
“Yo. It’s your big bro, Zeke. I left my phone at home and—why do you sound so weird?”
“Oh my God—GET OFF MY FUCKING PHONE!”
Eren shuts the line. If he missed your call because of this, he’s really going to kill him. He’s still grumbling under his breath when the phone rings again. The caller ID is still unknown. Refraining himself from grunting in protest, he picks up the call, “Zeke, for fuck’s sake, I’m gonna fucking kill you for real. I’m waiting for a girl to call me right now. If she—“
“Eren?”
Oh, wow. There you are. Calling him at three past ten pm and the first thing he said to you was his brother’s name and a string of expletives. And to think that he spent two hours practicing in front of the mirror to sound all smooth and suave, maybe even play hard to get like, “Sorry, who is this again? Oh, it’s you. I wasn’t expecting you to call me this early. What? You want to talk to me about our date? Shoot, I completely forgot about that.” He had everything planned.
“So, you’ve been waiting for me to call, huh?”
Eren knocks his head against the edge of his desk repeatedly as he says, “Not really.”
“Oh? What have you been doing then?”
“I was just… editing some photos. Touching up stuff.”
“You were touching-up stuff?”
If that first kiss of yours could be your villain origin story. This, you teasing him right now, can be his villain origin story. “Please don’t make fun of me, I’m already at my limit.”
“Dying again?”
“Probably.”
Your giggles soothe him down a little bit, making him feel less humiliated and more… serene. Which is weird, because you are also the cause of his distress. “Sorry, it took me a while to get back to you. I had, umm, family things to do.” And by family things, you meant stopping a car chase at Seventh Avenue. You’re still dressed inside your costume, actually, sitting at the edge of a skyscraper as you watch the city glimmering underneath you. “So, about that date. What do you want to do?”
Eren hates his filthy, filthy brain for coming up with ‘you’ as an answer. “I’m, uhh… I’m down with anything you want to do.”
“Oh? And what if I want to do something bad? Something… naughty.” You nibble at the corner of your lip, smirking as you wait for his response. Eren sounds like he’s choking on the other line.
“N-naughty like what?”
“I don’t know, like, cheating on my diet and stuffing my face with churros or something.”
“Oh…” You can actually hear the disappointment in his voice. “Oh, you mean that kind of naughty.”
“What kind of naughty are you thinking about?”
His face catches fire. “I’m—I’m not going to answer that.” There it is again. The most heartwarming, adorable giggle in the world that easily paints a smile on his face. “Maybe we could grab some coffee first and just see how it goes from there?”
“Hmm, I think we can do that,” you reply. “I know a coffee shop downtown that makes the best mochaccino.” We didn’t get to visit it last time because you threw up on me.
“Great.” He sounds much more relaxed now. “So, uh… Should I pick you up at your place or…?”
“Or I can just meet you at the coffee shop?” It’s too far away from my flat, and it’s faster for me to just swing by. “Let’s say at eight?”
“Okay.” His cheekbones are hurting from how wide he’s smiling. Even when he reminds himself to stop, it remains everlasting on his lips. “I’ll see you at eight, then.”
“Yeah, until then. See you, big boy.” And he can sense the smile in your voice too. “Try to keep your hands to yourself this time.”
“I wasn’t touching myself!”
The last thing he can hear before the line gets disconnected is his most favorite sound in the world, and he knows when he goes to sleep tonight, your face will stay permanently behind his closed lids. Eren sighs, throwing himself back to the bed. He’s over the moon, his body feels like floating in the air.
It feels so good to be in love.
***
Armin Arlert has been best friends with Eren for five years.
They met on the first day in high school when a bunch of school jocks tried to dunk Armin’s head inside the toilet bowl. Eren, who happened to be in the same bathroom—he had just finished doing number one and was washing his hands because although he might be an idiot, he was actually a very hygienic idiot—lifted his head when he saw four seniors hauling Armin’s body in the air before they pushed him inside a cubicle. The blonde boy was already on his knees, his eyeglasses cracked and tossed away to the floor when Eren stood behind them. To tell you the truth, Eren could’ve just punched one of them in the face and used the short moment of surprise to grab the nerdy boy by his collar and run away. But no. Eren, being an idiot like always, announced for the whole world to hear by saying the clichiest thing of the clichiest.
“Hey, assholes,” he shouted dramatically as he cast his backpack to the side. “Why don’t you pick somebody your own size?”
It was cringe. He said it as if he was starring in The Lion King. Eren could’ve just saved him without saying anything. He could’ve just kept his mouth shut, punched one guy in the face, kicked the other two in the balls, stuck a mop inside the other one’s ass, and called it a day. That would’ve been badass, peak cinema right there. But no, Eren had to be cringe. Armin knew that he, himself, was the epitome of cringe with all the outfits he was wearing (dude walked into the room dressed in Naruto’s flak jacket and orange pants), but Eren was on another level.
Even so, his cringy line managed to garner their attention. Whirling their bodies around to see who was this dumbass who stopped them from enjoying their daily entertainment, the jocks sneered. Eren had worn his most menacing glare on his face, chin tilted up high with his fingers already curled into balls of fists, ready to fight back if needed. One of the seniors stepped forward, lips pulled back to showcase a wicked grin before he grabbed Eren by the front of his shirt.
Then they dunked both Armin and Eren’s heads inside the toilet bowls at the same time.
“Well, I mean,” Armin said once the seniors had left the cubicle to pick another target to torture until the next period started. “At least they didn’t give us wedgies.” He handed the brunette his bottle of shampoo, one that he carried around with him every day as getting a swirlie at nine in the morning was already part of his daily routine. Eren, just like him, washed his hair and face clean.
“I’d prefer a wedgie than this, honestly,” Eren sighed, re-doing his bun even when his hair was still somewhat soaked.
“Dude, no,” Armin argued. “I can’t stand them. Wedgies hurt my ass and my balls. I’ve got huge balls so…”
“Well, a swirlie is even more humiliating. Wedgies don’t hurt that much. Man up.”
“Yeah,” Armin snorted. “Probably because you have small balls and an equally small dick.”
“I don’t have a small dick. You do.”
“Excuse you, you low-life degenerate. I’m five point eight inches long.”
“Ha, weak,” Eren jeered. “I’m six point eight.”
“Flaccid,” Armin corrected, his nose flaring. “Erect, I’m seven point five. Ha, weak.”
Eren, turning off the tap, loomed tall above him, exuding the same level of darkness as the final boss in Dante’s Inferno. “Erect,” he said, smirking, “I’m eight point three. Try to top that, bitch.”
With his jaw dropping to the floor, Armin seethed with rage. “That is bullshit! Let me see!”
It turned out Eren did have a big dick. Armin had never felt so mortified in his entire life. Disgraced, even. Getting a swirlie was one thing, but having the only asset he was proud of demolished by a fucking stranger?
“To be fair, you do have big balls, bro,” Eren assured with a friendly pat on his shoulder. “Cheer up. It’s not the end of the world.”
This would be such a nice story to tell at their weddings when they become each other’s best man in the future. Just two bros sizing up each other’s dicks and comforting each other afterward with their heads still smelling like toilet water.
“I fucking hate those guys,” Eren grumbled, drying the fat droplets of water off his face with some paper towels. “A bunch of assholes.”
“Yeah, what was your plan, man?” Armin asked. “Can you even fight?”
“I can, but not against four of them at the same time.”
“I know. That’s why I asked you what was your plan.”
“Do I look like a guy with a plan?” To be fair, no, he did not.
“Why did you do it then?” The blonde man’s frown was sketched deeply upon his forehead. “You could’ve just walked away.”
“I don’t know,” Eren exhaled. “I guess I just don’t like seeing other people get bullied.”
“You have a protagonist syndrome, that’s your problem.” But Armin offered his hand, fixing his broken glasses with his index finger as he spoke, “But I admire your bravery, young man. You’re foolish, true, but brave nonetheless. My name is Armin. Armin from the clan Arlert. I feel like we can be comrades.”
Eren looked at him weirdly before he accepted his handshake. “Eren Jaeger.”
That was the beginning of their friendship. They spent, quite literally, every hour of their days together, almost as if they were conjoined twins. Although they had different personalities, they shared the same interests and complemented each other rather well. They became so close that rumors started to spread in the hallway that they were more than just friends. A girl with freckles on her cheeks named Ymir approached them and asked them to join her LGBTQ club. Armin was happy to join as he had never had someone ask him to participate in anything before, while Eren was too nice to say no (poor boy didn’t even know what LGBTQ stood for), so that certainly added more proof to the case.
It also didn’t help when the school’s quarterback—who looked like he belonged in Tokyo Revengers with a heart kinder than Hello Kitty on her best day—Reiner Braun asked Armin, “Dude, is it true that you two fucked behind the bleachers that night after the homecoming game?”
Armin’s answer was, “That source of information you were talking to. Did they say I was the one who fucked Eren in the ass or was it the other way around?”
“They said it was you who fucked him.”
“Well, yes, that is correct,” Armin said, pushing back his eyeglasses. “I did do that. Now you know that despite popular’s belief, I am not a bottom. I have a bigger dick and I am much manlier than him.” For someone who (self-)proclaimed to be smart, Armin didn’t make sense most of the time.
Reiner gave him a high-five, patting his back like a proud father. “Is it true you’ve got massive balls too?”
“Everything is true, Reiner. Everything is true.”
(Eren did not hear a word about this until graduation. When he did, he went into a severe depression mode for three days straight, absolutely humiliated knowing that people thought Armin was topping the fuck out of him anytime he had the chance. Eren didn’t have that much problem being mistaken as a queer—nothing’s wrong with that—or even the fact that he’d be a bottom. But him bottoming with that fucking nerd Armin Arlert as his top? Jesus Christ. Forget his traumatic past. This was probably the reason why he started his video journal in the first place.)
Now that he looked back at it, maybe that was why Eren didn’t get to find himself a girlfriend. Surely, a guy like him would’ve been popular among girls in his school if people didn’t think he loved taking it in the ass. But that’s okay. Eren never needed one back then anyway, both a girlfriend or a dick in his ass. He felt content spending most of his high school memories being cooped up in Armin’s room, playing endless amounts of games, or binging TV shows.
Armin felt that way too. He thought his life had already peaked at that point. He got married to his favorite waifu, got to kick some random twelve-year-old’s ass in Overwatch on a daily basis, and got to laugh and be normal with his best friend, Eren Jaeger. There was nothing else he needed in the world, as long as he had his best friend with him.
Then you came along and suddenly, Eren turned into this desperate, downgraded version of Romeo who couldn’t do anything—not even finishing the first half of Assassin’s Creed without dying or crying—but talk about how angelic you were, how cute your voice sounded in his ears, how sexy your lips were and yada yada yada.
Ugh, gross.
“Armin, I need your help!” Eren comes barging into his room, kicking the door open without permission as always. He’s carrying half of the clothes he owns in his wardrobe in his arms, almost tripping over his feet before he lays everything on Armin’s bed. “I don’t know what I should wear for tonight’s date, and I’m so stressed out right now, my balls are literally sweating. You gotta help me out!”
Armin doesn’t budge from his swivel chair, not even sparing him a glance. With his fingers still smashing his keyboard buttons, he simply replies to him with a snort, mumbling, “Stupid incel brat,” under his breath.
Eren, grabbing a black button-down shirt and a black blazer in each hand, stands right next to him. “What do you think about this? Does this outfit say I’m hot and you should totally get handsy with me?”
Armin spins around, flatly staring back at him. “Eren, you’re going on a casual coffee date not a fucking funeral.”
“Okay, what about the white suit then?”
“You’re also not going to prom. Or a wedding.”
“Oh, God, I would love to marry her.” Eren literally has the attention span of a three-year-old, easily distracted, especially when the topic involves you. Hugging his clothes to his chest, he releases a dreamy sigh. “You know what would be nice? If both of us get married somewhere near the beach where we can hear the sounds of waves as they crash against the rocks in the background—”
“The only thing that’s great from being married near the beach is to have you swept away by a fucking tsunami so we don’t have to do this sappy conversation ever again.”
That was harsh, even Armin realizes that too, but he couldn’t help it. He hates that his best friend is turning into a lovesick fool. Eren has been a simp from day one, but it’s only getting worse by the second. It’s annoying, really, when Eren keeps changing the conversation. Suddenly, everything is all about you. Armin can be talking about the latest spin-off of Game of Thrones and Eren would be like, “You know who’s going to be a great mother of dragons? Her. Except, instead of mothering a bunch of little dragons, she’s gonna be mothering a bunch of my mini-mes.” Eren is like… the human version of Twitter right now.
But the thing with Armin is, even though he has the mouth of a pirate, he has the heart of a nun. Despite his vexation, he also wants to be happy for him. Truly. And when Eren pouts with his shoulders slumping forward and his bottom lip jutted out, what can he do? “I’m sorry,” Armin says, taking off his glasses so he can massage the bridge of his nose. “That was very mean of me to say. I didn’t mean that. I wouldn’t want you to die in a tsunami. Getting stung to death by gazillion bees? Probably. But not in a tsunami.”
Armin is putting on a facade, Eren can tell. Putting a stop to his dramatic pout, Eren leans himself against his desk, tossing his clothes back to the bed before he gives the man his full attention. “Okay, what’s wrong?” He questions. “Why do you have a stick up your ass?”
“I don’t have a stick up my ass.”
“You look like you do, Armin.”
“And how do you know? Because I look pissed? Has it never occurred to you that maybe I like having a stick up my ass?”
Eren gives him a look. “Come on, man.”
Armin heaves a defeated sigh, running a hand through his golden hair. “I’m just wondering… What happens after this?” To Eren’s surprise, the blonde male turns solemn. He’s taking away his mask and underneath it, Eren can finally see how distraught he is. “If your date goes well—and I’m sure it will—and then what? You’re gonna date her and you’re gonna spend a lot of time with her and then… What’s going to happen to us?”
Eren, not expecting the conversation to turn this way, turns stiff for a second. “Dude, what—”
“I’m just saying that,” Armin pauses to release a sharp breath. “I don’t want to sound like this, but… You’re my only friend. I know how important she is to you. I know how much you like her. But I haven’t been able to say a word to you without you making it all about her. And I’m sorry if I sound like an asshole, but I’m tired of it, dude. I’m worried that this is gonna be it for us. You’re going to live your own life, build your own family, have kids, and grow old together with your loved ones, and I’m going to live the rest of my life stuck in this hellhole, getting fatter by the day while playing fucking Overwatch with a bunch of twelve-year-old kids until I finally die from type two diabetes or worse: prostate cancer.”
Baffled by the situation, Eren can only reside in silence, observing the way Armin’s posture droops on his seat.
“I’m happy for you, Eren, I really am,” Armin wearily says, casting his gaze down to his lap, fiddling with his fingers. “But… I don’t want to say goodbye to our friendship just yet. You’re really important to me, bro. You were my first friend and you’re my only friend now. You were the first person who cared about me enough to have his head dunked inside a toilet bowl. I know I always made fun of you about it, but I really was happy when you stuck your neck out for me. No pun intended. And now, I just…” He slowly returns his gaze to his face. “I guess I just don’t want to lose you.”
There’s a little click in his brain when the dots are all connected in his head. Eren thought Armin had simply disliked you as a person—just like how he disliked everybody else, but that wasn’t it at all, was it? He’s just jealous, not of him, but of you.
I’ve been selfish, haven’t I? Eren muses, realizing just how much he’s been constantly shoving your name down his throat instead of truly spending time with his best friend when he’s the only one Armin has. How would he feel if the roles were reversed? What if Armin started dating a girl and moved on with his life while he was still there alone in his room, waiting for a chance to play Xbox with him again? He could only imagine how lonely it would be.
“I’m sorry,” Eren says, his voice turning equally as soft. “I’m sorry for being such an asshole. And I’m sorry for ignoring you. That wasn’t my intention at all.”
Armin isn’t sure what he wanted Eren to do, but seeing him apologizing like this with regret in his eyes feels unsettling. Wearing back his glasses, he clears his throat before he returns to his computer screen. “You know what, I was just being lame. Ignore me. So, about that outfit—”
“You’ll always be my best friend, Armin,” Eren cuts him off, stunning the other boy. “Nothing will change the fact that you play a huge part in my life. You’ve always been. And I promise you that me dating her isn’t going to change a thing between us.”
Armin, now flushed, can’t stand and listen to him for a second longer. “Yeah, I got it. Let’s move on—”
“I’ll make time for you every week,” Eren continues regardless. “Every weekend, I’ll come here to crash at your place and we’ll play—”
“Dude, I get it. Drop it—”
“No, listen to me. We’ll play games until morning and watch a new season of Jujutsu Kaisen together—hell, we can even watch that shit you like with the catgirls and the tentacles—”
Armin slams his head against his keyboard. “Oh, Lord.”
“And you know what?” Eren’s eyes brighten up, his face nearly being split in half from how wide he’s grinning. “When she’s ready to marry me and have kids together, you’ll be our godparent! We’ll have a special room for you in our suburban house where you can stay as long as you want—”
“YES, I GET IT! NOW SHUT UP!” Great, now he’s screaming. His mother would probably lecture him again about dealing with his anger issues, and that’s not fair because this is completely Eren’s fault for being so fucking sappy and cringe. He’s already talking about marrying you when he can’t even decide what to wear for his first date!
But Armin, standing abruptly from his chair, blushes to his toes. His sapphire eyes are seconds away from popping out of their sockets. For a moment, they both just exchange stares but the second Armin’s thin lips twitch in a smile, their boisterous waves of laughter fill the room.
“Are we being gay right now?” Eren says, eyes turning glassy from how much he’s guffawing.
“Shut up.” Armin gives him a light kick on the shin. “Even if I were into dicks, I wouldn’t date you.”
“Really? Why not?”
“Seriously? You’re gonna ask me that question?” He flatly replies. “Gonna make us sound even gayer?”
“What, I’m a charming man.”
“You’re an asshole.” But the tiny smile Armin displays on his face is filled with nothing but the fondness he held for the man. “You don’t have to fuss about your outfit, man. You’ll look good no matter what you wear. Just be yourself.”
“Be myself?” Eren snorts. “You want me to be myself? I’m a fucking idiot.”
“True, but she has a bimbo kink.” After his little lash-out, Armin decides that he’s going to go all out at supporting his best mate today. “The stupidest you act, the horniest she gets.”
“That’s not reassuring in the slightest,” Eren grimaces.
“Eren,” Armin puts pressure on his voice. “You’re an amazing guy, okay? You’re kind, you’re courageous, you’re funny and sweet even though you can also be annoying as fuck sometimes.”
The corner of the brunette’s mouth quirks up, an impish glint in his eyes. “Sometimes?”
“All the time,” Armin corrects with a playful roll of his eyes. “But you know, if someone as cranky as me can stand your corny ass for five years, I’m sure she would love you. I’d rather die to admit this so I’ll just say this once.” He stops tapping against his keyboards, turning around to face the other man. “You’re the greatest guy I know. So have faith in yourself. You got this.”
Armin was so serious when he said it. It was like he was trying to convince Eren to jump over a cliff to save his life when it’s really just about him choosing whether he should go with a gray shirt or a black tee. “Wow,” Eren responds, rubbing the tip of his nose. “I didn’t see that coming. The blonde boy promptly turns back to his computer, keeping himself busy as his brain couldn’t form a witty comeback to say. “So, like…” Eren begins. “Do you wanna make-out or—” He’s hit right on the face by a water bottle.
After going through twenty minutes of trying every attire he owned, Eren falls back to Armin’s bed, his groan muffled by his body pillow. “Fuck, what am I going to do? I don’t want to show up in a hoodie. What do boys usually wear on first dates anyway? What do girls wear?” He gasps when a thought enters his head. “Dude, what if she wears this cute little dress and she ties up her hair in a ponytail so I can see her neck and her baby hairs, and, like—"
“Aaaaand we’re back.” With a last tap on his keyboard, Armin pushes himself away from his desk, leaving his chair. “You want to look good? Fine, come here. I’ll show you how to look good.”
Armin takes a few strides and stops before his wardrobe, sliding the door open with one hand. “You know what’s gonna make a good impression?” He rhetorically asks, standing on his toes as he tries to reach the top drawer. “If you dress up like that dude from Attack on Titan.”
“I don’t know what that is.”
“The fact that I’m still friends with an imbecile like you is beyond me.”
“You literally just cried your eyes out, whining about how scared you were of me leaving you.”
“I didn’t cry!” Armin better be used to his teasing quickly because Eren’s not going to live this down for at least the next five years. “It’s an anime, really good. You might want to stop watching Euphoria sometimes and start watching real shows instead.”
“Now, why you gotta be rude like that.” Eren throws himself on the bed, sitting on its edge. “So, what, he’s the protagonist?”
“Yeah. He looks just like you. Long hair, green eyes. You even have his iconic man-bun look.”
“Is this guy popular among ladies?”
“Well, they’ve been calling him Zaddy.” Armin shrugs. “Like Daddy but, you know, swagier.”
Eren’s face contorts in repulsion. “Is he a dad? I don’t want to dress up like a fat older man, bro, come on now.”
Eren is the exact reason why Armin’s mother is getting more persistent in scheduling another appointment with his therapist these days. “I mean like Daddy in the sheets, you dumbass! Not actual daddy. Well, actually, according to one theory, he is the father of—”
“I literally don’t have time to keep up with you, Armin. I’ve got a date in less than three hours.”
“Rude,” he snorts, throwing a pack of clothes still sealed inside a plastic bag. “Here. I’ve ordered this for our next anime conference but desperate times call for desperate measures, so…” He rips open the package, tossing him a beige shirt with string tassels at the collar, a pair of dark pants, and a simple black mantle. “Try them on.”
With a frown, Eren shucks off his black band tee and wears the beige shirt. Armin watches him put on his mantle with his eyebrows furrowed and his arms folded neatly on his chest, scrutinizing every little detail. “Okay, good,” Armin comments, standing right behind his friend as they both stare at their reflections in the standing mirror. “Now, raise your right hand in the air. We can add some fake wound and blood dripping down your palm later—”
“What the fuck—“
“Ssh sshh sshh, just bear with me for a second.” Armin is in his serious mode right now, and if there is one thing Eren has learned from befriending him for five years is you don’t fuck with Armin when he’s being this focused. “Now, do a frown.” Eren isn’t frowning in anger; he’s frowning in confusion because what the fuck are they even doing? It seems good enough for Armin either way. “Perfect.” The blonde boy snaps his fingers in the air. “Now say, in the deepest voice possible, ‘It’s because I was born into this world.’”
Eren draws the longest exhale. Staring flatly at the mirror, he repeats, “It’s because I was born into this world.”
“Fuck, yeah, that’s it!” Armin shouts, punching the air in victory. “Holy shit, dude, we are so gonna win the next cosplay event—”
“Jesus Christ, Armin, I’m running out of time here!”
“Okay, okay, geez.” Randomly picking up one of the shirts and jackets Eren had brought into his room, he pushes them against the other boy’s chest. “Here.”
Eren narrows his eyes suspiciously. “You really think this is okay?”
“Look, Eren, what’s important is not what you wear, but how you act in front of her. Come here, let me teach you.” Armin provides him with a little demonstration as he gives out his instructions. “Follow me. Stand with your feet close together like this.” Eren follows with an eyebrow raised in question. “Yep, like that. Now stretch both arms out to your sides, held parallel to the ground. That’s it.”
Eren blinks in confusion. “What am I doing?”
“You’re T-Posing. To assert dominance. Show that bitch who fucking owns her.”
“I’m literally never going to talk to you again.”
***
Next Chapter
Huge thanks to Aleks and Nissa for beta-reading this chapter for me. I love you guys forever ❤️
Tagging:
@l6ffys @vivi-et @halparkebitch @fwess @littlemochi @thebeardedmoon @didiyogo @coyloves @erenbean @tehehebri @justasketch @infnteen @naiomiwinchester @spiderlingh @doyochii @ahornyenby @aengelren @sakurashell @princess-jaeger @resonancesoul @blrqt @cacapeepee @persyhange @jaegersdiary @erentoes @trashygremlin04 @meed18 @j0livi0ni @snowflake-201 @jaymihawk @eva-gates @claudevonstrukesblog @sofijaeger @rinsie @blanccofiie @ereninbunu @natanialora @khinjito @ackersune @watermelon-online @tropicsoda @damselofblueroses @alexackrman @bblgumz @jurrasicpork @erenjaegercult @holycandypizza
746 notes
·
View notes