I can't see how the writers still think Skystar's a good person. Like, twelve year old me liked him and thought he was interesting, but I was like twelve. And even I knew he was an irredeemable asshole after Moth Flight's Vision.
If a twelve year old can figure this stuff out I have no idea what these grown ass writers were doing.
DOTC has a thesis, stated in The First Battle, that really explains everything.
"Fear and Greed" is just a fake-deep way to reinvent a Good and Evil dichotomy. Because Clear Sky's abuse comes from a place of fear, it means it's not malicious, unlike a "greedy" cat.
He can be "soothed," ergo, he's a fundamentally good person.
Post-First Battle, the books are focusing constantly on his feelings, how sad it makes him to not be trusted, how happy he is when people are on his side. All while he continues to screech at people who tell him what to do, manipulate and mistreat his son, and even still beats and mauls those who offend him.
But because it's "fear," that doesn't matter. That's a justification, an excuse. The writers don't seem to believe in good and bad actions as much as they do good and bad people. True 'evil' comes from a person who hurts others for the wrong reasons, like 'revenge' or malice.
It's abuse apologia. Plain and simple.
The truth is that abusers don't think of themselves as evil people, and everyone, even you and me, is capable of being toxic or abusive. Talk to those who have been abused and we'll tell you; we often stayed because we "saw the good," or even felt responsible for them. Abuse can be passed down through generations because the kids come to believe the way they were treated was normal and okay.
If you go through life thinking that abuse only comes from evil/greedy people, you won't see it when it happens right in front of you. Fundamental good and evil is childish. Abuse comes from fear all the time.
Abuse is about power and control. Fear of rejection, of losing someone, of pain, those are all very common motivators as the abuser tries to stop them from happening before they even begin. It doesn't MATTER that your abuser is in pain too, you NEVER "deserved" what they did in an attempt to break your legs so you wouldn't run.
But... we can all change. Even the worst of us. It's never too late to stop hurting others, move on to a better life, but some people never will. Skystar loves his power, and he keeps that power no matter how many times he misuses it.
He has no reason to change as long as his cruelty rewards him with status and authority.
But the writers are incapable of recognizing that, because for this entire arc, they were stuck in an absurd view of the world in terms of Fear and Greed. Abuse can be excused if he did it for the "right reason," and that makes him "fundamentally different" from the truly evil villains, Slash and One Eye.
Hopefully, it now makes more sense to you.
105 notes
·
View notes
15 Lines of Dialogue
Rules: Share 15 or fewer lines of dialogue from an OC, ideally lines that capture the character/personality/vibe of the OC. Bonus points for just using the dialogue without other details about the scene, but you’re free to include those as well!
Tysm for the tag @myreia !! I feel like everybody got tagged in this already so if you haven't and you see this, pls consider I tagged you!!
Cleaning some of these so it's only the dialogue but it isn't purely Thesa bc she talks so little. I always have to go back on my fics to edit bc @ myself "she wouldn't say all that!!" so I'm giving a bit of context with who the scene is.
w/ estinien
“Alphinaud would find a way so he could keep traveling with you and Alisaie would pretend she didn't want anything with it but would still join right after him.”
“Sounds like someone I know.”
2. w/ ardbert.
“I'm not the one you have to lie to, you know that, right? You can tell me you're tired of this. There's nothing for me to do — and I wouldn't, either way.”
“What would change?”
“You'd be honest with yourself for a change.”
3. talking about zenos.
“We are not so different, him and I. It's why I pity him, and I don't like it one bit. All this is because we're just too much alike and-”
4. w/ thancred.
“Considering you haven't called me in yet... should I leave you be?”
“Just trying to make sense of my thoughts, so don’t. There's no need.”
5. w/ haurchefant.
“I can not stay. Alphinaud is alone and waiting for me. I need-”
“To rest, for now.”
“But I am good enough.”
“Don't lie. I was the last to know about what you're going through, so please, don't lie to me anymore.”
6. w/ thancred.
“The exarch knows?”
“His doing, I'm afraid. Haven't gained any magicks, if you wondered.”
“It was never necessary. Now, a lead, if you please.”
7. w/ hythlodaeus, about emet.
“... it's the matter at hand that gives him a tendency to be intense. If it unsettles you, I could ask him-”
“No. It doesn't bother me,” I'm used to it.
8. w/ thancred.
“You did seem off when I arrived. I would like to hear about it sometime later. What happened in the few seconds you were alone here tonight and there, on the moon.”
“I would like that too.”
9. w/ twins and estinien.
“I still don't want trouble with your father, so wait me back at the Annex? I will bring the food this time.”
“If we are talking about free food, then I'll linger for a moment longer.”
“And what if I don't bring you any?”
“I'll get Alphinaud's part. You wouldn't want that, would you?”
10. w/ thancred.
“Your reaction... what was that?”
“I fear I may have overstepped our-”
“It's ours, you have nothing to overstep. Besides, I would tell you if you did.”
11. w/ the twins.
“The forest didn't felt like home, and I couldn't stand people thinking it still did. So, I went looking for a new meaning for the word- I guess I found what I was looking for.”
12. w/ haurchefant.
“I can fill you in first.”
“Is that what you want?”
“It is what you want.”
13. w/ estinien.
“It's relieving. Having you back.”
“I could say the same about having you.”
“I never left, why-”
“You did, but not today.”
14. w/ emet, about ardbert,
“But of course, we are on the First. So that would explain him — which leaves me to wonder: won't you tell the Exarch and your Scions about that friend of yours?”
“That doesn't concern them. Specifically, not you either.”
15. w/ thancred, about ryne.
“It has to be enough because now you do not have time to overthink, just to show the girl that you're strong enough and that she's safe here with you.”
7 notes
·
View notes