"She gave it back."
Like Feyre, was Elain passing "a test" when she returned Truth-Teller, and/or her necklace, to Azriel?
Please don't share or screenshot this post without credit.
Disclaimer: this is a potential parallel that I noticed, which makes no claims of accuracy - I get it, it's pretty fanciful and could absolutely qualify as a crack theory, or just be a complete coincidence on SJM's behalf. Thank you, as usual, to the brilliant @wingedblooms for discussing this with me. 💜
Spoilers: Crescent City and ACOTAR series to date.
While looking up the Mor and Feyre quote I mention below for a different theory, the wording I used to find it was "gave it back." And wouldn't you know, the only two uses of that phrase in the entirety of the ACOTAR - ACOFAS omnibus ebook seem fairly significant.
I know a lot of Elriel antis love to use the following examples of Elain returning what Azriel had given her as proof that they aren't destined for each other, because Elain kept the ring Graysen gave her during their ill-fated engagement (and she loved him back then), and she has, we assume, kept - but not used - the spelled gardening gloves and pearl earrings that Lucien gave her over the last two winter solstices (and, if their theory holds, she'll love him in the future, I suppose?), but I disagree, respectfully.
Not only would it have been extremely rude and presumptuous of Elain to keep Truth-Teller at all, given Azriel told her he wouldn't be using it "today" - ie. he'd need it again tomorrow - but Elain likely did not throw the knife back at Az¹ as a metaphor for her being unable to handle his darkness/profession, she gave it back to him as he passed it to her. Gently. As for her necklace, I think that - crack theories about magical testing aside, and assuming she returned it herself - it showed growth on her behalf to not keep the gift² of a man or male who hurt her (of course Azriel obviously didn't want to cause Elain any pain, unlike Graysen, though an apology is still clearly in order, whatever happens).
¹ This was originally pointed out by @ofduskcourts, if I'm remembering correctly.
² As an aside - and because I discussed this with @123moiaussi last year and still haven't posted about it 😅 - I do think that Elain keeping her pearl engagement ring could end up being for another reason altogether: it most likely went into the Cauldron with her, so I suspect it is also Made. Now, I don't blame her if she simply chose to keep the ring as some sort of emotional crutch after Graysen's brutal rejection of her, but also, it probably wouldn't be a great idea for a human to be in posession of a Made object... could he even have handled it? What powers, if any, does it have? Can she use it as a focus for her own magic? Did it compel her, or strengthen her feelings at the time, such that she kept it? So many questions!
But I digress; back to the theory, which, ships aside, I hope you'll consider.
Feyre Archeron and Amren
In ACOMAF, Amren gave Feyre a necklace, an amulet that would supposedly protect her/keep her free whilst visiting the Bone Carver in the Prison.
Amren was standing at the foot of my bed. I jolted back, slamming into the headboard, blinded by the morning light blazing in, fumbling for a weapon, anything to use— “No wonder you’re so thin if you vomit up your guts every night.” She sniffed, her lip curling. “You reek of it.” The bedroom door was shut. Rhys had said no one entered without his permission, but— She chucked something onto the bed. A little gold amulet of pearl and cloudy blue stone. “This got me out of the Prison. Wear it in, and they can never keep you.” I didn’t touch the amulet. “Allow me to make one thing clear,” Amren said, bracing both hands on the carved wooden footboard. “I do not give that amulet lightly. But you may borrow it, while you do what needs to be done, and return it to me when you are finished. If you keep it, I will find you, and the results won’t be pleasant. But it is yours to use in the Prison.” By the time my fingers brushed the cool metal and stone, she’d walked out the door. Rhys hadn’t been wrong about the firedrake comparison. - ACOMAF, chapter 18
I could do this; I could master this fear. Amren had gotten out. And stayed out. And the amulet—it’d keep me free, too. - ACOMAF, chapter 18
I didn’t want to think about it entirely, not yet—not with that letter now on its way to him, if not already delivered. So I reached for the small box on the vanity and pulled out her amulet. “Here.” I handed over the gold-and-jewel-encrusted thing. “Thank you.” Amren’s brows rose as I dropped it into her waiting palm. “You gave it back.” “I didn’t realize it was a test.” She set it back into the case. “Keep it. There’s no magic to it.” - ACOMAF, chapter 28
The key things to note:
Amren entered Feyre's room undetected, as a spy might.
The necklace was specifically called an amulet, that would prevent anyone from keeping her.
Feyre could use it to do what needed to be done, then return it.
Feyre questioned whether her returning the amulet to Amren was a test.
Amren said there was really no magic in it.
Amren told her to keep it.
Now, let's see how these passages stack up against those specific to Elain.
Elain Archeron and Azriel
Elain gave Truth-Teller back to Azriel after the battle in ACOWAR, when she used it to end the King of Hybern, and save Nesta and Cassian.
“You honestly think he’d ever give up Truth-Teller?” “He gave it to Elain,” Mor said, admiring a moonstone necklace in the counter’s glass case. “She gave it back,” I amended, failing to block out the image of the black blade piercing through the King of Hybern’s throat. But Elain had given it back—had pressed it into Azriel’s hands after the battle, just as he had pressed it into hers before. And then walked away without looking back. Mor hummed to herself. - ACOFAS, chapter 4
Elain gave her necklace back to Azriel after their disastrous winter solstice interaction in ACOSF.
Azriel winnowed into shadows before she could say anything, appearing at the doors to Rhys's study a heartbeat later. His shadows whispered in his ear that Elain had gone upstairs.
Rhys growled, "Allow me to make one thing very clear. You are to stay away from her." "You can't order me to do that."
He slept as well as could be expected, but when Azriel returned to the river house to gather his presents before dawn, he found Elain's necklace amid the pile. He pocketed it. Spent the rest of his day, even the blasted snowball fight, with every intention of returning it to the shop in the Palace of Thread and Jewels. But when he returned from the cabin in the mountains, he didn't go to the market square. Instead, he found himself at the library beneath the House of Wind, standing before Clotho as the clock chimed seven in the evening. - ACOSF, Azriel's Bonus Chapter
With Truth-Teller in hand, Elain sneaked up on the King of Hybern, undetected, and stabbed him through the neck. Nesta also noted her stealth-like behaviour in ACOSF, and wondered if she had been taking lessons from Nuala and Cerridwen, her two spy friends.
Azriel specifically described Elain's necklace as a sort of amulet. As I theorised last year, could it (now?) have some sort of protective power?
Elain used Truth-Teller to do what needed to be done, and then she returned it, as Azriel gave it to her.
There are still three parallels left that are yet to be answered; the test, the magic, and her keeping it.
Were Truth-Teller, or her necklace, tests of a sort?
A test could either be considered one of skill or worthiness. When she returned her necklace or Truth-Teller, was Elain herself testing one of her powers, or was she being tested by someone else, in terms of her moral fortitude or magical abilities, for an event in the future?
Elain handing Truth-Teller back to Azriel, after doing what needed to be done - might I add, very successfully - could be read as her passing a test of skill (stealth, accuracy of aim, possibly even her Sight if that was involved, and maybe activating Truth-Teller's ingrained magic). And because it would have been rude of her to keep Azriel's dagger forever when she was only given it for the day - or because she was able to give back a powerful, Made blade - this could maybe be considered a test of worthiness, too.
Azriel finding himself standing before Clotho, especially after the snowball fight, almost paralleled Gwyn finishing the Blood Rite qualifier, except instead of asking for a prize, he was giving up an object that meant a lot to him... but what if he was not the one being tested? Although, who knows, maybe he was being tested for his ability to give up a magical necklace?
@wingedblooms and I have both suggested that Elain could work with Clotho and the priestesses at some point, but what if she has already started to do so? Could she have told Clotho about what happened, or realised that she had possibly Made or imbued the necklace with her magic (at which time it was probably best to keep it out of the jewellery shop and the hands of the general public), and Clotho then instructed her to have the necklace compel Az to bring him and it to the library, where he "found" himself at 7pm? I'll admit, compelling someone isn't the nicest thing to do, so I hope it wasn't active on Elain's behalf, unless she hadn't left the necklace on Azriel's pile of gifts herself (perhaps Koschei has shadow moles in Velaris). That being said, they're about to enter another period fraught with dangerous enemies, and if we don't judge Rhys for using his daemati powers on enemies, or even Feyre (when he made her think they were at the lingerie shop), then we should extend the same grace to Elain, or anyone else.
Alternatively, if Elain's necklace is now Made, as I suspect her engagement ring is also, does it have a mind of its own and so orchestrated the return by itself? Did Elain realise this somehow, perhaps because she was its Maker and they share a link, and subsequently tell Clotho what happened, and that she needed to intercept it? Given Clotho found the songs that (I assume) helped to weave a spell that lured Nesta into scrying for the Harp, perhaps she gave another spelled song to the priestesses that night, in order to call to Azriel?
A crack theory based on @wingedblooms shapeshifting post: during Azriel's ACOSF bonus chapter, Clotho and Elain could both read him without words. What if it was not Clotho who met with Azriel - as she presided over the dusk service that Nesta watched, rather than sitting at her desk - but Elain as Clotho instead? Was Elain testing her (hypothetical) ability to glamour or physically change her appearance to keep a potentially powerful object safe? And if she has been working with Clotho for a time, was she a part of this plan, too?
Was there magic involved at any time?
Amren said there was no magic in the amulet she'd given Feyre, that it was all a story she'd concocted to give Feyre the confidence to overcome her fear and enter the depths of the Prison mountain, which we assume is the truth... but what if this isn't the case for Elain?
While some of us suspected that Truth-Teller was Made before CC HOSAB was published, it is now canon that the Starsword used by Bryce and Ruhn is, in fact, Gwydion, a Made blade from Prythian, and that Truth-Teller is its paired dagger. Alpha and Omega, light and dark (light). Because of this, and all of the hints written into the ACOWAR scene when Azriel armed Elain during the final battle, not to mention Elain stepping out of a shadow, I think it's absolutely plausible to consider that there was magic at play.
Elain's necklace could have come pre-spelled - Azriel didn't think it during his inner monologue, true, but I wouldn't put it past any of the bat bros to boost the protection of a loved one - or perhaps it had no magic when Azriel gifted it to her, but Elain Made it, or imbued it with magic some other way, while it was in her posession?
Will Truth-Teller and/or the necklace eventually be returned to Elain?
The above passage from ACOFAS could plausibly be read as suggesting that Azriel will give Truth-Teller to Elain once more. Given the likelihood of it either providing some sort of magical link between the two of them, or Elain being able to activate its inherent abilities, this isn't, in my opinion, too far fetched.
As I mentioned above, if Elain was conducting some sort of test with her necklace, could Clotho know that it was intended for her and is holding onto it/gave it back to Azriel? Or, if the wilder option is true, and Azriel met with Elain as Clotho, rather than Clotho herself, could Elain already have it back, or have returned it to Azriel once more?
Nesta Archeron and "someone else"
As a bonus, Nesta also "gave it [her Death magic] back" in ACOSF, to save Feyre, Nyx and Rhys.
So Cassian asked, “Is your magic … The power’s really gone?” The brisk spring wind whipped her golden-brown hair across her face. “I gave it back to the Cauldron in exchange for the knowledge of how to save them.” She swallowed. “But a little remains. I think something else—someone else—stopped the Cauldron from taking all of it. And I made some changes of my own.” - ACOSF, chapter 78
Was this also a test of worthiness, and because she passed - though I'm not suggesting she could have failed - by bargaining with the Cauldron to give back the magic she stole in return for Feyre, Nyx and Rhys' lives, she was permitted to keep some magic? What was the magic that this "someone else" kept back from the Cauldron? Could it be Starborn power - light - that was always hidden underneath the death magic she loathed?
As with everything I just discussed, I can't wait to find out!
66 notes
·
View notes
SJM made it abundantly clear in his bonus chapter that Elriel's end is unmistakable. I'm not sure how Azriel could win her back, nor do I think he even wants to at this point.
How can he bounce back from referring to what they were about to do as a mistake?
👏 when 👏 a 👏 male 👏 says 👏 it’s 👏 a 👏 mistake 👏
👏👏 believe 👏 him 👏👏
Even when he left, Azriel felt justified in his decision to do so. He had already been pursuing what he wanted with Elain, which was distance, and had deliberately been maintaining that distance. When he walked away, it wasn't in anger over Rhys telling him to stay away from her. Rather, he left with the belief that he had been vindicated in his choice to do so.
Are Elriels hoping for Elain to pursue a male who has labeled them a mistake, holding out hope that he'll change his mind?
Do they want her to beg and plead after she has returned the necklace to him?
Because Azriel won't. He felt justified in his choice to distance himself from her.
If Azriel goes against his own choice to maintain distance from her, it does imply that he's grappling with his instincts to be with her. This raises the question of whether he is now struggling against the very instincts they criticize Lucien for when he actively resists them.
This is canon:
Rhys vanished, and Azriel was left standing before Elain, who still awaited his kiss. His stomach twisted as he pulled his hand from her hair and stepped back. Forced himself to say, "This was a mistake.”
This is canon:
Then he flew to the House of Wind, knowing that if he slept in the riverside manor, he'd do something he regretted. He'd been so vigilant about keeping away from Elain as much as possible, and had stayed up here to avoid her, and tonight...tonight had proved he 'd been right to do so.
Considering this happened after Elain had returned the necklace, this is also canon:
Indeed, Azriel and Cassian had just leaned against the wall, arms crossed, and smiled at them the entire time.
Gwyn threw Azriel a withering stare as she strode past him. “See you tomorrow, Shadowsinger,” she tossed over a shoulder.
Az stared after her, brows high with amusement. When he turned back, Nesta grinned. “You have no idea what you just started,” she said.
Az angled his head, hazel eyes narrowing as Gwyn reached the archway.
“Remember how Gwyn was with the ribbon?” Nesta winked and clapped the shadowsinger on the shoulder.
“You’re the new ribbon, Az.”
One thing is undeniably clear: Azriel makes it known where he stands in his relationship with Elain, and to him, it feels wrong.
He may have not cared but everything he had done after the fact doesn’t suggest that.
Another undeniable fact remains: despite her discomfort, her declarations that she doesn't want a mate, her demeanor towards Lucien, the deliberate distance Lucien chose to maintain between them, and the assurance that Rhys will protect her, Elain has not yet rejected their bond.
However, what remains unknown is how Elain truly feels about Lucien.
It's worth noting that in this series, characters have been wrong before in assuming how others felt, and this might be another case of such misinterpretation.
39 notes
·
View notes