What if, in Spring Unsprung, that topsy turvey book actually showed everyone’s somewhat true feelings/intentions.
Apple White might’ve been evil due to pressure/stress(aka ff where Raven Queen saves the day again)
Daring Charming might’ve actually been a scared boy but due to high expectations, he had to shove those fears to the bottom of his heart and make his father proud.
Cedar Wood longs to lie and finally succeeded when she heard the spell.
Humphrey Dumpty is obv a sci geek but can’t experiment or experience anyt due to his story, so he got the chance to face his fears ykykyk?
I’m not rlly sure abt this cuz Holly&Poppy and Ashlynn&Hunter aren’t rlly… suitable
guys what if humphrey was in the ballroom when james died so he saw how he died, his final words, and the man that he loved? what if humphrey was the first one that james spoke to after he died? what if humphrey comforted james? what if humphrey saw the swagger stick exchange? what if the reason why humphrey didn't say much just before the clock striked 12 was because he knew what it felt? what if he didn't say anything because he was there? JUST THINK ABOUT IT!!!!!!! HE WASN'T THERE WHEN ALL OF THE OTHER GUYS WERE OUTSIDE!!!!!!!!
— Barclay is up to something shady and sneaks into the basement of Button House and gets locked/trapped inside. Could die (but hopefully not for Alison’s sake)
— The Ghosts are squabbling about Julian pushing Alison out the window causing her to see the Ghosts in the first place. She walks in and overhears this, hence finding out finally why she can see them.
— There will be a ball for a special event and at this event Kitty’s sister will kill her in some way, possibly poisoning her or locking her away someplace where she can’t get out. I don’t think it will be related to the pineapple, despite that now being a popular theory.
— Cap is returning to Button House for VE Day celebrations. Possibly a medal ceremony on this day or just a unit reunion. Havers will be in attendance. Havers will actually be the one with the medals and he is witness to Cap’s death. Cap’s medals are on incorrectly because they are actually Havers’ medals that he pins to Cap before or as he’s dying. Cap will also end up with the stick at time of death, as I don’t believe he has it prior. Also possible Havers admits his feelings for Cap in the moment between Cap’s death and becoming a ghost so Cap doesn’t actively hear it but Robin does. Robin tells Cap, finally bringing him some closure.
— There will be a montage of Robin watching other Ghosts get sucked off. He will come to realise there is a pattern to it and explain it to the other Ghosts. One or more of the Ghosts will have similar events happen over the course of a day and they all realise it might be one of them so they stick together. They’re all together at midnight and when no one has gone, Humphrey makes a joke to lighten the tension, they all laugh, he bows to accept their appreciation of his joke, his head falls off and his body gets sucked off. Humphrey will be the one to go. As I predicted months ago.
Edit:
(Also, I didn’t make theories for any other scenes because I was at the BFI screening and know what happens in the rest of them)
Meet Justice,Shaun, Judy & Jade Humphrey. They Live in Windenburg with their two pomeranian pups Mango & Mojo (p.s. these two loveeee swimming in the pool!!!! 🥰)
We can already tell who's the star of the show,Jade has my heart😍❤️