#secret good supernatural

[cursed-byesexual]

I'm such a sucker for fics from the pov of some NormalPerson™ who tries to understand what the actual fuck is going on with your fave. For example;

- Hermione's parents sort of got used to their daughter talking about dragons and curses and she makes it sound like its no big deal so they just go along with their strange kid. Except now there's a man at the door who says he's the minister of magic and he would like to personally invite you and your daughter to the first memorial of the final battle as she is a war hero of the highest order. What do you mean there was a war? Hermione, get down here this instant!

-Or a true crime podcast about the crimes of Sam and Dean Winchester through the eyes of someone who went to college with Sam. He hosts podcast nights and everytime one of Sams alleged kills is described he tells the friends who are listening with them about that time Sam went vegetarian for a month after watching a nature channel docu.

-Or Percy Jackson returns to a mortal high school after one of his adventures and one of his teachers has to try and decipher the transcripts from his old schools. How the fuck did this little skater boy blow up his last school? Why isn't he in prison??? Or dead??? The parent-teacher conference night that follows is one for the ages as Sally Jackson lies her ass off, but with skill.

-Or John Watson decides to go to a class reunion against better knowledge and Sherlock tags along to learn more about John out of boredom. His former classmates don't understand what the hell Sherlock Holmes is doing at their party if there hasn't been a murder and absolutely come to the conclusion that the two are together. They have to be, right?

Basically anything that puts these unhinged adventures and relationships into perspective I guess, sorry if these don't make sense,,, tag me if you know any fics of this sort! For any fandom! Or comment you own hc!!!

#harry potter #hermione granger #Percy jackson #Pjo #bbc sherlock #Sherlock #john watson #secret good supernatural #Supernatural #Spn #sam winchester #Dean winchester #outsider pov #fic idea #fic rec #fandom #johnlock

[raisedmefromperdition]

I listen VERY intermittently to Supernatural: Then and Now, tuned in this week because it’s Ben Edlund on The End.

I would die for that man. Half-convinced that he was on here in winter 2020/21 with us all…His theories about Chuck, about alternate universes, about reality in the SPN universe.

hbo!Supernatural is great, but showrunnerEdlund!Supernatural…that would have been magnificent.

#supernatural #ben edlund #secret good supernatural #spnblr #god is a gender less being and ‘dad god’ #‘dad god’ is an archangel/ angel dream #his BRAIN #amnesis of the gods in the mortal plain #is a phrase that is used #spn #spn 5x04 #“’chuck was depicting a vision of failed becoming’

[stvivi]

i wanna rewatch supernatural

but not cw's supernatural

the supernatural i've convinced myself exists based on spn meta posts from my faves on tumblr

#the supernatural that has and follows up on implications #and is a horror show and a show about family and about sam and dean's mutual fuckedupness #but mostly is about sam #secret good supernatural

[artemis-pendragon]

Imagine you're some religious guy who agrees to let an angel inhabit your body for a holy purpose and it all goes great except your wife thinks you're insane and threatens to take your daughter and leave but this is IMPORTANT so you let the angel in anyway. But then BUT THEN. it turns out the angel's mission is to pull Some Guy out of Hell and the fucking angel is gay and insane and rebels against Heaven because he wants to kiss this guy from literal Hell on the mouth so so so bad. Also many years later he does use your now thankfully empty human body (you got killed by Lucifer during the fight to stop the apocalypse btw) to fuck nasty with the guy he rescued because again, he's gay and insane. Every day Jimmy Novak wakes up

#the last part is from the secret good spn but yknow. death of the authors we make the rules #insane gay show for insane gay people #destiel #spn #supernatural #nov 5th

[carrotkicks]

somebody asked abt what chuuya was up to in the analog horror au. Answer is, he never gets to escape the government. but since i'm letting up on the weird art for the rest of the night, just know that he occasionally hangs out with these two.

#so the deal is: #ayatsuji was a private detective that was getting dangerously close to uncovering the secrets the special division was hiding #and taneda and ango were like. this guy is good. so instead of silencing the dude they hire him. get him in on the situation. #make him help them stop supernatural-related crimes. #and he gets assigned to be tsujimura's partner #tsujimura is still a failgirl tho dw #doodles #bsd #analog horror au

[princessplaidheart]

Watching Supernatural, Dean gets the Mark and flees Cain's house with Crowley.

Husband: So, Cain's a Knight of Hell, right? And he made the other Knights of Hell?

Me: Yeah, more or less.

Husband: Does that mean that Dean's a Knight of Hell, too?

Me: Eh, not yet.

Husband:

Me:

Husband: Yet?

Me:

...oops.

#spn #supernatural #spn rewatch #supernatural rewatch #season 9 #first born #dean winchester #crowley #cain #jensen ackles #mark sheppard #timothy omundson #watching with my husband #I'm awful at keeping secrets (good or bad) #i did keep two things from being spoiled by me #the trickster's real identity #and ezekiel's real identity #so there's that

[talesfromthebandgeekmafia]

Fucking love fandoms of stuff based on Christian mythology because you get folks who in the interest of creating more accurate nuanced fanfiction and theories about their biblical blorbos will straight up become scholars of theological texts for funsies

#bitches will be like ‘we’re trying to analyze and figure out if this Uberangel Dave is the same as the Uberangel Dave in the Bible 2 #or if she’s actually a representation of this other dude from the secret diary of this 14th century monk that became classic lit in France’ #AND I EAT IT UP EVERY TIME #I am. fucking OBSESSED with cross referencing shit for literary allusions & what those allusions suggest about how to read the themes & plot #the stuff about Pride & Prejudice alone in Good Omens 2 has KILLED ME #I would’ve been an english major if I didn’t find drawing easier than writing essays #spilling the Tea #good omens #supernatural #spn

[danandfuckingjonlmao]

i am so thankful for fandom.

i am so thankful for the gifsets, the fanfic, the fanart, the memes, the overanalysis of every little aspect of a piece of media, the group chats, the private spamming in dms, the openness towards making our own representation, the queer and neurodivergent safety that is created, the lack of shaming for intense emotional reactions or for being obsessive, the community aspect and discussion, etc.

and i am especially thankful for the validation, the closure, the healing, the solidarity, and the connection that fan spaces can provide. i’m thankful that i can have so much content for all of my interests, that i can feel that fulfilment of my deep desire to enjoy the things i love fully. i’m thankful that after i finish a show, a book, a movie, anything, and i’m genuinely upset, in tears, or maybe even having a trauma response (ex. media with mental illness or grief themes), i can come here and laugh. if i’m angry, if i’m ecstatic, if i’m unsatisfied, if i’m so anxious i don’t know what to do after i finish something, i can come here and know i’m not alone.

fandom is NOT all good. the discourse, the gatekeeping, the lack of boundaries when real life people are involved, and yeah, a lot of it enables unhealthy relationships with media. so many obsessions i’ve had have been toxic (*cough* supernatural *cough*), and being a part of fandoms didn’t exactly help me get out of that. however that can coexist with the fact that having other people as passionate as i was made me feel so much less alone and to this day gives me a safe space to release what is in my mind.

basically, thank you. if you’re on this hellsite, if you’re a creator within fandoms, a commenter, or just a lurker contributing with likes, you contribute to people like me feeling less alone, and i’m really glad you exist.

#good omens #the umbrella academy #dan and phil #spring awakening #bare: a pop opera #supernatural #torchwood #the song of achilles #carry on #the lord of the rings #dead poets society #teen wolf #aristotle and dante discover the secrets of the universe #the rocky horror picture show #the perks of being a wallflower #bo burnam inside #skins uk #shameless #heartstopper #julie and the phantoms #everything sucks! #élite #swiss army man #jagged little pill #twenty one pilots #my chemical romance #fall out boy #our flag means death #what we do in the shadows #yeet my deet

[peachcitt]

actually if goncharov were real it would never live up to the standards the insane tumblrinas have built it up to be. there is a triangle of homoeroticism, political commentary, and inevitably tragic in which any live, real adaptation would only conceivably be able to achieve two of to their fullest extent. added on to the fact that this is a film that supposedly is filmed and takes place in the seventies makes the possibility of it truly containing all aspects of what we have made it out to be even more far fetched. however, tumblr has been able to spin gold on far more real and disappointing media than goncharov through its analyses of media such as supernatural, sherlock, and a secret third piece of media that the subsequent creation and analyses of the ‘greatest mafia movie of all time’ goncharov is simply a natural step that tumblr as an ecosystem is willing to take. in this essay i will,

#goncharov #unreality #peach stuff #goncharov 1973 #someone accused me of being an english major (true) (god forbid women do anything) so this is also the natural step to take i suppose #anyway i do think i have a point in that we’re all already so used to performing in depth media analysis on media that simply. is bad. that #creating media from almost literally nothing and performing media analysis on it is just . i mean how can anyone be surprised #also before anyone says anything about it i didn’t mention doctor who in my list of bad media because well ive actually never seen #any episode in its entirety and i do know (as an english major) that science fiction is a fantastic way to deliver political commentary #ive also heard that the most recent season has been doing important work (at least from a meta standpoint) in gender politics #sherlock is. well. other iterations of sherlock holmes have certainly been better. and we all know supernatural is bad #i only listen ‘a secret third thing’ because traditionally it’s good to list three things to cite in your thesis. oldest trick etc #and anyway. that’s all my disclaimers. expect the essay never because im already overworked and underpaid<3

[cuubism]

Librarian!Dream from your cryptid Dream series is actually Retired!Dream who kept some semblance of his power and Hob is still immortal, he's just been meeting Death instead of Dream every century and thats why he isn't as freaked out by the supernatural as he should be, calling the shots right now

who's to say, really....

will I ever confirm what's "up" with Dream in this au? idk... maybe not :) it's much more fun to leave it all vague and hinted at and to let anyone who reads it imagine what they like

#maybe hob's good sense is just being blinded by his obsession with dream XD or maybe he just never had good sense to begin with #maybe he also has a supernatural secret or maybe he's just a regular unhinged bloke #maybe dream is ex-endless maybe he's some fey creature that governs stories maybe he's The Librarian (tm) maybe he /is/ the library #imagine how you wish #bookstore cryptid dream #ask #just-cosmere-fan

[shinelikethunder]

like i know I've probably said it before, but. as much as s11 is my favorite of the late seasons of SPN, Dean's half of the season plot is boring and any potential it ever had is consistently squandered, and Sam's half only works if you're seeing the shrimp-colors cage-trauma version that jarpad is acting, not the "enemies to reluctant team-up to celestial-family reconciliation" nonsense that the writers think is a neat way to arrange their toys in the Big Epic (Unspeakably Stupid) Arc Plot dollhouse.

and i can't speak to how much of it was really intended or by whom, but there IS a throughline in there that may not be well developed or resolved, but still reawakens the good old "oh right that's why i ever went apeshit feral over either of these guys to begin with" feelings. the one where every step along the path of the Lucifer plotline is one of the most pants-shittingly terrifying things Sam has ever had to do, and every encounter brings a fresh kind of betrayal and violation that he somehow was not expecting, and every escalating step of the team-up is far too much to ask of anyone with the kind of history he has with this fucker. and he does it anyway, even though it's unbearable. and it just makes him more determined to stay capable of faith and charity and trust in the face of all this, because he needs to, because it's been foundational since season 2 that some kind of faith in a benevolent higher power is a psychological need for him to keep going in the crapsack world they inhabit.

that's the version jarpad is acting, the one where okay fine, sam will do it, but he'll look like he wants to fucking die the whole time. and the instant he (visibly! you can see it! like a switch got flipped between episodes!) gets told to stop harshing the vibes of their stupid "god and lucifer do family therapy" comedy bit with all that buzzkill Resting PTSD Face... that's the exact instant s11 dissolves like tissue paper. and i stop being able to suspend my disbelief that it's anything but a collection of unusually solid one-off episodes held together by the dumbest excuse for an arc plot on god's green earth. like oh, shit, this entire time they were literally just finding neat ways to arrange the toys in the dollhouse without any attempt to delve into what makes these characters tick in that configuration. even though it is RIGHT! THERE! and at least one of the actors is serving it up to them on a platter. they TOLD HIM TO STOP SERVING UP THEIR UNDONE CHARACTER WORK ON A PLATTER.

so yeah. entire season arcs propped up by jared padalecki's acting. who'd've guessed.

#supernatural #spn s11 #meta #sam winchester #spn!lucifer #i am an early-seasons deangirl 4lyfe but GOD s11 turned me into a samgirl through sheer desperation to fix what they gave him #the secret good s11 that lives in my head is so good and the sam whump is so delicious

[amourphousblob]

started watching spn again today after like a month. my two main takeaways are wow i forgot how much fun this show is and wow i forgot how questionable this writing is

#and the fun secret third takeaway. as always. is that dean and castiel are gay 4 each other #its a fun show. i will never accuse it of being a good show #spn #supernatural #river.txt

[casdeans-pie]

Supernatural is the only show I've seen where it has literally aired its Final Episode. and yet somehow it's still going

#I both love and hate this #because on one hand I crave more content but on the other please stop we've already suffered enough #supernatural #spn #destiel #the script drops causing us all collective psychic damage every time #the slow drip feed of the secret good spn that lives in everyones minds #the slow reveal of the love story WE ALL KNEW WAS THERE ALL ALONG

[stellerssong]

3. and 6. for the new years ask >:)

3. Do you anticipate writing for a new fandom this year? Which one?

might break into awake alan at some point, if only because at this point i have basically no faith in fandom-at-large's ability to acknowledge that woc have souls, brains, hearts, characterizations, or, indeed, major plot-driving storylines. same with blue eye samurai, with the added caveat that there's no way i would ever publish in that fandom, because AS a queer mixed race asian woman with a specific interest in japanese history. i just knoooooooooooooow people are already out there somewhere making strong statements about sexuality/gender divorced from race and historical context that would instantly transform me into an earthly vessel for the infernal powers of satan himself. and i'm not trying to get mixed up in that shit.

realizing this answer makes me sound extremely mean and jaded about fandom. hm! well! so it goes.

6. Which yet-to-be-started fic is first on your list?

well, i've got a lot of wips that need to be cleared off the docket before i can seriously think about starting anything new, especially since i'm really trying to have revisionsverse be truly donezo this year. HOWEVER i was vaguely talking to @eri-223 about some kind of character study of Kiran Estevez immediately pre-Control that brings in both her ill-fitting mentee/mentor relationship with Helen Marshall and her crackly but also sorta sexy antagonism with/towards Emily Pope, and i thiiiiiiiiink there's just enough canonical justification for her to end up talking to both of them and maybe even The Federal Bureau Of Control's One And Only Singin' And Dancin' Man. so. wheels turning, etc.

#ask games #chatter #now do i have any ACTUAL plot bunnies about bes. no not really #but i do look at mizu and think to myself ''i could creechur her so good'' so there you have it! #on god mizu we're gonna give you feathers. or a tail. or some such weird shit just give me a second to think #as for kiran.........god i do not want to do fbi-adjacent procedural fic even if it's in the secret supernatural fbi #BUT i do so love a woc who is extremely fucking tired and having a very bad day; week; month; year; maybe even lifetime #and i guess it falls upon me to unpack the structural racism at work in the upper echelons of the fbc #tragic. everyone go read katabasis.

[from-mars-to-venus]

telling my literary agent my project is like “Studio Ghibli meets the Legend of Zelda” before they open their mouth and a torrent of a million tiny knives shoot out at me, perforating my body endlessly and turning me into oozing Swiss cheese

#it’s like if The Mandalorian met The Witcher #it’s like if Lord of the Rings met Dune #it’s like if Rosemary’s Baby met Song of Achilles #it’s like if The Love Hypothesis met The Secret History #it’s like if Colleen Hoover met Colleen Ballinger #it’s like if Hamilton met 2Pac #it’s like if the McElroy Brothers went to Night Vale #it’s like if Sonic met Mario #it’s like if F.R.I.E.N.D.S met The Office #it’s like if What We Do in the Shadows met Parks and Rex #what if Ready Player One had even more anime references 😎 #it’s like if Good Omens met Dr. Who #it’s like if Star Trek met World War Z #it’s like if Supernatural met real life mutual aid practices #it’s like if Game of Thrones met…. da Magic School Bus???!! #it’s a bit of a cosmic gumbo #this is vaguing one particular book lol but it’s a trend that irritates me in general #it’s like if aesthetics met vibes

[cliveguy]

a piece of media that is technically so bad but also accidentally so oddly specific to something going on in your life that it just becomes something else entirely in your brain

#um.txt #i made fun of supernatural fans with a secret good supernatural in their head but i kind of get it now. secret good * that ive essentially #hallucinated based off my very biased interpretation of what was happening on my screen.