I tried to make it pretty accurate to both shows lmao but I had to guess on a lot of the dates
Unsolvednatural script by Caeli
Ryan: This week on Buzzfeed Unsolved, we look into the mysterious case of the Winchesters. The undead serial killer brothers from Kansas.
Shane: why’d you have to say “from Kansas” why is that relevant
Ryan: i dont know it’s just where they’re from
Shane: also how are they “undead”?
Ryan: I guess you’ll have to see
{Shane turns head and looks at camera, his love for Ryan decreasing by the second}
[Voiceover]
Ryan: On January 24, 1979, John Winchester and Mary Campbell Winchester had a son named Dean and four years later on May 2, 1989, their second son Samuel.
Then six months later, a fire started in Sam’s nursery, killing Mary.
Shane: but the baby was fine?
Ryan: yeah
Shane: what time did this happen? Like the middle of the day or-
Ryan: I think it was night time
Shane: then how did the baby survive??
Ryan: *laughs* i dont know he just did
Ryan: The family began to move around and their whereabouts are widely unknown until 2004 when Sam enrolled in Stanford University.
Then, a year later, a few days after Halloween, his girlfriend Jessica Moore was killed in a fire in their apartment.
Shane: and he survived again? That’s a coincidence.
Ryan: *laughs* yeah
Shane: what if he is the one lighting the fires? There it is solved the case
Ryan: and he set the first one as a baby?
Shane: you never know
Ryan: Then he went on a road trip with his brother Dean and again they go off the grid, until, March of the next year, Dean murders Becky Warren, another Stanford student. But when they go to arrest him, he is found dead in Warren’s house.
However, more than an entire year later, in April of 2007, a woman named Karen Giles calls 911 claiming someones in her house. When police arrive, they find Dean Winchester there over her body.
Shane: That explains the “undead” part
Ryan: ding ding ding
Shane: maybe he had a secret twin
Ryan: i don’t think he did
Shane: you never know
Ryan: he didn’t have a secret twin
Ryan: He and his brother escape police custody after they were almost killed by an officer.
[Video returns to Shane and Ryan at table]
Ryan: what’s interesting about that arrest though is that there’s a police video of Dean claiming that a monster killed Karen Giles and her husband and that he didn’t kill the previous girl either, it was a shapeshifter
Shane: what
Ryan: yeah
Shane: maybe he wasn’t lying
Ryan: I thought you don’t believe in monsters
Shane: I don’t but that’d be fun if he was telling the truth
Ryan: or hes just a sociopath
Shane: yeah true
[Voiceover again]
Ryan: Then in July of that same year, the brothers were involved in a bank heist where one woman died. However they didn’t steal anything and escaped unnoticed before they were caught.
They weren’t arrest again until August of 2008, when local police get a tip to their location. They are later killed in an explosion at the station, which also kills 5 employees.
Then we’re presumed dead until June 2012 when they go on a mass mudering spree across multiple states.
They were arrested again and died again in police custody.
Shane: and then they rise again?
Ryan: actually no this the last time they were officially seen alive
Shane: officially?
Ryan: yeah there’s been claims on the internet about people seeing them alive but we’ll get to that
Ryan: Let’s get into the theories
[theory music plays]
The first theory is a very popular one online. There are many claims and even some photos that try to prove the brothers are still alive. Along with this theory many believe that in the police tape of Dean, he in, in fact, telling the truth.
[Shane and Ryan at table again]
Shane: I said that!
Ryan: I’m aware that you said that
Shane: Ok but then why would these brothers be in so many situations like these? Are they monster hunters or something?
Ryan: True
Shane: also why would they go on a murder spree then too
Ryan: yeah... maybe more shapeshifters?
[Voiceover]
Ryan: The second theory suggests that the brothers come from a cult family, as many of their family members have had run ins with the law and supposedly risen from the dead.
This theory also suggests that the brothers truly believe they are killing monsters because they were brainwashed, mostly by their father.
Shane: that’s dark but it makes a lot more sense
Ryan: yeah but their father also died in early 2006 so why did they keep hunting these fake monsters
Shane: the wonders of brainwashing man
Ryan: Our third theory is that Sam and Dean are actually the characters from the book series Supernatural, come to life
Though since the books were always released after the events happened in real life, many people believe that it was based on the real life brothers
Shane: these theories get dumber and dumber. How would that even work?
Ryan: maybe they were friends with the author, Carver Edlund. He also went missing around 2011.
Shane: Ok that makes more sense the “book characters come to life”
Ryan: and our final theory is.... aliens
[back to the boys at the table]
Shane: *slams fits* YOU ALWAYS SAY ALIENS
Ryan: *wheeze* hear me out
Shane: I don’t wanna hear you out no
Ryan: just listen!
[Voiceover]
Ryan: in this theory, the brothers are actually an evil alien race that can rise from the dead
[back at the table]
Shane: no they’re not
Ryan: *laughs*
[voiceover]
Ryan: Whether they were brainwashed or they were aliens, the mysterious deaths and murders of the Sam and Dean Winchester remains Unsolved
[unsolved music and stuff]
[back at the table with le boys]
Ryan: which one do you think it is
Shane: the second one because it’s the only one that’s realistic or even makes sense
Ryan: but how does it explain how they rose from the dead?
Shane: i dont know man this case is weird
267 notes
·
View notes