Tumgik
#i'm definitely willing to change my opiniona on this I really like people give their opinions on jjba
sepyana · 3 months
Text
The most common reason why people think Diavolo's death was undeserved is because other villains who are just as bad him don't get he punishment he does. I do agree with that but I don't think that would make his punishment undeserved, it would just make it disproportionate. So you can think he deserves infinite deaths but still think his punishment unfair.
Tumblr media
And I DO believe it's disproportionate, at least when comparing how much harm they caused.
Diavolo's sphere of influence doesn't reach beyond Italy for the most part, compared to Valentine who would have fucked up every country besides USA if Johnny hadn't stopped him. But Valentine dies normally in the end. The only reason he keeps dying is because of his choice. He could die if he wanted to. Johnny says infinite rotation might destroy his soul but we don't know if that's even true.
Tumblr media
Dio gets a normal death too. He is just as sadistic as Kira and has caused way more suffering than him but he doesn't get fucking. banished to the shadow realm like Kira.
The only punishment that even compares to the infinite death loop is Kars's. But the way his ability is set up, it's not like there was any other way to defeat him other than sending him to space.
This is just one of many ways to compare their crimes, I didn't even include what happened to Lucy even tho it's a big reason why Valentine is a horrible person for me personally.
There is one thing I didn't mention though. There is a chance that the infinite death loop is not actually infinite. Generally, when stand users die, their stand dies with them. A stand dissapears with their powers. For example: when Risotto is at the brink of death, the needles and the scapels created by Metallica dissapear. What's also true is that Diavolo doesn't get his iron back, even tho that was caused by Metallica too. I'm not sure which one the death loop counts as. Does GER have to keep the death loop active or is it a one time thing? If it's the former, death loop would stop once Giorno dies (assuming GER dies with him). So he would be in the death loop for around 60-80 years. I still think that's the worst fate out of all the other villains' fates but I can definitely see why someone would argue otherwise.
But then again he wouldn't be in this situation to begin with if he wasn't selling drugs to kids. Maybe don't be evil↪ posts
26 notes · View notes