Tumgik
About
Privacy Policy
Removal Request
Visit Blog
Explore Tumblr blogs with no restrictions, modern design and the best experience.
Fun Fact
Users from the US are the majority of Tumblr visitors.
#Jane's deliberate choice to show mercy again and again IS essential to the story
thatscarletflycatcher
·
11 months
Text
The more the time passes, the more convinced I am that a reading of Jane Eyre that omits the theme of mercy as key to the story is incomplete at best and bad at worst.
#jane eyre
#i think this is at the root of all the insidious and useless darcy vs rochester comparisons
#because ultimately the wrong Austen heroes do is forgivable
#the effects of their sins are more or less easily reversable
#such as Darcy's pride and rudeness or Wentworth's pettiness
#there is mercy being served with atonement
#but it isn't a radical mercy
#which I think is the point in Jane Eyre
#Rochester's attempted bigamy is beyond justification
#it can only be understood as sourced in stupidity and immaturity rather than in true wickedness
#it can also be understood as part of the way he was raised up and the sins of his own father
#but cannot be justified
#Rochester can only be either hated and shunned or loved and forgiven
#there's no possibility of indifference
#the characters that create the most unhappiness to themselves and others in this novel are those who live without mercy
#and those who act with mercy the opposite
#Rochester's redemption is possible because he has shown mercy to others
#at least sometimes like Adele and his first years with Bertha
#st John can have everything in his favor and yet his mercilessness makes him a figure of fear for Jane
#Jane's deliberate choice to show mercy again and again IS essential to the story
#Jane Eyre is a bildungsroman AND a romance because of it
#readings that seek to turn Rochester into a complete forever villain
#i.e. he is a liar and he actually tortured Bertha into madness
#are ultimately readings that want a reason to reject any sort of mercy for him
#by making him incapable of good and repentance
288 notes
·
View notes
Last Seen Blogs
heughan
hannah
chantmoon-arclibrary
琉的文庫
cathychmilnitzky
click2bookflights
Untitled
mysteriouslybluepirate
A Curse is a Curse