erehis

[erehis]

https://twitter.com/erurouraito/status/1393485944074891267

Welp, I'm not active on tumblr anymore but I still love erehisu with all my heart and I will produce more EH content in future if I have time.

So if you found this tumblog by chance and want to contact me to ask anything related to my posts here, just DM @ erurouraito on twitter or @ shieru#0926 on discord, I don't bite.

[erehis]

Happy late EH day~

Link download: GG DRIVE

(No password)

#erehisu #hs myscans

[erehis]

"Live for myself" is Historia's motto, not "Live with chest puffed out" (Live with pride).

https://twitter.com/erurouraito/status/1366006282889486336

___________

the change of "you can relax" to "Mikasa" is still logical when Eren called her by name as Grisha told her name to Eren and she was the only kid around his age in that area before they meet, but I still find it kinda interesting because it made clearer when considering different hypotheses.

 https://twitter.com/erurouraito/status/1363789540171730946

___________

last time mks got headaches is 112, combining with the most likely reason is due to her trauma when she feels/is reminded of losing her family, i find it weird when she didn't have it hearing eren must be killed (136) & seeing eren is killed (137).

https://twitter.com/erurouraito/status/1363550372955004928

If he intentionally stopped her headaches in 112, Eren successfully stopped her from liking him. I mean, after being insulted, she kinda uncrushed him already but still doesn't wanna admit it?  But she still has feeling for him as a family member of course.

https://twitter.com/erurouraito/status/1363707659099152385

idk why isym didn't let her have headache in 133, i find it was kinda wasted bcz it'd be more impactful than 136 137.

https://twitter.com/erurouraito/status/1363752372825059328

#hs myposts

[erehis]

List of reasons why Historia's pregnancy doesn't belong to any plan and Eren is most likely the father of her child.

This is a list of references for EreHisu fans to avoid wasting time to explain everything to speed readers. You don't need to be Japanese to understand plot and theme, but you need to have ability to connect the dots in the whole picture and EHs have reasons to say Eren is the father of Historia's child.

• 50y plan needs Historia to turn into Titan first before having children. Historia getting pregnant not only postpones Beast inheritance while Zeke's tenure is ending soon, the pregnancy itself is risky that Paradis might lose Royal blood.

• MP wanted turn Historia into Beast asap because they didn't trust Zeke. Historia having child at the moment only made their plan messed up that they even came up with the idea to turn her into Titan when she was still in her pregnancy.

• MP interpreted Historia getting pregnant in order to prolong Zeke's life. Even MP didn't believe Historia having a child just to save herself regarding how risky the pregnancy was, they doubted her selfish act was due to Yelena and they considered H as possible traitor, so they checked out farmer.

From MP's perspective: 

→ Historia must've got guarantee from Titan power before having children.  → Historia needed to to eat Z first, not to get pregnant right away.  → Historia was seen as Yeagers' accomplice.  → Historia could be used as hostage if father of her child had link with Yeagers.

• Zeke & Yelena prepared the wine plan from the start. Without Historia's participation, (in which they'd have to spend more time to meet Historia under MP's eyes & to bet on her ability of reproduce that must've been in time), by using wine, they already were able to process everything as planned.

• Yelena was the one who stole serum to transform Eldian into Titan from Marley. If Yelena purposely didn't steal serum or didn't give them to MP, no one could force Historia to eat Zeke either, whether Historia got pregnant or not. Maybe Yelena simply didn't care because even if Historia become Titan instantly, she couldn't eat Zeke anyway with the military and wine plan are all in her hands.

• As Yelena said, the others must maintain Beast & Founder until the child pass away, meanwhile it's no different to do same method & wait for Historia to pass away as her age is just close to the latest generation. Historia having child only postpones Euthanazation that Zeke doesn't wish for.

Further explanation: Assume Zeke and Yelena planned Historia having child to maintain backup weapon for island, Zeke must've ensured that Historia already delivered baby. Which means, as Historia is a part of his plan, Zeke should've checked if Historia had given birth yet, just like how Levi & Pixis mentioned her name when discussing how to oppose the Yeagers.

But Zeke never mentioned Historia, neither had time to come in contact with Yelena to know her situation (assume Yelena knew it); it means Zeke was ruining his own plan by ordering Ymir to make Eldians incapable to create children immediately (before Rumbling) while Historia was still pregnant at the moment.

In short, Zeke was never shown to mention Historia's pregnancy as a part of his Euthanization plan. Moreover, if Zeke and Yelena planned this pregnancy, they must have waited some more time for the child to be born, as Historia's delivery was only happening after the Rumbling of current timeline a few days. But in fact they only waited for the world alliance force to gather and then Zeke was hurry to come in contact with Eren just to do Euthanazation.

• With MP's level of securities & how Yelena had her hands in military, it would be easier to help Historia temporarily hide somewhere rather than asking her to get pregnant. Moreover, Historia having kid out of her will means she wants to reproduce, which makes her against anti-natalism gang Zeke and Yelena.

From Z&Y's perspective:

→ H wasn't needed to prolong Z's life. → H didn't need to use pregnancy to protect herself either. → H having child only slows down Euthanazation progress. → H isn't really ZY's ally as she chose to reproduce rather than running away in few months.

• Eren had to fight a long way to come in contact with Zeke, he also had to fight Zeke in Paths to gain Founder over him. While in fact, Eren just needed to let Historia to turn into Beast after Zeke landing on island & it'd be way easier for him to avoid unexpected things & to control Founder.

→ Eren could've let Historia become Beast to access Founder power, by doing that he could have avoided an unexpected battle in Shiganshina and Historia would've been a greater ally rather than his anti-natalism brother, but he didn't do that because he never prepared to sacrifice Historia's life. 

• Assume Eren already has given up on Historia (let Historia save herself & prolong Zeke's life in her way), then when Zeke ordered Ymir to sterilize all Eldians, Eren shouldn't have that terrified face as he broke the chain and ran after Ymir at lightning speed as if he couldn't undo the order later.

→ Factor made Ymir stop wasn't because Eren caught her but because Eren's words moved her. Thus, as long as Ymir's on his side, Eren will still be able to redesign bodies of Subjects of Ymir even if they were sterilized. But apparently Eren was terrified bad thing would happen to the pregnant woman he knew at the moment.

• Eren didn't accept Historia to have children to sacrifice for the island. Logically, Eren wouldn't accept Historia to have a child for Zeke's plan nor his plan. Eren didn't allow her to become Titan and have her children eat her (inheritant cycle) which means "accept", thus he only proposed "run" or "fight" to her.

→ Eren didn't accept Historia have child for MPs plan, so of course he didn't use her child for another plan. Eren gave his friends “freedom” to help him or not in Liberio attack, he even gave Alliance "freedom" to risk their lives to fight him but didn't give Historia "freedom" to sacrifice her life for island, which means there’s no way Eren would have let Historia to save (kill) herself in dumbest way.

• Historia was willing to do anything to save Paradis, which means if there's a most reliable way for both island and herself, obviously Historia would pick it. Historia & Eren both have strong desire to protect home country, so although they know genocide is wrong, it's their only option.

→ Since everyone already gave up on her, naturally Historia couldn't come to hate Eren, the only one left who refused to sacrifice her and keep searching for solutions to save her life. And their mutual desire is to protect Paradisians' lives & Historia (herself)'s life; so needless to say, full Rumbling is the most efficient way to ensure their safety.

• Assume Eren was too late as Historia already got pregnant with farmer's child, it means her pregnancy was known ~10 months ago. However, by saying that, Levi wouldn't have misinterpreted Historia's due date, MP wouldn't have pressed to turn her into Titan impatiently as if she wouldn’t be able to give birth before the world’s attack on island, and Zeke+Yelena must've checked her to ensure the next royal heir is born as said.

→ Yelena had no reasons to meet Historia (scroll back to Zeke & Yelena’s perspective part). Also, Yelena only recollected meetings with Eren and Floch. From Historia's side, to have farmer's child from 10 months ago means MP+SC must've known his existence for at least 8-9 months, therefore they shouldn’t have mistaken the due date of her pregnancy that much.

• Historia was born as a planned and loveless child; she later runs an orphanage to help children who have lost their parents on island. Thematically, Historia wouldn't have a child just to save herself or to serve a plan like her parents did, since Isayama stated that, just like Eren, Historia killed & surpassed her father.

→ Historia definitely doesn't use her child for revenge or for saving her life, she had to taste the pain of being unloved and abandoned by her parents thus for a person has killed the father who wanted to manipulate her for his sake, Historia wouldn’t repeat that mistake. Moreover, people in last arc keep being reminded that they shouldn't use their children for their own sakes, adults should take all responsibilities and get the children out of forest because children are future.

Bonus farmer-kun's perspective: 

>I was proposed to have a child with queen who is problematic enough to make me be interrogated and treated as pawn of criminals >somehow the supposed child of mine is born sooner than expected but it looks like a full months newborn >some think it's premature birth, some think it's bcz I got her pregnant 10m ago >but 10m ago that person also met a guy few times >so I believe it's not my child >bcz she looks like she'd kill me just by looking at my existence already how tf I could touch her...

#erehisu #snk meta #erurouraito/status/1364990039722131456

[erehis]

Because Eren couldn't throw away what was important to him (future of Paradis), he made an irrational decision (genocide). Unlike him, Mikasa is a person who could give up important things in the end.

#hs personal

[erehis]

about Zeke and Armin conversation

#hs myposts #erurouraito/status/1362375260864012289

[erehis]

「その好意には正体も習性もやむにやまれぬ理由も無い

ただお前のためなら巨人をひねり殺せるくらい

お前が好きなだけだ」 

 I agree with anon (image below) this part is parallel of M→E & E→H. And imo Eren was thinking about Historia not only because Zeke's words triggered him; but it's also likely what Eren could have said to Historia.

First, the part "that favor has no compelling reason, neither true nature or habit" is as it's said in image above; just like Mikasa's affection towards him, Eren's feeling towards Historia has nothing to do with memories from Frieda or any other reasons.

Second, I always think it's strange that Zeke said 巨人を捻り殺せる (snap the titan's neck), which is "twist the titan's neck to death" aka using your limbs to lock and break the titan's neck/nape. A job that Mikasa never could do despite she's an Ackerman because she has a body size of human.

Since this technique requires a body size of titan. So unless you're as big as titans, you can only kill them by [slicing] their necks with blades, or by [blowing] their necks with thunder spears. and guess who's been breaking necks of titans with his four limbs in a titan body?

Zeke coincidentally used a metaphor that Eren could feel so relatable, and only he could. Eren must've known his favor toward Historia as well, everything would've been easier to let Historia become titan to do Rumbling since she wouldn't try to order Ymir euthanize Eldians in paths.

Next, I know considering the whole context, it's Zeke talking about Mks. However, since jpn usually omits subject in sentence, original text in bubbles texts attached to Eren could be interpreted as "(1) I'd snap the titan's neck just for you (2) simply because I love you."

Isym's words choice is interesting, the Yeagers convo is a continuation of EH convo. "Eren, I want to know the reason behind your favor towards me" "That favor has no compelling reason, neither true nature or habit. I'd snap titan's neck just for you, simply because I love you."

"[I'm doing this plan because] I only have 4 years left [to protect you]." "Well, Eren, what would you think about me having a child? (A life of yours that will continue even after you die)" <I want them to live long, happy lives> (Eren mentioned [them] in a conversation which mentioned Mikasa only)

If we say what Zeke said might be just figuratively comparison, then why Eren didn't bother to think of Mikasa, or why Isym didn't insert a {random panel} of Mikasa's favor toward Eren flashback to remind Eren that these acts are out of love as he always do for other characters.

EMs try hard to deny Eren didn't think of Hisu and it was just an only 'random panel', but I wonder do they consider the fact this panel randomly exists in the convo about Mks's feeling instead of her shard just shows that Isym didn't have intention to push the climax on her feelings but Hisu's ask, lol.

#erehisu #hs myposts #erurouraito/status/1356634293825507329

[erehis]

Rumbling chapter official release date is August 7, the day between the atomic bombing of Hiroshima (August 6) and Nagasaki (August 9). Japan also just held a ceremony to remember the 75th anniversary of the bombing on August 6, day before the release of c131 in Japan.

Now I somehow understand why did he particularly describe the Rumbling from innocent people's pov, people in the bombing 75 years ago were innocent citizens who didn't know what happened to them before they died as well.

I feel like he wants to imply that innocent people's death in war is inevitable, just like how Wall Maria, Hiroshima and Nagasaki habitants died when they were attacked. It's true deaths of people like Ramzi and Halil are unjust, but it can't be helped since he cannot prioritize their lives over lives of people who are important to him.

[erehis]

景色

The scenery that Armin saw: the death of a child.

The scenery that Eren saw: the birth of a child.

___

On the second thought, I think that it could be implied that Armin saw the destruction of the current world, but Eren saw the reconstruction of a new world.

#hs personal #you know what i mean #eren and his child #with historia of course #no room for mks

[erehis]

First off I hope your staying safe with covid19. Second any thoughts about chapter 130 and Erehisu conversation and the Bearing child moment and the possibility of Eren being the father still happing even though some still think he can't be the father because he will die in 4 years like Eren said to Zake or because of Mikasa feelings. So if you have time to answer my question please do and could you add some images while explaining about my question.

Thank you and sorry for late reply, I forgot to reply you for so long.

I answered a similar question about 2 years ago:

According to their argument, no child would be born during wars; and Grisha knew that he would die in 13 years but he still got married and Eren is obviously his love child with Carla.

And Eren isn't obligated to reciprocate Mikasa's feelings lol.

[erehis]

What is the meaning of dusk and dawn?

Dusk and Dawn collection: https://erehis.tumblr.com/post/178928870827/

#hs replies #rubberbrain7

[erehis]

How do you think Eren reacted when Historia asked him that question (regarding having a child)?

Somehow I guess it would be like this. lol

#hs replies

[erehis]

@ instagram snk pages take my edits/translations without credit and add your logo/name in my works instead: FUCK YOU.

[erehis]

EM shippers, are saying that Eren cannot be the father because the timeline doesn't add up based on when Historia's due & when Eren was on the island & in Marley. Do you have a better idea of how the timeline actually is? I thought he was gone about 2 years but some people are saying a couple months? Thanks!

I made a post about the timeline on island long ago. (here) In short, it’s been a month since the Liberio attack. However I’m gonna make another timeline about how long Eren was in Marley below.

Eren appeared in c93 for first time at the harbor and he saw Reiner with kids at that time and his armband was on the wrong side. In c100, in his memory, his armband was still on the right (wrong) side.  

→ IMO, Eren snuck into Marley’s military on the last day of the war. I mean, in c123, we can see that they arrived at Marley harbor and we didn’t see them using train so we can interpret that Kiyomi’s estate is just around the port so that Eren could go to the battlefield Slava easily by jumping in the ships. After the last battle between Marley & Mid-East alliance, warrior kids were at another harbor (not Marley harbor) where we first saw hobo Eren. Thus, I guess Eren just blended into Marley force during the battle and followed them go back to Marley later. 

But if Eren were a Marleyan-Eldian soldier for a longtime, he wouldn’t fuck up by wearing his armband on wrong side because it would only make him suspicious. The Eldian soldiers/warriors had to wear armbands even in battles so Eren just needed to stay in the military for a couple days to know which side to wear but we all see that he didn’t wear it correctly from battlefield to Liberio. Eren even wore it on wrong side before meeting Falco, so we can let aside the case he did it on purpose to get close to Falco. The only explanation I can come up with is that he didn’t really participate the fight because he only joined in on the last day.

I wouldn’t have mentioned this detail if Isayama let Eren wear armband correctly in battlefield and changed it later in Liberio so I can understand that he wore it wrongly on purpose. Otherwise, if he could wear it on wrong side for a long time without being noticed, he really had unreal luck. And he also risked his identity by constantly wearing it on wrong side although he hadn’t met Falco yet.    

The memory of Eren in c100 when talking to Falco also showed that Eren with moustache still had both eyes. But I consider this part is somewhat a mistake from Isayama or just a symbolistic implication from Eren (he still saw everything with both eyes, something like that), because in c130 he got his left eyes blinded when he hadn’t grown mustache yet. 

At the end of c93, we can see that they also went back to Liberio immediately during night. No time skip between their battle and their coming home since Eren wore the armband on the wrong side whole time.

In c95 and c97, I feel like because of Reiner’s long flashback between the chapters, Isayama made both Marleyan soldier and Eren using “the other day” (この間) to remind the reader c95 and c95 are continuous, この間 is a vague word about the recent events, usually just a couple days ago. My bet is about 1 week.

The memories about Marley that Eren mentioned was just "slept under the same roof, ate the same food" (exactly what he had done in c123) and it gives the vibe of him during the time in hospital since he didn’t mention any "fought together in battle", which is kinda odd to me if we assume that he were a soldier for months since fighting for their ideologies is a keyword of Eren & Reiner conversation.

And as I mentioned above that Eren wasn’t in Marley long enough to know that Eldians must wear their armband on the left, it means that he didn’t spend any time longer than what we’ve seen in c123, he just left after the international forum which was held the next day after their arrive as Hans said to Kiyomi. 

In c.98, we actually have a confirmation by Willy that it’s been 1 month from the day he entrusted Magath the duty (c97) to the day before the war declaration; and Falco sending letter for Eren was after their handshake panel, which means both events happened simultaneously. Udo also said that it was “just last month” since their war with Mid-East alliance.    

→ From c97 to c98 there’s a short time skip. 1 month + 2 days he spent with other SC members (c123) + about 1 week in hospital, up to the day before festival night, I think that Eren had been in Marley around 1 month to 1 month and a half only.

____________

In short, ~1.5 month in Marley + 1 month after Liberio attack (in Paradis) = 2-2.5 months.

#hs replies #Anonymous

[erehis]

Chào cậu! Tui cực thích mấy bài về EH của cậu, hóng bài của cậu thường xuyên ấy. Chả là tui muốn hỏi cậu vài vấn đề, trong c.130, flashback của Eren có cảnh Falco từ góc nhìn trên cao, tui thắc mắc không biết Eren có phải hóa thành thần nên mới nhìn được từ góc độ đó? Và c cũng rõ mấy bài khóc mướn về EM ở VN nhiều thế nào rồi đấy, fan EM luôn mồm nói rằng mấy mảnh ký ức về Mikasa to nhất là vì Eren yêu Mikasa nhất. Cậu có cách nào lý giải vấn đề này không? Chỉ là tui khá thắc mắc. Cảm ơn c.

Sorry for late reply, I don’t feel like to use pc lately.  

Basically you asked me about the angle of Falco shard and the size of Mikasa shard. 

About Falco, frankly I’m not interested in this character (his brother Colt was more interesting imo) so I don’t really pay attention to this matter. However I don’t think that point of view was from the flying falcon (most popular theory) because... that falcon is not a Subject of Ymir and it’s just a symbol of freedom of manga.

Personally I think that shard was from Colt’s view, he was also a Subject of Ymir without Titan Power just like 10yo!Eren in first chapter and we all know that Ymir Fritz can break in her subjects’ minds since they’re all connected by paths. Take a look at this scene again, Colt had to put Falco’s arm down which means when his brother got closer and looked at him with from up to down, he still kept the same pose as in previous page. 

About Mikasa, my answer is here but I quote this again for you:

“OMG MKS HAS THE BIGGEST FRAME SHE IS THE MOST IMPORTANT PERSON TO EREN!!”

>He doesn’t remember the tears of that girl in the recent event but Historia’s tears 10 months ago.

>He doesn’t remember muh “I will wrap this scarf around you forever” but a childhood’s memory.

>According to frame size logic, Carla has the small frame size so does that mean his mother is not as important as his adoptive sister?!

And as an update from new chapter: 

IMO, Mikasa shard in c120 was the biggest because it was related to the first shard in c130, his mind was triggered back then by Ymir Fritz and that’s why when he entered the paths it reminds him of that moment under the tree with Mikasa 10 years ago, it was like the item selected is bigger than other items when using phone lol. 

Moreover, in c130, the biggest shard is EH hand kissing scene, it wasn’t the page about future memories only, since the rest shards also have past events like crying Mikasa when they was about to be eaten by Dina (c50) and Bertolt when he was seen by Dina (c96). Thus, the EH shard(s) should be counted as a memory as well.

Lastly, the shard “come home” of Mikasa just has the same value as Sieg shard, where Eren already knew the result of the events (attacking Liberio & getting headshot) were all according to his plan (Mikasa would save him & his brother could catch his head). I don't find it meaningful but on the contrary, the absence of shard about 19yo!Mikasa's feelings in c112 or c123 makes me feel like he doesn’t care about those events. But yeah, EMfags only care about the shard size after all so they can’t see the problem here.   

#hs replies #snk 130 #Anonymous

[erehis]

Do you think were are gonna have a traitor in the cringevengers? Seen too late but still, Annie is the most likely choice.

Cringevengers’ goal is to stop Eren, even if they’ll have to kill him. In my opinion, Jean (who once defended Eren’s massacre) or Mikasa (who couldn’t answer if she’ll be able to kill Eren) are the candidates for this traitor role. 

Annie only wants to go home and to meet her father, she was ready to kill Eren because she doesn’t want her father to die and her homeland to be destroyed, however when she learned that there’s no way to save Liberio anymore, she’s lost her will immediately. Unless Isayama wants to explore Female Titan’s roar ability, I don’t see Annie will play any major role in future plot.

#Anonymous #hs replies

[erehis]

What do you think about floch?

What a coincidence, I also wrote my thought about him not long ago. 

I don't feel something like “I like this character!” because somehow Flock doesn’t have a connection to various characters that I can see his other faces. I mean, I can’t tell if he is a character because he’s more like an outsider of this story who points out reader’s thought and says what Isayama wants to say. *insert based Flock meme*. But I have to admit Flock is really cool, I guess I like him as an interesting character without having any sentiment attached to him.

In term of skills, he knows how to survive, such as nesting on his horse to avoid being hit by rocks, cling to walls low enough to get rid of bullets, fly through the windows when strong opponent like Mikasa appeared, etc. People can say he’s a coward only knows how to run and hide, but imo keeping yourself survive is as important as fighting, Flock is not an elite fighter because he never experienced various fights with titans like 104th. Btw the scene where Kiyomi restrained Flock makes me kinda irritated, Flock is a soldier and Kiyomi is a hag, also she wasn’t introduced as someone who’s skilled at martial art or something like that, I feel as if Isayama over handled this scene to make Kiyomi look like a heroine and Flock a useless villain.    

In terms of loyalty and discipline, I don’t think there’s anyone who can overcome Flock. He kept the secret that Eren was pretending to go along with Yelena and Sieg’s Euthanasia plan for 10 months long; being imprisoned he still managed to get connection to do the bomb plan. Back to the Shiganshina battle 4 years ago, Flock carried Erwin on his back a long way with hope to save commander / the devil who can fight against enemies. In reality, every national military needs people like Flock, who always prioritize the sake of his country, always follows military discipline and knows how to survive in battles.   

Flock is aware that he’s a coward, and he doesn’t deny it. He’s realistic though, people in SnK (war) always throw their lives easily, or they think that they can give up on living, but Flock wants to live, not a life in hell, he wants to live a better life the future and he’s moving forward in order to achieve it.   

Flock's patriotism/nationalism is extreme to the point he looks like a dictator, but he did all of it for his country after all. As readers, we disagree with him to an extent, but as someone who live on island, Flock did nothing wrong to his people and his comrades, unlike cringevengers.

#hs replies #Anonymous