the thing is, dumbledore and snape are just as much set at opposite moral standards as, say, harry and voldemort. harry and voldemort are set up to ponder the question of love vs power - their thematic arc is built around that central moral tension.
snape and dumbeldore are set up in a similar way, but their moral tension is about sacrifice vs selfishness. and itās done in a really interesting way, because while we do get a clear answer on where we should fall on the love vs power struggle (obvs the books steer us to love instead of power, as harry, personification of love, defeats voldemort, personification of power), i donāt think itās as clear-cut with dumbledore and snape.Ā
dumbledore is a personification of sacrifice. he is theĀ āall for the greater goodā character who thinks big picture, moves people around like chess pieces, and is always focused on saving as many people as he can without focusing on his personal feelings for them. he IS the guy who would sacrifice one life to save many lives - we see that with harry. itās clearly built out of his selfish (and i sayĀ āselfishā but perhaps i should say self-interested instead - this is about focusing on your personal needs without the negative connotations built intoĀ āselfishā) choices when he was a teenager, where he focused on his own personal relationships over theĀ āgreater goodā and lost his sister and his relationship with his brother for it. so dumbledoreās policy is always the many over the few and his morality is skewed toward that.
snape is the personification ofĀ āselfishness.ā we are constantly told to see him as self-interested and self-involved - he is the one who wants to be recognized for catching sirius, who watches the catch sirius forĀ āselfishā reasons, who has a personal grudge against harry, who is from theĀ āselfishā slytherin house and leads it. he is the one who is supposed to put the few above the many - namely, himself. and then, as we see in book seven, lily. snapeās morality is skewed toward the people he loves over the many.Ā
and knowing that really brings into perspective the way they react to events in book seven. of course dumbledore, who sacrificed his lover for theĀ āgreater goodā would recoil at snapeās desperation to save the one person he loves over everyone else. of course snape, who puts the people he loves first, would recoil at dumbledoreās decision to sacrifice harry for the greater good. the scenes where we see those reactions parallel so neatly itās impossible not to see how much they are supposed to be thematic and moral opposites.Ā
but the thing is, weāre never really encouraged to see aĀ āsideā like we do for harry vs voldemort. dumbledoreās disgust is read by the audience asĀ āvalidā - but so is snapeās. we are supposed to recoil with outage at snape supposedly putting lily before harry and james, but we are also supposed to recoil with outrage at dumbledore sacrificing harry for the world. dumbledore is notĀ ārightā and snape is notĀ āwrongā - theyāre both necessary.Ā
obviously i just want to write a term paper about this, but i honestly just find them fascinating to compare.
283 notes
Ā·
View notes
LOOK AT HER
256 notes
Ā·
View notes
According to Music Week, Faith In The Future has sold 35,239 units (14,944 CDs, 9,577 vinyl albums, 1,501 cassettes, 6,790 digital downloads and 2,427 sales-equivalent streams) in the UK, doubling the impact of Louisā first album, Walls.Ā
143 notes
Ā·
View notes
Louis Tomlinson is our November Artist of the Month so Tumblr and @lthqofficial are bringing you a custom theme to celebrate the release ofĀ Louis' new album,Ā Faith In The Future, out now.
As always, it's super easy to use. Just log into desktop web, head on overĀ hereĀ to our Themes page, hit āInstall,ā and check out 'The Greatest' theme yet.
2K notes
Ā·
View notes
INFORMATION I WAS NOT PREPARED TO LEARN. MAYBE WE *ARE* ALONE. BECAUSE WE ARE SO *EARLY*. IF THERE IS EVER GALACTIC CIVILIZATION THEY WILL NOT REMEMBER US AT ALL. BECAUSE WE ARE NOTHING. CELLS, JUST BEGINNING TO FORM LIFE. SORRY FOR SCREAMING. BUT ARE YOU LISTENING. ARE YOU THINKING ABOUT IT.
76K notes
Ā·
View notes
Louis backstage in Buenos Aires, Argentina - 22/5
255 notes
Ā·
View notes
childhood emotion of wanting a dragon that is your friend so bad that it feels like there is a vacuum in your soul that only a dragon who is your friend can fill
87K notes
Ā·
View notes
seeing people worshipping pdf like do you even know epub.. youāre in platoās cave and Iām begging you to see the light
5K notes
Ā·
View notes
27K notes
Ā·
View notes
What's your take on FL and Walls? Do you love the music? Which songs are your favourite? How do you think lt2 and hs3 will sound? What do you think about Harry's public relationships? I'm curious because you usually don't answer in posts ā¤
Soā¦.one of my long-standing pet peeves with any pop music is when the song takes two minutes to fade out and the entire time itās simply the singer repeating one or two lines over and over. So I actually havenāt listened to the entirety of FL because Iām pretty sure I wonāt like its repetitiveness. Watermelon Sugar was an ear worm and I viscerally disliked the video a lot. If hs3 is more of the same, it wonāt be for me. This makes me kinda sad because I really loved Harry a lot as part of 1D, and I wish I could appreciate him in his grown-up incarnation. I probably have thousands of gifs of him. What about Harryās public relationshipsāI think they look awkward but who am I to say. I noticed that when he and Olivia walked one way up the street in those recent pics, they were close together. The other one, far apart. Easy cropping for those who donāt wish to see her!
I love love love Walls, on the other hand. I appreciate the lyricism, the stories, the melodies, the meaning and emotion, the productionāI canāt wait to hear what Louis has had percolating during pandemic. I appreciate his smarts, his savvy, his persistence as an artist despite not having the uber-capitalist music industry fueling his career. I think heās gifted in many areas. The potential for his own creative and artistic satisfaction is huge for him, and I hope it includes a long and healthy stage career because DAMMIT I AM READY TO SEE HIM LIVE. I would love if he did another Live; I think itās great that heās throwing a festival. I would buy probably multiple copies of any CD or record he chose to put out.
Speaking as a writer and artist myself, appreciation and acknowledgment from a wider audience is lovely and feels so good to the creative souls. When Iām able to place my satisfaction in digging in to the work and getting into the state of flow, as a perfectionist Iām much happier and less anxious. It also feels really great to do creative work! Some of the best, most rewarding work! I hope Louis is generally doing well and canāt wait to see him next year (hopefully as the pandemic allows).
12 notes
Ā·
View notes
My heart ššš§”š§”
Guys GUYSS
Have you heard about Z Library because let me tell youuuuuu! It's FREE first of all and has FREE books on it like these and YOU CAN DOWNLOAD 10 PER DAY WITH A FREE ACCOUNT! AND IT FUCKING WORKS AND IT HAS SO MANY FUCKING BOOKS ON IT AND ITS FREE AND LEGAL AND FREEEEEE
682 notes
Ā·
View notes
"You just keep on buildin' up your fences
But I've never been so Defenceless~"
102 notes
Ā·
View notes
Louis and Charlie in St.Louis - posted 09.02
56 notes
Ā·
View notes