#tcoaal x reader | Explore Tumblr Posts and Blogs

coff-in · 3 days

Note

imagine Andy with uncomfortably, unreasonably big and needy endowments between his legs that puts out more fluid than he takes in

imagine him feeling like he's being driven insane by his hormones, like he's having an endless supply of pure unadulterated lust being pumped into his brain from his overactive nuts every single day, just in time for his sister to start clamoring for his attention

his mom and sister can't help but assume the bulge in his pants is a raging boner when he's actually flaccid, and whenever he's actually hard he has to struggle to keep it hidden and almost always has to plaster the nearest toilet bowl a new shade of white to calm himself

imagine Ashley eventually realizing she can instantly tell when she's turned him on because of the near-instant outline forming in his pants, followed by him desperately trying to find a release that won't be anywhere near his little sister, where he can hide the sheer mess he'll make thinking about her, again and again with each refractory period seeming a little shorter than the last

imagine Nina surviving well into high school only to be rendered comatose from asphyxiation because Andy got too pent up and couldn't stop taking out his frustrations on her throat until he'd drowned her twice over (maybe Ashley arranged it all from the start, teasing and teasing him for days before telling Nina what to do)

imagine Andy in the quarantine, realizing he's all alone with Ashley, and he's only going to get more desperate to get himself off with each passing day, and Ashley's going to be around the whole time to witness it, and he might be too completely overwhelmed by lust to even consider saying no if (when) she propositions him, and she knows and he knows she knows and he knows she knows he knows

if you were stuck with them, if you were really someone he felt he had to trust, you'd notice. he couldn't keep it together forever, not with you being so obliviously close and cute and Ashley constantly using any trick she can to see when he'll get hard. he could've if it was just one of you but it's not. you notice increasingly large stores of excessively used tissues and napkins, a strange smell every time you go into the bathroom after him, how he always tries to face his lower body away to hide it, and one day he has to come clean and tell you about it, maybe even ask for some privacy and go in, then out of the bathroom with a whole fucking glass of a sticky white water, filled to the brim (exactly what it looks and smells like, he says), pumped out fresh on the spot. and he swears to you, half proud and half disgusted with himself, that he could do it again, right there and then. he'd want to know if you'd ever tell anyone else. he'd want to know what you thought.

and by that point, maybe the lust, the constant denial, the sheer fucking anger with his own body and how much everything is taunting him is so much, that if you were to say "no, that cant be real", to leave him out of disgust, to just complain about how gross it is? he'd be so furious. so you can only see him as a gross sex-obsessed pervert because his dick matters so much more to you than the rest of him? fine. fine! you're just a pest like Ashley and a thoughtless whore like his mom, you're just as flighty and heartless and worthless as Leyley said (and he feared) you were. so guess what? you're not going anywhere. you're going to give him the relief and understanding of him that he needs every single day. you're a cumdumpster now, and he's never going to let you go, because if you can't appreciate his affection or friendship now, he may as well make you appreciate his body. he's going to show you just how much he can provide to you, even if he's going to have to drown you in it.

imagine Andy being completely dominated by his own lust until he has to dominate you in turn

thank you ♡

16 notes · View notes

coff-in · 5 days

Text

cupioromantic [reader] (i'm not aromantic, please correct me if i got anything wrong or misunderstood)

it's late for me right now. 1:33pm, and i'm thinking about andrew and ashley dating someone who doesn't know how to love and can't feel the romance they wish to feel. they can do their best to copy the scenes and moments they see on TV but they just don't feel the sparks with them, or anyone. i'm thinking about the angst that could follow with; the big fight or breakup between them as they try to figure out if anything they did was real or if it was all an act. the comfort that could end it as they decide to stay together to work things out as healthily as they can. it may not be romantic in the traditional sense, but they love each other.

#creaky coffin ⚰️#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal x reader

6 notes · View notes

coff-in · 7 days

Note

hi pookie. Back at it again.

hi pook. It's my birthday today, and you're gonna give me a birthday present :3

I was wondering what birthday sex would be like with Andy dandy? Like he can't get you anything for your birthday and he just ends up fucking you and claiming its your birthday present? :3

notes from coff-in: happy birthday pookie!! my birthday is also in june, we're like twins!!! wowie zowie! anyway, tried my best to keep this as gender neutral as possible :3 happy anniversary of your escape from the womb

[gender neutral] reader-insert, NSFW

andrew would feel bad that he couldn't get you a cake or something you wanted for your birthday. however, he's sure that birthday sex would be a reasonable substitution. he'd wait for you to get home if they're working, maybe try to cook them something for lunch or dinner (i don't think he's the worse chef ever), then lead them to the bedroom. he wouldn't let [reader] undress themself. he would kiss their face then trail his hands under their shirt to lift it over their head and throw it to the ground.

"look at you," he'd coon at [reader] with those fucking sexy bedroom eyes he knows he has, "so pretty for me, aren't you?" he'd run his hands up and down their sides then pull down their pants/skirt. "go lay down on the bed for me." he wouldn't let [reader] do ANYTHING today. it's their special day today and he plans on treating them like royalty today!

he would get between their thighs and kiss them, biting them and leaving his marks on their skin. he'd laugh when [reader] covers their face, just finding them so fucking cute! "hehehe, no no no. don't hide from me, baby, let me see that cute face of yours." he'd make them keep their eyes on him as he eats them out/sucks them off, obscenely slurping and licking them like a fucking freak. he'd moan around them and tongue them and just :3 heehee i can't get it out properly im sorry :3 :3

grrrr.... he'd tease his thick cock against [reader]'s wet and slick hole because he's still an asshole. "yeah, you want it baby, yeah? you want it inside? you want me? you do, don't you? it's ok, i'll give it to you. i'll give all to you, don't worry baby." he fucks [reader] gently at first, slow and deep thrusts. then he goes harder and harder, panting over [reader] as the room is filled with moans and harsh plap plap plaps. he kisses them as he cums inside, filling them up with his hot seed. a birthday creampie :3

they're both hot and sweaty as andrew cuddles up to them, wrapping an arm around [reader]'s body and kissing them on the forehead. "happy birthday, [reader]." ofc if the birthday baby is up for it, he can go for another round or two ;)

(he'd make you lay on your chest and bend your hips so he could spread your asscheeks and take a bite out of that birthday cake)

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #andrew graves #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #andrew graves x reader #IDK WHO YOU ARE 'NONNIE BUT HAPPY BIRTHDAY #i hope you have many more #(i hope this isnt too late and i missed it)

38 notes · View notes

coff-in · 12 days

Note

hii, I had made a request earlier but idk if you had got it, so I'm writing again just to be safe.

earlier I had a thought about how would Andrew be with a overly affectionate younger brother(reader)...? Like Andy and said younger brother would be cuddling on the couch watching some shitty movie Ashley had put on and she keeps glancing over to keep tabs on Andy and their her older siblings, knowing she can't do anything about it. So later that night when Andy gets his "nightmares" he crawls into his younger brothers bed while he's still awake because he can't sleep, so reader starts teasing Andy, and they take it from there 🤭

notes from coff-in: I DID GET YOUR PREVIOUS ASK AND IM KEEPING IT FOREVER!!! /positive what's better than incest? therapy and gay incest. LET ANDREW AND ASHLEY BE BI OR SOMETHING PLEASE!!! sorry. i'm losing myself rn, please enjoy what i have cooked up. this is also a ramble, i'm in a rambling mood rn

[masc] reader-insert, [reader] is younger than ashley by about one year, NSFW, incest, dry-humping

omg imagine if andrew liked boys :3 that's it send tweet. i wonder if andrew would have conflicting emotions about his feelings towards his brother since that's his brother you know? like, especially if he still has his incestuous feelings towards ashley, would he feel bad if he had them towards [reader], too? god, he is such a sis/sibcon. just some food for thought you know? (especially if he's dating julia around this time, omg. he goes on dates with julia while thinking about ashley or something and when he's at home he's getting real close and comfy with his baby brother-- poor julia)

i think an overly affectionate (especially physically) little brother would be kinda perfect for andrew. he definitely shows his love threw physical touch whether it's playing with his hair or holding his hand or pulling him close. there's also that added layer to their dynamic that they're both boys/guys, there's nothing wrong with them being shirtless or naked in the same room with each other and such. andrew could brush off their closeness as just them being brothers, this is normal for them cause they're brothers, nothing weird about this at all.

ashley being jelly of her baby bro is so silly to me omg. she presses herself to andrew's other side while they all watch a movie together but she still glances at andrew's arm draped around [reader], playing with his hair, or how [reader]'s probably laying his head on andrew's lap. ashley's not mad (maybe a little concerned because if andrew is exclusively attracted to guys that could be an avenue of control she loses access to) but she's letting it be known that she wants attention too.

later that night, [reader]'s in bed probably just staring at the ceiling or listening to the clock tick by to try to go to sleep. he looks over and sees andrew standing above them and he automatically lifts up his blanket to welcome him under. andrew encompasses [reader] in his arms and holds himself close to him while [reader] teases him, "do you need your little brother to help you sleep? poor andrew, it's okay. i'm here for you." and then, AND THEN AND THEN AND THEN

[reader] places a little kiss on his cheek. "there, there. all better, see?"

andrew is just like "wh-what the fuck? you can't just--" "why not? it's just a little kiss on the cheek. moms and dads give kisses on the cheek in movies." AAAUGH!!! love them love them love them. the cuddling turns into like a light makeout session, with [reader] and andrew kissing each other anywhere BUT the lips. just light pecks here and there, you know like brothers do.

time passes of them doing this and it evolves into rubbing against each other. at some point whenever andrew lets go and just fucking admits that he's a little incestuous freak (non-derogatory) he just starts humping [reader]. first while they're laying next to each other spooning but one point he gets on top of him and starts humping him like a dog, "ah- ugh- good boy... fuck..." "doesn't this feel better, andrew?" "yeah... it feels- uhg-- much much better now."

im absolute shit with dialogue but please see my vision, i beg of you. also thank you for bringing this to me. this was honestly so delicious

(no joke while writing this i was listening to an audio from reddit about a femboy little brother being used as a substitute for his big brother's girlfriend and OH MY GOODNESS)

embrace and indulge

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #andrew graves #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #andrew graves x reader #i just pop off when writing incest idk why

17 notes · View notes

coff-in · 12 days

Note

Hmmm how about Ashley growing up with a childhood friend reader can be male or female your choice. Who after noticing that Ashley doesn't get to celebrate her birthday decides to start throwing ones for her. The first one they throw for her being a surprise party.

notes from coff-in: this is pretty short but it was really cute to answer!

[masc] reader-insert

this is very cute! i think andy might be jealous of [reader] when this happens but he's also happy that leyley's happy, you know? the first party could take place at school, maybe? i've never had birthday parties myself so i don't really know how they would work all too much. maybe [reader] over hears leyley asking nina and julia to come over for her birthday and when they decline her, [reader] is like "woah, i should throw her a party :D"

he'd ask andy when her birthday is and what her favorite flavor of cake is and what she would like as a gift. andy is happy that leyley has someone who seems to be actually interested in her as a friend. idk if mr and mrs graves let friends over, but [reader] would definitely sneak in to throw a surprise birthday party for leyley!! she would be like "woah! what the fuck!! this is for me?"

GODS SHE'D BE SO CUTE!!! smiling and laughing while eating cake (a proper cake!) and opening up a gift. this is so cute, my heart!!! she would also get on [reader]'s ass whenever her birthday comes around after this, too. she's keeping [reader] close to her for now on, that's for sure.

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #ashley graves #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #ashley graves x reader

8 notes · View notes

coff-in · 13 days

Note

thank you so much for doing my request!! if you’re comfy with a pt 2 I’d love to read it!! seeing reader cope with becoming a parent and how reader copes with getting raped by andrew … how the dynamic at home changes, andrew as a daddy and ashley as a aunt!! does andrew force reader to marry him? <3 if ur not comfy w doing it as a req then maybe ramble or do it in any other form like a hc! thank youuu 🥹🤍

notes from coff-in: it's past midnight right now where i am (as it it's closer to 1:00am) but i need to write. this is definitely a ramble but thank you for clarifying that i could do that! writing properly for ficlets and headcanons take a bit out of me but i want go give you guys the best that i got, you know? sorry, sorry... on to your ask!

[fem] reader-insert, [afab] reader-insert(?), NSFW, rape, talks/mentions of pregnancy and abortion, incest in the last bits but it's skippable really

the biggest thing that i wonder about is how [reader] met andrew and ashley. how long have they'd known each other? were they quarantined together (was [reader] quarantined at all)? i think i'll leave it up to the reader's interpretation/imagination but these things feel like they should impact the story, you know? um... [reader] doesn't really take to being a mother too well. she doesn't want to be a mother, so it makes sense. ashley wouldn't let her get rid of the child, either. she doesn't like [reader] all that much but she does try to recognize potential opportunities to keep andrew close in this... situation.

the last thing a parent wants to do is to make their child sad. if ashley could get close enough to andrew's child (she'd love the child ofc, it's an extension of her brother) then she could keep andrew close to her, too. any separation of them would also affect the child and until it's born who knows how that can go. ashley doesn't like [reader] all that much. she could come to like [reader], but when i was writing the original piece i sort of didn't write it with ashely in mind... so any relationship they build would be after the rape event.

andrew. andrew andrew andrew. he... he wants the child. it's possibly a new chance for him to have a new life. not necessarily an ordinary life (years of sexual tension between him and his sister build up somehow to him raping a women they sorta kidnap/escaped with from an apartment after demon summoning, murder, and cannibalism) but it could be considered close enough if you squint and tilt your head. again, when writing the original piece i didn't really write with andrew and [reader]'s deeper relationship in mind, just the surface level stuff

andrew has come to care for [reader] to some extent, and the child makes him try to enforce that bond and relationship. he would reflect on his own parents and their parenting and how he raised ashley when it comes to his baby. trying to figure what to avoid (i think putting in the effort would be way better than what his parents did, though. it's not even a battle). he gets touchy feely with [reader]; sleeping in the same bed, holding their hand or resting it on their hip, brushing her hair, etc etc some of the stiff we've seen with ashley. i think he'd also talk to the baby bump, too.

[reader] isn't expected to kill people anymore or to do excessive physical labor. i don't think she takes part in the cannibalism as much either. i'm kinda leaving her vague because i want you guys to really just imprint on [reader] i guess when it comes to this situation. andrew would be a fairly good dad though. uh... sort of dozed off a bit trying to think about him as a dad. he would be way more attentive that his own parents, that's for sure. he's the voice of reason along with [reader] (ashley is that "cool aunt" that the kid loves), but andrew is also still a bit of a doormat or pushover. he can't stay too mad at this kids.

do i think andrew would force [reader] to marry him? maybe. it would probably be good for taxes and other legal documents but i don't know if he'd put such a high value on marriage. i think he'd like the intertwining aspect of it, the legal binding it brings. i doubt ashely would enjoy this but it's also dependent on your relationship.

mixing this idea with incest ideas because i can't help myself right now, fell free to skip this: andrew and a sibling [reader]. especially a younger one. i don't know but i kind of enjoy the idea of him during quarantine (or right after) just... losing control one night. it's not violent or loud or out of hate; it's quiet and gentle and out of frustration. he takes his younger baby sibling while they're sleeping as a way to just let it all out. the tension and stress and repression of his feelings for them... he just lets them go. ashley's dead asleep and so is [reader], as ling as he's quiet there are no immediate consequences to this action. he raised [reader] since they were a fucking baby and what a wonderful adult they had turned out to be (as wonderful as a graves could be).

aaaaahhh, i'm tired. sorry for the weird sleepy rant response. i feel like i should mention again: i have never been raped nor do i know friends or people personally who have been raped. i haven't really read anything scholarly about it so take all i say with a grain of salt and an open mind. thank you for requesting, 'nonnie. i love it when people ask for expansions or explanations in previous posts (reminds me of devious anon, i miss them)

anyway my eye saight is losing focus so i'll end it here. good day/night/evening whatever you are

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #andrew graves #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #andrew graves x reader #oh man so eepy rn

17 notes · View notes

the-ultimate-puppteer · 14 days

Note

How would Ashley handle having an S/O who loves her, but genuinely has no idea about her more violent side?

Ashley with a boyfriend who loves her but is oblivious to her dark side

•Ahh~ how did you land such an adorable girlfriend~

•You absolutely love Ashley it was honestly love at first site for you

•You met her in high school and she seemed to be a loner

•Well it's more like people seemed to avoid her and you weren't sure why

•So you being you decided to approach her

•You couldn't help it she was just so pretty and you were weak to girls with her aesthetic

•She just straight up told you to piss off before you open your mouth

•Saying something about some person named Andrew and what not

•You weren't really paying attention and outta nervousness simply blurted out that you didn't know who this Andrew was but that wanted to go on a date with her

•Ashley was stunned into silence by that

•Makes sense given that she's never been asked out like that and by someone who seemingly didn't care about andrew

•So Ashley being Ashley decided to put you to the test and accept your request for a date

•You weren’t gonna last long is what she thought, you just wanna get close to her to get close to Andrew is what that's obviously what's happening

•There's no way that he's actually interested in me

•And an two months went by and you've been boyfriend and girlfriend since that date

•You don't seem to show any interest in her despite having met him

•Your always hanging out with her, holding her hand and giving her kisses< You even make lunch for her

•What the hell, do you really love her that much?

•It doesn't matter now, you're hers,her boyfriend, her lover, her darling

•And she not gonna let anyone take you away

•This leads to her threatening other woman around you seeing them as hussies

•They obviously wanna steal you away from her, she sees how soany girls look at you

•She's even had to take it further than threats at times from girls who were blatant about wanting to steal you

•She has you spend less time with friends and more time with her

•You didn't even seem to mind at all

•In Fact you were apparently none the wiser about any of the things she’d done

•At that point she decided it was about time she truly claim you as hers

•This lead to you having your first time with her and you very frequently ended in such situations with Ashley after that first time

•She loves you so much and she refuses to let anyone have you and will refuse to let you leave

•Why would wanna leave though, after all your so smitten with this tar souled woman

#the coffin of andy and leyley #tcoaal #ashley graves x male reader #ashley graves x reader #tcoaal x reader

49 notes · View notes

coff-in · 16 days

Note

thank u for answering my question! ^^

if that’s the case and ur still taking requests then I’d love to possibly read about andrew who noncons reader and accidentally knocks em up but forces em to keep it !!

if ur not accepting requests then do ignore this <3

notes from coff-in: i've never been raped before, nor do i know anyone personally who has been raped. this is also my first time writing noncon, so please have mercy on me and my writing. i hope this is to your liking, anon. sorry for taking so long (speaking of long, this is about 1,892 words)

[fem] reader-insert, [afab] reader-insert, NSFW, non-consensual sex (somnophilia and rape), pregnancy, talks/mentions of abortion

Andrew couldn’t sleep that night.

He didn’t have a nightmare, instead, he had a dream. A wet dream. He can still imagine the hot scene. The loud slapping of skin, the erotic moans of both you and him, the smell of sex and sweat filling his nose. He couldn’t get rid of it. He didn’t really want to get rid of it, to be honest.

You slept in the other bed in the room, right across from Andrew. He quietly got up and stalked his way towards you. You looked so peaceful in your sleep, Your face was so relaxed, and your breathing was even. Blissfully unaware of him hovering right next to you. He slowly peeled the thin blanket from you, revealing your curled-up body. His green eyes trailed down your exposed legs. The pajama shorts you wore rode up your soft thighs.

He planted a hand on your thigh. Squeeze. God, you were so soft and warm. It’s like you were teasing him, inviting him over to you. He knew that couldn’t be the case though, right? You haven’t shown real interest in him romantically or sexually. Sure you joked a bit about being a housewife once, and you tended to leave your underwear around the motel you stayed at where he could see it, but that didn’t mean anything. You were just comfortable with him.

That didn’t stop his hand from trailing higher up your thigh, or his body from crawling on top of yours. It didn’t stop him from pulling at the hem of your shorts and tugging them down. You were comfortable with him and right now, he was pretty comfortable with you. Comfortable enough with you to stare at your cute striped blue underwear. Comfortable enough to trail his finger against your clothed lips, cupping your delicate hot flower in the palm of his hand. Yeah, he was getting real comfortable with you.

His eyes flicked to your face as he pressed his nose to your cunt. He took a deep inhale and let out a small groan of arousal. You smelled so sweet. Like a blooming flower displayed in a garden. Like you were teasing him, inviting him to you. Your eyelashes were long, he noticed. He noticed your cheeks and your plush lips. His own moved up your body, traveling from your clothed petals to your hips, then your stomach and waist. His hand traveled with him, pulling up your shirt to reveal your skin and chest. Your breasts greeted him, nipples perked and hard to say hello. His mouth came up to greet them back. Like a new babe, he sucked and licked at your nipples, quietly moaning in pleasure while doing so. Green eyes kept rapt attention on your face, watching for every faint change in your expression. The furrowing of your brow, the faint blush painting your cheeks, the slight parting of your lips to pant for breath.

You were so comfortable with him, teasing and inviting him in. It would be rude to not enter, no?

His fingers dipped past the band of your underwear and slipped in between your wet folds. They were slick and warm. Inviting. He pulled back from your plush breasts– not before planting a farewell kiss on each one– and pulled down your panties. He paused at the sight of your pussy, the beautiful centerpiece of your garden. His fingers rubbed your clit, teasing the throbbing button. His eyes snapped to your face as you let out a particularly loud moan. You’re so comfortable with him, you love this, don’t you? His fingers dipped inside you and slowly thrust in and out. He watches your lips part to let out sleepy pants and moans. You were getting wetter around him…

Swiftly and as quietly as possible to not wake you, he undid the button on his jeans and unzipped his fly. His cock was straining against the cloth of his boxers, aching to feel the warm grip of your cunt around it. It was aching to be invited in. He pulled down his jeans and boxers, dropping them onto the motel floor. Lifting your legs to wrap around his hips, he guided his leaking member inside of you. His head was covered in your slick and warm, and he had to cover her mouth with his palm to muffle his moan. You were so warm. You were so comfortable around him, hugging his cock perfectly. Once he was bottomed out, his full balls touching the curve of your ass, he just sat there for a moment.

“... Fuck…” He whispered.

He started to thrust in and out, each movement sending a wave of pleasure through his body. Each thrust sent him closer and closer inside your inviting warmth. He could feel you squeeze around him. You wanted this, didn’t you? You wanted him. Maybe you weren’t comfortable enough to tell him? You didn’t want to break the comfortable warmth you’ve made with him over the course of time you’ve known him. That’s alright, it’s okay– he’ll do it for you.

“You’re so warm… fuck!” He can’t help it. You’re too inviting. He leaned down and kisses your neck. He’s so enthralled in his pleasure, the feeling blurring his mind like cigarette smoke, he forgets that there are consequences to avoid.

You wake up.

“A… Andrew? Mghn!” His previously closed eyes snap open. Fuck. Fuck, fuck, fuck!

“F-fuck!” He’s already inside. A hand shot up to cover your mouth, your eyes looking at him frantically. “Y-you’re alright! You’re j-just… I couldn’t sleep and your bed looked so inviting.” You let me in.

His thrusting got faster and harder. He didn’t like the scared look in your eyes. He didn’t want to scare you, of course not, you’re friends. However, he couldn’t admit that he wasn’t getting off to the thrill of it. Getting caught by you doing something awful felt oddly good. Or maybe it just didn’t feel bad. His head was too foggy to think or to care, it all just felt good. So selfishly good.

“Don’t fight it. Just let it happen.” He told you. God, he was getting so close. He ravaged through your home, making himself comfortable inside your walls, picking the petals off of your flower. “Fuck! You’re so good… y-you’re so… good!” He was going to come at this rate, his dick throbbing inside of you.

You seemed to notice this too as your whimpering and moaning turned into crying and sobbing. You tried to shake your way out of his grip, your hands reached out to claw at his dark sweater to pull him off of you. He growled at your aggression and his hands wrapped themselves around your throat. Squeeze.

“Take it.” Squeeze. “T-take it…!”

His body shook as he finally came, planting his seed into your fertile garden. Sweat trickled down his face has his hips continued to slap against yours. Take it, take it, take it. His grip around your neck loosened as his pace slowed down. He could barely hear your deep inhale over the buzz in his brain and the over-stimulation of his penis as your cunt gripped him rightly. He panted and groaned as he pulled himself out. Cum trailed after his cock head and pooled out onto the bedsheets below your bodies. He watched it for a bit then looked up at your face.

Hiccups escaped your lips as tears fell from your puffy eyes and stained your flushed cheeks. Strands of hair were stuck to your sweaty forehead. You looked so beautiful to him. Even when you were ruined you were still so beautiful.

“You did so good, darling. Such a good girl.” He smiled and brushed the tears from your cheeks. “Here, let me help you cum.”

— — —

You stare at the pregnancy test a month later. Well, you try to stare at it at least, but every glance you gave it caused bile to climb up your throat. The two lines taunt you. Lying your head on the seat of the motel’s shitty (as in quality, not cleanliness, but at this point you can’t bring yourself to care) toilet seat, you sat on the tiled floor.

You’re pregnant.

God, even thinking about it made you feel sick. This entire situation was fucking sick and you were fucking sick of it all!

You tried your best to ignore what happened, you really did. The morning after that night, you found yourself entangled in Andrew’s arms, his chin resting on the top of your head. You couldn’t bring yourself to talk about it. A part of you just wanted to believe that it wasn’t real, that it didn’t happen, that it was just a bad dream, or a horrible vision of the future– not the present.

But now you’re here. Sitting on the bathroom floor, trying to think about how you’re going to break the news to Andrew that you’re pregnant with his child without vomiting. What would he even say? Did he plan for you to get pregnant? How the fuck were you going to get red of it without having to go to the hospital?

It’s dizzying how screwed you are.

You don’t notice the footsteps outside the door over you’re overwhelming thoughts, but you do turn to look at the door as it opens. It’s Andrew. He looks down at you on the floor, his expression concerned. “[reader]? What happened? Are you okay?”

You look away from him, “I’m fine.”

Your answer doesn’t seem to please him as his eyes look around the bathroom. They land on the pregnancy test, the positive pregnancy test. He grabs it and takes a closer look at it. “You’re pregnant…?” You cringe at his voice, the confusion and disbelief seeping in his voice.

“Yeah, yeah… I just found out…” You look back up at him, your eyes meeting his, “I’ll try… I’ll find a way to get rid–”

“No.”

“Huh?” Huh?

“I want you to keep it. This could be good for us. It’ll finally give us a chance to settle down and stop running.” Andrew smiles gently and bends down next to you, his green eyes peering at you adoringly. “We have nothing holding us back here. We can just leave this city and have a new life together elsewhere. Some place where they don’t know us.”

You can’t help the broken, nervous grin that climbs its way onto your face, “Andrew, you can’t be fucking serious. Even if we weren’t on the run from the cops– which we are, by the way because you constantly remind me– I don’t even want this child. Cannibalism and demon summoning aside, I’m not… I don’t want to be a mom.”

As you talk, Andrew leans forward to cup your face in his hands. He smiles warmly at you, “That’s why I’ll be there to help you. You won’t have to deal with all the struggles by yourself. We’d be working together to raise, as a team.”

“I don’t want this child…”

“And who's going to help you get rid of it?” Andrew’s hands gripped your cheeks as he glared at you, “You’re a wanted murderer with no money. No hospital or drug deal is going to take pity on you to help you, [reader]. You’re fucking stuck with us whether you like it or not…”

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #andrew graves #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #andrew graves x reader #kinda a struggle writing this ngl

46 notes · View notes

coff-in · 18 days

Note

heyhey!! (*￣∇￣)ノ 🕊 anon is back ^^

if reqs are still open, how do you feel about a platonic leyley + child reader request? (*´・∀・｀*)

feel free to consider it some extension of my previous request! some cute, sugar-inducing child interactions would be great!! (ゝω・´★)

notes from coff-in: AAAH welcome back 🕊 anon! i hope your day/evening/night is going well :3 thank you so much for requesting again!! i hope you like this, i'm actually writing this late at night lol

[fem] reader-insert

"leyley, that's not how you draw a cat."

"shut up!! it's my drawing and my cat can look like however i want it to look like!" leyley yelled as she gripped a black crayon in her small hand. on the paper before here was a crudely drawn cat that was laying on a crudely drawn leyley.

[reader] looked at her. "i didn't know that you had a cat."

"i don't," leyley looked up at [reader], "but when i grow up i may get one! i'd call it mayhem and it would sleep on our bed at night."

"our bed?" [reader] asked. leyley nodded her head and continued to scribble on the paper. "are we going to live together? what about andrew?"

"he would live with us, too!"

[reader] looked up at the clock and the words that were on the tip of her tongue feel down her throat. "aw crap!" she exclaimed and got up from her seat. leyley looked up at her exclamation. "i have a student council meeting today! i totally forgot!" she quickly grabbed her book bag and slung it over her shoulders, "sorry, leyley, i have to go."

"wait! what the hell?! you're just going to leave me like that?" leyley yelled at [reader], her eyebrows furrowed in anger and her pink eyes pierced through [reader]'s heart. regret shot through her, almost making her jump. "i thought we were supposed to hang out together until andy came to pick me up today? you promised!"

fuck. she did promise leyley, didn't she? she didn't want to break her promise, that's the last thing she'd ever want to do. fuck, fuck, fuck! [reader] looked at the ground for a quick moment to think of some sort of solution until it came to her. "you can come with me!"

"UUUGH! but that sounds so fucking boring!" leyley groaned, leaning back on the school seat she was in. "why can't you just skip the meeting today?"

"i can't just--"

"please??? it'll just be one time, [reader]! what do they need you for anyway? it's not like you do much there anyway."

[reader] frowned at leyley's harsh words. they weren't exactly lies-- she mostly just recorded what was said at the meetings to help keep accountability-- but it hurt her all the same.

"stay with me, [reader]. please?" leyley looked at [reader] with her big pink eyes. [reader] scrunched her face up, trying to steel herself against leyley's adorable pouty face before sighing. her shoulders fell down and she slowly started to remove her book bag.

"fine... just until andy comes to pick you up."

leyley giggled and got up from her seat to embrace [reader] in a tight hug. "thank you! thank you, thank you, thank you, [reader]!! you're the absolute best!" [reader] smiled and hugged leyley back. it was just one meeting... it wouldn't be such a big deal, right?

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #ashley graves #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #ashley graves x reader #i hope this was cute enough for you #🕊 anon visits the coffin

12 notes · View notes

coff-in · 21 days

Note

heyhey!! may i req ashley with a fem reader? i may ramble here so please bear with me (reader and ashley are the same age)

reader and ashley were basically childhood friends, reader being the only person to actually give ashley a chance to actually be her friend rather than befriend her to try to get to andrew (which ashley was very wary of reader right from the get-go)

reader is basically known for being perfect and even "pure" by her peers back in highschool (and being a part of student council is no help) mostly due to her mother forcing her to excel and reader never really having much of an identity because of it

so it would be pretty scandalous for rumors of reader and ashley dating to go out, right? well, ashley fuels those rumors meanwhile reader tries to shut them down because reader isn't even out when it comes to liking girls

reader's mother is pretty disapproving of reader's and ashley's friend/relationship but the two usually sneak around to hang out anyways, mostly ashley

in the current game setting, reader is quarantined with the graves siblings since at that point, her mother stopped caring and viewed her daughter as a lost cause and is practically an accomplice in everything that happened

of course, with the quarantine, ashley and reader have gotten closer than ever before to the point that reader is questioning herself and her attraction to ashley

the relationship will be relatively toxic especially with reader likely being more of a doormat than andrew (somehow) and ashley's nature in isolating reader from friends and even her peers in general

notes from coff-in: this is actually such a cool idea, 'nonnie! i don't know to like, add on to this because it's just... it's so fucking good. you really cooked here :D still i tried my best, please enjoy!

[fem] reader-insert, homophobia(?)

holy shit, i think leyley would actually be so happy if [reader] actually came over to celebrate her birthday. even if [reader] wasn't able to bring her a gift, just her showing up to say "happy birthday, leyley!" would cause leyley to break out into a huge adorable smile!! the fact that [reader] actually takes the time and makes the effort to be there for leyley would make her like [reader]. [reader] is there for her, she likes to be friends with her. even having her sneak out of the house to hang out with ashley is so heart touching to her and enforces the idea that [reader] likes her. it also builds up that attachment to [reader] in ashley character.

i'm not too entirely sure how people in the neighborhood the graves' lived at react to gay people but... i'm sure it would be some sort of struggle being "outed" as gay when you yourself aren't even sure if you're gay or not. [reader] would definitely panic when ashley teases her about the rumors. "didn't you hear about them? everyone's talking about us~ about our relationship~"

"what?! what no! ashley, they can't-- they're lying!! we're not dating-- i don't even--"

"you don't what, [reader]? you don't like me? aren't we friends?? you're MY friend!!" omg the back and fourth the two go through of ashley pushing the boundaries of their relationship and [reader] calming her down after she (purposely) misconstrues her words turning ashley down. and it's so hard trying to dispel the rumors because yeah, they always hang out with each other (because ashley gets mad when [reader] tries to hang out with other people) and yeah, [reader] doesn't have many other friends outside of ashley (because ashley doesn't like to share :3c) AND NO, SHE'S NOT JUST FRIENDS WITH ASHLEY TO GET TO ANDREW!!

and GOD ONCE [READER]'S MOTHER FINDS OUT???? ashley knows all about shitty mothers, this is just another factor that she could use to keep [reader] close. it's an aspect that they can bond over!! they're both disappointing daughters to their mothers... kinda romantic, isn't it? it's like the only other that can relate is right next to them huh? (ashley's giving her smug bedroom eyes to [reader] while [reader] is like "haha... ha yeah, so true ashley canwetalkabout somethingelse?") THIS CONFLATES OR LIKE COMBINES WHEN THE QUARANTINE HAPPENS LIKE "WOWIE YOUR MOM DOESN'T WANT SHIT TO DO WITH YOU EITHER!!! we should kiss rn"

biggest question i have is whether or not andrew would like it or not? he's used to being ashley's rock, her anchor, the only one who loves her. and now [reader] comes along and... well, not steals her but makes her less reliant on andrew. ashley's always going to andy so it's not like andrew's leaving her (not like he wants to do so either) but there must be some tension or competition between him and [reader]. especially since [reader]'s taking his spot as "doormat extraordinaire" like bro!!! what the fuck!!! honestly such a fun idea to explore.

[reader] has nothing left but ashley. ashley drove away her friends in middle/high school, her mother abandoned her due to rumors of her dating ashley, and now she's stuck with ashley (and andrew) for three months. no one is calling the phone to talk to her, no one is trying to break her out, and no one is missing her. it's only [reader] and ashley (and andrew)

fucking love this idea, come here. let me kiss that wonderful brain of yours 'nonnie. MWAH MWAH MWAH!!!

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #ashley graves #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #ashley graves x reader #sorry for the late response btw #got the wifi back

20 notes · View notes

coff-in · 30 days

Note

aaAAAA I've been lurking and um um um I have brainrot from two of the previous asks >_> What if what if

Younger Sister Reader from the I love you more than I should post x Yandere Andrew post Decay route?? And they have the same toxic thing going on from that one post where Andy threatens to off himself if the reader moves an inch from his side. Like all I can think of is Andy having a shit ton of romantic feelings for reader that the reader is just coming into realization about while also reeling from the fact that, yk, Ash is dead? Andy telling his baby sister that he doesn't want to live if he can't have her (romantically, carnally, etc.) I just really want a jealousy scene where reader like...looks at another man and Andy is like "So. You want me to die?" and then reader has to comfort her older brother in a variety of ways that are decidedly not very sibling-like. Andy basically going "date me or I die" and reader is just. panicking.

notes from coff-in: i had trouble writing a ficlet or headcanons for this for some reason so it's just me fucking word vomiting my thoughts directly. also also also, thank you!!! i would've never thought people come to lurk on my blog, GUH IT'S SUCH AN HONOR!!! ur going to make my heart explode

[fem] reader-insert, [reader] is 1 year younger than ashley, incest, NSFW

i think it would mostly play out the same as yandere andrew with the older sibling but with more incestuous overtones. all i can think about is andrew and baby sister [reader] going out shopping or something. baby sis [reader] asks one of the employees where she could find some seasonings or something and the employee points to the aisle and leaves, then andrew comes up behind [reader] saying “did you really need to talk to him? hm? maybe you just wanted to ogle at him up close, huh? is your big brother not handsome enough for you anymore?” [reader]’s like “no no no!! I just needed to find the chili pepper, im sorry :(” and andrew makes her kiss him with tongue in the aisle to calm him down.

they’d have to get a job together, this is non-negotiable to andrew. preferably the same position so they’re close to each other but i think he’d settle on being in the same workplace in general if reasoned with enough. baby sis [reader] hides back into her shell again like she did when nina died but she doesn’t come back out this time. faced with the loss of her big sister ashley and the possible suicide andrew threatens her with, [reader] just deems it safer for her to be as introverted as possible. she’s still has some independence and autonomy but it’s only around andrew if that makes sense. she’ll cook and clean and entertain herself at home with or without andrew but in public she’s very introverted and clingy with andrew. andrew isn’t complaining about any of this though.

andrew’s very happy that he gets his baby sister to himself now! with all the fucked up shit they’ve done together he’s not too conserned with introducing themselves as a couple even if people put two-and-two together that they’re blood related. i can see him being very physically close and intimate with his baby sis [reader]. a hand on her lower back, hand holding, a finger curled in her hair, sleeping in the same bed, and like… a lot of sex. [reader] loves her brother and he’s been respectful when it came to sex. it took her a while to properly figure out how to feel about andrew’s romantic attraction towards her but she does feel the same way too (whether it was natural or something that was fostered while on the run). he likes to leave hickeys on her neck and other obvious places so people know who she belongs to.

every morning they wake up together in the same bed and say “I love you” to each other and they do it again every night before they go to bed.

i also think about semi-public sex with them, too. andrew gets jealous somehow and drags [reader] into an alleyway and forces her on to her knees and flops his cock on her face. “how about you show your big brother how sorry you are, huh?” she tries her best to take him into her mouth but she’s just really bad at it because she’s never done this before. andrew doesn’t mind, though, and praises her for her effort and eagerness because he can’t be mad at his baby sister for that long :) he cums into her mouth and her cheeks get filled up too quickly and some of his semen spills out of her mouth as she tries to swallow it all and andrew’s like “aww, what a good baby sister you are :) it’s ok if can’t swallow it all. i’ll have more for you later.”

i love this idea, thank you ‘nonnie.

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #andrew graves #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #andrew graves x reader

47 notes · View notes

coff-in · 1 month

Note

ok Ok wait I'm here for angst consider!! Yan! Andrew and Older Sister Reader post Decay route, where reader walks in an Andrew right after he kills Ashley and talks him down or straight up restrains him from killing her/himself, promising to give him something to live for. She can't save Ashley, but she can save her remaining—however fucked up he may be—sibling right? However, all this means is that Andrew becomes even more yan than he already was and basically guilt-trips the reader and traps her with him. Regardless of where they go, regardless of who they meet, he can't stand being a step away from her. And if she doesn't listen, then all he has to do is pull out the knife again and put it to his own neck.

notes from coff-in: Teehee. I'm sorry if this isn't as angsty as you expected it to be. I don't usually read angsty stuff and this is my first time writing something like this. I saw this ask and just knew that I had to answer it as soon as possible, hehe. Thank you for requesting and I hope you enjoy it!

[fem] reader-insert, [reader] is older than andrew by about 2 years, this is a follow up to my previous "older sister reader" headcanons

I'll keep you in my arms and never let go.

(GOD THIS IDEA IS SO TOXIC, I LOVE IT!!!)

Big sis [reader] straight up runs up to Andrew, catching him off guard and gripping the hand holding the cleaver, BEGGING him not to kill himself.

“Stop it, stop it, stop it! Stop it! You can stay with me, you can have me, please! Don’t do it, Andrew, don’t do it! You can have me… don’t leave me… please…” [reader]’s fucking crying as she retrains his arm and hand, trying to pull the cleaver out of his hands. (I’m sorry for the poor writing, I saw this ask and all my neurons started rapid-firing ideas all at once).

She’s devastated about Ashley’s death– she was her younger sister after all– but she also tries to distance herself from what happened for the sake of Andrew. She can’t linger on the past when Andrew is right there asking for her help.

(I just realized that the Decay vision takes place in a future we don’t know much about yet, so I’m going to make some stuff up!)

When Ashley died in the demon/dream world her body in real life was left as a soulless husk of some sort. [reader] offered to just kill Ashley’s body and bury her somewhere discreet but Andrew said that he wanted to eat her. A weird final farewell but she’d do it for her little brother.

During dinner, Andrew asked [reader] a question that binded her to him forever: “You promise to never leave me, right?”

The answer fell out of her mouth so naturally that she didn’t even consider the consequences that could follow: “I promise to never leave you, Andrew.”

[reader] and Andrew leave the town they were living in to start anew somewhere else, to putting everything that had happened behind them. Andrew’s never been the youngest sibling before. [reader] dotes and babies him a lot not only since he’s her little brother but her only sibling now. She makes sure that he’s always comfortable wherever they go and gets a job to support the household.

Andrew doesn’t like the idea of his big sis getting a job. She would be talking to other people for most of the day… She wouldn’t be there for him! At first he stalks her workplace, then he tries to get a job working in the same office with [reader] so that they can be close. When that doesn’t work, Andrew waits for his big sis to return to their new home that night. A sharp kitchen knife sits comfortably in his tight grip.

{reader]’s boss had kept her at the office later than what she expected to make up overtime. He’s not waiting on taking advantage on his new employee, it seemed. She sighed as she walked up to the new motel Andrew and her were staying at. As she dugged through her coat pockets for her keys she noticed that one of the lights were on inside.

‘He must’ve had another nightmare again,’ [reader] thought to herself as her hand finally found the motel room keys. He had been racked with awful nightmares ever since Ashley died. Every night he would come to [reader]’s bed and asked if he could sleep with her. He said that it helped him sleep. At some point they stopped trying to sleep in separate beds and now they just shared one.

She entered the motel room and saw Andrew leaning against the kitchen counter. Neither of them made a sound as [reader] closed the door behind her. “I’m home. Sorry I came back late,” [reader] said as she proceeded to take off her coat, “My boss kept me back later than I expected.” Andrew never took his eyes off of his older sister. His silence was scaring her. “Did you get a nightmare?”

“Couldn’t sleep without you…” Andrew answered her silently. “I needed you… and you weren’t there.” His grip tightened on the knife in his hand and [reader] finally noticed it, its glint reflecting the motel room’s light. She stared to realize that this conversation was heading into a very dangerous direction.

“I’m sorry,” [reader] started as she took a slow step closer to Andrew, approaching him like he was a scared animal, “I’m sorry that I came home late, Andrew. I didn’t mean to… not be here with you.” In a flash, Andrew brings the knife’s sharp edge to his neck, the two surfaces a hair’s breath away from kissing and spilling blood.

“Then don’t go! Don’t leave me again!” Andrew yelled at [reader] as she stood in shock. “You promised that you’d never leave and you did! Don’t you love me, sis? Don't I mean anything to you?” [reader] quickly closed the gap between her and her brother and grabbed his hands just like she did when… when she saw…

“Of course I love you, Andrew! I’m sorry!”

'I’m so tired of your sorry’s. They don’t mean shit!'

[reader] wrapped her arms Andrew and hugged him, trying to run away from that moment. She wouldn’t lose another sibling. Not tonight. Not again. “I won’t go back. I won’t leave you again, Andrew.” Andrew wrapped his arms around his big sister and buried his face into the side of her head.

“Promise?” He whispered in her ear, smiling.

"Promise."

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #andrew graves #andrew graves x reader

35 notes · View notes

coff-in · 1 month

Note

Can I request a dynamic where the reader is the youngest Graves sibling (like a year younger than Ashley) and is objectively the most "normal" of the siblings (before Ashley and Andrew kind of ruin it)?

She's still clingy with her big brother and sister, but she's also happy to make friends outside of them and actively cares about them a lot. The thing is that Andrew forbids her from dating and Ashley scares off a lot of her friends and when quarantine rolls around she's stuck with two older siblings who are obsessed with her and she's not too sure what to do about it, because her siblings really are all she has left now.

Bonus details, I think it would be fun if her relationship with Andrew is bordering on romantic/he has romantic feelings he doesn't admit to but shows (sleeping in the same bed, holding hands) and he dotes on her a lot as the youngest. However, this strains her relationship with Ashley, who is used to having Andrew to herself before the youngest sister was born, but also loves reader (platonically, maybe transitioning to romantically) because she's never done anything but love Ashley unconditionally.

So it's a complicated thing where Ashley's possessive of both but also scared they'll get together and abandon her, Andrew is extra possessive and protective of reader but denies it to hell (as he does), and reader is slowly realizing some things about her siblings that she really should've realized much, much earlier...

notes from coff-in: GRRRR IT'S LIKE YOU LIVE IN MY MIND!!!! oh to have two possessive and obsessive older siblings who love you way more than a normal sibling should, not like i'm complaining, hahaha! i'm sorry these asks are taking so long... i just wanna hang on to all your wonderful asks and daydreaming about them indulgently!! even so, i hope this was to your liking and thank you so much for requesting!!

[fem] reader-insert, [reader] is 1 year younger than ashley, talks/mention of incest, brief NSFW

I love you more than I should...

Andrew and Ashley did not know why their mother thought she should have a second child. Maybe this was an accidental pregnancy.

When [reader] was old enough to walk and talk, Mrs. Graves delegated the responsibility of raising her to Andy, who was around maybe four or five years old at the time. He tried his best to keep them both happy and satisfied, but it was obvious to the keen few that he paid extra attention to his baby sister. Leyley wasn’t used to not having Andy’s full attention on her and expressed her hatred of the new status quo by picking on her little sister.

When [reader] would try to make amends with Leyley for whatever crime she committed, it shocked Leyley. She remembers when she was playing in the forest one day, picking on the bugs in the dirt, and having her little sister [reader] walk up clumsily to her with dug-up flowers in her hand.

“I’m sorry I made you upset, Leyley. Please don’t be mad.” Leyley picked on her less after that and a heated argument with Andy. In fact she tried to hang out with [reader] more often and tried her best to be nicer to her sister. She was someone besides Andy that she could call a friend. It wasn’t uncommon to catch [reader] following her older siblings like a lost puppy, eating lunch and studying with Andy or drawing and playing around with Leyley.

The other kids found it strange how [reader] would willingly hang out with Leyley. She was so normal like Andy was. She was sociable and had friends that she hung out with from time to time… until Leyley drew most of them away. The only ones that stuck around were Julia and Nina. Maybe [reader] knew that they were just using her to get closer to Andy or maybe she believed that they genuinely wanted to be her friends.

Once Nina died [reader] stopped putting herself out as much. She clung much closer to her big siblings and they were happy to dote and comfort her. Leyley made it so that [reader] promised with the blood pact she would never love anyone else but her and their bother.

As they got older, in middle and high school [reader] started to come out of her shell again. She tried to make some new friends but Ashley, again, did her hardest to scare most of them off.

“What do you need other friends for?” She’d ask [reader] when they see each other during the day, “You have me and Andy! You don’t need anyone else!”

It’s not like Andrew was any better himself. His possessiveness was less visible to others but it was still there. “Ashley’s right, sis. You don’t need to worry about making friends right now.” (God, to be the object of affection between these two <3)

He didn’t like the idea of [reader] dating. He knew it was wrong for him to think of his sister like this, but he didn’t want to share her with anyone else. He’d never admit that he got off on the idea of being her first; her first kiss, her first boyfriend… To avoid the jealousy he knew he’d feel if [reader] dated he simply told her that she wasn’t allowed to do so. Any arguments that [reader] had about him or Ashley dating (mostly about him dating Julia) were casually swept aside with the excuse that he’s older than her.

Ashley doesn’t like Andrew dating Julia. He can’t leave her! Does Julia really think that she’s better because Andrew can fuck her and not Ashley or [reader]?! While Ashley leaves 200 violent voicemails for Julia, [reader] calls Andrew a lot during his time in college to ask if he could come home.

“I miss you.” [reader] would say in that low, pouty voice that’ll tug on Andrew’s heart and make his cheeks red. “Could you come back this weekend to visit?”

And he’d say “Of course.” because he could never deny his little sisters.

Once they’re stuck in quarantine, Andrew and Ashley start showing (or at least then [reader] starts noticing) their more possessive and… weirder nature.

They’re always with [reader] except for when [reader] has to use the restroom. Ashley’s making [reader] do some chore with her or Andrew’s subtly holding [reader] close to him when he’s smoking on the balcony. Ashley would make her teasingly suggestive comments about [reader] and Andrew would immediately shut them down while avoiding looking at [reader] because he does think that they have a merit to them.

Andrew sneaks into [reader]’s bed when the nightmares come and cuddles up to his baby sister. He holds her close in his arms and rests his face on top of her head or in the crook of her neck or on her chest with her chip over his head. He relishes in her warmth and takes deep inhales of her scent to comfort himself.

Whenever [reader] does chores, he pats her on her head and says that she did a good job and that he’s proud. [reader] insists he praises Ashley too and it makes her heart pound a little faster and harder.

Skip over to Episode 1 when they break into the cultist apartment, Andrew tries to avoid having [reader] see what’s up. [reader] is reasonably freaked out and upset about having to dismember and EAT a dead guy until Ashley proposes that she’d just starve to death. Andrew argues with Ashley about letting their baby sister starve and would probably insist with Ashley that [reader] should eat the dead cultist.

Ah, this is going to be very lazy of me but I’m going to skip over to the Burial vision scene. In the vision, the siblings see themselves (all three of them) post-coitus, naked and marked up by each other. (Very self-indulgent but [reader] would be placed in the middle of them)

Andrew’s an embarrassed mess because holy shit, holy shit, holy shit!

He fucks his sisters. He fucks his baby sister, [reader]. He’s as elated as he is scared… she’s not like that. She wouldn’t fuck him. She wouldn’t fuck her older siblings and she wouldn’t want them as much as he wants her… would she?

Ashley’s never really considered [reader] in a romantic light like that, but she doesn’t mind it at all. Having [reader] close to her and Andrew like that brings a warm comfort to her.

With the way the trinket works, [reader] probably wouldn’t be able to see the vision since she can’t touch it when Andrew and Ashley are holding it in their hands. She’d be sleeping on the couch, waking up when she heard Andrew and Ashley yelling about the argument.

I wanna write smut about them having a hot incestuous threesome so badly but I’m losing steam right now. They all confess their feelings about each other and kiss tho. By the time Episode 2 ends [reader] has been sort of worn down by Andrew and Ashley’s weird feelings that she’s like “Yeah I’d fuck my siblings because I love them!”

----

coff-in

#cobweb in the coffin #tcoaal #the coffin of andy and leyley #tcoaal x reader #the coffin of andy and leyley x reader #andrew graves #ashley graves #andrew graves x reader #ashley graves x reader

104 notes · View notes