#yeah religion is transformative at the margins of society and oppressive at the centre

[cruelsister-moved2]

I think people have confused the fact that it's definitely possible to go "look this magical guy told me these are the rules so now you all have to obey" with believing that religion is intrinsically just that. and it's like they just discount the possibility that anyone has ever earnestly believed in a higher authority or genuinely had a mystical experience or whatever. the thing is if you actually observe how religious people behave, especially if you look outside of like evangelical megachurch pastors who are clearly just grifting, it immediately becomes pretty hard to ignore that.

for every example of religion maintaining inequality u have muslim charities successfully preventing FGM by informing muslim communities who perpetrate it that it's haram, sikhs opposing casteism, early christians fighting gender inequality etc etc etc + on an individual level literally countless people who have fought against poverty and oppression on the basis of religious belief. like... IS it really something specific about religion or is it the fact that hegemony will naturally pick up and spread whatever supports it and suppress whatever doesn't?because the same can also be said of like... music... so are u going to say music is just a tool of the elite or whatever? bc it definitely can be. but it's equally a tool for resisting oppression and also just a significant part of the human experience.

aren't we meant to be postmodernists now like i think maybe things sometimes do just happen sometimes. what Society does with it after the fact is another question, but if you look at the history of religion I'm surprised if you don't come away with some awareness that genuine belief in some sort of authority or mechanism which is outside of human control can be something very transformative. like the fundamental innovation of the torah was to say that every human life is equal to every other human life in opposition to the code of hammurabi which said that some people's life = other people's pocket change. only a power which comes from somewhere outside human society would be able to ensure that law was applied fairly and equally to all rather than manipulated on the whim of the human with the most power to enforce it. if the "abrahamic" religions can be said to have anything in common at all, it's probably a call to humbleness and the value of every human being. much to think about!!!!

#religion kind of just makes u more like whatever ur already like ngl #if anything can be said universally of religion it's probably just that #which is why I said what I said abt gay catholics #sorry everyone I needed to say this because I was trying to work out what was bothering me abt #the book I just read teehee #watched a documentary abt another gnostic gospel and it is just so like #yeah religion is transformative at the margins of society and oppressive at the centre #like so is everything in the world. what else is new #if you don't want to read this whole post then just go watch yentl. you'll understand #like it's easier to think about w music bc something I noticed w like victorian era popular music was literally like #the average guy just starts liking something because. it's exciting and interesting to him #and then there is some kind of move to retain control #like minstrel shows in the uk were partly a reaction to genuine enthusiasm for african american music because like. it's good and it's also #super different to anything people had heard before #so then there was this like. move to take control from black performers by having it be white performers doing caricatures at their expense #music hall was something people just started doing and then was ultimately turned into a whole panopticon of control #see also: every radical music genre that gets watered down and commercialised #anywayyyy hiii