Thereâs definitely a way that short stocky gymnasts get pigeonholed into a âpowerful but not artisticâ stereotype but I think a lot of it is upstream of fans and judges. Itâs coming from coaches and choreographers.
Like, fans saw Claudia Fragapane and correctly recognized that she was not especially graceful. Itâs not that they werenât being charitable (well, there was some nastiness but that wasnât all of it), itâs that she actually had bad choreo, no flexibility and poor dance foundations.
In contrast, I have never seen Flavia Saraivaâs artistry doubted in my years of being a fan, even though sheâs not tall and thin.
I think the issue is that a lot of coaches are not willing to put time into dance foundations for their powerhouse gymnasts, partially due to their own biases, and partially because they can get enough difficulty from their four tumbling passes that artistry deductions donât matter. Artistry and pretty leaps is a backup if chucking a silivas doesnât work out. And because of physics, chucking a silivas is easier if you have a shorter moment arm. Add in some poor choreography decisions and theyâre set up to fail.
35 notes
¡
View notes
so far not loving the webb and dude with webb commentary. They say a lot of things, but they don't tell me anything I don't already know, which is annoying.
4 notes
¡
View notes
I feel like abby lee miller was like. really meant to choreograph beam in this quad tbh lmao ? like some of the Moments in her dance choreo are weird but interesting and pretty* and musical and as much as sheâs a loser I feel like she would construct beam routines with zero artistry deductions
9 notes
¡
View notes
Ellie black has at various times in her career been a vault specialist, a floor specialist, a beam specialist and finally a bars specialist. The last one being the most surprising. She always has a standout event, but year on year she might decide to switch which one it is.
I get that she is a strong all-around athlete, but this thing where her strongest event is simply super fluid (and her stand out events always do stand out) is bizarre
19 notes
¡
View notes
Yulia Nikolaeva, 2024 Russian Championships
42 notes
¡
View notes
tags
I actually think that some people do automatically think of slimmer gymnasts as more artistic but to imply that someone might think that komova is one of the greatest only because she is skinny? Be for fucking real please
21 notes
¡
View notes
Iâm sorry but people acting like suni not being given any international assignments is noteworthy is crazy to me. (assuming these same people have been paying attention to the happenings of the last calendar year)
If youâre a fan I get why youâre upset but unless youâre like delusional stan level I truly donât get why u might be surprised lmaoâŚ?
32 notes
¡
View notes
I keep trying to like Kayla dicellos gymnastics like I really try. But itâs just so very Nothing to me. Thereâs no flair, no interesting skills or anything she does particularly well. Nothing she does is memorable to me.
42 notes
¡
View notes
âSome 10s are worth it some are notâ bart im screeching did u really say that live on the SEC networkâ˘ď¸ đ¤đ
15 notes
¡
View notes
Maddie Jones (ARK) quickly becoming my favorite NCAA gymnast: clean technique, pretty movement quality, a nice balance of power and control, and now 2 consecutive well-choreographed floor routines. Hope her star continues to rise, can't wait to see her put it all together.
1 note
¡
View note
prev tags
Ok like I understand that itâs their last season (for Kiya definitely and for Haleigh maybe đ) but why do they need to be doing AA basically every week? You have a whole ass platoon of a roster and AA doesnât mean anything in regular season other than pithy dual meet âtitles.â which is a stat barely anybody gives a fuck about. You have lineups like 8-gymnasts deep at LEAST, on every event, use the rookies in the front half of the season if youâre going to use them at all??? I really donât get the reasoning behind these choices tbh especially since we know LSU has a handful of healthy âalternatesâ who could really use competition experience and could go in 3rd/4th in lineups. Why are you exhausting them, haleigh in particular, in the early-mid season and risking injury in the processâŚ? idk just đđđđ
12 notes
¡
View notes
ETERI TUTBERIDZE WHEN I CATCH YOU.
(tw: mentions of weighing, eds)
117 notes
¡
View notes
Same, but I'm loving Leanne's success. She didn't start out as a favorite for me; I liked her cleanness but found her a bit stiff and cookie-cutter/good at most things but not a standout/the best at any. She's come a long way though, and I also vibe with the more serious, reserved personality; the NCAA gym world (and the real world to tbh) acts like having a big, vocal, expressive personality and putting it all out there 100% is key to success, but Leanne is such a boss.
the hate i have in my heart for florida for little to no reason only grows each season
19 notes
¡
View notes