#oh also i gotta clarify thats a strawman in my head. im not vaguing or misreading bonefalls recent post on him djdjdjfjf

[yuridovewing]

oh god another reason yellowfangs secret is inaccurate and shouldnt count: boulder is just a regular allycat and joins shadowclan when yellowfangs a baby on a whim when in tpb its a massive plotpoint that hes ex bloodclan and scourge knows him personally and theres no way in hell that that works with the timeline

#‘’oh well maybe he joined bloodclan briefly when he was exiled or that bloodclan was the previous leader-‘’ #first of all clan cats and scourge. not gonna work out. i really doubt boulder wouldve joined and left and scourge knows him well enough #from those two months or so to not only know him by name (bloodclan is HUGE) but trust him enough to entertain tigerstars deal #second of all its just more cohesive if he was born there and then left. third of all theres no way in hell bloodclan existed at that point #girl scourge is only like. 3 years older than firestar? yellowfang was an apparentice at this point #and incanon he is the founder #oh also i gotta clarify thats a strawman in my head. im not vaguing or misreading bonefalls recent post on him djdjdjfjf #hopefullyyyyy everyone knows that bloodclan existing before scourge is a headcanon/au/rewrite thing