Tumgik
hogwartsandhawkins · 17 days
Note
Omg, Steve and Billy throwing hands for her!
And Billy called her HIS girl!!! 😭 *Screaming*
It's going to be so worth it when they finally get together.
Counting down the chapters til it happens 🤞🏼
2 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 17 days
Note
Just a small one? On the cheek? It's New Year's! Everyone knows you kiss on new years for good luck!
And to say thank you for rocking Dennis's shit.
She can totally kiss Steve too! Maybe Billy's like 'WTF why does he get a cheek kiss for getting his ass beat I took most of the damage and did most of the hitting!' and then Jess kisses his cheek too. 🥹 Just a crumb of Jess/Billy fluffiness.
🧞‍♀️on it 🥰
3 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 17 days
Note
I swear to God if Jess doesn't kiss Billy at Benny's I'm jumping out the window 🤣🤣
I hope it’s a first story window bc this story is an agitatinglylyly slow burn 😭🤣🤣
3 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 18 days
Note
I feel bad because I lost where I was in your story "Prove Me Wrong" but I'm happy to be tagged so that way when it's finished, I can binge read it all.
Don’t worry about it! I’ll happily keep tagging you love 🥰
1 note · View note
hogwartsandhawkins · 18 days
Text
When I tell you I screamed with excitement when I wrote the “I’m here to stay part” I’m not over exaggerating, I got butterflies and I was the one writing it 🫠
All I’m gonna say is if you liked Steve and Billy in this chapter you’re gonna love what Steve does for Billy next chapter 🫡
Thank you so much for reading!!! It means a lot!! And I’m definitely ok now. I got all my work back so im definitely doing a lot better
Prove Me Wrong
Chapter 17: Winds of Change
If you need to catch up, here's the Masterlist
Tumblr media
Summary: Jess and the gang get kicked out
Word Count: 7.5k
Warnings: Fighting, mentions of blood, bruising, face injuries, of aged men hitting on under-aged girls 🤢, angst. As always let me know if I missed something!
AN: So I got a new laptop, and was super excited to write on it. And then when I uploaded my word doc, it crashed. 🤗 Long story short, after crying and being unmotivated to redo everything that I thought I lost, I fixed it.
The street was full of cars when Jess and Billy pulled up, causing them to park further down the street away from Tina’s. Billy pulled the parking brake and turned off the ignition, turning back to Jess. 
“So what the hell did he say?” Billy was staring at Jess, completely surprised that she had already admitted to Steve that they were a little more than just partners for an English project now.
“He suggested that we hold hands and skip through the football field.” Jess rolled her eyes as she heard the strong laugh leaving Billy’s body. 
“So is he pissed?”
“He’s not exactly thrilled…” 
“Yeah, well. Fuck it,” Billy shrugged unbuckling Jess’s seatbelt for her before taking the keys from the ignition, “Bout time he realized you’re your own person.” 
“He already does, Billy-“
“No he doesn’t. ‘’Cuz god forbid you decided to go to this party without him.” Before Jess could continue arguing, he opened his own door and stepped out, reminding her to “Stay right there,” as he left. When he opened the door for her, waiting for her to step out, he continued, “It’s like he wants you two attached to the hip…” He shook his head, looking as if he were annoying himself with the thought of Steve Harrington always around. 
Once Jess was out of the car, she began to take off the jacket, causing Billy to drop his current thought. “What’re you doin’, leave it on…” 
“I don’t wanna carry it all night when I have to take it off inside.” Before Jess had it all the way off, however, Billy quickly shed the one he was wearing, throwing it in the back and closing the passenger door. 
“There. Problem solved.”
“How-“ 
“Geez, Jess, I thought you were supposed to be the smart one,” Billy teased, “When you don’t want it, I’ll take it alright? Just… keep it on. Least till we get in…”
“You just want it on me to piss off Steve.” They began walking away from the car, the sound of music becoming louder despite the already drowning sound of teenagers that littered her outdoor area. There were easily twice as many people at this party compared to the one Carol had, as Tina was never picky about who came, something Jess had always appreciated about her. 
“I didn’t even know we were seeing pretty boy tonight, alright. Can we lay off the subject now?” 
“Oooh, someone’s testy,” Jess’s smile was faint as she poked fun at him, but slowly faded when she looked up to realize he wasn’t smiling back. “Okay… sorry…”
“No, it’s just… You ever get tired of only thinking about Steve when you do something?” 
“I do not!” 
“Like two goddamn peas in a pod. You’re obsessed with him, he’s obsessed with you,” Billy sighed, slowing down their pace to further the conversation without anyone overhearing, ensuring this by looking around before he spoke again, “It just would be awesome if I could do shit for you without you thinking it’s all this weird thing to piss Harrington off.” 
“Right, because you weren’t trying to at the diner?”
“Jess,” Suddenly, Billy stopped walking entirely, turning his entire body to face her as he looked past her, focusing on his actions from earlier. “I wasn’t trying to piss him off. I was just… fuck…” His shoulders shrugged with frustration, tensing as they dropped again. He looked over toward the house, his jaw now as tense as his shoulders. “He needs to know that I’m not exactly going anywhere,” His head slowly inched back to her as he sucked in a final breath for courage before continuing, “That I’m here to stay.” His eyes flicked to another group walking past them, behind Jess, locking onto them until they were far enough for Billy’s liking.  “Look, I’m not asking for him to like me. I just want him to know that we at least got one thing in common.” 
“And what’s that?” Jess took a step in his direction as she watched him look around one last time. 
“That we both think you’re cool as shit,” He answered as if it were obvious, now walking toward the house at the same, slow pace they had previously. 
Jess followed closely, her arm only inches from his. “Oh yeah? I figured it would be something like how you’re both scarily obsessed with basketball or something.”
“No, Logan. See, thing is, there’s still a big difference between me and him when it comes to basketball. I’m actually good and your little boy toy sucks.”
“He does not suck.” 
“Oh, so that’s the part of the sentence you’re gonna correct?” 
“He does not suck.”
Billy let out an airy laugh as he shoved his hands in his pockets due to the cold, his breath visible when his chuckle dragged out. “Alright, so he’s not that bad.”
“He’s starting five.” 
“So am I.” 
“So there you go,” Jess countered, “You both don’t suck.” 
Billy shook his head in surrender as they reached the wide-open front door. They both looked past the entryway into the main living room, which was already packed, when Jess felt two hands on either side of her neck, patting her shoulders softly.  
“We goin’ in or what?” Jess turned around to see Steve, Jason, Chrissy, and Patrick standing behind her, the others that came with them squeezing past to get inside. Jess and Billy lead the rest of the group toward the kitchen, Steve staying close behind. The music was even louder than it usually was, possibly due to the fact that Tina’s party wasn’t the only social gathering happening on this street. There were never any noise complaints called in on New Year’s Eve, surprising in a small town like Hawkins, and even if there were, there was always a good chance that Hopper would ignore them for the holiday. 
As they made it to the crowded kitchen, Jess noticed a large group of boys she had never seen before stocking the fridge with an assortment of beers, liquor, and mixers. It wasn’t until Tina’s older brother, Christopher, joined them from the dining room that she realized why she’d never seen them before. 
“Hey, Chris.” Jess watched as Tina sauntered over with Nicole, Vickie, Katie, and Jane, who were all giggling, seemingly excited that Tina gave them automatic access to the only college boys at the party. Before Jess could continue listening in, one of Christopher’s friends took notice of her, giving her a look that quickly made her uncomfortable. She turned around to face Steve, causing him to stop. 
“You okay, kid?” 
“Yeah, yeah it’s just, the kitchen looks packed, you know…” Steve looked past her, shrugging his shoulders as he looked into what seemed to be the most open part of the house.
Billy, however, looked where Jess had earlier, taking notice of the older group by the fridge. “You want anything outta there, princess?” He asked without taking his eyes off the cluster of boys. The question made Steve’s eyes roll, but he didn’t interject, allowing Jess to place her request. When he walked past the kitchen island to retrieve a red cup, he caught the attention of Jane, who quickly left the now large group she was in to stride her way over to him. 
“Hey there, Hargrove.” Jane leaned into him slightly, eyeing the drink that he now had in his hand with amusement. “That for me? Because that’s definitely not for you.” 
Billy looked down at the cup as well before laughing coldly, the corners of his mouth pulling downwards. “And why not?” The sarcasm dripped from his question, causing Jane to lean away, not sure if this banter was the friendly kind. 
“Because I know what you actually want.” 
Billy picked up on her tone, clearly expressing she was no longer talking about beer. “Yeah, I doubt that,” He deadpanned, not breaking eye contact as he watched her expression change from confident to irritated in a matter of seconds. 
“Really? Because that’s not the impression I got before break.” She batted her lashes ironically, challenging him on his not-so-new attitude towards her. He finally broke the staring, walking himself to the fridge that was still being crowded around. He pushed past the boys, not troubling himself to ask them to move as he bumped shoulders with the one now chatting up Nicole. To his dismay, she had followed him. He turned around to see her crossing her arms over her chest, almost as if she was triumphantly looking at the can he now had. “What did I tell ya, knew exactly what you’d be going for.”
“Don’t you got some desperate college dude to bug?” He asked rather loudly, still unbothered by the fact that said college boys were gathered around behind him. Billy heard one of them mumble something behind his back but didn’t budge to look behind him, as he felt he’d made his point perfectly clear. 
Jane looked over at the group he came in with, scoffing when her eyes met the back of Steve’s head, watching who he was talking to. “I didn’t know you were friends with Steve Harrington now.” When Billy only rolled his eyes in response, about ready to walk away, she poked at him once more, successfully stopping him in his tracks. “So, what you’re saying is you’d rather hang with Harrington and his little prude all night than have some actual fun, Hargrove?”
Billy scrunched his nose in annoyance, his jaw clenching as he heard the nickname Jane spat out. He wanted to retaliate, possibly hurt her feelings to the point where it would have ruined the rest of her night. There were names that were already lined up in his mind that he could call her and could have probably justified even hours later after he possibly felt bad for his actions. But he stood there for a moment, chewing on his tongue behind his closed lips that were contorted into a sneer. He stared off into the crowd, not exactly fixating on one person, refusing to look back at her face which he was sure was now sporting a satisfied grin, knowing it would anger him further. Instead, he cleared his throat and relaxed his jaw before responding with a simple, “Just fuck off, Jane,” not even bothering to finish his sentence before he continued walking back to Jess and Steve. 
Jess listened to Steve talk about the upcoming tournament as she glanced over to Billy, who was now striding toward her with two drinks in hand. Behind him, Jane purposely caught her attention, waving with only her fingers as she eyed the outfit she was in. Jess watched as her eyes landed suddenly on Billy’s jacket, taking a moment before forcing herself to peel them away and walk back toward the rest of her friends. Jess broke into a small smile, causing Steve to stop mid-sentence. “What’s so funny?” 
“Nothing,” Jess quickly responded, her eyes finding their way back to Steve’s. 
“So, Harrington, you hangin’ with us all night?” Billy stood next to the both of them, taking a quick sip out of Jess’s drinking, ensuring it tasted right, before handing it over to her. Steve thought for a moment, looking over at the red cup Jess had in her hand and then to Billy, who was now taking a drink out of his own Beer. 
“You totally can, if you want. It’s no big deal really,” Jess interrupted his thoughts, not wanting him to think that he had to leave. 
“You know what,” He looked over his shoulder to look around the room, “I kinda owe Heather a dance.” He then straightened his neck back to look over Billy intently. He stood there for a moment longer, evidently recalling something from earlier as he stared at Jess’s cup once more, causing him to relax his shoulders slightly. “Don’t have too much fun without me…” He then gave Jess a friendly smile as he backed away, turning to disappear into the crowd. 
Jess continued to look in the direction that she last saw Steve. “Weird…” 
“What? Weird that pretty boy left?” He took another long drink out of his beer, pretending not to even notice his absence, though if he was being honest with himself, he also found it odd as well that Steve had just agreed to leave them alone. He had intended the question to be a joke, fully expecting Steve to follow Jess around all night, not allowing her a single moment alone with him. And again, if he were being honest, he couldn’t really blame him. 
“I mean, he did cancel Benny’s just to be here…”
“Eh, like he said. He owes some girl a dance.” He shrugged it off as he scanned the room, catching Hagen’s attention as he looked toward the back door. 
“Aye! B!” Jess surprisingly was able to hear Tommy shout over the speakers, watching him pull Carol by the hand through the crowd. 
“Jesus, Tommy, slow down…” Carol mumbled as they reached Billy and Jess, pulling her hand away once his grip loosened. “Hey, you two.” 
“Did I just see you with Harrington?” Tommy questioned, not yet greeting Jess. 
“Yeah, what was that all about…” Carol left Tommy’s side and joined Jess, looking back over at her before adding, “No offense,” to the end of her sentence. 
“Nothing important.” 
Carol looked over at Jess, giving her the same look Chrissy always did when it came to Billy. “Well, I think it’s cute that you’re getting along with him now… Anyways. Tommy’s wanting a rematch.”
“I can’t this time. Driving.” Billy then gestured with his can over to Jess, giving her a wink before further explaining. “Gotta take this one home.” 
“Dude, lame.” Tommy groaned, “Why don’t you both just crash here?” 
“Jess has a curfew, remember?” Carol poked fun at her, pinching her cheeks as if she was a child. “It’s fine, the girls will play a round. Does your goody-two-shoes friend drink, like, at all?”
“Chrissy, I mean… yeah… sometimes but-“
“Good, wave goodbye to the boys,” Carol then looped her arm with Jess’s, walking purposefully toward Jason, Chrissy, and Patrick. “Cunningham. Come on, you’re up at beer pong.” 
Chrissy quickly stood at Jess’s side as they made their way to the kitchen. “I’m not very good…” She said apologetically, causing Carol to giggle. 
“Good. You’re on Jess’s team then.”
“You’ll be fine, Chris. Carol’s not very good either.”
“Bite me.” Carol led them away from Jason and Patrick, who were now eyeing the three girls suspiciously, and began making her way to the kitchen, eyeing the group that was still by the fridge. 
“Please don’t ask Jane to play…” Jess groaned, now dragging her feet a bit. 
“Oh god no. She fucking hates you, you know that right? Why would I ask her to play?” 
“Yes, Carol. Thank you. I know.” 
“I wonder why…” Chrissy leaned in, laughing out loud as she watched the way Jane quickly snapped her head over her shoulder as she heard footsteps coming toward her. 
“Tina, let’s play.” Carol unlooped her arm from Jess’s and grabbed Tina’s hand, pulling rather aggressively, only allowing Tina to wave by to a couple of the girls before she was headed out of the kitchen. Jess and Chrissy followed closely behind them as they navigated their way around the maze of teenagers that crowded the living room. When they finally made it outside, Jess saw Tommy and Billy already waiting for them by the table, Billy quickly making his way to Jess to grab the cup out of her hand. 
“Hey! I’m not-“
“Yeah, you’re done with this.” Billy then downed the barely touched drink, crushing the cup when he was done, tossing it toward the opened black bag that was by the ping pong table. “Like I said, I’m not bringing you home completely sloshed.”
“Oh don’t worry, Billy, your girl’s gonna be plenty sloshed when we’re done with her.” Carol then high-fived Tina as they set up their side of the table. “Hurry up and get over here, Logan, I’m tryna win.” 
Billy shook his head, leaning in to whisper in Jess’s ear. “Don’t worry, Tina’s shot’s trash. Played against her on Halloween. Go kick their ass, princess.”
Jess walked over next to Chrissy, who was putting their cups together, occasionally looking up at Tina and Carol’s side to make sure she was doing it right. Out of the corner of her eye, Jess watched as Jason and Patrick joined them by the table, Chrissy giving her boyfriend a shy grin as she waved over to him.
Carol let Chrissy start the game, teasing them by stating how it didn’t matter, and how she and Tina were going to win anyway. Their game went on for what felt like forever, most of their shots bouncing out of cups or missing them completely. Eventually, Steve wandered into the backyard as well, stopping by the table to watch. Once a little over half of the cups were gone, Jess looked over at Chrissy, who was now continuously bumping into her, giggling uncontrollably as she apologized each time. 
“I think Chris might be done,” Jess mentioned, watching as her friend took her time to grasp the ball and aim. 
“No! I’m fine… I just don’t drink a lot,” she continued to giggle, looking over at Jason as he started walking over to her. 
“Don’t get too wasted now.” Jason was now over, counting the cups on her side of the table. “You still got boutta hour to midnight.” 
“Okay okay, fine.” She tossed the ball haphazardly to Jason, who quickly shot his hand up to catch it, not expecting the toss. “You play then.”
“Hey, that means we win.” Carol pointed out, counting how many cups each team had left. “Logan, if she quits, we win!”
“Okay, fine, Carol, you win.” Jess gave in, causing both Tina and Carol to cheer, once again high-fiving each other. 
“What happened to kicking their ass, Logan?” Billy teased, watching her walk back to the side of the table. 
“Yeah, well, Tina had a better shot than you said.”
“Hey!” Tina overheard, crossing her arms as she stared down Billy. 
Jason still held the small ball, bouncing it off the table and catching it with his opposite hand. “You wanna finish this out, Patrick?” 
When he agreed, Tommy jumped in as well, “I’ll take other side. C’mon, B, jump in. We only got like… six cups left.” 
Billy nodded his head slowly, counting the cups himself, convinced he’d only have to drink a couple of them before he and Hagen won. “I ain’t playin’ another one after.” He then threw his now empty beer can in the trash bag that lay on the grass, its contents spilled out around it. “Watch how it’s done, princess.” He walked to Tommy’s side, Steve now taking his place by Jess. 
“Watch how it’s done, princess,” Steve mocked quietly, earning him a punch in the arm. “Good thing you’re staying another three hours. Those guys are good.” He nodded his head to Jason and Patrick before continuing, “No way he’s not downing all three of his.”
“Yeah right… Jason and Patrick only have four left. No way.”
“Oh yeah, well so do Hargrove and Hagen now.” 
Jess shot her attention back to the game, realizing that both Jason and Patrick must have made it in one, Jason now aiming the ball again. When he sank his second shot in the cup nearest Billy, Tommy pounded on the table, watching his friend down his second beer already. “Shit, shit…” The game was over quickly, with Billy only making one shot before the other four cups on his side were gone. 
“What happened to showing me how it was done, Hargrove?” 
“How the hell could I have known that the lightweight’s boyfriend could actually pl- owww.”
“Don’t call her that!”
“You look over at her recently?” 
He nodded his head toward the ground where Chrissy was sitting, looking up at the stars. Jason walked over to her, helping her up as she finally fixed her eyes on him. “Did you win?” 
Jason only laughed at her, leading her back inside so she could sit on the couch. “This is why you don’t play beer pong, baby.” He sat her down on the right side of the living room couch, plopping down next to her as she leaned against the armrest. Billy and Jess followed, Steve close behind them as they entered the house, all three sitting on the loveseat opposite the couch. It was a slightly tight squeeze for the three of them, causing Jess to be partially on Billy’s lap, something he didn’t mind at all. The close proximity caused her to take off Billy’s jacket, which Billy quickly took from her, draping it over the leg she currently wasn’t sitting on. 
Tina, Tommy, and Carol soon entered through the backdoor as well, making Jason scoot closer to Chrissy as they too squeezed to sit on the couch, Carol sitting completely on top of Tommy. Unfortunately, with Tina now sitting with them, the rest of her friends came as well, the college boys following closely behind them. Jess quickly felt eyes on her, and this time, it wasn’t Jane’s stare that caused her to feel uncomfortable. 
Jess nodded back at Tina’s brother, who sat on the floor in front of his sister after wordlessly greeting her. That’s when Jess noticed the same boy from earlier in the kitchen, seemingly more confident now, whether it be from alcohol or from the fact that he realized his friend was acquaintances with Jess. He eyed her noticeably, going out of his way to sit on part of the floor closer to the loveseat, grinning at her once again before pretending to listen to a conversation that was taking place on the couch. On his third attempt of getting Jess’s attention, Billy noticed, causing him to grit his teeth before releasing his jaw again, not wanting his annoyance to be obvious. He then looked over at Jess, attempting to gauge her interest. When she looked as if she were about to crawl out of her skin, he threw his arm around the back of her shoulders, leaning back into the cushions as if trying to convince his body to relax. 
He squeezed her shoulder gently, reassuring her that he was there, to not worry about the creep that happened to be there. Billy didn’t care to know the dude, didn’t care to know his intentions. His longing looks at a high schooler were enough to profile him as a weirdo that he couldn’t wait to get Jess away from. Based on the amount of alcohol at this party, he assumed this man was at least legal drinking age, knowing his friend, Tina’s brother, was 21 as well. Billy leaned down to whisper in Jess’s ear, still not taking his eyes off the only non-teenagers there. 
“You want anything outta the kitchen, princess?”
“It’s okay…” Jess answered quietly, seemingly able to read his mind, “Don’t worry about it… I’m sure they’ll leave.” She traced Billy’s gaze to the same guy still looking over at her, making her quickly look away. It took every ounce of patience in Billy to not call it out, to not pull him up by his collar, hitting him continuously until he fell back down on the floor. But it was only a look, he kept telling himself. He couldn’t risk looking crazy in front of Jess, or worse, embarrassing her in front of their whole class due to just a look. After another ten minutes of attempting to be interested in conversation, however, he kept glancing down at the college boy, apparently named Dennis.
Stupid fucking name.
Dennis had also continued to do the same to both him and Jess, looking between the two of them before staring at Jess for an unwanted amount of time, his eyes appearing to forget that she, too, was a person. Against Billy’s better judgment, he looked over at Steve before looking back at Jess. 
“I need a drink,” He said before whispering in Jess’s ear, “Stay with Steve, I’ll be back in a bit with some water for you, yeah?” He then got up and left Jess’s side, making sure to leave his jacket by her, using it to claim his spot. Jess watched as he disappeared into the crowd, spotting the way he would turn his head back over in their direction occasionally, jaw clenching every time he did. When she could no longer see him, she scooted herself closer to Steve, hoping that would save her from Dennis wanting to socialize with her in any way. It seemed to work for a moment, but she began to grow nervous when Billy had yet to show back up after a few minutes away. Dennis obviously had taken notice as well, scrutinizing the leather jacket that was placed in his way. 
Jess stayed as small as she could, refusing to make eye contact with anyone, until someone within the crowd shouted, “TWO MINUTES TILL MIDNIGHT!” Everyone began cheering, most of the group that was sitting began to stand, awaiting the anticipated countdown. It looked as if Dennis was lost in the crowd, making Jess relax for a moment, only to become on edge again when she felt an unfamiliar hand grab her wrist. 
“Hey,” Jess turned around to see Dennis now standing in front of her, much too close for her liking. “So where you gonna be at midnight?” She could unmistakably smell vodka on his breath, which made her stomach churn, it smelling much less pleasant than the slight smell of hops Billy would have after he would drink. 
She tried pulling away softly, but when his grip didn’t loosen, she panicked, looking back at Steve for help. “Sorry, I’m just gonna hang out with some friends…” She responded, still looking over at Steve who quickly arrived next to her. 
“Hang out with me instead.” He retorted confidently, not caring who was currently next to her. 
“Uhm no I-“
“She’s not interested, bud,” Steve quickly butted in, now directing his attention toward Jess, pulling her arm away, “C’mon kid, let’s go.” 
Jess eagerly began following him away until she was again stopped by the same unfamiliar hand, Dennis’s other hand nudging Steve away. “How about she tell me she’s not interested.” Jess felt her blood run cold, looking at the difference in stature between her friend and the unwanted college boy, who stood taller and broader than Steve did. However, it didn’t deter Steve from pushing back, much harder than Dennis had pushed him. 
“Let go of her, or else.” Steve was now in Dennis’s face, causing Christopher to come over, trying to defuse the situation. 
“Come on, Den, let’s get outta here…” Tina’s brother attempted to whisper, trying to take his friend’s hand from around Jess’s wrist. Jess continued to watch the way the older boy’s eyes faded in and out, clearly intoxicated, and furious. She tried to free her arm once again, but was much weaker than the stocky brunette, when suddenly someone grabbed Christopher’s shirt, quickly pulling him away from Dennis, Billy now standing in his place. Jess then felt a slight pinch in her wrist, hurting only for a moment, realizing after that her hand was suddenly free from Dennis’s grasp and secured softly in Billy’s. He then let go slowly, pointing over to Steve without taking his eyes off Dennis. Jess did as she was wordlessly told, making her way back to Steve’s side. She had never seen him this inflamed, his eyes wide and wild, his jaw ticking with anger. Everyone else besides a select few had yet to notice what was going on around them, continuing to count down, which almost drowned out what Billy said next. 
“You wanna explain why you’re touching my girl?” 
She wasn’t sure if she had heard it correctly, or sure if she, or anyone besides Dennis, was meant to hear it, but she was sure she would have been blushing currently if it wasn’t for the situation they were in. 
“FIVE!”
She watched the way Billy was now shaking out his wrists, occasionally clenching and unclenching his hands into fists, stretching out his fingers when they were released. She’s seen this movement from him only once before, and it didn’t turn out so good for the other boy he was facing that night. 
“FOUR!”
Billy patiently waited for a response, Dennis coming up with one he wasn’t expecting. The older boy chuckled at him, looking back over at Jess before saying, “Didn’t seem like your girl when I was talkin’ to her.”
“THREE!”
Billy’s expression slowly changed from enraged to feigned amusement, smiling maliciously before he chuckled back, scrunching up his nose as he did so. He continued to stare at him, nodding wordlessly before running his tongue along his top row of teeth. 
“TWO!”
Steve seemed to recognize this look as well, taking a step forward to get ready to shield Jess if needed, but still not obstructing her view. She then watched as Billy took one last look over at her, the same smile still there, but his mouth now closed. However, his eyes had a different look, almost apologetic in a way, before he turned back his attention to the creep in front of him. 
“ONE!”
“Yeah... Don’t worry though, I’ll make sure to show her a good ti-“
“HAPPY NEW YEAR!”
Dennis’s snide comment was quickly interrupted by a fist to the mouth, causing everyone in the vicinity to back away, some staring wide-eyed, others now cheering. Despite Dennis being slightly taller and wider than Billy, he didn’t seem to be able to stand up to the younger teen, who was relentlessly throwing punch after punch, not stopping until one of Dennis’s other friends jabbed Billy in the gut. Jess watched the way Billy winced in pain, now turning his attention to the other boy. When she saw Dennis standing up again, now squaring up to take an unfair punch, Jess almost screamed at Billy to turn around, but Steve stopped her as he pushed her back against the crowd softly. 
“Awe fuck,” Steve mumbled before quickly walking up to the other boy, grabbing his collar before shouting, “Hey!” He then swung his arm back, punching him so hard the boy’s cap flew off. Billy glanced over at Steve briefly, surprised at the sudden help. He then nodded at Steve before turning his attention back over to Dennis. Just when both Billy and Steve seemed to be holding their own, Steve taking on a few more punches than Billy, two other college boys stepped up, Christopher being one of them, who was now also swinging at Billy with Dennis. Jess could hardly keep track of the two boys she came with, watching helplessly as both of them disappeared in the middle of the four older ones. Jason and Patrick, however, emerged from the crowd, trying to pull the other boys off Steve and Billy. Jess watched as Jason grabbed for Christopher, who quickly turned and clocked Jason in the jaw, taking him aback only for a moment before he tackled Tina’s brother to the ground. The fighting went on for only moments more until Jess suddenly saw Billy grab for Dennis’s legs, swiftly lifting him and slamming him into Tina’s coffee table, the legs buckling and center cracking from the weight. 
“ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?!” Tina’s voice could be heard over everyone’s cheering, which quickly stopped once she screamed. “MY PARENTS ARE GONNA FREAK!!” Billy slowly rose from the top of Dennis, dusting his legs off before straightening back up, grimacing in pain as he did. Jason and Patrick both helped Steve off the floor who was now sporting a bloody nose. Billy simply stared at Dennis as he pitifully rolled off the now broken table onto his hands and knees, having a hard time getting back on his feet. Chrissy was now at Jess’s side, holding her hand in anticipation as she looked over at her boyfriend, who was also holding onto his own nose, blood dripping from his hand. However, Jess overlooked Jason’s or Patrick’s injuries, her worried gaze leaving Steve and now focusing on Billy, who now had a bruise forming on his cheek, his bottom lip cut. He had yet to look over at her, his eyes still fixed on the boy on the floor almost as if he was challenging him to get back up. He didn’t even flinch or look over when Tina began to yell again next to him. 
“All of you!” She then pointed at all the boys but her brother, “OUT!” 
Jason began trying to speak up, “C’mon Tina, they-“
“I said GET OUT!” 
Jason ran his hand over his face, flicking blood off, walking toward Chrissy, grabbing her hand with his unbloodied one, then nodding at Jess. “Let’s get out of here.” He then looked at the older boys in disgust as he led the girls to the front door, Patrick already out in the front yard. Billy swiped his jacket from the couch, looking back unsatisfied at Dennis one last time before turning and leaving as well, gesturing at Steve to follow him. Billy quickly caught up to Jess, staying close behind her. She could hear how rapidly he was breathing, making her look back at him, causing him to lock eyes with her before he placed his hand on the small of her back, telling her to keep moving. When they finally reached the concrete step that separated the communal sidewalk from the path leading up to Tina’s doorway, all four boys plopped down to sit, looking exhausted. Jess was the first to speak. 
“I’m so sorry guys I-“ 
“Don’t you dare fuckin’ apologize.” Billy stopped her, shaking his head as he stared blankly across the street. 
“Yeah, it’s not your fault, Jess.” Steve agreed, flashing her a sympathetic smile. “You alright?”
Before Jess could answer, however, Billy snapped his head in Jess’s direction, his eyes coming back into focus. “Let me see it,” he demanded, his voice lower in register.
“What?” Jess looked back at him now, confused at what exactly he was requesting. 
“Your wrist. Let me see it.” He held out his hand, figuring she would automatically comply, placing her hand into his, allowing him to examine it carefully as he intended. When she didn’t make a move to do so, his eyes darkened. “Jess…” 
The wrist in question was tucked securely under her blue sleeve, her fingers grasping the fabric against her palm tightly. She had yet to look at it either, but she was sure there was at least a red mark, based on how tight the older boy had ahold of it and how promptly Billy removed his grip when he saw it. She had just watched Billy calm down a bit, and she wasn’t too keen on seeing his rage spike back up. 
“You alright, kid?” Steve now reached for it, the wrist being closer to him than it was to Billy, but she moved it out of easy reach. 
“You guys are freaking out over nothing, it’s fine.” 
“Then let me see it,” Billy spoke again, his voice attempting to hold steady, not wanting Jess to mistake his anger as being directed at her.
“I’ll let you see it when we get out of here…” Jess softly responded, causing Billy to rise from his concrete seat next to Steve, his leather jacket still in hand. “Billy…” He said nothing in response, draping the jacket over Jess’s shoulders before gently reaching for her left wrist, raising it close to his chest before pushing her sleeve out of the way. Jess was surprised to see bruised lines forming in the shape of fingers. They were light, but certainly there. She then looked up at Billy, who was contorting his mouth in an angered frown, looking over her shoulder and then back at her wrist, as if trying to adjust his eyesight to ensure he was seeing this right. 
“Ga’damn,” Patrick now stood next to her, peering over to see the bruises. “That’s fucked, Logan.”
Jess’s eyes moved in his direction in annoyance, indicating he wasn’t helping any, Patrick throwing up his hands in response. Billy still had yet to say a thing, still adjusting his eyesight away from her wrist, only to find himself looking at it again, becoming more unwound with every glance. When he couldn’t keep looking at it, he turned to face Tina’s front door, his chest now heaving. 
“Billy no,” Jess said suddenly, not knowing whether he was thinking about going back in to find Dennis again or not. 
Steve must have felt the tension as well, also rising from the step, looking down at Jess’s wrist once, cringing at the sight of it. “C’mon man, let’s just leave.”
“And go where? Our rides are still inside.” Jason finally spoke up, still sitting as Chrissy stood over him, her hands secured in his, him not wanting to let go of her just yet. 
“You guys didn’t drive here?” Jess asked, looking over at Steve who typically always took his car. 
“Not this time.” 
“Awe shit…” Patrick cursed, sitting himself back down next to Jason.
“I can’t go back home now, my mom’s gonna flip if she sees blood all over me, gotta at least get this shit off me,” Jason groaned, Patrick quickly agreeing with him. 
“We could always go back to Benny’s like we planned?” Chrissy suggested, now trying to rub some of the blood off his cheeks. 
“With what car, babe?”
Jess gave Billy an inquiring look, practically asking permission before she mentioned his car out loud. 
“Can’t drive yet, princess… thought we’d be here for another two hours.”
“Steve’s sober,” she quickly responded.
He glanced over at Steve, now standing awkwardly next to the two of them, before shaking his head. “Hell no.”
“C’mon, Billy. You wanna sit here the rest of the night? Let’s go to Benny’s, you guys wash up, let the rest of your buzz go ‘way in the next couple hours.” When he didn’t budge, she added, “He’s a really good driver…” causing Billy to roll his eyes. 
Jason and Patrick looked up hopefully at Billy, wanting to get out of there as soon as possible as other classmates were now starting to come outside to ‘mingle’, making sure to continue to stare at the banished group. “There’s not ‘nuff seats, and the back’s small as shit.”
“It’s cool, Chris will sit on my lap, Jess and Pat can sit in the back with us, you get front since it’s your car. No big deal.”
Billy stood there for a moment, considering everything he heard before wordlessly tossing his keys to Steve. He then walked ahead of them, a little peeved this was how his night was ending, with a busted lip, a bruised ego, a ruined buzz, Steve fucking Harrington now driving his prized possession, and worst of all, it was his first real night out with Jess.
“Fuckin’ perfect,” He mumbled under his breath, “Just great.”
When they finally reached his car, he stood by the passenger door, eyeing Steve with warning. “If you put a single scratch on her, you’re dead.” He then threw the seat in the upright position, moving out of the way so Jess could squeeze in the middle. Steve did the same, Jason moving into the back seat behind the driver’s side, positioning himself before outstretching his hand to help Chrissy onto his lap. When Patrick began to enter behind Jess, Billy suddenly stopped him, grabbing him by the shirt and tugging backward before mumbling, “You take front.” 
Jess smiled when she saw Billy enter, pushing herself over into Jason more to try and make room for him. When he was semi-comfortable, he adjusted the seat back to allow Patrick to sit, leaning back after to try and relax. However, the tight fit made that difficult, not having much room for his legs. He stretched his left arm behind Jess, shifting every two seconds. “Ah shit…”
“Here, you want me to…” Jess then tried scooting her leg out of the way to allow Billy’s leg more room in the middle. 
After a few more failed attempts to sit comfortably, Billy grumbled in irritation. “Fuck it. C’mere.” He then grabbed Jess by the hips and effortlessly positioned her on his right leg, her back now facing the small triangle window. He placed his right arm in between her and the door, providing her back with more support, shifting lower so her head wasn’t rubbing against the ceiling. Her legs dangled in between Billy’s, which were now comfortably spread. “This alright?” He whispered in her ear. 
She began to nod when Steve entered the car, looking behind him. “You guys okay back th- … ere.” His eyes fixed on Jess and Billy, giving them both a disapproving stare. However, it only lasted for a moment before he turned back around, turning the ignition. He then readjusted the rearview mirror so Jess was able to see his eyes clearly. “Ready to go then? You guys… situated?”
“Ready when you are, Harrington,” Jason grinned, squeezing Chrissy’s thigh as he winked at her playfully. 
“Jess?” Steve questioned, glancing back at her through the mirror. 
“Uh y-up! Ready!” 
Steve nodded, appearing to relax as he accepted her response, again adjusting the mirror so he could see the road behind him.
“Let’s get the hell outta here then.”
Taglist: @nix-rose @fandom-princess-forevermore @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo @axionn @defenslessheart-main @the-lost-are-ignored @ahoyyharrington @strawberrykittey
49 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 18 days
Text
Prove Me Wrong
Chapter 17: Winds of Change
If you need to catch up, here's the Masterlist
Tumblr media
Summary: Jess and the gang get kicked out
Word Count: 7.5k
Warnings: Fighting, mentions of blood, bruising, face injuries, of aged men hitting on under-aged girls 🤢, angst. As always let me know if I missed something!
AN: So I got a new laptop, and was super excited to write on it. And then when I uploaded my word doc, it crashed. 🤗 Long story short, after crying and being unmotivated to redo everything that I thought I lost, I fixed it.
The street was full of cars when Jess and Billy pulled up, causing them to park further down the street away from Tina’s. Billy pulled the parking brake and turned off the ignition, turning back to Jess. 
“So what the hell did he say?” Billy was staring at Jess, completely surprised that she had already admitted to Steve that they were a little more than just partners for an English project now.
“He suggested that we hold hands and skip through the football field.” Jess rolled her eyes as she heard the strong laugh leaving Billy’s body. 
“So is he pissed?”
“He’s not exactly thrilled…” 
“Yeah, well. Fuck it,” Billy shrugged unbuckling Jess’s seatbelt for her before taking the keys from the ignition, “Bout time he realized you’re your own person.” 
“He already does, Billy-“
“No he doesn’t. ‘’Cuz god forbid you decided to go to this party without him.” Before Jess could continue arguing, he opened his own door and stepped out, reminding her to “Stay right there,” as he left. When he opened the door for her, waiting for her to step out, he continued, “It’s like he wants you two attached to the hip…” He shook his head, looking as if he were annoying himself with the thought of Steve Harrington always around. 
Once Jess was out of the car, she began to take off the jacket, causing Billy to drop his current thought. “What’re you doin’, leave it on…” 
“I don’t wanna carry it all night when I have to take it off inside.” Before Jess had it all the way off, however, Billy quickly shed the one he was wearing, throwing it in the back and closing the passenger door. 
“There. Problem solved.”
“How-“ 
“Geez, Jess, I thought you were supposed to be the smart one,” Billy teased, “When you don’t want it, I’ll take it alright? Just… keep it on. Least till we get in…”
“You just want it on me to piss off Steve.” They began walking away from the car, the sound of music becoming louder despite the already drowning sound of teenagers that littered her outdoor area. There were easily twice as many people at this party compared to the one Carol had, as Tina was never picky about who came, something Jess had always appreciated about her. 
“I didn’t even know we were seeing pretty boy tonight, alright. Can we lay off the subject now?” 
“Oooh, someone’s testy,” Jess’s smile was faint as she poked fun at him, but slowly faded when she looked up to realize he wasn’t smiling back. “Okay… sorry…”
“No, it’s just… You ever get tired of only thinking about Steve when you do something?” 
“I do not!” 
“Like two goddamn peas in a pod. You’re obsessed with him, he’s obsessed with you,” Billy sighed, slowing down their pace to further the conversation without anyone overhearing, ensuring this by looking around before he spoke again, “It just would be awesome if I could do shit for you without you thinking it’s all this weird thing to piss Harrington off.” 
“Right, because you weren’t trying to at the diner?”
“Jess,” Suddenly, Billy stopped walking entirely, turning his entire body to face her as he looked past her, focusing on his actions from earlier. “I wasn’t trying to piss him off. I was just… fuck…” His shoulders shrugged with frustration, tensing as they dropped again. He looked over toward the house, his jaw now as tense as his shoulders. “He needs to know that I’m not exactly going anywhere,” His head slowly inched back to her as he sucked in a final breath for courage before continuing, “That I’m here to stay.” His eyes flicked to another group walking past them, behind Jess, locking onto them until they were far enough for Billy’s liking.  “Look, I’m not asking for him to like me. I just want him to know that we at least got one thing in common.” 
“And what’s that?” Jess took a step in his direction as she watched him look around one last time. 
“That we both think you’re cool as shit,” He answered as if it were obvious, now walking toward the house at the same, slow pace they had previously. 
Jess followed closely, her arm only inches from his. “Oh yeah? I figured it would be something like how you’re both scarily obsessed with basketball or something.”
“No, Logan. See, thing is, there’s still a big difference between me and him when it comes to basketball. I’m actually good and your little boy toy sucks.”
“He does not suck.” 
“Oh, so that’s the part of the sentence you’re gonna correct?” 
“He does not suck.”
Billy let out an airy laugh as he shoved his hands in his pockets due to the cold, his breath visible when his chuckle dragged out. “Alright, so he’s not that bad.”
“He’s starting five.” 
“So am I.” 
“So there you go,” Jess countered, “You both don’t suck.” 
Billy shook his head in surrender as they reached the wide-open front door. They both looked past the entryway into the main living room, which was already packed, when Jess felt two hands on either side of her neck, patting her shoulders softly.  
“We goin’ in or what?” Jess turned around to see Steve, Jason, Chrissy, and Patrick standing behind her, the others that came with them squeezing past to get inside. Jess and Billy lead the rest of the group toward the kitchen, Steve staying close behind. The music was even louder than it usually was, possibly due to the fact that Tina’s party wasn’t the only social gathering happening on this street. There were never any noise complaints called in on New Year’s Eve, surprising in a small town like Hawkins, and even if there were, there was always a good chance that Hopper would ignore them for the holiday. 
As they made it to the crowded kitchen, Jess noticed a large group of boys she had never seen before stocking the fridge with an assortment of beers, liquor, and mixers. It wasn’t until Tina’s older brother, Christopher, joined them from the dining room that she realized why she’d never seen them before. 
“Hey, Chris.” Jess watched as Tina sauntered over with Nicole, Vickie, Katie, and Jane, who were all giggling, seemingly excited that Tina gave them automatic access to the only college boys at the party. Before Jess could continue listening in, one of Christopher’s friends took notice of her, giving her a look that quickly made her uncomfortable. She turned around to face Steve, causing him to stop. 
“You okay, kid?” 
“Yeah, yeah it’s just, the kitchen looks packed, you know…” Steve looked past her, shrugging his shoulders as he looked into what seemed to be the most open part of the house.
Billy, however, looked where Jess had earlier, taking notice of the older group by the fridge. “You want anything outta there, princess?” He asked without taking his eyes off the cluster of boys. The question made Steve’s eyes roll, but he didn’t interject, allowing Jess to place her request. When he walked past the kitchen island to retrieve a red cup, he caught the attention of Jane, who quickly left the now large group she was in to stride her way over to him. 
“Hey there, Hargrove.” Jane leaned into him slightly, eyeing the drink that he now had in his hand with amusement. “That for me? Because that’s definitely not for you.” 
Billy looked down at the cup as well before laughing coldly, the corners of his mouth pulling downwards. “And why not?” The sarcasm dripped from his question, causing Jane to lean away, not sure if this banter was the friendly kind. 
“Because I know what you actually want.” 
Billy picked up on her tone, clearly expressing she was no longer talking about beer. “Yeah, I doubt that,” He deadpanned, not breaking eye contact as he watched her expression change from confident to irritated in a matter of seconds. 
“Really? Because that’s not the impression I got before break.” She batted her lashes ironically, challenging him on his not-so-new attitude towards her. He finally broke the staring, walking himself to the fridge that was still being crowded around. He pushed past the boys, not troubling himself to ask them to move as he bumped shoulders with the one now chatting up Nicole. To his dismay, she had followed him. He turned around to see her crossing her arms over her chest, almost as if she was triumphantly looking at the can he now had. “What did I tell ya, knew exactly what you’d be going for.”
“Don’t you got some desperate college dude to bug?” He asked rather loudly, still unbothered by the fact that said college boys were gathered around behind him. Billy heard one of them mumble something behind his back but didn’t budge to look behind him, as he felt he’d made his point perfectly clear. 
Jane looked over at the group he came in with, scoffing when her eyes met the back of Steve’s head, watching who he was talking to. “I didn’t know you were friends with Steve Harrington now.” When Billy only rolled his eyes in response, about ready to walk away, she poked at him once more, successfully stopping him in his tracks. “So, what you’re saying is you’d rather hang with Harrington and his little prude all night than have some actual fun, Hargrove?”
Billy scrunched his nose in annoyance, his jaw clenching as he heard the nickname Jane spat out. He wanted to retaliate, possibly hurt her feelings to the point where it would have ruined the rest of her night. There were names that were already lined up in his mind that he could call her and could have probably justified even hours later after he possibly felt bad for his actions. But he stood there for a moment, chewing on his tongue behind his closed lips that were contorted into a sneer. He stared off into the crowd, not exactly fixating on one person, refusing to look back at her face which he was sure was now sporting a satisfied grin, knowing it would anger him further. Instead, he cleared his throat and relaxed his jaw before responding with a simple, “Just fuck off, Jane,” not even bothering to finish his sentence before he continued walking back to Jess and Steve. 
Jess listened to Steve talk about the upcoming tournament as she glanced over to Billy, who was now striding toward her with two drinks in hand. Behind him, Jane purposely caught her attention, waving with only her fingers as she eyed the outfit she was in. Jess watched as her eyes landed suddenly on Billy’s jacket, taking a moment before forcing herself to peel them away and walk back toward the rest of her friends. Jess broke into a small smile, causing Steve to stop mid-sentence. “What’s so funny?” 
“Nothing,” Jess quickly responded, her eyes finding their way back to Steve’s. 
“So, Harrington, you hangin’ with us all night?” Billy stood next to the both of them, taking a quick sip out of Jess’s drinking, ensuring it tasted right, before handing it over to her. Steve thought for a moment, looking over at the red cup Jess had in her hand and then to Billy, who was now taking a drink out of his own Beer. 
“You totally can, if you want. It’s no big deal really,” Jess interrupted his thoughts, not wanting him to think that he had to leave. 
“You know what,” He looked over his shoulder to look around the room, “I kinda owe Heather a dance.” He then straightened his neck back to look over Billy intently. He stood there for a moment longer, evidently recalling something from earlier as he stared at Jess’s cup once more, causing him to relax his shoulders slightly. “Don’t have too much fun without me…” He then gave Jess a friendly smile as he backed away, turning to disappear into the crowd. 
Jess continued to look in the direction that she last saw Steve. “Weird…” 
“What? Weird that pretty boy left?” He took another long drink out of his beer, pretending not to even notice his absence, though if he was being honest with himself, he also found it odd as well that Steve had just agreed to leave them alone. He had intended the question to be a joke, fully expecting Steve to follow Jess around all night, not allowing her a single moment alone with him. And again, if he were being honest, he couldn’t really blame him. 
“I mean, he did cancel Benny’s just to be here…”
“Eh, like he said. He owes some girl a dance.” He shrugged it off as he scanned the room, catching Hagen’s attention as he looked toward the back door. 
“Aye! B!” Jess surprisingly was able to hear Tommy shout over the speakers, watching him pull Carol by the hand through the crowd. 
“Jesus, Tommy, slow down…” Carol mumbled as they reached Billy and Jess, pulling her hand away once his grip loosened. “Hey, you two.” 
“Did I just see you with Harrington?” Tommy questioned, not yet greeting Jess. 
“Yeah, what was that all about…” Carol left Tommy’s side and joined Jess, looking back over at her before adding, “No offense,” to the end of her sentence. 
“Nothing important.” 
Carol looked over at Jess, giving her the same look Chrissy always did when it came to Billy. “Well, I think it’s cute that you’re getting along with him now… Anyways. Tommy’s wanting a rematch.”
“I can’t this time. Driving.” Billy then gestured with his can over to Jess, giving her a wink before further explaining. “Gotta take this one home.” 
“Dude, lame.” Tommy groaned, “Why don’t you both just crash here?” 
“Jess has a curfew, remember?” Carol poked fun at her, pinching her cheeks as if she was a child. “It’s fine, the girls will play a round. Does your goody-two-shoes friend drink, like, at all?”
“Chrissy, I mean… yeah… sometimes but-“
“Good, wave goodbye to the boys,” Carol then looped her arm with Jess’s, walking purposefully toward Jason, Chrissy, and Patrick. “Cunningham. Come on, you’re up at beer pong.” 
Chrissy quickly stood at Jess’s side as they made their way to the kitchen. “I’m not very good…” She said apologetically, causing Carol to giggle. 
“Good. You’re on Jess’s team then.”
“You’ll be fine, Chris. Carol’s not very good either.”
“Bite me.” Carol led them away from Jason and Patrick, who were now eyeing the three girls suspiciously, and began making her way to the kitchen, eyeing the group that was still by the fridge. 
“Please don’t ask Jane to play…” Jess groaned, now dragging her feet a bit. 
“Oh god no. She fucking hates you, you know that right? Why would I ask her to play?” 
“Yes, Carol. Thank you. I know.” 
“I wonder why…” Chrissy leaned in, laughing out loud as she watched the way Jane quickly snapped her head over her shoulder as she heard footsteps coming toward her. 
“Tina, let’s play.” Carol unlooped her arm from Jess’s and grabbed Tina’s hand, pulling rather aggressively, only allowing Tina to wave by to a couple of the girls before she was headed out of the kitchen. Jess and Chrissy followed closely behind them as they navigated their way around the maze of teenagers that crowded the living room. When they finally made it outside, Jess saw Tommy and Billy already waiting for them by the table, Billy quickly making his way to Jess to grab the cup out of her hand. 
“Hey! I’m not-“
“Yeah, you’re done with this.” Billy then downed the barely touched drink, crushing the cup when he was done, tossing it toward the opened black bag that was by the ping pong table. “Like I said, I’m not bringing you home completely sloshed.”
“Oh don’t worry, Billy, your girl’s gonna be plenty sloshed when we’re done with her.” Carol then high-fived Tina as they set up their side of the table. “Hurry up and get over here, Logan, I’m tryna win.” 
Billy shook his head, leaning in to whisper in Jess’s ear. “Don’t worry, Tina’s shot’s trash. Played against her on Halloween. Go kick their ass, princess.”
Jess walked over next to Chrissy, who was putting their cups together, occasionally looking up at Tina and Carol’s side to make sure she was doing it right. Out of the corner of her eye, Jess watched as Jason and Patrick joined them by the table, Chrissy giving her boyfriend a shy grin as she waved over to him.
Carol let Chrissy start the game, teasing them by stating how it didn’t matter, and how she and Tina were going to win anyway. Their game went on for what felt like forever, most of their shots bouncing out of cups or missing them completely. Eventually, Steve wandered into the backyard as well, stopping by the table to watch. Once a little over half of the cups were gone, Jess looked over at Chrissy, who was now continuously bumping into her, giggling uncontrollably as she apologized each time. 
“I think Chris might be done,” Jess mentioned, watching as her friend took her time to grasp the ball and aim. 
“No! I’m fine… I just don’t drink a lot,” she continued to giggle, looking over at Jason as he started walking over to her. 
“Don’t get too wasted now.” Jason was now over, counting the cups on her side of the table. “You still got boutta hour to midnight.” 
“Okay okay, fine.” She tossed the ball haphazardly to Jason, who quickly shot his hand up to catch it, not expecting the toss. “You play then.”
“Hey, that means we win.” Carol pointed out, counting how many cups each team had left. “Logan, if she quits, we win!”
“Okay, fine, Carol, you win.” Jess gave in, causing both Tina and Carol to cheer, once again high-fiving each other. 
“What happened to kicking their ass, Logan?” Billy teased, watching her walk back to the side of the table. 
“Yeah, well, Tina had a better shot than you said.”
“Hey!” Tina overheard, crossing her arms as she stared down Billy. 
Jason still held the small ball, bouncing it off the table and catching it with his opposite hand. “You wanna finish this out, Patrick?” 
When he agreed, Tommy jumped in as well, “I’ll take other side. C’mon, B, jump in. We only got like… six cups left.” 
Billy nodded his head slowly, counting the cups himself, convinced he’d only have to drink a couple of them before he and Hagen won. “I ain’t playin’ another one after.” He then threw his now empty beer can in the trash bag that lay on the grass, its contents spilled out around it. “Watch how it’s done, princess.” He walked to Tommy’s side, Steve now taking his place by Jess. 
“Watch how it’s done, princess,” Steve mocked quietly, earning him a punch in the arm. “Good thing you’re staying another three hours. Those guys are good.” He nodded his head to Jason and Patrick before continuing, “No way he’s not downing all three of his.”
“Yeah right… Jason and Patrick only have four left. No way.”
“Oh yeah, well so do Hargrove and Hagen now.” 
Jess shot her attention back to the game, realizing that both Jason and Patrick must have made it in one, Jason now aiming the ball again. When he sank his second shot in the cup nearest Billy, Tommy pounded on the table, watching his friend down his second beer already. “Shit, shit…” The game was over quickly, with Billy only making one shot before the other four cups on his side were gone. 
“What happened to showing me how it was done, Hargrove?” 
“How the hell could I have known that the lightweight’s boyfriend could actually pl- owww.”
“Don’t call her that!”
“You look over at her recently?” 
He nodded his head toward the ground where Chrissy was sitting, looking up at the stars. Jason walked over to her, helping her up as she finally fixed her eyes on him. “Did you win?” 
Jason only laughed at her, leading her back inside so she could sit on the couch. “This is why you don’t play beer pong, baby.” He sat her down on the right side of the living room couch, plopping down next to her as she leaned against the armrest. Billy and Jess followed, Steve close behind them as they entered the house, all three sitting on the loveseat opposite the couch. It was a slightly tight squeeze for the three of them, causing Jess to be partially on Billy’s lap, something he didn’t mind at all. The close proximity caused her to take off Billy’s jacket, which Billy quickly took from her, draping it over the leg she currently wasn’t sitting on. 
Tina, Tommy, and Carol soon entered through the backdoor as well, making Jason scoot closer to Chrissy as they too squeezed to sit on the couch, Carol sitting completely on top of Tommy. Unfortunately, with Tina now sitting with them, the rest of her friends came as well, the college boys following closely behind them. Jess quickly felt eyes on her, and this time, it wasn’t Jane’s stare that caused her to feel uncomfortable. 
Jess nodded back at Tina’s brother, who sat on the floor in front of his sister after wordlessly greeting her. That’s when Jess noticed the same boy from earlier in the kitchen, seemingly more confident now, whether it be from alcohol or from the fact that he realized his friend was acquaintances with Jess. He eyed her noticeably, going out of his way to sit on part of the floor closer to the loveseat, grinning at her once again before pretending to listen to a conversation that was taking place on the couch. On his third attempt of getting Jess’s attention, Billy noticed, causing him to grit his teeth before releasing his jaw again, not wanting his annoyance to be obvious. He then looked over at Jess, attempting to gauge her interest. When she looked as if she were about to crawl out of her skin, he threw his arm around the back of her shoulders, leaning back into the cushions as if trying to convince his body to relax. 
He squeezed her shoulder gently, reassuring her that he was there, to not worry about the creep that happened to be there. Billy didn’t care to know the dude, didn’t care to know his intentions. His longing looks at a high schooler were enough to profile him as a weirdo that he couldn’t wait to get Jess away from. Based on the amount of alcohol at this party, he assumed this man was at least legal drinking age, knowing his friend, Tina’s brother, was 21 as well. Billy leaned down to whisper in Jess’s ear, still not taking his eyes off the only non-teenagers there. 
“You want anything outta the kitchen, princess?”
“It’s okay…” Jess answered quietly, seemingly able to read his mind, “Don’t worry about it… I’m sure they’ll leave.” She traced Billy’s gaze to the same guy still looking over at her, making her quickly look away. It took every ounce of patience in Billy to not call it out, to not pull him up by his collar, hitting him continuously until he fell back down on the floor. But it was only a look, he kept telling himself. He couldn’t risk looking crazy in front of Jess, or worse, embarrassing her in front of their whole class due to just a look. After another ten minutes of attempting to be interested in conversation, however, he kept glancing down at the college boy, apparently named Dennis.
Stupid fucking name.
Dennis had also continued to do the same to both him and Jess, looking between the two of them before staring at Jess for an unwanted amount of time, his eyes appearing to forget that she, too, was a person. Against Billy’s better judgment, he looked over at Steve before looking back at Jess. 
“I need a drink,” He said before whispering in Jess’s ear, “Stay with Steve, I’ll be back in a bit with some water for you, yeah?” He then got up and left Jess’s side, making sure to leave his jacket by her, using it to claim his spot. Jess watched as he disappeared into the crowd, spotting the way he would turn his head back over in their direction occasionally, jaw clenching every time he did. When she could no longer see him, she scooted herself closer to Steve, hoping that would save her from Dennis wanting to socialize with her in any way. It seemed to work for a moment, but she began to grow nervous when Billy had yet to show back up after a few minutes away. Dennis obviously had taken notice as well, scrutinizing the leather jacket that was placed in his way. 
Jess stayed as small as she could, refusing to make eye contact with anyone, until someone within the crowd shouted, “TWO MINUTES TILL MIDNIGHT!” Everyone began cheering, most of the group that was sitting began to stand, awaiting the anticipated countdown. It looked as if Dennis was lost in the crowd, making Jess relax for a moment, only to become on edge again when she felt an unfamiliar hand grab her wrist. 
“Hey,” Jess turned around to see Dennis now standing in front of her, much too close for her liking. “So where you gonna be at midnight?” She could unmistakably smell vodka on his breath, which made her stomach churn, it smelling much less pleasant than the slight smell of hops Billy would have after he would drink. 
She tried pulling away softly, but when his grip didn’t loosen, she panicked, looking back at Steve for help. “Sorry, I’m just gonna hang out with some friends…” She responded, still looking over at Steve who quickly arrived next to her. 
“Hang out with me instead.” He retorted confidently, not caring who was currently next to her. 
“Uhm no I-“
“She’s not interested, bud,” Steve quickly butted in, now directing his attention toward Jess, pulling her arm away, “C’mon kid, let’s go.” 
Jess eagerly began following him away until she was again stopped by the same unfamiliar hand, Dennis’s other hand nudging Steve away. “How about she tell me she’s not interested.” Jess felt her blood run cold, looking at the difference in stature between her friend and the unwanted college boy, who stood taller and broader than Steve did. However, it didn’t deter Steve from pushing back, much harder than Dennis had pushed him. 
“Let go of her, or else.” Steve was now in Dennis’s face, causing Christopher to come over, trying to defuse the situation. 
“Come on, Den, let’s get outta here…” Tina’s brother attempted to whisper, trying to take his friend’s hand from around Jess’s wrist. Jess continued to watch the way the older boy’s eyes faded in and out, clearly intoxicated, and furious. She tried to free her arm once again, but was much weaker than the stocky brunette, when suddenly someone grabbed Christopher’s shirt, quickly pulling him away from Dennis, Billy now standing in his place. Jess then felt a slight pinch in her wrist, hurting only for a moment, realizing after that her hand was suddenly free from Dennis’s grasp and secured softly in Billy’s. He then let go slowly, pointing over to Steve without taking his eyes off Dennis. Jess did as she was wordlessly told, making her way back to Steve’s side. She had never seen him this inflamed, his eyes wide and wild, his jaw ticking with anger. Everyone else besides a select few had yet to notice what was going on around them, continuing to count down, which almost drowned out what Billy said next. 
“You wanna explain why you’re touching my girl?” 
She wasn’t sure if she had heard it correctly, or sure if she, or anyone besides Dennis, was meant to hear it, but she was sure she would have been blushing currently if it wasn’t for the situation they were in. 
“FIVE!”
She watched the way Billy was now shaking out his wrists, occasionally clenching and unclenching his hands into fists, stretching out his fingers when they were released. She’s seen this movement from him only once before, and it didn’t turn out so good for the other boy he was facing that night. 
“FOUR!”
Billy patiently waited for a response, Dennis coming up with one he wasn’t expecting. The older boy chuckled at him, looking back over at Jess before saying, “Didn’t seem like your girl when I was talkin’ to her.”
“THREE!”
Billy’s expression slowly changed from enraged to feigned amusement, smiling maliciously before he chuckled back, scrunching up his nose as he did so. He continued to stare at him, nodding wordlessly before running his tongue along his top row of teeth. 
“TWO!”
Steve seemed to recognize this look as well, taking a step forward to get ready to shield Jess if needed, but still not obstructing her view. She then watched as Billy took one last look over at her, the same smile still there, but his mouth now closed. However, his eyes had a different look, almost apologetic in a way, before he turned back his attention to the creep in front of him. 
“ONE!”
“Yeah... Don’t worry though, I’ll make sure to show her a good ti-“
“HAPPY NEW YEAR!”
Dennis’s snide comment was quickly interrupted by a fist to the mouth, causing everyone in the vicinity to back away, some staring wide-eyed, others now cheering. Despite Dennis being slightly taller and wider than Billy, he didn’t seem to be able to stand up to the younger teen, who was relentlessly throwing punch after punch, not stopping until one of Dennis’s other friends jabbed Billy in the gut. Jess watched the way Billy winced in pain, now turning his attention to the other boy. When she saw Dennis standing up again, now squaring up to take an unfair punch, Jess almost screamed at Billy to turn around, but Steve stopped her as he pushed her back against the crowd softly. 
“Awe fuck,” Steve mumbled before quickly walking up to the other boy, grabbing his collar before shouting, “Hey!” He then swung his arm back, punching him so hard the boy’s cap flew off. Billy glanced over at Steve briefly, surprised at the sudden help. He then nodded at Steve before turning his attention back over to Dennis. Just when both Billy and Steve seemed to be holding their own, Steve taking on a few more punches than Billy, two other college boys stepped up, Christopher being one of them, who was now also swinging at Billy with Dennis. Jess could hardly keep track of the two boys she came with, watching helplessly as both of them disappeared in the middle of the four older ones. Jason and Patrick, however, emerged from the crowd, trying to pull the other boys off Steve and Billy. Jess watched as Jason grabbed for Christopher, who quickly turned and clocked Jason in the jaw, taking him aback only for a moment before he tackled Tina’s brother to the ground. The fighting went on for only moments more until Jess suddenly saw Billy grab for Dennis’s legs, swiftly lifting him and slamming him into Tina’s coffee table, the legs buckling and center cracking from the weight. 
“ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?!” Tina’s voice could be heard over everyone’s cheering, which quickly stopped once she screamed. “MY PARENTS ARE GONNA FREAK!!” Billy slowly rose from the top of Dennis, dusting his legs off before straightening back up, grimacing in pain as he did. Jason and Patrick both helped Steve off the floor who was now sporting a bloody nose. Billy simply stared at Dennis as he pitifully rolled off the now broken table onto his hands and knees, having a hard time getting back on his feet. Chrissy was now at Jess’s side, holding her hand in anticipation as she looked over at her boyfriend, who was also holding onto his own nose, blood dripping from his hand. However, Jess overlooked Jason’s or Patrick’s injuries, her worried gaze leaving Steve and now focusing on Billy, who now had a bruise forming on his cheek, his bottom lip cut. He had yet to look over at her, his eyes still fixed on the boy on the floor almost as if he was challenging him to get back up. He didn’t even flinch or look over when Tina began to yell again next to him. 
“All of you!” She then pointed at all the boys but her brother, “OUT!” 
Jason began trying to speak up, “C’mon Tina, they-“
“I said GET OUT!” 
Jason ran his hand over his face, flicking blood off, walking toward Chrissy, grabbing her hand with his unbloodied one, then nodding at Jess. “Let’s get out of here.” He then looked at the older boys in disgust as he led the girls to the front door, Patrick already out in the front yard. Billy swiped his jacket from the couch, looking back unsatisfied at Dennis one last time before turning and leaving as well, gesturing at Steve to follow him. Billy quickly caught up to Jess, staying close behind her. She could hear how rapidly he was breathing, making her look back at him, causing him to lock eyes with her before he placed his hand on the small of her back, telling her to keep moving. When they finally reached the concrete step that separated the communal sidewalk from the path leading up to Tina’s doorway, all four boys plopped down to sit, looking exhausted. Jess was the first to speak. 
“I’m so sorry guys I-“ 
“Don’t you dare fuckin’ apologize.” Billy stopped her, shaking his head as he stared blankly across the street. 
“Yeah, it’s not your fault, Jess.” Steve agreed, flashing her a sympathetic smile. “You alright?”
Before Jess could answer, however, Billy snapped his head in Jess’s direction, his eyes coming back into focus. “Let me see it,” he demanded, his voice lower in register.
“What?” Jess looked back at him now, confused at what exactly he was requesting. 
“Your wrist. Let me see it.” He held out his hand, figuring she would automatically comply, placing her hand into his, allowing him to examine it carefully as he intended. When she didn’t make a move to do so, his eyes darkened. “Jess…” 
The wrist in question was tucked securely under her blue sleeve, her fingers grasping the fabric against her palm tightly. She had yet to look at it either, but she was sure there was at least a red mark, based on how tight the older boy had ahold of it and how promptly Billy removed his grip when he saw it. She had just watched Billy calm down a bit, and she wasn’t too keen on seeing his rage spike back up. 
“You alright, kid?” Steve now reached for it, the wrist being closer to him than it was to Billy, but she moved it out of easy reach. 
“You guys are freaking out over nothing, it’s fine.” 
“Then let me see it,” Billy spoke again, his voice attempting to hold steady, not wanting Jess to mistake his anger as being directed at her.
“I’ll let you see it when we get out of here…” Jess softly responded, causing Billy to rise from his concrete seat next to Steve, his leather jacket still in hand. “Billy…” He said nothing in response, draping the jacket over Jess’s shoulders before gently reaching for her left wrist, raising it close to his chest before pushing her sleeve out of the way. Jess was surprised to see bruised lines forming in the shape of fingers. They were light, but certainly there. She then looked up at Billy, who was contorting his mouth in an angered frown, looking over her shoulder and then back at her wrist, as if trying to adjust his eyesight to ensure he was seeing this right. 
“Ga’damn,” Patrick now stood next to her, peering over to see the bruises. “That’s fucked, Logan.”
Jess’s eyes moved in his direction in annoyance, indicating he wasn’t helping any, Patrick throwing up his hands in response. Billy still had yet to say a thing, still adjusting his eyesight away from her wrist, only to find himself looking at it again, becoming more unwound with every glance. When he couldn’t keep looking at it, he turned to face Tina’s front door, his chest now heaving. 
“Billy no,” Jess said suddenly, not knowing whether he was thinking about going back in to find Dennis again or not. 
Steve must have felt the tension as well, also rising from the step, looking down at Jess’s wrist once, cringing at the sight of it. “C’mon man, let’s just leave.”
“And go where? Our rides are still inside.” Jason finally spoke up, still sitting as Chrissy stood over him, her hands secured in his, him not wanting to let go of her just yet. 
“You guys didn’t drive here?” Jess asked, looking over at Steve who typically always took his car. 
“Not this time.” 
“Awe shit…” Patrick cursed, sitting himself back down next to Jason.
“I can’t go back home now, my mom’s gonna flip if she sees blood all over me, gotta at least get this shit off me,” Jason groaned, Patrick quickly agreeing with him. 
“We could always go back to Benny’s like we planned?” Chrissy suggested, now trying to rub some of the blood off his cheeks. 
“With what car, babe?”
Jess gave Billy an inquiring look, practically asking permission before she mentioned his car out loud. 
“Can’t drive yet, princess… thought we’d be here for another two hours.”
“Steve’s sober,” she quickly responded.
He glanced over at Steve, now standing awkwardly next to the two of them, before shaking his head. “Hell no.”
“C’mon, Billy. You wanna sit here the rest of the night? Let’s go to Benny’s, you guys wash up, let the rest of your buzz go ‘way in the next couple hours.” When he didn’t budge, she added, “He’s a really good driver…” causing Billy to roll his eyes. 
Jason and Patrick looked up hopefully at Billy, wanting to get out of there as soon as possible as other classmates were now starting to come outside to ‘mingle’, making sure to continue to stare at the banished group. “There’s not ‘nuff seats, and the back’s small as shit.”
“It’s cool, Chris will sit on my lap, Jess and Pat can sit in the back with us, you get front since it’s your car. No big deal.”
Billy stood there for a moment, considering everything he heard before wordlessly tossing his keys to Steve. He then walked ahead of them, a little peeved this was how his night was ending, with a busted lip, a bruised ego, a ruined buzz, Steve fucking Harrington now driving his prized possession, and worst of all, it was his first real night out with Jess.
“Fuckin’ perfect,” He mumbled under his breath, “Just great.”
When they finally reached his car, he stood by the passenger door, eyeing Steve with warning. “If you put a single scratch on her, you’re dead.” He then threw the seat in the upright position, moving out of the way so Jess could squeeze in the middle. Steve did the same, Jason moving into the back seat behind the driver’s side, positioning himself before outstretching his hand to help Chrissy onto his lap. When Patrick began to enter behind Jess, Billy suddenly stopped him, grabbing him by the shirt and tugging backward before mumbling, “You take front.” 
Jess smiled when she saw Billy enter, pushing herself over into Jason more to try and make room for him. When he was semi-comfortable, he adjusted the seat back to allow Patrick to sit, leaning back after to try and relax. However, the tight fit made that difficult, not having much room for his legs. He stretched his left arm behind Jess, shifting every two seconds. “Ah shit…”
“Here, you want me to…” Jess then tried scooting her leg out of the way to allow Billy’s leg more room in the middle. 
After a few more failed attempts to sit comfortably, Billy grumbled in irritation. “Fuck it. C’mere.” He then grabbed Jess by the hips and effortlessly positioned her on his right leg, her back now facing the small triangle window. He placed his right arm in between her and the door, providing her back with more support, shifting lower so her head wasn’t rubbing against the ceiling. Her legs dangled in between Billy’s, which were now comfortably spread. “This alright?” He whispered in her ear. 
She began to nod when Steve entered the car, looking behind him. “You guys okay back th- … ere.” His eyes fixed on Jess and Billy, giving them both a disapproving stare. However, it only lasted for a moment before he turned back around, turning the ignition. He then readjusted the rearview mirror so Jess was able to see his eyes clearly. “Ready to go then? You guys… situated?”
“Ready when you are, Harrington,” Jason grinned, squeezing Chrissy’s thigh as he winked at her playfully. 
“Jess?” Steve questioned, glancing back at her through the mirror. 
“Uh y-up! Ready!” 
Steve nodded, appearing to relax as he accepted her response, again adjusting the mirror so he could see the road behind him.
“Let’s get the hell outta here then.”
Taglist: @nix-rose @fandom-princess-forevermore @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo @axionn @defenslessheart-main @the-lost-are-ignored @ahoyyharrington @strawberrykittey
49 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 2 months
Text
Not my video from tiktok, credit to the original creator.
He's constantly telling people Max isn't his sister then, when he thinks she's in danger (in a stranger's house with an almost grown ass man), "I'm looking for my stepSISTER" my thirteen year old SISTER.
He loves her. Just saying.
2 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 2 months
Note
Would you ever roleplay Billy?
I’ve actually been asked this before! And honestly probably not. Don’t think I’d be any good at it. I’ve only ever role played in a DND/Pathfinder/Shadowrun setting but that’s always with characters I’ve made myself
0 notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 2 months
Text
Omg I LOVE that I’ve been able to turn you on to an OC fic!! To be completely honest this was supposed to be a Billy x reader fic originally but she def needed a name for what may very well be a 25-30 chapter fic.
YOU ARE THE SWEETEST THO ILYSM you’ve fr been one of my number 1 fans for forever 🤍🤍
Prove Me Wrong
Chapter 16: Same
If you need to catch up, here's the masterlist
Tumblr media
Summary: Billy convinces Jess to go out New Year's Eve
Word Count: 9k (sorry)
Warnings: Cursing. Fluff, cuddling, Billy is kinda OOC if you squint. Little bit of angst. As always let me know if I missed anything. Also, not exactly proof read
AN: I had to break this chapter up because I didn't realize I made this chapter like 20k words. So. It's now in two chapters. (Which is also why it took me longer to release this than I thought it would LOL)
“Let me take you to Tina’s party.” Billy continued to look at the screen while Friday the 13th: Part 2 played. They had the whole house to themselves, as Jess’s parents were currently on their scheduled date night, allowing them both to be much louder than they would normally be at 12 AM. Their homework was sprawled across Jess’s bed, untouched beside them taking the materials out of their bags. 
“But Steve isn’t going, and I don’t think Chris is either… so I’m gonna have no one to talk to-“ 
Billy gave Jess an annoyed, stern look. “Jess.”
“Well, if you would have let me finish, I was going to say, I’d have no one to talk to if you decided to do your own thing.” 
“I’m not gonna ditch you.” 
“Okay.”
“Did I last time?”
“That was different,” Jess explained, “If you did end up ditching me that night, I would have had other people to actually hang out with.”
“You’re missing my point. Point is. I didn’t. And I won’t.” Billy paused a moment to look back over at the screen, thinking about whether he should say the next part. “Hagen said you used to hang with everyone that came to those things.” 
“So you do still talk about me,” Jess teased. 
“Not like that. …What happened?”  
“It’s not like they were really my friends. They were Steve’s friends. I just kinda… became friends by association. I thought I was so cool being one of the only freshmen at those things back then, I just wanted to be around everyone, be friends with everyone, and then last year… perspectives change… I guess.”
“You wanna do something else then? New Year’s Eve?” 
Jess looked over at him, laughing in response. “I’m not gonna make you ditch a party because I don’t wanna go.” 
“Eh,” Billy repositioned himself against the headboard, squaring himself up to better look at the TV now, “Might be lame anyways.” When he didn’t get a response from her, he continued, still pretending to watch the camp counselors on the screen dance in the current cabin they were in. “What were you gonna do then?” 
Jess shrugged.  “Just stay home. Catch us up on some homework since we’ve been pretty bad about it. You know we start school again on the fourth right?” 
“Okay… Just ditch the homework tomorrow night, and I’ll be by first thing next morning to help, alright? What, we got…” Billy picked up their shared reading for the first time that night and flipped through what they needed to read “Jesus… Okay. So I’ll be here the first and second, and the third we can write the essay and boom. Done.”
“You have work on the third.”
“And? I’ll come by after. No big deal.” 
“All so we can go to one party that might be lame.”
“Come on. Do something without pretty boy for a change.” Billy spoke his nickname for Steve with less malice than he usually did, catching Jess’s attention. 
“If you ditch me, I swear…”
“I’m not gonna ditch you. We have a deal? Party tomorrow?”
Jess huffed, looking away from Billy and back toward the TV screen. “Party tomorrow.” 
Billy turned toward Jess again, smiling at her deviously. He nudged her, causing her to sway back and forth, her shoulders rubbing against her headboard as she returned the same smile. “You’re excited.” 
“Oh yeah, keep telling yourself that, Hargrove.”
“Admit it, you have more fun with me than you do with Harrington.” Billy had started to become much bolder recently. Ever since that day in the arcade parking lot, he had felt more confident in where he stood with her. He continued to tease her more often, knocked on her windowpane even more frequently, allowed her more time behind the wheel of his car where he would purposefully take hold of her hand. He continued to watch as she shook her head, knowing it was a joke but wishing it had some truth behind it for her. 
“Steve is a lot more fun than you.” 
“Really?” He began to look around the room, pretending as if he was looking for something he couldn’t see. He then turned back to her smugly, clearing his throat as he eyed her up and down. “So why am I the only one here then?” 
“We- I …” Jess stuttered over her words, his confident statement obviously catching her off guard, making Billy smirk with satisfaction. She rolled her eyes at his smugness and decided to retaliate. “Because he doesn’t bug me as much as you do, and never knocks on my window unannounced,” She teased, again returning the same smug grin he was giving her.
“I guess that just means I like you more than Steve does.” 
Jess scrunched her eyebrows but released them quickly, looking down at her lap to avoid the look he was now giving her, the same look he had been giving her every day since she had gone to apologize. It would mostly come spontaneously. Sometimes it would happen when he would lightly graze the golden necklace she now wore every day, sometimes it would be when they would interrupt the movie they were watching to have random conversations, other times it would be in the middle of a bite she was taking of her Big Al burger, which would cause her to stop eating abruptly. But there was always a time when she could expect to be looked at like that. 
It was an unfailing constant for them now, Jess waiting by her window around 10 at night, Billy knocking shortly after. Her blinds would already be drawn in anticipation; all she ever had to do was pull the window up, letting the cold wind blow his familiar smell back into her room. And every night without fail, Billy would look at her as if she could push him from that roof ledge and he would devotedly scale the side of her house again. But in the same look, he also conveyed how he knew she could never do that. 
Not her. 
Even on the coldest nights, he would arrive with his jacket in hand, or not even with him at all. He knew the longest part of his journey to her room would be the short jog there, as now knocking was just a formality. She would see him before he would even reach her driveway and would have the window open as soon as his knuckles struck the glass for the first time, greeting him with the same reserved smile she always held when he made her nervous. 
“Yeah right. You just like hanging with me because I’m getting you a ‘B+’ in English.” Her rebuttal was enough to make his look shift back to his usual, playful one, one that didn’t involve her heart fluttering at the sight of it. 
“I won’t say that doesn’t have somethin’ to do with it.” Billy clicked his tongue as his eyes traveled down her body and back toward their assignments. “You make studying bearable.” 
Instead of leaving the conversation there, or laughing his comment off, Jess folded her legs towards her and shifted closer to Billy, making sure her body was now facing his. “You know, umm. I’m really glad that uh… I’m glad that Mr. Crowley paired us up together.” 
Jess watched Billy’s smile grow, the glint in his eyes feeling familiar to her. She remembered seeing the same smile in their shared practices when they were made to share the gym, or when she would cheer for the varsity basketball team at their games. This smile was only directed at her once before this, and it was when he had caught her watching him during practice. Correction. Watching him and not watching Harrington.  
His smile was full of pride, a feeling that was hard for Billy to contain when he ever had a dose of it, for it was typically stripped away the second he would walk through his front door.  And despite being appointed the new keg king or possibly even the new king of Hawkins High, he rarely ever felt this. It was only ever when he was on the court, contributing to a win for whatever team he was currently playing for: this was when he felt so much gratification that he couldn’t contain it.  
Well, until now. 
These past months, it felt to him as if he were playing a game he had no chance of winning, that Jess would eventually forget about him, that he was bothering her too much, that she would never see him as anything more than a means to an end, that Jess counted the days to when she would never have to invite him over again. 
“So I finally won you over, huh? About time. Could only fake nice for so long-“ Jess’s shove was expected, Billy grabbing her wrist before she was able to connect, pulling her even closer to him. “I’m kidding.” Billy’s hand left her wrist, slowly moving its way up her forearm to her elbow, his fingers softly grazing her skin as it did so. “Same.” 
“Same?”
“I feel the same way.” 
The screams coming from the TV weren’t enough to turn either Jess’s or Billy’s attention. Jess allowed her knees to press against Billy’s side, her body becoming less stiff with every second they stayed like this. “Well, again, it’s probably because-“ 
“Fuck the grade, Jess,” Billy swiftly cut off Jess’s teasing, his tone alarmingly firm. 
“What about your scholarship to a fancy California school?” Jess chuckled, attempting to ease the serious note that now filled the room. 
Billy shook his head, breaking the eye contact Jess was now feeling confident enough to hold. He looked over at the TV again for a moment before sighing and looking down at his lap. “Can… can I be honest with you for a sec?” 
“Yeah, of course.” Jess sat up a little straighter, waiting through the long silence to hear what he needed to say. 
“The only reason why I wanted to even go to college was to, you know, get away.” 
“From Hawkins?”
“No… Well,” Billy paused for a moment again, looking around at the random memorabilia displayed throughout Jess’s room, “Okay yeah, maybe get away from Hawkins. But mostly, from him.”
Jess nodded in understanding, staying silent and allowing him to continue. 
“And I chose California… cuz… it’s…” Billy continued to struggle with the last part of his sentence, the words not willing to be said out in the open, though he thought them nearly every day. “… It’s where I thought shewould be.”
Jess’s heart ached at the mention of his mom. She had only heard about her a few times from Billy. She knew that she was gentle, loved to bake, and loved the ocean. She also knew that she left Billy. She left him alone with his father. She left when he was young, no more than 10 maybe. She was reminded of that whenever Billy spoke of her. “She would always bake my birthday cakes, but I haven’t had one since she left”. “She used to take me to this beach, but I stopped going to it when she left”. She knew that every amazing memory that he had left of his mother was soiled by the fact that she was now gone, and Billy had no idea where she was or why he wasn’t with her. 
“But now, I just…” He let out a frustrated breath before he finished his thought, not wanting to say it out loud because he wasn’t sure if he fully meant it yet, “Why should I be the one to go out of my way to go where she is?” Billy’s voice began to rise, feeling as though he was now asking himself this question versus speaking to Jess. “I mean, I’m her fuckin’ kid. I’m her-“ Billy stopped his rant immediately when he felt his voice begin to shake, clenching his jaw to ensure he stayed quiet. Jess took this time to grab the hand that Billy had placed gently against her elbow in her hand, brushing the top of his thumb with her own. Billy took his free hand and ran it through his hair haphazardly, looking down at the one Jess now had in hers. “I just don’t feel like I need to now.” Jess watched as he nodded his head, almost as if he was satisfied with his realization.  
“What if you just went to school there because you wanted to? Not because of your mom, or your dad. Just for you?” 
Billy chuckled at the thought of this, shaking his head at her suggestion. “If I was doin’ what I wanted to do, I wouldn’t really be goin’ to school at all. Guess you were right.”
“What do you mean?”
“You acted all surprised the first time I told you I wanted to go to college.” Billy’s lopsided smirk made an appearance again, putting Jess at ease. 
“No I didn’t!” Jess nudged his arm with the top of her shoulder. 
“Aye watch it, I had a shitty practice today and the arm’s sore. And yeah, you did.” 
“Okay, okay, maybe I was a little surprised that you wanted to go, but now that I know you’re a complete math nerd it’s starting to make sense to me.” 
“Aye! No, no, no, watch what you call me now, princess. Plus, I’m not that good at it, you still got the better grade… nerd.” Billy dropped his smile one last time and pushed his arm back against Jess’s, now realizing he was still holding her hand. “Hey, Jess?”
“Hmm?”
“Thanks, you know, for letting me hang here all the time. And for not telling anyone… anything.” 
“Like you said before, you keep some of my secrets, I keep some of yours.” Jess smiled warmly at him, causing him to do the same again. 
“You know what that means?” 
“What’s that, Hargrove?”
“You gotta tell me somethin’ else about you now.” 
“That is not what that means!” 
“Ah c’mon…” Without letting go of her hand, Billy adjusted the pillow that was against his back so he could lie comfortably with his head propped up, allowing himself to still be able to see the movie that they were no longer watching. When Jess had yet to do the same, Billy tugged her hand downward, cocking his head once to indicate she should follow. 
Jess made a move to lay down, careful not to shift her right hand too much to cause Billy to let go. When he did anyway, her heart dropped slightly only for it to jump back up into her throat when she felt the same hand on the small of her back, softly pulling her closer to him. He did it so casually, as if without thinking, like they had been laying like this, with Billy on his back, Jess on her side, using his chest in place of a pillow, for months before now. 
Billy shifted once before he settled, looking at the television set nonchalantly. “Tell me about volleyball.”
“What?” The question caught Jess off guard, causing her to almost forget the current position she was in. 
“That team picture when you were in middle school.” Billy’s head nodded toward the framed photograph he came across his first night having dinner with the Logans. “You never told me why you don’t play anymore. You said you were good.” 
“Just, things happened, I couldn’t play anymore, and chose cheer instead.”
“Anythin’ to do with that shit knee of yours?” Billy always watched the way she would run when they shared the track together, watched as she favored that knee during her last lap. He also watched the way she would land during cartwheels or flips. Even the way she walked, it became obvious to Billy that she would take prolonged steps with her left leg to make up the distance that her right leg couldn’t handle. It wasn’t noticeable, and by no means did she walk with a limp, but over the last couple of months Billy Hargrove made it a point to observe every quirk she had, and this happened to be one of them. 
“Observant aren’t we…” Jess responded sarcastically, “Turns out landing on your knees continuously isn’t good for them. Had to quit.” 
“So that’s how you fucked it up then? You said it wasn’t from cheer.” 
Jess sighed, thinking about her past injury, pausing to remember the excruciating pain that came with it and the heartbreak that followed when she found out she would have to quit any contact sport. “No, it wasn’t even from playing. It was… I fell. I fell on some stairs. It should have never even happened. It was so… so stupid and… You know, volleyball was the one sport I really loved. I didn’t play for long. My mom got me into it when I was in elementary. She was so excited when I tried out for the middle school team and made it. I got to play one season my sixth-grade year, and before regionals, I shattered my kneecap.” 
“Jesus, Jess.”
“When we moved in this house, I had to sleep downstairs for almost a whole year before we could make my room be up here. But by eighth grade, the knee healed and by freshman year, doc said I could ‘participate in physical activity’ again,” Jess mocked the way she remembered her old pediatrician talking to her mother about her knee as if she weren’t in the room listening as well. “I just couldn’t do anything that could cause me to land on my knees hard anytime soon. So volleyball, even with the kneepads, was out of the question, and so was basically any other sport that I could get hurt in. So…” 
“… So that left cheerleading.”
“That left cheerleading…” Jess cleared her throat, looking around her room the best she could at all the cheer posters, Hawkins High flags, photographs of her and her cheer team, photographs of her and Chrissy, and others of her and Steve at his games. “I mean, don’t get me wrong, cheer’s been… it’s been great. I made some of my best friends because I was in cheer.” 
“A lot of them you don’t talk to anymore…” 
“Okay, yeah. But still. It was probably the only reason I made friends in high school in the first place. I was a total loser in middle school.” 
Jess felt Billy’s chest vibrate against her head as he laughed at her statement. “I doubt you were. Thought you were friends with King Steve when you were, like, twelve.” 
“Yeah… but we went to different middle schools. I didn’t transfer to this district till I was in eighth grade, and being the new kid isn’t easy either. Steve was already in high school by the time I transferred.”
“How the hell did you even meet him then?”
“My dad’s friends with his dad. They worked together.” 
“So you cheering at my game next weekend?” Billy shifted the conversation fairly quickly, no longer interested in talking about Steve or his dad in any way. He looked down at Jess, who was still lying on his chest.  Jess shifted her gaze up at him, turning on her stomach so that her chin rested against him now. 
“It depends if coach tells me to. She might make me cheer at the girls’ game again.” 
“Well tell her you wanna go see me play instead.” Billy winked as he said this, making Jess attempt to hold back the smile that was already halfway displayed on her face. 
They laid like this for a while, occasionally shifting to better look at one another when they spoke about something interesting. Jess continuously made excuses in her head throughout their conversations as to why cuddling up next to Billy Hargrove was acceptable friendship behavior, and in no way romantic at all. 
Of course, Jess and Chrissy always laid on each other's shoulders after an away game they went to together, especially if it was a football game, as it would always be a late night getting home. Even she and Steve had a couple of nights where they slept against each other. Sure, it would typically be due to exhaustion from hunting down demidogs all night or waiting for Will Byers to no longer be possessed by the mind flayer. And sure, there was never an instance where Steve ever felt the need to drape his arm along her back, pulling her into him as they lay on the same bed. However, with Billy’s hand against her back, her head securely nuzzled against his chest and arm, she felt a sense of security she hadn’t felt in… well… ever, and it was becoming alarmingly comfortable, so comfortable that she felt the weight of her eyelids as the clock showed it was close to 2 AM. Her mind began to still more and more as she closed her eyes, listening to the sound of Billy talking about the new job he’d be applying for at the Hawkins pool when it opened for the summer. 
“You better come visit me when I get the job.” Billy expected a snide remark, something to do with how shit he’d be as a lifeguard, or maybe something more subtle like ‘if you get the job’, enough to get the point across. When he was met with silence, he looked down. “Earth to Je-“ 
The sight of Jess sound asleep on his chest made him smile softly to himself. He slowly shifted his body downward so that his head was now flat against the pillow he was propped on earlier, making sure she was still secure against him. He slid his free hand underneath his head, looking up at her bedroom ceiling as he listened to her steady breathing. He didn’t turn his head when he saw headlights illuminating Jess’s darkened bedroom. Her parents were now home, but knowing them, they would let Jess sleep through the night, checking in on her in the morning. Billy made no move to turn off her TV which was now again the only source of light in the room. He was sure he’d do that eventually, that he would get up and go to his usual place on the floor, taking the pillow he was lying on with him. He would grab the spare blanket in Jess’s closet, not needing to turn on the closet light since he knew it would be right where he left it this morning. But right now, he stayed, telling himself that he didn’t want to wake her, that she had just fallen asleep, so he would wait. He waited until he heard her parents close their own bedroom door. He waited until he heard her usual, soft snores. He waited until he felt his own eyes become heavy with sleep. And still, he stayed. 
Jess awoke the next morning, her breathing slightly blocked by something unfamiliar against her face. She shifted slowly, tilting her head toward the ceiling to catch more air, her eyes still closed. When she felt whatever it was next to her move, she moved with it, instinctually draping her arm over it to get more comfortable in her sleeping position. It wasn’t until she heard it breathe against her neck that she slowly opened her eyes, confused as to what she was now lying against.  She was met with a simple white T-shirt, which was rolled at the sleeve, revealing what kept her in place. 
Billy’s arm was slung tightly around her, continuing to pull her in anytime one of them moved. Her gaze left his arm and moved to where she thought his face would be. When she didn’t find it through her blurred vision, she felt another breath against the same spot on her neck, which woke her even more. She groaned realizing her back felt tight as she was lying in a position she was not used to, her head resting against the mattress and the headboard. She now felt Billy’s other arm underneath her, his elbow bending on the back side of her body, his forearm pulling her in as well. When she looked down, she found the top of Billy’s head, his face against the crook of her neck. Her eyes began to widen as her surroundings became clearer, her vision no longer fogged by lack of sleep. She felt the numbness of her own arm underneath her and shifted it. Her arm tingled along with her insides as she began to realize this was how she slept. This was how they slept.  She could now feel every breath Billy took, very much aware of how she changed a darker shade of red every time he exhaled.
Oh my fucking god.
She didn’t want to wake him. She wanted nothing more than to just stay there, nuzzle against him, and fall back asleep. But her elevating heart rate wouldn’t allow that to happen. She felt as if her room was now ten degrees warmer, causing her to stir uncomfortably. When she heard Billy groan, however, she stopped her movements suddenly, unsure of how he would react when he realized they were tangled together in her bed. 
“Ah, shit.” Billy shifted his arm which was underneath Jess, pulling her in tighter before letting her go. He propped himself up with his now free hand, the other running through his now slightly messy hair, though to Jess’s surprise, his curls stayed mostly intact throughout the night.  “What time is it?” Billy whispered to himself, and when he looked up at her wall clucked, he realized he was there a little later than he expected. “Fuck.” He finally looked down at Jess, realizing she was already awake. “Shit, princess, sorry. Didn’t mean to wake ya up.” 
How is he so goddamn calm???
Jess continued to look at Billy, completely shell-shocked. When he finally noticed how uncomfortable she looked, he turned away from her, beginning to feel guilty about allowing himself to sleep next to her like that, without her knowing.  “Sorry, I, uh… you fell asleep, and I didn’t wanna wake you up right after. And I, uh.” 
Before Billy could continue his apology, Jess quickly stepped in, “No! No, it’s okay. I mean I’m sorry for just, you know, falling asleep on you like that. My fault. Really…” 
Billy chuckled, biting down on his bottom lip as he looked back over at her. He leaned against her headboard, feeling his back pop, the new sleeping position seemingly having an effect on his body as well. “I didn’t mind it,” He boldly admitted, watching her to see if the confession was too much. 
“Oh, uh… I didn’t… It wasn’t like I did either… just…” 
Billy smiled brightly at her stuttering but interjected when he realized he wouldn’t get a complete sentence from her anytime soon. “Hey, thanks for letting me come over basically every night this break. Kinda saved my ass these past two weeks, you know?”
“Oh yeah, of course.” Jess eagerly accepted the change of topic. “Surprised you’ve been able to sneak away all the time without anyone noticing.” 
“Not like Neil cares where I am during break. He barely cares where I am during school nights.” Billy laughed bitterly at the mention of his father, shifting his jaw with annoyance before turning his attention back to Jess. “So I’ll see you later tonight, right?”
Jess had already forgotten about the invitation she accepted from Billy, and with how she woke up, she was more nervous than ever to go through with it. “Hmm? Oh yeah, yeah. I’ll see you later.” 
“Too late to back out now, Logan.” Billy teased her, as if able to read her mind, something he seemed to be doing a lot of lately. He retrieved his jacket from the floor and shrugged it on. “I’ll be back here at 8, got it? Don’t want your parents all weirded out that I picked you up late or whatever.” With the promise of Mr. Logan not going into work this morning due to the holiday, Billy decided he didn’t need to wait before leaving and opened the windowpane. 
He began to make his way over the window ledge before stopping himself. He looked down at his coat, hesitating slightly before he ripped it back off and tossed it on her bed. He then looked away toward his own home. “Wear that tonight, it’s gonna be cold and you don’t have shit for jackets.” Before she could protest, he climbed out of her room, looking back at her one last time. “See you later, gorgeous.” 
As promised, Jess heard the doorbell ring throughout the house at 8 pm sharp. Before meeting Billy downstairs, she held his jacket, looking at the one she was planning to wear before on her bed. She had spent the majority of the afternoon thinking about waking up next to him, Billy pulling her down into him last night, and then how she had watched him throw his leather jacket down on her bed, requesting she have it on tonight. She didn’t understand his reasoning, however. She had plenty of jackets. Sure, a lot of them were dainty, and some were thin, but she still had warm ones, she planned on wearing a warm one even tonight. 
She placed Billy’s jacket over her shoulders, draping it delicately like a blanket, and looked at herself in her dresser mirror. Her blue, cut-off sweatshirt was now covered by the brown leather coat, the same one that was left at her house by accident, and the same one she refused to wear to school. She felt a slight pain in her chest, causing her to second guess whether she should actually oblige and wear it this time, or go with her simple jean jacket instead, the one that was already spread out neatly on her bed. When she anxiously rubbed her hand against her collarbone, she felt the golden chain, her fingertips following it to the horse charm at the end. She hated the way she smiled like an idiot anytime she thought about where it came from. But she did without fail this time as well, holding it in between her index finger and thumb, placing it back gently against her skin when she was again calm. She took one step back, taking in the entirety of her outfit, realizing how much it fit, having the necklace he gave her for Christmas, combined with a jacket that was unmistakably Billy’s. She smiled at her image one last time, lifting her hands from underneath the jacket to both ends of the collar to bring them closer together. 
“Hey hun, I think Steve’s at the door… What time is your party going till?” Jess’s mom quickly turned her attention toward the stairs when she heard her daughter’s footsteps. 
“Oh, uh… Steve isn’t actually going to this party, he’s doing something else tonight.”
Before her mother could question her further, Jess rushed to the front door and revealed Billy, wearing a burgundy button-down, with many of those buttons not buttoned down. She cleared her throat as her eyes tore away from his bare chest, remembering the position she woke up in only hours before this. 
Billy casually eyed her up and down, not caring to hide it, his eyes stopping at the leather coat. “Hey there, gorgeous.” He smirked down at her, visibly pleased with what she had on. 
“Billy?” Jess heard her father’s voice from behind her. “What are you doing here, son?”
Billy squinted quizzically at Jess and then aimed his attention at his father, not knowing how to start. “I, uh, she didn’t say…?” 
“I told you, Dad, I’m going to a New Year’s Eve party…” 
“Well, is Steve not going to the same party?” Mr. Logan began questioning her, crossing his arms interrogatively, “You normally go with Steve.” 
“No, Dad, he’s not…”
“I see… So who’s all going to be there then, Jess?” 
Before either Billy or Jess could respond, Mrs. Logan left the counter she was leaning against and walked to her husband’s side. “Oh Stan, stop it… Billy will make sure she’s back safe, won’t you Billy?” 
“Uh, yeah… yeah for sure.” Billy started stumbling over his words even more, which was something new Jess was experiencing, and though he was responding to Jess’s mother, his eyes stayed fixed on her father, who was nodding at Billy’s response. 
“So can we go now please, without you being all weird.” 
“Yes… you can go. But you remember curfew still applies…” Stan started to turn his attention back to Billy when his head snapped back to Jess, his eyes focused on the jacket she was wearing. “Is that… mine?” Mr. Logan grabbed the sleeve, raising it and dropping it again, it uselessly flopping against the rest of the leather. 
Billy couldn’t help but chuckle, his gaze dropping to the carpeted floor he was currently standing on. He quickly covered it with a cough, however, when he heard Jess begin to object. 
“What? No, Dad, it’s not yours…”
“Well it’s definitely not yours.” 
“Stan, I think it’s time the kids go, we’ve been keeping them long enough, don’t you think? Jess, you’ll be home by 2, don’t forget.” Mrs. Logan patted her husband lightly on the chest, shooing the two of them away back toward their master bedroom. She looked back and winked at her daughter, causing Jess to groan at the embarrassment she just had to endure. 
“There’s no way that jacket’s hers,” She heard her dad mumble as she quickly rushed Billy out the door, locking the handle before closing it. 
“Jeez, Jess, you couldn’t have told your parents I was coming to get you?” Billy walked to the passenger door of his car, opening it for Jess despite how annoyed he seemed with her. 
“I didn’t think it was a big deal. I told them I was going to a party…” Once Jess responded, Billy slammed the door, quickly walking around the hood and opening his own door. 
“Now I look like a total ass picking you up late at night without you telling your dad first. Jesus.” Billy turned the key in the ignition aggressively, running his other hand through his hair. “And is Steve the only person that has ever taken you anywhere?”
Jess couldn’t help but laugh at Billy’s annoyance. “Billy, you don’t look like an ass. Besides, my parents like you. For whatever reason.”
“The hell is that supposed to mean?”
“I’m just saying, my dad is pretty good at reading people.” 
“What the hell is that supposed to mean?!”
Jess giggled once more, “It’s just that you do have a reputation at Hawkins already, you know. That whole, ‘bad boy’ yada yada thing you got goin’.” 
“I do not.” 
“You definitely do, and you know it.” 
“Shut up and tell me where we’re eating, Logan.” 
Billy quickly pulled into Big Al’s, ordering Jess to not open her door. When her door was opened for her, she swung her legs out of the car and smiled teasingly up at Billy. “Look who’s getting better at being a gentleman.”
“Yeah, yeah, get out.” 
“Don’t be grumpy, Hargrove,” Jess responded, grabbing the hand he had outstretched for her and pulling herself up and out of the cockpit. “Like I said, they adore you. Stop being all freaked out. Besides, since when did you care about what my parents thought of you? You were literally flirting with my mother the first time you came over.” 
Billy grimaced at the last sentence, remembering the argument they had about that incident directly after up in her room. “Yeah, well. Like I said. I’m over there enough. Would be nice if they didn’t hate me.” Billy had yet to let go of her hand, leading her to the door of the restaurant, being sure to allow her inside first, him following closely behind. He finally dropped her hand slowly when they were inside, helping himself to two of the menus that were on the podium and leading Jess to a larger booth. 
It was surprisingly busy inside for the night it was. But apparently, everyone had the same idea: eat some satisfying, greasy food before getting shit-faced by midnight. There were even a few people she recognized from school, making her suddenly uneasy by the fact that she was with Billy alone. When she noticed the group of teenagers looking in their direction, she audibly sighed, walking faster to keep up with Billy. 
“Maybe eating here was a bad idea,” she whispered, and to her dismay, Billy looked over his shoulder at the table she was referring to, eyeing them down coldly before turning his attention back to her. 
“Why?” 
“You know-“
“Fuck ‘em.” He then smiled coolly down at her, cocking his head toward the booth he had led them to. “After you, princess.” 
Jess slid in halfway, still leaving plenty of space on both sides due to the size of the bench. As Billy slid in next to her, she shed the leather jacket from her shoulders, placing it to her right. Right when Billy was sitting comfortably, their waiter came by with a notepad and a smile. 
“Hey guys can I get you guys started with drinks?” 
“Yeah, she wants a strawberry milkshake, I’ll getta coke.” Billy then bumped Jess’s shoulder with his, grabbing her attention away from the menu. “The usual, princess?” When she wordlessly nodded, he ordered their food as well, gently taking Jess’s menu away and handing it to their waiter. 
“How do you remember all that?” Jess questioned once their waiter was out of earshot. 
“Your order really isn’t that hard, Logan.” When Jess opened her mouth to disagree, she was interrupted by the door of the diner being pushed open, the bell above indicating that more customers were arriving. 
“Oh my gosh, Jess! What are you doing here?!” Chrissy practically ran to their booth, scooting into the side opposite Jess and Billy. “Steve said you were gonna be busy with schoolwork! We’re all going to that old diner that shut down tonight if you still want to go?” She then looked knowingly at Billy, then back and Jess, smiling deviously. “Unless… you had other plans?” Her boyfriend, Jason, slid in next to her, nodding at Billy, who half-heartedly did the same. 
“Oh yeah, uh…” Jess smiled awkwardly at her friend, occasionally stealing glances at Billy that Chrissy only seemed to notice. “We were going over to Tina’s thing instead.”
“So… not homework…” Chrissy kept the same smile, but when the four of them heard the ringing of the front door again, they all shot their heads toward the sound, a larger group of teens entering this time. “Hey, Steve, look who it is!” 
Steve, along with six others, walked their way towards the booth. Billy cleared his throat, making sure to look anywhere but at Steve. “Hey, kid! What’re you doing here? Thought you had…” He then looked at who was sitting next to her and nodded his head apprehensively. “… homework.” 
“Well, yeah. I still do. But… uh… Billy kinda convinced me to go out. You know, since it’s a holiday and all…” She looked up at Steve sheepishly. He had yet to make a move to sit at the booth that was now apparently everyone else’s as well. Instead, he pressed himself at the head of the table, placing his hands in his letterman pocket. 
“So. You’re coming to Benny’s then.” Steve didn’t phrase this as a question but rather waited for Jess to agree. He had invited her before Billy convinced her to ditch the homework, and she knew that he did not expect any alternative.  
“Taking her to Tina’s actually.” Billy finally turned his gaze toward Steve, who eventually did the same, his eyes not yet leaving Jess’s until his head was fully facing Billy. 
“Really…” Steve stood there, nodding his head painfully slow, his mouth staying open as it contorted into an annoyed smile. He then clenched his teeth together and sucked in, telling Jason to scoot over as he now decided it was time to sit. “That’s funny, ‘cause, I don’t think she wanted to go to Tina’s.”
“Eh,” Billy ticked the side of his mouth upward, scooting over so the rest of those who came in the door with Steve could sit. Jess did the same, picking up the jacket and moving it on her lap. “You know, Harrington…”
“What’s that, Hargrove.” Steve now sat almost exactly across from Billy, crossing his arms on the table as Billy leaned back, draping his right arm over the side of the booth Jess was on. 
“She probably just needed the right person to ask her is all. Know what I mean.” Billy then felt a strong kick to his shin, causing him to roll his head back and over to Jess, giving her an almost apologetic glance. “Or, just needed one more person to ask.” Billy still faced Jess as he said this, giving her a ‘is that better’ kind of look. 
“It’s just… he promised to help out the next few days with our assignment, so I figured I’d have time to come out after all,�� Jess eased in, her eyes downturned as she held a tight-lined smile at Steve, practically begging him not to get mad.
Before Steve could respond, the boy now next to Billy interrupted, “Dude seriously? You’ve been dodging me and Hagen all break because you say you need to go over and do that damn project and you’re still not done?” Billy couldn’t help but chuckle at his question, making Jess sweat despite no longer having multiple layers on. 
“Here you guys go.” Saved by the bell. The same waiter now had a tray containing their order from earlier, a double bacon burger, fries, and a coke for Billy, and a cheeseburger cooked medium, with no pickles and well-done fries for Jess. When the waiter placed her milkshake and the extra ketchup in front of her, he then turned his attention to the others. “Should I… get something going for you folks too?” 
Chrissy was first to order, making sure to go quickly so she could turn her attention back to Jess, who was now poking at her fries. “You didn’t tell me he was coming over all the time!” she whispered, leaning over the table, attempting to ensure Jess was the only one who heard. 
“Chris! Hush!” When Jess looked over at Billy briefly, he was already looking over at her, smirking. “We’ll talk about it Monday.” 
“We better! You don’t tell me anything anymore!” She glanced over at Billy as well, then leaned back against Jason’s arm, giving both of them a knowing look, making sure to grab one of Jess’s fries on the way back to her seat. 
“And for you?” Steve’s attention was now on the waiter and his menu, not having the time to look at it for long due to where his attention was earlier. 
“Billy,” Jess leaned closer to him when Steve began ordering. “If you’re wanting me to tell him we’re friends eventually, you’re not helping your case.” 
“What?” He whispered back, “I’m just fuckin’ with him.” 
“Then stop. Fucking. With. Him,” Jess ordered, not amused by the smirk he still had plastered on his face. 
Billy watched the way her features attempted to convey her seriousness, her brows twitching as they furrowed, her jaw slightly clenched. Instead of scaring him into obeying, however, her look just made him smile even more. He thought it was adorable. He then reached down for his fries with the arm that wasn’t draped over Jess’s seat and dunked two in her milkshake, still not breaking his smile, and before he took a bite, he looked her in the eye and rather loudly responded, “Whatever you say gorgeous.” 
Jess saw Steve’s head snap in their direction through the corner of her eye and was careful to not look over in his direction right away. Instead, she looked back over at Chrissy, who held back a smile, her lips sucked in between her teeth. Jason pretended not to hear the pet name, going for one of Jess’s fries as well and inhaling it as he cleared his throat. Jess took a long drink of her milkshake, maybe slightly hoping that she would receive a brain freeze so bad it would knock her unconscious. 
“You know what,” Steve finally chimed in again. “Tina’s thing sounds great. We should skip Benny’s.” 
“I mean, I’m down,” Jason shrugged, leaning back to look at the rest of the group. “You guys down?”
Everyone ended up agreeing, some more disappointed than others, one of the girls at the end mumbling something about ‘last minute’. 
“Perfect,” Steve said flatly. “Tina’s it is.” He then looked over at Billy eating his burger as if nothing happened, shrugging when Steve finished.
“Good for you guys,” was all he said to this, dipping his fries in Jess’s shake again before winking at her. “Look at that, more people you know are coming after all.” 
Jess and Steve ate in silence, occasionally looking over at one another, while everyone else, including Billy, chatted through their meal. When Billy was done with his, he looked over at Jess and stole one of her fries, dipping it in the ketchup she had on her plate instead of his own, making Steve’s eyes roll as he sipped mostly air through his straw. 
“You doin’ okay, princess?” Billy asked as he reached for another one, realizing she hadn’t talked much since scolding him earlier. 
“I’d be doing a lot better if you weren’t such a dick sometimes.”
“I wasn’t being a dick, Jess.” She peered at him through her eyelashes, rolling her eyes away from him when he denied it. “I’ll be nicer, alright. Promise.” 
“Well good thing you got all night to make up for it,” Jess jabbed, grabbing another bite from her burger before washing it down with her milkshake. 
“Yeah, yeah.” Billy then flagged down the waiter who was walking passed the table. “Can she get a water please?” When the waiter nodded and walked away, Jess gave him a questioning look. “You’ll thank me tomorrow morning, princess,” Billy murmured, “Plus, I’m not tryna take you back home to your parents drunk out of your mind like you were last time, you’re hydrating all night.” 
“I wasn’t drunk out of my mind!” 
Billy laughed briefly before moving even closer to her, his lips inches away from her ear. “All I know is, because of how surprised your dad was at me takin’ you out, he’s probably gonna wait all night for you, and I’d really like it if this wasn’t the first and last time he let me take you out, yeah?”
“Yeah, well. I wasn’t drunk out of my mind…” 
The waiter quickly returned with the glass of water. When it was passed all the way down to Jess, Billy asked to be let out of the booth to pay, everyone else following him to the podium, everyone except Steve. 
“Be right back, princess, then we can motor.” 
Steve scooted down the booth’s bench more, right across where Jess was sitting, then leaned back and crossed his arms. 
“Ahem…” Jess looked up innocently, her water cup in hand as she continued to drink from it. “Oh don’t give me that look, Jess… I don’t like,” Steve gestured with his hand, continuously pointing at Billy then Jess, “what the hell is going on here… what the hell is going on here?”
“He’s just trying to piss you off, Steve, okay?”
“Yeah? Well it’s working, Jess. It’s really working. I asked you again yesterday to make sure you still didn’t wanna go out, and you said no. So in between yesterday afternoon and right now, Hargrove got you to say yes?”
“Like I said, he promised we’d get done by the fourth so I just figured I wouldn’t be the only person that stayed in tonight… Please don’t be mad…” Jess pleaded, putting down her glass to look at him better. 
“I’m not mad, Jess. I’m confused. So what, you goin’ to parties with him now? And what’s with him calling you cute lil… it’s weird.”
“I mean, not really,” Jess attempted to reason with him. “He flirts with like… everyone…” 
“Well from what I hear, he’s been over at your place every damn day. Which by the way, it’s really annoying hearing shit about your best friend when it’s not coming from your best friend. So, he hasn’t exactly been able to ‘flirt with like… everyone’ this whole break. Just you.” 
“We’re just friends, Steve.”
“Oh,” His eyebrows began to rise as if he just heard some interesting news, his mouth contorting back into that annoyed smile before he blinked sarcastically, “So you’re friends with Hargrove now.” 
“Steeeevee…”
“Why don’t we just, you know, start inviting him to sit with us at lunch, or even… I don’t know… go on cute little friendship dates, where we hold hands and skip through the goddamn football field behind the school and go under the bleachers where we giggle and gossip about-“ 
“Steve knock it off.”
“I’m just saying since you’re such good friends with him now…” Steve leaned in and waved her to come closer as well, beginning to whisper as if he were going to say something important, “Is he holding you hostage? Because all you gotta do is blink twice and I’ll get you outta here and-“ 
“Oh my god, Steve!”  Jess quickly pushed herself away, slamming back into the booth harder than intended. 
“I’m just saying I have Hop on speed dial …”
“He’s not that bad, Steve, honestly.”
“Oh yeah? Tell that to my goddamn face!” Steve whisper-yelled across the table, “Look, look at my nose. I’ve been staring at it for a goddamn month and it’s crooked. Fucking crooked, Jess.” 
“No it’s not!” 
“Yes, it is!” Steve then grabbed her hand and placed it on his bridge, rubbing it against a small bump that she hadn’t noticed before. “Yeah, you see that, he broke it, Jess. Broke it! If I get hit again my nose is gonna distract all the girls from my best feature, and what the hell am I supposed to do then, huh?” 
Jess began to giggle uncontrollably, making Steve break into a smile as well. “It’s not that bad, Steve.”
“Well I’m glad you think it’s so funny, brainiac, but I’m telling you, it’s more crooked than it was three months ago.” 
“I don’t think so…” Jess looked over at the podium suddenly, seeing Billy was done and was just watching them. When he noticed Jess looking over at him, he cocked his head to the side, indicating he was ready to go. Jess then turned back to look at Steve, who already knew what she was going to say. 
“So you’re still gonna ride with him to Tina’s?”
“I came here with him, didn’t I? It would be kinda rude to ditch him… plus…” 
“He isn’t really that bad. So I heard.” 
Jess began to leave the table when she suddenly felt the jacket on her lap. She held onto it as she slid out, Steve following behind her. “Oh you gotta be kidding me…” Jess turned back around toward Steve, who was eyeing the leather jacket in her hand. She then watched as he looked over at Billy, who had on his own coat, and then back toward the other that clearly belonged to him as well. 
“It’s cold…” 
“Then wear a coat you own? Just a thought.”
“Steve…” 
“We won’t do this here, but I swear to god we’re talking about this in our Spanish class bright and early Monday morning. I don’t care if the whole conversation is ‘en español’, you’re gonna tell me everything. Got it?” 
“Got it…” 
“Enjoy the blue death trap.” 
Jess huffed as she watched Steve walk away to the podium to pay for his tab. She then turned back to Billy, who was giving her an inquiring look. When she finally reached him, he turned away from her to look at the podium for a brief moment. “You still good?” 
“Surprisingly, yes.” When Billy continued to look at her, wordlessly asking her to elaborate, she just shook her head. “Can we at least get outta here, it’s already 9…”
“Alright,” Billy gave in but instantly stopped her as she made her way to the front door, “Hang on now, princess, it’s cold out there.” He then proceeded to give her his signature, sly grin, and even though she wanted to be irritated with him, she couldn’t help but smile back. 
“You’re something else, you know that? Probably don’t even care if I’m cold, you’re just being a jackass.” 
“Sweetheart, if I didn’t care whether or not you were cold, I wouldn’t have given it to you in the first place.” He smoothly stepped closer to her, watching her shake her head in disbelief. Jess draped it over her shoulders, this time pulling her arms through the sleeves. He went ahead and fixed the collar for her, gently sliding her hair out from underneath. “Thatta girl.” He winked at her playfully before he turned around, completely missing the blush forming on her cheeks. He then nodded at Steve, eyeing him up and down once before saying, “See ya there, Harrington.” 
Taglist:
@nix-rose @fandom-princess-forevermore @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo @axionn @defenslessheart-main @the-lost-are-ignored @ahoyyharrington @strawberrykittey
34 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 2 months
Note
Omg I love PMW Billy.
And Jess finally called him her friend to Steve's face!
I love Steve but he needs to sit his cock block ass back down and wait with the rest of us for Billy and Jess to realize they love each other.
THANK YOU!
So so so glad you’re liking it so far 😭
And you fr have a point I irritate myself when I have to write his cock block moments but let’s be real he would most def have an aneurism if he ever found these two dating 😅😅🤣 But honestly, Steven, it’ll be fine.
1 note · View note
hogwartsandhawkins · 2 months
Text
Prove Me Wrong
Chapter 16: Same
If you need to catch up, here's the masterlist
Tumblr media
Summary: Billy convinces Jess to go out New Year's Eve
Word Count: 9k (sorry)
Warnings: Cursing. Fluff, cuddling, Billy is kinda OOC if you squint. Little bit of angst. As always let me know if I missed anything. Also, not exactly proof read
AN: I had to break this chapter up because I didn't realize I made this chapter like 20k words. So. It's now in two chapters. (Which is also why it took me longer to release this than I thought it would LOL)
“Let me take you to Tina’s party.” Billy continued to look at the screen while Friday the 13th: Part 2 played. They had the whole house to themselves, as Jess’s parents were currently on their scheduled date night, allowing them both to be much louder than they would normally be at 12 AM. Their homework was sprawled across Jess’s bed, untouched beside them taking the materials out of their bags. 
“But Steve isn’t going, and I don’t think Chris is either… so I’m gonna have no one to talk to-“ 
Billy gave Jess an annoyed, stern look. “Jess.”
“Well, if you would have let me finish, I was going to say, I’d have no one to talk to if you decided to do your own thing.” 
“I’m not gonna ditch you.” 
“Okay.”
“Did I last time?”
“That was different,” Jess explained, “If you did end up ditching me that night, I would have had other people to actually hang out with.”
“You’re missing my point. Point is. I didn’t. And I won’t.” Billy paused a moment to look back over at the screen, thinking about whether he should say the next part. “Hagen said you used to hang with everyone that came to those things.” 
“So you do still talk about me,” Jess teased. 
“Not like that. …What happened?”  
“It’s not like they were really my friends. They were Steve’s friends. I just kinda… became friends by association. I thought I was so cool being one of the only freshmen at those things back then, I just wanted to be around everyone, be friends with everyone, and then last year… perspectives change… I guess.”
“You wanna do something else then? New Year’s Eve?” 
Jess looked over at him, laughing in response. “I’m not gonna make you ditch a party because I don’t wanna go.” 
“Eh,” Billy repositioned himself against the headboard, squaring himself up to better look at the TV now, “Might be lame anyways.” When he didn’t get a response from her, he continued, still pretending to watch the camp counselors on the screen dance in the current cabin they were in. “What were you gonna do then?” 
Jess shrugged.  “Just stay home. Catch us up on some homework since we’ve been pretty bad about it. You know we start school again on the fourth right?” 
“Okay… Just ditch the homework tomorrow night, and I’ll be by first thing next morning to help, alright? What, we got…” Billy picked up their shared reading for the first time that night and flipped through what they needed to read “Jesus… Okay. So I’ll be here the first and second, and the third we can write the essay and boom. Done.”
“You have work on the third.”
“And? I’ll come by after. No big deal.” 
“All so we can go to one party that might be lame.”
“Come on. Do something without pretty boy for a change.” Billy spoke his nickname for Steve with less malice than he usually did, catching Jess’s attention. 
“If you ditch me, I swear…”
“I’m not gonna ditch you. We have a deal? Party tomorrow?”
Jess huffed, looking away from Billy and back toward the TV screen. “Party tomorrow.” 
Billy turned toward Jess again, smiling at her deviously. He nudged her, causing her to sway back and forth, her shoulders rubbing against her headboard as she returned the same smile. “You’re excited.” 
“Oh yeah, keep telling yourself that, Hargrove.”
“Admit it, you have more fun with me than you do with Harrington.” Billy had started to become much bolder recently. Ever since that day in the arcade parking lot, he had felt more confident in where he stood with her. He continued to tease her more often, knocked on her windowpane even more frequently, allowed her more time behind the wheel of his car where he would purposefully take hold of her hand. He continued to watch as she shook her head, knowing it was a joke but wishing it had some truth behind it for her. 
“Steve is a lot more fun than you.” 
“Really?” He began to look around the room, pretending as if he was looking for something he couldn’t see. He then turned back to her smugly, clearing his throat as he eyed her up and down. “So why am I the only one here then?” 
“We- I …” Jess stuttered over her words, his confident statement obviously catching her off guard, making Billy smirk with satisfaction. She rolled her eyes at his smugness and decided to retaliate. “Because he doesn’t bug me as much as you do, and never knocks on my window unannounced,” She teased, again returning the same smug grin he was giving her.
“I guess that just means I like you more than Steve does.” 
Jess scrunched her eyebrows but released them quickly, looking down at her lap to avoid the look he was now giving her, the same look he had been giving her every day since she had gone to apologize. It would mostly come spontaneously. Sometimes it would happen when he would lightly graze the golden necklace she now wore every day, sometimes it would be when they would interrupt the movie they were watching to have random conversations, other times it would be in the middle of a bite she was taking of her Big Al burger, which would cause her to stop eating abruptly. But there was always a time when she could expect to be looked at like that. 
It was an unfailing constant for them now, Jess waiting by her window around 10 at night, Billy knocking shortly after. Her blinds would already be drawn in anticipation; all she ever had to do was pull the window up, letting the cold wind blow his familiar smell back into her room. And every night without fail, Billy would look at her as if she could push him from that roof ledge and he would devotedly scale the side of her house again. But in the same look, he also conveyed how he knew she could never do that. 
Not her. 
Even on the coldest nights, he would arrive with his jacket in hand, or not even with him at all. He knew the longest part of his journey to her room would be the short jog there, as now knocking was just a formality. She would see him before he would even reach her driveway and would have the window open as soon as his knuckles struck the glass for the first time, greeting him with the same reserved smile she always held when he made her nervous. 
“Yeah right. You just like hanging with me because I’m getting you a ‘B+’ in English.” Her rebuttal was enough to make his look shift back to his usual, playful one, one that didn’t involve her heart fluttering at the sight of it. 
“I won’t say that doesn’t have somethin’ to do with it.” Billy clicked his tongue as his eyes traveled down her body and back toward their assignments. “You make studying bearable.” 
Instead of leaving the conversation there, or laughing his comment off, Jess folded her legs towards her and shifted closer to Billy, making sure her body was now facing his. “You know, umm. I’m really glad that uh… I’m glad that Mr. Crowley paired us up together.” 
Jess watched Billy’s smile grow, the glint in his eyes feeling familiar to her. She remembered seeing the same smile in their shared practices when they were made to share the gym, or when she would cheer for the varsity basketball team at their games. This smile was only directed at her once before this, and it was when he had caught her watching him during practice. Correction. Watching him and not watching Harrington.  
His smile was full of pride, a feeling that was hard for Billy to contain when he ever had a dose of it, for it was typically stripped away the second he would walk through his front door.  And despite being appointed the new keg king or possibly even the new king of Hawkins High, he rarely ever felt this. It was only ever when he was on the court, contributing to a win for whatever team he was currently playing for: this was when he felt so much gratification that he couldn’t contain it.  
Well, until now. 
These past months, it felt to him as if he were playing a game he had no chance of winning, that Jess would eventually forget about him, that he was bothering her too much, that she would never see him as anything more than a means to an end, that Jess counted the days to when she would never have to invite him over again. 
“So I finally won you over, huh? About time. Could only fake nice for so long-“ Jess’s shove was expected, Billy grabbing her wrist before she was able to connect, pulling her even closer to him. “I’m kidding.” Billy’s hand left her wrist, slowly moving its way up her forearm to her elbow, his fingers softly grazing her skin as it did so. “Same.” 
“Same?”
“I feel the same way.” 
The screams coming from the TV weren’t enough to turn either Jess’s or Billy’s attention. Jess allowed her knees to press against Billy’s side, her body becoming less stiff with every second they stayed like this. “Well, again, it’s probably because-“ 
“Fuck the grade, Jess,” Billy swiftly cut off Jess’s teasing, his tone alarmingly firm. 
“What about your scholarship to a fancy California school?” Jess chuckled, attempting to ease the serious note that now filled the room. 
Billy shook his head, breaking the eye contact Jess was now feeling confident enough to hold. He looked over at the TV again for a moment before sighing and looking down at his lap. “Can… can I be honest with you for a sec?” 
“Yeah, of course.” Jess sat up a little straighter, waiting through the long silence to hear what he needed to say. 
“The only reason why I wanted to even go to college was to, you know, get away.” 
“From Hawkins?”
“No… Well,” Billy paused for a moment again, looking around at the random memorabilia displayed throughout Jess’s room, “Okay yeah, maybe get away from Hawkins. But mostly, from him.”
Jess nodded in understanding, staying silent and allowing him to continue. 
“And I chose California… cuz… it’s…” Billy continued to struggle with the last part of his sentence, the words not willing to be said out in the open, though he thought them nearly every day. “… It’s where I thought shewould be.”
Jess’s heart ached at the mention of his mom. She had only heard about her a few times from Billy. She knew that she was gentle, loved to bake, and loved the ocean. She also knew that she left Billy. She left him alone with his father. She left when he was young, no more than 10 maybe. She was reminded of that whenever Billy spoke of her. “She would always bake my birthday cakes, but I haven’t had one since she left”. “She used to take me to this beach, but I stopped going to it when she left”. She knew that every amazing memory that he had left of his mother was soiled by the fact that she was now gone, and Billy had no idea where she was or why he wasn’t with her. 
“But now, I just…” He let out a frustrated breath before he finished his thought, not wanting to say it out loud because he wasn’t sure if he fully meant it yet, “Why should I be the one to go out of my way to go where she is?” Billy’s voice began to rise, feeling as though he was now asking himself this question versus speaking to Jess. “I mean, I’m her fuckin’ kid. I’m her-“ Billy stopped his rant immediately when he felt his voice begin to shake, clenching his jaw to ensure he stayed quiet. Jess took this time to grab the hand that Billy had placed gently against her elbow in her hand, brushing the top of his thumb with her own. Billy took his free hand and ran it through his hair haphazardly, looking down at the one Jess now had in hers. “I just don’t feel like I need to now.” Jess watched as he nodded his head, almost as if he was satisfied with his realization.  
“What if you just went to school there because you wanted to? Not because of your mom, or your dad. Just for you?” 
Billy chuckled at the thought of this, shaking his head at her suggestion. “If I was doin’ what I wanted to do, I wouldn’t really be goin’ to school at all. Guess you were right.”
“What do you mean?”
“You acted all surprised the first time I told you I wanted to go to college.” Billy’s lopsided smirk made an appearance again, putting Jess at ease. 
“No I didn’t!” Jess nudged his arm with the top of her shoulder. 
“Aye watch it, I had a shitty practice today and the arm’s sore. And yeah, you did.” 
“Okay, okay, maybe I was a little surprised that you wanted to go, but now that I know you’re a complete math nerd it’s starting to make sense to me.” 
“Aye! No, no, no, watch what you call me now, princess. Plus, I’m not that good at it, you still got the better grade… nerd.” Billy dropped his smile one last time and pushed his arm back against Jess’s, now realizing he was still holding her hand. “Hey, Jess?”
“Hmm?”
“Thanks, you know, for letting me hang here all the time. And for not telling anyone… anything.” 
“Like you said before, you keep some of my secrets, I keep some of yours.” Jess smiled warmly at him, causing him to do the same again. 
“You know what that means?” 
“What’s that, Hargrove?”
“You gotta tell me somethin’ else about you now.” 
“That is not what that means!” 
“Ah c’mon…” Without letting go of her hand, Billy adjusted the pillow that was against his back so he could lie comfortably with his head propped up, allowing himself to still be able to see the movie that they were no longer watching. When Jess had yet to do the same, Billy tugged her hand downward, cocking his head once to indicate she should follow. 
Jess made a move to lay down, careful not to shift her right hand too much to cause Billy to let go. When he did anyway, her heart dropped slightly only for it to jump back up into her throat when she felt the same hand on the small of her back, softly pulling her closer to him. He did it so casually, as if without thinking, like they had been laying like this, with Billy on his back, Jess on her side, using his chest in place of a pillow, for months before now. 
Billy shifted once before he settled, looking at the television set nonchalantly. “Tell me about volleyball.”
“What?” The question caught Jess off guard, causing her to almost forget the current position she was in. 
“That team picture when you were in middle school.” Billy’s head nodded toward the framed photograph he came across his first night having dinner with the Logans. “You never told me why you don’t play anymore. You said you were good.” 
“Just, things happened, I couldn’t play anymore, and chose cheer instead.”
“Anythin’ to do with that shit knee of yours?” Billy always watched the way she would run when they shared the track together, watched as she favored that knee during her last lap. He also watched the way she would land during cartwheels or flips. Even the way she walked, it became obvious to Billy that she would take prolonged steps with her left leg to make up the distance that her right leg couldn’t handle. It wasn’t noticeable, and by no means did she walk with a limp, but over the last couple of months Billy Hargrove made it a point to observe every quirk she had, and this happened to be one of them. 
“Observant aren’t we…” Jess responded sarcastically, “Turns out landing on your knees continuously isn’t good for them. Had to quit.” 
“So that’s how you fucked it up then? You said it wasn’t from cheer.” 
Jess sighed, thinking about her past injury, pausing to remember the excruciating pain that came with it and the heartbreak that followed when she found out she would have to quit any contact sport. “No, it wasn’t even from playing. It was… I fell. I fell on some stairs. It should have never even happened. It was so… so stupid and… You know, volleyball was the one sport I really loved. I didn’t play for long. My mom got me into it when I was in elementary. She was so excited when I tried out for the middle school team and made it. I got to play one season my sixth-grade year, and before regionals, I shattered my kneecap.” 
“Jesus, Jess.”
“When we moved in this house, I had to sleep downstairs for almost a whole year before we could make my room be up here. But by eighth grade, the knee healed and by freshman year, doc said I could ‘participate in physical activity’ again,” Jess mocked the way she remembered her old pediatrician talking to her mother about her knee as if she weren’t in the room listening as well. “I just couldn’t do anything that could cause me to land on my knees hard anytime soon. So volleyball, even with the kneepads, was out of the question, and so was basically any other sport that I could get hurt in. So…” 
“… So that left cheerleading.”
“That left cheerleading…” Jess cleared her throat, looking around her room the best she could at all the cheer posters, Hawkins High flags, photographs of her and her cheer team, photographs of her and Chrissy, and others of her and Steve at his games. “I mean, don’t get me wrong, cheer’s been… it’s been great. I made some of my best friends because I was in cheer.” 
“A lot of them you don’t talk to anymore…” 
“Okay, yeah. But still. It was probably the only reason I made friends in high school in the first place. I was a total loser in middle school.” 
Jess felt Billy’s chest vibrate against her head as he laughed at her statement. “I doubt you were. Thought you were friends with King Steve when you were, like, twelve.” 
“Yeah… but we went to different middle schools. I didn’t transfer to this district till I was in eighth grade, and being the new kid isn’t easy either. Steve was already in high school by the time I transferred.”
“How the hell did you even meet him then?”
“My dad’s friends with his dad. They worked together.” 
“So you cheering at my game next weekend?” Billy shifted the conversation fairly quickly, no longer interested in talking about Steve or his dad in any way. He looked down at Jess, who was still lying on his chest.  Jess shifted her gaze up at him, turning on her stomach so that her chin rested against him now. 
“It depends if coach tells me to. She might make me cheer at the girls’ game again.” 
“Well tell her you wanna go see me play instead.” Billy winked as he said this, making Jess attempt to hold back the smile that was already halfway displayed on her face. 
They laid like this for a while, occasionally shifting to better look at one another when they spoke about something interesting. Jess continuously made excuses in her head throughout their conversations as to why cuddling up next to Billy Hargrove was acceptable friendship behavior, and in no way romantic at all. 
Of course, Jess and Chrissy always laid on each other's shoulders after an away game they went to together, especially if it was a football game, as it would always be a late night getting home. Even she and Steve had a couple of nights where they slept against each other. Sure, it would typically be due to exhaustion from hunting down demidogs all night or waiting for Will Byers to no longer be possessed by the mind flayer. And sure, there was never an instance where Steve ever felt the need to drape his arm along her back, pulling her into him as they lay on the same bed. However, with Billy’s hand against her back, her head securely nuzzled against his chest and arm, she felt a sense of security she hadn’t felt in… well… ever, and it was becoming alarmingly comfortable, so comfortable that she felt the weight of her eyelids as the clock showed it was close to 2 AM. Her mind began to still more and more as she closed her eyes, listening to the sound of Billy talking about the new job he’d be applying for at the Hawkins pool when it opened for the summer. 
“You better come visit me when I get the job.” Billy expected a snide remark, something to do with how shit he’d be as a lifeguard, or maybe something more subtle like ‘if you get the job’, enough to get the point across. When he was met with silence, he looked down. “Earth to Je-“ 
The sight of Jess sound asleep on his chest made him smile softly to himself. He slowly shifted his body downward so that his head was now flat against the pillow he was propped on earlier, making sure she was still secure against him. He slid his free hand underneath his head, looking up at her bedroom ceiling as he listened to her steady breathing. He didn’t turn his head when he saw headlights illuminating Jess’s darkened bedroom. Her parents were now home, but knowing them, they would let Jess sleep through the night, checking in on her in the morning. Billy made no move to turn off her TV which was now again the only source of light in the room. He was sure he’d do that eventually, that he would get up and go to his usual place on the floor, taking the pillow he was lying on with him. He would grab the spare blanket in Jess’s closet, not needing to turn on the closet light since he knew it would be right where he left it this morning. But right now, he stayed, telling himself that he didn’t want to wake her, that she had just fallen asleep, so he would wait. He waited until he heard her parents close their own bedroom door. He waited until he heard her usual, soft snores. He waited until he felt his own eyes become heavy with sleep. And still, he stayed. 
Jess awoke the next morning, her breathing slightly blocked by something unfamiliar against her face. She shifted slowly, tilting her head toward the ceiling to catch more air, her eyes still closed. When she felt whatever it was next to her move, she moved with it, instinctually draping her arm over it to get more comfortable in her sleeping position. It wasn’t until she heard it breathe against her neck that she slowly opened her eyes, confused as to what she was now lying against.  She was met with a simple white T-shirt, which was rolled at the sleeve, revealing what kept her in place. 
Billy’s arm was slung tightly around her, continuing to pull her in anytime one of them moved. Her gaze left his arm and moved to where she thought his face would be. When she didn’t find it through her blurred vision, she felt another breath against the same spot on her neck, which woke her even more. She groaned realizing her back felt tight as she was lying in a position she was not used to, her head resting against the mattress and the headboard. She now felt Billy’s other arm underneath her, his elbow bending on the back side of her body, his forearm pulling her in as well. When she looked down, she found the top of Billy’s head, his face against the crook of her neck. Her eyes began to widen as her surroundings became clearer, her vision no longer fogged by lack of sleep. She felt the numbness of her own arm underneath her and shifted it. Her arm tingled along with her insides as she began to realize this was how she slept. This was how they slept.  She could now feel every breath Billy took, very much aware of how she changed a darker shade of red every time he exhaled.
Oh my fucking god.
She didn’t want to wake him. She wanted nothing more than to just stay there, nuzzle against him, and fall back asleep. But her elevating heart rate wouldn’t allow that to happen. She felt as if her room was now ten degrees warmer, causing her to stir uncomfortably. When she heard Billy groan, however, she stopped her movements suddenly, unsure of how he would react when he realized they were tangled together in her bed. 
“Ah, shit.” Billy shifted his arm which was underneath Jess, pulling her in tighter before letting her go. He propped himself up with his now free hand, the other running through his now slightly messy hair, though to Jess’s surprise, his curls stayed mostly intact throughout the night.  “What time is it?” Billy whispered to himself, and when he looked up at her wall clucked, he realized he was there a little later than he expected. “Fuck.” He finally looked down at Jess, realizing she was already awake. “Shit, princess, sorry. Didn’t mean to wake ya up.” 
How is he so goddamn calm???
Jess continued to look at Billy, completely shell-shocked. When he finally noticed how uncomfortable she looked, he turned away from her, beginning to feel guilty about allowing himself to sleep next to her like that, without her knowing.  “Sorry, I, uh… you fell asleep, and I didn’t wanna wake you up right after. And I, uh.” 
Before Billy could continue his apology, Jess quickly stepped in, “No! No, it’s okay. I mean I’m sorry for just, you know, falling asleep on you like that. My fault. Really…” 
Billy chuckled, biting down on his bottom lip as he looked back over at her. He leaned against her headboard, feeling his back pop, the new sleeping position seemingly having an effect on his body as well. “I didn’t mind it,” He boldly admitted, watching her to see if the confession was too much. 
“Oh, uh… I didn’t… It wasn’t like I did either… just…” 
Billy smiled brightly at her stuttering but interjected when he realized he wouldn’t get a complete sentence from her anytime soon. “Hey, thanks for letting me come over basically every night this break. Kinda saved my ass these past two weeks, you know?”
“Oh yeah, of course.” Jess eagerly accepted the change of topic. “Surprised you’ve been able to sneak away all the time without anyone noticing.” 
“Not like Neil cares where I am during break. He barely cares where I am during school nights.” Billy laughed bitterly at the mention of his father, shifting his jaw with annoyance before turning his attention back to Jess. “So I’ll see you later tonight, right?”
Jess had already forgotten about the invitation she accepted from Billy, and with how she woke up, she was more nervous than ever to go through with it. “Hmm? Oh yeah, yeah. I’ll see you later.” 
“Too late to back out now, Logan.” Billy teased her, as if able to read her mind, something he seemed to be doing a lot of lately. He retrieved his jacket from the floor and shrugged it on. “I’ll be back here at 8, got it? Don’t want your parents all weirded out that I picked you up late or whatever.” With the promise of Mr. Logan not going into work this morning due to the holiday, Billy decided he didn’t need to wait before leaving and opened the windowpane. 
He began to make his way over the window ledge before stopping himself. He looked down at his coat, hesitating slightly before he ripped it back off and tossed it on her bed. He then looked away toward his own home. “Wear that tonight, it’s gonna be cold and you don’t have shit for jackets.” Before she could protest, he climbed out of her room, looking back at her one last time. “See you later, gorgeous.” 
As promised, Jess heard the doorbell ring throughout the house at 8 pm sharp. Before meeting Billy downstairs, she held his jacket, looking at the one she was planning to wear before on her bed. She had spent the majority of the afternoon thinking about waking up next to him, Billy pulling her down into him last night, and then how she had watched him throw his leather jacket down on her bed, requesting she have it on tonight. She didn’t understand his reasoning, however. She had plenty of jackets. Sure, a lot of them were dainty, and some were thin, but she still had warm ones, she planned on wearing a warm one even tonight. 
She placed Billy’s jacket over her shoulders, draping it delicately like a blanket, and looked at herself in her dresser mirror. Her blue, cut-off sweatshirt was now covered by the brown leather coat, the same one that was left at her house by accident, and the same one she refused to wear to school. She felt a slight pain in her chest, causing her to second guess whether she should actually oblige and wear it this time, or go with her simple jean jacket instead, the one that was already spread out neatly on her bed. When she anxiously rubbed her hand against her collarbone, she felt the golden chain, her fingertips following it to the horse charm at the end. She hated the way she smiled like an idiot anytime she thought about where it came from. But she did without fail this time as well, holding it in between her index finger and thumb, placing it back gently against her skin when she was again calm. She took one step back, taking in the entirety of her outfit, realizing how much it fit, having the necklace he gave her for Christmas, combined with a jacket that was unmistakably Billy’s. She smiled at her image one last time, lifting her hands from underneath the jacket to both ends of the collar to bring them closer together. 
“Hey hun, I think Steve’s at the door… What time is your party going till?” Jess’s mom quickly turned her attention toward the stairs when she heard her daughter’s footsteps. 
“Oh, uh… Steve isn’t actually going to this party, he’s doing something else tonight.”
Before her mother could question her further, Jess rushed to the front door and revealed Billy, wearing a burgundy button-down, with many of those buttons not buttoned down. She cleared her throat as her eyes tore away from his bare chest, remembering the position she woke up in only hours before this. 
Billy casually eyed her up and down, not caring to hide it, his eyes stopping at the leather coat. “Hey there, gorgeous.” He smirked down at her, visibly pleased with what she had on. 
“Billy?” Jess heard her father’s voice from behind her. “What are you doing here, son?”
Billy squinted quizzically at Jess and then aimed his attention at his father, not knowing how to start. “I, uh, she didn’t say…?” 
“I told you, Dad, I’m going to a New Year’s Eve party…” 
“Well, is Steve not going to the same party?” Mr. Logan began questioning her, crossing his arms interrogatively, “You normally go with Steve.” 
“No, Dad, he’s not…”
“I see… So who’s all going to be there then, Jess?” 
Before either Billy or Jess could respond, Mrs. Logan left the counter she was leaning against and walked to her husband’s side. “Oh Stan, stop it… Billy will make sure she’s back safe, won’t you Billy?” 
“Uh, yeah… yeah for sure.” Billy started stumbling over his words even more, which was something new Jess was experiencing, and though he was responding to Jess’s mother, his eyes stayed fixed on her father, who was nodding at Billy’s response. 
“So can we go now please, without you being all weird.” 
“Yes… you can go. But you remember curfew still applies…” Stan started to turn his attention back to Billy when his head snapped back to Jess, his eyes focused on the jacket she was wearing. “Is that… mine?” Mr. Logan grabbed the sleeve, raising it and dropping it again, it uselessly flopping against the rest of the leather. 
Billy couldn’t help but chuckle, his gaze dropping to the carpeted floor he was currently standing on. He quickly covered it with a cough, however, when he heard Jess begin to object. 
“What? No, Dad, it’s not yours…”
“Well it’s definitely not yours.” 
“Stan, I think it’s time the kids go, we’ve been keeping them long enough, don’t you think? Jess, you’ll be home by 2, don’t forget.” Mrs. Logan patted her husband lightly on the chest, shooing the two of them away back toward their master bedroom. She looked back and winked at her daughter, causing Jess to groan at the embarrassment she just had to endure. 
“There’s no way that jacket’s hers,” She heard her dad mumble as she quickly rushed Billy out the door, locking the handle before closing it. 
“Jeez, Jess, you couldn’t have told your parents I was coming to get you?” Billy walked to the passenger door of his car, opening it for Jess despite how annoyed he seemed with her. 
“I didn’t think it was a big deal. I told them I was going to a party…” Once Jess responded, Billy slammed the door, quickly walking around the hood and opening his own door. 
“Now I look like a total ass picking you up late at night without you telling your dad first. Jesus.” Billy turned the key in the ignition aggressively, running his other hand through his hair. “And is Steve the only person that has ever taken you anywhere?”
Jess couldn’t help but laugh at Billy’s annoyance. “Billy, you don’t look like an ass. Besides, my parents like you. For whatever reason.”
“The hell is that supposed to mean?”
“I’m just saying, my dad is pretty good at reading people.” 
“What the hell is that supposed to mean?!”
Jess giggled once more, “It’s just that you do have a reputation at Hawkins already, you know. That whole, ‘bad boy’ yada yada thing you got goin’.” 
“I do not.” 
“You definitely do, and you know it.” 
“Shut up and tell me where we’re eating, Logan.” 
Billy quickly pulled into Big Al’s, ordering Jess to not open her door. When her door was opened for her, she swung her legs out of the car and smiled teasingly up at Billy. “Look who’s getting better at being a gentleman.”
“Yeah, yeah, get out.” 
“Don’t be grumpy, Hargrove,” Jess responded, grabbing the hand he had outstretched for her and pulling herself up and out of the cockpit. “Like I said, they adore you. Stop being all freaked out. Besides, since when did you care about what my parents thought of you? You were literally flirting with my mother the first time you came over.” 
Billy grimaced at the last sentence, remembering the argument they had about that incident directly after up in her room. “Yeah, well. Like I said. I’m over there enough. Would be nice if they didn’t hate me.” Billy had yet to let go of her hand, leading her to the door of the restaurant, being sure to allow her inside first, him following closely behind. He finally dropped her hand slowly when they were inside, helping himself to two of the menus that were on the podium and leading Jess to a larger booth. 
It was surprisingly busy inside for the night it was. But apparently, everyone had the same idea: eat some satisfying, greasy food before getting shit-faced by midnight. There were even a few people she recognized from school, making her suddenly uneasy by the fact that she was with Billy alone. When she noticed the group of teenagers looking in their direction, she audibly sighed, walking faster to keep up with Billy. 
“Maybe eating here was a bad idea,” she whispered, and to her dismay, Billy looked over his shoulder at the table she was referring to, eyeing them down coldly before turning his attention back to her. 
“Why?” 
“You know-“
“Fuck ‘em.” He then smiled coolly down at her, cocking his head toward the booth he had led them to. “After you, princess.” 
Jess slid in halfway, still leaving plenty of space on both sides due to the size of the bench. As Billy slid in next to her, she shed the leather jacket from her shoulders, placing it to her right. Right when Billy was sitting comfortably, their waiter came by with a notepad and a smile. 
“Hey guys can I get you guys started with drinks?” 
“Yeah, she wants a strawberry milkshake, I’ll getta coke.” Billy then bumped Jess’s shoulder with his, grabbing her attention away from the menu. “The usual, princess?” When she wordlessly nodded, he ordered their food as well, gently taking Jess’s menu away and handing it to their waiter. 
“How do you remember all that?” Jess questioned once their waiter was out of earshot. 
“Your order really isn’t that hard, Logan.” When Jess opened her mouth to disagree, she was interrupted by the door of the diner being pushed open, the bell above indicating that more customers were arriving. 
“Oh my gosh, Jess! What are you doing here?!” Chrissy practically ran to their booth, scooting into the side opposite Jess and Billy. “Steve said you were gonna be busy with schoolwork! We’re all going to that old diner that shut down tonight if you still want to go?” She then looked knowingly at Billy, then back and Jess, smiling deviously. “Unless… you had other plans?” Her boyfriend, Jason, slid in next to her, nodding at Billy, who half-heartedly did the same. 
“Oh yeah, uh…” Jess smiled awkwardly at her friend, occasionally stealing glances at Billy that Chrissy only seemed to notice. “We were going over to Tina’s thing instead.”
“So… not homework…” Chrissy kept the same smile, but when the four of them heard the ringing of the front door again, they all shot their heads toward the sound, a larger group of teens entering this time. “Hey, Steve, look who it is!” 
Steve, along with six others, walked their way towards the booth. Billy cleared his throat, making sure to look anywhere but at Steve. “Hey, kid! What’re you doing here? Thought you had…” He then looked at who was sitting next to her and nodded his head apprehensively. “… homework.” 
“Well, yeah. I still do. But… uh… Billy kinda convinced me to go out. You know, since it’s a holiday and all…” She looked up at Steve sheepishly. He had yet to make a move to sit at the booth that was now apparently everyone else’s as well. Instead, he pressed himself at the head of the table, placing his hands in his letterman pocket. 
“So. You’re coming to Benny’s then.” Steve didn’t phrase this as a question but rather waited for Jess to agree. He had invited her before Billy convinced her to ditch the homework, and she knew that he did not expect any alternative.  
“Taking her to Tina’s actually.” Billy finally turned his gaze toward Steve, who eventually did the same, his eyes not yet leaving Jess’s until his head was fully facing Billy. 
“Really…” Steve stood there, nodding his head painfully slow, his mouth staying open as it contorted into an annoyed smile. He then clenched his teeth together and sucked in, telling Jason to scoot over as he now decided it was time to sit. “That’s funny, ‘cause, I don’t think she wanted to go to Tina’s.”
“Eh,” Billy ticked the side of his mouth upward, scooting over so the rest of those who came in the door with Steve could sit. Jess did the same, picking up the jacket and moving it on her lap. “You know, Harrington…”
“What’s that, Hargrove.” Steve now sat almost exactly across from Billy, crossing his arms on the table as Billy leaned back, draping his right arm over the side of the booth Jess was on. 
“She probably just needed the right person to ask her is all. Know what I mean.” Billy then felt a strong kick to his shin, causing him to roll his head back and over to Jess, giving her an almost apologetic glance. “Or, just needed one more person to ask.” Billy still faced Jess as he said this, giving her a ‘is that better’ kind of look. 
“It’s just… he promised to help out the next few days with our assignment, so I figured I’d have time to come out after all,” Jess eased in, her eyes downturned as she held a tight-lined smile at Steve, practically begging him not to get mad.
Before Steve could respond, the boy now next to Billy interrupted, “Dude seriously? You’ve been dodging me and Hagen all break because you say you need to go over and do that damn project and you’re still not done?” Billy couldn’t help but chuckle at his question, making Jess sweat despite no longer having multiple layers on. 
“Here you guys go.” Saved by the bell. The same waiter now had a tray containing their order from earlier, a double bacon burger, fries, and a coke for Billy, and a cheeseburger cooked medium, with no pickles and well-done fries for Jess. When the waiter placed her milkshake and the extra ketchup in front of her, he then turned his attention to the others. “Should I… get something going for you folks too?” 
Chrissy was first to order, making sure to go quickly so she could turn her attention back to Jess, who was now poking at her fries. “You didn’t tell me he was coming over all the time!” she whispered, leaning over the table, attempting to ensure Jess was the only one who heard. 
“Chris! Hush!” When Jess looked over at Billy briefly, he was already looking over at her, smirking. “We’ll talk about it Monday.” 
“We better! You don’t tell me anything anymore!” She glanced over at Billy as well, then leaned back against Jason’s arm, giving both of them a knowing look, making sure to grab one of Jess’s fries on the way back to her seat. 
“And for you?” Steve’s attention was now on the waiter and his menu, not having the time to look at it for long due to where his attention was earlier. 
“Billy,” Jess leaned closer to him when Steve began ordering. “If you’re wanting me to tell him we’re friends eventually, you’re not helping your case.” 
“What?” He whispered back, “I’m just fuckin’ with him.” 
“Then stop. Fucking. With. Him,” Jess ordered, not amused by the smirk he still had plastered on his face. 
Billy watched the way her features attempted to convey her seriousness, her brows twitching as they furrowed, her jaw slightly clenched. Instead of scaring him into obeying, however, her look just made him smile even more. He thought it was adorable. He then reached down for his fries with the arm that wasn’t draped over Jess’s seat and dunked two in her milkshake, still not breaking his smile, and before he took a bite, he looked her in the eye and rather loudly responded, “Whatever you say gorgeous.” 
Jess saw Steve’s head snap in their direction through the corner of her eye and was careful to not look over in his direction right away. Instead, she looked back over at Chrissy, who held back a smile, her lips sucked in between her teeth. Jason pretended not to hear the pet name, going for one of Jess’s fries as well and inhaling it as he cleared his throat. Jess took a long drink of her milkshake, maybe slightly hoping that she would receive a brain freeze so bad it would knock her unconscious. 
“You know what,” Steve finally chimed in again. “Tina’s thing sounds great. We should skip Benny’s.” 
“I mean, I’m down,” Jason shrugged, leaning back to look at the rest of the group. “You guys down?”
Everyone ended up agreeing, some more disappointed than others, one of the girls at the end mumbling something about ‘last minute’. 
“Perfect,” Steve said flatly. “Tina’s it is.” He then looked over at Billy eating his burger as if nothing happened, shrugging when Steve finished.
“Good for you guys,” was all he said to this, dipping his fries in Jess’s shake again before winking at her. “Look at that, more people you know are coming after all.” 
Jess and Steve ate in silence, occasionally looking over at one another, while everyone else, including Billy, chatted through their meal. When Billy was done with his, he looked over at Jess and stole one of her fries, dipping it in the ketchup she had on her plate instead of his own, making Steve’s eyes roll as he sipped mostly air through his straw. 
“You doin’ okay, princess?” Billy asked as he reached for another one, realizing she hadn’t talked much since scolding him earlier. 
“I’d be doing a lot better if you weren’t such a dick sometimes.”
“I wasn’t being a dick, Jess.” She peered at him through her eyelashes, rolling her eyes away from him when he denied it. “I’ll be nicer, alright. Promise.” 
“Well good thing you got all night to make up for it,” Jess jabbed, grabbing another bite from her burger before washing it down with her milkshake. 
“Yeah, yeah.” Billy then flagged down the waiter who was walking passed the table. “Can she get a water please?” When the waiter nodded and walked away, Jess gave him a questioning look. “You’ll thank me tomorrow morning, princess,” Billy murmured, “Plus, I’m not tryna take you back home to your parents drunk out of your mind like you were last time, you’re hydrating all night.” 
“I wasn’t drunk out of my mind!” 
Billy laughed briefly before moving even closer to her, his lips inches away from her ear. “All I know is, because of how surprised your dad was at me takin’ you out, he’s probably gonna wait all night for you, and I’d really like it if this wasn’t the first and last time he let me take you out, yeah?”
“Yeah, well. I wasn’t drunk out of my mind…” 
The waiter quickly returned with the glass of water. When it was passed all the way down to Jess, Billy asked to be let out of the booth to pay, everyone else following him to the podium, everyone except Steve. 
“Be right back, princess, then we can motor.” 
Steve scooted down the booth’s bench more, right across where Jess was sitting, then leaned back and crossed his arms. 
“Ahem…” Jess looked up innocently, her water cup in hand as she continued to drink from it. “Oh don’t give me that look, Jess… I don’t like,” Steve gestured with his hand, continuously pointing at Billy then Jess, “what the hell is going on here… what the hell is going on here?”
“He’s just trying to piss you off, Steve, okay?”
“Yeah? Well it’s working, Jess. It’s really working. I asked you again yesterday to make sure you still didn’t wanna go out, and you said no. So in between yesterday afternoon and right now, Hargrove got you to say yes?”
“Like I said, he promised we’d get done by the fourth so I just figured I wouldn’t be the only person that stayed in tonight… Please don’t be mad…” Jess pleaded, putting down her glass to look at him better. 
“I’m not mad, Jess. I’m confused. So what, you goin’ to parties with him now? And what’s with him calling you cute lil… it’s weird.”
“I mean, not really,” Jess attempted to reason with him. “He flirts with like… everyone…” 
“Well from what I hear, he’s been over at your place every damn day. Which by the way, it’s really annoying hearing shit about your best friend when it’s not coming from your best friend. So, he hasn’t exactly been able to ‘flirt with like… everyone’ this whole break. Just you.” 
“We’re just friends, Steve.”
“Oh,” His eyebrows began to rise as if he just heard some interesting news, his mouth contorting back into that annoyed smile before he blinked sarcastically, “So you’re friends with Hargrove now.” 
“Steeeevee…”
“Why don’t we just, you know, start inviting him to sit with us at lunch, or even… I don’t know… go on cute little friendship dates, where we hold hands and skip through the goddamn football field behind the school and go under the bleachers where we giggle and gossip about-“ 
“Steve knock it off.”
“I’m just saying since you’re such good friends with him now…” Steve leaned in and waved her to come closer as well, beginning to whisper as if he were going to say something important, “Is he holding you hostage? Because all you gotta do is blink twice and I’ll get you outta here and-“ 
“Oh my god, Steve!”  Jess quickly pushed herself away, slamming back into the booth harder than intended. 
“I’m just saying I have Hop on speed dial …”
“He’s not that bad, Steve, honestly.”
“Oh yeah? Tell that to my goddamn face!” Steve whisper-yelled across the table, “Look, look at my nose. I’ve been staring at it for a goddamn month and it’s crooked. Fucking crooked, Jess.” 
“No it’s not!” 
“Yes, it is!” Steve then grabbed her hand and placed it on his bridge, rubbing it against a small bump that she hadn’t noticed before. “Yeah, you see that, he broke it, Jess. Broke it! If I get hit again my nose is gonna distract all the girls from my best feature, and what the hell am I supposed to do then, huh?” 
Jess began to giggle uncontrollably, making Steve break into a smile as well. “It’s not that bad, Steve.”
“Well I’m glad you think it’s so funny, brainiac, but I’m telling you, it’s more crooked than it was three months ago.” 
“I don’t think so…” Jess looked over at the podium suddenly, seeing Billy was done and was just watching them. When he noticed Jess looking over at him, he cocked his head to the side, indicating he was ready to go. Jess then turned back to look at Steve, who already knew what she was going to say. 
“So you’re still gonna ride with him to Tina’s?”
“I came here with him, didn’t I? It would be kinda rude to ditch him… plus…” 
“He isn’t really that bad. So I heard.” 
Jess began to leave the table when she suddenly felt the jacket on her lap. She held onto it as she slid out, Steve following behind her. “Oh you gotta be kidding me…” Jess turned back around toward Steve, who was eyeing the leather jacket in her hand. She then watched as he looked over at Billy, who had on his own coat, and then back toward the other that clearly belonged to him as well. 
“It’s cold…” 
“Then wear a coat you own? Just a thought.”
“Steve…” 
“We won’t do this here, but I swear to god we’re talking about this in our Spanish class bright and early Monday morning. I don’t care if the whole conversation is ‘en español’, you’re gonna tell me everything. Got it?” 
“Got it…” 
“Enjoy the blue death trap.” 
Jess huffed as she watched Steve walk away to the podium to pay for his tab. She then turned back to Billy, who was giving her an inquiring look. When she finally reached him, he turned away from her to look at the podium for a brief moment. “You still good?” 
“Surprisingly, yes.” When Billy continued to look at her, wordlessly asking her to elaborate, she just shook her head. “Can we at least get outta here, it’s already 9…”
“Alright,” Billy gave in but instantly stopped her as she made her way to the front door, “Hang on now, princess, it’s cold out there.” He then proceeded to give her his signature, sly grin, and even though she wanted to be irritated with him, she couldn’t help but smile back. 
“You’re something else, you know that? Probably don’t even care if I’m cold, you’re just being a jackass.” 
“Sweetheart, if I didn’t care whether or not you were cold, I wouldn’t have given it to you in the first place.” He smoothly stepped closer to her, watching her shake her head in disbelief. Jess draped it over her shoulders, this time pulling her arms through the sleeves. He went ahead and fixed the collar for her, gently sliding her hair out from underneath. “Thatta girl.” He winked at her playfully before he turned around, completely missing the blush forming on her cheeks. He then nodded at Steve, eyeing him up and down once before saying, “See ya there, Harrington.” 
Taglist:
@nix-rose @fandom-princess-forevermore @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo @axionn @defenslessheart-main @the-lost-are-ignored @ahoyyharrington @strawberrykittey
34 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 3 months
Text
Prove Me Wrong
Chapter 15: Friends Don't Lie
If you need to catch up, here's the masterlist
Tumblr media
Summary: After days of not talking, Jess figures she should apologize.
Word Count: 4.4K
Warnings: Cursing, angst for sure, I think that's it? As always, if I missed anything, please let me know
Author's Note: I missed you guys :') I definitely feel out of practice so if this is shit I'm so so sorry
It had been days since Christmas Eve, and Billy had yet to come around the house. There were no taps on her window at night, no knocks on her door during the day. She hated how her room didn’t feel like hers anymore without Billy being there. She hated the way his absence made her feel. Only about a month ago, his not being here would have been welcomed. Jess would eagerly finish their shared assignment alone, hoping that Hargrove would stay away for the remainder of the break. But now? Now she was used to waking up with the blond boy sleeping on the floor by the foot of the bed. She was used to him griping about the movies she would put on, or about having to read a book he would never touch again. The thought of Billy made her reach slightly below her collarbone and fiddle with the necklace he had gotten for her for Christmas, reaching for the note that she now kept in her nightstand.  
Before you say anything 
yeah, I know the stupid horse isn’t in the book. 
It should be. 
But I saw this and thought of you anyway. 
Thanks for reading to me like a child
Merry Christmas Princess
-Billy
Jess sighed while rereading the note, remembering the argument they had over whether the Trojan Horse was in The Iliad or not. They were lying in her bed, as they had every night for a week before Christmas Eve. Billy had been throwing one of Jess’s stuffed bears up in the air like a basketball, catching it at his chest before passing it back to the imaginary person on the ceiling. 
“So when is that big ass horse in the book?” 
“Huh?” The question made Jess prop herself up on her elbow to look over at Billy. 
“You know. That thing they hide in to get into the city.”
“You know about the Trojan Horse?” 
Jess’s surprised tone caused Billy to pause his game of one-person catch, twiddling with the bear’s ear. “Jesus. How long is it gonna take for you to realize I’m not an actual idiot?” 
“I don’t think you’re an idiot! I’m just… it’s just cool you know about it,” Jess defends, giggling at the end. 
“So when is it in?” Billy threw the bear back up in the air again, a little too hard this time, causing it to bounce off the ceiling and back down aggressively toward Billy’s head, which he quickly dodged, catching it with his right hand. 
“It’s actually not.” 
“Bullshit.” He pauses tossing the bear up in the air again, propping himself up just as Jess had to look at her properly. 
“I’m serious. The book doesn’t make it to the end of the war.” 
“Then how the hell does everyone know about it?” 
Jess shrugs as much as she can with her free shoulder. “It’s in the next one I think.”
“The next what? Book?” 
Jess nods at his question, smiling at him as she raises her eyebrows. “Jesus. There’s another goddamn book?” His question made Jess laugh harder than she had earlier, leading to Billy feigning annoyance, rolling his eyes while giving her a lopsided smile. “Well, it should be in the fucking book we’re reading. That’d be badass.” 
“Why don’t you just read the other one after? It’s called The Odyssey. I have it here somew-“
“Fuck no! I’m barely getting through this one!”
Jess pushed her head farther back into her pillow, tossing the note back into its home, her other hand running over the golden horse that was attached to its matching, dainty chain. She had been wearing it since the night Billy handed her the small, wrapped package, and had only taken it off to shower and sleep, placing it atop Billy’s handwritten note anytime she did. She, however, made it a point to tuck the small horse away under the top she would wear, not wanting her parents to question her about her new gift. And when she saw Steve Harrington’s car pull up in her driveway yesterday afternoon, she hurriedly threw on the first turtleneck she could find, shamefully realizing at that moment this was why Billy Hargrove was mad at her in the first place. 
Jess looked over to the right side of the bed, Billy’s side. Even if he never actually slept there through the night, she slowly realized how she was now leaving room for someone on that side, no longer sleeping closer to the middle as she used to. She groaned as she lifted herself from where she was. Looking at herself in the mirror, she made sure that this time, the necklace was now untucked from her sweater and admired it for a moment before retreating downstairs to the kitchen. 
She was greeted by her mother, who was organizing the pantry with what she just brought home from the store a few moments ago. “Morning, hun.”
“Morning, Mom.” It was in fact no longer morning, but instead a little after one in the afternoon. By this time, Jess would have been up and about, either doing homework with Billy, or out with him getting lunch at Big Al’s, or maybe even out with Steve as they drove passed the new mall that was being developed. Jess and Billy drove by that mall all the time too, him joking about how it was going to be “super lame” because “which stores would actually want to develop here?” 
Instead, however, she had been in her room moping all morning, too stubborn to speak with him first, but coming to the realization that Billy was much more stubborn than she was. She and Steve barely ever fought, and even if they did, he was always the first to break the silence, coming to her first with an apology. Steve and her also never went days without talking like this. 
When Jess made her way passed her mother to the refrigerator, Mrs. Logan took notice of the necklace around her daughter’s neck. “Oh, that’s pretty. Is it new?” Mrs. Logan asked, now rotating the flour from the top shelf. 
“Uh, yeah…” Jess paused for a moment, retrieving 3 cranberry muffins from the fridge, and closing the door once they were secure in her hands. She hesitated for a moment more, looking down at what she could see of the necklace, and then looked back at her mother. “… Billy gave it to me for Christmas…” 
This made her mother pause what she was doing, her hands leaving the sack of flour so that her body could turn to face Jess more directly, being sure to look at the necklace once more.  “Well, it’s very pretty,” Beverly said with a knowing smile, causing Jess to shake her head, realizing this was the exact reason why she had been hiding the necklace away in the first place. “You know, I haven’t seen him around for a few days, which is… strange…” Beverly continued, “Everything alright?” 
“Yes, Mom. It’s not like he has to be here every single minute. And one of those days happened to be Christmas. So,” Jess snapped back.
“Okaaaaay. I’m just saying, he’s been here a lot recently…” She continued to give her daughter the same smile. 
“Mom. Please stop.”
“What? I’m just saying. He seems to enjoy being around here. That’s all.” 
“Steve’s here all the time too, Mom.” 
“Yes, that’s true…” She went back to fixing the flour. “But Steve got you that sweater for Christmas, hun, not a piece of jewelry.” 
Jess huffed at her mother’s quick response. “I should probably go.” 
“To Billy’s?”
“Mom.” 
Mrs. Logan only chuckled at her annoyed tone. “Really quick, there’s something I’ve been meaning to ask you. Steve and Billy, they’re not exactly friends, are they?” 
“Yeah… not exactly.” Jess leaned against the counter across from her mother, placing all three muffins down and twirling around one of them, the bottom of the lining circling the granite. 
“Your father and I could tell. Dinner was… interesting to say the least.” 
Jess snorted at her mother’s description. “I told you not to invite them.” 
As if reading her daughter’s mind, she again stopped what she was doing, and moved closer to Jess, pausing in front of her for a moment before continuing. “You know, you can be friends with both of them. Steve’s a good boy. He cares about you. He’ll understand.” 
“It’s not exactly that simple…” 
“And why not?” 
“Well…” Jess stopped spinning the muffin around and sighed, looking from the counter to her mother. “They kind of… got into a fight not too long ago. Like November…” 
“Oh… like. A fight fight?” Jess only nodded. “How’d Steve do?” 
“You remember that time him and Joyce’s son got into a fight?”
“Ah. So not very good.” 
“Nope.” 
“Well, sweetheart, Steve’s your friend, but you don’t always have to do what you think he wants. You are allowed to have other friends. Billy’s a good boy too. Who knows, maybe you’ll be the reason they become cordial.” 
“Yeah. Right,” Jess laughs out sarcastically but quickly stops. “Mom?” 
“Yeah, hun?” 
“You don’t think Steve’ll hate me?” 
“I think you two have been through too much together for him to hate you.” 
If she only knew how true that was. Jess pondered it for a moment, nodding her head slowly at the possibilities of how Steve could react to the news of her actually enjoying Billy Hargrove. There were a few options. One, and highly unlikely, Jess would tell Steve the truth and Steve would automatically accept it, not caring that she was now spending her nights with the dude who would have loved nothing more than to beat his face in a little over a month ago. Option two, which her mother was most likely banking on, would be that he would feel a little put out and would need a bit to process it, but ultimately accept her decision and would move forward. And then there was option three, the option Jess dreaded, the option that she was sure would have happened until now, Steve refusing to talk to Jess again. 
However, her mom was right. Steve was her best friend. She was the one who stayed with him through his relationship with Nancy, and their breakup. Hell, they’ve fought demi dogs together with a bunch of children. He wouldn’t just drop her for not seeing eye to eye with him, would he? 
Jess grabbed the muffins from the counter, finding a new surge of motivation. “Thanks, Mom.” 
“Of course.” 
“I should uh, I should probably get going…”
“To Billy’s?” 
“Yes, Mom, to Billy’s.”
“Well tell him I said hi.” 
Jess promised that she would and headed toward the door, grabbing her jacket as she exited her house. It wasn’t as cold as it had normally been, but it was still cold enough for her to want to hurry and hand the muffins off so she could be able to put on her jacket. She made the short walk over to Hargrove’s/Mayfield’s home, seeing Billy’s blue Camaro being the only car in the driveway.
At least he’s home.
Jess hesitated at the door for a moment, wondering whether this was a good idea. It had only really been two days since Christmas, maybe he just needed a little more time. Maybe he wasn’t actually mad and apologizing would just make her look stupid. Maybe he doesn’t want to see her, or he’s busy, or-
“MAX! If you want me to drop you off at that damn arcade with your freak friends, then hurry up!” Billy opened the door as he yelled the last part, practically screaming in Jess’s face before he turned around and realized there was someone at the door. They both paused, not yet saying anything, both staring the other down. However, Billy’s expression differed from Jess’s. While Billy attempted not to show any emotion whatsoever, his face as still as stone, Jess looked as if she was a deer caught in headlights. Billy was the first to break the silence, walking passed Jess to get to his car, practically bumping her out of the way. “If you’re wanting to finish up the project, it’s gonna have to wait. I’m busy.” 
Jess’s shoulders deflated. So he was mad. “That’s… that’s not why I’m here.” Her confession caused Billy to pause at his car door, both his hands placed on the roof while he hung his head slightly. 
“Then what?”
“I, umm…” Jess moved to where he was, standing by the hood of his car. “I brought you some muffins… you’re favorite…” 
Billy took one of the cranberry orange muffins handed to him and took a small bite. “My favorite’s actually the blueberry ones,” he deadpanned, not returning eye contact. 
“Oh… I just thought. You always asked for these ones. So. Nevermind. Sorry.” 
“So you just here to drop these off then?” He finally looked at her again and watched the way her gaze dropped to the concrete driveway as she shook her head in response. His gaze then traveled down to where the necklace sat against her sweater, causing him to clench his jaw to keep from smiling. 
“Billy, I-“
“I get it, Jess. Okay? I do.”
“Then why are you upset?” Billy sighed, throwing his head up to where he was looking at the sky then back down to where his eyes were now meeting hers. He knew exactly why. He knew how much he hated how he couldn’t walk the halls with her without the both of them looking around to see who was watching. He hated how quickly she would separate herself from him when she saw Steve coming her way, how he could spend every night with Jess and it still wouldn’t be enough for him to have a chance of staying in her life after this shared assignment was over. 
“Jess. I just thought-“ 
“Hey!” Max had finally exited the house and closed their front door, running over to Jess and hugging her. “Oh, thanks.” She took one of the muffins Jess had in her hand, turning away to enter the other side of the car.  
Jess handed the third to Billy and turned to face her own home. “I can… I can come back when you’re not so busy. I’ll-“
“Max, get in the back.” 
“No really, Billy, I don’t want to-“ 
“Get in the car, Jess.” 
Max did as she was told, climbing over the middle console as she normally did when Jess was tagging along. Jess then sat in the seat beside Billy, who was already starting his car. Once her door was closed, Billy peeled out of his driveway and sped toward the end of their street, turning without much of a stop at their street’s stop sign. They had arrived in front of the Palace Arcade even quicker than he’s accomplished before, possibly due to the tension in the car. Once they got close to the entrance, Billy stomped on his brakes, causing Jess to lurch forward.
“Alright, shitbird-“ 
“I know, I know. I have an hour.” 
Max began to climb through the middle before Billy stopped her, looking at Jess intently before he decided, “You can make it three.” Max’s face lit up, scrambling to get out of the car before he changed his mind. “But hey! I want you out here when I come get you!” Max nodded, slamming the door before Billy even finished his sentence. 
Jess sat there, making herself as small as she could, now feeling the awkwardness of having just them two in the car. It normally wouldn’t have felt this way; she typically liked it when it was just them two. Now, however, she wasn’t exactly sure where she stood with him. Jess began fiddling with the charm on her necklace, causing Billy to look over at her and decide to park in the arcade parking lot. 
“What are we doing?”  Jess looked around, slightly confused. “We’re not sitting here for three hours… are we?” 
He continued to watch the way she grabbed at her necklace, which was something new for her, as he’s never actually seen her wear one before. “No. Just. Thought you wanted to talk.” He looked down at her necklace again, realizing she wasn’t planning on saying anything anytime soon, so he decided to ease the pressure. “Cute necklace.” 
Jess smiled sheepishly at his joke. “Yeah? Some asshole gave it to me as a Christmas present.” 
“Is that so?” Billy chuckled a bit at her comeback, looking out her window before turning his attention back on her. “Well, that asshole has great taste.” When he earned a laugh from her, he looked down at her sweater, something else she had on that was new. “You get this for Christmas too?” He grabbed the bottom of it gently and rubbed it in between his fingers, just as he did with the sleeve of her dress Christmas Eve, making Jess’s stomach erupt. 
“Yeah. Yeah, it was. Steve actually got it for me.” 
Billy quickly removed his hand from the sweater and shifted in his seat, pushing his head into the headrest. “Fuckin’ Steve.” 
“What?”
“You couldn’t have come see me with another damn sweater on?”  He teased, though only slightly, as he was also somewhat serious. It was ironic to him that the first time he was seeing his present for her on, it was accompanied by something Harrington got for her, and that didn’t necessarily sit right with him, though he knew he had no right to think that way. 
“See, this is exactly why I don’t tell Steve about anything. Because you two absolutely hate each other! You can’t even stand that I’m in a sweater he simply got me for Christmas.” 
“Listen, alright, I’m sorry for freaking out Christmas Eve. But Jesus. I’ve been hanging out with you non-stop for weeks now, Jess. Isn’t he gonna find out eventually?” 
Jess didn’t know how to respond. As always, he was right, even if she wished he wasn’t. “I just want him to find out on my terms, Billy. That’s all.” 
“And what exactly are those terms? You gonna tell him after you ditch me once our project is done like you’ve been promising him you’d do? Huh?”
“Billy, what…”
“I heard you that day after practice, Jess, okay?” 
“And what about you? You don’t-” 
“Yeah, well, the difference between you and me is I don’t mean the shit I say to them. You fucking do.” Billy began running his fingers through his hair in frustration, slightly messing up the curls that he seemed to have worked hard on this morning. 
“I didn’t realize you cared what I say to Steve…” 
“I do when it’s true.” The left corner of his mouth ticked downward as he cleared his throat. He then turned away from her, looking out his front window, which was now faced at the brick wall of the arcade. He scrunched his nose in irritation as he had yet to hear a response from Jess. “Be straight with me, Logan, after this project, we goin’ back to how shit was before?” 
“I…” Jess paused, looking down at her lap, and then followed Billy’s gaze to the windowed brick wall right in front of them, being able to find Max and Lucas standing at a machine by themselves, laughing, while the other three boys and El were huddled around another machine. She had been watching them for too long, as Billy sighed, slamming his head back into his headrest. 
“Really wish I would have known that before all this shit.”
“Wait… Billy…” Her attention quickly snapped back to him, who was now looking everywhere but at her. 
“Jess. I don’t care. Just would have been fucking nice to know.” His demeanor, however, betrayed his words. He was clenching his jaw again, as he did when she first saw him this afternoon, but he was now blinking rapidly, looking around the parking lot once more before he opened his door to get out of the car. Without a word, he slammed the door shut. Jess watched as he reached into his coat pocket, pulled out his pack of reds and placed on in between his lips. At this moment, Jess decided to follow him out, rounding the front of the car to the driver’s side. 
“Fucking piece of shit.” Billy was now aggressively raking his finger across the starter of the lighter, failing each time to get it to light. He groaned as he realized he might not get it to work, but continued to try, looking over to see Jess had joined him outside. “What.”
“I didn’t mean it.” 
“What’re you talking about?” Billy looked down at his lighter, which finally decided to spark, and brought it up to his cigarette before letting it go and putting it back into his pocket. He took a long drag from it before Jess spoke up again. 
“What I said to Steve, everything I’ve said to Steve. I don’t mean it.” Billy shot his head in Jess’s direction, his eyes fixated on hers, seeing if they held any insincerity. He stood there a moment, letting his red continue to burn at his side, and when the ash began to grow, he finally broke eye contact, flicking the butt of his cigarette, and letting the collection of ash drop on his boot. 
“What happened to ‘friends don’t lie’?” 
“Well, I’ve been a pretty shit friend lately…” Her voice shook faintly.
Billy’s gaze left the ash still on his foot and returned to Jess, his eyes holding a softness she was not yet used to. “No you haven’t.” He gave her a sympathetic smile, which she briskly returned, and opened his right arm for her, still holding his Marlboro in his other hand. In two quick steps, she closed the gap between them, wrapping both arms around his waist while Billy’s free arm pulled her in. She normally would have looked behind her, through the window, to ensure none of the six teenagers she knew would have seen them. She would have made the hug short if she even went in for it at all. 
But all that is what caused this in the first place. 
“I’m really sorry…” 
Billy clicked the roof of his mouth with his tongue, pulling her away only so he could look at her better. “I get it. Look. You don’t have to tell Harrington. That’s not what… Just… It’d be cool if I still got to hang with you even if we’re not doing homework together anymore.”
“I mean, to be fair, I’ll still probably need you for pre-calc. You know, considering you’re a math whizz and all.” Jess beamed up at him, causing Billy to roll his eyes playfully. 
“Oh yeah? And what about summer? Still gonna need me?” He looked down at her the same way that always made her wordless, his eyes starting at her own, slowly regarding each of her characteristics as he made his way down to her lips, occasionally stopping on a certain feature of hers, squinting ever so slightly as if to dial in and appreciate it even more than he already had before. She couldn’t continue to watch him and turned away, hoping she did so just in time before her blush became evident. 
“I think so.” 
Billy smirked in response, reaching down to hold the gold horse in between his thumb and index finger. “Gold’s your color.” 
“Yeah, well, like you said, the guy who got it for me has great taste.”
“Yeah, he does.” But even though he continued to hold on to the charm, he was no longer looking at it. Instead, he was again looking at her. She furrowed her eyebrows as he continued to stare into her, not sure if she understood what he meant. As her mind began to wander, Jess felt a slight shiver run down her back, which Billy mistook for her being cold. 
“Get in the car, gorgeous.” Though he had only a puff from his red, he threw it down on the asphalt and snuffed it with the ball of his boot. Jess moved to the other side of the car, opening the passenger door and climbing into the cockpit, with Billy moving in next to her shortly afterward. 
“So where are we going?” 
Billy looked over at her and down at her necklace again, grinning to himself for only a moment. “Wherever you want.” 
“Oh, can we uh. Can you teach me how to drive again? If we have the time?” Jess asked, looking at Billy hopefully. 
“Oh Jesus,” Billy groaned, smiling a bit while he looked out his front window, nodding to himself. He threw his car in reverse and reached his right arm across Jess’s headrest, backing out of the parking spot with ease. “Whatever you want.” 
Jess bounced in her seat excitedly, causing Billy to chuckle, muttering, “Don’t make me regret this, Logan.” As they continued to drive to the abandoned space she had practiced in before, Jess was unable to look anywhere but at Billy Hargrove, who was now drumming his steering wheel with the music, completely unaware that the girl next to him was imagining how his hand would feel on her lap while he drove with his other, or maybe he would rather hold her hand in his. She imagined what it would be like to park on the side of the road, or her driveway, or a parking lot, and watch him lean over the middle console, feel his hand at the base of her neck pulling her in, and have his lips on hers. She imagined what it would be like to wake up with Billy in her room with her, and instead of him being on the floor, he had her pulled in next to him in the comfort of her bed. 
“What’re you thinking about?” Billy caught Jess’s gaze, noticing the way her pupils stayed dilated before he’d brought her back to reality with his question. He continued to stare at her curiously, only shifting his eyes away to look at the road briefly. 
Jess shook the thoughts away as she finally looked away from him. “Nothing. Just zoned out I guess.” 
“What happened to ‘friends don’t lie’?”
Yeah. Well. They’re not supposed to make you feel like this, either.
Taglist: @nix-rose @fandom-princess-forevermore @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo @axionn @defenslessheart-main @the-lost-are-ignored @ahoyyharrington @strawberrykittey
46 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 6 months
Text
Prove Me Wrong
Chapter 14: Wonderin' Where I Am
If you need to catch up, here's the masterlist
Tumblr media
Summary: Things become tense at Christmas Dinner
Warnings: Swearing, angst, mentions of bruising, mentions of Neil. As always let me know if I missed anything!
Word Count: 4.4k
Authors Note: I had to give Jess a walking down the stairs in a dress scene. She deserves it
Jess awoke Christmas Eve morning with a knot in her stomach. It was currently 9:22 AM, which was much too early for her to be up considering she was up with Billy Hargrove until about 4 in the morning last night. 
It had been a little over a week since they watched Friday the 13th, and almost every night after Billy had been over, whether her parents knew about it or not. He had left her alone the couple nights following that one, not wanting to come off as desperate or pushy, until eventually, he used the excuse of their shared project that he honestly couldn’t care less about. The week started off with him just coming over for homework, but quickly turned to him knocking on her window and her pretending not to notice new bruises forming or new cuts appearing. She had tried a few times to offer ice or Neosporin, but her offers were always waived away. After the third fight resulting in Billy seeking sanctuary, Jess let it go. He mentioned how irritable his dad gets towards the Holidays, and how he’s forced to stay home longer to “take his mandatory vacation”, which explained the constant fighting. It came to a point where Billy was able to avoid the fighting entirely, exchanging the nights spent at home with nights with Jess. It became a strange constant with them, and Jess always wondered how her parents would feel if they found out about her sneaking a boy into her room late at night and allowing him to stay until after Mr. Logan left for work. 
She also wondered how Steve would feel. 
He, like her parents, had no idea how she was truly spending her nights. And though she had seen him as well since school was let out for break, the subject of Billy never truly came up, unless, of course, he asked about her project. Now that they would be under the same roof for Christmas Eve, however, she worried that it might come out, that Billy would divulge details of their strange new friendship, whether it be accidental or to get a rise out of Steve. 
Jess slowly slid out of her bed, her legs fighting to stay under the warmth of her covers. If it had been any other morning after spending all night with Billy, she would have looked at the clock and immediately went back to sleep. She felt the need to be ready today. She felt the need to prepare. She shuffled over to her dresser, staring at the disheveled hair and large, swollen eye bags she was currently sporting. She hung her head for a moment, finding the energy to walk to her closet and search her closet for the dress that she wore last year. Once her legs decided to move, she opened her closet and walked over the clothes, shoes, and gear to make it to the back, where the red satin dress hung for a year. She unhooked it along with the hanger and stumbled over to the door again, laying it delicately on her bed, the end of it draping over her footboard. She rubbed the fabric of the right sleeve between her fingers before walking out of her room to the bathroom, looking forward to her warm shower. 
Turning on the shower head, she placed her hand under the running water, instantly regretting not waiting another minute, the cold water piercing her wrist and palm; an immense contrast to sleeping in her sweatshirt under her comforter. She stripped from her clothes, using the sweatshirt to dry her wet hand, hoping to warm it some, before placing the opposite hand under the water. The water was much warmer now, though not yet at the temperature she preferred. However, she stepped in anyway, knowing that it would feel much better than the cold she was feeling now. 
Jess huddled underneath the water, her muscles relaxing more as it gradually became warmer. When she no longer felt the chill that came with the lack of clothes, she began lathering shampoo in her hair and soap on her body, careful to take her time. She needed everything to go perfect, to look perfect, to smell perfect. Though she couldn’t quite put a pin into why it needed to be perfect, Jess chalked it up to having both the Harrington’s and the Hargrove’s over in one night. Of course, there was Billy, who was now continuously giving her butterflies and causing her to second guess everything she ever did around him, this wasn’t the only factor that was making her overanalyze everything. 
She would have new people in her home, Max, whom she wasn’t too worried about if she was being honest, Susan, whom she hasn’t really said a single word to since meeting her, and Neil. Neil was what made her stomach churn the most. She was aware that he would be around her intimate area now, her home. And that he would be around her mother for the first time, which scared her even more. She knew of his temper, though also knew of his ability to hold his temper around company. Which is why she wanted everything to be perfect, not necessarily for her sake, but for both Billy and Max. 
She stepped out and wrapped her towel around her as quickly as possible, attempting to beat the cold air. She flipped the toilet lid down and sat there for a moment, still exhausted from the lack of sleep. When she finally stood up again, she picked up her clothes that were scattered on the bathroom floor and began to walk back to her bedroom, deciding to finish getting ready for the evening in there. 
When Jess heard the doorbell ring for the first time tonight, she hurried out the hall to the stairs, anxious to see who it was. When she saw Neil and Susan enter first, she immediately slowed her pace down the steps, wanting her parents to be the first to greet them. She then saw Billy walk through the door, wearing a hardened, distorted smile. He began to look back at someone behind him, who Jess assumed was Max, and started to open his mouth. Before he was able to speak, however, Jess caught his attention as she continued to slowly walk down the stairs.
Billy’s wry smile fell suddenly as he took in her appearance. Her hair was pinned back on one side, sweeping it out of her freshly done face, the makeup look being something he remembered from the party they had recently attended, the only difference being that her lips were now lightly tinted red, which matched the red silk that was draped perfectly over her body. His eyes left her lips to the sweetheart neckline that fell below the hems of the sleeves, which met with the dress in the middle of her shoulders, accentuating her collarbone. The extra fabric of the sleeves made them puff faintly before fitting tightly below her elbow where they ended. Billy continued to gaze at her in amazement, his eyes finally arriving at the A-line skirt that hugged her figure until it met the top of her hips, breaking away and flaring ever so slightly. 
He returned to her lips again. She was smiling at him the way she normally did, but Billy Hargrove felt everything but normal in that moment. He began to open his mouth to speak again, but Max grew tired of him blocking the doorway, which he had been doing without him realizing until Jess made it completely down the stairs. 
“Move, asshole,” Max whispered, shoving Billy out of the way, closing the door behind her. She then caught a glimpse at Jess as well and stole Billy’s words from him, “Holy shit, Jess, you look amazing!”
“Maxine! Language!” 
Max gave an apologetic smile to her mother, who was then reassured by Jess’s mother that it was alright and mumbled something about Max being right. 
“Yeah, thanks,” Jess said sheepishly, “It’s just the dress I wore last year, so…” She began to look back at Billy before being called by her mother to introduce herself to the Hargroves, again. Jess turned away from the two for a moment, allowing Billy to take in the back of the dress, which plunged under her shoulder blades. Billy’s eyes roamed down her body for a moment, then looked shamefully down to his feet. He began to feel uncomfortable with the amount of people in the room, partially wishing it were just the two of them. 
But then, what exactly would he do if it were just the two of them?
Nothing.
It had always been just the two of them. And yet, here he was, still painfully aware of how she was able to make his heart stop within a second and still not willing to do a single thing about it. His mind continued to race, becoming frustrated that she looked like this, and he was unable to tell her just how beautiful she was to him. 
And then, the doorbell rang. Knowing who it was, Billy ushered Max to the living room where the parents were standing, brushing passed Jess as she made her way toward the door. Mrs. Logan pulled Billy in a tight hug, telling him how happy she was to have him there, letting go to do the same thing for Max. 
Jess quickly turned the door handle to reveal a shivering Steve Harrington, who had a small stack of presents in his right arm, his other free to pull Jess into a hug before stepping forward to allow his parents in. 
“Heyyy girl, look at you! You look great!” Steve then grabbed the wrapped boxes with both hands, pointing with them to his right. “Where you want these?” Jess nodded her head to where he was pointing, feeling Mrs. Harrington hug her from behind. 
“Merry Christmas, love,” she said warmly, walking over with her husband to greet the Logans. Steve began to carry the presents under the tree when he stopped abruptly. 
“What the f-“
“I told you, we were having other people over…” Jess nudged Steve secretly, as if asking him to behave.
He bent his head down slightly to her level, still not taking his eyes off Billy. “You never said he was the ‘other people’.”
Jess feigned a smile, looking up at Steve and then back at the crowd they had in the living room. “Max is here too, you know…” She then looked over at Billy as well, who now had a smug smile plastered on his face, crossing his arms as he sized up Steve for a moment. 
“Hey there, Harrington.”
Steve snorted out a laugh, rolling his eyes as he walked straight to the tree. 
“Oh, Steve!” Mrs. Logan took the presents from him, hugging and wishing him a Merry Christmas. “You know Billy? He told us you were on the team together. His father is the new security guard at Stan’s job. Stan?” 
Mr. Logan looked away from the conversation he was having with both the Hargroves and the Harringtons. “Yeah, hun? Oh, yes.” He broke away from the group and walked toward Steve, patting him on the back before steering him toward Mr. and Mrs. Hargrove to properly introduce him to the rest. “… And of course, you know their son Billy…” 
Steve cocked his head back, staring at Billy with the same intensity that Billy was staring at him. Jess watched as Steve clenched his jaw before speaking. “Yup,” he muttered, clearing his throat, “he’s just, great.” The sarcasm dripping from his compliment caught Mr. Logan off guard, causing him to whip his head to face Steve, and then Billy, furrowing his eyebrows at the both of them in confusion. 
“Ookaayy…” But before Mr. Logan could question it further, Max moved Billy out of the way to greet Steve, excited to see him finally this break. 
“Hey! Great job on Dustin’s hair, by the way, he didn’t look like a total freakazoid like I thought he would.”
Steve chuckled lightly, “Hey kid. I actually didn’t do it; it was all him.” He then peered behind him, leaning back to give Jess another annoyed look. “If I would have known you were coming, I would have got you something…” He made sure to speak loud enough for Jess to hear while she pretended she didn’t. 
Mrs. Logan clapped her hands once, asking for everyone’s attention. “Dinner’s just about ready and the table is set… so if everyone wants to go take their seats while me and Stan get everything out…” 
Mrs. Harrington of course refused to sit without helping, patting Stan lightly and inviting him to go sit with her husband, which he did reluctantly. The grown-ups happened to migrate towards the end closest to the kitchen, leaving the opposite end for Jess, Steve, Max, and Billy. Jess took the seat on the corner, Max sitting across from her. Steve took the chair to Jess’s right, which left the seat at the end of the table for Billy. 
Billy brushed passed Jess’s chair, sitting to her left at the end. He continued to give Steve a sly smirk, but when Jess would catch his eye, he dropped it and avoided eye contact with her, which she thought to be strange. 
“So Hargrove, what you been up to so far, huh? Drinking with Tommy get boring yet?”
Billy snickered bitterly at Steve’s statement, “You know what, Harrington? I haven’t actually seen Hagen yet. Like I said, I’ve just been doing whatever this one says.” He tapped Jess’s hand, still without looking at her. 
“So homework then. Isn’t that fun...” 
Billy grinned at Steve again, swiping his teeth like he normally did when contemplating how to ruin Steve’s day. His eyes shot at Jess momentarily before locking in on Steve again, biting the inside of his cheek. “So that’s what she’s been telling you, huh?” 
Jess’s back straightened suddenly as she turned toward Billy with wide eyes. She shook her head as carefully as she could so that Steve wouldn’t notice. When Billy finally faced her, her eyebrows contorted with her irritation and horror. However, her face relaxed a bit as she watched Billy’s features change as well. He clenched his jaw for a moment as his eyes displayed what Jess could have sworn was anger before he leaned back in his chair and rolled his eyes away from her, staring toward the other end of the table. 
Steve had not noticed his change in demeanor, however. He was currently nodding his head in disbelief. He laughed through his nose, looking at Max, who immediately shrugged her shoulders, and then looked at Jess, holding an annoyed smile as he clicked his tongue with the roof of his mouth. He leaned in so his shoulder was against Jess’s, now looking away to not give off the impression that he was questioning her. “What the hell is he talking about…”
“I don’t even know. He’s just being stupid.” Jess looked pointedly back over at Billy, watching the way his jaw clamped even tighter when he heard her excuse.
Mrs. Logan and Mrs. Harrington began to bring out large dishes, Mrs. Logan placed the mashed potatoes at the teens’ end, being sure to mention she knew how much both Billy and Steve enjoyed them. Both boys smile at her politely before glancing in each other’s direction, Steve looking more vexed than Billy did. 
“Alright, gang, let’s eat!” Mr. Logan announced, causing Steve to get up as quickly as possible, his mismatched chair dragging against the floor loudly. Everyone else followed suit, making their way to the food they were currently loading their plates with. The only two who remained by their seats were Billy and Jess. 
Billy slowly added mashed potatoes to his plate, Jess staring at him, obviously displeased. 
“What.”
“What happened to behaving?”
“What happened to ‘friends don’t lie’?” 
“I’m not lying!” Jess hissed, looking over her shoulder to see if anyone was interested enough to listen in on their conversation. 
“Whatever you say, princess,” he said, his tone accusatory. He then plopped the serving spoon back in the potatoes rather aggressively, but when he looked up and met her eyes again, the anger he held in his gaze melted away. Though he was irritated with her, he knew most of the irritation stemmed from him being unable to relax around her like he was able to without Steve Harrington there to ruin it. He began to feel put out by the fact that no matter how many nights he spent with her, how many secrets he divulged, how many times he made her laugh, she would always choose Steve Harrington. And she would always choose to keep him a secret. Not that he could really blame her, but that doesn’t mean he couldn’t be bitter about it. Besides, he was in love with this girl, how could he not be bitter?
Fuck.
No. That couldn’t be true. He couldn’t actually be in love with her. There was no way. No way he was in love with the way she smiled, the way she looked at him when no one else was around. No way he was in love with quietly listening to her read to him as his mind continued to wander about whether she knew how much he loved seeing her pull her hair back in the clip she used only when they studied. No way that he secretly wished that she was in love with him too. There was no way. Because he didn’t even know what that word even meant. He clenched his jaw again, but this time it wasn’t out of anger. He left Jess standing there by herself, filling his plate even if he no longer had an appetite. 
When everyone sat back down, the adults continued to talk amongst themselves, conversation ranging from work to what their neighbors have been up to. When the conversation shifted to the high school basketball tournament which was being held in late February, their attention turned to the boys sitting at the end of the table, who were now avoiding eye contact. 
“How’s the team looking this year, son? We haven’t been to a game in a month it feels like.” Mr. Logan was looking over at Steve, which caused him to force the bit of turkey down with his water before he answered. 
“Yeah, we had a few away games, but we’re doing okay I think. Looking good for February.” Steve looked over at his father, who gave him a nod of approval. 
“Some of us are having trouble planting our feet.” Billy chimed in flatly, taking a forkful of mashed potatoes when he was done. 
“You know,” Steve cleared his throat, turning his body to face Billy, “I’ve been noticing a different problem.” He then shifted his body back toward Mr. Logan, who, along with the rest of the adults, was eyeing both boys peculiarly. “We’ve been having problems fouling, you know what I mean. Some of us even get benched in the middle of some games because they can’t seem to figure out how not to go a game without a technical.”
Billy shrugged at this, smiling to himself as he continued to look down and eat his food. Jess looked up at Max, who was minding her business, happily putting away what was on her plate. She was either oblivious to what was happening, or simply didn’t care, Jess hadn’t decided. She then looked over at Steve, who had a hardened look on his face, his hair partially coming undone from how many times he ran his fingers through it tonight. And then there was Billy, who continued to look smug in his seat, occasionally giving Jess strange looks that she couldn’t decipher. 
“The girls are getting ready for the bake sale,” Jess announced suddenly, attempting to change the subject and ease the tension that she wasn’t sure whether the rest of the party could feel yet. 
“Oh, a bake sale? How fun!” Susan voiced with a smile, looking around the table for more elaboration. 
“Oh yes, the girls on the cheer team always do a bake sale when the tournament starts,” Jess’s mom began, causing everyone’s attention to veer away from Jess’s end of the table, something she was grateful for. 
Dinner ended with Mr. and Mrs. Logan placing both a pumpkin and apple pie on the table. Jess got up to get a slice of pumpkin, but only picked at it when she sat back down, ready for this exhausting night to be over. They continued to talk for what seemed like hours after the pie was brought out until finally, Mr. and Mrs. Harrington rose from the table. 
Jess got up as well, hugging Steve goodbye and walking with him toward the door. “Sorry about… tonight,” she whispered, looking behind her as she spoke. 
“Not like you invited him.” He looked over at Billy one last time before shaking his head. 
“Right…”
Steve then raised his hand, now looking over at Max, “See ya, kid.” 
“BYE!” 
Steve then gave Jess a sympathetic smile before following his parents out the door, looking back as she gave him one last goodbye. Jess then closed the door behind them, turning back to the rest of the table. 
“Well thank you so much, Stan, Bev, we should probably get-“
“Wait, Jess, can I see you’re TV first?” Max interrupted her mother, excitedly moving her chair back and walking around Billy. 
“Uh, yeah, sure. If it’s okay with your mom.”
Susan looked over at Neil, who was now wearing a tight-lined smile, something that made Jess anxious. “Sure. Sure, honey. But then we have to leave.”
“Sure, mom,” was all Max said in response. Max then ran up the stairs as if she already knew where her room was. Jess took her time walking up the steps, careful to not catch one of her heels on the edge of a stair, and finally made it to a bouncing Max. 
Jess opened her bedroom door, Max rushing in without hesitation. 
“You’re room’s so cool.”
“It’s alright I guess.”
“I would kill to have a room this big.” Max was now walking around to the other side of the bed where she suddenly made a strange face. “Why do you have beer under your bed? I thought you hated beer. 
“Oh shit.” Jess quickly made it to where Max was standing, slowly bending down to retrieve what was left of Billy’s six-pack he had a week ago. “Shit, where do I put this.” She then opened her closet and kicked off her heels, walking over her mound of items before settling the beer in the far corner, being sure to throw a decent amount of clothes over them before leaving. 
“You’re messy.” 
“Yeah, I’m aware.”
“Were those Billy’s?”
 “Why do you ask?”
“They’re the same ones he always gets.”
Jess sighed. Knowing Max, she wasn’t going to get away without answering her questions. “Yes, they’re Billy’s.” 
“You guys spend a weird amount of time together,” Max walked away from the bed, heading toward the TV, running her hands over it before looking back at Jess, “Is that why he was acting all weird tonight?”
“MAX?” 
Saved by the bell.
Max rolled her eyes and groaned. “COMING!” She opened the door and quickly ran down the stairs. By the time Jess made it downstairs as well, the Hargroves/Mayfields already had their coats on and were migrating toward the door. 
“Thank you so much for having us over, tonight, we had a great time.” 
Everyone said their polite goodbyes as Billy fiddled with something inside his coat pocket. He slowly walked over to Jess and without looking at her, he asked, “Walk me out?” 
Jess found his question odd, considering how angry he seemed to be with her only moments ago. But of course, she nodded in agreeance. Billy walked over to the Logan’s coat hanger without delay and grabbed one that looked like it belonged to her, draping it over Jess’s shoulders lightly before following his family out the door. 
When his father opened his car door and turned to him expectantly, Billy cleared his throat, looking down at the pavement before cautiously looking back at him. 
“I’ll walk.” 
“Son, get in-“ 
“Neil it’s okay, we’re only down the road anyways.” 
Neil gritted his teeth for a moment before sliding into the driver’s side. Susan smiled apologetically at Jess, entering the car after her husband. Before speaking, Billy watched his parents’ car drive further away, causing Jess to become anxious. 
“Billy, what-“
“Are we friends, Jess?”
“What? Billy what are you even-“ 
“Are we friends.”
“Well, yeah…”
“Does pretty boy know that?” Billy pointed out toward the road with his thumb, assuming the direction of where Steve was at the moment. 
“What, you want me to tell him that you sneak into my room whenever you want?” 
“That’s not what I asked.” 
“Of course he doesn’t know. Does Tommy or Carol know? Does Jane-“
“You know what, they just might.” Billy stared into her, the look of disappointment obviously embedded in his features. 
“Billy, I-“ 
He cut her off by reaching into the pocket he was fiddling with and taking out a small, wrapped present. The wrapping was folded into a square and was mostly flat besides where the presented rested between the paper. 
“Open it tomorrow. Or tonight. Whatever.”
“Billy…”
“Just let me know when I need to come back over to finish our shit.”
“Wait…”
He looked her over one last time, taking in her dress that he probably would never have the pleasure of seeing her in again. He sighed, dropping his gaze as he walked closer to her before looking back up. He took one of her sleeves between his index finger and thumb, rubbing it softly just as Jess did this morning. After a moment of staying silent, he looked away again, finally saying what he wanted to all this time. 
“You looked beautiful tonight, Jess…” He nodded to himself after saying this, as if he were agreeing with himself, and turned away, walking back toward his house. 
Taglist: @nix-rose @fandom-princess-forevermore @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo @axionn @defenslessheart-main @the-lost-are-ignored
80 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 6 months
Text
THANK YOU!! You have no idea how happy it makes me that people are enjoying this story, even tho it’s long as hellllll. Realizing my whole goal with this fic was to make people love Billy as much as I do 🥰🥰🥰
Prove Me Wrong
Chapter 13: The 13th
If you need to catchup, here's the masterlist.
Tumblr media
Summary: Watching a horror movie with Billy goes better than expected
Warnings: Cursing, Slight angst for a millisecond, Mentions of blood and gore (from the movie they watch), mentions of death (again from the movie). As always let me know if I missed something.
Word Count:4k
Author's note: Sorry this post came late loves! My son got sick so that was fun to take care of. But good news, because I slacked you guys get two chapters this weekend 🤗
Also, as someone who also isn't a big horror fan, I watched this movie as homework and surprisingly, completely straight-faced this entire movie. Guess Billy's right, it was kind of cheesy 😂
Billy climbed his way to Jess’s bedroom with ease this time. With the knowledge that Jess’s parents were not directly below her, he took less care about whether or not he was silent and instead jumped quickly from the trash can to the last quoins, lifting himself over the gutters where he found himself once again in front of her draped covered window. He tapped the glass lightly and was immediately met by a still annoyed Jess opening the pane and quickly walking away. She was now wearing a faded cheer sweatshirt and a pair of cloth shorts. He looked over at the sickly green atrocity that held her TV just above her bed level, the VHS sitting on top of it. Her bed was littered with snacks, some from the store and some that she seemed to have provided herself, Billy taking note of the stack of brownies, which he hoped were as good as last time he snuck into her room. 
She seemed to be pacing before he got there and was continuing to do so as he arrived. “Please tell me you’re not serious about wanting to be here for Christmas.” 
“Doesn’t really look like that’s up to me. What? You don’t want me over? Where’s your holiday spirit, princess?” Before he knew it, a Charleston Chew bar hit him in the chest. 
“For once, be serious. Steve is gonna be there. And I don’t want to deal with the two of you bickering like an old married couple.” 
Billy picked up the candy bar and tossed it back on the bed, grinning to himself. “I’ll behave if he does.” 
Jess stopped pacing and turned to him. “Right, because he’s the one I should be worried about.” Jess recalled earlier today how Billy purposefully blew smoke in Steve’s face right before successfully irritating Steve with the thought of him spending all winter break with her. 
Billy walked over to the side of the bed he usually sat on and pushed the assortment of food to the other side and sat down, kicking off his shoes as he did so. He sucked in his cheek and bit down, contorting his mouth in a downward smirk. “Don’t gotta worry about me, sweetheart. I’ll be an absolute angel. Call it an early Christmas gift.” 
Jess considered his promise for a moment, her eyes traveling from his smile to his eyes, which gave off a hint of playfulness but no level of insincerity. “I always have to worry about you,” she huffed before settling down on the opposite side of the bed, pushing snacks closer to Billy. 
“That’s cute of you,” Billy teased before eyeing the cans of beer that were at the foot of her bed. He leaned forward and grabbed the pack, twisting a can out of the plastic ring that held it secure to the other five. He swiftly cracked it open and took a swig from it, earning him another annoyed glance from Jess. “What? You want one, Logan?” 
“Absolutely not.”
“Why? You’re cute when you’re drunk.” 
The mention of her being intoxicated began to stir the memories from that last weekend, how she spent the majority of her night with Billy, and how that night ended. She began to feel light-headed from the memory of how close she stood to him towards the end of that song, how she was practically leaning against him for support. She was brought back to reality by the bed shifting, Billy placing the remaining five cans underneath her bed. “Let’s get this show on the road, princess. Not tryna keep you up all night…” 
Jess shoved him, making his beer slosh. 
“Aye watch it…” 
She made her way toward her TV, taking her time to put the VHS in, not in a hurry to start hiding under her covers the whole time. She looked over the cover, “Friday the 13th, The Final Chapter…” Jess scoffed, placing the tape in the player. “Billy, I swear if this is as bad as the first one-“ She was quickly cut off by the tape being played where it was last on, causing Jess to jump at the sight of Jason killing the hitchhiker on the side of the road. 
“Oohhh shit!” Billy laughed out, taking another sip of his beer before swinging his legs off the bed and quickly making his way to where Jess was standing. He watched her close her eyes, turning away from the TV as the ominous music played. “Go back to the bed, princess, I got it.” He squatted down, pressing the rewind button on the VCR as he stared down the TV, waiting til he heard a click, indicating it was done. 
He turned back around to find Jess already underneath her blanket, the top of it bunched up by her mouth with her hands. He smirked down at her, able to see her eyes squint up at him in irritation. “Don’t worry, it’s honestly not that bad. I chose the cheesiest one of the two. Promise.” He chuckled as he made his way to her light switch, flipping it off, and began to sit back down on his side of the bed, deciding to take a brownie as adjusted himself back against the headboard. 
Jess’s glare softened as he joined her on the bed. “You’ve seen this before?” Billy only nodded, turning his head to the side to look over at her, smiling for a moment before looking back over at the screen. 
They stayed that way as the movie started, Jess bunching the blanket over her face, Billy smiling to himself as he continued to look over at her, sipping his beer contently. Billy felt the blanket shift suddenly, suggesting to him that the sight of Jason’s hand falling free from the stretcher startled her. He bit down into his brownie and smirked to himself, swallowed, and then turned to look back at her once more. “If it makes you feel better, Logan, we’re not out camping right now so it can’t happen to us.”
“Yeah. Great. Thanks.”
Billy chuckled out loud, looking down at the load of snacks that separated the two of them, silently cursing the barrier as he sat up straighter. He picked up the Charleston Chew that was thrown at him and tossed it on her lap. 
“Eat a candy bar, you’ll feel better.” 
Jess smiled lightly, grabbing the bar from her lap and slowly unwrapping it, not taking her eyes off the screen, lifting her knees to her chest. Billy continued to look from the snacks to her, watching the way the shifting lights from the screen illuminated her features, the way she cautiously bit into her snack, pausing with it still in her mouth when she was preparing for something that could possibly scare her. He continued to smile to himself as he noticed the way she squinted her left eye more than her right when she braced for oncoming jump scares and the way she slowly began to relax more throughout the movie. When they watched the hitchhiker get stabbed for the second time that night, Billy finally summoned the courage to start moving the snacks. 
The rustling of the wrappers being moved made Jess finally remove her eyes from the screen and look over at the cause of the noise. He moved the bags of chips to the nightstand closest to him, along with the baked goods, seeing as he was the only one eating those, leaving the assorted candy bars where they were for Jess. 
“What’re you doin’?” 
“Making more room.” Billy shrugged as he coolly answered. He then playfully tossed the rest of the candy onto her lap when she didn’t make a move to remove them from the middle of the bed. “Think those belong to you.”
“Yeah, so did those-” She was now pointing at the Doritos that Billy had already moved, but then quickly shifted back her attention toward the TV when she heard a twig snap. “Oh, don’t walk alone…” 
“Don’t worry, she doesn’t die. Yet.”
“Billy…” He only laughed in response but stopped immediately when she looked more annoyed than scared. 
“Hey, I’m just kidding.” He scooted inches closer to her, the snacks no longer blocking his way. When she didn’t say anything in response, he offered, “You want me to turn it off?” He continued to look down at her, his tone was serious and softer than it had been tonight, which caused Jess to look up at him. 
She furrowed her eyebrows at the sight of him and then began to shake her head. “No…” She then looked back at the TV for only a moment, “I guess you’re right, it’s not as bad as I thought it was gonna be.” When she turned to face him again, she noticed the smirk he was now giving her and rolled her eyes. 
“See what happens when you try new things, Logan?”
“It’s still bad,” she rebutted. “And by the way. I do watch horror movies. I just don’t like them.”
“Whatever you say, gorgeous.” He then reached for the Dorito bag that he placed on top of the nightstand and moved it to the opposite side of Jess, where it wasn’t separating the two of them, making it a point to reach behind her as he did so. When the chips were secured next to her, he allowed his hand to linger longer than needed before resting his arm above the pillow she was leaning against. He cracked his knuckles nervously, his arm tensing up every time Jess shifted. 
Get it together, Hargrove. He cursed himself, attempting to look down at her without her noticing, but she was too busy noticing the way her body burned at the close proximity to his, attempting to free herself from the blanket without making it too obvious it was now causing her to overheat. When she could have sworn she was beginning to sweat, she jumped up suddenly. 
“Bathroom…” was all she said, assuming the word would explain itself. 
Billy sucked in before clearing his throat. “You want me to pause it?”
“God no,” she laughed out, exiting the room before the TV became too bright and he was able to see the strong blush that she knew currently covered her entire face. Billy chugged what remained of his now warm beer once Jess was clear of the room, hoping maybe it would loosen him up slightly. But unfortunately, he knew it would take a lot more than one beer to do that, and he would definitely like to stay sober while he was with her, at least in her bedroom. 
When he heard footsteps reappear in the hallway, a mischievous grin appeared on his face as he got up from the bed and walked to the door just as she opened it, grabbing her hips as he scared her, believing all she would do was jump. When she let out a loud, short scream, however, he quickly widened his eyes and placed his hand over her mouth, chuckling quietly.
“Shit, Logan.”
Jess smacked his chest, causing Billy slowly to take his hand off of her face. 
“Dammit, Billy, if my parents heard me…” She was answered by the sound of a door creaking open and the shuffle of footsteps. She pushed Billy further into her room as she stepped back into the hallway and found Stan at the bottom of the stairs. 
“You okay, kid?” 
“Uh. Yeah. Just watching some stupid scary movie. Sorry.” She looked back into her bedroom for only a moment, but enough to see Billy’s smirk growing on his face. 
Stan Logan gave her a strained look, but then shrugged his shoulders and turned away from the stairs, “Keep it down next time kid, it’s the middle of the night.” 
“Sorry,” she then turned to look back at Billy before she continued, “It won’t happen again.” 
She made it back into her room and shut the door behind her, refusing to break eye contact. “You absolute asshole!” she hissed, picking up another uneaten candy bar and chucking it at him, which he easily swatted away as he laughed, attempting to be quieter. 
“How was I supposed to know you’d scream like that?” 
“It’s like you want to get me into trouble.” She shook her head in exasperation, but when Billy could only laugh at the incident, it caused her to break into a smile as well, which she attempted to hold back once it appeared. “It’s not funny!” Her giggling, however, said otherwise, and she rolled her eyes once more, plopping down on her bed as Billy sprawled out on his side, now taking the candy that was thrown at him and opening it for himself. 
The sound of glass breaking made both of them turn their heads back to the screen as they watched some poor girl get thrown from the top story onto a car by Jason, making Jess cringe. 
“So they’re just all dying at once now, huh?” 
“Typically how it goes,” Billy answered, biting into the candy bar and quickly swallowing, “Surprised she didn’t survive that.”
“She was thrown out of a window!” 
Billy just shrugged nonchalantly, “Eh, the car cushioned her fall.” Billy then turned back and smiled at her, taking another bite. 
“The car cushioned-“ Instead of finishing this sentence, she shook her head in disbelief and began laughing even harder. “You’re insane.”
“I’d survive that fall.”
“Sure you would, tough guy.” 
Billy scooted his way closer as they continued watching the movie, making the excuse that Jess was ‘hogging the chips’. Jess stopped feeling the need to shield herself from the jump scares and gory scenes as Billy continued to make jokes and ridicule how each character handled the situation, making her laugh as if she were watching a comedy. By the end of the movie, Billy was practically leaning against Jess as he continued to eat more chips than he wanted. 
“So what did you think, princess? Not that bad huh?” 
Jess shook her head slowly. “No, not that bad.” 
Billy beamed at her then tapped her leg with his hand before climbing over her, swinging his legs off her side of the bed, and heading to the door. 
“Bathroom’s this way, right?” He asked as he pointed in the right direction. 
“Yes, just please be quiet.”
“You got it, Princess.”
While he was gone, Jess took the time to remove the wrappers and crumbs from her bed, getting back under the covers as Billy was reentering the room. 
“Alright, Logan.” He climbed over her again to make it to his side of the bed and then sprawled out, laying his head on one of the pillows, “Goodnight.”
“You think so, huh?” 
“What?” He then looked at her with feigning surprise. “You wanna sleep all by yourself tonight? I guess you’re a big girl after all.”
“Shut up.”
Billy relaxed against the pillow he was lying on and moved his gaze to the ceiling and quickly changed the subject. “So have you seen the other ones?”
“Just the first one. Like I said, I’m not into scaring myself for fun.”
“You know what that means…” Billy nudged her side as he continued staring up, the solid blue light from the screen softly illuminating the room. “We gotta go on a marathon.” 
“That is not what that means,” Jess responded, also settling into bed, lifting the covers so that it barely covered her chin.
“I thought you said it wasn’t that bad,” he teased, shifting his head so he could look at her. Her eyes met his, rolling to the side before looking back at him, peering at him through her eyelashes, making Billy feel as if his chest would explode if he didn’t look away. Despite his whole body pleading with him to turn away, he kept his eyes fixed on hers as he continued. “I’ll tell you what,” he smiled deviously at her, “we switch off. You show me one of your lame chick flicks, and then we’ll watch the first Friday movie, yeah?” 
“First of all,” Jess pulled the covers back down to her chest so she could prop herself up with her elbow, “they’re not lame, and second, I’ve already seen the first one.”
“Then it shouldn’t be a problem to see it again.” Billy continued to stare at her, challenging her to accept. He also moved to incline himself, taking his pillow and folding it in half. 
“Fine. But after Friday the 13th, we’re done with horror movies.”
“Unless I make you like them.” Billy widened his smile, opening his mouth a bit to allow his tongue to run along the bottom row of his teeth. 
“Yeah right,” Jess scoffed, scrunching her eyebrows in disbelief.
“You seemed to like this one just fine.
“That’s only because you’re-“ She stopped abruptly, not allowing herself to finish that sentence, but when she looked over the expression Billy was making, the way his smile dropped and his eyes squinted, she knew she had to say something. “It’s only because you were making fun of it.”
Billy’s smile returned, but not as wide as it was earlier. “Then I’ll make sure to do the same thing next time.” He winked at her, settling into his folded pillow as he listened to her complain about how much she was going to hate this upcoming movie marathon, and how scared she was to watch the other two she hadn’t seen yet. But he knew better. He had watched how comfortable she had gotten after the first 30 minutes, watched how her shoulders stopped tensing. He liked to think he maybe had something to do with it, or maybe it was just the fact that he did pick the corniest movie out of the two. 
He wondered what would have happened if he had picked a different movie, a more frightening one. Would she have cowered under her blanket the whole time? Would she have cowered behind him? He quickly shook the ‘what ifs’ away. He knew that’s not how he wanted this night to go. He didn’t want to be the default guy she cuddled next to, didn’t want her to feel like she had to get close to him. This was the same reason he didn’t fight Steve about taking her home so early into the party. And he knew this was why he chose this franchise of horror movies to introduce her to. 
He continued to listen to her talk about all the movies she would make him watch. She figured she might show him the Star Wars movies since he was so adamant about making her watch a franchise as well, which he just scoffed at, but he knew watching some weird sci/fi films wouldn’t be the worst thing ever if it were with her. 
They continued changing topics for hours, whether it be about movies, school, and again about California until the conversation moved to the party that was being thrown on New Year’s Eve. 
“You’re going right?” 
“If Steve goes, yeah.”
“Why does it matter if Steve goes? You didn’t even hang out with him last time.”
“Steve happens to be my ride. And plus, I normally hang out with him. He was just busy last time.”
“Yeah, I saw,” Billy replied bitterly, “You forget I have a car or something?”
Jess looked at him interrogatively, “You’d want to take me?”
“If you need a ride, I can give you a ride.”
“That’s not what I was asking.” 
“Sounds like what you were asking.”
Jess sucked in and sighed, folding her pillow in half as well now and laying into it as her eyes started to get heavy. “I mean,” she paused for a moment, knowing exactly what she meant, just not how to say it, “I mean… everyone’s gonna be there. And everyone’s gonna see you taking me to this party. It’s not just you taking me to school anymore.” 
“And?”
“You want people to see me in your car?”
Billy shook his head and chuckled sarcastically, “Seems like you’re the one who’s worried about it, not me.”
“No that’s not…” Jess began to backtrack but paused. He was right, she was worried about it, but not in the way that he thought. It was when Billy began to get up that she started to speak again. “What’re you doing?”
“It’s hella late, and I’m falling asleep.” He began to grab for his jacket that was on the floor next to his side of the bed, holding it at his side as he turned to face Jess again. “Look, if you don’t want me to give you a ride, then I won’t, that’s all you had to say. You don’t need to go into some lame excuse about how I don’t want to-“
“That’s not what I meant...” Billy stood there, continuing to look at her, finally shrugging his shoulders, exaggerating the movement as to tell her to keep going. “It’s just. Your friends don’t like me, okay? And I already had trouble when you first started taking me to school and-“
“Who gave you trouble?” Billy quickly interrupted, seemingly unamused by this bit of information. 
“That’s not the point nor does it matter…” She sighed one last time, “The point is, I don’t want to be the talk of the school again, especially if your friends are the ones doing the talking.”
Billy took this into consideration, nodding as she finished, he then looked down at the ground, pondering what to say next, and looked back at her. “You know, Carol’s just bitter you don’t talk to her anymore. She doesn’t hate you.”
“That’s not really the vibe I get.”
“So who’s giving you trouble then, because I know it’s not Carol, she talks but she wouldn’t come at you directly. And Tommy really couldn’t give a shit.” Billy tossed his jacket down again and sat back on the bed, folding his left leg under him as his right hung off the edge. 
“Who do you think?” When Billy continued to stare at her, just about ordering her to give him an answer with the raise of his eyebrows, she scoffed, “Your girlfriend, that’s who.” 
Billy began to shake his head, laughing coldly at the news. “Which one?” he teased before releasing his downturned smirk, “Next time just tell her to fuck off.”
“I did.”
Billy nudged her lightly, conveying his approval. “That’s my girl.”
“It doesn’t make it any more fun though.”
“Getting to tell Jane to fuck off isn’t fun?”
Jess laughed at this, nodding her head in agreeance. “I meant the being talked about part.”
“Yeah, well, fuck ‘em.”
“Is that what you tell yourself? ‘Fuck ‘em’?”
“I’m starting to.” Billy drew a short, loud breath threw his nose, nodding slowly as he turned away from her for a moment. “It took me a while to get there but… yeah. Fuck ‘em all.” 
Jess giggled at this statement, relaxing her shoulders at the thought of not having a care in the world of what others thought. “So is that why you’re such an asshole?” Jess teased, earning a snort from Billy. 
“Nah,” Billy paused, staring at the foot of her bed, “No that’s not why…” He then tilted his head to look over at her, the light from the screen casting still shadows on her face. He smiled more to himself than at her before lying back down on the pillow that was now partially unfolded.
“I thought you were tired?”
“I am,” he said flatly. 
“I thought you were leaving?”
“That’s because I was irritated, and now I’m not.” When she didn’t respond he tilted his head and asked, “Do you want me to leave?”
“No…” she whispered suddenly. 
“Good. Because I don’t want to either.”
Taglist: @nix-rose @fandom-princess-forevermore @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo @axionn @defenslessheart-main @the-lost-are-ignored
85 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 6 months
Text
Prove Me Wrong
Chapter 13: The 13th
If you need to catchup, here's the masterlist.
Tumblr media
Summary: Watching a horror movie with Billy goes better than expected
Warnings: Cursing, Slight angst for a millisecond, Mentions of blood and gore (from the movie they watch), mentions of death (again from the movie). As always let me know if I missed something.
Word Count:4k
Author's note: Sorry this post came late loves! My son got sick so that was fun to take care of. But good news, because I slacked you guys get two chapters this weekend 🤗
Also, as someone who also isn't a big horror fan, I watched this movie as homework and surprisingly, completely straight-faced this entire movie. Guess Billy's right, it was kind of cheesy 😂
Billy climbed his way to Jess’s bedroom with ease this time. With the knowledge that Jess’s parents were not directly below her, he took less care about whether or not he was silent and instead jumped quickly from the trash can to the last quoins, lifting himself over the gutters where he found himself once again in front of her draped covered window. He tapped the glass lightly and was immediately met by a still annoyed Jess opening the pane and quickly walking away. She was now wearing a faded cheer sweatshirt and a pair of cloth shorts. He looked over at the sickly green atrocity that held her TV just above her bed level, the VHS sitting on top of it. Her bed was littered with snacks, some from the store and some that she seemed to have provided herself, Billy taking note of the stack of brownies, which he hoped were as good as last time he snuck into her room. 
She seemed to be pacing before he got there and was continuing to do so as he arrived. “Please tell me you’re not serious about wanting to be here for Christmas.” 
“Doesn’t really look like that’s up to me. What? You don’t want me over? Where’s your holiday spirit, princess?” Before he knew it, a Charleston Chew bar hit him in the chest. 
“For once, be serious. Steve is gonna be there. And I don’t want to deal with the two of you bickering like an old married couple.” 
Billy picked up the candy bar and tossed it back on the bed, grinning to himself. “I’ll behave if he does.” 
Jess stopped pacing and turned to him. “Right, because he’s the one I should be worried about.” Jess recalled earlier today how Billy purposefully blew smoke in Steve’s face right before successfully irritating Steve with the thought of him spending all winter break with her. 
Billy walked over to the side of the bed he usually sat on and pushed the assortment of food to the other side and sat down, kicking off his shoes as he did so. He sucked in his cheek and bit down, contorting his mouth in a downward smirk. “Don’t gotta worry about me, sweetheart. I’ll be an absolute angel. Call it an early Christmas gift.” 
Jess considered his promise for a moment, her eyes traveling from his smile to his eyes, which gave off a hint of playfulness but no level of insincerity. “I always have to worry about you,” she huffed before settling down on the opposite side of the bed, pushing snacks closer to Billy. 
“That’s cute of you,” Billy teased before eyeing the cans of beer that were at the foot of her bed. He leaned forward and grabbed the pack, twisting a can out of the plastic ring that held it secure to the other five. He swiftly cracked it open and took a swig from it, earning him another annoyed glance from Jess. “What? You want one, Logan?” 
“Absolutely not.”
“Why? You’re cute when you’re drunk.” 
The mention of her being intoxicated began to stir the memories from that last weekend, how she spent the majority of her night with Billy, and how that night ended. She began to feel light-headed from the memory of how close she stood to him towards the end of that song, how she was practically leaning against him for support. She was brought back to reality by the bed shifting, Billy placing the remaining five cans underneath her bed. “Let’s get this show on the road, princess. Not tryna keep you up all night…” 
Jess shoved him, making his beer slosh. 
“Aye watch it…” 
She made her way toward her TV, taking her time to put the VHS in, not in a hurry to start hiding under her covers the whole time. She looked over the cover, “Friday the 13th, The Final Chapter…” Jess scoffed, placing the tape in the player. “Billy, I swear if this is as bad as the first one-“ She was quickly cut off by the tape being played where it was last on, causing Jess to jump at the sight of Jason killing the hitchhiker on the side of the road. 
“Oohhh shit!” Billy laughed out, taking another sip of his beer before swinging his legs off the bed and quickly making his way to where Jess was standing. He watched her close her eyes, turning away from the TV as the ominous music played. “Go back to the bed, princess, I got it.” He squatted down, pressing the rewind button on the VCR as he stared down the TV, waiting til he heard a click, indicating it was done. 
He turned back around to find Jess already underneath her blanket, the top of it bunched up by her mouth with her hands. He smirked down at her, able to see her eyes squint up at him in irritation. “Don’t worry, it’s honestly not that bad. I chose the cheesiest one of the two. Promise.” He chuckled as he made his way to her light switch, flipping it off, and began to sit back down on his side of the bed, deciding to take a brownie as adjusted himself back against the headboard. 
Jess’s glare softened as he joined her on the bed. “You’ve seen this before?” Billy only nodded, turning his head to the side to look over at her, smiling for a moment before looking back over at the screen. 
They stayed that way as the movie started, Jess bunching the blanket over her face, Billy smiling to himself as he continued to look over at her, sipping his beer contently. Billy felt the blanket shift suddenly, suggesting to him that the sight of Jason’s hand falling free from the stretcher startled her. He bit down into his brownie and smirked to himself, swallowed, and then turned to look back at her once more. “If it makes you feel better, Logan, we’re not out camping right now so it can’t happen to us.”
“Yeah. Great. Thanks.”
Billy chuckled out loud, looking down at the load of snacks that separated the two of them, silently cursing the barrier as he sat up straighter. He picked up the Charleston Chew that was thrown at him and tossed it on her lap. 
“Eat a candy bar, you’ll feel better.” 
Jess smiled lightly, grabbing the bar from her lap and slowly unwrapping it, not taking her eyes off the screen, lifting her knees to her chest. Billy continued to look from the snacks to her, watching the way the shifting lights from the screen illuminated her features, the way she cautiously bit into her snack, pausing with it still in her mouth when she was preparing for something that could possibly scare her. He continued to smile to himself as he noticed the way she squinted her left eye more than her right when she braced for oncoming jump scares and the way she slowly began to relax more throughout the movie. When they watched the hitchhiker get stabbed for the second time that night, Billy finally summoned the courage to start moving the snacks. 
The rustling of the wrappers being moved made Jess finally remove her eyes from the screen and look over at the cause of the noise. He moved the bags of chips to the nightstand closest to him, along with the baked goods, seeing as he was the only one eating those, leaving the assorted candy bars where they were for Jess. 
“What’re you doin’?” 
“Making more room.” Billy shrugged as he coolly answered. He then playfully tossed the rest of the candy onto her lap when she didn’t make a move to remove them from the middle of the bed. “Think those belong to you.”
“Yeah, so did those-” She was now pointing at the Doritos that Billy had already moved, but then quickly shifted back her attention toward the TV when she heard a twig snap. “Oh, don’t walk alone…” 
“Don’t worry, she doesn’t die. Yet.”
“Billy…” He only laughed in response but stopped immediately when she looked more annoyed than scared. 
“Hey, I’m just kidding.” He scooted inches closer to her, the snacks no longer blocking his way. When she didn’t say anything in response, he offered, “You want me to turn it off?” He continued to look down at her, his tone was serious and softer than it had been tonight, which caused Jess to look up at him. 
She furrowed her eyebrows at the sight of him and then began to shake her head. “No…” She then looked back at the TV for only a moment, “I guess you’re right, it’s not as bad as I thought it was gonna be.” When she turned to face him again, she noticed the smirk he was now giving her and rolled her eyes. 
“See what happens when you try new things, Logan?”
“It’s still bad,” she rebutted. “And by the way. I do watch horror movies. I just don’t like them.”
“Whatever you say, gorgeous.” He then reached for the Dorito bag that he placed on top of the nightstand and moved it to the opposite side of Jess, where it wasn’t separating the two of them, making it a point to reach behind her as he did so. When the chips were secured next to her, he allowed his hand to linger longer than needed before resting his arm above the pillow she was leaning against. He cracked his knuckles nervously, his arm tensing up every time Jess shifted. 
Get it together, Hargrove. He cursed himself, attempting to look down at her without her noticing, but she was too busy noticing the way her body burned at the close proximity to his, attempting to free herself from the blanket without making it too obvious it was now causing her to overheat. When she could have sworn she was beginning to sweat, she jumped up suddenly. 
“Bathroom…” was all she said, assuming the word would explain itself. 
Billy sucked in before clearing his throat. “You want me to pause it?”
“God no,” she laughed out, exiting the room before the TV became too bright and he was able to see the strong blush that she knew currently covered her entire face. Billy chugged what remained of his now warm beer once Jess was clear of the room, hoping maybe it would loosen him up slightly. But unfortunately, he knew it would take a lot more than one beer to do that, and he would definitely like to stay sober while he was with her, at least in her bedroom. 
When he heard footsteps reappear in the hallway, a mischievous grin appeared on his face as he got up from the bed and walked to the door just as she opened it, grabbing her hips as he scared her, believing all she would do was jump. When she let out a loud, short scream, however, he quickly widened his eyes and placed his hand over her mouth, chuckling quietly.
“Shit, Logan.”
Jess smacked his chest, causing Billy slowly to take his hand off of her face. 
“Dammit, Billy, if my parents heard me…” She was answered by the sound of a door creaking open and the shuffle of footsteps. She pushed Billy further into her room as she stepped back into the hallway and found Stan at the bottom of the stairs. 
“You okay, kid?” 
“Uh. Yeah. Just watching some stupid scary movie. Sorry.” She looked back into her bedroom for only a moment, but enough to see Billy’s smirk growing on his face. 
Stan Logan gave her a strained look, but then shrugged his shoulders and turned away from the stairs, “Keep it down next time kid, it’s the middle of the night.” 
“Sorry,” she then turned to look back at Billy before she continued, “It won’t happen again.” 
She made it back into her room and shut the door behind her, refusing to break eye contact. “You absolute asshole!” she hissed, picking up another uneaten candy bar and chucking it at him, which he easily swatted away as he laughed, attempting to be quieter. 
“How was I supposed to know you’d scream like that?” 
“It’s like you want to get me into trouble.” She shook her head in exasperation, but when Billy could only laugh at the incident, it caused her to break into a smile as well, which she attempted to hold back once it appeared. “It’s not funny!” Her giggling, however, said otherwise, and she rolled her eyes once more, plopping down on her bed as Billy sprawled out on his side, now taking the candy that was thrown at him and opening it for himself. 
The sound of glass breaking made both of them turn their heads back to the screen as they watched some poor girl get thrown from the top story onto a car by Jason, making Jess cringe. 
“So they’re just all dying at once now, huh?” 
“Typically how it goes,” Billy answered, biting into the candy bar and quickly swallowing, “Surprised she didn’t survive that.”
“She was thrown out of a window!” 
Billy just shrugged nonchalantly, “Eh, the car cushioned her fall.” Billy then turned back and smiled at her, taking another bite. 
“The car cushioned-“ Instead of finishing this sentence, she shook her head in disbelief and began laughing even harder. “You’re insane.”
“I’d survive that fall.”
“Sure you would, tough guy.” 
Billy scooted his way closer as they continued watching the movie, making the excuse that Jess was ‘hogging the chips’. Jess stopped feeling the need to shield herself from the jump scares and gory scenes as Billy continued to make jokes and ridicule how each character handled the situation, making her laugh as if she were watching a comedy. By the end of the movie, Billy was practically leaning against Jess as he continued to eat more chips than he wanted. 
“So what did you think, princess? Not that bad huh?” 
Jess shook her head slowly. “No, not that bad.” 
Billy beamed at her then tapped her leg with his hand before climbing over her, swinging his legs off her side of the bed, and heading to the door. 
“Bathroom’s this way, right?” He asked as he pointed in the right direction. 
“Yes, just please be quiet.”
“You got it, Princess.”
While he was gone, Jess took the time to remove the wrappers and crumbs from her bed, getting back under the covers as Billy was reentering the room. 
“Alright, Logan.” He climbed over her again to make it to his side of the bed and then sprawled out, laying his head on one of the pillows, “Goodnight.”
“You think so, huh?” 
“What?” He then looked at her with feigning surprise. “You wanna sleep all by yourself tonight? I guess you’re a big girl after all.”
“Shut up.”
Billy relaxed against the pillow he was lying on and moved his gaze to the ceiling and quickly changed the subject. “So have you seen the other ones?”
“Just the first one. Like I said, I’m not into scaring myself for fun.”
“You know what that means…” Billy nudged her side as he continued staring up, the solid blue light from the screen softly illuminating the room. “We gotta go on a marathon.” 
“That is not what that means,” Jess responded, also settling into bed, lifting the covers so that it barely covered her chin.
“I thought you said it wasn’t that bad,” he teased, shifting his head so he could look at her. Her eyes met his, rolling to the side before looking back at him, peering at him through her eyelashes, making Billy feel as if his chest would explode if he didn’t look away. Despite his whole body pleading with him to turn away, he kept his eyes fixed on hers as he continued. “I’ll tell you what,” he smiled deviously at her, “we switch off. You show me one of your lame chick flicks, and then we’ll watch the first Friday movie, yeah?” 
“First of all,” Jess pulled the covers back down to her chest so she could prop herself up with her elbow, “they’re not lame, and second, I’ve already seen the first one.”
“Then it shouldn’t be a problem to see it again.” Billy continued to stare at her, challenging her to accept. He also moved to incline himself, taking his pillow and folding it in half. 
“Fine. But after Friday the 13th, we’re done with horror movies.”
“Unless I make you like them.” Billy widened his smile, opening his mouth a bit to allow his tongue to run along the bottom row of his teeth. 
“Yeah right,” Jess scoffed, scrunching her eyebrows in disbelief.
“You seemed to like this one just fine.
“That’s only because you’re-“ She stopped abruptly, not allowing herself to finish that sentence, but when she looked over the expression Billy was making, the way his smile dropped and his eyes squinted, she knew she had to say something. “It’s only because you were making fun of it.”
Billy’s smile returned, but not as wide as it was earlier. “Then I’ll make sure to do the same thing next time.” He winked at her, settling into his folded pillow as he listened to her complain about how much she was going to hate this upcoming movie marathon, and how scared she was to watch the other two she hadn’t seen yet. But he knew better. He had watched how comfortable she had gotten after the first 30 minutes, watched how her shoulders stopped tensing. He liked to think he maybe had something to do with it, or maybe it was just the fact that he did pick the corniest movie out of the two. 
He wondered what would have happened if he had picked a different movie, a more frightening one. Would she have cowered under her blanket the whole time? Would she have cowered behind him? He quickly shook the ‘what ifs’ away. He knew that’s not how he wanted this night to go. He didn’t want to be the default guy she cuddled next to, didn’t want her to feel like she had to get close to him. This was the same reason he didn’t fight Steve about taking her home so early into the party. And he knew this was why he chose this franchise of horror movies to introduce her to. 
He continued to listen to her talk about all the movies she would make him watch. She figured she might show him the Star Wars movies since he was so adamant about making her watch a franchise as well, which he just scoffed at, but he knew watching some weird sci/fi films wouldn’t be the worst thing ever if it were with her. 
They continued changing topics for hours, whether it be about movies, school, and again about California until the conversation moved to the party that was being thrown on New Year’s Eve. 
“You’re going right?” 
“If Steve goes, yeah.”
“Why does it matter if Steve goes? You didn’t even hang out with him last time.”
“Steve happens to be my ride. And plus, I normally hang out with him. He was just busy last time.”
“Yeah, I saw,” Billy replied bitterly, “You forget I have a car or something?”
Jess looked at him interrogatively, “You’d want to take me?”
“If you need a ride, I can give you a ride.”
“That’s not what I was asking.” 
“Sounds like what you were asking.”
Jess sucked in and sighed, folding her pillow in half as well now and laying into it as her eyes started to get heavy. “I mean,” she paused for a moment, knowing exactly what she meant, just not how to say it, “I mean… everyone’s gonna be there. And everyone’s gonna see you taking me to this party. It’s not just you taking me to school anymore.” 
“And?”
“You want people to see me in your car?”
Billy shook his head and chuckled sarcastically, “Seems like you’re the one who’s worried about it, not me.”
“No that’s not…” Jess began to backtrack but paused. He was right, she was worried about it, but not in the way that he thought. It was when Billy began to get up that she started to speak again. “What’re you doing?”
“It’s hella late, and I’m falling asleep.” He began to grab for his jacket that was on the floor next to his side of the bed, holding it at his side as he turned to face Jess again. “Look, if you don’t want me to give you a ride, then I won’t, that’s all you had to say. You don’t need to go into some lame excuse about how I don’t want to-“
“That’s not what I meant...” Billy stood there, continuing to look at her, finally shrugging his shoulders, exaggerating the movement as to tell her to keep going. “It’s just. Your friends don’t like me, okay? And I already had trouble when you first started taking me to school and-“
“Who gave you trouble?” Billy quickly interrupted, seemingly unamused by this bit of information. 
“That’s not the point nor does it matter…” She sighed one last time, “The point is, I don’t want to be the talk of the school again, especially if your friends are the ones doing the talking.”
Billy took this into consideration, nodding as she finished, he then looked down at the ground, pondering what to say next, and looked back at her. “You know, Carol’s just bitter you don’t talk to her anymore. She doesn’t hate you.”
“That’s not really the vibe I get.”
“So who’s giving you trouble then, because I know it’s not Carol, she talks but she wouldn’t come at you directly. And Tommy really couldn’t give a shit.” Billy tossed his jacket down again and sat back on the bed, folding his left leg under him as his right hung off the edge. 
“Who do you think?” When Billy continued to stare at her, just about ordering her to give him an answer with the raise of his eyebrows, she scoffed, “Your girlfriend, that’s who.” 
Billy began to shake his head, laughing coldly at the news. “Which one?” he teased before releasing his downturned smirk, “Next time just tell her to fuck off.”
“I did.”
Billy nudged her lightly, conveying his approval. “That’s my girl.”
“It doesn’t make it any more fun though.”
“Getting to tell Jane to fuck off isn’t fun?”
Jess laughed at this, nodding her head in agreeance. “I meant the being talked about part.”
“Yeah, well, fuck ‘em.”
“Is that what you tell yourself? ‘Fuck ‘em’?”
“I’m starting to.” Billy drew a short, loud breath threw his nose, nodding slowly as he turned away from her for a moment. “It took me a while to get there but… yeah. Fuck ‘em all.” 
Jess giggled at this statement, relaxing her shoulders at the thought of not having a care in the world of what others thought. “So is that why you’re such an asshole?” Jess teased, earning a snort from Billy. 
“Nah,” Billy paused, staring at the foot of her bed, “No that’s not why…” He then tilted his head to look over at her, the light from the screen casting still shadows on her face. He smiled more to himself than at her before lying back down on the pillow that was now partially unfolded.
“I thought you were tired?”
“I am,” he said flatly. 
“I thought you were leaving?”
“That’s because I was irritated, and now I’m not.” When she didn’t respond he tilted his head and asked, “Do you want me to leave?”
“No…” she whispered suddenly. 
“Good. Because I don’t want to either.”
Taglist: @nix-rose @fandom-princess-forevermore @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo @axionn @defenslessheart-main @the-lost-are-ignored
85 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 6 months
Text
This was too fun! Thank you as always for the tag @nix-rose
Jason Todd (DC)
George Weasley (HP)
Arwen (LOTR)
Loki (MCU)
Billy Hargrove (ST)
Violet Baudelaire (SOUE)
Finnick Odair (HG)
Luke Castellan (Percy Jackson)
Dean Winchester (SPN)
Belly Conklin (TSITP)
I tag @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo and anyone else who would like to participate!
10 characters, 10 fandoms!
Thanks @steph-speaks for the tag! (not in order)
Hobie Brown (sm atsv)
Peter Quill/starlord (gotg)
Dean Winchester (spn)
Jake Sully (avatar)
Barbie (2023 barbie)
Billy Hargrove (st)
Katy (shang chi) 
Sam Winchester (spn)
Spiderman (tasm)
Nebula (gotg)
@hogwartsandhawkins @avgvstlover @ghost-proofbaby and @anyone who wants to join
5 notes · View notes
hogwartsandhawkins · 7 months
Text
Prove Me Wrong
Chapter 12: Don't Be A Stranger
If you need to catch up here's the masterlist
Tumblr media
Summary: Apparently... Jess has new plans for Christmas
Warnings: Mentions of Neil (gross), crude language, cursing, Neil being homophobic if you squint, Billy being a little shit. I think that's it, but as always, let me know if I missed something.
Word Count: 4.8K
Author's Note: I'm so sorry I've been MIA for so long but I'm officially back from my month and a half vacation! TBH I've missed you guys and hope you all enjoy!
“You chaperoning tonight?” Steve walked with Jess toward the parking lot from the gym as they left practice much earlier than usual. The coaches considered this an “early Christmas present” but ensured the basketball team would be having practice a week before school started again in January. The Snow Ball had been the talk of this school week even if it was only meant for the middle schoolers. However, it had also been an excuse for the high schoolers to throw their own parties or get-togethers, not to mention it marked the beginning of winter break, something everyone, including Jess, was looking forward to. 
“Not this year, you?” Jess already knew the answer. Steve never enjoyed that kind of thing, and even if he did, both Nancy and Jonathan would be there tonight, which would have made him want to change his plans. 
Steve shook his head but added, “I’m helpin’ mini-Harrison with his hair tonight though and droppin’ him off tonight.” 
“Who? Dustin?” 
“Hell yeah Dustin. He’s gonna kill it tonight, I know it.” Jess laughed at the thought of Steve combing another teenager’s hair for them. 
“So what are your plans tonight then?” Jess contemplated this question. She wasn’t sure whether she would start on the tedious task Mr. Crowley assigned both her and Billy as Billy probably wouldn’t want to spend his first night of freedom studying. Considering the night it was, she was sure that Hargrove already had plans. She then looked out into the lot and saw him leaning against the familiar blue car, cigarette already placed in his mouth of course. Max was there as well, which surprised Jess since their practice was released 20 minutes after Max’s school was. 
“Uhm, maybe get a head start on some schoolwork. I’m not sure really.” She kept her eyes on Billy though, hoping that maybe that would change.
“Lame.” Steve teased. He continued to walk with Jess, passing his own car as he did so.
“Uh wasn’t that-“
“I thought I’d walk you. Besides Max is there,” was all he said, keeping his eyes on the pair in front of them now, eyeing Billy skeptically as he walked up. “You excited for tonight, kid? You’re first one, right?” 
Max beamed up at Steve, clutching her board as she responded, “Oh yeah, can’t wait, especially since Henderson said you’d be doing his hair again, and that went soooo well last time.” Steve cringed at the memory of two weeks ago, which was described to Jess as a wreck. Dustin apparently was adamant about doing it himself, as he was a hands-on learner apparently, and it ended with screaming from spraying product right in his eye and a small chunk of hair being ripped out due to his hair tangling in the comb, which Dustin swore was due to him balding. 
“Yeah well, I’ll be doing it tonight… I think.” Steve began to stare down Billy again who was also looking at him intently, blowing smoke straight at Steve when he glanced over at him. 
Steve aggressively waved his hand once to get most of the smoke away from him, annoyed by the gesture. “Harrington.” Billy nodded his direction once Steve was able to get most of the smoke out of his face. 
“Hargrove.” They stared at each other for a moment longer when Steve continued, “Guessing you got big plans tonight,” he prodded, insinuating he would be partying with Tommy and Carol, as the pair were always up to something during the Snow Ball. 
Billy swiped his teeth with his tongue as he crushed his red with his boot, smirking to himself when he looked down to ensure it was fully put out. “Don’t really know, Harrington. Depends on what this one wants to do.” He gestured toward Jess, which caused Steve to shift uncomfortably, not enjoying the thought of Jess spending as much time as she had been with Hargrove. Steve rolled his eyes at this, being the first to break the staring, and directed his attention back to Max. 
“See you when I drop Henderson off. Don’t have too much fun.” He directed his last statement to Jess, shoving her arm lightly as he finished his sentence, flashing her a smile of acceptance to lighten the mood. He made sure to give Billy one last look of disapproval, though, before he turned back in the direction of his own car, shaking his head as he left them. 
Jess sighed as she watched her best friend leave. She had made it a point to hang out with Steve more this week, as there wasn’t much for her and Billy to do for their shared reading and she felt as if she had been blowing him off more the past week. However, she felt guilty when she would sometimes imagine what Billy was doing during her moments with Steve.
Considering his failed relationship with Nancy, a relationship that he sacrificed a decent amount of his friends for, she knew he needed her in a way. And the feeling was mutual. He had been the one person she could turn to after the haunting incidents from a year ago and again just a couple months ago. She knew she could never lose Steve. And yet, here she was, spending time with the one person Steve couldn’t stand. Throughout the week Steve had come to accept her and Billy’s strange partnership, which Jess always defended with, “we may as well get along for the project” or “he hasn’t been a total ass yet” occasionally sprinkled in their conversations. 
This thought also irritated Jess. She wasn’t able to do right by Steve, her best friend since moving to this town, when she secretly enjoyed Billy’s company. And she couldn’t do right by Billy, a boy who over the past weeks had shown just how great of a friend he could be when she constantly undermined his character around Steve. She began to realize she was running out of time, that she would have to be truthful eventually, and that she was on the verge of hurting someone’s feelings. But just like cleaning out her closet, she decided to push this task for later. After all, she wasn’t exactly lying, was she?
“Okay, Jess, I’m in.” Max’s voice ripped her from her thoughts as she turned back around to face the passenger side of Billy’s vehicle. 
“Oh, right.” Jess lowered herself in the seat, placing her bag on the floor of the car as she closed her door softly. Billy still had a smirk plastered on his face as he too watched Steve walk toward his car, but it fell when he shifted his head to Jess who was looking at him, mildly annoyed. 
“What?” 
“I know you’re just trying to piss him off.” 
“You don’t know shit, Jess.” Billy gave her a teasing smile as he reached toward the glove box to retrieve his Ray Bans. 
“I know he really doesn’t like you.” 
“Yeah, well.” He placed the glass on the bridge of his nose and pulled out of his parking spot, unphased by Jess’s statement. Jess tsked at his nonchalant behavior rolling her eyes slightly, turning up the radio for background music. “So what are you doing tonight, Logan? You’re not one of those freaks who chaperone are you?” 
Jess nudged his arm harder than intended. “I used to be, thank you very much. But no, not this year.” 
Billy laughed at how offended she was. “I’m just sayin’ I don’t understand why any normal teenager would want to spend their night doing that.” 
“It’s not that bad. It’s actually kind of nice.”
“Whatever you say, princess. You know, we haven’t broken in your ‘new’ TV yet.” Billy began to raise his eyebrows at her. “Let me take you to Family Video and actually pick out a good movie.” 
“I actually already watched Sixteen Candles this week in my room. So it is broken in.”
“Without me?” Billy pretended to be hurt by this fact, gasping at the end of his question for effect. “After I moved it to your room and everything?” 
“You don’t even like that movie.”
“I do!” Max spoke up from behind them, leaning in closer to the middle console as she scooted her body closer to their seats. 
Jess turned to face her, smiling triumphantly as she addressed her. “Well then maybe we should have a movie night.” She then eyed Billy smugly, insinuating he was the one who had shit taste in movies. Max bounced excitedly at the thought of this, realizing that she would have all the free time in the world this winter break. 
“Alright Logan, you let me pick one movie, and the rest can be all the corny chick flicks and sci-fi shit you pick out.” 
The three of them pulled into the Mayfield/Hargrove driveway, Billy turning off the ignition before turning to Jess. “Wanna come in for a bit, need to pick up my wallet and drop the kid off to get ready for the Shit Ball.” He flicked Max’s forehead as he said the last part, earning his hand a loud swat from Max. 
“The Snow Ball.”
“Whatever.” Jess once again rolled her eyes at their bickering and left the car, but before Jess could position the passenger seat to allow Max to leave comfortably, she instead climbed the middle console as she normally did in the mornings and stepped on the seat before crawling out. “Aye, watch the shoes shitbird.” Max ignored him, walking into the house first with her skateboard in hand. Jess and Billy quickly followed, Billy holding the door for them, closing it once they were all inside. Max quickly retreated to her room, Billy leading Jess to his. 
Billy walked straight to his mirror, which stood next to a table that had an assortment of colognes and an ashtray. His wallet was placed next to the tray. Billy thumbed through it to make sure its contents were still there and turned to see Jess standing by his dresser, eyeing what appeared to be a photo album. “Ah shit, forgot to put that away.” He began to grab for it, but instead of putting it away as he first intended, he opened it in front of her. “I guess I did promise to show you California, huh?” 
Billy flipped through the album and within seconds made it to pictures of his favorite beach. It looked exactly as Billy described last weekend. The sand looked so soft like it couldn’t possibly burn your feet even if you stepped on it on the hottest day. The ocean was crystal blue, white foam collecting at the edge where it met the shore. Jess looked at the picture at the bottom left and saw the same beach, but this time a beautiful woman was standing in the middle, smiling as bright as the sun that caused her to shield her eyes when taking the shot. 
“Is that…”
“My mom,” Billy confirmed. He stared at the picture with Jess, his face still as stone. 
“You look a lot like her,” Jess replied softly, afraid that the comparison would make him uncomfortable. Billy nodded his head. He knew this already. Everyone said it. 
Except Neil. 
“Yeah…” he whispered, his head nod accompanied by a melancholy smile. Jess turned the page slowly, allowing Billy time to stop her if he felt the need to. When the page was flipped, what she found instead of the same beach were birthday pictures, a young Billy posed in almost every one of them. She looked at the middle picture on the right page and saw Billy smiling behind a cake with five candles lit in a circle. The color of the frosting caught Jess’s attention, as it was a strange shade of purple with random blue streaks hidden in spots of the cake. 
“You like purple as a kid?” 
“What?”
“Your cake.” Jess watched as Billy���s eyes made his way toward the same picture, and then he began to shake his head. 
“No, uh, my favorite frosting’s strawberry.” He began to run his index finger over the cake lightly before pulling away again. “But, you know, strawberry frosting’s pink.  And my dad didn’t like that so much. Made my mom fix it. She was tryna turn it blue.” Billy then turned the page and directed Jess to another cake, this time it was a shade of bright red and had six candles that were not yet lit. “My dad didn’t like the purple too much either but said it was better than nothing.” He then let out a sad laugh as he kept his attention on the new cake.
“But the next year my mom changed the color. Perfected it, I guess. That’s kind of why red’s my favorite color now, got used to it every year.” However, this wasn’t entirely the case. The truth was, though he did favor red when buying certain clothing and objects for his room, he would much rather be able to say that pink was his favorite. He wasn’t sure why. Maybe it was due to the fact that he wasn’t allowed the color in his life. Maybe it was the way that he was envious Max was allowed it though she was able to choose not to like it. But he chose red, just like his mother did, and that would have to be enough. 
Before Jess could figure out how to respond to this, Billy began to navigate effortlessly through the pages again, where he found more recent pictures of himself and other teenagers who looked around his age at the same beach he showed her earlier. They stayed for a moment as he pointed out certain pictures and memories before he grabbed the album and plopped it on his bed, nodding toward it, indicating she should go sit. He went to the opposite side dropping himself down as well as he moved the album closer to the pair. Billy propped his upper half with his left elbow, his lower half draped off the right side of the bed. His head would have been on her lap if he hadn’t been holding himself up, making Jess shift nervously. They continued to look at pictures of the beach before Billy changed positions, allowing his eyes to meet hers. 
“So whatya think now, Logan, east coast or west coast.” Jess looked away from the pictures and down at Billy, who was already giving her a smug grin, looking up at her with a glint in his eye. 
“Mmm…” Jess then shrugged her right shoulder forward, rocking the upper half back and forth, teasing her uncertainty, “I guess California isn’t too bad.” 
Billy turned himself once again, facing the album, his arm now brushing against Jess’s leg as he continued to flip through the pages with his other hand. There were now pictures of carnival rides and games. Behind most of these pictures was a beach, but it was much more crowded than the beach Billy had been showing her. 
“Santa Cruz beach boardwalk,” Billy said as he continued to turn the pages. Lots of pictures were taken here, many of which had what looked to be an 8 or 9-year-old Billy throughout them. There was only one of what looked to be a younger Neil, still sporting the same mustache he had now. Unlike his son, he wasn’t smiling as he barely wrapped his arm around Billy for the picture. “My mom always wanted to visit the Bay Area.” 
They continued to look through the pictures, Billy attempting to only show her the pictures of things to do in the state of California and avoid pictures of his family and childhood home. It wasn’t until Billy glanced down at his wrist to look at the time when they decided to leave his room. “Better get goin’ if I’m picking the movie tonight, huh?” Billy playfully smacked Jess’s leg as he began to pull himself off the bed. He reached into his jeans pocket and pulled out his keys, jingling them in his hand as he made his way to his bedroom door. Jess left the album open on the bed as she followed him out of the room, both of them walking out the front door together. 
Billy walked toward the passenger door as he began to make a habit of opening it for Jess when she was riding with him. She remembered when she used to be annoyed by the gesture, but now she realized that she rather enjoyed it, allowing him to shut the door for her when she was secured inside. When he entered the car as well, he quickly peeled out of the driveway, ensuring they were no longer driving on Cherry Lane when Neil’s vehicle pulled in. 
They pulled into the parking lot for Family Video in record time, Billy wasting no time as he promptly exited the car. He began rounding the front of the Camaro but stopped when he watched Jess open her own door and exit just as quickly. Jess noticed where he was standing and looked back at the door before looking at Billy again. 
“Oh. Sorry.” 
“Didn’t I say I was a gentleman?” 
“Eh. You’re kind of on and off with it.” Jess smiled back at him as he shook his head. 
“Smart ass.”
Billy walked closely behind Jess as they entered the store, making a point to open the door for her before they did. She began to look around the store, beginning to walk toward the left. However, Billy grabbed her arm and began to steer her to the right of the store. “Wrong way, princess.” She looked in the direction of where he was leading her, and her eyes began to widen as she saw the section they were entering. 
“Absolutely not!” 
“Ah come on. I’ll be right there.” 
“Yeah. That makes me feel soooo much better.”
“The fuck is that supposed to mean?” 
He let go of her arm and began thumbing through the horror movies, looking around to try and find something more interesting than what was already in front of him. He then looked over at Jess again, still expecting an answer to her earlier statement. 
“You seem like the type to try and scare me even more than the movie is going to.” 
“You should learn to trust me a little more, Logan.” He then held up two tapes and faced them toward her. “How about I let you choose.” Jess was now looking at Friday the 13th and Halloween II. 
“How about…” She mocked the way he spat out his last sentence “… neither.” After what happened in Hawkins, she would have thought her fear of horror movies would have subsided, that nothing could beat the fear of what she witnessed both last and this year. It was only a week before Halloween that Steve also attempted to watch Halloween II with her and Nancy, and instead of Nancy cuddling up to Steve as he intended, she was allowing Jess to hide behind her as she refused to look at the screen. Steve looked only slightly put out the rest of the movie, earning Jess the nickname “cock-block” for the rest of the week. 
“Alright then, smart ass.” He put back Halloween II, the movie Jess would have picked if she really had to, considering she had already “seen” it, and held the other tape in his right hand, beginning to steer Jess to the front counter with his left. 
“Are we really gonna watch that?” 
“I’ll let you pick out the snacks.” 
“Great...”
Billy successfully added the rented movie to his family’s account and the two of them left, Jess shuffling her feet a bit slower than usual, slightly less excited for tonight, not wanting to seem incredibly lame for her inability to watch the screen as the movie Billy picked out played.
As they left the parking lot, Billy drove passed the mini-mart everyone usually picked out snacks for a movie from Family Video, and instead began in the direction of the grocery store on the other side of town. Jess began to turn her head toward the mini-mart and began to open her mouth before Billy quickly interrupted.
“Can’t go there. The guy won’t sell to me.” 
“Won’t sell to… what do you mean ‘won’t sell to you’?”
Billy just gave her a mischievous grin and turned his attention back to the road. Jess then scoffed. “You really think we’re gonna be drinking in my room with my parents in the same house?” 
“Relax… it’s just for me. Unless you actually wanted some. Then whatever.” Jess just shook her head in response, failing to hide her smile as she pretended to disapprove. 
They arrived at the grocery store where Billy apparently had the “hookup”, a middle-aged man who looked like he would rather be anywhere else but there. Billy quickly went after a six-pack of American Colonial and then turned to Jess. “Whatever you want, princess.” 
“Whatever I want.” Jess repeated back, reassuring Billy that she will be getting just that. Considering that she would be forced to watch a movie that would cause Billy to tease her for the rest of Christmas break, she figured he owed her. She made her way to the candy isle first, grabbing a few Charleston chews bars and then a Twix bar. She handed these over to Billy, freeing up her hands as she walked over to the chips and crackers isle, grabbing a bag of Doritos and a package of room-temperature microwave popcorn. “You’re lucky I have drinks at the house,” she stated smugly and began walking toward the register Billy pointed out to her earlier. 
“Is that everything…” The middle-aged man, apparently named Brian, asked with a monotone voice. 
“Yup,” Billy responded, not looking back at the man until he slid his cash out of his wallet and handed it to him. 
“One thirty-two is…” 
“You can keep it big guy.” Billy grabbed the bag and the six-pack from the side of the register, nodding at Brian as he turned to leave. 
“Yippie…” Jess heard Brian sigh as they walked away. 
The ride to Cherry Lane was longer as this grocery store was not on the same side of town as their neighborhood was. When they eventually made it back home, it was beginning to get dark, which made Jess slightly anxious. 
“Shit, I think dinner’s done…” Jess began as she unclicked her seat belt and reached for the door handle. The original plan, as described by Billy, was for him to drop her and the goods off, park his Camaro back at his house, and wait a few hours before climbing her roof to her window. However, she looked back at Billy with something else in mind. “Do you… wanna maybe come in? For dinner I mean. I don’t think my parents will care. You can still come back later tonight.” 
Billy looked at her for a few moments, watching her nervously shift as she asked this question. It caused him to smile. If he were to tell her the truth, he would say how much he enjoyed the first time he ate dinner with her and her family, and how she would never have to ask if he wanted to do it again. All she would have to do was tell him he was welcome to. 
Instead, he dropped his smile and shrugged nonchalantly, looking away from her and to her front door. “I mean, I guess.” 
“You don’t have to if…” Billy was already out of the car, unwilling to have her finish that sentence. 
“Let’s get to it, Logan.” Billy was at her car door again, opening it as she grabbed the plastic bag from her feet. When her door was closed, she noticed that he had taken the six-pack out of the car with him. 
“You said that was for you!” She whispered harshly at him. 
“It is. For tonight.” He winked at her and positioned the pack at the bottom of the bag, covering it with the rest of the snacks. “Why do you think I asked for your shit to be double-bagged?” 
“Dammit, Billy.” 
“Better hurry upstairs.” He winked again, nudging her with his shoulder. “Hey, don’t worry. I’ll distract them. They love me.” 
He was right. For some strange reason, they had taken a major liking to him, especially since the TV incident. And to her dismay, her mother refused to stop talking about how Billy Hargrove was such a ‘nice boy’.
Yeah. Right.
Jess swiftly unlocked the front door and made her way to the stairs, movie in one hand, the now heavy plastic bag in the other. 
“Hey mom, I’m just gonna-“
“Oh hi, hun. Oh and Billy! What a wonderful surprise! Dinner’s about ready if you’re hungry dear.” 
Billy had obviously occupied her parents without even trying, giving Jess an ample amount of time to stash the bag before either of her parents even wondered what she had. When she made her way back downstairs Billy gave her a chum smile, accompanied by another wink as he made his way to the dining room. 
“Told you,” he whispered just loud enough for Jess to hear, both Mr. and Mrs. Logan scrambling around the kitchen. 
“Shut up.”
Dinner tonight was made up of skirt steak, Mrs. Logan’s famous garlic mashed potatoes as served last time Billy stayed for dinner, and an assortment of roasted vegetables. As usual, it was amazing. The silence that accompanied the occasional sound of silverware clanking against porcelain was soon interrupted by Mrs. Logan. 
“Oh! Billy!” Mrs. Logan took a drink from her wine glass before continuing as she captured the rest of the table’s attention. “So my husband has been talking to your father…” she smiled at Mr. Logan, missing Billy’s cringe at the mention of his dad. “They’ve been doing a lot of that at the bank, and the topic of Christmas came up.” She was now looking back at Billy and Jess, both their expressions confused. 
Mr. Logan cleared his throat, nodding as he was beginning to remember the conversation his wife was alluding to. “Right. So we normally do Christmas Eve with the Harrington’s and their boy Steve. He’s actually on the basketball team as well, I’m sure you know him.” 
The same mischievous smile from the car came back as he looked over at Jess quickly before turning his attention to her father. “Oh yeah. Harrington. We’re great friends.”
“Oh good. Figured you would be.” Billy glanced over at Jess again as she cleared her throat. “Well we were thinking, since your family is new into town, you guys live practically next door, and since you, Steve, and Jess seem to be friends, I invited your family over for Christmas Eve as well. We just do dinner and-“ 
Mr. Logan was interrupted by Jess choking on her steak. She reached out for her water and chugged a bit, clearing her airways before looking at her dad. Billy was covering his smile with his hand, his elbow propped up on the table, attempting to look unphased. 
“Sorry,” Jess coughed out. “D- do you think we’ll have enough room? I mean, we don’t have that many chairs and-“ 
“Oh don’t be silly, it’ll be fine. Besides, the table extends and I’m sure we’ll find some other chairs upstairs," Mrs. Logan butt in. Billy remembered the room upstairs with all the old, mismatched furniture, and wondered if any of those chairs would be in any condition to be sat on, considering most were missing legs. 
“Alright,” Jess said in a small voice, pushing her food around with her fork. It wasn’t the idea of having Billy over for Christmas Eve that made her uneasy, rather, the fact that she would be having Billy over for Christmas Eve with Steve Harrington. It will be a whole evening. A whole evening of Harrington and Hargrove in the same house. At the same table. And she would be in the middle of it. 
The vexatious glint in his eye was still there as he removed his hand from in front of his mouth and looked back and forth between her parents. “That sounds great. Can’t wait.” He then smiled over at Jess before bringing back his attention to his food and began to eat again. “By the way Mrs. Logan, dinner is amazing.”
Jess continued to sneak annoyed glances at Billy, who was smugly eating his dinner, apparently amused at what just happened. When everything was finished and both Billy and Jess brought the remaining dishes back to the kitchen, Billy once again spoke up. 
“Thank you so much for tonight, but I should get going soon. Again, Mrs. Logan, dinner was great.” 
“Well thank you for stopping by, don’t be a stranger!” Mrs. Logan called out to him. 
Billy strutted his way back to Jess, who was standing at the landing of her stairs by the entryway. As he reached out for the doorknob, he looked down at Jess, towering over her until he bent down so his lips were just at her ear. 
“See you tonight, gorgeous.”
@nix-rose @fandom-princess-forevermore @ooo---hazelgrimm---ooo @axionn @defenslessheart-main @the-lost-are-ignored
67 notes · View notes