Okay I'm done with the film review for my sociology class, now you can all have my rant about it, and it's LONG so it's going under a read more:
I'm watching that new Netflix documentary about dirt - Kiss The Ground. For context, I'm an undergrad researcher in biogeochemistry and I study the carbon cycle, particularly a very specific type of decomposition that occurs in waterlogged soils - methanogenesis.
I'm so thrilled that something this mainstream is talking about soil carbon, soil microbes (my beloveds), and carbon sequestration. They're talking about root exudates and mychorrizhae and agriculture as part of an ecosystem! That's exciting. There's also a really excellent dose of climate hope in this documentary - and I am really excited to see that concept getting out of niche environmental circles and into things that regular people might actually watch.
On the other hand, parts of this documentary tick me off. I do not consider Tom Brady, nor his wife, to be a reliable source about the importance of organic agriculture. I know you're trying to interest the non-science types but come on, that is a classic appeal to irrelevant authority fallacy. And they should have said the thing about how we do still have to stop using fossil fuels and reach net zero emissions IN ADDITION TO sequestering the carbon we've already emitted more than one time in the whole film, because I just know people are going to take the rest of this message and run with it in the wrong direction. And they are really hammering home the appeal to emotions in the first half, to the point where I think the core of their argument suffers for it. Are you trying to explain this thing to me or are you throwing around buzzwords and pictures of sick children in hopes I'll get distracted?
Also they keep introducing guests with credentials like "ecologist from the Rodale Institute." You know nobody knows what the fuck that is, right? (It's an NGO dedicated to organic farming, for the record, but I did have to google it, and they had multiple guest speakers from this group.) Come on, you have no credibility if I can't tell where your info's coming from, and most people are not going to do background research as they watch a documentary.
Overall, I agree with their main points but I'm annoyed with how they made them. They're right about the ability of soil to sequester carbon, they're right that it could play a big role in climate change mitigation, and they're right that helping the soil is also better for people, ecosystems, and the planet. They're right about no till farming, permaculture, and crop diversity. They're even right about the bullshit that is the US industrial agricultural system, and they dug into how it came about in the post-WWII era, which isn't something I see talked about much. Kind of baffled how they managed to talk about soil degradation in the Midwestern USA without getting into the unique ways prairie soil and roots work, and instead went down a weird rambly path about how plows are bad (true, at least here - I cant speak for ecosystems I don't know as well - but explained poorly) and cows are good because this system evolved to have bison in it (sort of true, but incomplete. Cows aren't bison and the differences do matter.)
Also, reduced meat consumption is a very common thing that a lot of experts say is needed for climate change mitigation, and don't think I didn't notice how you sidestepped the issue just to say 'cows are good actually, stop vilifying cows.' I call bullshit. Just because cows work well in some ecosystems on a certain scale does not mean that it's possible to farm meat sustainably on the scale we currently do - factory farming and feedlots (CAFOs, if you want to get technical) are what allows us to make this much meat in the first place. You just admitted we need cows spread out on a lot more land to making ranching sustainable, and then failed to address the fact that this idyllic system doesn't really mesh with a world in which everybody eats multiple servings of beef per day. I see that decision and I know why you made it, because asking people to make sacrifices for the climate tends to make them ignore you, I don't even necessarily disagree with that decision because I know you're trying to persuade normal people and not environmentalists, but don't think I didn't notice.
Okay, fine, NOW they're talking about eating less meat and how what meat people do eat needs to come from more sustainable agricultural practices. Good. Better.
Oh look at our free range eggs, they're orange and that means they have more nutrients. Do they? Please back up this claim with scientific evidence. Of course the farmer says his eggs are better, he raised them. It's plausible, but I am pedantic and a scientist and I want data. You have to prove things to me.
Overall not a horrible documentary but ticks me off in several ways and tries to cram too many different subjects into like an hour and a half. Also, visiting the film's website makes me MORE ANGRY because they say even STUPIDER things about how they think climate science works. They make it sound like carbon sequestration in soil is THE solution which is BULLSHIT. There is no THE solution, there's gotta be a bunch of em stacked on top of each other - according to basically every climate change mitigation plan I've ever heard of (Project Drawdown is a good example). There's this metaphor I like to use to explain this to people - there's no silver bullet, but there could be silver buckshot. I read that somewhere once and cannot remember where but I'll never forget it.
Anyways, if you want a good intro to soil health directed at non-scientists/environmentalists, Kiss The Ground isn't bad, but you gotta think critically about some of the claims it's making because some of them are bullshit.
3 notes
·
View notes
i got to premiere a monster I had in the back of my mind yesterday: gluttonous soil
it's a monster that is somewhere between a turbot and an earth elemental, mixed up with several teeth and eyes. it looks simply like undisturbed soil, until it feels weight on itself, when it then waits for the weight to move over its mouth before it chomps away
hard to kill since you basically have to destroy the connections between the grains of sand, which even gives off a bit of blood that seeps into the creature again, causing a blood frenzy as a defence mechanism
lots of fun to run and great for a trap or two. party yesterday encountered it in a smaller form (about 2m²), but I've planning to mayhaps hide one in the desert (like ... 1km²???), in the snow, in the jungle, etc.
so many ways to use them. the image of the party stepping onto a rock in the desert, the rock then shudders and reveals it is one of several eyes all around them staring hungrily?
yea baby
2 notes
·
View notes
we went to a nearby plant nursery on my last day off and got just about everything we want to grow this season!! i’m most excited about the strawberries but we also got parsley and two bell pepper plants, one of which grows purple peppers?? i’ve never seen them before! i’m so excited for the first ones to come in :D
adrian is interested in growing flowers so he picked a really lovely bellflower plant and a small pot of alyssums. his mom grows flowers a lot so he’s got some basic experience already, though desert gardening plays by different rules than the midwest. it’s nice to see him all energized to help out, i think it’ll be good for both of us to get some sun and fresh air over the next few months :> if this batch goes well i want to get more vegetables to plant during our fall season!!
4 notes
·
View notes
Got my native garden plants todaaay! My favorite so far is the american dittany, such a cute little thing. I’m also really happy to be planting those scraggly looking ones on the ends, Torrey’s mountain mint, which is endangered in several states including mine.
I also picked up swamp milkweed, lyreleaf sage, wild bergamot, dense gayfeather (ngl mostly because of the name), and pink fuzzybean (ngl even more because of the name).
There’s still a few I really want that the county sale didn’t have, namely butterflyweed, some kind of beebalm, and my only nonnative addition, a lilac bush for my late miss Lilac. So will have to go looking at another nursery in the next couple weeks maybe.
6 notes
·
View notes