TBH I LOVE JACK MARSTON. Please do not kill me, but his story is SO SAD. As you can tell from the game he calls most of the people from the camp "uncle's" or "aunts" which died. Not in front of him, but one, someone told him. Or two, he had to find out by himself, if he had to add the pieces together or not. Also, Jack asks at least one time about Dutch, and if he would come and visit. You can tell that he cares a lot about his, what I would say "old family." He never gets the full story about them. ALSO ALSO. Jack gets kidnapped so many times, two times or one in RDR2, and RDR (1) gets kidnapped by the government. Still then, I would not think he should get the full story from Abigail or the police. There was not much time after that to tell Jack as well, you got to go do stuff with Abigail, then Uncle, then go after Jack to hunt, then go get him bc he went hunting by himself, ect, ect. Then John gets killed, and Abigail dies from a sickness soon later.
From knowing what I know of Abigail, she would only tell pieces and leave stuff out. He saw, death Uncle, heard about death, heard about people leaving bc "uncle" (dutch) was a bad person. He must have seen how bad the world was and that is why he is kind of a bitch.. I mean in RDR(1) he kinda acted like a brat, he had no way to cope, but read out of writing. But he could not really talk about it to anyone. So I would guess that was the reason.
Also about the voice thing, I agree that he voice sounds funny. BUT HAVE YOU HEARD JOHN YELL, I LAUGH EVERY TIME. 😃
But I do hope that Jack is the next protagonist in RDR, I think it would be cool to see what would happen next to the last person in the Dutch Van Der Linde game.. or many see Issac Morgan?? I know he is dead. But no one really sees him get killed. All Arthur sees are their graves. So I think that would be cool. (JASSAC.) Tbh I have any ideas if Issac and Jack meet up. My partner has helped me to! But I think that will be fun. Ik the new game is LONG time away, so who knows! All I hope is ITS NOT TRASH. And I think we ALL would agree on that.
(PLEASE DON'T HATE ON ME I WAS BORED SO HERE IS MY OPINION ON THR NEXT RD 😭🙏)