So, the Chapter 2 Q&A dropped (semi) recently. Thereās a ton of fun information in there, but Iām particularly focused on the reveal of Davidās favorite and least favorite colors. Yellow (reason: inspiring), and gray (reason: depressing).
These are clearly in reference to his main color associations. His fake inspirational speaker persona is associated with yellow and his current āguilty as chargedā persona is associated with gray. Davidās opinions on these colors are likely stand-ins for his opinions on his personas.
So now, an important question: Why does he still like yellow?
Itās a commonly agreed upon analysis that David doesnāt like the performance he has to put on in order to be an inspirational speaker. Itās a role heās forced to play, not one that he believes in personally. In the Chapter 2 trial he ditches that persona (and the yellow in his design) to act in a way that seems more liberating. Itās like his ātrue selfā, or at least a bit truer of a self. But thatās gray David, and David doesnāt like gray. Itās ādepressingā.
I think the colors represent how David feels about his own personality. I think that he wishes he could genuinely be like his inspirational speaker persona. If he was, heād probably be happier. He secretly wishes he could believe in the things he says to inspire people.
But David doesnāt believe in personal growth. He thinks if someone can become better, they were already good. He probably sees himself as a lost cause under this philosophy. Thereās no hope for him to be kind, genuine, or happy.
ā¦And thatās where Xander comes in. Xander, in Chapter 1, is a person who is kind, genuine, and happy. He fights for whatās right. And he looks up to David as someone who inspired him to be who he is today. David sees him use that inspiration for good when he stands up for Nico. When Xander tells David he inspires him, David responds by saying Xander is inspiring as well. Theyāre each otherās role model.
We have no way of knowing right now how much of what David does in Chapter 1 is genuine, but the fixation on Xander in the Literature Girl Insane MV makes me think that David and Xanderās connection was genuine, at least a little bit. But I donāt think itās just because Xander became his friend. I think itās because Xander became his role model.
Xander, to David, represents who David wishes he could be. He was more than just a friend. He was Davidās hope. A personification of the good Davidās given the world, as well as the chance David has to change. If he becomes more like Xander, maybe heāll live up to his inspirational speaker title. So they become friends and role models. Itās very sweet.
Then Xander tries to kill Teruko. And then he gets electrocuted and dies.
David vehemently defends Xanderās honor in the first trial. Itās not just because he liked Xander. If Xander was his role model of a good person, but he tried to kill someone, then there would be no hope left for David to be a good person either. Davidās symbol of hope dies abruptly.
In Chapter 2, David says no one is truly capable of change. He (likely) lies about killing Arei to get himself and the entire case executed. Heās given up on improving or ever being happy. Because the person who gave him the hope that he could change is dead.
I know itās a bit weird to go from Davidās color preferences to āXander is his hopeā, but thatās what clicked into place for me when I read those fun facts. Xanderās eyes are also gray/yellow, like Davidās, but unlike David they fluctuate with his emotions and not whatever persona heās putting on.
Also, Iām obviously not an expert. I could be totally wrong. Either way, Iām excited to see whatās done with Davidās character! Hello DRDT fandom.
It's always funny to me how Xanvid fans characterize Xander as being the hopeless yearner in their dynamic, because you look at the Literature Girl Insane MV (plus Tally5) and David is pulling some fuckery like "If something is important it will disappear" 'I hate the things that I love and I love the things that I hate" and THIS SHIT
Motherfucker, I will use my right as a boyliker to call you a slur
See I like Sans but not in the funny meme sexyman way I like him in the way that he promised Toriel to protect a child that was going to be served as a sacrifice from the start because he couldn't find himself to say no to her genuine laughter and sense of humor at every dumb joke they told each other, how he cracked jokes and pranks to make this child feel comfortable while warning them to be careful and reminding them that people loved them and having a gentle heart doesn't make you weak like to this day I still think about "Take care of yourself, kid. Cause someone out there really loves you." and "You didn't gain LOVE, but you gained love." Sans is our friend actually