#this isnt even the only thing i could write on this type of subject wrt ONE

[upsidedowngrass]

dunno why but always uneasy when i see "post-ONE liam becomes the new airy and hosts season 3" aus tbh? LIKE. ofc i dont think all of them are like that cut n dry but it just doesnt feel right for his character yknow? yeah ppl act ooc when faced w horrible situations but it feels like it contradicts how liams arc over the series implies he responds to things.

airy AND liam are both normal people in horrible situations ofc! and liam and airy are very much meant as parallels. but even if there was an equivalent to airy creating ONE for liam, i dont think it would be creating a new season of the very thing that traumatized him

also, season one happened over a decade ago, and airy ALSO only died a bit over a decade ago. he also died and ended up COMPLETELY alone. this implies he pretty quickly teleported ppl to the plane and subsequently threw a rock at them (not that simple yeah but u get the idea). he was lonely and restless and missed PEOPLE that i think he quickly i dont think airys experience of dying then being isolated evokes the same responses as liam being taken to the plane and Experiencing The Horrors does if that makes any sense?

a lot of liams motivations very specifically lie in saving ppl from the fucked up situation he was subjected to, and that prompts the majority of his actions! airys motivations are that of someone so isolated after dying that he wanted to bring ppl TO him! of anything, while their general concepts parallel each other, their responses to their experiences act more like foils, similar to how liam and amelia have concepts that act the same as each other and responses that mirror the other!

they both represent how these types of situations cause ppl to act in ways they never would before. but i think EVERY character represents this, but i think they are all meant to show these responses and different ways, and i think thats a key to understanding the intricacies of the characters better! (ex: amelia gives up on her old life and pours herself into helping the others, bryce pushes it all aside and views it as a worst case scenario type thing, etc)

liams response initially (as implied by the "i know it eas hard to let go" line) was to hold onto any hope he could (which seems to have been . very stressful) but then he stopped seeing himself as part of the equation. his main priority was to save anyone while he could bc as far as he was concerned, it was already over for him

airys response , while we dont see where he started outside of his present dialogue, seems to have been quickly letting go of that home of returning home. but he didnt just let go, he let go fast, by the looks of it. he didnt leave the world hed found specifically bc he thought it was the best he was gonna get. so he starts making everything liveable. but in doing so, he kinda gave himself a new motivation, that being ONE

liam held on as hard as he could, but resigned himself to letting go and saving the others from being stuck on the plane

the moment he felt like hed lost everything, he stopped caring about himself

airy let go quickly, but in doing so found something to take its place, which was bringing people to him and making his world more fun

the moment he realized hed gained something, he poured 10 years into perfecting it

#i also think it contradicts the narrative themes of one #BUT also a lot of these r aus so i get that thats not rly the focus of them! #also not maintagging this bc i dont want anyone to think im like #mocking their aus or saying their aus suck #bc like i said a lot are more complex than just #but i just have a loooot of thoughts on character personalities in one and how they relate to the other characters! #tho i will admit some versions of these aus make me a little. uncomfortable when they write liam as like #like That #if that makes sense #like the very. 'oh hes unhinged now' ones #which isnt TOO often but enough to make me uncomfortable yknow? #that might just be me though! #hfjone spoilers #ask to tag :) #also sorry if this is incoherent i just have many thoughts about ONE #this isnt even the only thing i could write on this type of subject wrt ONE #SHIT. after posting this it put one of the tags at the top. forgot quotes do that. bit also im on mobile so retyping the. is. NOT an option #so that series of tags may not make sense i am so sorry #BUT did also wanna reiterate that !! aus r ok and i dont want anyone to feel like im sayin their aus bad #i just have a lot of thoughts abt post-one and #esp since many ppl actually have this not just as an au but an interpretation of what happens after one 18 #and i wanted to throw my own thoughts into the ring!