#and them + celebrimbor + celebrimbor’s oc daughter; + all associated wives/mothers/in-laws

[tanoraqui]

optimal Fëanor reembodiment shenanigans, pt. ? of ?:

Fëanor: [generally trying to be Good(TM), but nonetheless throwing a minor hissy fit over how the jewelsmiths and related crafters of the Noldor have rallied around Celebrimbor as their leader and have no interest whatsoever in changing]

someone: I’m sorry, but did anything YOU ever made singlehandedly—okay, three-handedly—preserve the power and safety of Elves in Middle Earth for an Age and a half of the world, and play a major role in the salvation of the world from evil in general?

Fëanor: [points angrily and exemplifyingly up at the Star of Eärendil sailing by] YES!

someone else, swiftly: Oh, so you agree that Eärendil’s continued holding and keeping of the Silmaril is essential for the good of all Arda and should not be disrupted for any reason?

#feanor #oath of feanor #the silmarillion #feanor and feanor's kin #man you could make a fucked up paladin for that. anyway… #I DO want someone who isn’t me - preferably someone who a) has experience parenting and b) knows enough about smithing to make good metaphor #to write a 40k fic about feanor returning after curufin returned a few years or decades ago #and them + celebrimbor + celebrimbor’s oc daughter; + all associated wives/mothers/in-laws #working some stuff out about fatherhood; parenting; ethics of making powerful magical artifacts #when and how to let things and people go do their own thing even when you made them #when and how to go do your own thing even when you love your parent #etc #finwe should probably be there too #oh also they do this while working on some big craft project together obv #or multiple projects or sthng #the point is they cannot make a truly functional great thing until they sort out their messy feelings #ALSO I think it’d be fun if feanor’s initial first attempts to reforge a relationship with his grandson #involve him being like ‘you like jewelsmithing and are VERY good at it…/i/ like jewelsmithing and am still somewhat better at it… #I’m so proud of you and I’d love to teach you (and your friends! I’m sharing!) the things I know! #maybe we could even do a group project? #and overall completely accidentally hits every annatar-related red flag and celebrimbor shuts him down HARD