I wanna know your thoughts on why reg joined the death eaters and the relationship he had with them
hayati did i tell you already that i love you <3 anyway you've broken a dam so here is the official dissertation. TLDR first to lure you in and then more details under the cut.
Main narrative points in this essay:
The older gen of Blacks who went to school with Riddle were not supportive of the Death Eaters;
Regulus took the Mark out of his own volition;
The Death Eaters do not operate as a systematic regime like the Nazis (contrary to popular misconception), but rather as a typical religious terror organisation
When Regulus took the Mark, he was operating under several factors of pressure that pushed him to it:
him being a gullible impressionable 16yo like all boys are at this age;
a natural desire for power;
the DEs tactics of fear and intimidation;
all the important people in his life (who did not leave) joining them (Bella, his school friends, Lucius > so essentially Narcissa);
And most importantly:
Sirius' disinheritance leaving him in a position of the main and only male heir of the house aka the man who is supposed to protect the family, which, with the combination of factors at hand (the DEs terror tactics and the Blacks' status in Wizarding society that essentially determined their side in the war for them), could only be done by joining the Death Eaters
The older gen of Blacks who went to school with Riddle were not supportive of the Death Eaters: This is something Sirius himself mentions repeatedly. While he has no motive or desire to defend his parents, he states that they were not Death Eaters. Walburga and Co. all went to school with Riddle, they knew him as a half-blood orphan and an arrogant wanna-be dark wizard who they probably looked down on for his status. They were never part of the original DE gang (the Knights of Walpurgis). They could not afford to vocally oppose Voldemort due to their status as part of the Sacred 28 (re: social pressure), but I really, really doubt any of the older Blacks supported Bella and Reg joining the DEs.
Hence, the conclusion is that Regulus took the Mark out of his own volition, not out of pressure from his parents. (i recently talked about it here, here and here)
The Death Eaters do not operate as a systematic regime like the Nazis, but rather as a typical religious terror organisation: (talked about this in detail here) the DEs' pattern which we keep seeing all throughout the books and especially HBP + DH is by-the-book typical terror organisation behavior.
The main different is that a systematic regime (like the Nazis) acts by spreading propaganda first, bringing up an idea, brainwashing the population, then using said people to fight their war. It's an ideological war, the Nazis genuinely believed that the Jews are an inferior race.
Voldemort is not a parallel to Hitler, saying that is just misunderstanding how bad the Nazi regime really was. He does not believe that. He's a half-blood himself, he has no issue with people like Snape, he could NOT care less about the cause. He uses it in order to promote his own personal agenda, which in this case is immortality as a parallel to wealth. He is the CEO of Taliban.
The DEs, as a terror organisation, latch onto an existing bigotry in the Wizarding World, then abuse it and use it in order to establish themselves within pure-blooded circles and lure people in said community to join them using tactics of intimidation and terror (see: the Malfoys in HBP and DH. He forces himself onto them, their house, their son - it is very clear that they are not doing it out of free will, rather than fear of what might happen to them if they don't cooperate).
Okay, Dani, what does any of this have to do with Regulus taking the Mark?
Regulus is sixteen. Unlike his brother, he is shoved into a House which is essentially an echo-chamber of the same ideology he grew up with. All his friends are other members of the S28, none of whom challenge any of his views. He is young and impressionable like all boys his age, and he has a natural desire for power and control, especially coming from a house with parents like Walburga and Orion, that leave very little freedom and control to their children.
Sirius and Andromeda leave. Bellatrix joins the DEs and Narcissa marries Malfoy, who later joins them as well (altho they do it for different reasons - Bella is seeking power and control, while Malfoy seeks protection for his family. For Regulus, it's a combination of both), so in his 16 yo brain, what registers is: okay, these are my two options. I have to either be a traitor (and lose any money and respect I had), or join a terror cult (gaining power and protection). The choice is pretty simple in his head.
Now, these are my speculations at this point, but judging by the way Voldemort treats the Malfoys in HBP+DH, it is easy to assume that upon recruitment, any pure-blooded family that refused to provide support would suffer some sort of consequences.
On top of all that, Sirius leaves +/- 1 year before Regulus canonically takes the Mark. This comes as a surprise and leaves Regulus with a lot of responsibility and baggage that he was never prepared for.
He is now the only remaining male heir of the House - it means not only that he is now single-handedly responsible for the lineage's survival, he is also the "provider" and the "protector" of the family - his wrong choices will bear consequences and punishment not only for him, but for his parents and cousins. He can not allow himself to fuck up.
56 notes
·
View notes
I think what a lot of tumblr-only people are missing about twitter failing, is that it was always a better website when it came to small businesses, instant world event news, fact checking, having users from all over the world, being a source for disaster relief information or warnings, and anything else to keep people up to date with going ons.
Sure, tumblr has many users from all over, but the website is still largely english biased and not nearly as widespread as twitter. I know a lot of news and knowledge comes in on here too. I've learned a lot and see a lot of donation posts in regards to world events, but its nothing like twitter unless you know who to follow. Not to mention, half the news I got here, was days later and from twitter to begin with.
Seeing that being taken away in favor of hate speech and enabling abusers (with the recent potential of getting rid of the block feature over there) and pushing blue user comments to the top (aka elon's weird fans), drowning out anyone else on popular posts, sucks! It sucks for the world and small businesses. because there's really no alternative to it right now.
The site's running rampant with spam and scammers and its becoming more and more unusable by the day. And some people think it's silly to be upset over it or "you shouldn't have all your eggs in one basket" well there only is one basket! This is literally people's livelihoods people seem to be making fun of anytime a change happens that breaks the site and people post all their socials.
And everyone from every country is talking about different websites they're considering, and its splitting up our connection to the world. And surely he knew who this was hurting with every decision.
1K notes
·
View notes
Chapter 158 vs. Chapter 298
“I am under no illusions that I could ever beat you on my own.”
(don’t mind me going insane under the cut)
ugh there’s two big things that make me crazy about this and
1 is the surface level of just how yamaguchi’s individual growth keeps going even after the seijoh 2 match—when he gets those run of points and it becomes clear to us that his hard work has paid off—but it doesn’t just stop there! the first panels here are from the shiratorizawa match, the next match after seijoh 2, and i love this bc it’s another example of haikyuu saying “hey so that thing you wanted, you worked hard, you earned it, celebrate!” but then going on to ask “okay so what do we work for next?” and for yamaguchi he’s gone from ‘i just want to be on the court with them’ (deciding to learn jump floats) to ‘i wish i could get my body to listen to me the way theirs seem to’ (failing in siejoh 1 and doubling down during tokyo training camp) to the first panels here ‘i want to contribute/add value to the team’ to then finally the panels from the nekoma match where he can do more than just help, now it’s ‘i want all those things and more. i’m going to get these points with the team and for the team, all with my serve.’ and he DOES! like the GROWTH in his confidence!! aahh
and 2!! this is where i start to really lose it lmao, is his inspiration for all of that! why does yamaguchi play volleyball? because he thinks volleyball is cool. why is it cool? bc tsukki plays and tsukki is cool, and akiteru played and akiteru is cool, right? but is that enough?? by the time high school comes maybe it isn’t, bc of everything that’s happened and he’s a little disenchanted, but then he hears hinata and kageyama’s “as long as i’m here you’re invincible” and he thinks oh sHIT that’s cool! but he doesn’t have that kind of confidence, and he isn’t a setter or really a hitter, he’s barely even a server at this point—the only position on the court where you could gain points entirely alone—but THEN he also sees and understands the significance of a perfectly executed serve and block and he thinks not only is that ALSO super cool, but he realizes if he can get better he can do that super cool thing not just for himself, but for the team and more specifically, for tsukki.
yamaguchi sees hinata and kageyamas totally insane, reciprocal declaration of making the other better and he starts to get mad at tsukki for not trying. because volleyball is cool, making each other stronger is cool, and tsukki is supposed to be cool too!! and instead of giving up, yamaguchi puts tsukki in his place and then yamaguchi just keeps trying even harder!! and his hard work and dedication is perplexing to tsukki. it’s frustrating bc he can’t understand it yet but he also can’t deny the fact that it certainly isn’t lame. yamaguchi’s passion has never been lame, and then tsukki starts to get inspired too. slowly it begins to cycle, and spiral upwards. yamaguchi took the first initiative to seek out shimada, tsukki joins his brothers practices and agrees to train with the gym 3 boys, yamaguchi has his ‘moment’ when he gets all those points in seijoh 2, tsukki has his when he stuffs ushijima (and neither of them is surprised by either of those moments!! of course they work they’ve been watching has paid off), and then by the time the nekoma match comes up yamaguchi’s confidence has grown tremendously, he gets an ace immediately after those panels and thennn he and tsukki execute their first successful serve and block. the volleyball equivalent of a perfect play.
we never see yamaguchi and tsukki practice together, and yet separately they’ve been working toward this, silently inspiring each other over and over. individual work but not only individual growth. tsukki tells kuroo he never ever thought he could beat any of them on his own. in his own way, yamaguchi’s actions have made tsukki invincible too. and kuroo and tsukki also both acknowledge that yamaguchi is already a step ahead once again, planning how he can do even more, starting the cycle another time. they keep passing the inspiration back and forth, connecting one volleyball moment to the next to drive the other to keep working, keep trying for even more!!!!! aaaaaahh
98 notes
·
View notes