#the shaving of the sideburns looks exceedingly silly

[heyclickadee]

Weird confession, probably an unpopular opinion, but: I actually like a lot of the concepts and basic designs behind the costumes in the Rings of Power series more than I like the concepts and basic designs behind the costume in the PJ Lord of the Rings films (with the costumes for the rohirrim and the people in Gondor being the exception). Don’t get me wrong, the costumes in the PJ Lord of the Rings series look amazing. They’re gorgeous and, on the whole, better made than the Rings of Power costumes. It’s just that the there’s something very dungeons and dragonsy about the PJ Lord of the Rings costumes (especially for the elves), and I know that’s because there was a twenty year feedback loop where there was a slight DnD-ness to the PJ Lord the the Rings elf outfits which then just became standard Elf Clothes in LOTR fanart which then fed back into the people making art for the DnD handbooks, but still. And I’ll admit I’m biased—it just so happens that that aesthetic is one I don’t particularly like. So seeing the costumes in Rings of Power make a clean break from that was really refreshing. And they mostly look like clothes people would wear. And I love the ideas in the designs! Elrond’s brown cloak with the feathers? That’s a sweet little tribute to his mom. The gold dust makeup on Disa’s hands and her robe (which honestly looked better in action than it did in the promo shots)? Neat concept. Tar-Miriel’s crown (and all of her outfits, actually)? Stunning. I’m in love. I just wish the designers and costume makers had been given all the time they needed to really make every costume look as good as they probably looked in their heads.

#rings of power #a lot of them did look very nice on screen #some of them just needed a little more time in production #also you know what #I’m okay with elves with short hair #the shaving of the sideburns looks exceedingly silly #I’ll admit that #but elves can have more than one haircut #(I’ll admit that the long iron straightened half tied back in elegant twists look #is not an aesthetic I particularly like #either #and that I have kind of #weeeeeelll #ambivalent #feelings towards the PJ elves #I adore those movies but I do cordially disagree #with many of the adaptational choices #Tolkien adaptations #this is only tangentially related #but in my head Glorfindel has very long very curly floofy hair