hi, i wanted to give you an update on that post of mine you reblogged. heritageposts has informed me that they were using the red triangle in this context: https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20231123-one-small-red-triangle-palestine-we-are-finally-looking/
i was wrong about what they meant with the 🔻 emoji and i am officially rescinding my previous statement
I am all for fact checking and I would love to believe that Heritage Posts did not mean this particular horrible thing they did.
However, Middle East Monitor (MEMO) is not a reliable source for information in this conflict. If HP is actually using MEMO for news, they should focus on more reliable ones going forward.
There are plenty of other left-leaning sources with more reliability, credibility, sourcing, and transparency.
They have failed several fact checks for misleading and occasionally false information. The publication is explicitly and repeatedly pro-Hamas, and they often omit vital information to skew their stories.
While they are not rated as an outright propaganda publication or as a source of conspiracy theories, they do often cite sources which do and are.
Finally, they are funded by donations. Of course these donations largely come from people who support the kind of reporting that people who donate to them support. They are a nonprofit organization, which is not inherently a bad thing. But this means their interests are not based in journalistic ideals but in political ideology. This is not a reason to completely discount a source, but it is something to keep in mind.
In general, with a topic this intense and with such profound consequences for so many people, I’m only engaging with sources who receive a “reporting” rating of “high” or better and a “credibility” rating of “high credibility.”
I would POSSIBLY consider a “reporting” rating of “Mostly factual” if it had a “high credibility” rating and several extenuating circumstances and reduced media bias to compensate for its lower score in another area.
Leftist sources worth referencing instead:
Forward Progressives
Haaretz
International Policy Digest
Current Affairs
And many others
Personally, though, (for this particular conflict especially) I tend to prefer sources that fall into the central three categories: left-center biased, least biased, and right-center biased.
No news source is perfect or without bias. But this conflict is so fraught that I frankly don’t trust anyone reporting with extreme ideological intentions. And I also don’t want to only read sources that make me comfortable. I am personally very leftist in all of my personal politics and voting. However, I also know that the far left has been more hostile to me based solely on my Jewish ethnicity than anyone else in these past months. Furthermore, I think politicians should be more left, but journalism should always prioritize facts and a full scope of a situation over any one viewpoint. I am the daughter of a journalist. I am deeply in favor of journalistic freedom. And I absolutely do NOT believe in “both sidesism.” Sometimes, there really aren’t two sides to a situation that are both equally worth listening to. There is no alternative viewpoint to “Black Lives Matter” for example that is not deeply racist.
There are not “two sides worth teaching” when it comes to The Holocaust.
But the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is not so simple. Israel should stop its bombing of Palestine. Palestinians should have full and equal rights. Jewish people in Israel and around the world should not have to live in constant fear or attack, harassment, or murder. There are a lot of extremely valid perspectives from Palestinians, Muslims, Israelis, Arabs, and Jews. And right now, the far left and the far right are weaponizing their ideologies to reduce all of the aforementioned groups to their worst actors. That is not something that will help anyone with regard to this conflict.
Left Leaning Sources
ABC News
Associated Press
Atlantic Media
Boston Globe
The Forward (This is a Jewish source. They had one failed fact check in the last five years, but issued an official correction.)
Human Rights Watch
Institute for Middle East Understanding (This is a Palestinian source and it has a completely clean fact check record)
Least Biased Sources
Jewish Telegraphic Agency (Obviously a Jewish source)
Reuters (this has a Very High reporting rating)
American Press Institute (not only have they not failed a fact check in five years; they have never failed a fact check ever)
The Conversation
Pew Research
Foreign Policy
Foreign Affairs
Sky News UK
Right Leaning
Note: As I stated numerous times, including in this post, I am a leftist. However, something important for American readers of this post to know is that, when it comes specifically to matters involving military analysis of foreign conflicts, a slight right lean in perspective is common and sometimes preferable to leftist idealism. I say this as someone who votes and holds opinions that are about as far left as one can get. However, I also say this as someone with a background in university studies of international politics. Because analysis of military conflicts is often done by those with experience in and understanding of the military, most of the most credible and detailed analyses of foreign military affairs do tend to be more right leaning than sources of equal worth focused on domestic political matters. Furthermore, a leftist tendency toward pacifism (which I share) tends to mean less leftist involvement in military-involved political matters at all. Of course, none of this means there are no quality leftist sources on the current conflict (which I obviously demonstrated by linking to such sources above). I am simply explaining the value of such sources to those who may justifiably be skeptical of anything right-leaning after the hellish past two decades of domestic policies and US-caused violence in other countries.
Note 2: There are plenty of right-leaning sources that received “high” credibility ratings and “high” reporting ratings. I found no sources that had both “very high” credibility and “high” reporting ratings in the “right-center” category.
Boston Herald
Chicago Tribune
Counter Extremism Project
Foreign Policy Research Institute
The Jewish Press (clearly a Jewish source, this publication is geared toward the Modern Orthodox Jewish community. They have no failed fact checks)
ITV News
Jewish Unpacked (this source has no failed fact checks. this source is right-leaning by necessity because of its historical examination of antisemitism in leftist spaces making those spaces inherently unsafe for Jews—not specifically in this most recent flare up in the I/p conflict, but for years).
Right Bias
Note: I don’t personally follow or read any of these sources. But I did list leftist sources with high credibility and reporting ratings, so I will do the same here in the interest of fairness. It should be noted that all other source bias ratings had results several pages long. Right Bias sources with high credibility and reporting ratings were confined to one page only. There are no Right Bias Sources with Very High reporting ratings and high credibility.
Economic Policy Journal (no failed fact checks now or ever)
Influence Watch (tends to view liberal and progressive politics as “extremist,” but has no failed fact checks.)
I am not inclined to trust HP simply because their most recent antisemitic behavior fell short of hoping for Jewish genocide. I have a higher bar for accounts than that.
164 notes
·
View notes
I finally caught up with WBN, and oh dear gods I am so scared for them. I also have thoughts, because this whole episode felt like a giant panic attack going in two directions. This got long.
Ame can't pinpoint the moment she decides she needs to go, but I feel like it's that moment after you've realised you've partied too long and it's getting late. Like you need to go home and you're already in trouble and you know you can't fix it, but you still need to go like an hour ago. If only you could like reverse time long enough to make that decision at the moment you should have.
But it's not a conscious decision, so it's a nascent panic. That Fox is going to feel, and is going to interpret that as feeling trapped. So it ends up, at least how I'm seeing it as a feedback loop. Ame's not aware she's pushing those feelings aside, it's been fed to Fox and Fox is feeding back feeling trapped and claustrophobic and needing to run. And since it's all under the surface, it's hard to articulate, other than I need to go.
Because let's face it. These three need to have a nice long conversation about this internal shit and kind of explain how things are processing, but at the moment it's literally a "gotta go now, can't talk, words too slow"
And poor Suvi, who, like Brennan said in the fireside, has been taught from every single adult in her life that obedience is love, doing hard work you're not really into is how I show my appreciation and love, has also just walked out of her mom's place fully intending to go with Ame. It's not until that order from Steel that she stops moving because at that point, that it hits her how devastating that decision is and how in this moment she cannot cross this line. This line is too far, this line may not be the manifestation of throwing her family away but it feels like that. Decades of being the good and obedient child, the one who follows the rules to the letter all the time, every time is going up against a very new and burgeoning rebellion and possibly a search for autonomy, but I'm not willing to put words in Suvi's mouth just yet.
But I do know the feeling of panic that happens when you've always been the one who listened and followed the rules and stepping out of line here and now (I'm not ignoring the first chapter, but the first chapter was Suvi truly believing she was heading in the right direction and being stealth for safety's sake, and even the running after Ame was more a panic impulse decision) this decision here to leave her mom's place and then ignore her order is so much deeper, so much more than just "oh I need to protect my friends".
Prior to this, and even here, had Ame or Eursulon been in true danger she would have thrown hands. This is her home and even with the weirdass situation of the imperium dragging folks from their homes, Suvi knows she's safe and by extension believes both Ame and Eursulon are safe as well. So she's not sensing any of the danger that Ame is feeling, so she's not going to go against her mom. I'm assuming this is one of those "well shit, but mom probably has more Intel and that will help and if we can't get to Toma because it's super unsafe then at least we'll go to the north pole".
But unfortunately for all of them, Ame's panic is playing that weird like 5th dimensional time travelling chess with both the Fox's need for freedom, and who knows how much inherent magic and history she has just inherited as the opponent.
Maybe Suvi is right and the most they'll be delayed is 45 minutes and off they go. And maybe whatever panic is driving Ame is correct and if she doesn't get home to Toma to claim that space, the council will have an easier time destroying her. We don't know, and likely won't know even next week if this was a terrible decision or not.
Nobody is at fault, and yet they all bear some responsibility for how this happened. They're doing exactly what they feel is necessary in the situation and yes communication would help, but it cannot solve this. This is two fundamental forces that don't oppose each other but do have wildly different origins butting heads for real. Witches are wisdom based and emotional and social and have a lot of we do this because we have to take into consideration that we are important but also guests in a world built by spirits. And wizards are intelligence, and taxonomy, and strategies, and if I can get enough information I will understand this problem and find a solution.
Eursulon, is caught in the middle, but also can see that if it weren't for Suvi and by extension Steel, his life in the Citadel would be very different. So given his history with how quickly safe cities and towns turn hostile, if a witch says run, he's going to run.
I'm so happy that the dice wanted to tell a specific story and Eursulon was able to save those wizards and see all of the paths. I can't wait to see what he decides to do.
I am also devastated at the fracture that has appeared in Ame and Suvi's friendship and I'm hoping that they are able to find the path to healing. I trust the narrative and I super trust all the players, they definitely know what they're doing. I've been watching the actual plays long enough to trust that process. But until then I'm going to cry for them and gnaw on furniture until the next episode.
And the Fox is an innocent boy who added 2+4 and somehow divided by 0 to get explosion.
5 notes
·
View notes