They Don't Teach This Review
They Don’t Teach This Review
Hi, and welcome back! Today I will be talking about “They Don’t Teach This: Lessons From the Game of Life” by Eniola Aluko.
The blurb reads:
First class honors law degree. 102 appearances for England women’s national football team. First female pundit on Match of the Day. UN Women UK ambassador. Guardian columnist.
All of these achievements belong to Eni Aluko, who, is keen to share her…
View On WordPress
0 notes
Eni Aluko is a part owner of FC Como
The primary owner is financial group, Mercury13
https://www.theguardian.com/football/2024/mar/12/mercury13-the-group-aiming-to-rethink-football-ownership-moving-the-goalposts
#RMSoccer
0 notes
Breaking Boundaries or Breaking Point? Joey Barton's Diatribe on Women Football Commentators
In the evolving world of football broadcasting, the game's flow is complemented and enriched by the voices describing its details. Recent comments regarding female broadcasters within men’s football made by former footballer Joey Barton has created uproar. As football fans we are not merely spectators, we are active participants, engaging in a larger conversation that helps to shape our experiences of the beautiful game. Interestingly, Barton’s recent remarks extend further than a single conversation: his comments added fuel to existing, wider conversations about diversity. Are we witnessing a necessary evolution in football commentary, or has the push for diversity reached considerable challenges?
What is happening?
Barton’s recent remarks, that began on the social media ‘X’ have sparked numerous reactions across the football community and beyond. Essentially, he is rejecting the idea of women having commentary roles in men’s football, branding this to be part of a broader ‘woke agenda’. His statements are not merely personal observations, deliberately stirring discussion about wider societal change and gender dynamics in the world of football broadcasting.
Joey Barton argues that he’s not against women because of their gender; he doesn’t like the principle of women being awarded roles that are important in men’s football as a way of showing people that they are inclusive. He believes that in football commentary people should be selected based solely on their skillset even if that means that there will be no women.
History of Women in Football Commentary
Sports commentary has had a long history of unequal treatment based on gender. Women have had a tough time getting into commentary for many years, and when they do their contributions are often not appreciated or taken seriously. Old-fashioned, stereotypical ideas and conventions about what men and women should do have shaped people’s perceptions of women football commentators. Barton’s comments fit into a similar narrative from history, where women are kept on the sidelines, trying hard to overcome long-standing prejudices. As described by Ali Bowes et al 2023 the increased inclusion of women as pundits in televised match coverage has been a gradual process. In 2007 Jacqui Oatley became the first female football commentator on the television programme Match of the Day since its origins in 1964. The next female was former England International Eniola Aluko, breaking ground in 2014 as the first women in this presenting role. Aluko notably contributed to the television coverage of the 2018 World Cup, pushing her into the media spotlight.
Women reporters have often found it challenging to get players and coaches and even the audience to see them as reporters first and women second. A study made by Swanson 2009 was conducted where he interviewed female journalists. He found that they “spoke of a love or passion for sports” with the majority playing one or more sports in the past. This discredits the suggestion that women commentators are less knowledgeable, qualified, and professional than their male counterparts.
Has there been improvement?
Over a five-year span there has been an increasing number of female pundits. Looking at the research from David Lenton 2022 he identified that the presence of women covering men’s games, either as commentators or pundits has seen remarkable growth. It grew 5650% from 2016/17 to 2020/21 (from 12 appearances to 690). Two seasons ago (2020/21) saw 2500 male commentators and pundits appearing in all televised men’s games - a difference of 1810. While the female representation has grown dramatically, there is still a huge gap to fill.
Push for diversity
The push for diversity is a vital aspect of progress in the sports industry. It helps to break down historical barriers and provide opportunities for individuals regardless of gender. The drivers behind the push include the recognition that talent and expertise are not limited by gender but can be found in individuals with diverse backgrounds and experiences. Alex Scott is a brilliant example of this. After retiring from football in 2017 she broke major barriers by becoming the first female football pundit at the World Cup for the BBC and joined Sky Sports Super Sunday as the first female pundit. Findings from 2017 found that 88.5% of sport reporters were male which makes Alex Scott’s achievement even more impressive.
Like any significant shift, there can be unintended consequences. As depicted by Burch et al 2023, even with female commentator's obvious expertise they often face scepticism about their knowledge and competence in sports. Additionally the rise of online platforms has exposed them to a wave of harassment and abuse, perpetuating a hostile and discouraging environment. However, within the industry the ongoing efforts to promote gender equality are evident. Gender pay gaps still persist, with female journalists earning less than their male counterparts for similar roles and responsibilities.
Some people support Barton and say that everyone has a right to an opinion. However, many others like me disagree with Barton’s outspoken standpoint. Football commentary and broadcasting should be platforms that embrace diversity and inclusivity. Dismissing the idea of women having roles in football commentary sustains current biases and contributes to the ongoing issue of sexism in football commentary. He pointed out how you need to play football at a high level to be able to talk about it, however there are many talented women broadcasters that didn’t play football at all. A couple that spring to my mind is Kate Abdo and Laura Woods. This makes me question whether Barton’s idea of who is ‘Credible’ is more about keeping things the way they’ve always been and maintaining sexism in football commentary.
So what is the solution? Football commentary has always been opinionated people sharing their opinions more than sharing facts. Fans may watch certain sport shows because they like personalities such as the CBS Sports Champions League Show, which is full of personalities including the likes of Thierry Henry, Micah Richards, Jamie Carragher and Kate Abdo. What arguably makes the show entertaining is that they are brilliant personalities while also reporting on the football. This has nothing to do with their gender which is why I don't understand Joey Barton's sexist comments.
Seeing change in the future
Football, as a dynamic and influential part of our cultural landscape, provides a unique platform for connection, dialogue and debate. Barton’s comments have sparked discussions reflecting the extremes within the football community. On one side, fans unite with a shared goal of supporting one another; while on the other side, you have people's passion which blinds their negative comments and viewpoints.
The necessary evolution in football commentary demands a positive change in fan engagement. Supporters should channel their voices to drown out the negativity. Embracing this shift will not only enhance the fan experience but also contribute to creating an inclusive and supportive environment within the realm of football commentary.
What’s your take on Joey Barton’s Views? Is the push for diversity in football commentary a necessary evolution, or does it risk undermining the credibility of the sport? Share your thoughts below and join the conversation.
N0993793
2 notes
·
View notes
Dug back in the archives and I found out I was at a game and saw this line up play 🤯🤯
England Starting XI: Karen Bardsley; Claire Rafferty (Alex Greenwood 61), Steph Houghton(C), Casey Stoney, Lucy Bronze; Jill Scott, Karen Carney (Jade Moore 82), Katie Chapman (Fran Kirby 72), Lianne Sanderson (Fara Williams 61); Toni Duggan; Ellen White (Eniola Aluko 61). (4-4-2)
3 notes
·
View notes
The Mead stans don't realized, what Mead rrally said. Even in the article revision, the context is still the same. She denies racism in women football. I think she didn't listen to Eniola Aluko or Anita Assante. Two black footballer who experienced racism.
3 notes
·
View notes
Eni’s latest Instagram caption reads like this new role wasn’t really her choice but more like she had to because the higher ups weren’t too happy. Idk maybe I read too much into things.
https://www.instagram.com/reel/ChSdFAXpCp-/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
Hmm.. interesting
3 notes
·
View notes
$100M Investment: Eniola Aluko Makes History as First Female Black Football Club Owner in Italy
Nigerian-born, former British footballer Eniola Aluko recently made history as the first black woman to own a football club in Italy.
0 notes
ENI ALUKO BIOGRAPHY, EDUCATION, CAREER, CONTROVERSIES AND NET WORTH
ENI ALUKO BIOGRAPHY – Eniola Aluko MBE, born on February 21, 1987, is a British-Nigerian football executive, broadcaster, and former professional player, known for her versatility as a winger and striker. She has transitioned into roles off the field, notably as a broadcaster for live football matches. Aluko made history as the first Sporting Director for Angel City FC and previously served as…
View On WordPress
0 notes
Fotbollen i England växer så det knakar
Få länder har genomgått en så enorm utveckling av fotbollen som “moderlandet” England.
När jag såg Chelsea för första gången 2013 ute i Tooting och träffade Emma Hayes, hennes assisterande Paul Green och landslagsspelaren Eniola Aluko efter en match mot ett amerikanskt universitetslag hävdade Hayes att England skulle ha världens bästa liga om 4-5 år.
Man kan fortfarande diskutera om England har…
View On WordPress
0 notes