Genie's SG-1 Rewatch: Singularity
Season 1, Episode 15. In which I have a VERY unexpected reaction to the setup to this episode, and then cry.
PREVIEW:
6:42
THIS IS WHY YOU DON’T PUT A LITERAL WELCOME SIGN ON A PLANET ANNOUNCING YOUR PRESENCE JFC
“Dear Bad Guys, the SGC has an outpost here on this defenseless planet, please come kill everyone in it and send a doomsday device in the chest of a cute, traumatized little girl to destroy the SGC and all the stuff in a several-mile radius, kthxbai”
6:46
And now I’m getting upset that I don’t think they ever deal with the fact that it’s essentially their fault Hanka showed up on the Goa’uld radar at all
And not in a “sometimes our presence has unintended, unforeseeable consequences” kind of way but in a “We were homicidally negligent in our treatment of this planet” way
5:10
Yay Singularity
A nice palette cleanser after Hathor, ugh
Lol Daniel “it’s black and it’s a hole”
This man is a PhD
5:11
I love Sam’s spiraling hand gestures describing the matter entering the black hole
Very cute, if dangerous
5:12
“Actually, it’s called the accretion disc”
That’s my man, Jack
Not just a pretty face
5:14
HEH Daniel’s slow on the uptake there
Again, this man is a PhD
5:15
HEE Sam backing Jack’s knowledge up I loooooove it
And I love them
Sassy squared
“Not initially” ew jack
5:17
Okay, hold up though — is this the first (and I’m pretty sure the last?) time we get this like road sign for a planet?
5:18
I am very confused by this thing, because I don’t think you’d want to advertise the SGC’s presence on this planet (HI GOAULD, WELCOME TO HANKA, ENJOY YOUR STAY!)
And people from the SGC would certainly know who FROM THE SGC would be there
5:19
What is exactly the point of this highway sign aside from memorializing whoever Douglas McLean is (of blessed memory, I’m sure, not trying to be mean to this person)
5:20
What a weird ass thing to put here
5:22
Teal’c spidey sense is tingling
Oh no poor guy
I’m glad that they’ve put Daniel through at least some basic emergency protocols
He springs right into action there
5:24
So one of the things that Mr Genie and I talk a lot about is that the US military would not send just 4 people through through an alien device to unknown territory
5:26
And I also have trouble suspending disbelief a little with remote bases on other planets because it’s veeeeerrrrry unlikely there’d be just a handful of people in these places ever
So like SG1 showing up and wondering where everyone is...is just not something I think would actually happen
5:30
(Another random aside: I also sometimes wonder why they picked the Air Force as the managing service for the Stargate and not, say, the Army — I get it’s the most technology-oriented of the services and I am definitely biased toward them, but the USAF doesn’t really do infantry. I would have expected to see them either hand field operations over to the Army or see Joint Operations established waaaaaay earlier)
5:32 PM
Oof they’re all dead
I knew that was coming, but still, that sucks
5:33
WHY IS JANET’S HAIR DOWN
AND WHY IS IT DOWN OFF WORLD
The military doesn’t care if you’re pretty! JFC
5:34
Although yes, damn Janet is pretty
Don’t distract me, you’re out of uniform!
5:36
Ugh is that a kid? I hate that (I mean I know other kids must have died but of course it upsets me to see it)
5:37
Do we ever find out if Cassie has any siblings?
I wish we’d gotten more of her backstory
5:38
I feel like the story of her life before Sam and Janet was pretty thin considering this calamitous thing that happened
hahaha Teal’c is making that face!
5:40
(I always thought it was RDA that said this, but apparently it was Michael Shanks who once took Chris Judge aside and was like, “you’re a handsome guy, why are you always doing that thing with your face???”)
TEAL’C IS SO GENTLE I LOVE HIM SO MUCH
My heeeeeeaaaaaart
5:41
Oh Sam, please stop telling the little girl who’s entire world was basically just murdered that everything’s okay
5:43
I like that Sam gets to be soft in this episode
So often characters like hers don’t get to be soft without being punished in some way for it
5:45
Okay, so here’s the thing though
I get why Sam would feel that SGC died for nothing if they didn’t study the black hole
BUT I don’t understand the argument she’s trying to make about the rest of HANKA
At this point there’s no reason to believe their deaths have anything to do with the phenomena so her curiosity comes across as really callous and selfish
5:49
That was a good bit of camera work, seeing the gate room from Cassie’s perspective
It came across as pretty daunting
5:50
Oh my god Sam, why in the world would you think leaving a little girl whose WHOLE WORLD HAS JUST DIED in a concrete room on an unfamiliar planet by herself?
5:51
This isn’t even “never been a parent before” stuff, this is BASIC HUMAN DECENCY STUFF
5:52
why is Janet’s hair STILL DOWN
It is way past her collar
I don’t know why this is bugging me BUT IT IS REALLY BUGGING ME
5:54
Sam drawing herself into Cassie’s picture so she knows she’s not alone kills me every. time.
5:55
Y’all ever think about Cassie was trapped by herself on a planet surrounded by the corpses of everyone she ever knew
5:57
I hate that we didn’t see the real consequences from that in the show
5:57 PM
sighs forever at this shows ongoing inability to handle real fallout on screen like 99% of the time
5:58 PM
The scene with Jack explaining black holes to Teal’c is very funny but totally pointless
Couldn’t we have skipped this and dealt with emotional stakes instead
Did we just need to remind everyone that Jack and Teal’c are still on the planet? Lol
6:01
I love that silly grabby hands thing Sam does to Cassie in the infirmary
Very much something I might do to make my kids laugh
6:02
Oh Cassie
6:03
“What? What do I do?”
Aaaaahhhh Sam
I feel ya honey, it’s the worst
6:04
Why are they doing CPR though? Is she not breathing? They didn’t say Cassie wasn’t breathing
I’m confused
Okay, so now she’s intubated that was fast
Not sure what’s actually wrong here but it sucks all around
6:06
There’s...nothing attached to the breathing tube
Why is it there
Did they mean to place an airway?
I AM VERY CONFUSED BY THIS DRAMATIC MEDICAL SCENE
6:13
Okay, not for nothing, but: if the show had chosen to pivot to Janet and Sam: Adoptive Moms/Life Partners Who Solve Mysteries, they would have had at least one viewer
That viewer would have been me
6:14
I know this is a serious moment but this shot with that blue lighting is very flattering to Janet, Sam, and Daniel
6:15
Okay, I’m sorry, hold up again
How exactly are they visualizing or trying to remove (or whatever it is they’re doing) Cassie’s chest bomb thing?
Did they cut her open??? Is it minimally invasive surgery? What exactly is happening here
6:18
Are we saying it’s an intelligent tumor/bomb
I never got this part of the story
6:20
This is a really sweet moment between Sam and Daniel
Daniel is actually being kind and supportive and I love him for it
Good job, Daniel
6:21
I love that Jack is enthusiastic about studying the black hole
But I am a little annoyed that they let him enjoy this without making fun of him for it
And that he gets to be proud of his knowledge of astronomy
While Sam is so often set up and then mocked for her expertise/belittled for enjoying nerdy things
BUT WHATEVER I’M NOT BITTER
6:42
THIS IS WHY YOU DON’T PUT A LITERAL WELCOME SIGN ON A PLANET ANNOUNCING YOUR PRESENCE JFC
“Dear Bad Guys, the SGC has an outpost here on this defenseless planet, please come kill everyone in it and send a doomsday device in the chest of a cute, traumatized little girl to destroy the SGC and all the stuff in a several-mile radius, kthxbai”
6:46
And now I’m getting upset that I don’t think they ever deal with the fact that it’s essentially their fault Hanka showed up on the Goa’uld radar at all
And not in a “sometimes our presence has unintended, unforeseeable consequences” kind of way but in a “We were homicidally negligent in our treatment of this planet” way
Like, I am kind of appalled now because I can’t unsee it
Did they never talk to Cassie about this? Jesus
Like holy shit this is several levels of terrible that I never thought about before
6:56
That is some amazing resolution on that telescope (not satellite, lol)
(Apologies, I’m pretty salty tonight)
7:00
And now I’m feeling very conflicted about using this little girl’s trauma as drama fodder for Sam
Damn, I am looking at this ep in a whole new way
(And also. I don’t buy Sam’s ‘military’ excuse for having to be detached. that doesn’t make sense to me at all)
7:02
Stepping back from the hella problematic setup of this storyline (and HOO BOY IS IT A BIG ONE), lots of potential Sam/Daniel shippyness in this ep
I see solid friendship here but I totally get why someone would see a ship instead
7:05
Oh, so now you’re okay with sending additional backup to defend against one little girl but a few guys to protect an entire planet and probably a million dollar’s worth of equipment after you’ve broadcast your location to your deadliest enemy is fine
Got it
(Man. I am genuinely surprised by my reaction to this ep. Oof.)
7:10
I am begrudgingly acknowledging that this is a good shot of SG-1
I want it on the record that I am lodging this note on their attractiveness under protest
7:11
Heh “What about the abandoned nuclear facility at—“
“Right!”
I suspect that bit of dialogue was inspired by military PA’s standard response to questions about nuclear weapons facilities: “I can neither confirm nor deny the presence of nuclear weapons at ____________.”
@sharim28, 7:13
Hahaha yes convenient cut off
Very smooth
@geneeste, 7:14
So smooth
Sam holding Cassie while she sleeps in the back of the truck is legit heartbreaking stahp
I don’t want to feel things while I’m mad at you, show
7:16
Aahhhh Sam already knows she won’t be coming back up when Jack offers to take Cassie
You can see it in her face
That is some great acting by AT and MY HEART
And I swear Jack has an inkling too
It’s why he’s so insistent about the time
7:17
And that eye contact between her and Jack as the elevator doors close
GAH
Stupid show.
7:18
“Please, go back to sleep.”
STOP IT I MEAN IT
7:19
This really is difficult to watch
Poor Sam. Poor Cassie. Poor everybody.
7:21
Ahhhh Sam
DON’T CRY SAM
7:22
That Jack switches from Captain Carter to Sam is just chefskiss.gif
7:23
So I love both the fact that Jack is desperately ordering Sam to come back up AND that Sam is desperately ignoring him
Also perfection
7:24
(Don’t think I’ve forgotten the shitty thing you did show I HAVE NOT FORGOTTEN I’M JUST TAKING A BREAK)
Jack’s not leaving MY HEART
7:25
And also I love SG1 but of course Jack wouldn’t leave
Cassie’s “I love you” really does feel earned here and that’s hard to do in such a short amount of time
A testament to AT’s acting chops because I’m not feeling particularly charitable toward the writing right now
7:26
More great camerawork on Daniel and Teal’c
I wonder who directed this ep
7:30
Mario Azzopardi — he hasn’t done much I recognize now. Peter Woeste on cinematography. Good work sirs.
More good camera work on the guys
7:31
“We could have been wrong about the time.”
“We could have been wrong about what would happen.”
I love the drama but I’m mad about it
7:32
He switched to Sam again!
I can’t wait to listen to this podcast ep of Chevrons Locked
7:34 PM
Yes Daniel’s celebratory slap at Teal’c HA I love it
7:35
Why are we insisting on putting Sam in mom clothes
Although I’m loving Teal’c's fashion
7:36
“A mother’s instinct, perhaps.”
“Subtle, but no.”
That is such a great little moment between Teal’c and Sam
7:38
Jack not so subtlety ushering the dog and the guys away
7:38
So sweet
Big old softy
Pretty sure that dog is walking Jack, but whatever
7:40
Sweet ending
7:41
I will never look at this episode or the whole storyline leading up to Cassie’s appearance the same way again, though
Phew. That was an unexpected ride
7:42
Um. I just looked it up. Katie Stuart (Cassie) is a year older than me. Wut.
the actress is frozen in my brain at 13 so this is very weird to discover
2 notes
·
View notes