#we should've had P3 actually | Explore Tumblr Posts and Blogs

twentyseven-evil-bunnies · 6 months

Text

I'm a Charles girlie (if it wasn't already obvious from a quick glance at my profile), but Charles being committed to an immovable center as the GQ editors note frankly in this article [ https://www.gq.com/story/charles-leclerc-carlos-sainz-ferrari ], highlights a peculiar flaw in the 1st driver-2nd driver issue. For a team like RedBull, that system seems to work, but for Ferrari, they've dominated more when they've had constant and equal support for both drivers.

All this solemn and outright sacred treatment of Charles would be bound to make feel his teammate disappointed, forcing him to want to prove himself, in a non-symbiotic way. When you play favorites, you'll create rivals who would not want to help out the other until their position is first solidified. Mexico 23, where Ferrari was P1-2 and we ended up with P3 leading with P5 ramming into P1—Max should've been blocked my guy, what were you doing???

Sainz's family's saltiness towards Charles is both weird and understandable. As a parent, you'd want your kid to not be treated as a second choice right. I mean I'm in no way saying that the shady tweet likings are is in any way a healthy way to deal with such concerns, but at the end of the day, Charles, even in his losses is lauded, while Carlos's wins are even dismissed [p.s. Ted Kravitz's Ferrari won with the wrong car].

Then again, Charles has proven himself a considerable contender for the world championship, as seen in 2022, so a rudimentary conclusion would be that such partiality towards Charles is deserved. But in the long term, Ferrari switching back and forth between favouring drivers goes against themselves as well as the drivers.

Here is where RedBull wins out. Yes, they would much rather have Max win to continue his winning streak, but don't be fooled—Max wins FOR RedBull, not for himself, at least that's the idea, it would seem, from RedBull's end. He's just another employee, a star employee maybe, but an employee nonetheless. They have to have the P1-2 finishes always, because that'd mean more collective points, thus a bigger earning for the company. Naturally, Checo might have to always help Max (sometimes with no return), but he'll never be "sacrificed." ["I think they're going to sacrifice Leclerc. "— George Russell, most probably Singapore 23] Because guess what RedBull actually wants both of their drivers to do good!

#charles leclerc #carlos sainz #reread this article and it made me feel really bad for carlos #carlos is not the problem ferrari is #rant post #don't mind too much about this #just random stuff actually

17 notes · View notes

caitie-likes-talking · 11 months

Text

Part 4 Critique: Everything I'd Change

I love DIU..however, I consider it one of the post flawed of the JJBA Parts. Honestly, I feel like Araki didn't fully know where he was going with it til halfway, which is why the plot can be so janky. No matter what, let's dive into it. First, characters.

(also quick disclaimer: this is all my opinion and i am biased for MANY things.)

if u diagree w me dont tell me i think it would crush me

Characters [Josuke, Jotaro, Okuyasu, Kira]

Josuke Higashikata

I LOVE Josuke. I think he's a lovely character concept and his design is really cool. My main problem with him is literally his LACK of screen time!! He is the Jojo of this part, yet his spotlight is constantly stolen by other side characters like Koichi, Rohan, and even Jotaro. This also happened a lot in Part 3, with it basically being the Polnareff show (idk why Araki did this sm in pts3-5...either let the mc have screen time or don't have them be the mc!!)

I think Josuke had some of the most missed opportunities in DIU. Especially with his relationships with other characters. I think this part could've been way more interesting if it chose a solid theme, and one that I think would've made sense is commentating on death & tragedy and how that can impact personal relationships. The reason I believe this is because there's already easy set ups for this in the story. Ryohei's death, The Nijimura Brother's family, Reimi, Shigechi, and Jotaro all have that theme in place, but not enough connecting points or real arcs related to this. What was the point of killing off Ryohei (who was the only father figure Josuke had growing up) if you're not going to show how this impacted Josuke, Tomoko, and how he acts with others besides one single page? Sure, it taught him that his powers have limits and that he can't save everyone, but that was a stupid thing to teach him because Okuyasu doesn't fucking die when he should've!! Like why did we make an arc saying 'hey stands aren't magic they can't bring ppl back to life' just for EXACTLY THAT to happen??

Moving on, I also have problems with his stand. I LOVE Crazy Diamond, I think it has a super cool design and power concept, but personally I wish it's powers were more grounded and had clear limits. I feel like a lot of stands suffer from this treatment of vague power limits (ex: Golden Wind..) but my problem with CD is that there were MANY opportunities to add one! For example: we know Josuke couldn't bring back Ryohei even after using his stand on him. So that bears the question: what can CD not fix? What is the real reason it can't bring a dead person back to life? Jotaro says "No stand has the power to bring back the dead" WHY?? am i missing something? Have I forgotten when it was officially established that stands cant do that? I mean, literally in part 3 there was a stand that could reanimate corpses. So does it have to do with the soul? No matter what, I would've used this moment to establish that CD can't bring back ANY living thing. I actually wrote a short fic abt this and included the fact that he also couldn't "fix" a dead leaf. I feel like overall his stand needed more grounding.

Also, I have beef with Josuke's backstory, but I'll get into that later.

Jotaro Kujo

Ok firstly, I have MAJOR beef with his design in part 4. Mainly the fact that he's drawn extremely pale in the anime. Like..obviously he COULD be pale as he is wasian (im not trying to say all wasian ppl look the same), but he is TAN in part 3. Why did they take that away?? Pisses me off to the extreme. At least they fixed it in p5+6. Anyways..

Character wise, I really enjoy Jotaro's personality in p4. I like how he's mellowed out in comparison to p3. However, I feel like he needed a more clear role in the story. He showed up to figure out grandpappy's shit, and then took the leader role when facing Kira. Why don't I like this? Because most of the time Jotaro was just..there. I think Araki wanted him and Josuke to have a mentor/student relationship (ex: rat episode) but just didn't focus enough on them or Josuke training with his stand for this to work.

Also, the fact that it took Jotaro so fucking long to figure out who Kira is WITH the help of all those other stand users is so goofy. Like him and the gang back in '89 found Dio's ass from a goddamn microscopic fly in a photo but couldn't find Kira's identity?? Like ugh he almost redeemed himself with the button thing but then he got blown up like gosh what happened king

When it comes to stands, I forever find it stupid that Jotaro didn't work with his stand to become more powerful. Araki just had to nerf him (which is something he does with most reoccurring characters, ex: Joseph). I don't like it and it pisses me off.

With the death of Ryohei, I feel like it would've made more sense for Jotaro to somewhat open up to Josuke and be a bit more sympathetic towards him about it (or maybe he stays closed off until Josuke explodes, causing Jotaro to reveal the truth about his past.) Either way, I think the two of them could've bonded over shared grief.

Okuyasu Nijimura

I absolutely ADORE Okuyasu. I think his dynamic with Josuke is really fun to watch and his personality is just overall super enjoyable.

Stand wise I do think Araki slightly nerfed him by making him dumb as fucking rocks, but I let this slide a little more just bc he's a side character..

I honestly think Okuyasu has the best character arc out of the whole part 4 cast. I think he definitely deserved more screen time, but what we got was really solid in my opinion. His relationship with his brother was well developed and it was really interesting to see how it still affected him even after his brother's death. The way he felt a need to get revenge for his brother and still felt like he wasn't enough really hit me in the gut. I love him.

When it comes to Okuyasu's "death" I have very mixed opinions. On the one hand, ofc the goat of part 4 survived. On the other hand, I feel like him surviving goes directly against the idea we've been given since the beginning. You can't save everyone. And on the one hand, I enjoy the subverting of expectations. On the other hand, I don't like how it's still just never fully explained. I guess in JJBA as long as your soul doesn't feel like dying yet, you won't. I wish we saw Okuyasu actually speaking to his brother when he "died" however. I find him and Keicho's relationship really gut-punching and that would've been a fire scene imo.

I have more to say on him, his dad, Keicho, and the arrow, but I'll save that for when I'm talking about the plot.

Yoshikage Kira

I find Kira to be a really interesting villain. I really enjoyed every moment we got going deeper into his psychology and it's something I really wish we got to see more of. I enjoy his sleek design and he's fine asf tbh.

Im not gonna give commentary on his stand rn bc honestly i dont fully remember how that shit worked by the time he was using the arrow

Character wise I just really wish he was established as the main villain sooner. The build up and hints dropped about him were so addictive, so it's disappointing that they're only there a little before his full introduction.

The psychology of Kira is something I really liked. The way he truly believes he's never really done anything wrong and only wanting to live a peaceful life is something I wish was even more looked into. Also, correct me if I'm wrong, but from my memory, in the manga Kira's whole thing with his nails growing quicker when stressed/when his need to kill is getting too strong was only psychological. At least, I don't remember them growing the same way it's shown in the anime. I think this would've been something really interesting to deep dive into. The fact that he believes his nails grow when his need to kill is really high is really intriguing and the overall connection between hands and his killings are something I wanted to be fully developed more. I know it was kind of just a weird ass fetish but like..that's interesting!! this is interesting!!

I'll probably make an individual post to talk more abt him.

Plot

Where do I even begin. The plot of part 4 is all over the place. I loved many episodes, and I enjoyed when it leaned more into the slice of life style, but why the fuck where there like 3 seperate plots? Honestly, cut out Anjuro. His whole plot shit was annoying as hell. Didn't care for him.

Akira's entire plot pissed me off. I only like this arc because of Okuyasu. Overall I found there to be a lot of plot holes and just annoying parts. Everything til Kira was like this for me. Like get to the REAL plot please.

The arrow annoyed me. I've never wanted to rip my hair out more than when Kira's dad got a hold of it. He was SO GODDAMN ANNOYING. I like the concept of Kira using the arrow to get allies or ways to cover up his plot, but most of the stand users that came out of this were annoying and Kira's dad was insufferable in the worst way possible.

I think something I wish was more covered by the plot is the aftermath of Part 3 and Dio in general. This is something that CDDH (best jojo spinoff) covers really nicely, however. Go read it.

I also just in general think more should've been done w Okuyasu's dad, as he is a direct aftermath of Dio.

I feel like a lot of the women in Part 4 were set up to have strong, actually plot-influencing roles, but then were totally side-lined. I'm going to make a full post abt this tho.

Reimi being connected to Rohan never made sense to me. Just narratively speaking, why did you connect the main motivation for catching Kira to a side antagonist instead of the main character? This is slightly fueled by my hate for Rohan but like, c'mon! I think it would've made more sense to 1. just not include Rohan so fucking much and 2. connect Reimi to Josuke's past.

Speaking of Josuke's past, I feel like it just..needed more. Or at least, I think something needed to be done with the boy who saved him. I can appreciate the idea of it connecting to a theme of the general kindness of strangers, but you don't see that theme pop up as much in the rest of the plot. Also, I again would've connected Reimi to Josuke because WHY ISN’T SHE CONNECTED TO THE MAIN CHARACTER OH MY GOD

Overall tho I like the vibes of part 4, i really enjoyed different arcs and characters, and I just wish Araki got more time to flesh everything out and refocus on certain themes and characters.

#jjba #jojos bizarre adventure #diu #diamond is unbreakable #jjba part 4 #josuke higashitaka #jotaro kujo #okuyasu nijimura #yoshikage kira #plot review #critique #just my opinions #i love part 4 i swear #josuke is my fave jojo #review #commentary #manga #manga analysis

29 notes · View notes

leqclerc · 1 year

Note

I was really optimistic yesterday with Charles quali and strategy. Like we knew race pace was an issue but there was confidence in getting P3.

Then as you said when they changed components … only for that DNF. And with his luck it was Charles car and not Carlos (not to hate Carlos but the performance was not there today, it’s always the guy in front who DNF with Ferrari it’s amazing actually)

What makes me pessimistic right now (besides Charles sad face tonight) is really what you said about Ferrari history and Mercedes history. Last year Mercedes challenged for P2 with THAT car because they are consistent and have no reliability issue with their engine, and they improved. Now AM have the car (thanks to RB engineers but kudos to them for hiring them) and a reliable Mercedes engine. In the meantime we have Ferrari sacrificing years after years because « next year is our year » only to arrive having made a step forward two step backward.

And the worst is they did not expect those issues : reliability was supposed to be fixed, even Mattia had to go out and say it was his car because he was so sure of his PU. The aero was supposed to be better too. Yet that car still eats tyres. So it a rocket on flying laps. Great if there was points for quali ! It seems like the same mistakes again and again. It’s starting to feel like they really don’t have the right tools at all, engineers wise.

RB were so superior for the second part of the 22 season and right now too. Everything clicked : engine, car, driver, strategy/pit wall, development (I know cost cap …) You can’t afford to make mistakes with the car when there is that kind of dominance. We are so much on the back foot pace wise. I only hope it’s really Barhain specific. And I know RB came back in 22 but performance was more equal with Ferrari, Ferrari had reliability and strategy issues and then TD39 so it was possible for them to come back. Circumstances are everything. Right now it’s even sadder for how it went for Charles in 22, he couldn’t have won against that RB in the end but the misses opportunities in Monaco, Silverstone… it will hurt so much more if he can’t fight properly this year.

I would have been so so happy with P3 it’s crazy.

To see Aston Martin get past Carlos that easily when they were P7 last year …

I truly hope Charles does not renew his contract too soon. We talk about Lando Norris being stuck at McLaren but come on when you want to be world champion clearly Ferrari is also not the place to be at the moment and hasn’t been for 16 years.

Hello! 🫱🏻‍🫲🏻I agree with you 😭

Yeah, Carlos really didn't impress in terms of race pace (in general but also relative to his teammate) or tyre deg today, and it's becoming more and more noticeable.

This is why the 2022 season was so hard for me to I guess let go of, personally. Why I was so frustrated with Binotto who seemed all too happy to throw in the towel after about five or six races already, and the self-inflicted mistakes from the pit wall. That was their best shot, the best chance they've had in years. They brought a quick car that played into Charles's strengths and, at least initially, seemed to do everything right to maximise their points haul. Technical failures aside (I will give some leeway there because reliability is notoriously difficult to nail in the first year of a new regulation cycle - the 2014 Mercs were fast as hell but suffered from PU failures, overheating, etc.) they just made way too many avoidable mistakes in races that should've been wins or podiums at the very least (Monaco, Silverstone, Hungary being the big three). Then we were fed the justification that, actually, they knew they couldn't win that year and they were just focusing on being competitive and that apparently Binotto switched the focus to building and developing the 2023 car relatively early on in the year. And now his engineering legacy is... this. 🙃

Tyre deg issues have been plaguing Ferrari for literal years now and while I believe they can maybe mitigate it a bit with those wing upgrades they've mentioned, I'm starting to feel like they really can't make a car that doesn't have a tendency to eat tyres 🙃 It just sucks that they always seem to have to compromise something, while Red Bull seem to be able to create a package that's virtually close to perfection in terms of marrying balance, speed, tyre deg, etc.

I think Red Bull will be competitive at basically every track tbh precisely because they've found that sweet spot with the car. They were already strong at pretty much every track, regardless of characteristics, last year, and this car improves on what they already got right in 2022. If anything, I could maybe believe that Aston's performance will be more track dependent. I'm already hearing they're excelling in medium and slow speed corners so like. Alonso Monaco win incoming 🙃

I think the possibility of contract extension talks is the furthest thing from his mind right now tbh. The Daniel/Oscar ditching-and-poaching saga last year proved that contracts aren't necessarily airtight 100% of the time if both parties want it badly enough. Pierre had also recently confirmed an extension with Alpha Tauri and then joined Alpine the same year. Alonso dragged out putting pen to paper with Alpine long enough to enter talks with Lawrence and sign, all while managing to keep it under wraps from his team boss AND the media. He was confirmed the same weekend Seb announced his retirement. That's insane.

#replies #anonymous #discussions and predictions #long post

2 notes · View notes

crime-bot · 14 days

Note

okay so i definitely recommend you search what ken looks like because he looks like goro (& shido) a lot (i've always thought shido had browner-yellowy eyes and ken has brown eyes, shido's goatee? is spiky and so is ken's hair (& we can assume shido had spiky hair), its just a lot of that. ken looking more like their father and goro looking like their mom is also so real.. theyre identical twins regardless cause the differences seem tiny when theyre next to eachother (theres actually a fic called the sword & the scale and it goes into them being half-siblings its whatnstarted my ideas and its so good. the latest chapter has them talking to the PTs and everyone unable to tell them apart because they keep doing everything the same) ANYWAY. ken lore time.

ok, basically in p3 .. do you remember that dude with the rogue persona i told you about whos NOT a villain? that's shinjiro aragaki. hes really important to ken lore. ok so basically his persona's rogue: 2 years before p3 takes place (takes place 2009-2010,) on october 4th, 2007, shinjiro's persona went rogue and killed ken's mom (& made their whole building collapse.) shinjiro felt bad and quit the SEES and went back to living on the streets (he was previously at an orphanage before the SEES but that was burnt down) and shinjiro keeps taking the persona suppressors (which are killing him. he starts wearing a beanie and heavy jacket bc hes cold all the time bc he cant regulate his temp anymore.) fast forward to 2009, where ken gets a persona called nemesis (greek goddess of revenge) and learns how to use .. i forgot what its called but its kinda like a pole? ykwim. anyway. he plans to kill shinjiro (bc he doesnt know it was an accident) for killing his mom and almost does it on october 4th 2009 when takaya (also rogue persona haver. villain. extremely gay for shinjiro & his fellow villain jin tbh. takaya makes me sad anyways) shows up and goes to kill ken, but shinjiro blocks it and gets shot and dies instead. sound familiar to one persona 5 boy? ken never kills again ( hes literally 11 in 2009 btw. goro turned 16 in 2014 when he killed wakaba. these kids were YOUNG. goro started working with shido when he was 15, since in nov he says its been almost 2 & a half years of working w eachother) and instead basically gets adopted by the kirijo group? idk its never explained but in p3 the kirijo group stages ken's mom death as a car accident (bc it originally happened in the dark hour) and the main makoto-ish girl is mitsuru kirijo (who is an icon and hates the group so we love her) but anyway we never really get an explanation with who ken is staying with, he just stays with the SEES? so im saying the kirijo adopted him.

anyway.. them as kids together would be ... very odd. hectic if they were deaged to after their mom died (& in the au goro sees she killed herself but then a few mins after the house gets fucking destroyed by castor/shinjiro's persona so ken never knows she killed herself. boy who doesnt know any jp/doesnt speak having to help his little brother who knows jp/speaks drag their mom & themselves out of the rubble of the house immediately after seeing his mom hang. doesnt say anything to his brother abt it 💔💔)

Ayy I survive! Thanks for the patience man

The wildest part is that I've Seen Ken before, multiple times, and I never really made these connections. I could definitely see them as twins, and oh man I wanna check out that fic later!

God that's wild, to be fair I've known of bits and pieces about Ken and his backstory, but nothing in great detail, so it's wild to see the bigger picture (and some more about Shinjoro! This poor guy!). A hot temper and steady will really seems to run in the family.

Dude that would be so wild!!!! I'd love to see the shit they'd get up to, as well as witness the kind of emotional processing they should've been allowed to have, with the support of the PTs and Akria's confidants. When it comes to traumatic experiences, it is crucial that there are multiple people of different kinds that the person is able to turn to after the fact to talk to and have support from

0 notes

sillyfudgemonkeys · 2 years

Note

apparently persona 3 is rumorred to be getting a remake... https://twitter.com/IdleSloth84_/status/1572869029823676417

KFLDJSF;KJ;FK And here I thought hope was dead.

I can see them announcing it officially a year or two from now (as they....probably should....as not to conflict with their ports).

If they announce it sooner....well...I told them to pull a FF7 guess they decided to finally do it. Not timed the best but whatever. These ports should've been a thing, for the PS4, sometime after P5's first release in Japan. THEN they could've slowly worked on getting them ported on other devices.

Then by now, we would've had the ports out for awhile, and announcing a remake wouldn't be so weird.

P1/2/3(P) are the Persona games I think really need remakes, but I'll take remakes of all the games I'm not picky. uwu Esp since I think they can still add new content to P3/4 (actually finally did a post for P3 additions I'd like to see here), and P1/2 (mobile games stuff) and just a nice change in graphics and gameplay would be cool.

As long as the only similarity to P3's remake to P5 is "New 3D environments" (aka stuff like P3D and improved on that) and QOL stuff (aka, making it easier to get free time and max SLs, and thus give us more time to do other stuff, either optional events or otherwise).

My only issues (as long as P5's finger prints aren't all over P3 that is), is if this gets announced before we even get a PORT of P1/2.

#silly asks #silly answers

1 note · View note

rachel-bloom · 5 years

Text

#anti charmed reboot #what 5 episodes and already under 1m? we stan a failing #attempt to make money off someone elses success #not gonna lie i would have #actually continued watching it and enjoying it if they wouldn't try so hard to recreate the goofy chemistry p3/p3 2.0 had #also the cast is lowkey rude as hell and the show should've had a different title just saying #also the show is campy as hell....they do a lot of talking but not actually show anything so..........

8 notes · View notes

sillyfudgemonkeys · 2 years

Note

Iirc pq2 and the dancing games were being developed the same time as p5, so I dunno if it's a case that they weren't thinking, more likely they didn't care lol (might've been due to p5 being delayed so much or something)

I can tell they aren't thinking, they still aren't. 8U If it's them not caring.......that's annoying then. If you aren't gonna care then leave imo. Or, they do care and are thinking, but aren't as good as Hashino or Tadashi when it comes to coming up with ideas (*cough*except Kido*cough*)

Kinda, for P3/5D at least. As you can see here, it was at the tail end of, P5's development. And PQ2 right when they finished P5.

It's just....so odd. Why not have more people start working on new entries earlier than that? Was it really all hands on deck? I mean it's not like they can't juggle entries, we literally saw them do it before!

I know they said they had everyone focusing on P5 releasing but.....it really feels like poor planning. I mean they even stated they had to rush PQ2 because of the Switch! And yeah I can see the rush, you really screwed up your lore-*inhales* Breathe Silly.....breathe. *exhales*

Tbh PQ2 probably should've been in development not long after PQ1. At least had it on the back burner, slowly simmering and being worked on. And then by the time P5 came out, we'd have a game line up for at least 2017. It's not Atlus' fault for the Switch release (actually maybe it is, I'm sure nintendo must've told developers about it much sooner than the general public.....IF that's the case...and IF it is then that's even.....there was a lot of stupid going on at Atlus with the planning then).

If they did know about the Switch AND/OR were planning for some sequel earlier on, then this would've been the best timeline:

2014: After the release of PQ1, Atlus starts on PQ2 with the rough scenario we already have in progress (aka they iron out the wrinkles compared to what we got)

Late 2015/early 2016: they work on doing the PS classic on PS4 and porting the PS2 vers of P3/P4 (at least, maybe PS1 vers of P1/2 too) and maybe begin the planning of P5S (rather than pussy footing around since they had been doing talks, assuming it was just Atlus being like "oh maybe we'll do it" instead of "oh we have to wait till this time to start doing it cause of KT/legal reasons"...if it's the latter then nothing we can do....except maybe have a separate P5 spinoff/sequel in the works)

Mid 2016: P5 releases, P3/5 crossover game begins development (this is not the same game we got, instead it's a legit crossover where there's dance battles and plot+more character interactions).

Late 2016: P3/4 are dropped on PS4 classics, PQ2 announced for late-early/mid 2017

Tail end Early/Mid 2017: PQ2 drops. P5S (if talks began) announcement is dropped, if not a separate spinoff/sequel game is announced, if not that then P3/5D crossover game is announced.

That's roughly how I'd (in this scenario with this info, I know I've restructured this 1000 times but c'mon) structure it for maximum usage outta all the entries.

If we have to shift all the games (including P5) like 3 months later that's fine, at least that means all the titles will be released in a better timely manner. P5 fans get to familiarize themselves with P3/4 in time for some crossover games, and maybe even a spinoff/sequel.

That being said, it could be some of the new blood too, atm I'mma just blame them hiring Yuta Aihara and Hirokazu Tohyama. so far they've only worked on titles I don't like so I'mma blame them for what happened to PQ2 >8U

P3/5D has a lot of vets iirc, so I'mma blame them being just money hungry 8U

#for the tcg anon i'mma wait for the reveal #cause atm that answer is very.....short #silly asks #silly answers #short answer for the tcg thing is: yeah it looks cool I'm interested but I don't have a lot of knowledge on tcg stuff tbh #of course those people came up cause of imdb and that stuff isn't 100% accurate #they migh've worked on other things #imdb doesn't exactly have the correct info for p3p and kido

2 notes · View notes

sillyfudgemonkeys · 3 years

Note

I think Makoto's Brand New Days should have Aigis dancing it.

Soul Phrase should've been a dual dance between Makoto and Kotone

Darkness (Erebus fight theme) should've been a Ryoji/Metis DLC

Yup yup! I agree totally with all of that. Darkness def would be a Metis DLC with Ryoji as one of the partners. I’d love to see them react to each other DX Same with Sho vs Minato/Hamu

Tbh, while I think P3 has more danceable songs in general than P5, and the dancers and dances are a bit better.....I think Atlus still could've been better with the song selection (really they should've had A LOT more songs). Here’s a list of at least 3 songs (tho I think 4 or 5 would work, esp since we could get more remixes). Hamu should’ve def been a main dancer (screw it let’s pretend Metis/Ryo were also main dancers too!)

Some songs will change, some will stay the same (Yukari, Junpei, and Fuuka I think mostly stay the same with some additions).

Makoto: Mass Destruction, Moon Reaches Stars (I always shorten this name sorry), More than one heart

Hamuko (I'll accept Kotone when we get her in an actual Atlus game, it doesn't feel right to cherry pick her stage play name just cause Atlus was too lazy to do a separate adaptation, esp since it means ignoring the male's name): Wiping All Out, Way of Life (OG or Remix), Place of my Heart

Makoto/Hamuko special duo dances: Soul Phase, Burn my dread last battle, Never ending night (the Pachinko song), Place of My Heart Duo ver/Remix, Our Moment

Aigis: Brand New Days (reg or remix), Heartfelt cry ATLUS Konishi Remix, some techno remix (she’s a robot for christ sakes, I don’t care steal from Junpei’s list if we have to, Maybe a Techno remix of Fate In our Hands).

Yukari: When the Moon Reaches for the Stars P3D Remix, Want to be close P3D remix, Changing Seasons Reincarnation (except an updated ver?)

Junpei: His two songs are ok (even if I think Aigis should have the more techno songs), 3rd song should be Want to Be Close reincarnation, Dorm Song remix

Mitsuru: Snow Queen (OG or Remix, not necessarily the DLC one Atlus gave us but just a remix), Living With Determination Reincarnation, Enduring bonds/Tranquility mashup-remix (just a lighter and more elegant song)

Fuuka: Deep Breath Deep Breath Reincarnation, Time ATLUS Kitajoh Remix, Tender Moment Jazzy Remix

Ken: Wiping All Out Ryota Koduka Remix (or a diff Remix), Light the Fire Up in the Night P3D Remix,

Akihiko: Unavoidable Battle Reincarnation ver, Danger Zone Remix, Light that fire P3D remix (I dunno have him more leaning towards battle songs)

Shinjiro: Wiping All out/Mass destruction mashup, Danger Zone/Master of Tartarus mashup, “One Hand, One heartbeat” remix (I think having him deal with mash ups of the two MC’s battle songs symbolizes his POSSIBLY different fates, with a more mellow song from the movie he’s featured in)

Metis: Battle Hymn of the Soul Remix/Heartfelt Cry Remix/Brand New Days Remix, Darkness, P3 FES extended (I need an extended ver in my life DX)

Ryoji: Battle Hymn of the Soul, Snow Queen Remix (OG or diff remix), Burn My Dread Last Battle, Falling Down

Why give the girls Tender Moment even tho it only appears on FeMC side? Just cause I think those two would fit well with a pop and jazzy remix of it. I can see them dancing to it over the boys (tho.....my memory wants to tell me Tender moment may appear with the girls too but my brain fuzzy and tired)

That’s not even me going into Arena/Ultimax or PQ2 music (or looking more into PQ1 music too), and probably barely scraping the surface for the movies tbh. They should’ve had 80-90% of the Reincarnation OST in P3D, those songs are def danceable u_u P3 has a lot of entries and a big library (as big as P4′s) and they could def remix to their hearts content.

Edit: not me forgetting to give Ken a 3rd song I’ll do it tomorrow DX

#silly asks #silly answers #i'd do one for P5D #but that would mean I'd have to listen to P5 songs #i'd rather blow out my ear drums #jk #half jk #P5D's ending song and P5S' dungeon songs are good #PQ2's lobby theme is good too #i've run out of good songs to praise P5 with #oh I guess Royal only songs were good too #I've now run outta things to praise p5 with skldjfla;dfj #actually I wonder how well these would fit..... 030 #excuse me I'mma actually mess with my video play for a bit #did I just call P3MC both minato and makoto in the same post? yes yes I did #i don't care anymore

2 notes · View notes