#plus I don't think anyone here watches Grey's Anatomy | Explore Tumblr Posts and Blogs

warmaidensrevenge · 2 years

Text

Decision, decision

Eddie Munson x Plus size reader

If you want to read my other work you can find it HERE

Ok I lied there will be a part 3. Cuz I don't have time to finish this today. And I really wanted to get some opinions on how I should end this. Seems kinda obvious how it should end but I'm seriously on the fence. So feel free to suggest something.

Part 1, Part 3

Part 2

Warning: angst, cursing

Not proof read and no word count

Just an fyi I used a bit of the scene in Grey's Anatomy where Meredith asked Derek to choose her and a scene in one tree hill.

😮‍💨❄️✉️✉️

So Friday night was the plan. Samantha was still sick so Eddie thought you two could be alone and finally catch up on what you did for the summer. So after his campaign he went to the video store to pick out something. He placed a copy of Teenwolf on the counter grabbing a bag of popcorn and a pack of red vines.

" Hot date?" Steve asked while ringing him up.

" nah just hanging out with a friend." Eddie reached his hand to rub the back of his neck. That's right she's just a friend.

" so how's y/n" Robin said coming from the back room

" she's umm good I think." Eddie replied.

" what do you mean you think? Weren't you guys like a thing?" Steve said eyeing Eddie

" Uh what do you mean?" Eddie was confused.

" what aren't you guys like together?" Robin asked. " I thought you guys have been together."

Eddie let out a nervous chuckle. " Uhh no. Nope she's just my friend."

" I'm confused" Robin said looking at Steve.

" ooooohhhh I was wondering why she was hanging out with that hoodlum." Steve said putting Eddie's things in a bag. " Well I guess she has a type after all." Steve smirked.

" oh come on Robin. You can't be that clueless."

Eddie stood there awkwardly watching the two friends converse.

" you see the way y/n looks at Eddie. Or at least use to look at Eddie. Vance is like a weird shorter, thicker blonde headed version of him."

Robin gave Eddie a once over. " huh yeah I can kinda see it."

Eddie was so confused. What the hell are they talking about?

" Munson man you fucked up." Steve scoffed

It was then he realized what the two idiots were getting at. You liked him. And since he was with someone else you went for the best thing you could find. A more aggressive but mini him. Shit what has he done?

" you ok there Munson?" Robins question brought Eddie back to the present.

"uh yeah I uh got to go." Eddie said as he grabbed the bag and left.

Robin and Steve stood there watching him leave then looked at each other and grinned. They knew exactly what they just did. For some reason they liked to meddle in others affairs. And since seeing Eddie with Samantha they knew they had to intervene.

...

Eddie couldn't get his thoughts together while driving home. You liked him? For how long? Why didn't you say anything? Why didn't he say anything? Why didn't he noticed it? He thought you just acted like that because he was your best friend. But now all the sleep overs and getting dressed in front of him, and leaning up against him when you guys would just sit in his room talking meant more to you than he thought. Fuck and you were coming over. He had no idea how to approach this newly found information.

He was sitting in his living room constantly getting up to pace then returning to sit back down, only to repeat the pattern all over again. Shit what was he gonna do? Fuck what about Samantha?

"Hey bud-" you started to say before Eddie pulled you in for a hug.

Eddie heard soft tapping at his front door. He froze. He had no idea what he was gonna do or what he was gonna say.

He went for the door and took a deep breath. He swung it open and you were there all smiles.

Eddie held you so tight. He waited so long for this moment, he just had to hold you. And when you hugged him back he held on tighter. He sniffed your hair in the process. God you smelled so good. He missed you so damn much. So did you by the way you held onto him. After a lengthy amount of time, that if anyone would have seen they would have thought you were more than just friends too, you guys finally pulled apart. But you weren't done with him. You pulled him back in for one more squeeze. This made Eddie's heart fill with joy. You loved him didn't you? You needed his arms to wrap around you. He needed it too.

Finally letting go you pushed by him to get into his trailer. Eddie felt cold when you left him. He wanted to pull you back but the thought of Samantha came. He had to break up with her. He needed to do it now. But he didn't want to leave you. You just got there. Besides how would he know if you truly wanted to be with him. So he waited. He was still determined to break up with Samantha regardless. He closed the door and turned to watch you take off your sweater and shoes. You were wearing your pajamas. Where you planning on staying the night like you use to? How did Vance feel about you doing that?

" So what's on the agenda bud?"

Bud?

Eddie cleared his throat. "Uhh teen wolf"

You smiled at Eddie choice. " Sounds good"

Eddie nervously laughed and grabbed the bag holding the things he picked up. Tossing you the red vines.

" Aww you remembered?"

Of course he remembered. He remembered everything about you.

He went to heat up the bag of popcorn as he watched you get up and slide in the vhs. How was he gonna do this? He pulled out the bag burning himself in the process. But you didn't notice. He poured it into a bowl and stood in the hallway looked towards his bedroom. Thinking about the letters he started to write for you but never sent. He wrote one every day that you were gone. Explain how much you meant to him. Writing how he and Samantha started to see each other. But how he wished it was you. But he stuffed them into a shoe box and wrote something else to send.

"Hey you're missing important plot points" you said while looking at the movie, bring a red vine to your lips.

Eddie looked at the screen and smiled. It was just the opening credits. He made his way to the couch sitting at the opposite end from you. That's when you did what you always did when it was just you two hanging out. You leaned your back against him propping your feet up on the couch. Pulling his arm around your shoulder.

" Missed you Eddie"

" Missed you too." He said just above a whisper.

For the whole movie he watched you while you watched it. Trying to find the right thing to say. And when the movie ended you yawned.

"Sleepy?" He asked

" mmm just a bit. Is it cool if I stayed the night?"

" uh yeah yeah sure"

You looked up at him. " Samantha won't be mad?"

" Why would she?"

" I don't know. Sharing your bed with another girl might not make her too happy."

" No I don't think she will. What about uh Vance?"

You shrugged. " He knows your my best friend. Even if he does mind then I'm gonna have to break up with him."

You would do that? For him? Ok this was happening.

Eddie watched you get up and turn off the TV and headed to his room. He cleaned up and followed you. You were already snuggled up in his blanket facing the wall. Eddie hesitate before changing into his pajamas. Which consisted of just a pair of sweat pants. He climbed in and got under the blankets back against the mattress looking up at the ceiling. He laid there for what felt like forever when you reached behind looking for his arm. Finally finding it you pulled him to spoon you.

His heart was racing and his breathing hitched. The sent of your shampoo filled his nostrils, making butterflies flutter in his stomach. Did you know that the actions you were doing had such an effect on him?

" Hey uhh y/n are you asleep?"

" not yet"

" umm I need to tell you something"

You turn to face him. Eyes droopy from tiredness. " What's up?" You whispered

" I uh was talking to Steve and Robin today...about you and uh Vance."

" uh huh"

" They said something about how he kinda looks like me"

You adjusted yourself a bit before answering. " huh yeah he kinda does"

You closed your eyes as Eddie continued

" they said that that's the reason why you are with him.... Because he looks like me."

" Umm ok?"

" Is that true? Are you seeing him because he reminds you of me?"

You laid on your back and rubbed your eyes to try and wake up a bit more. This was a conversation you hadn't planned on having.

" I uhh I don't know. Maybe"

" Maybe?"

You sighed. " Yeah maybe. Since you're with Samantha, I kinda just thought maybe it was time to move on. You know....get over you."

Over me? You were over me? Please please don't say that. He thought.

Silence fell. Only the dripping of the bathroom sink was all you could hear.

" ummm I-i don't want that."

" Don't want what Eddie?"

He hesitated. " I don't want you to be over me."

Now you were wide awake. You turned your head and were met with his big eyes.

" umm what?"

" I uhh I don't want you to stop liking me."

You were confused. Wasn't he still with Samantha?

" Why?" You asked

Eddie took in a sharp breath. " Because I'm in love with you."

You shot up and shook your head. You got up and went to the living room. With Eddie following.

"y/n?"

You let out a sarcastic laugh. " You have got to be joking?"

" I wasn't."

You put on your shoes and pulled on your jacket.

" Why? Why now?"

" Because y/n I just found out that you feel the same way."

"Felt." You corrected him.

" Felt?" Eddie was hurt.

" Yes Eddie. Felt!"

" Are you saying you don't have feelings for me anymore?"

" Eddie you have a girlfriend and I have Vance. We can't just hurt them like that."

You paused for a moment. Because yes you were still very much in love with him. But you guys were with other people now. What were you guys supposed to do? Break up with them and live happily ever after.

You guessed the moment took a bit longer than you intended because Eddie was now right in front of you.

"y/n I'm sure they would understand why."

" No Eddie. Have you met Vance? He's...he's violent. He will hurt you."

" Just because I don't get into fights doesn't mean I don't know how to. And if I get my ass handed to me then....then it will be worth it. If we can be together."

Eddie reached up to touch your face but you stepped back.

" Don't. Don't make me choose....don't make me choose between you and him....we had our chance and we missed it."

" No don't say that" Eddie took a step closer. "I can't promise you that." Eddie tucked a strand of hair behind your ear.

" Here it is y/n. I love you. I love you so much. It feels like a piece of me is missing when you're not around. The type of love I have for you is the forever kind of thing. It's the kind of love that you throw your fist in the air when you finally get the girl. It's like wanting to hold a radio over my head towards your window. Like riding off into the sunset. Living happily ever after kind of love....I love you... Damnit y/n I love you so much. So please say you love me too. Because I know you do... Please baby. Please choose me. Pick me."

You didn't even know you were crying until Eddie was wiping away your tears.

" I can't." You shook your head. " I just can't."

You moved away from him and went to the door.

" y/n please just wait. Just wait. I have something for you."

You stood there shaking your head. When Eddie came back. He handed you a shoe box.

" in here is everything I ever wanted to say to you....please read them. And then make your decision."

You didn't looked at him. You just took the box and left.

...

@salenorona23 @let-love-bleeds-red

#eddie munson #eddie munson x female original character #eddie munson x you #fanfic #eddie munson x plus size reader #eddie x reader #stranger things #eddie my beloved #eddie x fem!reader #eddie x y/n #eddie x plus size reader #eddie x you

73 notes · View notes