THE NIGHTMARE NEARBY, chapter three
the corinthian x gender neutral!reader
word count: 12K
warnings: mention of death and (slightly?) description of a dead body. description of injuries and blood. angst. a lot of angst, be ready. corinthian will face a long self-doubting spiral, so prepare the tissues. BUT THERE'S SOME FLUFF IN THE END, there will be a time when it'll look like it won't come, but it will, I promise!!!
summary: the journey of a nightmare trying to fly into the warmth of the sun. and, the first wax burn that marked his skin.
A/N: I'm so sorry for taking so long to post this chapter, I was on a hiatus that last month due to my mental health and my studies, but I'm back! It's a very long chapter so I'm not sure if I had proofread everything, soon I'll check this chapter again, so I hope you enjoy it either way.
After this chapter, there will have a time jumping till the next one and I'll reblog a prompts list so you can request drabble ideas for the detective and the Corinthian during this one-month time jump!
And for last but not least, I want to thank @kameronrose, @80-s-cup-of-milk-and-honey and @ondragonhonour for helping me before, during and after my hiatus, helping me through my writing process and being patient with me lol, thank you so much, I meant it!
Now, I hope you enjoy this chapter as much as I do. For sure, it is one of my favorites so far.
| prologue | chapter one | chapter two | fic's masterlist |
chapter three: the corinthian and the fall of icarus
The pearly moon hanging in the center of the dark night reflected perfectly on the blade in Corinthian's hands. Especially now that he was finally done cleaning up the blood in it.
Sighing, as his breath lingered in the cold air, he tucked his blade back into one of his holsters, previously hidden by his blazer. The only thing that never left his hands was his handkerchief, now soaked in the blood of the dead young miss lying in the motel’s bed.
There was no longer a trace of white on the handkerchief, yet without any hurry, Corinthian used it to wipe the blood running from one of his eye sockets. The blood-soaking handkerchief stained his fingertips through the thin fabric but he didn’t give it a mind, doing his best to clean himself and his things from anything that could relate him to the body of the woman who was only a few steps behind him.
Unlike the others that the Nightmare had killed so far in that town, she wasn’t a boy, much less a prostitute. He never intentionally changed his victims during all the time he traveled from city to city — state to state — on a killing spree. However, now, he had to make an exception.
A little thing to stir a certain detective's head. To shake up that game of cat and mouse between you two since you were more committed to this case and its conclusion than he had initially thought.
Even when it was hours since both of you were walking through the town and drinking at that same bar, he could still hear your voice in the back of his head. How engaging you were about the case and looking forward to taking the next step tomorrow at work. Not only that but you were slightly captivated at knowing more about him — the stranger who seemed to feel all the overwhelming storm that gathered in you — and also sharing a little about yourself in return.
Silly things really, nothing that usually would intrigue the Nightmare. However, with you, any of them sounded silly at all, not even foolish. For a moment, while listening to you and saying a thing or two himself, he felt… Nevermind. That wasn’t his point.
The point was that, unfortunately, you mentioned nothing about your visions. You never did, not directly. Neither way, luckily, talking with you was intriguing enough to keep his attention until you both headed home.
He never said he was going home but to finish a job. And that he did.
The Nightmare began to dress, idly looking for his sunglasses until he found them beside the bed. By accident, as if he wanted nothing, his vision collided again with the frame of the person's body stretched out — thrilling the pattern of their own red blood covering every detail of their skin.
However, Corinthian jumped out of himself immediately when his sockets stopped at their face.
They were you. He’d recognize the contours of your face anywhere. Although, what really made him shiver was not meeting your eyes, your pair of myriad colors and emotions.
How they used to blaze every time you were motioning as you spoke. How your eyes sparkled and, suddenly, you felt more alive. You could make anyone around you feel more alive but only when you were comfortable enough to let your walls slowly give in.
When you felt safe enough to let people pry through those walls.
Safe for saying things that typically you wouldn’t be with other people but did with him. Him from all people.
You gave him the password to let him in the door and you should have regretted it.
In the past, the Nightmare laughed when someone stated that ‘eyes were windows to the soul’. There wasn’t such a thing for him. For him, eyes were the window to the truth and nothing more.
Yet, with every second he spent admiring your eyes and how your corners crinkled when your gazes met, he may or may not have learned he was wrong… In a few parts.
The eyes could be the window for the soul and the truth — because, what was a soul if not the truth about the being that carried it within itself? Wasn't a soul the chest of their past, present, and future?
Then, he took them from you.
His stomach turned at the realization, he got your eyes and ate them. At the time, he enjoyed the whole thing but now, knowing to whom they belonged, he felt sick. The Corinthian had never felt sick, he didn’t know how he knew the word or the feeling.
He just knew it felt like a stab in the chest.
Not a single stab but a thousand of them, followed one by the other. Tearing his skin apart from the inside and bringing him back to the night Dream nearly unmade him.
He had never been the one stabbed.
His vision, for the first time in decades, blurred. The blood soaking his hands and his handkerchief were yours, redder than anything he had ever seen. And for the first time, he hated himself for how that same blood had once brought comfort to his fingertips but was now nothing more than a terrible cold burden, pulling his body down and against the squeaky clean motel floor.
The Corinthian jerked his face away from your body and threw the bloody handkerchief as far into that room as possible. So that he would never find him later no matter how hard he tried.
However, when he dared to glance at the same body again, they weren’t you. They had never been you. She was a student he had met while wandering around the town that night, not you.
You had never been the one who was laying peacefully in the motel’s bed, covered in your own blood and missing both of your eyes.
Even if you were, why did it freak him out?
It didn’t make sense, the mere thought of it shouldn’t affect him. There were many reasons for that but he could start with the obvious one: he had met you for a day and a few hours. You were much a stranger to him as he was to you, except for the part where he knew your name (something you couldn’t say the same about him) and that you could or not have a link to the place where he came from.
Besides that, you being that shouldn’t bring that kind of reaction of his.
Pursing his lips in a thin line, the blonde threw himself into a chair near the window, taking his blade back from his holster and searching for a piece of wood inside his blazer. It was one of his many wooden pieces that were almost done, scraping every now or then when…
Well, you know, when he needed to think.
The blonde turned to score the wood, gently blowing away the dust and a few small pieces of wood far away, something he should clean before leaving the room.
A different thought crossed his mind at each scratch he made on the wooden piece. But the same question always made him stop what he was doing before resuming it again.
What the hell were you? Because it had to be you, right? The thing that didn't fit. What was troubling his mind and making him feel something that shouldn't be there. It could only be you, whatever your ability or your true nature was, it was making him sick.
If he knew that playing with you would backfire so fast, especially like that, he’d have followed his plan strictly that night and killed you in the first alley. Indeed, it would bring less headache than now, and it wouldn’t upset him in the same way.
Upset? He huffed to himself and resumed back to scratch his wooden piece, he wasn’t upset. Tonight wasn’t the first time he had imagined you dead, killing you with his own hands like he had done many times before — you wouldn’t be the first and let alone the last victim of his. Yet, something felt different now and he couldn’t figure out what or why.
Suddenly imagining that the blood on that handkerchief was yours, not that lady's… Brought something in him. Very different from what he felt when he killed, nothing so fleeting as since even now, while scoring his blade against the piece of wood in his hands, the Nightmare felt the stabbing sensation lingering in his core.
Similar to what he had felt when he sat by your side that night.
When you two met at the cafe the following day and he placed his hand over your gloved hand, you dared to smile at him. Or, a few hours ago, when you two went to the bar again, together, and chatted until your friend Bruce had the decency to kick you out kindly.
Just… Peaceful. Nothing had felt peaceful to him before, until you.
It wasn’t a coincidence, not at all. The Corinthian had lived long enough to know that.
He rotated the forming carving in his palm, the roughed edges grinding into his palm like a sharp reminder of the wooden hilt he had gripped only seconds ago. His lips twitched as he thought to himself, grabbing the piece before scraping it once again, trying to finish it along with the dilemma he was finding himself in.
Feeling what others don't feel changes a person in a way. It makes you more human.
It made you more human. At the point to want to hear about the interests of a Nightmare even if your conscience was aware of the danger in it. What a curious human you were, indeed.
Usually, he’d just keep going with it and wait for it to end. Despite being different from the last people he had played, you’d bored him sooner or later — just like the others — and he’d have to kill you when it happened. Not ‘have’, he ‘would’.
However, the Corinthian would have to go against his rules precisely because there was something different about you. The initial plan was to understand what you were, day after day patiently. Now, he couldn’t be patient any longer.
With the last scratch from his blade, the Corinthian looked at the finished wooden piece in his hand. How he had perfectly captured each contour and curve of the familiar figure, especially, the pair of eyes full of emotions.
Grinning down at your face engraved in wood, the blonde wondered how much those eyes hid even without their owner's knowledge.
Then, he gathered his things and fixed the scene he’d left behind. There was only one place that the Nightmare knew would have the answers he was seeking, even if have been a long time since he hadn't visited there, he was finding himself forced to change that.
Corinthian would go back to the place where once was his home.
The Dreaming had changed.
The Nightmare had predicted it would have.
It was even expected since it had been a long time since Lord Morpheus had returned to his realm. Therefore, viewing the place how it was now shouldn't have amazed him, but it did.
Lands that once were filled with a plethora of colors and annoying waves of laughter were vacant — drained to nothingness. Not a sign of life could be found as the Nightmare wandered through the outside of the palace, trying to catch any dream or nightmare still lingering at their home.
So, it hit him, there was no one to be found.
It seemed like everyone had run away, thinking that their creator abandoned them once and for all.
That brought a smile to the Corinthian’s face as he fixed the hat over his head. Perhaps, finally, the others could understand why he had fled to the Waking World — what it really meant to be free or to search for that freedom. How it was to look for something beyond what you were designed to be.
While nearing his way to the front of the palace, the Nightmare saw a few things that were still intact at The Dreaming. Despite how lonely and empty the realm felt, it looked like the House of Mystery and the House of Secrets remained strong, which meant that Cain and Abel did not leave the place. Predictable.
But they weren’t the only ones, speaking of predictable. Far away, Corinthian could see a bit of green among the grey area that covered the Dreaming grounds. The Fiddler’s Green continued to wait for his creator patiently even when most of his friends and siblings had fled.
The Nightmare wondered about the idea of visiting the dream just to nag him but ended up changing his mind. He could still remember the times he'd dared to walk among the dream’s trees and that same dream's attempts to drive the blonde out of his perfectly green lawn.
Standing close to the front doors of the palace, Corinthian gave a last look to the broken fields left of the Dreaming. For a reason he couldn’t grasp quite yet, he wasn���t smiling anymore, something in him stirred with a strange feeling. In a short time, not even the House of Mystery, the House of Secrets, or Fiddler's Green could fight the loneliness that prevailed in the Dreaming anymore, weighing on the chest of anyone who looked at the empty and lifeless place for too long.
Not that the Nightmare felt terrible about it. He didn’t, there was no world where the sight of the remains of those soulless hills made him feel remorse. The Dreaming hadn’t been his home for decades, nothing now could change how he thought about what the realm once was, what it used to mean for him.
With a sigh, he turned on his heels and watched the doors to the palace warily open for him, as who greeted someone that they used to know. And, as the Nightmare passed through them, he didn’t look back.
As the Nightmare passed through them, he didn’t look back. He just waited for the click of the door closing behind him to go towards the known path to the library.
If outside, the realm was shattered in pieces, gathering what it had left — inside the castle, everything was falling apart.
The immense pillars, perfectly carved where each contour told a story, rested in crumbles on the ground and no longer supported the magnitude of the place. The Nightmare's gaze followed its destroyed pieces' path, step after step, how they revealed to him how the grand hallways and room of the majestic Dream's palace were nothing more than an old memory.
Inside the castle, strolling to the library made Corinthian feel stranger than outside when all he had was a view of a land ravaged by the lack of its king. The walls surrounding him were a single reminder of who had brought that to the realm, the same Nightmare that dared to walk calmly through the place as if nothing hadn’t changed over the centuries.
He could hear the wind hissing at him, shifting after every turn he’d take. The palace recognized him and if it weren’t completely empty, anyone would feel the rogue nightmare aura back to the Dreaming as the place did. They would sense the air becoming heavier in his presence.
The Nightmare that strayed from the Dreaming. The being who stated that would never return. And the reason the place he was raised was on its last breath. Not that anyone knew that but probably, they could guess since their lord was looking for him before he disappeared.
It has been more than fifty years. Things at the Dreaming weren’t like before, the loneliness that the walls exhaled made it clear.
After some time, the Corinthian found the entrance to the library. A grimace was placed on his face, confused by the uncommon deafening silence — everywhere used to be noisy. It was strange not to see a familiar face squinting their eyes at him suspiciously as they mumbled about the rogue nightmare.
He shook his head to himself, it should be a blessing and not something to bother him.
Once the Nightmare got into the library, the sight gracing him left him much more confused.
As anywhere in the realm, it was falling in itself. Most of the shelves that used to fill every inch of the place, full of books and stories that were currently being written were gone. Wood pieces of those shelves were left where they onetime were. The many books that brought the endless smell of fresh papers in the air now turned into dust, covering every surface.
And no sign of the loyal librarian who cared for the Dream’s library with her whole heart.
Holy shit, how was the Corinthian supposed to find your book now? He was expecting that the entire realm would be affected by the absence of its lord… But the library?
It was a collection of every book imagined and every story of a soul, human or not. The Nightmare thought that the place could work on its own, as long as people continued to create and live.
However, it couldn’t be like before, could it? It wasn’t like how things worked. Once someone took an essential piece off the board, the rules changed.
Everything changed. Perhaps, he hadn’t foreseen this as well as he'd thought before.
The Nightmare walked past what remained of the library, searching for anything that could be resisting the fall of a kingdom. Any standing bookshelf, a book facing down the cold ground, or even a single page by itself. Nothing.
If there was any magic around there, even if a little, the blonde in sunglasses didn’t feel it. Crumbles and dust made up the place once filled with magic, to the point of being sickening to the Nightmare now roaming its voidness.
Then, after so long, all that the Corinthian met was the breath of a dying land.
For a moment, he caught himself sitting in the middle of the long-lost library, was he supposed to feel something about all of it?
Because he didn’t regret helping that charlatan to keep an Endless trapped, especially when that Endless was his creator, all he wished was freedom. And only for that did Lord Morpheus try to unmake him?
Just for dreaming?
Was it really wrong wanting to feel emotions like humanity felt? To be among them, try to look and be like them? To envy them? For fulfilling his purpose perfectly while experiencing the ephemeral sensation of being human?
No. I wasn’t. Dream of the Endless was wrong, he was a self-centered, cruel, and blind creator to believe it was, to condemn any of his creations to do something as simple as dreaming.
So, Dream deserved what it came for him. Some would even say it was karma.
Thus, why wasn't the Corinthian satisfied?
He got the freedom he had long wished for. He was among humanity and fed from their fear and distress. In a second, he could feel how mortals were gifted to feel.
And even so, it wasn’t enough until he was drawn to your way at that bar that damn night.
One time or another, what he could regret was not killing you that same night for how your mere presence affected him. But, ironically or not, your effect on him was the exact reason for him to most of the time be relieved for not killing you yet.
Relieved. One more word that he didn’t understand its meaning or sensation before you and he shouldn’t, not in the way he did. That’s why he had returned to the Dreaming, looking for your book, for something that could explain what you were.
Why, when he was around you, to feel was easier? Stronger, even.
Corinthian tsked, rummaging in his pockets. His voided sockets wandered at anything but what he fished out of a specific pocket of his blazer, it would be better if he didn’t. It was bad enough for him to have recognized what he was looking for just by tracing his fingertips into the sharp edges of the wooden piece recently carved.
Why? It was simpler to ask this, the Nightmare realized when he finally stared at the piece he held fiercely. A heavier wave of confusion washed him as he looked back at those carved eyes.
Then, he sensed it.
Like something stroking the back of his neck and forcing him to look back at a spot under some wooden planks. Instead, what was hiding there.
A large burgundy book with a gold-edged spine was tucked away in what little remained of the various shelves. A unique aura enveloped its pages, the last drop of magic still lasted in the forgotten library. It wasn't for nothing that it wasn't easily felt but now that the Nightmare acknowledged it, he could feel every new word being written on its pages.
The Corinthian pushed himself up, slowly approaching the book. From where he was, he couldn’t read what was its exact title.
The D- And that was it.
Standing up beside the planks that were hidden in the book, the Nightmare was about to kick them away when…
“... Corinthian?” The sound of a certain voice caused him to stop dead in his tracks.
“Lucienne,” the Nightmare turned around, facing the librarian with pointy ears and rounded glasses.
Ever the loyal library, even if from an abandoned realm. Perhaps, the Corinthian was wrong for quickly assuming that she’d leave the Dreaming as the others did.
“You’ve returned,” the librarian sized the Nightmare up, carefully. Her hands gripping a book close to her chest, its title away from curious eyes, “Unfortunately, his Lordship is missing at the moment.”
Corinthian fought back a snort. Rather, grinning at her wording.
With ‘at the moment’, Lucienne meant sixty-five years and four months.
“Dream is missing? What a misfortune,” with a dramatic sigh, the blonde pretended not to notice how the librarian raised a brow at him. He didn’t answer her question and was well aware of that. As was she, perhaps that was why he felt like she could bore a hole into his skull, “Good thing I hadn’t returned, I’m only passing by”
“Hm,” Lucienne murmured skeptically, not falling for the alluring toothy smile that the Nightmare showed off, “And I suppose you do not know anything about our Lord's whereabouts?”
“I don't know what you're trying to imply with that tone,” Corinthian clicked his tongue, “Wherever Dream is, I am sure he is having all the time of the world to think.”
Usually, the librarian wouldn’t be the reason for the Nightmare to shiver. She was one of the most loyal Dream’s servants and could intimidate anyone that messed with her nerves.
Yet, when Corinthian was still a nightmare that carved wood under the comfort of a shadow in the Dreaming, Lucienne's squinted eyes and tight lips didn’t affect him. Not like it did now, as she threw daggers at him with a single stare.
“Think?” the librarian repeat the word, her voice not contained anymore. She was outraged, to say the least.
If he had to admit, it had made him shiver. It would be a secret only shared in a mundane night's silence.
Lucienne wasn’t the type of being that played following the rules of someone else’s game, especially a nightmare’s. After decades of aiding other dreams and nightmares, it could have taught her not to be deceived.
“Where the loyalty for your creator lies, Corinthian?” The librarian asked, her voice hardly above a whisper, “To fail him with such disrespect as to decide to have a part in his disappearance?”
So, she knew. The Nightmare couldn’t tell how much the librarian knew, but it was enough for her to know what was fact and what was still a shot in the dark.
Certainly, Jessamy had told Lucienne about his involvement. He remembered seeing the raven flying around the Burgess manor — because of that, he did himself the favor of warning the magician about the Dream's faithful messenger.
Yet, he had seen no sign of the raven in the Dreaming. If she were there or in the Waking World, she’d sense his presence in the realm and would make sure to be the first to confront him. Despite that, the Nightmare didn’t hear any beat of wings when him when he first stepped back into the Dreaming or now, as he discussed with Lucienne.
Did that charlatan get rid of…? Corinthian shook his head, that wasn’t something to be worried about. In fact, to celebrate, Jessamy could be quite annoying sometimes.
Then, why he wasn’t smiling anymore?
“Why should I be loyal to him?” Corinthian bit back, ignoring how hoarse his voice suddenly got, “He never had loyalty to me, not even to you or any of the others. There is a reason for almost every creation of his had fled the moment he didn’t respond to their pleas, don’t you agree?”
Listening to his words, the library frowned. The irritation in her furrowed brows and tight lips was replaced by a sympathetic look and lips pressed in a straight line, gulping back her thoughts. In a certain way, she knew where that resentment was coming from.
A long time ago, many nightmares and even dreams had blurted out about how sometimes it was difficult to feel anything for their lord but indignation.
“You misunderstand him, Corinthian,” Lucienne wasn’t hiding the sorrow painted on her features, yet if briefly. She might not tolerate the Nightmare but she felt sorry for him being unable to see things as they truly were, whether they like it or not, his twisted vision and mind were the real reason they were having this conversation.
The Corinthian wasn’t stupid, he didn’t need to take a second glance at the librarian’s face to see what was crossing her mind while she stared at him quietly. Pity, she was pitying him and he hated it.
If someone was supposed to pity, that someone was him. The Corinthian should be the one to pity the other people from the Dreaming, being sorry for them.
Sorry for Lucienne, the ones who chose to stay, and even the others servants that still had a little faith in their Lord as they lived in the Waking World. For all of them, they all were delusional, and couldn’t have the guts to cut the thread that linked them to Dream.
The Nightmare pitied them, they were the ones who didn’t understand Dream. He let out a wry chuckle, shaking the fragile walls that hold the library up with the sound of it.
“To the contrary, I see him for what he is,” he clutched at something he was holding, embracing the sharp contours in wood meeting the skin of his hand. The blonde lifted his lips and gave the librarian a mock grin, forcing the words out of his mouth, “If you think I failed with him, I don’t mind. You just can’t pretend that he didn’t fail with us first, he doesn’t care about you or me. Or for what we think.”
Lord Morpheus could have been the one who created them, but he never would be capable of truly seeing them. Being the one that brought them to life didn’t make him a good creator or Lord, quite the opposite. Precisely for being the one who gave them the breath of life, Dream didn’t see them beyond the duty that he thoroughly shoved right to their throats.
Dream of the Endless didn’t care about his servants, he only cared about himself and his kingdom.
And for that, the world was drowning in the fragments of a kingdom’s downfall.
That was the end that The Dreaming deserved, his Lord’s masterpiece, after everything that Dream had turned a blind eye to.
Lucienne not once missed the dark lenses of the Corinthian’s sunglasses — eyes and voidness locked in an unnerving quietness. Both servants of the same Lord: the loyal librarian and the rogue nightmare, which one would look away and turn their backs to that discussion?
Laying all of his bets on the table, Corinthian thought he had a good guess about who it would be. That was before the so-called 'good guess' fixed the round glasses on the tip of the nose and took a step forward toward him.
“You’re wrong, Corinthian,” Lucienne raised her chin and the Nightmare turned his nose at her insistence, “Not only for the twisting view you have of Lord Morpheus and for what you did to him… But for how you have harmed the Waking World and the Dreaming while doing so”
Had he?
The Nightmare doubted that… Decades ago, when he had nothing to be confused or uncertain about.
Still, something was different now. He didn’t know why. Still, something was different now. He didn’t know why but his head was constantly rewinding to what he had witnessed once he arrived back in the realm of dreams and nightmares. A land that had lost its life and colors, followed by grey clouds ready to start an endless storm.
After, all of them came in. The doubts.
And, if anyone wanted to hear some sincerity coming from Corinthian, the last thing he needed was more doubts. The number one reason for him to be there, at the Dreaming, was to crack the doubts that he already had back in the Waking World.
Therefore, he honestly didn’t need Lucienne instigating the new tide of doubts that broke in his thoughts, flooding each one of them. Despite his will, it came to him anyway.
Memories of how agitated and vivid those lands used to be when even the darkest spots used to bring comfort and not shivers, were shuffled with the brutal reality images of how the kingdom was now. A realm of dust and crumbles.
All by taking the card from the house of cards base.
The Corinthian looked away, rubbing his forehead. The staring contest between him and Lucienne didn’t matter anymore — it had never mattered — not when he was trying to look for the quickest way to put his head back to place.
A nightmare being tormented by his own mind, who would have thought about that day would come? Not him.
Corinthian sighed deeply, darting his tongue across his dry lips. Who had built that house of cards in the first place?
“Now, am I really the one to blame?” His low voice swallowed the silence in the library, Lucienne studied him carefully, paying no mind to the wind attempting to scare a nightmare off, “Everything I had done was to be free, if anything it’s thanks to me that the others finally gave in to what they always wanted to. Besides their duties and what they were created for, without fearing Dream punishing them for doing so.”
Knowingly, he said the last part bitterly, biting the two words and swallowing them down.
Some of the words the librarian had given him with such certainty were still running wild between the tracks of his train of thought, so he had all the right to refund them in some way. Paying for every letter, every gap, and every wound they unwittingly inflicted on his nonexistent soul back.
Mockingly, the Corinthian bowed his head in Lucienne’s direction, “You could follow suit and give it a try. Who knows, you might like it”
One last strike into the librarian’s nerve, carried by poison in every curve in his words.
Lucienne winced slightly, realizing the vicious teasing behind the Nightmare’s suggestion. If she didn’t have any self-control or sense, she’d smack him with the very book in her hands, Corinthian didn’t even need to read much in her narrowing eyes to acknowledge that.
Wait… Did the librarian hold a book? The Nightmare furrowed his brows, lowering his vision to the servant’s hands — there, she indeed was carrying a book when she first encountered him in the library. Perhaps, the book under the pranks wasn’t the only one persevering the loneliness of a kingdom?
The book. Glancing at the burgundy book hidden in the resemblances of a shelf, Corinthian remembered what he had found and tried to take a look before he was interrupted. Lucienne’s presence almost made him leave without what he had just found.
Even during his discussion with the librarian, if the Nightmare focused enough, he’d feel the magic pulling him to the collection of pages in a cover. Mesmerized by the familiar aura enveloping and sheltering it from the realm’s decay.
If he closed his eyelids, even briefly, he’d go back to the days when everything used to feel enough.
And now what lingered in the bare of his being was a longing nonsatisfaction. Despite how much he had achieved.
“If you really wished for that freedom that you so roguishly conquered,” Lucienne’s voice stood above the Nightmare’s train of thought again, bringing his attention back to her quipped brows, “why have you returned now?”
Corinthian raised a brow back to her, glancing between the librarian and the book she held, “I said I’m passing by”
“And I don’t believe you,” Lucienne rolled her eyes, fixing her posture. Her analytical stare bored through the pair of sunglasses that the Nightmare wore, trying to decipher his true intentions back in the Dreaming, “I’ll ask you again and I wait for an appropriate answer: why are you here?”
Fucking hell, the Corinthian pressed his lips into a thin line. What should he say? If he wanted Lucienne out of his way and to take that book without her nosiness, he should give her some type of answer. How much of the truth he could tell her without feeding her suspicions about him?
The half of it? The tenth of it?
“I was looking for a book,” Corinthian opened his arms, glancing around where he kept his two feet. The place hadn’t changed a bit since they started their little conversation, it still hung by a thread, “But I guess I won’t find it here.”
Lucienne tilted her head, looking the Nightmare up and down. Disbelief was clearly written over her features.
“A book,” Lucienne could believe what she had just heard. With a grin, Corinthian slowly nodded to confirm that she hadn’t heard wrong. The librarian scoffed, that sounded ridiculous, even for a nightmare, “You’re saying that your search for a book brought you back to a place you had sworn never come back to?”
The Corinthian shrugged, “Is it so hard to-”
“What is the name of the poor soul you want to read about before killing them?” Lucienne cut Corinthian off like a blade crossing thin air. Immediately, the Nightmare’s vision snapped back to her, taking time to process exactly what she had said.
Anyhow, both were oblivious to how the ground shook beneath their feet toward the insinuation. The librarian took upon Corinthian’s lack of answer to continue, “As you have been killing many others through the last decades?”
And that was her mistake.
The sound of the Corinthian’s jaw setting is swallowed by the library, his three mouths gritting his teeth in an iron grip. The Nightmare didn’t have veins or blood to run through them but, somehow, he thought he listened to the sound of blood flushing furiously inside of his head. Probably, it could be blood, it would explain why he was seeing red.
From outside the library and the palace, the clouds trembled. The Dreaming’s sky was completely painted gray and black, covering the lands in a big and cold shadow.
Now, Corinthian knew that Lucienne didn’t know about the detective. There was no way she would, that was a fact. That was supposed to be obvious.
Nonetheless, the facts didn’t matter, on the contrary. He didn’t like the implication that was intertwined in the librarian’s words, the incredulity in her tone when she referred to you as one of his next victims.
Like the ones who he amused himself by inviting them to the night, luring them to the comfort of his embrace before stabbing their backs. Then, with hands soaked in blood, taking their eyes out with the help of his blade, devouring them — blissfully enjoying the bittersweet taste lingering in his mouth, filling his chest with delight. Temporary, but still a pleasure, it used to satisfy him.
However, you were nothing like them. One day, you’d be one of his victims? Yes, he’d have to kill someday soon, but it would never be like how he had done with the others.
Not because he didn’t want to but because he couldn’t do such a thing. Not with you.
At the end of the day, besides all the Corinthian's attempts, they wouldn’t change how he felt anytime he imagined his hands soaked in your blood and your eyes consumed by his voidness. His stomach turned upside down just from trying to view you without your eyes, empty sockets and stolen soul.
Would your aunt be right? Would you forever be stuck in the mundane world if he took your eyes off you?
Incapable of finding peace?
There was no world where he could do it with you, submit you to a fate as being trapped in an eternity of loneliness. As long it was with any other boy or girl, it didn’t bother him. The Nightmare didn’t care about any of them, they didn’t deserve what was given to them.
Yet, for some reason, you did.
When it was about killing you and eating your eyes, that was a sight that he could never bear. And he couldn't figure out why.
Still, somehow, realizing that made the Nightmare’s limbs feel like they were made of lead.
“You’re wrong in assuming I’m searching for a next victim’s book, Lucienne,” Corinthian muttered, the words spat out dryly. Although he stiffed his posture back and tried to regain his control over the discussion, the Nightmare let out his annoyance when he clenched his teeth along his tone.
What he actually wanted to say was a single question: How could you think this of me? But, that could be easily retorted with an even better question.
How wouldn’t she?
After all, he is the Corinthian. Regardless of knowing that much, the Nightmare rested a hand over his chest, “Even I am not that sadistic, not at this point”
Lucienne blinked at that, dropping her arms to the side so she could take a better look at the blonde. Was he joking? He had to be, she hoped he was. However, the way he wasn’t chuckling in the way he used to do, was enough to tell her that he meant it. Which didn’t make sense, because yes, he was that sadistic.
Worse than being a nightmare, terror being the core of his nature, he had been corrupted by the evil in himself and humanity. Corrupted by what he was and what originally was his purpose.
Scanning the Nightmare’s form, the librarian searched for anything that could answer the unspeakable question that lingered in the air, absorbed by the walls in the library was raising — one that, as well, pickled in the back of her mind.
Because the nightmare before her can’t be the same nightmare that she witnessed running away from their realm. So, what was he?
What had changed him during the years he had been with humanity?
For all the librarian knew, the consequences of Dream being kept away from his duties could affect the Corinthian in the Waking World, right? Mess with the bareness of his existence? As it would probably affect any other dream and nightmare who fled to live among the humans.
No, it didn’t make sense. If that was ever the case, the other dreams and nightmares would have already come to her and reported anything hypothetically wrong with them.
So.. Could it be a curse? Did the nightmare cross the wrong person in the past decades? Maybe a demon, sorcerer… Anyone powerful enough to put him under a hex that forced him to feel a drop of human empathy, since all he wanted was to feel like humanity did.
But if someone cursed or plagued by evil was walking through the Dreaming, any servant there would had felt something off. And, Lucienne hadn’t sensed any magic in the nightmare that didn’t belong with him.
Lucienne remembered too well that even a few years after his escaping, Lord Morpheus was having to deal with the huge trail of bodies that the Corinthian had in his tail, accompanied by a wave of dread and terror that washed over the humans that he crosses ways. He hadn’t changed at that time, and that was one of the reasons their Lord decided to put an end to this matter and unmake him.
Therefore, what was different now? After so many years? Decades? Almost a century?
The librarian was running out of answers. Nothing made sense, it was like she was overthinking it.
Yet, she wasn’t. Something had changed, she just couldn’t quite grasp what.
Not until…
Puzzled, Lucienne drew her brows together, eyes stopping at the track.
“I thought you had stopped wood carving,” she noted out loud, eyes fixed at what Corinthian held fiercely in one of his hands.
Corinthian’s face dropped by the librarian’s voice, what she was pointing to with her wise eyes.
He was supposed to have kept it back in one of his pockets when Lucienne entered his space, but he forget it. How did he not notice that he was still holding his figure? And, instead, unconsciously found comfort in holding it tight.
For a nightmare as clever as him, he was losing touch.
“Looks like you're back with your old hobby,” choosing to ignore the Nightmare’s quiet shock, Lucienne added.
The way she was saying, prompting the subject, wasn’t helping the Corinthian to understand where the librarian wanted to go with it. What was the importance of him going back to wood carving or not?
It had nothing to do with what they had discussed in the last few minutes.
So he decided to take that rope she was giving him anyway, without giving it a mind. If it would help to distract Lucienne, he would willingly pull the rope.
“Stop is a strong word, I just wasn’t interested anymore for a while,” Corinthian shrugged it off, fixing his sunglasses, “Humans would call that a pause”
“I see,” the librarian stepped closer to the Nightmare, calmly, “You started to wood carve again when you arrived at the Waking World?”
Corinthian raised a brow at the question, pondering it carefully. What was so interesting about he wood carving again? When he used to do his hobby in the Dreaming, no one commented about it or his little creations, much less Lucienne.
“No…?” he tilted his head, incapable of reading the now Dreaming’s keeper, what she had running on her mind.
As a matter of a fact, it had been three days since he started wood carving again.
Trying to be as casual as possible, without causing any fuss, the Nightmare slipped the wooden figure back into his blazer pocket. He didn’t appreciate the idea of not knowing what was boiling in the librarian’s mind while locking her eyes on his piece.
“Is someone you met?” Lucienne asked, dipping her head. In response, the Nightmare furrowed his brows, not understanding what she was asking exactly. What was she referring to now? Towards the lack of an answer, the librarian pointed to his pocket, “I’m talking about the figure. It doesn't look like anyone I met from the Dreaming or any other realm”
Oh…
Corinthian sneered at himself, contemplating the situation where he was put as his eyes echoed the sound. Mocking the Nightmare themselves, even when they were him.
It was almost tragic if not frustrating. If he was alone in the library, he’d have screamed until he could understand what humans meant by their ‘lungs burning’.
Lucienne tricked him in her own game. It had been a long time since they weren't playing cards according to his rules, but hers. And without realizing it, the Nightmare fell into the librarian's trap.
He was cornered and in the exact place that Lucienne wanted him to be. In a position where even if he answered her or refused to, he would be giving her an answer anyway.
The Nightmare tutted, tilting his head while analyzing what had led him to where he stood.
The librarian could be quiet and always in her place in the past, knowing when was her time to speak or not. However, she was always there, somehow. When things unfolded and another servant needed to her to the wise, whether they like it or not, Lucienne was there like a shadow. An annoying one, in the Corinthian’s opinion, she always had some advice to give.
Unlike any of the other creations, dreams or nightmares, Lucienne was one of the few who was well aware of what the Nightmare was: his story, the moment he violently rose, and what he had become from there.
Therefore, of course, she’d have noticed that something was off.
From the moment that she stopped at the entrance of the library and her eyes locked on the Nightmare, she knew. Whatever it happened in the Waking World, it made the Corinthian return to what once was his home, in search of an answer or of what could solve his problems back in the Waking.
The very world that he adamantly claimed from the bottom of his being, the only place where he could be free. For the Nightmare to break his own vow and leave quickly that same world before going back, something would have scared him.
Him. The Corinthian. The Nightmare. The reflex of humanity.
What would scare such a being?
Would be the same thing that brought back his interest in wood carving back? An old habit that the Nightmare used to have even before Lucienne existed. A thing that he treasured and kept with him before he went to the Waking World for the first time, along with their Lord? And which, after that, when he was once back to the Dreaming, was never seen around again.
To make the Corinthian fall back to one of his old hobbies, a forgotten one even by himself, it needed to be something powerful. It wouldn’t be for anything that would make a nightmare get glimpses of his old self and question what he had achieved — how he had, the cost.
Then, the final card was the wooden figure. When Lucienne had her eyes on it, she finally understood.
What was more powerful than a human’s heart?
Nothing.
No, the Corinthian took a step back. He refused.
He can’t bear the idea of Lucienne knowing all of that. And, even if she did, that being his true.
Or, worse, what if the librarian discovered more about you? Would she ask for a dream or nightmare she trusted to warn you about him? Make sure you find out about his true nature? What he has done?
Would Lucienne be that cruel? With him?
Corinthian can’t let that happen. What would you do if you knew everything through someone else?
“I think we’re done here,” the Nightmare didn’t care about the strange book that he had found before Lucienne arrived, not really.
He wouldn’t be there any longer, he couldn't let Lucienne get more answers out of him than she already had. His questions could be left to think about later, but now they weren't on his top priorities anymore, “I won’t entertain you anymore with my presence”
Bumping into the librarian’s shoulder, the Corinthian passed by her. When he felt her eyes following his back, he ignored them.
The Nightmare still was clever enough to leave when it was necessary. Even if it meant that he had lost in their game.
In the Corinthian’s command, the wind returned to involve his body in a tight hold, a gale reserved for him and him only. Dust and sand camouflaged the Nightmare in thin air, ready to follow him wherever he wanted to be.
The Dream shuddered at the Nightmare’s demand, willingly giving his ticket back to the Waking World.
“Corinthian,” Lucienne called for him before he was completely gone from Dream’s realm again. The Nightmare expected the library to say something about their Lord, to remind him adorably that he was wrong in this matter — he imagined her saying anything to him except what spilled out of her mouth, “Whoever they are, let them be. Don’t destroy their life”
Then, with that, the rough breeze that had been there from the beginning led him back to where he belonged. To humanity.
But that didn’t stop him from hearing Lucienne’s last words to him. And they hit his intrinsic in a final blow, “Nothing good comes when you’re around, not to them”
The clicking sound of the glasses full of alcohol hitting the tables, along with the loud laughs of some drunks, was one of the few things that kept Nightmare from completely drifting his mind away.
Inside the bar, most of the people were seeking the shelter of a drink and the comforting warmth in spaces like that, anything that would make them forget about how cold it was outside. It could probably be one of the coldest nights of the season, forcing humans to find new ways to keep themselves safe from the icy breeze of the town.
For the first five minutes, Corinthian thought that it would be better if he headed to his nightly routine and didn’t meet you that night at all. Bruce, the bartender who took care of the bar at night, had seen him and greeted him? Of course. Would he probably tell you he was there and left before you arrived? For sure, after all, the bartender had a fondness for you — the reclusive detective with fickle humor.
It didn’t mean that, for a second, the Nightmare had pondered the idea of going to his routine and let the bartender tell you he had left anyway. But, he didn’t leave.
Instead, he had left the table he had taken in the back of the bar and sat on the counter’s stool.
Now, ten minutes since he had first arrived. Corinthian exchanged a word or two with the bartender, filtering little of what was said as he constantly caught himself back in what had happened in the Dreaming. The things Lucienne had said to him and what he would have said to her.
The details that were left in suspense, which were never mentioned but that had taken their places in the corner of his existence. Carving their own holes and burying themselves in him. All well aware that in the late night, when no sigh could be heard, the Nightmare would dig them up till the tip of his fingers turned to sand and clay again, trying to cling for what they were. The details, what they were? What did they mean? Why they held his unconscious conscious as their home?
In a moment, while the Corinthian drifted in and out of the conversation, Bruce mentioned something about a bottle of wine that he kept untouched in his house. At first, the Nightmare thought the bartender was trying to seduce him to his bed, it wouldn’t be the first time that a handsome man told him about a very old and expensive wine in their house that needed to be shared. That made Corinthian return his full attention to what Bruce was saying, just then noticing where he was going with the ‘untouched bottle of wine’ point.
“Do you believe it? A Château Lafitte as a gift? From 1828?” the bartender snorted, shaking his head, “That kind of stuff is rare, to not say very expensive, I almost refused but I’m sure you already know how the grumpy detective is”
“The detective?” Corinthian furrowed his brows slightly, “I didn’t quite catch, the detective was who gifted you that bottle of wine?”
“Yes, sir,” Bruce nodded, chuckling at the memory as he poured another glass of vodka for the Nightmare, “According to the dear detective, I deserved a reward for putting up with such a moody presence at the bar for a year.”
Well, that much sounded like something you would say indeed. The Corinthian nodded in understanding — for others, you were reclusive and someone of few words, rather staying in your quietness than instigating a conversation. Perhaps, it was because of it that you’d suggest sometimes that you were a complicated person to be around, the way your coworkers referred to you didn’t help you to think otherwise either.
However, you weren’t. Complicated, that was. Not for the Nightmare.
Sure, there were times when he couldn’t understand you. He still didn’t know how your abilities worked or where they came from, for example, only that they remind him of the Dreaming. That was why he had gone there and regretted it instantly, going back to the Waking World, (annoyed, he might add, it was the better word to describe his mood without going further).
Also, he couldn’t quite grasp yet the reason for you wanting people to discover their truths. What was the point in showing someone what they will continue to be oblivious about?
Okay, maybe it was your sense of justice, he could understand that. You believed that people deserved to face reality.
Although, he of all people had a say in the matter, an incontestable fact: humanity is afraid of acknowledging their truths, to confront reality, the reflex that would stare them back in the big mirror of the world. And, you could do nothing about that.
Thus, why keep trying? It was useless. If they couldn’t see what was in front of them and inside them, in their intrinsic, so they didn’t deserve to wander among the others. Someday, he hoped, you would understand — before you died, preferably.
Speaking of you… He glanced around the bar, distractible, dark lenses stopping at the bar’s doors for a second. Better late than never.
Escaping from the icy wind, you fixed your scarf and readjusted the black gloves covering your hands, protecting you from the winter's sudden potential. Flashing your eyes at a couple of drunks settled in their tabled, you winced by their shoutings and kept your hands in the pockets of your coat, as usual.
Your face didn’t carry the best of expressions, any energy you had before drained by what you had to deal with at work today. Dragging your gaze to the counter, finding where the Nightmare and the bartender were, you did your best to mask your tiredness. But it was clear, as you made your way to the stool next to him, that something had dreaded you.
The Corinthian could smell the fear leaving your pores and coating your frame. However, nothing of it was yours, but from someone else.
A flash of the face you the girl he had killed between last night and today, her expression contorted in horror and lack both of her eyes. Her blood pooled on the floor and stained the bottom of his black shoes.
The student…
“Hey Bruce,” you dipped your head, adjusting your figure over the stool. Your eyes were on the counter but, clearly, your attention wasn’t there, “Can I get a whiskey in one of those exquisite glasses and with ice?”
The bartender puffed, glancing at the Corinthian as he held a laugh, “You mean a whiskey on the rocks?”
“Good to know we’re speaking the same language,” you said with a smug, one that quickly faded from your face. The Nightmare snorted at your tone, sipping his drink — at least, he wasn’t the only one sulking anymore. Laying your arm over the counter, you faced the man in sunglasses, his hat resting in his lap, “Sorry for being late, my case is… It’s complicated”
The Nightmare took a second to contemplate you from up close since you were sitting by his side. You weren’t excited as you were when you both shared your goodbyes in the middle of the night, your eyes beaming at him as you whirled your back to him. Now, your irises felt haunted.
Gulping a lump that formed in his throat, the Corinthian frowned at himself. His mind was drowning in words, a single being played repeatedly like a broken record.
Haunted. Haunted. Haunted. Haunted. Haunt-
“And you?” you asked in return, tilting your head at the Nightmare. Instantly, he noticed a subtle scent of tobacco coming from your clothes, not your breath.
It grounded him more firmly in the present.
“A lot like you, I hadn’t the best of days,” he raised his glass, shrugging.
“Hm,” you muttered, tapping the counter as you waited for your order, “Are you okay?”
Corinthian huffed, to not say that he scoffed at your question. Not because of the question itself, but for you being the one asking it. You, who were overflowing in worrying, despite your attempts to keep all that gathering in your core. And you still cared to ask him if he was okay?
That sounded like a joke. How would he even start explaining? Better, what would he actually say?
I was working and suddenly you came to mind and it distracted me enough to make me go home and I hated it, in fact, it’s still bothering me. So could you please stop with whatever you’re doing? Because you have to know what you’re doing.
No, that wasn’t one of the best ideas, for far not the brightest.
“Are you okay?” he returned the question, “What happened, another victim?”
“I wish it had been only that,” you sighed, “But I believe things are getting harder the closer I get to the answer.”
“Well, enlighten me,” the Corinthian offered an encouraging smile, one that you returned with a nod before starting to explain.
Quickly, Bruce handed you your drink before giving the both of you a wink and going back to his work. You didn’t touch the whisky, just thanked the bartender in a mumble and ranted about how your case was going as you let the ice melt in the drink and diluted the alcohol.
And, for what it seemed, only one thing had happened as the Corinthian had predicted that day: his changing his victimology so suddenly did not only stir your head but your precinct as well.
Aside from the complete change of target, the young adult was murdered in the same way the others had. About the eyes... Like the last times, they were taken too. Nothing else had changed.
Your hands gestured in the air while you talked in a lower tone, wishing for Bruce not to hear how was the student’s state when you went to the morgue.
Her skin was coated by the smell of dead, lifeless, her clothes soaked in her blood and her chest exposed — with wounds that even if she hadn’t died in the motel, she’d not make it to the hospital. And her face…
You stopped yourself before continuing, a shiver running down your spine when you relived her fear and worry for her own life.
Her face was pure void, according to your words. You didn’t know another way of describing it. Blood tears had stained her cheeks and turned into two portals for emptiness where her eyes once were.
The Corinthian went quiet while you continued to explain what happened at your work, how your case was going, how the new victim would change it, etc. His dark lenses were fixed on your face, even if he wasn’t paying attention to what you were saying anymore. The vodka he had in his hand turned warm when the smell of tobacco in his gloves couldn’t hold his thoughts to the ground anymore, rewinding to the shadows in his being once again.
Into emptiness.
For some reason, the Nightmare could still feel that there was something in his hands. Staining, soaking, and coating them with a bloody weight. Drop by drop, he heard the vividly liquid fall from his fingertips to the drink in his glass, tainting his vodka with his wrecks.
Looking up, he could see the crumbles in his being that mimicked the ones in the Dreaming. His feet sank in sand, dust, and clay as he strolled among the nothingness that fill him. Each step left a red footprint behind him, the tracks of a fallen creation. A killer.
Wasn’t that what he was supposed to be? The truth about humanity was ugly, horrible, and gloomy — his purpose was that, to represent that side of them. To defy them to see the shadows of their reflex, a sight they wouldn’t dare to face when they were awake.
So, he would make them see it himself. Acting like them, camouflaging among them and killing the ones who didn’t know how to enjoy what they had. Feeding from their eyes and enjoying it himself, for once, the Nightmare could feel like humans did.
And then, he was greeted by the void again. Vacancy.
Everything that, now, the Dreaming reflected too.
The Corinthian bit the inside of his cheeks, looking for anything that would push that memory away, even pain. But he felt nothing, sand filled his tongue and vanished at the same second, leaving a bitter taste instead.
The Dreaming was a part of Dream, as Dream was a part of the Dream, and he — a nightmare — was made with the resemblances of Dream, his creator. Would that mean that Dream was feeling like he felt? That lack of everything and nothing at the same time?
Something in thinking about it, made the Corinthian feel sick. Sicksicksicksicksicksick, an unfamiliar word with a new meaning and he hated everything about that word. It implied that he felt bad about his creator if it was true if Dream was really passing through what he has been in his entire existence.
That hole grew bigger and bigger in his core.
And, if that was the case, he couldn’t feel sick about it. He should be satisfied with it. Eventually, Dream would understand him.
“Even if one of the offices behind those other cases replies to my letter, it will be useless,” the sound of your voice slowly grounded him back to his stool. If you had noticed that the Corinthian wasn’t entirely there, you didn’t say anything about it, “Until there, my case will close, unfinished, and I won't be able to continue it from here.”
“What?” the Nightmare drew his brows together, “What do you mean?”
You pressed your lips in a thin line, sipping your drink for the first time.
“MacDonald got in touch with the cops in the other cities, the closest from here, asking them about the victimology, and who answered her said that my case matches their old cases,” Corinthian’s sockets widened, raising his brows at it and returning to drink again. He would need it, “My unsub has been working for ten years, if not more”
Way more, the Nightmare pursed his lips. It wasn’t like he was going to count how many years had passed since he'd started, it had certainly been over fifty.
It started before Dream was captured. So, there was the math.
His lips turned into a pout when the name emerged again in his mind. Dream.
“Sorry if you had already explained, I’m just trying to understand,” the Corinthian fixed his sunglasses, twitching his nose, “But why this means that you will close your case?”
Drumming your finger on the surface of the counter, you looked away from the Nightmare in silence. The same lullaby was playing constantly, it made the skin of the Corinthian tremble as if they were strings trying to follow a melody’s chord.
He felt that wave again. Emotions threatening to escape from your chest and that claimed for him to reach them one more time. Like he had done the other times.
However, this time, the Nightmare chose to ignore it. To let the wave pass through him and don’t adventure in the deep of those waters. To not swim further.
Just stay.
Suddenly, he felt it. Vividly.
That feeling when you would be drowning and the water filled the bottom of your lungs, digging its way into your organs, tissues, flesh, and core. Lungs screaming for oxygen, pleading for it even a bit, anything that would make the pain go away. The burning.
The Corinthian’s lungs were burning.
Despite him not having lungs or feeling pain, not as humans would do.
But, he felt.
“It’s just that…” you stopped yourself, the words trembled every time you opened your mouth, “The others officers, from these other cities, they all said the same thing, you know? The unsub always leaves after he murders the seventh victim, he moves from town to town, taking advantage of the officers who don’t give his cases a second thought.”
That… That was true.
The Corinthian pinched the bridge of his nose when he remembered that. Remembered by you. How had he forgotten a crucial thing as it?
It could be because he had never shortened the time between his killings. Or because he had never been that absorbed before.
Enjoying more what happened after the killing and the delight than the process itself.
That wasn’t optional: he should find his next victim.
But, it would mean that he’d have to leave the town soon after. And, if he left, he could just let you continue here.
Everything that Corinthian was planning to do in the future far away would have started to be set in motion. That idea, unlike when he first thought about it, didn’t bring him any excitement. Or amusement. In reality, it made that burning feeling return to his lungs.
His chest.
“MacDonald just took information from them because she technically forced them to re-check closed cases and even so, it will be for nothing” Your glass of whisky danced in your hand, sparkling under the bar’s dim lights. You frowned at the whisky, glancing at the Nightmare, “Probably, tomorrow another body will be found, and even if get to the motel instead of asking for the cops to bring the victim to the station… The unsub will be on the road already, he could be anywhere.”
Yes, he could.
The Corinthian mimicked your frown, taking in what you had just said. The agony of drowning in the void as you wait for a helping hand or for that torture to end — but nothing ever coming to happen.
Condemned to the lack of a something, an anything. A conclusion.
The lack of everything and nothing. That would make you two, right?
After the bar, both of you would be doomed to a similar fate. You would have to die without your answers while he would have to keep living without his answers, but the doubts you planted in his head.
And your blood in his hands.
The Nightmare winced at the mere thought, seeing his blade cutting through your fresh. Only one time, he wouldn’t have the courage to stab you more than once. So, for that, he’d have to hit you in your head, more specifically, your medulla oblongata.
You would die ten seconds later, gazing at him in his empty sockets while one question lingered in the air and you’d never find the strength to make it. Why? Then, your eyes wouldn’t close, they would continue to stare at him, emotionless. Completely numb, empty, just a void of what you were.
A reflex of him.
He’d never find in himself to close your eyelids. Or maybe, he would, not wishing to remember you in that way.
He needed to remember you by the way you’d look at him while explaining something that you didn’t have sure he’d understand — but it didn’t matter, because he would be paying attention, and that was enough. Not only by how your eyes widened at him, pouring how you felt out but your determination, what some would assume to be stubbornness. Yet, he appreciated it, even when he didn’t understand why you kept doing what you did, he liked that you weren’t one of giving up.
You never were or would be. You were the type of person that wouldn’t die without pulling up a fight, trying until your last breath to carry on.
The Nightmare’s hand hovered over the pocket of his blazer, feeling the edges of the wooden figure there.
He had to make a decision.
“You seem too positive about that,” the Corinthian remarked in a mutter, loud enough for you to hear and bring your attention back to him.
It was inevitable, the wanting to kill would strike again and he’d give in to it.
He’d have to murder another victim, no matter when.
“What do you mean?” it was your turn to ask.
That was the key: no matter when.
The Corinthian grinned at your question as if you had asked exactly what he wanted to hear.
“You had said to me that the killer probably is killing and setting his scenes as he does because he wants attention,” the man in sunglasses quipped a brow, pulling his drink away from him, “Especially from the press”
“Yes…?” you furrowed your brows, folding your arms, “Where you want to go with it?”
“Calm down, sweetheart, I was already getting there,” the Corinthian held his hand up, not noticing how you lowered your head, bashfully, “As you said, none of the other officers even investigated the case, so until now no one had instigated his interests”
Not that he didn’t want attention.
After years of murdering and rarely being a topic around common people, he had grown to like the mornings after the murder.
When he’d walk among the humans, waved by the sun upon his head, while they were utterly unaware of the horribles of the other night. The danger that was nearby.
It wasn’t something that you needed to know, though.
“What are you suggesting?” you abandoned your drink, narrowing your eyes at the man in sunglasses.
“Give what he wants,” the Corinthian offered, drumming the counter as you did before, “I know people that if I knock on their door right now, would have it published tomorrow morning”
With a threat. But the point was that they would do what he asked them to do.
You opened your mouth, then closed it and opened it again.
“Would you do that?” you asked, trying to hold back a smile. Either way, the corners of your lips turned up, “Seriously?”
“Of course, I would,” he flashed you a smile, genuine this time, “Am I not a journalist?”
Your face relaxed in relief, tears threatening to escape from your eyes while you stare at his sunglasses. Your gloved hands gripped the stool where you were sitting, not knowing exactly what to do with them. Perhaps, if you weren’t so afraid, you’d ask him if you could hug him.
“You don’t know how much this means to me, thank you,” you brushed your shoulders against his, briefly, “I owe you this one”
“No, there is no need for such a thing,” the Corinthian shook his hands, resting them over the counter, “See this as I doing a favor for a friend”
Friend? Was that what you were?
“Huh, if you say so,” you nodded, “I’m sure you would like a last drink before heading to some of your contact’s house?”
The Corinthian chuckled, “I’m not one to refuse a drink when offered”
You laughed at him, much lower than the others in that bar and, yet, sweet.
“Bruce, please,” you called the attention of the bartender, who quickly perked up at your order from his position behind the counter, “One round to me and…”
The sentenced paused there, remaining in the air. Your eyes stopped at the being by your side again, as if you waited for something.
It took a couple of seconds for the Nightmare to realize.
His name. You were asking for his name.
He was taken aback by that, fixing his position on the stool sheepishly.
You didn’t want any of you to be a stranger anymore. That made his chest burn again, but not in a bad way like before, it was something else.
Let your name run around or, worse, give a face to said name was a dangerous thing to do. It would only bring you trouble for the person.
“Hm,” Corinthian scratched the back of his neck, “You can call me Cori”
But the Nightmare was willing to take the risk.
Your brows rose, “Cori?”
He liked how the name sounded in your mouth, how your lips moved along the letters. It felt right when you repeated, coating the world in honey and turning it into a sweet melody, a lullaby. A dream.
Everything that he lacked.
“Did I get it right?” your eyes crinkled when you questioned, lowering your head in his direction.
Cori smiled again, nodding, “Yes, and you? I suppose you have a name, detective”
Rolling your eyes, you pondered it for a moment.
A name wasn't something that someone should give to any one.
In the end, names held power. Identities were made by names, and names molded souls. Once you gave a name to something, it became real, it had a meaning.
Yet, you gave yours to him freely.
And, even with Corinthian knowing what was your name way before you knew his, it was there.
At the moment that his chest filled with flames that burned but couldn't be felt.
The beginning of the downfall of a nightmare.
.
next chapter.
.
Taglist: @slashersimp101 @mavsketch @lostcause514 @tuttifuckinfruttifriday @morallygr4ygay @milleca @ravenous-says-stuf @smoke-n-fiire @laydreams @kameronrose @mischiefmanaged71 @seraferna @lupinlie (if you want to be added, let me know!)
98 notes
·
View notes