also people in the notes of these bs/ofmd polls being like "they're too different in tone and narrative style to compare! apples and oranges" I used to be like you and in general I agree. we can enjoy them both for very different reasons. however. there is an obvious answer to which one is the Better Piece Of Television as in better crafted and executed in all the areas that matter to televisual storytelling (writing, cinematography, editing, production design, scoring, etc) and it's black sails. no contest. toby stephens died so rhys darby could flop around
watching black sails now. sorry for being immediately insanely annoying but the opening title card is interesting, saying that all “civilised states” declared war on pirates. which is technically true! but only because Britain and other imperial powers entered into formal agreements with private companies to protect them from piracy, which before that point piracy benefited those empires because pirates would plunder ships and bring the goods back to Britain and Europe. “pirate” became a constructed class of criminal as a result of states nationalising (and therefore monopolising) violence as a state tool of regulating commerce
🦜 the winner of this Round 3.5 poll will proceed to Round 4 with episodes 3.03, 3.10, & 4.10 next week, October 28 (11:30PM SGT) | more info.
SUMMARIES UNDER THE CUT!
[LEFT] X. (2.02) — A member of the Walrus crew unexpectedly returns, but finds himself cruelly tethered down on a beach. Flint, still stuck in the bowels of the ship, sets his plan in motion to become a captain in two days' time by offering advice to Dufresne on a certain route to navigate the galleon through. Meanwhile, Silver tries to make himself indispensable to his crewmates by reading them gossip that the quiet cook Randall witnesses daily aboard the ship. Meeks asks Eleanor to dispose of his captain, Ned Low since his unquenchable thirst for power is causing the crew to be reckless. After Jack learns about the intimate encounter between Max and Anne, he accepts it and later proposes his next money-making scheme with them.
[RIGHT] XVIII. (2.10) — In Charles Town, the day of Captain Flint's trial comes. Lord Ashe offers him a chance to avoid humiliation, but Flint declines, still bitter at Ashe for Mrs. Barlow's death. However, help for Flint arrives in the unlikeliest form: Charles Vane. Vane's men launch their attack on the city, and Flint and Vane fight their way out, with Flint murdering Ashe en route. They reach the ship to find Flint's crew have regained leadership, but Flint orders Vane's crew be released - realizing pirates have to unite against the rest of the world. Silver, after being tortured, is forced to have his leg amputated. When he finally awakens, he reveals that the spy they hired to watch the Spanish soldiers sold the location to Jack, but he leaves out his own part in the exchange. The ending scene shows Max celebrating Jack's success at bringing the treasure back to Nassau.
in Interview with the Pirate, an older Jim Hawkins tracks down an ageing John Silver to conduct research on a book he’s writing. they meet in a tavern and over the course of several sessions, Jim learns more and more about the so-called golden age of piracy and the rise of the dread captain flint. silver has trouble remembering things clearly since he’s getting so old, which is what he tells Jim. max owns the tavern btw.
Hot tip: The best way to get me to not want to watch or read something is to do the thing where you go "Well, you know this classic story you love and means a lot to you? Well this is like that but BETTER!"