#so i dont really understand why the erins tried to make dust and sand seem..younger?

[wc-confessions]

Another problem with Warriors being bad at ages and timelines is Firestar and Graystripe were made Warriors early??? I never saw it that way since they had just had their assessments so I assumed they were adults and it was Sandstorm and Dustpelt that were being held back, probably for their bad attitudes.

yeah it doesnt make sense. i actually went and read back parts 1 and 2 of tpb out of curiosity and i think it's just messy writing. because there's no actual time skip said/implied when they both are made warriors and bluestar openly says yeah that was sick they're worthy now. like time has passed but we arent really told if it means theyve aged. aside from this a little before greystripe says he wouldnt be a warrior for many moons and firestar wasnt even in thunderclan for that long, yet to himself he states its been some moons and hes grown in size but never actually states if he's talking abt his age since kittens actually grow in size (if you take into account that irl they grow in size daily, which is a thing warriors only acknowledges Sometimes). but the thing is he's only been there for two moons if you go by months taken place. and..theyre literally referred to as still kittens and young apprentices throughout the first book. then after the ceremony, second book, is when we get an actual timeskip and firestar then refers to himself as no longer a kitten..so yeah i dont really know what went on in the erins' heads.. i feel like if ages are pretty important in this series, they should be better planned and memorized.

i guess the erins meant for them to be 12 moons (warrior age) by the end of into the wild?? but barely any time passes enough for firestar and greystripe to be at that age. but really at this point i don't think it matters because time isnt detailed or meant to be a concern in warriors. just do what you can with the info you have

#so yea #ig theyre supposed to be adults?? #despite what bluestar says and how theyre described #its just funny bc firestar openly boasts abt being an adult in the 2nd book #despite little time passing #not a confession #text #asks #anonymous #also raven greystripe sandstorm and dustpelt are all the same age #having been kits together etc #so i dont really understand why the erins tried to make dust and sand seem..younger? #maybe it was bc of their behaviour idk