I would have loved to see this and cry my heart out rather than having to witness that creepy dude wanking to alicent's feet, and her weirdo ass of a son jerk off at the window like wtf
they were so desperate to make daemon one dimensionally evil rather than show his good side ugh
567 notes
·
View notes
Okay, so here are some unedited thoughts from episode 1 og House of Dragon:
I'm excited - so much so that it scares me. I'm very wary considering what happened last time, but I enjoyed the atmosphere, the establishing world building, the characters, the acting. The CGI seemed a bit wonky at times, but hey.
HOWEVER. The birthing scene in House of the Dragon was horrifying, disgusting and vile.
And how I saw it, the writers fell into the same track as GOT in later seasons when it came to altered, worsened sexual violence against women in the adaption process - solely for shock value and ratings. Right - there wasn’t any explicit sa of queen Aemma in this episode, but the way she was put through a brutal c section WHILE AWAKE AND ACTIVELY SCREAMING AND PROTESTING, just seemed so on the nose to get a rise out of the audience - just like scenes like Ramsay raping Sansa on their wedding night in GOT.
I picked up Fire and Blood after this first episode and on p. 359 it says:
"Thus did matters stand in King's Landing late in the year 105 AC, when Queen Aemma was brought to bed in Maegor's Holdfast and died whilst giving birth to the son that Viserys Targaryan had desired for so long."
No mention of a forced c section while awake. Not in my copy at least - if there is an expanded text somewhere that elaborates, please let me know!!
I'm just - God, they could have done so much to emphasise the tragedy without making it so horrifically and unecesarilly nasty. Aemma could have made the choice, begged for it, they could have given her milk of the poppy to put her under just before performing the surgery. They could have made the cinematography of the scene not feel like a brainstorming session for "how to capture the most gory details of a medieval c section surgery". They could have done SO much to not be so viscious and nasty when it didn’t serve the story.
It just takes me out of the illusion - makes me think "wow, the writers wanted to show balls with this, live up to the scandalous reputation of got - show that they pulled no brakes". Instead of feeling for Aemma, for Viserys and Rhaenyra and being invested in the emotional stakes of the story, I'm just left wondering why the showmakers are so crude and cruel towards the audience. It doesn’t feel like skilled showmaking and it doesn’t build trust and enthusiasm with the audience. Shame.
47 notes
·
View notes