Where The Heart Is, Part 2 - Eddie Munson x Reader
Summary: After meeting Eddie over Thanksgiving break, the two of you only want to become closer with one another. You can read part one here.
Note: The response I got to the first part of this truly blew me away. I never expected so many people to leave comments or send me messages, and I just want you all to know how much it means to me. I wasn’t sure if I would continue it or not, because part of me liked where I ended it, but after so many requests, I decided to go further with these two. I have to thank @munson-blurbs for helping me the many times I got writer’s block!
Warnings: phone sex, smut, p in v, oral f! receiving, mentions of trauma, mentions of bad family life, general upside down-related unpleasantness
Words: 17.9k (Whoa.)
[Part 3 | Where The Heart Is masterlist]
The first thing you do when you see your roommate walk into your dorm after returning from Thanksgiving break is tell her to not ignore the phone if it rings. She gives you a funny look, like you’re weird for assuming she’d ignore it at all. But you know her, and if she doesn’t feel like doing something, she won’t. That includes answering the phone.
“Who’s calling you?” she asks. Shelby has a talent for making basic questions sound like insults. Though you have to concede that it is true that no one has ever called you before.
“His name is Eddie.”
Suddenly, she’s interested.
“A boy?” she asks, yet again making it sound like an offensive question.
“Yeah, a boy,” you say. You’re putting the last of your clothes away that you’d brought with you to Hawkins and with each piece you touch, a memory of what you did in it comes to mind. A smile grows on your lips as you pick up the blue sweater you wore when you met Eddie. The soft material gets a small squeeze in your hand before you hang it up.
“You met a guy in Iowa?” Shelby asks as she tosses her suitcase on her bed.
“Indiana,” you correct her. “Yeah, one of Nancy’s friends.”
“And he’s going to call you?”
“Yes,” you say as you roll your eyes, head in your closet. “We really hit it off.”
“Huh,” Shelby muses and you have the urge to strangle her with the pair of tights you just picked up.
Luckily, Shelby decides to stay with her boyfriend in his room for the night, so you can rest from your trip in peace. When the night passes by without Eddie calling, you’re a little disappointed, but also understand because you just saw him this morning. Maybe you were becoming a little obsessed. You sprawl out flat on your back on your bed and stare up at the ceiling. Why is this how it goes? You don’t have feelings for a guy in what feels like forever, then you get hit harder than you could’ve ever possibly imagined you could fall for someone. Thoughts start spinning around your head too loudly for you to possibly get some sleep, so you grab your Walkman from your desk and settle in under your blankets. When you press play, the sound of Queen fills your ears, and you end up falling asleep with an easy smile on your lips.
Alarm startling you awake, noise no longer coming from your headphones since the tape had finished during the night, you jump and clutch at your sheets. Letting the adrenaline that’s surging through your veins abate, you lay back and throw an arm over your eyes. Afraid of falling back to sleep, you push yourself up and start to get ready. You take care to layer up, knowing the biting cold waiting for you once you step outside. Though your black coat looks good when you inspect yourself in the mirror, you can’t help but think Eddie’s leather jacket would look even better.
A gentle snow falls down as you step out of your dorm building, but the harsh wind blows the flakes so fast they sting as they hit your face. You pull your scarf up over your mouth and nose as you make the trek to the English building. As far as early morning Monday classes go, there were far worse ones to have than English.
You’ve finished reading the book you were assigned for the class far ahead of schedule, so the discussion doesn’t hold your attention since everyone is behind you and discussing plot points you already know the resolutions to. Your mind drifts and starts with pleasant thoughts of Eddie, but eventually your own insecurities chime in and make you wonder if he meant it at all when he said he’d call you. Were you dumb for believing him? Did he just want to have a girl to make out with over Thanksgiving and you’d fit the bill?
It’s still going through your mind when you join Nancy for lunch before your last class of the day, which you share with your friend.
“Can I ask you something?” you ask as you sit down across from her in the dining hall.
“You know you can.” She shoots you a smile before taking a bite of her sandwich.
You scratch your nail across your napkin, watching your finger leave holes in its wake. It’s easier for you not to meet her eyes as you speak.
“Did Eddie really like me? Or was I being dumb?”
Nancy stops chewing and lets her sandwich fall back to the plate.
“What? Are you kidding me?”
Your eyes glance up at her before looking into your cup of soda.
“I mean, like, does he treat all girls like this? Am I stupid for thinking I’m special?”
“Look at me.” When you don’t, she reaches over and taps your wrist. “Look. At. Me.” You tilt your head up and meet her eyes. She looks like she wants to throttle you and it makes you shrink under her gaze. “You really think I’d play a part in something that wasn’t real? You think I’d just let him come over in the middle of the night or that I wouldn’t stop him from flirting with you so much if I knew he was just treating you like he treats other girls?”
Shame fills you as you drop your eyes and shake your head. You hadn’t thought about it that way, caught up in your own head and your own insecurities. But Nancy was nothing if not a good friend and she deserved better than to be thought of like that.
“I’m sorry, Nancy, it’s not what I meant,” you say. “You’re right, you would never do anything like that. Ever. I guess I’m just second guessing myself now that I’m back in reality. It kind of feels like Eddie was just some dream I came up with.”
Nancy sighs and picks her sandwich up again. She takes another bite and swallows it before she speaks.
“I get it,” she says. “When I first came here and left Steve back home, I had a hundred negative thoughts running through my mind. And we’ve got years of history and I know you and Eddie only had a few days. Look, I know I told you that I’ve never seen you the way I saw you with Eddie. But I guess I didn’t tell you that I’ve never seen him like that either. Now, to be fair, I haven’t known him well for very long. But when you go through the kind of shit we went through together you do get to know someone well quickly. And as for other girls? I’ve never even heard him talk about a girl before.”
“Oh, come on,” you say with a little laugh. “Look at him. Like he’s never had a girl before?”
“I never said he never had a girl,” Nancy says, shaking her head. “But I’ve never heard him talk about one before. And Eddie is not the kind of guy to play girls. If he tells you he cares about you, he means it. He’s very sincere. Too honest sometimes, if I'm being truthful.”
The smile that comes to your face is involuntary and you try to hide it by taking a sip of your drink. Nancy sees it anyway, but decides not to comment on it, but smiles to herself. You go to take a bite of your mashed potatoes but have to ask one more question first.
“You don’t think I’m crazy, do you? Getting so attached so quickly?”
Nancy shakes her head as she swallows the bite of food currently in her mouth.
“You’re not crazy at all. If you two were talking about going off to Vegas and eloping, I’d be worried. But giving him your phone number? Hardly something drastic to do when you like a guy.”
“I feel crazy,” you admit with a laugh. You drop your fork and rub your hands over your face.
“It is kind of fun for me.” Your friend smirks at you and raises an eyebrow. “Seeing you all riled up like this. So unlike you.”
“It’s why I feel crazy!”
Nancy laughs. “Oh, you’re fine.”
The first day back to classes wears you out. You drag yourself back to your dorm after dinner and collapse on your bed. The winter sun setting earlier in the day makes you want to curl up in bed and call it a night. But your clock tells you it’s only a little after seven.
“I don’t want to be productive,” you mumble into your pillow.
You kick your boots off and force yourself up to switch your things out of your backpack for your classes tomorrow. If you went to bed without doing it, you know you’d end up forgetting in the morning. Luckily, Shelby hasn’t come back to your room so far, but you know it’s only a matter of time.
The phone rings and your textbook slips out of your hand, landing on the tile floor with a loud thud. You trip over it on the way to the shelf between your and Shelby’s beds, snatching the phone up.
“Hello?” you ask.
“Hey.”
Your body practically drops to the floor in relief, grinning to yourself as you sit with your back against the wall and tuck your legs up against your body.
“You sound scared,” you say with a giggle.
Eddie laughs and the sound sends butterflies throughout your body.
“I was scared I was going to get the bitchy roommate!”
“Just me, unfortunately.”
“Bite your tongue,” he says. “You’re the only person I’ve wanted to talk to since we said goodbye at the airport.”
If Shelby were there, she would make fun of you for the rest of the semester for the dopey grin on your face.
“Actually,” Eddie admits, and his voice has gotten quieter. “I wanted to call you last night, but I thought that’d be kind of clingy of me.”
“Honestly? When I was lying in bed last night, I wished you would call.”
“Aw shit, sweetheart,” Eddie says. “You sound just about as lovesick as I am.”
“Lovesick,” you repeat. “That’s a good word for it.”
You hear a breath of laughter on the other end of the line, and you close your eyes to picture what him laughing looks like. His eyes crinkle in the corners and all his bright teeth gleam in happiness.
“How was your first day back?” he asks.
“Exhausting,” you say. “But it’s much better now.”
Eddie groans and the sound should worry you, but it sends heat running south in your body instead.
“You talk all sweet like that and I’m gonna miss you even more,” he says.
Your socked feet tap up and down on the floor in glee and you wrap your arm around your knees.
“Harder to miss me if you’re talking to me,” you say.
“I’m closing my eyes and pretending you’re here next to me.”
“Eddie,” you say with a dreamy sigh. “You’re going to be the death of me.”
“Me? Be the death of you?” He sounds exasperated by the very idea.
“I said what I said.”
Eddie laughs and it solidifies itself as your official favorite sound in the world.
“Do I sound too desperate if I say I want to call you every night?” Eddie asks.
“No more desperate than me,” you say. “But you should go out and have fun with your friends, too.”
“Yeah, I s’pose the Hellfire guys would be kind of pissed if I just stopped showing up,” he says.
“Mhmm,” you hum. “As much as I want to steal you, I don’t think that’d be very fair.”
“Oh princess, you have my full permission to steal me anytime you want to.”
The nickname quickens your heart rate and a buzz tingles down your limbs.
The doorknob to your room turns and you must let out a groan because Eddie asks you what’s wrong.
“Bitch incoming,” you whisper just before the door opens.
Shelby strolls in and gives you a dirty look for sitting on the floor. You choose to ignore her and close your eyes to focus on your conversation.
“Tell her I said she better be nice to you,” Eddie says.
“I don’t think that would work,” you answer.
“Have Nancy kick her ass.”
You laugh and rest your forehead down on your knees.
“She’s tiny but she definitely could,” you say.
“I have homework to do,” Shelby says as she slams a textbook down on her desk.
Eddie must be able to hear her because he scoffs in your ear.
“What crawled up her ass and died?” he asks.
“I can think of a lot of things,” you mumble, and it makes him laugh.
“I don’t want to cause any problems,” Eddie says. “How about I call you tomorrow night, hmm? I get off work at six - uh, that’s seven there. So, I’ll call when I get home?”
“Promise?” you ask.
“Cross my heart, gorgeous.”
“Okay,” you say. “I guess I’ll talk to you then.”
“Bye, sweetheart.”
“Bye, Eddie.”
During the next phone call, you make sure to get Eddie’s number so the burden doesn’t always fall on him to call. But no matter who is calling who, you manage to talk to each other at least four days a week. It’s usually more, but sometimes it’s not as often as you’d both like because Eddie has Hellfire or you have a meeting with your baking club, which Nancy had encouraged you to join earlier in the semester. You’d always enjoyed baking, but never got a chance to properly try it out, but with her encouragement, you signed up.
A week to go before Christmas break, Shelby has thankfully gone to spend the night with her boyfriend again, so you have the room to yourself the whole night to talk with Eddie. There hasn’t been a Friday night you’ve both been able to stay up late together since Eddie’s had to work Saturday mornings the last few weeks. Most students from your floor were out at bars, clubs, or somewhere else you wouldn’t want to be caught dead at, but you knew for a fact that Nancy was in the same position as you - curled up in your bed, wearing your comfiest clothes - and talking to her boyfriend at the other end of the hall.
“Okay,” Eddie says once you’ve been on the phone for a little over two hours. “There’s something I want to ask you.”
“Alright,” you say, tugging your blanket up to your chin in the cool dorm. “What’s up?”
“Well,” Eddie starts. There’s a hitch in his voice and you realize this is the first time you’ve heard him sound a little nervous. “You can totally say no. I don’t want you to think I’m pressuring you or trying to make you feel like you have to, o-or…”
“Eddie,” you cut him off with a laugh. “What is it?”
He takes a deep breath and your tummy buzzes in anticipation.
“I was wondering if you’d want to come visit for Christmas, maybe?” His voice kept getting higher the further along in the question he got.
“Oh, Eddie, I’d love to,” you say. The smile on your face is so wide it’s hurting your cheeks. “But I don’t want to just assume I’m welcome back at Nancy’s house.”
“Oh, no, no!” Eddie says. “I meant like…do you want to come stay with me?”
The breath catches in your chest and your mouth freezes, unable to form words. Somehow, the breath dislodges itself and you huff what sounds like between a sigh and a laugh.
“You want me to come stay with you?” you ask.
“I sure do.” He says it with such confidence that it makes your eyes water. “Wayne wants to meet you real bad. He said he’s heard enough about you that he feels like he knows you already.”
“Aww, do you talk about me?” you can’t help but tease him despite the strong stinging blush on your cheeks.
“Every chance I get,” Eddie says.
“You really are the sweetest,” you say with a content sigh.
“Does that mean you’ll come?” he asks, voice hiking up in hopefulness.
“Well, I have to go home to see my niece, but I’m seeing her next week,” you say.
“You’re leaving on Friday, right?” Eddie double checks. “Right after your last exam?”
“I am,” you say. Your eyes scan around your dorm room, half packed up with things you’re taking back with you to New Hampshire next week. “And I’m seeing my sister and niece on Tuesday and Wednesday. But after that? If you really want me to, I’d love to come for Christmas.”
“Oh, thank God,” Eddie lets out in a rush. “Because I miss you so much.”
You grin to yourself and curl up on your side.
“I miss you too,” you tell him quietly.
“Yeah?” Eddie asks, and there’s an edge to his voice that sends a shiver up your spine.
“Yeah,” you say, voice going lower.
“Mmm,” Eddie hums and your thighs clench together at the sound. “How much?”
“So much,” you tell him as you roll onto your back. “So much it hurts.”
“Hurts where, baby?” The pitch of his voice lowering makes you bite your lip and slide a hand down your chest. God, you hope this is going where you think it’s going.
“My heart,” you start off. “And…other places.”
Eddie’s groan gives you the last hint of motivation you need to slip your hand down your sweatpants.
“What places, baby?”
The nickname has you slipping your hand into your panties as well.
“Gonna make me say it?” you ask, breath becoming labored. There’s material rustling on the other end of the phone and the thought of Eddie in the same position as you has you arching your back.
“Mhmm,” Eddie hums, his own breaths coming quicker. “Wanna hear you.”
“Fuck,” you moan out softly as you start to slide your fingers through your folds. You’d touched yourself countless times since coming home from Indiana, but never while talking to Eddie.
“What’re you doing, sweetheart?” Eddie asks. His voice is rough and ragged, and it only makes you wetter.
“Got my hand down my panties,” you tell him, cheeks burning at the admission.
He lets out a moan as your middle finger rubs right over your clit, the combination leading you to moan out as well.
“What’re y-you doing?” you ask once you’ve slightly recovered.
“Dick in my hand,” Eddie stutters out.
“Wish I was there to see,” you tell him, and he chokes on a laugh.
“Fuck, me too, baby,” he says. “What else would you do if you were here?”
The nastiest thoughts flash through your mind and, surprisingly, you don’t feel the need to hide them from Eddie. He makes you feel at ease, even stepping out of your comfort zone like this.
“Shit, I’d lick you from base to tip.” The small noises coming from the back of Eddie’s throat encourage you. “I’m not sure how good of a gag reflex I have but I’d let you test that out on me as much as you’d like. Over and over. And I’d swallow every last drop you gave me. Fuck, bet you have a pretty dick.”
“Not as pretty as your pussy must be, baby,” he answers.
You bite your lip and let out a whimper. The sound of Eddie’s slick hand working over himself comes through the phone and you slip a finger inside of yourself.
“Bet you taste fucking perfect, too,” Eddie adds, and your hips canter off the mattress.
“What would you do if I was there?” you ask. “Taste me?”
“Oh, fuck, yes. Shit, I’d devour you like you were my last meal. How would you want me to touch you, baby? Tell me.”
“Everywhere,” you whine out with a pathetic moan. “I want your hands all over my body. Maybe squeeze at my tits as you go down on me. Would you like that?”
The growl you get in response tells you that he would.
“Hell yes, baby. Shit. Bet you’re so tight. First, so tight around my tongue and fingers. Then my cock. Squeezing me so well. Like a good fucking girl.”
“God, you’re killing me,” you say with a breathy laugh, working your middle finger in and out of your pussy.
“Feeling’s mutual, princess,” Eddie groans out. “Rub your clit for me, baby?”
You don’t need to be told twice. You slip your finger out of your drenched core and run it over your clit, applying the perfect pressure as you rub back and forth.
“I-I am,” you whimper.
The sounds of Eddie’s heavy breaths and fist gliding over his cock keep you company as you work yourself closer to the edge. Sweat is making your sweatshirt stick to your stomach and rub against your sensitive nipples, but you can’t bring yourself to take your other hand off the phone to take it off. Eddie’s sounds are addicting, and you don’t want to miss a second of them.
“Fuck, baby, I’m so close,” Eddie whines.
“Yeah?”
“Uh huh,” he says. “Was half hard the moment I heard your voice.”
His words make you moan and rub tighter circles over your throbbing clit.
“Eddie,” you whine.
“Gonna make me cum even faster, gorgeous,” he says.
“Do it,” you sigh out. “Want to cum with you.”
“Close, princess?”
“Uh huh.”
“Come on, baby,” Eddie says. “Fuck, can’t wait to do this in person.”
“Shit, Eddie,” you cry out at his words. “M’gonna cum.”
“Let go, sweetheart,” he moans.
You cry out as your back arches off the bed, orgasm overtaking you. Eddie’s groan and whimper from the other end of the phone lets you know he’s cumming too, and the image has you rubbing your clit even quicker to milk your orgasm out.
Breaths coming out in heavy pants, your body collapses back against the bed. You giggle to yourself when you hear Eddie breathing the same way that you are.
“Still with me?” you ask.
“Yeah,” Eddie says between breaths. “Fuck, that was good.”
“Oh yeah,” you agree. Using the back of your wrist, you wipe some sweat off your forehead as you cuddle back against your pillow. “Now, what was that about doing this in person?”
“Huh?” Eddie asks, breath and voice slowly returning to normal. “Shit, I didn’t mean to-.”
“Eddie!” You laugh as he starts to ramble. “I was going to say I was looking forward to it.”
“Oh.” Relief is evident in his voice. He lets out an awkward chuckle and you can hear fabric rustling from his end. You imagine him tucking himself back in his pants and you lick over your lips. “Well, I mean, we don’t have a guest room. So, if you’re gonna be staying here you’ve only got the one option.”
You can practically hear the smirk in his voice, and you close your eyes to picture it. His hair is probably all messy over his pillow with sweat making a few pieces stick to his forehead.
“Slumber party, huh?”
“Only if you want, baby,” Eddie says. “I wouldn’t force you to do anything.”
“I know that,” you assure him. “I guess I should tell you something, though.”
“Anything, sweetheart. You know that.”
After what the two of you just did together you should not be feeling nervous with him. But you can’t help it as your thumb comes up to your mouth and you gnash your teeth against the corner of your nail.
“What we just did is the farthest I’ve ever gone,” you tell him. “I’m a virgin, Eddie.”
“Oh, is that all?” Eddie says and you feel your heart relax.
“I didn’t think you’d care,” you get out in a rush. “Just can be a weird topic to talk about.”
“That’s true,” Eddie says. “So, it’s good you brought it up, because now I can tell you that I’m a virgin too.”
“Really?” you say before thinking better of it. You squeeze your eyes closed because you can’t imagine how that must’ve sounded. “I-I just mean I’m surprised because you’re like…ridiculously hot. And I have a hard time believing girls wouldn’t throw themselves at you. Especially at your shows.”
Eddie laughs and it’s both genuine and self-deprecating.
“You flatter me, baby,” he says. “But our shows usually consisted of an audience of half a dozen barflies until I met Nancy and the crew.”
“No groupies?” you ask.
“Not a one.”
“Well,” you say with a shrug, even though Eddie can’t see you. “I’d be happy to be a Corroded Coffin groupie.”
“Is that so?” he muses.
“Please, sir?” You bite your lip at the blush clinging to your face as you utter the words.
“Fuck,” Eddie groans and it turns into a chuckle. “You say shit like that we’re going to have to go another round.”
“Isn’t my job as a groupie to tease you?” The innocent tone of your voice isn’t lost on you nor Eddie.
“You’re really good at it already.”
Giggling, you sit up in your bed and hug your knees to your chest.
“Not to change the subject, but I’m going to before I get distracted too,” you say. “If I’m going to be there for Christmas, I’m going to have to get on buying a present for my secret Santa. Think you could give me a few ideas?”
“Sure thing, princess,” Eddie says. “Who’d you get?”
“Max,” you tell him.
“Oh, Red’s pretty easy. She likes comics, especially Wonder Woman. She skateboards. Uh, what else? Big Kate Bush fan.”
“What about clothes?” you ask. “Jewelry?”
“Shit, I wouldn’t be able to help you out with those. She doesn’t really wear jewelry and I couldn’t even tell you what kind of clothes she wears, really. Never paid attention.”
“Hmm, okay,” you hum as you slip your feet further under your blankets. “I’ll keep all that in mind. Now, who’d you get?”
“Robin,” Eddie says with a sigh. “I have no clue what to get her.”
“If you’re still stuck when I get there, we could always go shopping together?”
“I am the worst shopper in the history of the world,” Eddie groans. “I’d love to have you with me. I’ll hold your hand and buy you hot chocolate.”
You duck your head with a bashful laugh.
“Sold.”
Finals week was always hell, but you had to admit, the thought of seeing Eddie soon helped ease the pain a bit. You and Nancy spent most evenings held up in whoever’s room was free of its roommate, pouring over notes, shuffling flash cards, and quizzing each other back and forth. It pays off, the both of you feeling pretty confident once all tests are said and done.
Nancy gives you a hug and tells you she’ll see you in a week before she catches her ride to the airport. Unfortunately, Shelby wasn’t leaving for break until the day after you, so you were forced to share the room until you’re able to get in your car and go.
Once you do though, you realize it wasn’t really anything to look forward to. You’d either be arriving at an empty apartment, or one where your mother was. You’re not sure which is worse. Just as you’re about to pull your car onto the highway and out of Boston though, a store catches your eye, and you make a U-turn to get a closer look.
You park your car and smile to yourself as you see the custom skateboards on display in the windows. Inside the store, the boards are even nicer. The decks are all hand painted, the clerk tells you, and you’re amazed at the talent as you take in all the vibrant and beautiful works. One in particular catches your eye and you know you’ve found the right present.
The apartment is silent when you arrive home. The only noises are from the surrounding tenant’s homes. There’s Christmas music playing somewhere a few doors down and someone on the floor above you has their shower running. The smell of stale air wafts through the rooms and you wonder when the last time your mom cracked a window was.
You drag your suitcase to your small room in the corner of the apartment and flop down on your twin-sized bed. It smells just as stale as the air, so you get up and decide to throw your blankets and some clothes from your closet into the laundry.
It’s well after dark when your mom arrives home, and if you were expecting to be greeted with excitement, you were wrong. Luckily, experience had taught you not to hold your breath on that. A hug hello, some vague questions about school, then she’s off to bed. Not that you mind at all. In fact, you decide to get comfortable in your bed of clean sheets and try to get some sleep yourself. Burying your face in your pillow, you inhale the clean scent of the detergent you used. It’s a nice smell, but it gives you an even better idea. You roll onto your back and smile to yourself as you stare up at the ceiling. Eddie may not be your boyfriend, but you doubt he’d care if you borrowed a t-shirt or sweatshirt to bring back with you when school starts again. The thought of having something you could hold in your dorm bed that belongs to Eddie, his scent all over it, makes you giddy, and you let out a short giggle into the dark room.
The day you get to spend with your niece is by far the best day you have at home in New Hampshire. She’s the sweetest seven-year-old you’ve ever met in your life and the fact that she adores you warms your heart. Chloe is by far your favorite relative, even though that wasn’t a very high bar to begin with. The princess dress you gave her lit up her face in a way that brought tears to your eyes. Her hug was bone-crushing for such a small child, and you took advantage of every second of it. The only reason you don’t cry as you say goodbye to her and your sister is because you know you’re seeing Eddie very soon.
“What are you doing for Christmas?” Chloe had asked you as you tossed your bag into your car. You sat down sideways in the driver’s seat and pulled her over to hold her tiny hands in your own.
“I’m going to see a friend for Christmas,” you told her.
“Who?”
“His name is Eddie.”
“Is he your boyfriend?” Her face wrinkled up in an adorable and excited seven-year-old fashion. It made you laugh, and you pressed a kiss to her cheek.
“Maybe.” He wasn’t technically, but you weren’t about to explain the complexities to her. Plus, after your upcoming trip, he might be.
The escalator leading down to the baggage claim level in the Indianapolis airport moves far too slowly for your liking. Everyone else seems content with the pace, but you’re practically buzzing with nervous energy. The family in front of you can’t move fast enough out of your way as they step off, leaving you irritated as you try to navigate your way around them. You manage to get clear of the crowd without smacking anyone with your backpack and make your way over to where Eddie will be waiting.
“Excuse me, miss,” you hear from behind you. “But I can’t help but notice how devastatingly gorgeous you are.” The smile on your face as you turn around at the familiar voice is so wide it feels like it’s going to fall off your face. “Do you think I could interest you in spending Christmas with me?”
Eddie’s grin matches your own and you fling yourself in his arms. He catches you with a joyful laugh, managing to slip his hands under your backpack so he can lift you up. A squeal leaves your lips as you wrap your legs around his adorably tiny waist, and the two of you squeeze one another so hard you’re surprised you don’t meld into one body.
“I missed you so much,” Eddie mumbles into your hair.
“I missed you, too,” you say. You pull back to look at him, infectious grin still on his face as he holds you. Taking his face between your hands, you press a firm kiss on his lips. He chuckles against your mouth, and you press a few more quick pecks to his lips before you unwrap your legs from his body. He sets you down and you bounce up and down on the balls of your feet.
“How are you even more beautiful than I remember?” Eddie asks as he tucks a loose strand of hair behind your ear.
“I guess the same way that you’re even more handsome than I remember,” you answer.
Eddie rests his forehead against yours and gives your lips one more peck. He slips his hand into yours and you lace your fingers together.
“Let's go get your bag,” Eddie says.
Gentlemanly as ever, Eddie carries your bags to his van and loads them in the back. Before he lets you get in though, he takes advantage of the empty parking garage around you and gently presses you up against the passenger door. The devilish smirk he sends you makes your tummy buzz and your toes curl in your boots. He leans in and presses his lips against yours in a searing kiss, knocking the breath from your lungs. Your arms come up to wind around his neck, fingers coming up to tangle in the hair at the base of his neck. His tongue licks across your top lip and you gladly open them to him. The van is cold against your back, but Eddie’s warming you up plenty. His hands rest on your hips, thumbs rubbing up against the soft material of your coat. You never knew a gray concrete parking garage could be so romantic.
On the ride to Eddie’s, neither of you shuts up. If someone had told you that you’d meet someone who you would talk to on the phone for hours at a time multiple days a week, but still find things to talk about all the time, you wouldn’t have believed them. But there were never silences, let alone awkward ones, with Eddie. As you got closer to his place you actually had a twenty-minute conversation about the shoes Eddie was wearing.
“Shit, I forgot to ask you,” Eddie says, suddenly seeming a little nervous. “Nancy and Steve want to have lunch with us tomorrow afternoon. That okay with you?”
“Of course,” you tell him. He doesn’t seem relaxed by your answer, so you reach over and put your hand on his shoulder. “You okay?”
“Yeah,” Eddie says with a nod, but you’re not convinced.
“What, are you nervous to go on a double date?” you ask with a chuckle.
He smiles over at you and reaches up to grab the hand you placed on him. He gives it a squeeze before putting it back on the wheel.
“Never nervous to spend time with you, baby. Oh, I should tell you,” Eddie says as you drive past the sign welcoming you to Hawkins. “Wayne took the night off from work tonight. He wants to have dinner with you, it being your first day here and all.”
“Aw, that’s so sweet,” you say, smiling over at him.
“It’ll probably be pizza, nothing fancy,” Eddie says with a shrug.
“Pizza is better than fancy every time, Eddie. Duh,” you say. “I’m kind of nervous to meet your uncle though, to be honest.”
Eddie lets out a laugh and shakes his head.
“Nervous to meet Wayne? Oh sweetheart, trust me, nothing to be nervous about. He likes to act like a hardass with me, but he’s a teddy bear deep down.”
“Okay,” you say, and take a deep breath.
Eddie’s quiet for a moment before he speaks again.
“It does mean though…” he trails off and you look at him in concern.
“What? What’s wrong?” you ask.
“I mean, with Wayne there I don’t really think we should, ya know-.”
You cut him off with a laugh and shake your head.
“Eddie, baby,” you say, and you notice him flush at the nickname. “I’m going to be here for a while. We have plenty of time for all that fun stuff. A lot of it.”
Eddie groans and gently bangs his head against his headrest.
“Fuck, you’re killing me,” he says through a chuckle.
“Oh yeah?” Your voice hikes up at the end and Eddie clocks the way you adjust your crossed legs, thighs squeezing closer together.
“Been half hard since I saw you,” he admits, cheeks turning even darker.
“I mean, I could help you with that,” you say, cheeks flaming red yourself.
“Sweetheart, you don’t have to do that.”
“I want to.” You blush even redder at how quickly you replied. “You’ll need to tell me what to do, though. Like, h-how you like it. I’ve never done this before.”
“Shit, baby,” Eddie says, and you squeeze your legs together even tighter at the endearment. “I doubt you could do anything I wouldn’t like. But yeah, I’ll talk you through it.”
Eddie pulls the van up to a red light and you unbuckle your seatbelt and lean over closer to him. Your hand goes to reach for his zipper when the van is jerked from behind. Eddie immediately reaches out to grab you since you’re not wearing your seatbelt, and he curses under his breath as the vehicle gently rocks back and forth from the hit.
“Someone hit the van?” You’re almost positive that’s what happened, but your head was a bit dazed from thoughts of what you were about to do.
“Yeah,” Eddie says as he puts the van in park. “Are you okay?”
“I’m fine,” you say as you get back in your seat. “Are you?”
“Fine. Just pissed.” Eddie sighs before he opens the driver’s door. “I’ll be right back. You stay nice and warm in here, princess.”
Eddie slams the door behind him and after a few moments you hear him yell, “Oh, you’ve got to be fucking kidding me.”
You open the passenger side door and hop out, closing it behind you and heading to the back of the van to see what was wrong. You’re expecting horrible damage, injured people, or Eddie getting ready to kick someone’s ass. But what you see makes you laugh, and you cover your mouth with your hand to stifle the sound.
The curly-haired boy you met last month, Dustin, is getting out of the car behind the van, a grimace on his face, looking paler than you remember. An older man gets out of the passenger side with a clipboard and your eyes trail to the top of the car where there’s a red sign that says, “Student Driver.”
“Shit, Eddie,” Dustin says. “I’m so sorry. I got excited when I saw your van and then I forgot which pedal was which and I just…oh!”
Dustin sees you and grins. You chuckle and send him a small wave, but Eddie is still glaring at him.
“Are you okay?” the driving instructor asks.
“Fine,” Eddie says, eyes not leaving Dustin. The boy shrinks under his gaze.
“Are you okay, Dustin?” you ask.
“I’m fine.”
“For now,” Eddie growls out.
You inspect the back of the van, but you don’t see a single scratch. Dustin’s lucky. Whoever pays his bills is lucky too because you doubt the driving school would have taken any damage lightly.
“Should we call the police?” the instructor asks but Eddie waves him off.
“It’s fine,” Eddie says. He puts his hands on his hips and sighs. You walk over to him and put your hand on his back, rubbing gently, and it seems to calm him.
“I’m so sorry,” Dustin says but Eddie shakes his head at the boy.
“He’ll forgive you,” you assure Dustin. “He’s just a little worked up.”
How you manage not to smirk at your double entendre, you don’t know. Eddie huffs out a chuckle though and nods his head.
“Everyone’s okay,” Eddie says with a shrug. “Plus, I know you’ll make it up to me, Henderson.”
“How?” Dustin asks.
“That’s up to you,” Eddie calls to him as he turns back towards the van, slinging his arm over your shoulders. You giggle and bury your head in Eddie’s neck as he walks you back to your door.
“Bye, Dustin!” you shout as Eddie opens the passenger door for you.
The echo of Dustin’s responding goodbye is cut off when Eddie shuts the door. He climbs in the driver’s side and lets out a mixture of a groan and a sigh as he puts the car in drive.
“I love him,” you tell Eddie as he continues down the road.
“He’s a pain in the ass,” Eddie says, but there’s a fond smile on his face.
There’s a sign that comes into view that announces Forest Hills trailer park is half a mile up the road. Despite Eddie’s reassurance earlier, you start to feel the knot of anxiety in your stomach again. The only family in Eddie’s life is Wayne, so what would happen if he didn’t like you? A large hand comes over to cover yours and you realize you have been fidgeting with your fingers in your lap. Eddie’s thumb rubs over your hand and you shoot him a grateful smile.
Eddie pulls the van into the trailer park, and you look around, taking in his neighborhood.
“It’s a trailer park,” Eddie says with a chuckle. “Not much to look at.”
“This is where you live. What you see every day,” you say. “I’m interested.”
He smiles to himself as you crane your neck to take in everything. Eddie isn’t sure he’s ever had someone interested in his life like this before. Certainly there wasn’t anyone who was ever nervous about meeting his uncle. The thought of someone being nervous to meet Wayne was truly hilarious to him.
The van parks in front of the trailer and Eddie’s stomach drops as he sees you frown at the small dwelling. You’d known all along he lives in a trailer, but is it even worse than you imagined? Is it too small? Too dirty? Eddie licks over his lips and runs his hands over the steering wheel just to do something with his nervous energy.
“You don’t have any Christmas lights up,” you say, turning to face him.
Eddie’s shoulders sag in relief and a smile comes to his face.
“I guess we don’t,” he says. “I don’t think we own any, actually.”
He lets out a laugh at your affronted face and leans over to press a kiss to your cheek.
“You’re so cute,” he says.
“Don’t try to sweet talk your way out of decorations, mister.” But you can’t help but smile at his actions.
“How about we go to the store tomorrow? You can pick out what you think looks best.”
“Wait. Are you telling me you don’t have decorations inside either?”
“We do not.”
“What about a tree?”
Eddie grimaces and your jaw drops open.
“Eddie! No tree?”
“Okay, I was planning on getting one,” he says, holding his hands up in defense. “Just haven’t yet. I usually pick up whatever’s left on the lot a few days before Christmas.”
“So, a Charlie Brown Christmas tree?” you ask.
“Pretty much,” he says. “Now come on. Let’s get inside where I can show you my room.”
You laugh as Eddie wiggles his eyebrows at you. He throws you a wink before he hops out and opens the back door to get your bags. Following him over to the steps, you rub your hands up and down your arms, partially out of coldness and partially out of nerves. Since his hands are full, you reach around and turn the doorknob for him, and he knocks the door all the way open with his hip. Eddie sets your bags down just inside the door and takes your hand in his as you step inside. He closes the door behind you as you look around the living room, taking in the mugs and hats that make up the decor.
“My favorite mug is the Garfield one,” you tell Eddie.
“Got that when I was six,” he says. He lets go of your hand to wrap both of his arms around you from behind. He rests his chin on your shoulder and you lean back in his embrace.
“I bet you were an adorable six-year-old,” you say.
“I looked like little orphan Annie with the curls and all.”
You laugh but it dies in your throat as you hear footsteps coming down the hallway.
“Relax,” Eddie whispers in your ear, giving your waist a squeeze before stepping out from behind you.
A weathered but friendly looking man steps into the living room and the smile he gives you reminds you of Eddie’s. His blue and black flannel makes you wonder if he and Eddie ever steal each other's clothes.
“Well, you must be the young lady I’ve heard so much about.”
Both you and Eddie blush at his words.
“I guess that’s me,” you say with a shrug. “It’s nice to meet you, sir.”
“Oh, please doll, no need to be so formal. Wayne is fine. It’s great to meet you too, though.” He steps forward and offers you his hand, which you shake gladly. Eddie wraps an arm around your waist and Wayne turns his gaze on his nephew.
“What took you so long, boy?”
“Had a little fender bender,” Eddie admits with a sigh. Wayne reaches over and smacks Eddie upside the head, making you cough out a laugh. “Ow, what the hell?”
“Her first day here and you’re already getting in a car accident?”
“It wasn’t my fault!” Eddie protests.
Wayne huffs and crosses his arms across his chest.
“My apologies then.” He turns to you and leans in conspiratorially. “Boy had to take his driving test three times.”
“Okay, thank you Wayne,” Eddie says, stomping down the hallway, dragging a giggling you behind him. He tugs you into a bedroom at the end of the hall and it’s instantly recognizable as his room.
You let his hand drop from yours as you walk around, taking in the small space.
“Believe it or not, I cleaned up,” Eddie says, scratching the back of his head.
“I believe you,” you say, shooting him a playful smirk that makes him roll his eyes. You stroll over to the Corroded Coffin banner hanging on the wall and Eddie sidles up beside you.
“I want to see your band play,” you say.
“We haven’t played together since Jeff went off to college.” Eddie tugs you against his side and presses a kiss into your hair. You lay your head on his shoulder with a smile, giddy that he keeps his hands on your every chance he gets.
“Is he home for Christmas?” you ask.
He pulls back and looks at you, a grin sliding on his face.
“He is. You’re a genius.” He presses another kiss to your head and your cheeks heat up at this one. “Maybe the guys will want a little reunion.”
“Will you play this?” you ask, nodding to the guitar hanging adjacent to where you’re standing.
“Sure will. She’s my sweetheart.” Your eyebrows pull together in a frown and Eddie coos at you. “Aw, baby. She’s my first sweetheart. You’re my number one sweetheart.”
When you keep frowning Eddie takes his thumb and runs it over the lines on your face.
“What’s the difference?” you ask.
“Well, I loved her first and I -.” His face turns beet red, and you can’t help the smile that lights up your face.
“And you what, Eddie?” you ask, wrapping your arms around his neck.
“And I, uh.” Eddie coughs, avoiding your eyes. “I have you as my sweetheart now. I mean, um.”
As adorable as his scrambling is, you can’t take how uncomfortable he looks so you raise yourself up on your toes and press a kiss to his lips. Eddie sighs in relief against your lips and rests his hands on your hips.
“You’re cute when you ramble,” you mumble against his mouth.
“M’glad,” he mumbles back. “You’re cute all the time.”
The doorbell rings and Eddie rests his forehead against yours.
“That’ll be the pizza,” he says. “On the one hand, I’m hungry. On the other hand, I want our mouths to be busy with different things.”
A flush comes up your body as you pull away from him.
“Eat first, lots of kissing later,” you tell him.
Dinner with Wayne and Eddie is nice, and you’re surprised at how funny Wayne is. He tells stories from his younger days, even making Eddie laugh as well, though he’s probably heard these stories so many times he could tell them himself.
“So,” Wayne says as he wipes his hands off on a napkin. “Eddie tells me you go to college with the Wheeler girl?”
“I do,” you affirm. “Emerson College. I love it, but Boston is very cold right now.”
“I don’t know how much better it is here,” Eddie says, leaning to look out the window, checking for any signs of snow.
“What’re you studying?” Wayne asks.
“Psychology.”
“So, is my nephew your first patient?”
You break out into a fit of giggles and Eddie’s dropped jaw and affronted face makes you laugh even harder. Wayne lets out his own chuckle and shrugs his shoulders.
“I’ve never gotten to embarrass Eddie in front of a girl before. I’m taking full advantage of this,” Wayne says.
“Aww, Eddie,” you coo, while still laughing, and rest your head on his shoulder.
“I’m going across the street to have dinner with Max,” Eddie says, even as he reaches for another slice of pizza.
“Max lives here?” you ask with a smile.
“Sure does. She’s a good kid,” Wayne says. “Bit of a mouth on her, but she’s a good kid.”
“I’ll have to say hi when you’re at work one day.” You pout up at Eddie, jutting your lower lip out.
“I got a few days off though,” Eddie says, slipping an arm around you as he shoves the pizza into his mouth. “I’ll only be coming back smelling like oil and gasoline a few days.”
“Y’all have any plans while you’re here?” Wayne asks.
“Well, I promised we’d get some decorations to make this place look more festive,” Eddie says. “Getting a tree, of course. Anything else you want to do while you’re here?”
“Nothing specific,” you say with a shrug. “Told Nancy I’d see her, of course.”
“Indiana sure ain’t known for being a tourist destination,” Wayne says.
“But I’m here,” Eddie says with a playful smirk. You know he’s joking, but he’s also right.
“Well, I wouldn’t spend Christmas with just anyone,” you say.
“And we’re glad to have you,” Wayne says.
“Very,” Eddie adds, pressing a kiss to the top of your head.
Out of all the films that made up Eddie and Wayne’s small collection, not one was a Christmas movie. Luckily, Frosty the Snowman is on television, followed by How the Grinch Stole Christmas. Wayne reclines in his chair, and you curl up next to Eddie on the couch to watch the animated programs. Eddie’s arm is wrapped snugly around you the whole time, and he pays more attention to the fact that he’s holding you than he does to the storylines.
As you’re getting ready for bed in the small bathroom, your tummy erupts in an excited sort of nerves at the fact that you’re sharing a bed with Eddie. A rather small bed, too. Part of you is glad it's winter and you’re wearing warm plaid pajama pants and an oversized Boston Bruins t-shirt, because you know you would’ve put pressure on yourself to wear more suggestive items to bed if it were warmer.
You open the bathroom door, and your socked feet pad down the hall to Eddie’s room, where he’s already lounging, one arm up over his head and the other resting on his stomach. His own plaid pajamas bottoms - black, instead of the pink ones on your bottom half - sitting low on his hips and his gray faded Dio shirt making him look hotter than he had any right to be. He smiles when you walk in and lifts his hips up so he can pull down the blankets for the both of you. There’s a pleasant buzzing sensation in your limbs as you slip into the bed next to him. He automatically wraps his arms around you, and you cuddle into his chest.
“You’re warm,” you mumble against his shirt.
“You’re hot,” he says, and you break into a giggle, burying your face in his neck.
You tilt your head up and press a kiss to the underside of Eddie’s chin.
“What time are we meeting Steve and Nancy tomorrow?” you ask.
Eddie gets that nervous look about him like he did in the van when he originally told you about the plans.
“They’re going to come here, actually,” he says, running his hand up and down your back. “Bringing food from a diner down the road from Steve that he loves, so prepare for him to bring half the menu.”
“Fine with me.” You run your nose up to behind Eddie’s ear and you feel him shiver under your touch. The echoes from the television drift down the hall and you’re pretty sure it’s the only thing keeping the two of you from jumping one another.
Eddie reaches behind him to flip the light off and curls back into you, resting his forehead against yours.
“Hi,” he whispers.
“Hi, you.”
“I’m really glad you’re here.”
“Me too,” you say. “No one I’d rather spend Christmas with.”
“No?” he asks. “Not even your niece?”
“Eh, that means I’d have to spend it with my sister too, though, so no.”
He chuckles and presses his lips against yours.
“No one I’d rather spend it with either,” he says. “But there is something I want to ask you.”
“What’s that?”
“Well,” he says, and even in the darkness you can tell that his face is getting pink. “I realized that even though we’ve been pretty inseparable since we met, I’ve never even asked you on a date.”
“Eddie,” you giggle his name against his lips. “That is so sweet. But we’ve had phone sex, I came to stay with you for Christmas, and I’m pretty sure we’re losing our virginities to each other real damn soon, so I think we’re a little past that.”
“Okay, fair,” Eddie agrees with a breathy laugh. “What about you being my girlfriend then? Can I ask you about that?”
“You can.” You rub your hands over his chest. “But I’m pretty sure you know what the answer will be.”
“I hope so.” He pecks your lips again. “But I want to ask anyway.”
“Go ahead then.”
“Be my girlfriend? Like, officially?”
“Depends,” you say with a smile. “Will you be my boyfriend?”
He purses his lips and lets out a hum before responding.
“Can I think about it?”
“Fine,” you say with a shrug. You take your hands off him and go to take the covers off of your body. “Yeah, that’s fine. I’ll just go sleep at Nancy’s until you decide.”
He laughs and wraps his arms around your middle as you go to get up.
“No!” he whines and pulls your body back down against his. Back pressed against his chest, he squeezes you in his arms and presses loud smacking kisses against the back of your neck. “I’ve been yours since I first saw you.”
The grin his words bring to your face makes your cheek muscles ache.
“I could say the same,” you tell him.
“Shit, how’d I get so lucky?” he whispers into your hair.
“By being so cute, I guess.”
He hums a chuckle and tucks the blankets up around the two of you.
“We should probably try to sleep,” he says.
“Probably. But I don’t want to.”
“Me neither.”
The sun is almost up by the time you finally fall asleep in his arms. You’re used to hearing his voice right before you sleep from your regular phone calls, but it’s even better having his voice up close and personal right in your ear. Eddie falls asleep soon after you but still wakes up first.
As consciousness comes drifting back to him, he’s aware there’s something warm in his arms. His brow furrows before the apple scent of your shampoo jogs his memory, and a smile comes to his face as he huddles closer to your warmth. His eyes break open and the smile grows as he sees your sleeping face on the pillow next to his. Your face is so peaceful and calm, and it makes his heart stutter at how beautiful you look. He reaches up and softly strokes his thumb over your cheekbone, his eyes taking in every little detail of your face. There were times that Eddie thought he’d never get a girl to even say yes to going on a date with him, yet here he is, not even a month after meeting you, lying next to the girl he’s positive he’s falling in love with. And he finds it even crazier that you seem to feel the same way about him.
You start to move in his arms and Eddie stays still so he doesn’t disturb you. His hand drops down to your hip as you turn on your side and snuggle closer to him. He can’t help but press a gentle kiss on your forehead, lips pulled up in a grin against your skin. A hum leaves your throat and Eddie looks down at you at the noise. You blink your eyes open, lashes fluttering as your eyes adjust from sleep.
“Morning, gorgeous.”
At the sound of Eddie’s voice your head tips up and you meet his gaze. A smile lights up your face and Eddie presses another kiss to your forehead.
“Morning, handsome,” you reply.
“How’d you sleep?” he asks.
“Good,” you say with a dreamy sigh. You nuzzle your head into Eddie’s neck, and he wraps you up in his arms. He knows he should get up and get dressed, but he can’t bring himself to get up. It’s partially because he’s dreading the conversation he knows he needs to have with you. If he wants to have sex with you - and Lord knows he does - that means he’s going to have to take his shirt off. You’re the first person Eddie has met whom he’s positive won’t judge him on how gruesome they look. But that doesn’t mean you won’t ask how he got them.
“How’d you sleep?” you ask him and start peppering kisses up his neck.
“Best I ever have, I think,” he says, eyes fluttering closed. A moan slips out his lips and the vibration from the sound travels down his throat and into your lips. “You keep doing that and we’re never getting out of this bed.”
“That wouldn’t be so bad,” you speak against his skin.
Eddie agrees, but the knot in his stomach is from nerves as opposed to hormones - though there was definitely some of that too. The thought of you seeing his scars without any warning beforehand is the only thing keeping him from stripping the both of you naked in record time.
“Baby,” Eddie says, pulling away from your lips. “We should get up and get ready.”
A whine slips out as you bury your face in Eddie’s chest.
“Don’t wanna,” you say.
“Me neither,” Eddie says as he pushes the blankets off the two of you. “But I don’t want Steve coming in here and seeing you in your sexy pajamas.”
You laugh as you look down at your cozy attire, but your cheeks heat up at his words, nonetheless. Eddie slides out of the bed and tugs the blankets all the way off you. He smirks as his cold hands grab at your ankles and pull you down towards the foot of the bed. A squeal leaves your lips as you squirm, trying to escape his freezing fingers.
“Up, baby, up!”
“I’ll get up if you kiss me,” you offer.
“Ugh, if I have to.” He walks over to your side of the bed and leans down, pressing his lips quickly against yours. “Deals a deal, princess.”
With a huff, you climb out of the warm bed and search through your suitcase for some clothes for the day. Once both you and Eddie get dressed, he leads you into the living room and pulls you into his lap on the couch.
“There’s something I want to tell you,” he says, running one hand up and down your jean clad thigh.
“What’s up?” you ask as you card one of your hands through his hair.
He lets out a sigh and licks over his lips, avoiding your eyes. You frown and press a kiss to the top of his head.
“You can tell me anything, sweetheart,” you tell him.
There are tears in his eyes as he looks up at you, but he gives you a grateful smile.
“Do, um, do you remember the, uh, story Nancy and I told you? About what happened back in March?” He massages his fingers over your thigh, eyes trailing the patterns he’s making.
“Of course.”
“Well, uh, it was all the truth. But there’s even more to it.”
You tilt his chin up so he’s looking you in the eyes.
“Eddie, you can tell me.”
“It’s kind of hard to believe,” he says, hand patting your leg nervously.
“You’ve not lied to me yet,” you say with a shrug.
With a deep breath, Eddie begins to tell you a story that seems like it was ripped from one of the fantasy novels you love, only much more sinister. A tear escapes his eye and makes its way down his cheek as he recalls his near-death experience with the otherworldly creatures.
“And there were these bats—we called them ‘demobats,’ because of the demogorgon,” he explains, anxiously tapping his fingers along your leg. “I tried to fight them off, tried to buy more time, but they…they got me. Pinned me to the ground and tore out chunks of my skin. Hurt like fuckin’ hell.” He gnaws on his lower lip. “I would’ve been dead if Harrington and Henderson didn’t drag me outta there. Sometimes…sometimes, I wonder if I would’ve been better off dead.”
The last line is what breaks your heart most of all. Tears were already raining down your face, but at this last admission, you throw your arms around Eddie’s neck and squeeze him so tightly that it has to be uncomfortable for him.
“No,” you gasp against his neck. “No, don’t ever say that.”
You feel the emotion get the better of him as his body starts to shake, his own breath hitching as he begins crying in earnest. He clings to you and the pads of his fingers dig into your back as he buries his face in your neck. The two of you cry together, you try to soothe Eddie by rubbing his back and pressing kisses into his hair while doing so.
“You’re safe now, Eddie,” you whisper to him once your own crying has subsided for the most part. “I’ve got you.”
He nods in recognition of your words, but his tears don’t cease. You just keep holding him, willing to never move from his lap again if it meant you could give him even an ounce of comfort. After a few long minutes, you feel his body relax under your touch. He pulls his head away from your neck and you pull back as well so you can see his face. It’s red and splotchy, his eyes are swollen, and traces of snot are on the end of his nose. He’s still the most beautiful man you’ve seen in your life. Moving slowly, not wanting to scare him or to give him time to pull away if he wants, you lean in and gently press your lips to his. Your hands come to cup his face as you pull away, looking at him through your own teary eyes.
“Eddie, wow.” You shake your head, not even sure where to begin. “Sweetheart,” you say, tilting his head to make sure he’s looking you in the eyes as you say this. “You’re a hero.”
He immediately shakes his head, and it hurts your heart.
“You are,” you insist. “You didn’t have to go back in like you did. It seems you were specifically told not to. But you did because you wanted to help. To give them the best chance. Even if it meant something terrible at your own expense.”
Eddie looks up at you under his thick lashes, big brown eyes even more childlike while shiny from tears.
“Sounds like a hero to me, babe,” you tell him.
He lets out a sigh and rubs the palm of his hand against his eye.
“I didn’t think I’d cry like that,” Eddie admits. “But I’ve also never told the story before, either.”
“What?” You move some hair off his face, stuck there because of the tears. “Not even Wayne.”
Eddie shakes his head.
“I couldn’t do that to him. He was worried enough as it was, I wasn’t about to add to it. He knows plenty, just not every gory detail. But you deserved to know the truth. Because I’m hoping you’ll be around for a while.” It’s the first time you’ve heard him sound shy and unsure of himself. It makes sense his confidence would be a little rattled after telling you that nightmare-come-true.
“I’ll be around as long as you’ll have me,” you assure him. “And Eddie? It really means a lot to me that you’ve trusted me with this. I know it wasn’t easy. And I need you to know I appreciate it.”
He gives you a small smile and you take it as a small victory.
“There’s another reason I wanted to tell you, too,” he says. He’s avoiding your eyes again and it makes the knot in your stomach start tightening again.
“What, baby?” you bring your hand to cup his cheek and press a kiss to the tip of his nose.
“Well, the, uh, attack. It left some…some fucking nasty scars.”
The way his face blushes in embarrassment makes you want to strangle any creature, native to this dimension or not, who ever caused Eddie a bit of harm.
“So, you wanted to tell me before I see you without your shirt on,” you guess.
He nods his head, cheeks still red.
“Eddie, look at me.” When he does, you continue. “It wouldn’t matter to me if you had scars on every square inch of skin on your body. You’re the most beautiful man I’ve ever seen and something as trivial as scars could never change that no matter how hard they tried. I may not have seen your body under your clothes yet, but what I have seen?” You lean in to whisper in his ear. “I love.”
Eddie looks up at you questioningly and you move yourself so you’re straddling his lap. Your hands wind behind his head and you interlock your fingers against the back of his neck.
“Your smile was what I noticed first. It’s so genuine and bright, I almost couldn’t believe it was directed at me when we first met. Then, of course, your amazing hair. It’s far nicer than mine and I’m equal parts jealous and turned on by it. And you know what else drives me crazy? This tiny waist.” You dig your fingers into his sides and Eddie chuckles when it tickles him. “It’s so hot. Really. And I’m not sure if you noticed, but I couldn’t stop staring at your bat tattoos all throughout thanksgiving dinner. It’s the sexiest tattoo I’ve ever seen.”
Eddie’s face is still blushing, but by the smile that’s on his face, you’re optimistic that it’s now for a different reason.
“So, I know for a fact that I’m going to love all the parts of you I haven’t seen bare yet. There’s no scar that’s going to keep me away from you. There’s no wound that’s going to make me not want to have your body pressed up against mine. It’s just not possible.”
Tears begin to well in Eddie’s eyes now, but there’s a light in them that wasn’t there when he was telling his story. His face looks hopeful, but the fact that he thought any of this would change the way you feel about him is absolute ludacris.
“This why Steve and Nancy are coming over?” you ask.
“Yeah,” Eddie admits. “They knew about all the insane shit in this town way before I did. Figured they could answer any questions I couldn’t. And maybe provide proof if you didn’t believe me.”
“I believe you,” you tell him truthfully. “And I also want you to know that you don’t have to show me your scars until you’re ready. I know we talked about having sex but -.”
“No, no, I want to,” Eddie cuts you off. His wide eager eyes make you laugh and lean forward to give him a soft kiss.
“So do I.”
The sound of a car pulling up outside has you and Eddie both looking towards the front door. Wayne had left bright and early this morning, Eddie had told you, meeting up with some old friends who were back in town for the holidays. It made the trailer the perfect place to talk about interdimensional incidents over lunch without prying ears.
There’s a soft set of footsteps that approach the front door, followed by a heavier gate. You slip off your boyfriend’s lap as there’s a gentle knock on the door. A knock you’ve heard on your own dorm door a hundred times before.
“They better be up,” you hear Steve say.
Eddie rolls his eyes as he pushes off the couch. He opens the front door and puts on a fake show of yawning and stretching his muscles out.
“Was I loud?” Steve asks Nancy, to which she responds by rolling her eyes. She steps past the two boys to come inside and give you a hug.
“How was the flight?” she asks.
“Not bad. What about yours?”
“Crying baby, but other than that, can’t complain.”
Eddie helps Steve set all of the food he brought down on the kitchen counter.
“Hey!” Steve calls out to you as he steps around the counter to pull you into a hug. “How are you?”
“I’m good,” you say, squeezing him around his middle.
“I take it from the red eyes, Munson, that the conversation’s already started?” Steve asks.
“My part’s done,” Eddie says with a shrug as he struggles to open a takeout box. He manages to get the lid off and takes a sniff at the food inside. “What is this?”
“Some cornbread thing they said I have to try, I don’t know,” Steve answers.
“Are you…okay?” Nancy asks, clearly not knowing how to ask how you’re feeling about the whole Upside Down thing.
“It’s a bit much,” you admit with a sigh. “A lot to wrap my head around. I mean, I totally believe it, it’s just…”
“A lot to take in?” Steve offers, to which you nod. “I know,” he says. “I walked in on it firsthand. Had a gun pointed to my face, almost wet myself, then came back with a bat full of nails and joined the fight.”
“Who the hell held a gun to your face?” you ask, brow furrowing and Eddie laughs from where he’s going through the food.
Steve shoots a pointed look at his girlfriend, who shrugs and gives you a grimace.
“You almost shot your boyfriend?!” you yell.
“He wasn’t my boyfr- oh. Wait. Yeah, he was my boyfriend then. I guess I did do that. But in my defense, I was trying to make him leave so he didn't get caught up in the whole mess. Clearly, it didn’t work.”
“He takes any excuse to tell a story about his precious bat with the nails, I swear,” Eddie says, coming in from the kitchen with half a turkey sandwich. He holds it up to your lips to offer you a bite, which you take.
“And El really has powers?” you ask.
“We should sit down and eat,” Nancy says, gesturing to the food. “This could take a while.”
Nancy and Steve are able to answer all of your questions so well that even if you had thought this was all some sort of joke, you wouldn’t have any more with all the details they’re giving you. It would take your mind a while to accept this all as a reality, but you know you’re the lucky one because they’ve been through this hell while you’re just trying to imagine it.
“Holy shit,” you say when they’re done. “No wonder you’re all bonded so much. You guys can only talk about this with each other.”
“Yep,” Eddie says. “Also part of why I could never tell you over the phone. But I mean, this is kind of a more in person conversation anyway.”
“Wait, they bug your phone?” you ask.
“They used to,” Nancy says. “Not sure if they still do.”
“I hope not.” Your face blooms red, imagining some government people listening in on your phone sex session with Eddie. Steve catches onto the reason for the color on your face.
“Don’t worry,” he says. “If they are still bugging our phones, nothing you guys said could be any worse than what they’ve already heard from me and Nance.”
Eddie smirks while you turn redder and Nancy hits Steve on the arm.
The couple stay with you and Eddie for a few hours. The conversation moves to lighter topics and after hours of laughter and banter later, it’s almost as if the four of you have forgotten the dark note this visit started out on.
After they leave, with Nancy promising you a shopping trip when Eddie goes back to work in a few days, you feel mentally exhausted. It’s obvious Eddie does as well, so you suggest a good old fashioned snowball fight before it gets too dark out. Eddie accepts the challenge and the two of you dodge each other around the sides of the trailer for over an hour. Slinging scooped and formed bits of snow, cheering when you successfully hit one another, or cursing too loud when you missed. Soon, your bodies feel as tired as your minds, and you head back inside the trailer.
Eddie insists you go through the small movie collection and pick out whatever you want while he heats up some leftovers from lunch and makes two mugs of steaming hot cocoa. You pop in the Carrie VHS and snuggle up with Eddie on the couch. There’s a blanket on the other end of the couch and you reach over for it so you can drape it over you both. As Carrie attends her prom on screen, oblivious to the copious amounts of pig’s blood she’s about to be wearing, Eddie taps on your shoulder and points out the window. Snow is coming down in the evening sky and the sight of it makes you smile. Was there a better way to spend the night? Curled up against your boyfriend’s side with delicious food and hot cocoa, watching a horror movie while there’s snow falling outside.
After Carrie’s hand pops out of the ground at the end, not scaring either of you - even though it definitely did the both of you the first time you saw it - you stretch your legs and roll out your ankles.
“Tired?” Eddie asks.
“Only a little,” you say.
He presses a kiss to the top of your head, and you hum at the feeling of his lips on you.
“Wanna go to bed?” There’s another question in there, but the way his voice deepens as he asks it makes your tummy flip.
“Sure,” you tell him. The blanket falls to the couch as you stand up. Offering a hand to Eddie, you help him up, but he doesn’t let go of your hand all the way to the bedroom. Though you’re the only ones home and will be until sometime the next morning, he still shuts the door behind the two of you.
You turn to face Eddie and see him fidgeting with the hem of his shirt. Walking over to him, you take each of his hands in your own. He squeezes them and you lean up to peck his lips.
“We don’t have to,” you say quietly.
His smile is aiming for a smirk but looks gleeful instead.
“I want to as long as you do.”
“Of course,” you tell him. He takes a deep breath, and you grab the bottom of his shirt in your hands. “Can I?”
Eddie nods, anxiety clear in his eyes as you’re about to see his scarred chest and abdomen. You raise the fabric up slowly, giving him the opportunity to stop you at any point if he wants to. But he doesn’t, he just lifts his arms to help you get it over his head.
When he’s there bare chested before you, your mind holds a few thoughts. First is how absolutely breathtaking he looks. You weren’t lying before; you really do love his adorable tiny waist. There’s something so sexy about it. The second thought is that the scars looked like they were incredibly painful when he was first inflicted with them. It makes you want to take down all the mythical beings that ever thought of laying a hand on your boyfriend. The third thought is of how heartbroken you are that Eddie had to go through all of this and still doesn’t see himself as a hero. His battle scars are right there, pink and white jagged lines that show off his bravery and strength. How Eddie sees anything other than that is beyond you.
“Eddie, you’re so beautiful,” you say, eyes glued to his chest. He’s watching your face carefully, but you can’t tell because your eyes are tracing the patterns the injured skin created. “Can I…can I touch them? Do they hurt?”
“They don’t hurt anymore,” he assures you. “And yeah, you can touch them if you want.”
You waste no time and start to lightly run your fingers over the healed wounds, mapping out Eddie’s chest. It’s obvious where the demobats took the largest bites of his body, and you ghost your fingertips over those areas as well.
“I don’t know why you were afraid to tell me about these,” you say, eyes never straying from the puckered flesh of his body. “They’re beautiful. Every single bit.”
His chest flushes pink at your words and you’re assuming his face does the same. Your hands keep going further down until they rest at his waistband. His belt buckle makes you smile as you try to figure out how to undo the handcuffs.
“This okay?” you ask, looking up at him through your eyelashes as you open one of the cuffs.
“S’perfect, baby,” he whines. Already so needy for you. The thought sends a buzz through your body before finally settling between your legs.
You get the belt buckle undone and he helps you push his pants down past his hips. He steps out of them, kicking them behind him somewhere. Eddie’s fingers ghost over the hem of your t-shirt. He searches your face for approval, and when you nod at him, he slides your shirt up and over your head. You’d worn your nicest bra today because you figured Eddie would be seeing it. It’s black lace, the only one you have matching panties of, which you also wore today. The way Eddie’s eyes trail your torso makes you want to cover yourself. Your arms even flinch to do so, but then you remember how vulnerable Eddie is being by letting you see his scars, and you leave your arms where they are.
“You’re so beautiful,” he whispers in the air between you. The flush on your cheeks spreads down to your chest and it makes Eddie grin like a kid in a candy store. He leans in to whisper in your ear. “Now, whenever I make you blush, I’ll know just how far down it’s going.”
The color on your skin only darkens at his words, and you also feel the effect they have down in your core. As Eddie reaches for the button of your jeans, you reach up and cup his face in your hands. He leans in and kisses you softly as he pops the button open and starts to push the material down. You wiggle your hips to help, but that causes him to groan against your lips. You giggle as you pull back.
“I was just trying to help,” you say.
“And it was sexy,” he says. “Oh, and fuck, so are those.” He looks like he’s in pain as he stares at your black lace panties. You step out of your jeans and move backwards until the backs of your knees hit the bed. Eddie follows eagerly, his mouth chasing yours. Lips connected in a tender kiss, Eddie gently lowers you to the bed. You use your elbows to crawl backwards up towards the pillows while never breaking the kiss. Eddie crawls up along your body, hand softly grazing your skin as he goes. You lay back against the pillow and Eddie rests an elbow on either side of your head. He leans in, tilting his head to kiss you at a new angle as he lowers his body gently down on yours. When you feel his clothed erection through his boxers it makes you shiver, causing Eddie to chuckle against your lips.
“What, baby?” he says softly.
“Feels good.” You take his head in your hands to press your mouths together again. “You should take those off.”
He raises a teasing eyebrow at you.
“Want me to be the first one naked, huh?”
“Mhm,” you hum with a soft giggle.
“As you wish.”
Eddie reaches down and pushes his boxers down, leaving you to gasp and bite your lip as he kicks them off his legs.
“Well, shit, Eddie,” you say. “It’s official. Every part of you is fucking perfect.”
Eddie ducks his head, cheeks red at your comment, and presses kisses against your shoulder. He trails his lips up your neck, one hand bracing him up, and the other running over the smooth skin of your hip. Two fingers slip under the band of your panties on your hip, then he lets the material snap back against your skin with a smack. You let out a whimper and Eddie keeps up his ministrations on your neck, working his way up to your jaw.
“Wanna touch you, Eddie,” you whine.
He hums a laugh against your skin.
“I should warn you, baby,” he says against your jaw. “You touching me is going to throw me over the edge.”
“That’s fine,” you purr in his ear. “Gives me plenty of time to work you up again.”
“Fuck.” Eddie drops his forehead to your shoulder. He knows he isn’t going to last long, and you haven’t even touched him yet.
The feeling of his precum dripping onto your stomach makes you even wetter as your legs brush up against one another underneath Eddie.
“So, can I?” you ask shyly. “Can I touch you?”
“‘Course you can, sweetheart.” His voice is gravelly and stuttering. It’s almost making you dizzy, this effect you’re having on him. It’s a different sort of high you want to chase again and again.
“You’re going to have to tell me what to do, baby. How you like,” you say.
Again, Eddie huffs a laugh against your neck.
“Princess, I don’t even know if we’ll get that far. Just… spit on your hand, yeah? Good, like that.”
You do as you’re instructed and slowly start to reach for his dick. It’s not that you don’t want to touch it - because you really, really do - but your inexperience is making you a little anxious, even though you know Eddie has the same inexperience. But he knows his body and you’ve never even seen a penis in real life until this moment. You know basic biology and anatomy but being in this situation is a whole lot different than doing a homework assignment on the male reproductive system.
“Baby, you’re not going to hurt me,” Eddie assures you. “Shit, I’m worried about doing that to you.”
“Guide me?” you ask in a small voice.
“Of course, sweetheart.” Eddie presses a kiss to your forehead, nose, then lips. He takes the wrist of your slick hand and brings it down to his cock. He wraps your hand right where he wants it and the moan that comes out of him when your fingers touch him is enough to make you cum yourself.
His skin is surprisingly soft as you finally leave the anxiety behind and now focus on the feeling of him in your hand. Eddie’s hand adjusts your grip, and he shows you how he likes to be stroked. He does it once, twice, three times with you, then lets you go so you can do it on your own.
“S’good?” you ask, your eyes glued to your hand working over his dick.
“Mhm. Fuck.” He had been watching your hand work as well but needed to close his eyes because the sight of you touching him was about to bring him over the edge. “Shit babe, I’m sorry, not gonna last.”
“Good, I want to make you cum,” you say.
Eddie grits his teeth, the muscles of his abdomen tighten underneath his scarred skin, and his fist clenches the pillowcase your head is resting on.
“I-I’m cumming. Holy shit, I’m cumming.”
He barely gets the warning out in time before he’s releasing all over your hand. You stroke him through it, keeping the same consistent pace you were doing before. The thought that you’d get lots and lots of practice with this makes your head spin.
Eddie’s white seed coats both his and your stomach by the time he’s spent, every last drop milked from him.
Watching Eddie come apart on top of you was hands down the most beautiful thing you’ve ever seen. His face contorted in pleasure, a thin sheen of sweat making his body glisten. He’s never looked more perfect.
With a dopey grin on his face, Eddie tries to get his breathing back to normal as he comes down from his high. He needs to lay down, so he flops down next to you.
“Oh baby, that was…fuck. Perfect, is what it was. Thank you.”
He turns his head towards you to give you a kiss. You smile against his lips, pecking them a few times. Then you look down at your stomach, lines of white looking like a Jackson Pollock painting. You swipe two fingers through it and pop them in your mouth. Eddie moans as he watches you suck his cum off yourself.
“You’re going to get me harder again faster than I thought,” Eddie says with a breathless laugh. “But first, it’s your turn.”
He sits up and scoots down to the foot of the bed. This time when he grabs your ankles his hands aren’t freezing. You giggle as he tugs you down, but the laughter turns into a whine as he begins to slip your panties off. You lift your hips to help him, and he gets them off and tosses them on his nightstand. When you raise an eyebrow at him, he just smirks.
“If I had a back pocket, they’d be put there. But that’ll have to do for now.”
You expect him to spread your legs, but he leans up over your body to kiss your lips. His hand cups your neck, then slides down your shoulder and over your breast. He palms it over the lace and that feeling alone has you closing your eyes and arching your back. His thick fingers trail down the side of the bra until he reaches your back. You sit up just enough for him to reach behind and unclip the bra. You smile to yourself, wondering how long it would take him. He gets it fairly quickly, a triumphant sigh spilling from his lips as he does. The lace straps of the bra feel nice against your heated skin as you slide them down your shoulders and toss the bra off the side of the bed. Eddie’s gaze is hungry, and it sends a jolt of pleasure down your spine.
Eddie gently lowers you back down to the pillows. He starts by kissing your lips, then moves down to your jaw, your neck, your collarbone, then up the swell of your breast until he reaches your nipple. His tongue works over it before he takes it into his mouth and lets it go with a satisfying pop. Never one to half ass something, Eddie moves to your other breast to give it the same attention. Once he’s satisfied there - even though he makes a mental note that he wants to put as many hickeys as he can there asap - he kisses down your tummy, hands coming to massage your thighs. The further he slides down your body, he eases himself off the bed until he’s kneeling on the floor. One gentle hand on each knee, he spreads your legs in front of him and a moan comes out at the sight.
“Well shit,” Eddie says, echoing your statement from before. “It’s official. Every part of you is fucking perfect.”
You try your best not to be self-conscious, but it’s hard as no one has ever been down there before. When Eddie starts to press kisses on the inside of your thighs, you feel yourself calm down. You let your eyes slip closed and just try to be in the moment and not in your own head. Just feel Eddie’s lips on your skin, inching closer to the place you want them to be.
“You okay?”
“M’fine,” you say, voice in a dreamy haze. The fact that he’s checking in with you eases your nerves as well.
Kisses go higher and higher, coming to the apex of your thigh. Your body jumps, startled as Eddie’s fingers glide along the outside of your folds.
“Sorry, princess,” Eddie says with a chuckle. “Didn’t mean to scare you.”
You hold up your arm to give him a thumbs up and he chuckles again. You’re glad you’re both able to laugh and be silly with one another with this. It makes it feel more real, more intimate, more you.
Eddie uses his fingers to part your folds and the moan that emanates from his throat is purely pornographic.
“Shit, baby,” he says. “Your pussy is so pretty. Fuck, I bet it tastes as good as it looks.”
Between his words and your anticipation for what’s coming next, you feel the urge to buck your hips up, but manage to hold them still.
Eddie’s thumb ghosts over your clit and your hand immediately fists the sheet below you. Your boyfriend smirks to himself, loving making you squirm like this. It blows his mind that he gets to be with you like this. That he’s going to be able to learn your body. What makes you moan, what makes you scream, how to touch you and kiss you just right to make sure you feel as good as you make him feel.
He wants to take it slow since this is both of your first times, but the urge to just dive into your pussy is so strong. He needs to know how you taste. If it’s as sweet as he’s imagined since he jerked off to the thought of you when he went home after meeting you for the first time.
He runs his thick fingers through your slick folds and lets out a hiss when he feels how wet you are.
“This is all for me, baby? Does me touching you work you up this bad?”
“Yes,” you whine out. “Love it when you touch me. Makes me so wet.”
A growl rattles in Eddie’s chest and he experimentally runs a finger around your hole, but never breaching it.
“How’s it feel when you put your fingers in yourself?” he asks.
“Not enough,” you say, breathing becoming more rapid by the second. “Not big enough. Can't reach deep enough.”
“Think my fingers would be better then, princess?”
“Yes!” The way you practically shout it gives Eddie all the encouragement he needs to slide a finger into your right hole. You barely have time to get used to that before his tongue is assaulting your clit. “Fuck! Oh fuck, Eddie.”
The way you say his name has his cock stirring again. He slips a second finger in with the first and the way you move your hips lets him know you’re starting to feel the stretch. Eddie knows the first time can be painful for girls, and the last thing he wants to do is hurt you. He wants this to be perfect for you.
As he starts to slowly pump the two fingers in and out of you, Eddie attaches his lips to your clit, sucking on it as he listens to your little whimpers and moans coming from above.
“Like it, baby?” he pulls his mouth away to ask. “God, you’re so fucking tight around my fingers.”
“So much.” You sound like you’re about to cry, but not in a sad way. Overwhelmed, more likely. When Eddie crooks his fingers in a “come hither” motion and hits that sweet, sweet spot inside of you, your hips buck up and you moan a string of eddie-eddie-eddie-eddie’s. Eddie pumps his fingers a few more times before pulling them out. He doesn’t hesitate, his thick fingers covered in your slick go right from your pussy into his mouth. The garbled noise that comes from the back of your throat is part desperation since your hole feels empty now, and partly at how hot it was to watch Eddie lick you off of himself.
“God, you’re even sweeter than I thought,” he says. “So fucking perfect.”
Eddie lifts the back of your knees over his shoulders so he can be up close and personal with your cute little button and pretty little hole. He dives in immediately, licking into your hole, his fingers keeping you open wide as possible for him. He hardens his tongue as he thrusts it inside you and your hand searches for something to grip onto. You settle for another pillow, but that’s fine. You just need something to squeeze as Eddie brings you pure bliss.
Eddie’s tongue moves up to your clit, licking and sucking, and putting just the right amount of pressure on it. The fact that Eddie was only going to get better at this over time blows your mind. This is his first time and he’s already making you feel euphoric.
His mouth moves down again, but he takes a position where every lick he gives to your hole, his nose nudges against your clit, sending shockwaves up your body.
“Eddie, fuck,” you whine. “Gonna cum, baby.”
“Good girl,” Eddie says against your mound. He slides his hands up to cup at your breasts. “Cum for me, princess.”
It only takes a few more swipes of his tongue until your buildup can’t take anymore. White flashes behind your eyelids as your orgasm gets its hooks in you. The arching of your back was involuntary, and the whimpers and moans you’re making are sounds you didn’t know you were capable of producing. Head thrown back in the pillow, thighs closing around Eddie’s head, you feel ecstasy in this moment. It washes over your body, wading and cresting like waves on a beach.
Letting out a deep breath, you relax all the muscles that have tightened up, including the ones holding your boyfriend’s head between your legs, and melt into the sheets of the bed.
Eddie’s smirk is triumphant as he crawls up the bed, hovering over you as you try to catch your breath.
“So, how was that?”
“Holy shit,” is your only answer and it seems to satisfy him.
Eddie leans down and presses a loving kiss to your lips.
“I can’t wait until I can get a better view of your face when you cum. I bet it’s breathtaking. Your sounds alone are enough for me to get off to for years. But I must say, the view I had was pretty fucking amazing. Damn, baby. The way your pretty little hole kept sucking my fingers in. And your adorable little clit that I could play with all day.”
His words turn you scarlet red and you try to turn your head to hide it in the pillow. Eddie’s not having it though and uses one hand to tilt your chin back towards him.
“You better get used to me giving you compliments, sweet thing. It’s only going to get worse now that you’re officially my girlfriend.”
“How do you always make me feel so warm and fuzzy inside?” you ask.
“Because I’m basically a metal teddy bear,” he says, drinking up his nose in the most adorable fashion.
“You are!” The title fits him so well that you can’t help but laugh.
Eddie chuckles and leans in for another kiss. It starts off tender and innocent enough, but quickly evolves to all tongues and teeth, and Eddie starts pawing at your breasts. Your hips raise off the bed and rub against Eddie’s, where you can feel his cock, hard again now.
“Eddie,” you whine as he moves his kisses to your neck.
“Yeah, baby?” He’s leaving a hickey that will definitely show, even if you wear a turtleneck.
“Need you.”
He hums against your skin as his hands roam the expanses of bare skin before him.
“How, sweetheart? Tell me how.”
“Need you in me,” you whimper. “Need you so close.”
Eddie leans over your body, and it places one of his most gruesome scars right in front of your face. Lifting yourself up on your elbows, you place a soft kiss against the patch of pink and white skin. There’s a smile on Eddie’s face as he comes back with a condom and small tube of lube in hand.
You watch as Eddie slips the condom on. It shouldn’t be as hot as it is, but you can’t take your eyes off his long, thick cock. If just two of his fingers made you feel the stretch, you can’t imagine how full you’ll feel with all of Eddie buried inside you.
He grabs the lube and shrugs as he pours some into his hand. The smell of cherries floods the air.
“Just wanna be extra careful,” he explains as he fists the lube over his cock. “I want to make it as painless for you as I can.”
“You are the absolute sweetest,” you tell him.
Once the lube is sufficiently applied, you lay back against the pillows and watch Eddie settle between your legs. He grabs a spare pillow and taps the side of your hip. You raise them so he can slide the pillow under.
Eddie leans up and presses a slow and loving kiss against your lips.
“Ready, princess?”
“Mhmm,” you hum. “Kiss me while you go in?”
He did not need to be told twice. Eddie lines himself up with your entrance, and barely breaches you. You hardly feel a thing as Eddie comes up and kisses you, pouring all his devotion and heart into it. His hand snakes between your bodies as well to start rubbing your clit. Maybe between the kissing and the attention on your clit will help ease any discomfort you might have. The sting and burn are still there though, but it’s more bearable with the world's best kisses.
“Tell me if I’m hurting you, sweetheart,” Eddie says against your lips.
“N-Not hurting,” you say, hand coming up to grip at his shoulder.
Eddie nods, kissing your neck. “Let me know what you need. I’ll give you whatever you n-need.”
“Just keep doing what you’re doing, baby.” You wrap your legs around his, helping to guide him in.
Eddie groans and the sound makes you tremble with pleasure. “Shit, you feel s’fucking perfect. Like we were made for each other.”
“Uh huh,” you pant out, one hand sliding up to tangle in Eddie’s hair. There’s a pinch and you feel a sting between your legs as Eddie bottoms out, but you don’t say anything as you feel his hot kisses on your skin. It doesn’t hurt for long, and you know Eddie would pause his motions, but that’s the last thing you want.
“F-Faster, Eddie,” you say. “Want more.”
His kisses trail up to your lips and his hips pick up speed.
“This good, baby?” he asks.
“Yes. Fuck, yes.”
His hand moves from your clit to squeeze your hip. He holds it in his tight grip as his hips start to piston in and out of you, his pace becoming more irregular. It gives you a warm feeling in your limbs as you realize you can already recognize when Eddie is close to cumming. You clench around him, and he gasps, hand sliding from your hip to cup your breast.
“I can’t believe how fucking tight you are, baby,” he groans. “Such a perfect pussy.”
With a moan, you arch your back, forcing your breast even more into your boyfriend’s hand.
“Eddie, you’re so big. Love how you fill me up.”
“M’close. Wanna hold out but you feel too good around me.” His lips capture yours and you’re instantly licking into his mouth. Your hand tugs gently on his hair and his hips snap forward, the mattress creaking in protest at the ferocity. You pull back and rest your forehead against Eddie’s.
“Want you to feel good,” you say. “Want you to cum.”
A guttural moan comes from his throat and it’s enough to make you orgasm on the spot. His sounds are music to your ears, and you’d listen to him make them for the rest of your lives if he let you.
“Gonna, baby. Gonna cum.”
You nod at him, encouraging him as your fingers scratch at his scalp. He goes to bury his face in your neck, but you stop him.
“Wanna see your face,” you tell him. “Wanna watch you.”
Eddie nods, sweat beading on his forehead as his face scrunches in pleasure. He looks so beautiful you can’t help but steal a few more kisses.
“Cum for me, Eddie.”
The words are all he needs, his hips thrusting once, twice, before a whine leaves his lips as he spills inside the condom. The feeling of his cock twitching inside of you sends a flutter through you and a smile spreads on your face. Eddie’s eyes focus on your face as he rides out his high, and a matching smile grows on his face as he takes in your flushed and grinning face.
“Fuck, you’re perfect,” Eddie says between ragged breaths.
You reach up and cup his face in your hands and bring his lips down to yours. Never taking his mouth off of yours, he slips out of you and lays down next to you on the bed.
You reluctantly pull away when you need air, but you rest your hands on Eddie’s chest so you’re still touching him in some way. He slips out of the condom, ties it off, and tosses it in the trash can next to his bed. When he rolls back over to face you, you wrap your arms around his neck, and he pulls your body against his.
“Holy shit,” Eddie says.
“Good, baby?”
“Good? Good? Try fucking amazing,” Eddie says. He peppers kisses all over your face, making you giggle. “I’m sorry you didn’t cum though, baby.”
“Sweetie, I did,” you tell him. “Because of your sinful mouth.”
Eddie ducks his head bashfully, a red tint coming to his cheeks.
“Yeah, but not while I was in you.”
“That’s okay,” you say honestly. You push some of the damp hair from his forehead and kiss his cheek. “Most girls don’t the first time like that. But my boyfriend is generous and made sure I was taken care of beforehand.”
His hand trails up and down your back as he smiles down at you.
“Was my pleasure, baby. Trust me.”
With a giggle, you slip from his arms and off the bed. He pouts but you assure him you’ll be right back before slipping into the bathroom. Your sister never taught you much in life, but once piece of advice she’d given you is to pee after sex. When you walk back into Eddie’s room, his face is still blissed out as he stares up at the ceiling. He lifts his head when he sees you in the doorway and raises an eyebrow at you.
“All good?”
“Mhmm,” you say, making your way back to the bed. “There was only a little bit of blood.”
Eddie sits up quickly, frown coming to his face.
“What? Blood? Are you okay? Was I too rough?”
The concern on his face melts your heart and you shake your head as you sit down next to him.
“Oh, baby, no.” He pulls you into his lap and you rest your hands on his shoulders. “It’s just something that happens the first time. You were perfect. Thank you for being so careful with me.”
Eddie nods and rests his forehead against yours.
“Of course, sweetheart.”
“Sleepy?” you ask.
His responding yawn makes you chuckle, and you slide from his lap. You grab your panties from the nightstand and Eddie’s shirt from the floor and slip them on.
“You’re not gonna stay naked?” Eddie asks with a pout.
“It’s freezing!” you say.
“I’ll keep you warm.” Eddie lays down and opens his arms for you. You scoop his boxers up from the floor and toss them at his chest before slipping under the covers. He pulls them up his hips and situates himself back against the pillows.
Blankets pulled up to your neck, you sling your arm over Eddie’s middle and lay your head on his shoulder. Wrapped up in his embrace, you’ve never felt happier. The two of you whisper back and forth in the dark room for a few moments before you drift off to sleep, warm and cozy in each other’s arms.
1K notes
·
View notes