Leftovers [2/3]
Simon Riley x fem!Reader | a non-canon addition to my mafia!141 series
part 1 | part 3
warnings: unhealthy relationships, anxiety and depression, minor smut, possessive Simon, abusive behavior
you're his, now
wc: 4.6k
It had been months since the night your life ended and started again.
For the longest time, you were livid. Inconsolably upset at everything. A special type of betrayal festered in your chest where it rattled and raged against the hollow cavern between your ribs. That betrayal quickly revealed itself to be grief as the days went on. That utter melancholia threatened to suffocate you every time you thought about your old partners, The Prices. How they kept you like a pet, to be played and toyed with. How they decided to have a child without your input. How they only told you when they announced it to all their friends, like you were nothing more than a guest in their lives.
Then, there was Simon. Your savior. Or, at least that’s what he liked to call himself. It didn’t feel like salvation when he ripped you from the grasp of your old partner's bitter and unloving hands, not when you realized the cost of it. Lying wasn’t supposed to be synonymous with loving, and yet it was the very thing that had put you in the palm of Simon’s hands, made you so pliable for him as he fucked and marked you that night, making it impossible for you to ever return to your old life.
There was nothing but poison waiting for you with your old lovers, if you could even call them that. But being force fed the antidote hurt just as bad when that corruption had become the only comfort you had ever known.
Simon had a way of making things feel better, which usually consisted of him being anchored between your legs. If there was an issue he couldn’t fix by talking or kissing it away, then he would fuck it out of you, and you hated that it worked as well as it did. When you wanted to be mad at him for lying to you, for tricking you into giving yourself to him, his cock always ended up burrowing into your cunt. Your breath would be lost, stolen from your very lungs, and your words along with it. He had grown to know you so well that he was able to pull orgasms out of you with his eyes closed, rendering your brain numb and incapable of argument or resentment.
This cycle continued for what felt like forever. Your days would pass by with you rotting in bed in frustration and anguish as you choked on that antidote and feeling of betrayal, and when Simon had enough of your unresponsiveness, he would fuck you into submission. Coo and embrace you like a true lover would. It created some sort of dissonance within your very being. You were supposed to be mad at him for tricking you, and yet it felt divine being held against him. You couldn’t get enough of the searing sensation of his lips along your skin, or his breath caressing your ear as he slept.
It was agony being torn apart; forever caught between the gravity of your old lovers and the man that stole you from them.
Eventually, you woke up one day and it didn’t hurt anymore. Whatever frustration or anger that burrowed underneath your skin dissipated; vanished into thin air as if it had never existed in the first place. Things seemed brighter, you cried less, and Simon looked at you with adoration rather than pity for your shattered mental state.
Perhaps it was the ignorance that made things better. Without any access to the Prices, you had no knowledge at all of how they handled your absence, if they even cared at all. All you knew was that you had managed to find solace within Simon, despite the terrible start to your relationship. He really did take care of you, just like he said he would. He insisted on paying for everything, refusing to let you work, and provided you with everything you would ever need.
After all, you were his now.
Which was why you found yourself in front of a boiling pot of water in the kitchen of his apartment. Without the use of your phone, Simon had given you an old CD player to keep you occupied as you cooked or went about your day. Radiohead’s album In Rainbows droned on in the background as you mixed the pasta around the pot to keep them from sticking together. Spicy marinara bubbled on the next burner over, and its heavy aroma hung thick in the air around you, leaving you in a mouthwatering stupor.
Just as the alarm on the stove went off signaling the pasta was cooked, the deadbolt began to jingle behind you. After you turned the burners off, you quickly slipped out of the kitchen to greet Simon, who flashed you an entertained smirk. Exhaustion pulled at his eyes, yet they always seemed to light up when they landed on you, and you couldn’t help but grin up at him. It wasn’t often that he got home before ten, as his new job often kept him late, so you were ecstatic that he arrived just as you finished cooking up dinner.
“Smells like you’ve been busy,” he chuckled as he locked the door behind him.
“I thought I would have to leave some out for you again,” you admitted. His hands found your hips and he drew you closer, catching you in his gravity. “I’m glad you’re home.”
Before he allowed himself to respond, Simon squeezed your hips as his lips descended onto yours. It was the way he always greeted you when he arrived home from work, like he couldn’t get enough of you, or more accurately, like he knew you couldn’t get enough of him. You could taste the stale cigarettes on his breath, and the slight hint of mint that he used to attempt to cover it, and it took everything in you not to moan at the flavor. He was the one to pull away first, and your lips curved into a smile as his thumbs rubbed soothing circles along your hips.
“Let’s eat, yeah?” he prompted.
It didn’t take long for dishes to be served and for both you and Simon to settle on the couch in the living room while some programme droned on in the background. Even during meals you always huddled close to him as if you would die without his heat. Your leg laid pressed against his as you leaned into his side, and had Simon not been as large of a man as he was, you certainly would have smothered him with your presence.
“How was work?” you questioned once half your plate had been emptied.
“Was alright,” Simon replied with his mouth full of pasta. “Bit slow.”
“That why you’re home early?”
“Mhm.”
Simon never seemed like much of a talker, and neither were you until recently. A majority of your life had been spent in silent pining for your basic needs and desires, but once Simon had stolen you away, it was like all you ever wanted to do was talk. Perhaps it was because he genuinely seemed to care about what you had to say. Or maybe it was because some sort of loneliness still managed to creep into your life, like a ghost that haunted you.
“I’m glad you’re home early,” you admitted. “I’ve been missing you all day.”
“I missed you too, sweetheart. I always try to come home as soon as I can,” Simon assured you.
A twinge of exhaustion lurked underneath his tone, screaming at you that despite the fact he got off early, he certainly had a long day. He always seemed drained after arriving home, proving to you just how hard he worked in order to support you, to give you the life he told you that you deserved. You always had someone who would crawl into bed with you, someone who wasn’t ashamed to show you affection and love, someone to truly take care of you. Despite the circumstance, Simon was everything you could have ever asked for. Everything you would ever need.
So why did it feel like something was missing?
That night after the dishes were washed and the lights were turned down low, you and Simon hid underneath the covers where your limbs intertwined with one another. For some reason he always insisted that you sleep naked, and though you weren’t sure why, you didn’t really mind. In fact, feeling the warmth of his body seep into you was so intoxicating you probably would have come to that conclusion even without his prompting. You couldn’t get enough of his scent, or how his skin felt against yours, and even though the two of you had laid in bed for nearly twenty minutes you buzzed.
Nothing could satiate your need for him. You wouldn’t be satisfied until you were able to crawl into him and hide yourself away underneath his very flesh. You wanted to shrink yourself down, become some small thing, and tuck yourself into his pocket to be forever stuck with him. A vile yearning for him tainted your very essence, and yet you wished it would destroy you all the same.
“What’cha so wiggly for?” Simon questioned, half awake yet still teasing.
“I missed you,” you whined as you buried your face further into his bare chest.
His chuckle sounded low and grumbly in his throat as his arms wrapped firmly around your center. Wandering hands caressed along your hips and down your thighs, traversing and memorizing every single dimple of your flesh like it was the only story he ever wanted to know.
“I’m here now, love,” he hummed.
“I know, I just get so lonely when you’re gone,” you admitted with a pout. “You’re gone forever at work, and I just wanna talk to you. I was thinking that maybe if I had my phone back I could message you-”
“What did I say about your phone?”
The tone Simon used to cut you off was sharper than anything you had ever heard from him before, and it stopped you in your tracks. There was a fatigued sort of frustration that drenched his words which left a part of you wishing that you had never opened your mouth in the first place. He was too tired, too irritated to have a conversation, especially one like that, and you were afraid you had pushed his buttons a bit too much.
You swallowed hard as Simon’s hands moved to your chin, forcing you to look up at him through the dim light rather than keep your face hidden in his chest. Darkness obscured his face, making it near impossible to truly read his expression, and yet you found your bottom lip quivering all the same.
“Sweetheart,” he urged, softer that time, “what did I say about your phone?”
“That it’s… better if I don’t have it,” you answered as your teeth bit into the inside of your cheek.
“Yeah?” His hand moved from your chin to your cheek where his thumb gently rubbed at your skin. The notion was comforting, soothing even, yet you knew he was truly checking for tears. “And why’s that?”
“Because then the Prices won’t be able to contact me.”
Just like that, your mood was ruined. Any reminder of your past lovers was a painful one. Even after all those months they still seemed to have some sort of control over you, and the fact that they could sour your mood with just a simple memory was dehumanizing. Your somberness was so potent it exuded from your body like fine mist, and Simon’s caressing of your face increased tenfold in an attempt to calm you before things became catastrophic. You were his sweet, fragile girl, after all.
“Right. And it’s better that way, isn’t it sweetheart?” he concluded softly. “It’s better here with me, because I take care of you, don’t I? I don’t neglect you, or treat you like some pet.”
Although he was right, it didn’t make the bitter ache in your chest go away. Simon did his best to sooth the pain with his hands and words, and you shivered as his fingertips traversed from your face, to your shoulders, and down your waist. He had to find some way to distract you, some way to remind you that he was the only one you needed, and that you had to stay far away from Price and his trophy wife. You were too good for them; he needed you to know that.
“You’re mine, and I’m yours, that’s what we agreed on, yeah?” he continued. His hand began to dip lower, moving from your waist, over your stomach, and between your legs. Your breath caught in your throat as his fingers burrowed between your thighs, searching for access to your not quite slick cunt. Your emotions were too high for you to be wet, Simon was well aware, but you both knew he could change that within an instant. “They’ll never see you again, never get to abuse you again because I’m here to protect you. I love you in a way they never did.”
Right as he spoke those last few words, his fingers greedily swiped against your clit, and your legs had no choice but to fall apart and grant him greater access. A gentle tremor shook the bed as Simon repositioned himself, pushing you on your back so that he could hover over your exposed body like it was a fresh meal just for him. Famished lips descended onto your neck as his fingers prodded against your entrance, forcing your mind to go blank with longing.
“Needy thing, aren’t you? Need my full attention? I’m sorry, sweetheart, shoulda fucked you the moment I got home, huh? I’m all yours, and you’re all mine. Say it,” Simon urged as he still withheld himself from you.
Squirming, you reached out for him with wanting hands as you snaked your arms around his neck. This was how he healed you, with his fingers teasing your cunt and his saccharine words plugging your ears. There was nothing else in the world you needed besides Simon. Every chord of your body yearned for him as if he was the only sustenance your body craved. This was how he healed you. With honeyed words and a worshiping mantra reminding you of who you belonged to.
“I’m yours.”
That night only added on to the other countless evenings spent with Simon tucked between your legs to voraciously consume you whole. There was no thinking to be done when he could mercifully do it for you, and you were content with that. At least, you thought you were. Things always became difficult when Simon vanished off to work, and he would do his best to make it up to you when he arrived home, to distract you from the empty feeling that seemed to fester inside of your chest. But no matter what he gave you, what he did for you when he was home, your mind always wandered when he was away.
You couldn’t help but think back to when you lived with the Prices, how cold and lonely that house was, and how colder still your lovers were. Mr. Price — no, John — had sent you over to Simon like a bitch; some obedient pup meant for entertaining but not for loving, and it didn’t make sense. He had sent you over to comfort Simon so flippantly, yet acted as if the world had ended when you never returned back to them that terrible night. Was there some sort of miscommunication? Was that never his intention at all? And still, they left you out of the imperative conversation about their pregnancy like it never concerned you at all.
You were spiraling again, and Simon was able to pick up on it just as easily as he could sniff out a bad wound. He could only keep you caged up so long, and he knew he needed to remedy it before he was back at the beginning with you. So you shouldn’t have been surprised when he arrived home one day with a gift. Beautiful, blush pink cloth sewn into a perfect sundress sat underneath delicate tissue paper, and you had a hard time hiding your awe and surprise when you revealed the astonishing dress. Simon’s eyes seemed more dilated than normal when he saw you hold it up to your body, and you caught onto his small smirk.
Without hesitation, you slipped into the dress at his prompting, and you were ecstatic to find that it fit perfectly. Simon had gotten used to your sizing after having to buy you a whole new wardrobe after you escaped the Prices, but even then you were impressed at how well it formed to your measurements. It was as if Simon had every inch of your body memorized after the months you had spent together to the point that there was no way he could mess up your sizing. You couldn’t help but smile knowing that no one else had ever done that for you before.
It didn’t end there. With Simon having to work longer hours that night than normal, he insisted on taking you out to lunch, which was something you couldn’t ever recall doing. Ages had passed since you had even stepped foot out of Simon’s apartment, and you couldn’t remember the last time you felt the sun on your skin. You didn’t know why he hadn’t taken you out sooner, but if you had to guess, you were certain it was for the same reason he did everything else; to keep you safe from the Prices.
The restaurant Simon took you to was the fanciest you had ever seen before. Several art pieces adorned the walls with such vibrant shades you were convinced that the art itself cost more than whatever it took for them to construct the building itself. Crystal chandeliers hung high above your heads, and before either of you could order the waiter had filled your glasses with the finest of wines. The menu itself didn’t even have any prices, but Simon didn’t seem at all concerned with it, and insisted that you ordered whatever you wanted.
There was something deliciously domestic about being there with him. You belonged to him, and he belonged to you, that much was evident, but there was something exciting about being able to show that fact in public. To prove that someone loved you enough to show it off, rather than hide you away. No matter how hard you tried, you couldn’t wipe that grin off your face as the two of you talked about nothing while eating the mouthwatering meals on your plates. For a moment, you two were the only beings in the world.
For a moment.
A flash of something caught your attention. Maybe it was a giggle, or the cooing and awing, but all you knew was that your eyes suddenly glued themselves on the patrons a few tables away from you. For a split second, you thought you saw them. John and his wife. It wasn’t them at all, but you realized you only feared that because this woman, this beautiful woman with her glowing skin and healthy laugh, was pregnant. Obviously so, too, as her stomach swelled and stretched with the growing life inside of her. Her husband could hardly take his eyes off of her, constantly reaching across the table to hold her hand despite her attempt at trying to enjoy her lunch. It was… stomach lurching.
By that point, Mrs. Price would be four months along. Or, no, more than that for sure. It had been four months since you had been taken from them, since you had even heard from them. Four months without closure, or the opportunity to talk and get answers. A part of you needed to know why things happened the way they did, but you were completely in the dark. All you had received was whatever Simon spoon fed you, but it wasn’t enough. You weren’t sure if it would ever be enough. Maybe you had been empty for too long to ever be full again.
“Everythin’ alright, sweetheart?”
Your eyes tore away from the unsuspecting couple and landed back on Simon. He studied you carefully with a neutral expression, but you saw the slight press of his lips. Dark red wine faintly stained his pale skin, yet you couldn’t find yourself able to appreciate the beauty of it. All you had was a rotten feeling in your stomach and the sudden urge to vomit.
“Yeah, of course,” you lied.
Things got bad again when Simon left for work that night. Maybe it was the knowledge that he wouldn’t be home until late that made your brain ceaselessly buzz. Or maybe it was the image of that pregnant woman at the restaurant, the one that reminded you of the suffering you had to endure all those months ago. You attempted to silence that incessant sound in your mind as best as you could, because you knew you couldn’t afford to blow up, so you did anything to distract yourself. Music blasted through the CD player louder than it ever had, certainly to the annoyance of your neighbors, but for once you found yourself incapable of caring about anyone but yourself.
When that didn’t work, you put on a movie instead. It wasn’t one you recognized, just something you had flipped to when you were browsing through streaming services. You had gotten dressed in one of Simon’s plain tees in an attempt to drown yourself in his scent, and yet that didn’t dull the ache either. All you could think of while the images flashed in front of you on the screen were the movie nights at the Prices. How John would make you cuddle up next to Simon, how the only comfort you could find was in his beating heart as he held you close to him…
There had to be a reason for it all.
When the movie ended and there was nothing to accompany you but silence and the sound of your own breathing, that’s when you knew you couldn’t handle it anymore. You needed something. You needed answers.
Like a feral rat, you began to search every nook and cranny of the apartment for your phone. If you could find it, maybe you could get some answers from John. Even if Simon said it was bad for you, you knew you needed closure, no matter how much it hurt. Wherever Simon had put it, it was well hidden. You nearly tore apart his dresser, every drawer in the kitchen, the corners of the bedroom closet; everywhere you could think of, and it wasn’t there.
Just when you were about ready to tear the floor up, you finally found it. Really, you had half expected him to have thrown it away, yet there it sat underneath the bathroom vanity, hidden behind a myriad of cleaning supplies so far back the overhead light couldn’t illuminate it. When you finally had it in your grasp, you nearly cried, and you weren’t sure why. A fit of emotions bubbled in your stomach, each of them violently conflicting, yet frustration took over when you attempted to turn the phone on and the screen wouldn’t light up. Of course it wouldn’t, it hadn’t been used for months.
Rushing off to the bedroom, you quickly borrowed Simon’s charger and let your phone sit on the nightstand as it ever so slowly charged. Answers almost within your reach, and yet your anxiety bubbled up more than ever as you waited for that black screen to flicker to life.
It took ages for the thing to fully load up once it was charged enough to turn on, and you held the device in your shaking hands. All your old apps appeared on the screen, countless pictures that you had taken over the years, but the most eyecatching of them all was the amount of notifications you had for your text messages. 172, all within the last four months.
When you clicked on the app, you quickly realized that all of those messages had been sent by John, and you hated the way your stomach dropped. But this was what you wanted, wasn’t it? Answers? To have him explain why he did what he did? To make it stop hurting? With a heavy breath, you clicked on his name, and the app instantly scrolled up to the very first message he had sent in his cluster over the last few months, and it was then that you noticed something was wrong. Just before his onslaught of messages, there was a reply sent by you, one you didn’t remember sending.
Don’t contact me again.
This wasn’t you. That had to have been Simon, because he had taken your phone from you before you ever got the chance to respond to them yourself. Their worried messages, their pleading for you to come home, to know that you were okay. It didn’t work, obviously. The next few messages after that one was full of John pleading to speak with you, of several missed calls, of him apologizing for anything they did to upset you. The texts dated back only hours, sometimes minutes apart, and it was strange. You had never seen him so desperate before. Not for you.
Eventually they seemed to stop for a while, only to start back up again weeks later. There were plenty of comments saying how much they missed you, how they wished you would change your mind and come home, and it felt… wrong. Hadn’t Simon told them that you were with him? He told you he did. He had even quit his job with Price because he didn’t want any bad blood, so why did they act as if you were lost? Like they didn’t know where you were at?
Confused, you continued scrolling, eyes glossing over at the repetitive messages, until eventually you stumbled across pictures. Baby clothes. Cute little shoes. Ultrasounds. Pregnancy announcements. A gender reveal. They were having a girl, and they painted the nursery a cute shade of pink, just like the dress Simon had gotten for you that day. And then there was a video. It was short, and though it wasn’t visually stimulating, it had a rhythmic pulse accompanying the audio. The baby’s heartbeat.
Wish you were here to share these moments with us.
You weren’t able to stop the tears streaming down your face, or the food that came back up to say hello. Indignifying as it was, you sobbed on the cold bathroom floor as you vomited and continued to dry heave the emptied contents of your stomach. Everything crashed down on you all at once, and yet you felt numb at the same time. Nothing made sense. Why were they still trying to talk to you after all that time, like there was still a chance you would return?
Then, you suddenly thought back to the morning Simon admitted his lie to you. How he had done it so easily and without remorse. How he grabbed at your cunt like he… owned you. You would have thrown up again at that thought if you had more food in your stomach, but you instead rose from the cold tile to rinse your mouth. You didn’t feel like a lover. You didn’t feel cared for. For the first time in months, you felt like a pet.
So you did the only thing you had ever been good at doing: you ran. You ran just like you did back at John’s club, and every other time your emotions conflicted so bad you swore you would die. After you gathered a small bag full of personal items, your phone and wallet included, you rushed out the door and didn’t bother to look back as it closed behind you.
an: this was only ever supposed to be a one shot, but i decided to expand on the story a little more, as i felt the first part wasn't able to fully convey the story i was trying to tell. once the 3rd part is posted though, that'll be it, so please don't harass me about more parts again (: gives me anxiety
711 notes
·
View notes
don't dream it's over
Part 6 to the series Chemistry, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4 , Part 5-- Eddie Munson x Fem!Reader
stranger things masterlist | Spotify playlist
summary: thanks to Eddie Munson, Y/N faces the consequences of breaking her parents number one rule: no boys allowed. After a month of no fun, no friends, and no boyfriends, Y/N makes a harrowing realization about just how much she misses the "freak" of Hawkins High
cw: angst, fluff, anxiety, hurt/comfort, shy/nerdy!reader, pre-ST4, cocky!Eddie, swearing, strict parents,
a/n: this chapter was a long time coming so I thank you all so much for waiting patiently. I also meant to end the story at the 6th chapter but my last chapter did mitosis again and this isn't the end (just yet), but for now enjoy this extra long chapter
“Eddie,” Y/N cries out in despair.
“It’s ok sweetheart. I’m right here.” Eddie replies.
He tightens his arm locked around her waist and pulls her body closer to his. He breathes in the scent of her hair. Feels the warmth of her body pressed against his as they lay in his bed.
“I-I need you,” she calls out to him, too afraid to turn over and look him in the eyes.
“It’s ok, I need you too.”
“But I can’t. I-I’ve never needed someone like this before…”
***
When Y/N woke, there was a brief moment of reprieve.
Her swollen eyes struggled to widen amidst the soft sunlight peeking through her blinds. She breathed deeply, barely on the brink of consciousness to relish the last waking moment she would have before remembering the horrors of the past twelve hours.
Soon enough, the look on her mom’s face and the tone of her dad’s voice came flooding back to her. The memories loom accompanied by an intense pounding in her head.
She’s reminded of the tears she had cried throughout the night, but now, there’s only silence.
Numbness overcomes her, and for the rest of the day, Y/N simply floats by, barely interacting with the world around her.
At breakfast, lunch, and dinner, she looks down at her plate and only opens her mouth to take a few bites of whatever is in front of her.
In the calm clear morning air, her parents reinstate her month long punishment with the new addition of having her phone privileges taken away too.
Y/N knows from her sister’s many moments of being grounded that the punishment usually entails promptly coming home from school, with the exception of extracurricular activities, and only leaving the house for family outings. But for the first time, it’s Y/N’s turn to be on house arrest. Forbidden from seeing Eddie and any of her friends.
And if it wasn’t drilled into her head before, the whole, “no fun, no friends, and no boyfriends” thing was permanently embedded in her skull. That and the idea that those are all worthless distractions from the only thing that does matter: doing well in school.
Y/N almost wants to complain. A thread of anger in her shouts that this is all unfair, but a bigger, much louder part of her knows the harsh reality: life isn’t fair. And this is exactly what would happen by doing something as stupid as falling in love in a house that forbids it.
Now, she’ll have to pay the price for her idiotic actions and make sure nothing like this happens again.
Even when she hears a faint tapping on her window later that night, only to discover Eddie climbing up the roof of her house.
Y/N starts hyperventilating and feeling the blood in her veins scream.
“Eddie, what are you doing,” she whisper yells, from the window cracked slightly ajar.
Eddie, with his tongue slightly poking out of his full lips, lost in focus from trying not to fall and quietly make his way to her window, doesn’t hear her.
As he climbs Rapunzel’s tower, a small part of Y/N can’t help but feel her heart soar. On this cool autumn night, here Eddie is, climbing the edge of her parents house in his signature leather jacket he fills out so well and chunky ring clad fingers clutching the railing.
As Eddie nears her windowsill, Y/N stands in front of it like a guard, blocking his attempted entrance.
“Hey sweetheart,” he reaches forward and caresses her cheek with one calloused hand while the other holds him upright, balancing carefully on the rooftop. “You didn’t call. I was starting to get worried.”
“Eddie, you can’t be here right now,” Y/N frantically states before looking over her shoulder. “My parents could hear you. I could get in trouble for this.”
“I know,” He sighs, “But I wanted to see you.”
Eddie smiles at her, not in that million dollar gleam way he always does that she loves so much, but in that bashful heart warming way that makes her stomach do a whole gymnastics routine.
Y/N shakes her head and firmly states, “I don’t care. You need to go home Eddie.”
Eddie frowns, partially at her words and also at the sudden realization that her cheeks have been stained with what were presumably tears.
“Eddie, please.” Y/N shoos him away. The pleading sense of urgency is audible in her voice.
Eddie takes a beat, realizing the events are not unfolding like he imagined they would have.
He knew it might take some convincing. Nothing with Y/N has been easy, but he thought throwing rocks at a girl’s window always worked, at least in the movies it does.
But the frazzled look on her face and the shaky look in her eyes right now say otherwise.
“Eddie, please, I’m serious. You need to go home, right now.”
She looks like she could be on the verge of tears and that alone is enough to make Eddie stop. His heart absolutely broke at the sound of her cries over the phone last night. It would practically kill him to be the one bringing tears to her mesmerizing eyes.
“Ok,” he replies reluctantly before slowly making his descent down the side of the house.
When his muddy Reebok sneakers hit the pavement, he’s left disoriented. Not that the climb had any effect on him, but Y/N’s mood was just so off putting.
He knew she would at least be bummed. He imagined her parents would get mad and maybe even ground her and that’d be enough to have her properly pissed off, but he didn’t expect her to be so… perturbed.
Maybe it should come as no surprise, given how anxious she was before she got home last night. And you’d think after all the things Eddie’s cynical eyes have seen, he would know better than to have hope, but something in him can’t help himself. For once, he wanted his expectation to meet his reality no matter how much he wished he didn’t.
For Y/N, all sense of hope disintegrated the night before. It feels like nothing even matters. Once in a tug of war between her parents wishes and her own, the rope got yanked out of her hands making her fall in the mud.
She couldn’t run away. She couldn’t fight it. All she could do was freeze. Freeze and retreat into a hole of safety and familiarity which was obeying her parents and keeping any hope of something with Eddie tucked away at the back of her bleeding heart.
***
The silence continued the next day at school, where a cloud of doom loomed over her incessantly. Y/N breezed by, narrowly escaping the minimum amount of effort required of her classes and demands of friends or teachers.
Until chemistry class.
As soon as she walked in, Eddie, who normally arrives as the bell rings, was already there waiting for her. He rushed over to her and engulfed her in a warm hug.
“Sweetheart, what happened? Are you okay?”
Y/N pulled away, acutely aware of the odd stares from her classmates. But those were pinpricks compared to the blistering pain of her parents' wrath.
“I don’t want to talk about it.”
He frowns.
She shrugs his touch away, “Meet me in the woods behind the school during lunch.”
Like clockwork, Eddie finds her sitting on the shoddy wooden bench in the clearing out past the track and field. The sound of his footsteps with leaves crunching under his feet and the chain swinging along his jeans announcing his arrival.
“Hey smarty pants,” he greets, gently teasing. He slides in the spot next to her and wraps a protective arm around her hunched over shoulders. He kisses the top of her head and the proximity of his actions brings the scent of soap and the sort of musky scent she doesn’t know what to call other than just, boy, to her nostrils. It makes her close her eyes and shoulders drop slightly.
“I was worried about you yesterday. Was hoping you might call, sweetheart,” he sweetly says as he cups her cheek.
Y/N turns the other cheek and looks down at her lap. His touch is too tempting. Her body yearns for him, but she can’t. She has to be strong enough to resist.
“My parents took my phone away. I’m not even allowed to use the main phone in the kitchen unless it's for an emergency,” Y/N glumly replies.
“I think a quick call to your local dungeon master counts as an emergency,” he teases.
“Eddie,” She looks up at him sullenly, “It’s not funny.”
Y/N looks down and Eddie frowns.
“Hey, look at me,” he softly instructs, turning her shoulders towards him.
She holds her breath and looks into his warm eyes. They’re so beautiful, she wishes she could just jump into his irises and swim in the warm lagoon of their honey hue.
“We’re gonna figure this out, okay?”
“How? My phone privileges were taken away and I’m grounded for a month. I’m pretty much not allowed to do anything but go to school.”
“Seriously,” he asks, arms tensing at the thought.
“Yeah,” she looks down dejectedly.
“That’s bullshit. Are you kidding me?”
Y/N frowns angrily and huffs. Like she doesn’t already know that.
“Those’re the rules, Eddie” she shrugs glumly. “I have to follow them.”
Eddie exhales through his nostrils. “And what if you don’t?”
Y/N looks at him incredulously, “Eddie are you serious? I got the ass-chewing of a lifetime. I’ve never gotten in trouble like this before. I-I feel horrible for what I did.”
“Well, you shouldn’t.”
“Eddie, what are you talking about?”
“Y/N did nothing wrong. Your parents are just blowing this way outta proportion. Teenage rebellion is good. Healthy even.”
“Look Eddie, just because you can get away with being rebellious doesn’t mean I can.”
Eddie huffs in frustration. “I’m just saying, you need to stand up for yourself. Your parents are only gonna keep controlling you if you let them.”
Y/N opens her mouth to say something but nothing comes out.
“And besides, who are your parents to stop you? I mean, think about it. The first time you do something like that, it’ll shock them, but the more you do it, the more they’ll get used to it. Then they’ll have no choice but to face the fact that we want to be together.”
Y/N looks at him in disgust and shakes her head before looking up at him with fear in her eyes, “Eddie, what the hell? I barely made it out of there alive.”
Eddie drops his shoulders he hadn’t realized were tensed up.
“You just don’t understand. It’s never gonna get any better. And even if it did, I… I wouldn’t want my parents to just put up with us dating. I love my parents and I don’t want to disappoint them any more than I already have.”
Eddie looks her square in the eye and throws the curveball of a question, “Y/N are you really disappointing them or are you finally doing what makes you happy?”
Y/N jerks her head back. She doesn’t know why his words cut as sharply as a knife as they do, but it stings nonetheless.
“It doesn’t matter. What matters to me is being with you, the right way. I want my parents to accept us.”
“And what if they don’t?”
Eddie looks into Y/N’s eyes.
“Are you only ever going to do things they approve of?”
Y/N’s teeth clench and her lips purse. She grabs onto the wooden table for stability as she feels tears threatening to spring from her eyes, but she can’t let Eddie see her cry. She can’t.
The question in her mind that has her on the verge of explosion: Is it really so wrong for me to want to date Eddie and have my parent’s approval too?
Eddie’s features soften at the sight of her state of deep tension. He has to remind himself that Y/N isn’t the one he should be mad at, it’s her parents. Even though Y/N is the one freely letting her parents drive the wedge between them even deeper.
A small part of him is envious. He almost admires Y/N’s willingness to obey her parents. And the way she doesn’t hate them for what they’ve done. She hasn’t even thought to continue dating him just to spite them.
And yet, the bigger part of him, full of spite and resentment he has toward his own parents, is angry, both at and for her. He crashed and burned trying to get his own father’s acceptance way back when and doesn’t want her to do the same.
“Look, I’m just… I hate seeing you like this,” he presses a palm to her back and gently rubs. “I know you really care about what your parents have to say, but they’re wrong about us, about you,” he whispers as he brings a hand forward to caress her hair. “Y/N, listen, you didn’t do anything wrong, okay?”
Y/N breathes in deeply, “Eddie… You didn’t see the look on their faces. It was like-like I’d taken their hearts and just smashed them into tiny little pieces, right in front of them.”
Eddie wants to say something, but is rendered speechless. He wants to complain about how unfair her parents are being or how ridiculous it all is, but he can see how upset she already is. He doesn’t want to be the one to bring any more tears to her precious eyes.
He wraps his arms around her and whispers in her hair, “I know.”
Y/N leans into his touch but doesn’t wrap her arms around him back.
Eddie takes a deep breath in and slowly pulls away. “So what are we gonna do now?”
Y/N peers up at him, through her curled lashes. Her eyes like falling stars.
“I think we need to call it.”
“W-What?” He chokes.
“I can’t,” Y/N sniffles and shakes her head, “I don’t think I can do this.”
“What?” He sighs and frustratedly runs a hand through his hair, “Is this really what you want?”
Y/N shakes her head, “No, but I–”
“Sweetheart,” Eddie calls out to her, making her heart constrict. Y/N looks at him from the corner of her eye. “Remember what I said to you that night, on the phone?”
Eddie cocks an eyebrow at Y/N awaiting her answer as she reluctantly nods.
“I meant it, okay? Every word. I’ll do whatever it takes for us to be together. To have a shot at finding out whatever this is, it’s the least we deserve, right?”
He moves his head to meet her gaze.
“I want,” his voice cracks and he clears his throat. If Eddie starts crying then Y/N will surely cry too and absolutely none of that can happen.
“I need you in my life, Y/N. And I know you feel the same way too.”
Y/N’s breath hitches in her throat. Hearing Eddie say he needs her in almost the same way she did to him in the dream she’d had that night makes her heart drop to her stomach, but only for a moment.
“Eddie, it doesn’t matter what I feel. And there’s nothing you can do to change the fact that my parents won’t let us be together.”
Eddie takes one good look at her. The creases in her forehead. The tension in her shoulders. The pout on her pretty lips. And the nervous look in her eyes. The kind of look you have when you need to be on guard. Before, it was just her heart she had to guard, but now it’s her spirit too.
“And besides, what’s the end game here?”
“What?” Eddie shakes his head in confusion.
“I mean, even if we did… date, how long could it possibly last?”
Eddie blinks, completely thrown for a loop by her question. “I don’t know, as long as we can keep it going I guess.”
“Eddie, what’ll happen when we graduate? When I go off to college?”
“I-I don’t know. I hadn’t really planned out our relationship Y/N,” Eddie says in a snappier tone than he’d meant. He knows Y/N likes to plan ahead, but even for something like this?
“Maybe they’re doing us a favor. Saving us the trouble.”
Eddie tenses, fighting his lip from quivering at the thought.
“Do you really believe that,” Eddie’s voice cracks and Y/N looks away.
She wishes her father’s words could go away. That they could’ve just gone in one ear and out the other. But they didn’t. They stuck to her. And as much as she’d like to believe in the little dream that anything is possible, she knows it's better, safer to be realistic.
For Eddie, it doesn’t matter if their relationship lasts 10 days or 10 years. And yeah it’ll hurt like hell when it’s over either way, but for her, he’s willing to take that chance. Or so he thought
“So that’s it? We’re not even going to try and see what this could be?” He asks in a steady and calculated voice.
Y/N frowns and looks away. When he puts it like that, she feels ridiculous, idiotic. Like a fool for not even trying. But how could she? How could she be brave enough to stand up to her parents? To stand tall in the face of adversity?
To cower in fear and hide away is what she’s always done. She did it whenever her sister did something rebellious and had to face the ugly consequences.
Y/N thought she could avoid that fate. All she had to do was obey her parents. If she did what she was told her life was easy, familiar, and safe.
“Eddie, I just…”
Y/N can feel her heart being torn down the middle. It’s killing her to let the people she loves down. If it’s not Eddie then it’s her parents. But she can stand to disappoint Eddie. She can’t stand to disappoint her parents anymore than she already has. She never wants to experience that ridicule again.
“For the first time in my life, I felt brave. You made me feel brave. You made me feel alive. And happy. But maybe it was all too much because then…then it all blew up in my face. And now, I’m scared.
I'm scared it’ll happen again. I’m scared that even wanting something like this makes me a bad person. I’m scared that I’ll lose you again because of something I have no control over.
So yeah, I’m sorry if that’s not the answer you want, but it’s the only one I’ve got.”
Eddie’s eyes widen. He’s surprised by her answer. And if she wasn’t giving him the worst news possible, he would be proud of how assertive she’s being. If only she could channel that energy toward her parents.
“I think it would be best if we just acted like none of this ever happened. Now that our chemistry assignment is over and done with, I think we should just go our separate ways.”
And before he even has a chance to say anything, Y/N gets up from the table and runs away in the direction of the school.
Her muscle memory has her making her way to the cafeteria, but as soon as she sees her friends sitting at their usual spot, she freezes in her tracks, almost bumping into someone walking with their lunch tray.
“Watch where you’re going,” they spit at her.
Y/N tenses up and looks back at her friends smiling and laughing. It should make her happy to see her friends so happy, but at this moment, all she can feel is the fragile lines of her heart cracking into broken pieces.
She can’t do it. She thought she could at least handle lunch with them, but not today.
She makes the great escape from the cafeteria till her legs bring her to the safe haven of the school’s library.
She takes a spot towards the back, behind rows and rows of bookshelves by a window with a view of the student parking lot.
She spots a few of the jocks cutting class. For a moment, she almost hopes Eddie might come and find her. But more than anything, she just wants to scream.
***
For the rest of the week, Y/N avoids Eddie like the plague. Much to her chagrin, Eddie’s persistence has resulted in many a chicken scratch written note in her locker.
Y/N please, can we talk? I miss you like crazy. If you change your mind, I’ll be waiting by my van after school today (p.s. I promise I’ll be on time).
You didn’t show up yesterday. I guess you had an after school thing. One of those clubs you’re in that I forgot about. Ever the lovely smarty pants. Anyway, I have to stay after school for Hellfire today. Just so you know, the drama club doors are always open.
I know you won’t talk to me, but I just wanted to say you look really pretty today. Well, you look pretty everyday, but especially today.
I listened to the mixtape you made me. I wish I could tell you in person, but I think I might not hate the Thompson Twins (Don’t tell the Hellfire boys though).
I miss you sweetheart, please don’t shut me out.
Y/N crumbles each of them up and shoves them into her bag, letting them collect at the bottom. It takes every ounce of energy she has not to succumb to Eddie’s poetic ways.
In the meantime, Y/N continues to laser focus on school and avoid her friends.
She stopped eating lunch in the cafeteria and came up with an excuse to get out of any conversation with them in class.
Y/N didn’t want to have to explain what happened or pretend like everything was normal to anyone, so instead she’s choosing to walk the paved path before her alone.
Whenever Y/N comes home, she hides away in her room like a crab hiding in its shell, only coming out at meal times or to leave for school in the morning.
By the end of that long miserable week, Y/N asks her sister to take her to the Radio Shack. She’s been saving up her birthday money for an emergency and this was as much of an emergency as anything.
Normally her sister would object to chauffeuring her around, but even she felt a little bad for Y/N.
Luckily, because her sister would accompany her, Y/N’s parents allowed the little field trip.
A brand new Walkman and a few tapes of her favorite albums might be the only beacon of hope she has for a while, at least until this all passes. If it passes. Unlike the storm that night in the back of Eddie’s van, she fears this torment may never pass.
Eddie feels equally tormented by the whole thing. For one, he never expected to fall for a girl like Y/N. And now that he has, she’s just out of reach. Just his luck.
He knows the universe is just laughing at him like it always does, because for the first time in a long time, he actually had hope. Hope that even he can have a happy ending. But it’s long gone now.
As the days fly by and there’s no sign of change, he realizes this isn’t just a setback anymore. That there really might be nothing he can say or do to change her parents' minds. To change her mind.
And even if by a miracle, they could be together, he can’t help but feel sort of hurt and rejected by Y/N's insistence on avoiding each other and acting like what they had means nothing.
Her act of obedience is not only taking her own happiness away, but his too.
It hurt, but he hated letting it show. So he exchanged his pain for irritability or anger.
He would lash out at the boys from Hellfire Club for the littlest things. He would drive home to the loudest most brash music he owned a cassette too.
At the trailer, he would angrily pluck away at his guitar. And sometimes, on the more difficult days, he would even pick fights with angry drunks at the hideout just to feel something.
When it inevitably didn’t, all he had to do was turn to that lucky little black tackle box to take his pain and anger away. And oh, what a familiar delight that was.
Anything to numb the pain of losing her. And what could have been.
As Eddie began to turn to his vices for comfort, Y/N found comfort in a few bad habits of her own.
Self-imposed isolation in times of turmoil was one. She hardly spoke to anyone at home or school. She couldn’t be seen without her headphones on or the Walkman attached to her hip.
It probably would have killed Eddie to know she couldn’t listen to Prince anymore. If she so much as listened to the first 3 seconds of any track on Purple Rain, she would fall apart.
But, on a hard day, she’ll pop in that one tape, lie in bed with the covers over her, and sob into her pillow as the ballad of Purple Rain flows into her ears like medicine.
The rest of her days include hiding away in her room or the library at school. She makes excuses to get out of hanging out with her friends. She cries at night and sleeps a lot during the weekends.
Another bad habit she turned to was extreme focus. All her newfound time and energy was devoted to the one and only thing in her life she could control: academics.
The self-imposed torture was alarming to many of the people in her life.
During the first week of her punishment, her parents were taken aback at her change of temperament, but figured she was just upset. But the longer it went on, the more worried they got. So did her friends and teachers.
When they all tried checking in on her she gave the same excuse that she was just stressed about college applications, which to a degree was true.
However, she could fool her teachers or her parents, but she couldn’t fool her friends.
Michelle especially knew something was up. Even though Y/N hadn’t told her anything about what happened that weekend with Eddie, Michelle figured it must have something to do with the reason Y/N was acting so weird.
And even though Y/N wanted it to be kept a secret, Michelle told the rest of the girls in their friend group, out of concern.
Just like Y/N thought, they were shocked at first, but she would be surprised to learn just how happy they were for her. Happy that Y/N finally found someone, even if it was a freak like Eddie Munson.
Immediately, they knew they had to talk to Eddie. Michelle was already at the defense, prepared to interrogate Eddie and literally fight him if he had done anything that would hurt Y/N.
Little did they know that what hurt Y/N the most was not being with him at all.
***
After her one month punishment was served, Y/N the zombie still hadn’t left. She continued to shut the world out.
Her parents tried to talk to her, wanting to understand why she was acting this way but she wouldn’t budge. She was giving them what they wanted, right? Anything more would be a death sentence.
And with early decision applications due soon, Y/N was in no place to waste time with friends or family or anything else that would distract her.
She mustered up the energy to craft them to perfection. With near perfect SAT scores and gpa, all that was left was to refine her resume and essays.
It only took many a sleepless night, but by the time she had a decent application together, she put them through an extensive review process.
She reviewed them with her current English teacher and every English teacher she had since she started high school.
She found another school counselor who could review them and even reviewed them with the school librarian.
And just when she thought they might be good enough, she even went to review them with the librarian at the public library in town.
Countless hours of editing, hundreds of pencil shavings, and red pen ink stains later and she was almost there.
Before she knew it, that dreaded November day was upon her. If she wanted her application to arrive by the deadline, she would have to mail them in soon.
One fateful Saturday morning, she sat in her room and rifled through her materials at least ten times to make sure every element of her application was present and accounted for, pristine, and completed to perfection.
She put them in the envelope and sealed it shut. With the packet addressed and ready to go, she left the house and bicycled over to the post office.
She walked through the doors setting off a jingling noise to her ears. She walked over to the counter and handed over the packet to the person working there.
In the blink of an eye, she sent three and a half years worth of work off its merry way to be scrutinized for her aptitude at the University of Chicago.
She had time before she would submit applications to her safety and reach schools. And with an application perfect enough for U Chicago, she knew she could reuse those same materials.
But this was it. All those hours studying, volunteering, and working built up to this moment. And suddenly, the pressure built on herself was free to flow from her shoulders down to her hands into that packet and on their way to Chicago, IL.
As she walks out the door and the bell chimes again, a sudden and intense pang feeling hits her chest.
Like a bomb, this gut level feeling hits her: she has no more control at this point. Between now and the time admission decisions get released, there is nothing she can do.
There is nothing now.
As she reaches the bike stand, she begins to weep and instinctively, her hand flies to cover her mouth.
At first it was a few hot tears quietly slipping their way down her cheeks. But then it became a deep seated cry, starting from her lungs and chest working their way up to her throat then her eyes and finally her head.
It had been weeks of crying, but now it felt explosive. For the first time since that dreadful night, she truly feels lost and alone.
Without a goal to keep her company or give her hope anymore, she’s never felt so small.
As she hops on her bike and cycles past a park, she wanders through a clearing in the woods. She finds access to a stream and hops off her bike to gently kneel before it, watching as the current lazily washes over the rocks. The light breeze in the air swooshes against her hair.
For a moment, she can see her muddled reflection in the water. Her teary eyes blinking rapidly and her cheeks red hot.
Once she was sure no one was around, she let it all out. No holding back. She held her head in her hands as she cried and screamed till her cheeks and lungs burned.
All these years, she’d spent 110% of her effort trying to be perfect for others, to submit to their scrutiny. It took every ounce of energy she had. The weight of it all that's been crushing her down all these years is suddenly gone.
For the first time, the pressure is gone. The need to be perfect, at an all time low.
It doesn’t matter what she does. Whatever is meant to happen will happen. The earth will still spin on its axis at a 23 degree angle. The sun will rise and fall no matter what she does. Or who she is.
At the very least, she’ll want to maintain her gpa to graduate as number 3 in her class, but otherwise… She doesn’t really have to do anything to prove herself anymore.
She can finally breathe.
She lowers her hands and looks at her reflection in the water. She laughs aloud and sighs.
When there were no tears left to cry, she regains her breath, dusts herself off and cycles back home.
***
Y/N feels a shift in her spirit. Like she's a new person, well, sort of. She’s no longer the girl that grinds herself to shreds to achieve her goals, well not until the next goal presents itself. But for now, she can relax. She can surrender to life.
What sort of person will she become with this newfound freedom? She doesn’t quite know.
When she gets home, she ignores the sounds of her parents and sister and goes upstairs. She locks herself in her room and searches through her closet. She takes out the dusty old half-used sketchbook. She sits at her desk, puts on her headphones, and starts her Walkman.
She takes out a perfectly sharpened, long, yellow, number two pencil. She lets the pencil hit the paper and it flies.
She draws and draws and draws for the rest of the day.
Without even thinking, she just draws whatever her hand feels like drawing. She fills pages and pages of the sketchbook. She never stops to eat or drink or even use the bathroom. She has years worth of drawing she needs to let out.
She draws pictures of Hawkins, her friends, memories of Chicago, her favorite album covers, her room the way it is now, her room the way she wished it had been decorated, her favorite movie posters, outfits she’s seen other people wear that she thought looked cool, people from school, landscapes of school, college applications, the stress of maintaining a perfect gpa, herself when she graduates, and Eddie.
She draws so many pictures of Eddie. Eddie in the library, Eddie at the diner, Eddie in his van, Eddie at the lake, Eddie and his beautiful long hair, Eddie’s lovely hands adorned with chunky rings, Eddie's tattoos, the new tattoos she had drawn on him that day, Eddie in a Hellfire shirt, Eddie in his Metallica crop top, Eddie in that jacket he wears like a uniform, Eddie with the chain on the jeans hung loose on his hips, Eddie with a bandana hanging out of his back pocket, Eddie in his room, Eddie playing guitar for her, Eddie teaching her how to play guitar.
Eddie Munson, the first boy to ever steal her heart.
It all comes out of her so fiercely. It takes over her like a spell. She was in the zone. She didn’t realize the magnitude of the force of her drawing till she woke up the next day still seated at her desk. Light seeping through the slits of the curtains. She turns to the side and sees a plate of what must have been dinner off to the side of the desk.
What? Who brought her that? When did they come in? Was Y/N already asleep? Surely they wouldn’t have left it if she was asleep. How did she not notice them?
She looks back at the clock on her wall that reads 12:36.
Y/N’s never woken up this late. What happened yesterday?
She looks down at the sketchbook opened at a page with a drawing of the Grease movie poster reimagined with her and Eddie smudged at different places.
Her desk is littered with pencil shavings, eraser filings, and broken or shorter pencils.
She flips through the pages filled with at least dozens of new drawings. Some are messy and crude while others are bright and beautiful.
She closes the sketchbook and holds it to her chest. She smiles and starts crying. She’s confused by the tears despite feeling relieved and realizes they’re tears of joy.
After all these years, she’s still got it. More than ever before, drawing has brought her so much joy. Joy she almost forgot even existed.
She takes a deep breath in satisfaction. This alone is enough to keep her happy. Even if she never makes a penny on her drawings, she’ll continue to do them. She doesn’t care what kind of job she has, as long as it can afford her to live comfortably and have time for this. Drawing. It’s what makes her happy. It’s what feeds her soul. It’s what makes her spirit soar.
She loves it so much, she just wishes she could share it with someone. But who? Her parents never cared for her talent. Her friends might think it’s cool the first few drawings but after that? Who knows.
Someone knocks on her door and slowly opens it. And for some reason, Y/N’s mind instantly runs to Eddie.
But it’s her sister who peeks through the crack in the door before sighing in relief and opening it all the way.
“Phew, you’re awake. And conscious.”
“What happened?”
“You stomped home and shut yourself in your room which is what you usually do now, but whenever we called you for lunch and dinner you didn’t answer so we checked in on you to see a drawing demon possessed you.”
Y/N looks around her desk.
“Are mom and dad mad?”
“Nah. They were weirded out at first but then they were just glad you weren’t crying or sleeping.”
“Oh,” Y/N replies, not sure if her parents' reaction is a good thing or a bad thing.
“Is everything okay? You’ve been acting really weird.”
Y/N glares at her sister. So much for the, now short lived, joy of drawing.
“It’s nothing.” Her sister would never understand.
“Is it because mom and dad won’t let you date? Just do it in secret. They won’t know the difference.”
“That was me trying to date him in secret,” Y/N offhandedly admits to herself. “Guess I’m no good at it.”
“It sucks, but you’ll get over it and then next thing you’ll know, you’ll have moved on to the next guy.”
Y/N shakes her head. “I don’t want to move into the next guy. I couldn’t even if I wanted to. You of all people should know that it’s not about which boy I date, but about not getting to date period.”
“You get better about hiding the more you do it.” Her sister shrugs.
“I don’t want to have to hide or lie about it. I hate doing that. I always feel horrible after.”
What Y/N wants is for her parents to be cool with her dating like her other friends' parents are. Y/N doesn’t want to feel like a bad daughter for falling in love.
Before her sister can respond, her mom calls out from downstairs.
“Is Y/N awake?”
“Yes,” her sister yells out.
“Come down, lunch is getting cold.”
Y/N’s sister raises her eyebrows before turning around and heading down stairs.
Y/N sullenly follows suit, trudging down the stairs. As she walks into the kitchen, she sees her family sitting at the table. Her mom's eyes light up when she sees Y/N.
Y/N begrudgingly takes a seat.
“Good afternoon sleeping beauty,” her mom teasingly greets. The words make Y/N cringe, but she musters a half smile.
“How are you feeling?”
Y/N shoves a fork into her food, “Fine”.
Y/N’s mom pointedly looks at her dad.
“We’re going to go to the grocery store after this, want to come? We can get your favorite cereal,” her mom excitedly offers.
What is Y/N, five years old?
“No thanks, I’m okay.”
“Are you sure? You’ve been up in your room an awful lot. Maybe it’ll do you good to go outside. Get some fresh air.”
Y/N shakes her head, “What’s the point? It’s not like I’m allowed to do anything fun right?”
“Drop the attitude Y/N,” her dad scolds.
“Y/N, you can’t be mad forever. There’ll be plenty of opportunities to have fun after high school.”
For a moment, Y/N thought she was in the clear. She thought things would get better again. But it turns out drawing was just the bandaid on a bullet wound.
The next day at school, Y/N’s mood slightly improves, only if she’s scribbling in her sketchbook.
Eddie notices her pulling it out in class and he could just cry. He’s so proud of her for getting into drawing again. He wishes he could say something to her or ask to see one of her drawings, but he knows there’s a line that’d be crossed if he did.
Later that day, Michelle and the rest of Y/N’s friends decide to finally talk to Eddie.
“You’re Eddie Munson, right?” Michelle asks as she approaches Eddie at his table at lunch.
“Who’s asking,” Eddie defensively replies.
“I’m Michelle, a friend of Y/N’s,” Michelle says and Eddie’s eyes soften. “We need to talk.”
Michelle leads him over to their lunch table where Y/N is undoubtedly gone again.
As Eddie sits down, the other girls stare at him, some confusingly, others surprisingly.
“What’s going on with Y/N. Is she okay?”
Michelle looks at him cautiously, “We could ask you the same thing Munson?”
“What are you talking about?” Eddie asks in confusion.
“We know something’s wrong with Y/N and we know you have something to do with it.”
“Uh, I’d say it’s more her parents fault than anything.”
The girls look at each other confused. Eddie furrows his own eyebrows in confusion.
“What do you mean?” Michelle asks.
“I mean, I know I’m kind of at fault for not being careful enough, but I just didn’t think her parents were going to find out, you know.”
“Y/N’s parents found out about you?!”
“Yeah,” Eddie responds looking at them curiously, “Did she not tell you?”
“Y/N hasn’t said a word to us since that weekend,” Michelle says. “Any idea why that is?”
“No,” Eddie shakes his head, “ I mean, I know why she’s avoiding me, but I don’t know why she would avoid you guys. She was grounded for a while and her parents wouldn’t let her go out or use the phone, but I’m pretty sure she could still talk to you at school.”
The girls look at each other in shock.
“Eddie, what exactly happened between you and Y/N that weekend,” Michelle asks. And Eddie tells the girls everything.
He tells them about how it all started with a simple chemistry assignment. That they’d seen each other practically every day after school. How she wanted to see him again, even though she was afraid of being caught. How much they’d grown to like each other, especially after that day at the lake.
But when he brought her home only thirty minutes past curfew, her parents absolutely flipped out. Her mom was outside waiting for her and saw Eddie. He had no idea what happened after that.
But when she’d called him later that night, she was crying. She’d sounded so heartbroken. And the following Monday at school, she called it off. And he hasn’t heard from her since.
“We need to go find Y/N right now,” Michelle declares as she stands up.
“And do what Michelle, interrogate her? It’s obvious she wants to be left alone.”
“She’s been left alone long enough. She needs us. All of us,” Michelle adds, looking pointedly at Eddie.
“And you, why didn’t you say anything? Why didn’t you do anything? You left her to deal with all that alone?” Michelle asks Eddie.
Eddie stands up and scowls, “Listen princess, you don’t know a thing about me, okay?”
Michelle and the other girls look at him with wide eyes and slack jaws.
“And I didn’t… I didn’t leave her to deal with it alone. I wanted to deal with it together, but she wouldn’t let me. She kept… pushing me away,” he mutters the last words through gritted teeth. He looks up at her, and she sees the pain and torment in his eyes.
Michelle looks at him with pity. She doesn’t know Eddie well, but it comes as a shock to see his tough guy persona facade crackling right in front of her very eyes.
She sits back down and takes a deep breath. Eddie sits down with her.
“Guys, what are we going to do?”
“Michelle’s right, maybe we should go talk to her, see what’s going on. Let her know we’re here for her.” One girl says.
“I don’t think it should be all of us though. I think she might get freaked out. You said she didn’t even want us to know right?” Another girl adds and Michelle nods.
“Maybe you should talk to her, Michelle. I think if it’s just you, she might be willing to open up.”
The lines in her forehead crease and she contemplates. “I don’t even know where to find her. I’ve seen her hide out in the library a few times and even then she always avoids me.”
“If she’s not there, she might be in the woods just past the school,” Eddie suggests.
“I think she has honor society meetings on Wednesdays too,” one girl adds.
“That’s today,” Michelle exclaims. “Okay, I know just what to do.”
“Wait,” Eddie juts his hand out.
“What?” Michelle asks.
Eddie’s eyebrows furrow and straighten. He blinks and opens his mouth, “I…”
The girls all look at him as he searches his brain for the right words to say.
“If you see Y/N, could you tell her that… I would let the whole world know I love Prince if it meant we could be together.”
***
For the rest of the school day, Michelle is lost in thought, planning out just what she’ll say to Y/N. A small part of her is worried the plan won’t work, but a bigger more determined part knows it will.
She knows Y/N tends to retreat inward when times get tough. That she hates letting it show when she has a moment of weakness, but that was usually over a bad test grade or minor problem she was having with someone in honor society. It’s never gotten this bad before.
Michelle waits for Y/N outside the honor society meeting room, nervously checking her watch. To her luck, Y/N is one of the last few to leave the room.
When Y/N walks out of the room, she doesn’t notice Michelle at first. Michelle stands straight and calls Y/N’s name. Y/N stops, like a deer frozen in headlights.
Michelle walks up to her and nervously smiles, “Hey.”
“Hi,” Y/N squeaks.
“Can we talk?” Michelle asks. Y/N looks at her nervously. “I was thinking we could go for a drive? I can give you a ride home too, so you don’t have to walk in the cold.”
Now that is an offer Y/N can’t refuse. But she still blinks nervously. “Ok.”
The two walk to the front of the school. “How was honor society today?”
“It was alright. We’re getting ready for winter formal.”
“Oh, that’s exciting,” Michelle says, “and stressful?”
“Exciting, yes,” Y/N laughs, “Stressful? Should be, but I just don’t have it in me to care anymore.”
“What?” Michelle asks in amused surprise. “Y/N, not caring about something school related? Who are you and what have you done with my best friend?”
Y/N weakly laughs. “It’s exhausting to care so much”
“Yeah, I hear that one” Michelle says as they get into her car.
They continue to make small talk as Michelle pulls into the parking lot of the public park by their houses. It’s the park they used to go to all the time as kids.
Michelle parks the car and looks over at Y/N.
“Hey girl, is everything okay? You’ve been really distant. The girls and I are starting to get worried about you.”
“Oh, haha, that?” Y/N laughs nervously, “sorry about that. I was just really caught up in college application season, you know? I just wanted to put all my time and effort into having the perfect application for U Chicago and didn’t want anything to distract me from it.”
Michelle sees through Y/N instantly. She knows there’s some truth in her explanation, but it’s not enough to explain the emotional distance too. But before she fully interrogates her, she decides to ease her way in.
“So how do you feel about your application? Have you submitted it yet?”
“Yeah, I submitted it over the weekend. I, um, I feel pretty good about it. I know I did the best I could. Just sort of worried it still won’t be…”
“Good enough?”
Y/N presses her lips together and nods.
“Y/N if U Chicago can’t see what a superstar you are, it is their loss, you hear me?”
Y/N smiles meekly, letting out a breathy laugh.
“Seriously. They’d be so lucky to have you as a student. You’re the smartest, most hardworking and talented person I know.”
“Thanks Michelle,” Y/N softly smiles. “It’s all just really nerve-wracking.”
“I know, but we all believe in you. You need to believe in yourself too, okay?”
“Yeah, I’m… trying,” Y/N smiles weakly.
Michelle looks down at the sketchbook in Y/N’s lap and smiles up at her.
“You’re drawing again?”
Y/N’s eyes widen, “Oh, um, yeah.”
“That’s awesome!” Michelle compliments, looking Y/N sincerely in the eye.
Y/N smiles shyly and looks away, “Yeah, um, now that I don’t have to worry about college applications that much anymore, I have more time for, um, this.”
“That’s really great. I’m happy you’re drawing again. I know how much you missed it.”
Y/N winces and smiles. “Yeah.”
Michelle leans over and peeks at the pages between Y/N’s fingers “Can I see one?”
Y/N’s head shoots up and her eyes grow to the size of golf balls. She clutches the sketchbook to her chest and tenses her shoulders.
Michelle nervously laughs and leans back, “I mean, if you ever wanted to, I’d love to see what you’ve drawn.”
Y/N loosens her grip and looks down. In a dream world, no one would ever bear witness to her creations. To live inside her mind this way would be too invasive. But at the same time, what’s the use of creating something if it isn’t meant to be shared with the world. As scary as the world is, her best friend might be a good start.
She opens the book slowly and flips through the pages to find one she knows Michelle will like.
It’s a picture of all the girls together at Starcourt mall. The day they went to see Footloose together. She even drew the movie poster in the corner.
She puts the book on display for Michelle and shs grabs the ends.
“Y/N,” Michelle squeaks, eyes widened in awe. “I love it.”
“Portraits and faces aren’t really my forte, but it’s a bit easier to draw things from memory.”
“No, no it’s perfect. The girls would love it too.”
Y/N frowns and Michelle tenses. “I mean, if you ever wanted to show them.”
Y/N presses her lips together.
“Y/N, I miss you Y/N. We all do. Why don’t you come sit with us at lunch anymore?”
Y/N opens her mouth to reply but nothing comes out.
“Did we do something to upset you?” Michelle asks cautiously.
“No, no,” Y/N shakes her head. “I’m just… I’ve just been busy, is all.”
“Y/N,” Michelle scolds.
“I-I am.” Y/N shrugs.
Michelle takes a deep breath in, “I know you’ve been busy with college applications and everything, butThis… This wouldn’t have anything to do with a certain member of the Hellfire Club, would it?”
Y/N eyes nearly pop out of her head as every muscle in her body tenses. “What?” She mutters between gritted teeth.
“I noticed you started avoiding us after that weekend you said you were going out with him. Did something happen?”
“Um, no, no. Nothing happened,” Y/N says nervously.
Michelle cocks an eyebrow, “Y/N, did Eddie do anything to… hurt you?”
“What?! No! No… Quite the opposite actually.”
“Oh, so what happened?”
“What happened?”
“Yeah, what happened with you and Eddie that weekend?”
“Um, it was… I just realized he wasn’t the right guy for me,” Y/N replies as she looks down and fidgets with the corners of her sketchbook.
Michelle glares at Y/N. Y/N peers up at Michelle.
“What?” Y/N asks innocently.
“Why are you lying?”
“I-I’m no—“
“Bullshit Y/N. I know what happened. Eddie told us everything.”
Y/N gasps, “You talked to Eddie?”
Michelle nods.
Y/N grows teary eyed imagining Eddie tell her friends about the moments they shared together in his trailer, at the diner, at the lake, in the back of his van.
“He told you… Everything?”
Michelle grabs Y/N’s hand and squeezes, “Everything.”
Y/N wiggles her hand out of Michelle’s grasp and brings both to cover her face. She hangs her head in her hands and starts sobbing.
“Y/N,” Michelle says endearingly. She wraps her arms around her and hugs her tightly. Y/N leans into her touch and continues to sob. Her teardrops run down her cheeks as her palms squish them flat.
“I know, I know. It’s okay,” Michelle comfortingly hums as she strokes Y/N’s hair.
She’s never seen Y/N like this before. She knows Y/N hates crying in front of others, so it must be something bad enough to make her act like this.
When some of her sobs soften, Michelle says, “Y/N I’m sorry things didn’t turn out the way you wanted it to, but you were so brave for putting yourself out there. It took a lot of courage.”
Y/N sniffles and sobs even harder. “It was so hard. It hurts so much.”
“I know, I know. It took a lot of guts. I’m proud of you for even trying.”
Y/N sheds a few more tears before moving her hands away and looking at Michelle.
“Really?”
Michelle smiles at Y/N’s puffy eyes and blotchy cheeks.
“Of course! I know how you are. And I know how your parents are. For someone who hardly ever listens to their heart, I’m glad you did this time. I know it must’ve been scary, but not a lot of people have the courage to follow their heart and do what makes you happy, especially when no one else understands.”
Y/N raises her eyebrows. Michelle places a hand on Y/N’s shoulder, “You deserve to be happy Y/N, even if it’s the school freak causing it ”
Y/N looks away and laughs. She mutters, “it doesn’t feel that way. My parents made sure of that.”
“Have you tried talking to them?”
Y/N glares at Michelle, “Not since the night it happened. They made it pretty clear they won’t budge on their stance.”
“Things are different now, right? Maybe that night they were just caught up in the heat of the moment. Maybe it’d be different if you tried talking to them now.”
“And what would I say? Hey mom, dad, can I please have a boyfriend? Pretty, please? All my friends have one.”
“No,” Michelle rolls her eyes and chuckles, “I’m just saying, let your parents know where you’re coming from. You’re a great daughter. They have every reason to trust you. And they should trust they raised a responsible girl.”
“Michelle,” Y/N shakes her head. “There’s no way I can do that. My parents aren’t like the parents you see on tv or in movies. I can’t just negotiate things with them. What they say is law and I have to abide by that if I want to make it out of there alive.”
Michelle frowns, “What if we were there with you?”
“Huh,” Y/N wipes her cheek.
“What if the girls and I were there with you while you talked to your parents? For moral support. And evidence of how great of a person you are to support your case.”
Y/N rolls her eyes, “you still have 4 years till you go to law school Miche, you don’t need to practice your lawyer skills on me.”
Michelle rolls her eyes and smiles. “It’s not like that, I’m simply exercising my human right to support my friends. So what if the scales of justice propel my life?”
Y/N laughs. “Thanks, but, in all honesty, I don’t think it’d be worth it. We’d all be wasting our time. My parents tell my sister and I time and time again that they’re not one of our friends. I doubt they’d care what you all have to say.”
Michelle searches Y/N’s eyes. She won’t take no for an answer. If not this way, then she'll find another, but she has to know. “If you knew there was a chance they might listen to what you have to say, and that you could convince them, would you want that?”
“What do you mean?”
“For arguments sake, let’s just say you could somehow convince your parents to let you date Eddie and actually change their minds about the whole thing.”
“Okay?”
“Would you want that to happen? To be able to change their minds?”
Without hesitation Y/N says, “Of course.”
Michelle grabs her hand and pauses for a moment before asking, “Do you miss Eddie?”
Y/N peers up at Michelle before looking down at her lap, brows furrowed. “I’m trying really hard not to.”
“I think he is too.”
“What,” Y/N eagerly looks at Michelle.
“Yeah. That boy has a real soft spot for you.”
Y/N scrunches her nose, “I don’t know about that.”
“He wanted me to tell you he really did love Purple Rain. Wouldn’t have pegged him for a Prince fan, personally.”
Y/N sniffles and laughs, “I guess that’s kind of my doing. We don’t really like the same music, but Prince became the one thing we could agree on.”
Michelle smiles at her.
“He learned to play a few songs for me too. It was really sweet,” Y/N sighs happily before her features turn down again. “Anytime I listen to his music, I think of Eddie and it makes me really sad.”
Michelle sighs. Y/N, who’s always been so strong, has never looked more weak and defeated.
Y/N might have lost hope, but Michelle hasn’t. She knows they can find a way to make things right. But for now, she doesn’t exactly know what that way is.
***
For the rest of the week, Y/N carries on like usual. She starts making brief appearances at lunch, but she usually comes up with some excuse to leave early.
When Y/N’s gone, Michelle tells the girls what happened when she talked to Y/N. “I don’t know how we’re going to do it, but we are going to make sure Y/N’s parents let her date Eddie.”
“How exactly are we going to do that?” One girl asks.
“I don’t know,” Michelle slumps in her seat. “I really think they’d hear Y/N out if one of us was there too. Especially if all of us are there. She needs our moral support and there’s strength in numbers.”
“Wouldn’t her parents just think we’re ambushing them?” Another girl asks.
“Maybe,” Michelle contemplates, “But maybe it wouldn’t be a complete ambush if Y/N didn’t know.”
“What?”Another girl asks. “Wouldn’t that be worse to just walk up to their door like, surprise! Now will you please give us ten minutes to convince you why our best friend should have a boyfriend?”
“Not exactly. But I think if we showed up and really talked to them, we could find common ground saying how we’ve been concerned about Y/N from the way she’s been acting and wanted to check on her. We heard what’s happened with Eddie and wanted to let you know how great of a guy he is for her.” Michelle explains.
“Shouldn’t Eddie be here for this conversation then?” One girl asks.
“I don’t know, should he?” Another chimes in.
“Yeah, he probably should. I mean, we are trying to get them back together right?”
“Yeah, let me go get him,” Michelle says. She walks over to Eddie’s table and summons him back to theirs.
“Here’s the deal Eddie, I talked to Y/N and she’s doing a lot better, but she’s still really broken up by this whole situation. So, I propose we all go to her house and talk to her parents to see if we can convince them to let you two date.”
“What? Are you out of your mind?” Eddie scowls. “No way. It’s a miracle I left her house in one piece that night.”
“Eddie, don’t tell me you’re scared of Mr. and Mrs. Y/L/N?”
“I’m not… scared. I just know what I’m up against. I know her parents don’t like me and don’t want us to be together.”
“Well, I can’t guarantee they’ll like you any more after this, but if you want to date their daughter, they’ll at least need to respect you.”
Eddie sneers. In what world could any of this possibly work?
“And we’ll be right there with you. They like us, so you’ll get like ten points by association.”
Eddie shakes his head. He can at least pretend to entertain the thought that talking to her parents could work. “Okay, so what do I have to do?”
“You need to come with us, be presentable and on your best behavior, and help us convince Y/N’s parents to let her date you.”
Eddie rolls his eyes. “What? You want me to grovel to her parents? No way.”
“Eddie c’mon.”
“No, not happening. Why should I be the one to kiss their asses? Why should I have to change myself for their approval? I swore to myself I’d never do that shit again.”
“Eddie, we’re not asking you to change yourself. It’s obvious Y/N likes you just the way you are. We’re not messing with that. We just need to show her parents… your good side.”
“My good side?”
“Yeah. Show them what a gentleman you are. That you’re gonna take care of their daughter and treat her with respect. That you’ll be a good influence on her.”
Eddie scowls in disgust. “What else? Do you want me in a monkey suit too? Cut my hair to a suitable non-Beatle length?”
“Eddie, work with us, okay? We’re on the same team.”
Eddie sighs and runs a hand through his hair.
“Look, let’s try a little role play. I’ll be her parents and you just answer as yourself.”
“Not the kind of role play I’d willingly get into but okay.”
“Eddie.”
“I was talking about D&D,” Eddie snickers.
Michelle rolls her eyes, “Okay, Eddie, is it. What are your intentions with our daughter?”
“To corrupt her. Stray her away from the path of God. Convert her into a super senior freak like me,” he answers confidently and smiles crazily with his tongue hanging out.
Michelle smacks his arm, “Eddie, I know you think you’re being funny right now, but this is serious. Do you want to be with Y/N yes or no?”
Eddie sighs and looks away, muttering, “Yes.”
“Okay, let’s try this again. Eddie, what are your intentions with our daughter?”
Eddie closes his eyes and breathes in. He opens them and looks straight into Michelle’s eyes. “I want to date your daughter. I know she isn’t normally allowed, but I care about her a lot and want to have an honest conversation about why I should.”
“Ooh,” the girls all coo.
Michelle raises her brows and nods, “Okay, that’s a start.”
“Ugh,” Eddie sneers. “I feel like I’m in court, pleading my case.”
“In a way, you are Munson. Her parents are the judge and we’re all witnesses. But lucky for you, I’m your attorney.”
“What?” Eddie asks with disdain.
“I want to be a lawyer when I’m older. I’ve been able to argue my way out of pretty much anything since I was 5.”
“Where were you the night we got caught?” Eddie rolls his eyes.
Michelle shakes her head. “Okay, let’s try another one. Eddie, our darling Y/N is a stellar student on the way to becoming a freshman at the University of Chicago. How are you doing in school? What are your plans after graduation?”
Eddie begins sweating, throat growing dry. “I don’t know what to say.”
“What do you mean?”
“I know the answer to that question isn’t something they want to hear.”
“Here we’ll workshop it. Just give me the real answer and we’ll work on the wording together.”
“Um, this is my third senior year and I don’t even know if I’ll graduate so I haven’t even thought that far enough?”
“Yikes, okay—“
Eddie rubs a palm over his face, “See! This is stupid there’s no way they’re gonna say yes to this,” Eddie comments as he points to his face.
“Eddie, get a grip, okay,” Michelle orders as she grabs his shoulders and shakes him. “It’s really starting to piss me off how hopeless you and Y/N are being about this.”
Eddie scoffs, “I hate this. I never care what anyone thinks about me. But for Y/N… for some reason, I do. It was enough of a miracle for her to like me. And I normally wouldn’t care what her parents think either, but it means enough to her for me to.”
Michelle looks at him understandingly.
“And her parents… I barely met her mom so not enough to get a real impression. But from what Y/N’s told me… I’m terrified. I mean, you've met her parents right? How are you not afraid of them?”
“Well for one, I know how to kiss ass to get what I want. But two, I’m not really afraid of anyone. If someone doesn’t like me that’s their problem. And if they make it my problem, I know I can just change their minds. It’s really not that hard. Just takes a little work.”
“For you, maybe,” Eddie spits.
“That’s what I keep trying to tell you Eddie. I’m here to help you and Y/N. We only have a fighting chance if we all combine our strengths together.”
Eddie humphs knowing Michelle is right.
“So what should I say?”
“Well, you can admit that academics aren’t your strong suit in the way Y/N’s are. It sounds nice and it’s the truth. Then just tell them what other things you’re good at.”
“Um, so I could just say… Can you repeat the question?”
“Sure. What are you like in school Eddie? Any big plans after graduation?”
“Um, school is… okay… but not exactly where I shine. I leave that all to Y/N,” Eddie laughs nervously.
“That’s good,” one girl encourages.
“She’s right, that was good,” Michelle says. “Go on.”
“I, um, play guitar. I’ve been playing for as long as I can remember. I used to play for the school band, but stopped so I could form my own band. We, um, have a gig at a small venue just outside town every Tuesday.”
“That’s good. What about life after graduation?”
“Um, as for after graduation. I… won’t be going to college. I plan to start working. I used to, um… help my dad work on cars when I was younger. I still do it sometimes with my Uncle so I think I’ll probably try to become a mechanic.”
The girls look at him and contemplate his answer.
Eddie nervously looks across their faces, “How was that? Was that… good?”
Michelle looks off into space, “Yeah, I’m just trying to think if there’s anything they might find an issue with but no I think that answer was good.”
Eddie nods.
“And just so you know, humility goes a long way with them. Having confidence is good, but if you get cocky with them they’re gonna hate it. The nervous ums and stuff will help.”
Eddie quirks his eyebrow. “Remind me to hire you when you pass the bar.”
Michelle mocks salutes, “Will do Munson.”
“So, what else do you think they’ll ask?”
“Well they’ll probably just try to get to know you. Know what their daughter is getting into. They might ask you about your interests and hobbies or your family and friends.”
Eddie sharply inhales.
“Listen, you don’t have to tell them anything you don’t want to, but give them enough. They’ll want to know what Y/N’s getting herself into and trust that she’ll be okay.”
“No pressure right?” Eddie uncomfortably jokes.
“Eddie, the most important question you’ll need to answer is: why should we let you date our daughter?”
Eddie gulps. His forehead creases as he tries to find the right words.
“Because… I really like her. And… she’s a great girl.” Eddie winces and shrugs
Michelle furrows her eyebrows and leans forward, “Eddie, dig deep. Is that really all you’ve got?”
“No, I'm just… I don’t know what to say, man. I’m not good with words.”
“Well you better find them. This is your only shot at getting Y/N back and I’d hate to see you blow it.”
Eddie scowls at Michelle. She’s annoying, but she’s right. What other choice does he have? If he can’t change Y/N’s mind, maybe he can change her parent’s minds.
Will they be reasonable people? Who the hell knows. But he’ll be damned if he doesn’t even try.
“Fine, let me try again,” He sys through partially gritted teeth.
Michelle gives him a small encouraging smile. She takes a beat and repeats the question, “So Eddie, why should we let you date our daughter?”
Eddie takes a deep breath in. He furrows his eyebrows in concentration.
“Well Mr. and Mrs. Y/L/N,” he cringes at the formality, “Dating Y/N is an honor I’m not quite sure I even deserve. Believe me, I don’t take it for granted one second that a beautiful girl like her, as smart as she is, even likes someone like me. Does Y/N deserve a guy like me? Probably not. She deserves the damn world. And I’ll do everything I can to give it to her.”
The girls all widen their eyes and say their “aw’s”
Eddie flinches, “And, um, I promise to take care of her. To respect her. To listen to her. To support her. Whatever she needs, I want to give that to her and more.”
Michelle nods, “That’s it.”
***
The next day drones on as usual, till Y/N stays after school for tutoring. After her session with a boy on the basketball team is over, she clears up her desk and packs her things in her bag.
“Good work Travis, I’ll see you next week,” she waves him off as he leaves his desk and exits the classroom.
She exits the classroom soon after and makes her way down the empty hall. She turns into a different hallway and nears the drama room. She slows down her pace to a stop before the closed door. She takes a deep breath in and edges closer to the small window on the door, only to find an empty room with the light turned odd. She lets a breath out and sullenly walks toward the front of the school.
She opens the doors and tightens her jacket to her chest as a blast of cold air hits her in the face. She grits her teeth, bracing for the cold, and nearly chokes on the scent of cigarette smoke nearby.
As she approaches the parking lot, a cloud of smoke presents the nearby offender, no doubt leaning against the pillar. She cranes her head in an attempt to see who it might be, but the view is blocked.
She shrugs it off and continues to walk, not caring enough to investigate further. She has to get home and out of this wretched cold. November is off to quite a frigid start.
“Y/N?” A voice undoubtedly coming from the smoker calls out to her.
Y/N freezes in her tracks. She should just ignore him and keep walking, but her body won’t let her.
“Y/N,” the voice calls out again and Y/N turn over her heels. She finds Eddie leaning against the pillar, one leg bent, foot pressed against the cinderblock. He drops the cigarette in his hand and lowers his foot to stomp it out. His hair shakes and the chain on his jeans jingle in the process.
Y/N’s throat dries as she nervously watches him, still very frozen in place.
Eddie cautiously walks, no struts, over to her, reeboks stomping against the pavement in the process, and offers her the smallest smile. Even after all this time, just seeing him like this is enough to make her heart skip a beat.
Shut up heart, It’s just Eddie.
“Hey,” Eddie whispers in a raspy voice, peering deep into her eyes.
“Hey,” Y/N squeaks, surprising herself by returning his strong gaze. She hasn’t spoken to Eddie in weeks.
They stare blankly at each other for a moment before Y/N is the first to break the silence. “What are you doing here?”
“Needed to clear my head,” he shrugs casually.
Y/N cocks an eyebrow up, “On school grounds, when last class let out an hour ago?”
Eddie shrugs painfully, “Yeah.”
Y/N gives him an unconvinced look.
“Was supposed to be at Hellfire, but I cut the meeting short.”
“Oh,” Y/N whispers, “What happened?”
Eddie presses his lips together, “The boys were just… their heads weren’t in the game, you know?”
Not really, but she nods as if she does. The tension in his eyebrows and clenched jaw tell her it wouldn’t be such a good idea to poke the bear.
“What about you?” Eddie asks.
“Tutoring,” Y/N meekly responds.
Eddie nods and notices the way Y/N tightens her arms crossed over her chest and the slight shivering of her shoulders.
“You headed home?”
Y/N turns over her shoulder and nods at him.
Eddie reaches back and scratches at the back of his neck. “Could I, uh, give you a ride home? If that’s okay?”
“I don’t know if that’s such a good idea,” Y/N mumbles.
“C’mon, it’s freezing out. Can’t have my local smart pants getting sick on my watch.”
Y/N slightly snorts at his comment and it brings a grin to Eddie’s face.
“Thanks Eddie, but I-”
“C’mon,” He gently grabs her wrist, “You’re off probation right?”
He winks and she surprisingly finds the humor in a joke about the longest month of her life.
Y/N nods and Eddie tugs, leading her to his van. “Your chariot awaits.”
Y/N complies in a stunned silence. As she climbs into the van, the worn seats feel foreign under her skin. They can’t be the same seats she sat in a little over a month ago.
But much like Hawkins, nothing in this van has changed, only her.
Eddie starts the car and remains stationary to let the vehicle warm up. They sit in a comfortable silence as Eddie tunes the radio to Y/N’s favorite station even though a commercial is on. Y/N refrains from smiling despite the tug she feels at the corner of her mouth.
Once the van has warmed up, Eddie pulls out of the parking lot and off to Y/N’s house. His rough slender fingers curled around the steering wheel.
The two remain in comfortable silence till they reach a stop light and suddenly, Cyndi Lauper’s Time After Time comes on.
Both Eddie and Y/N instantly look at each other when the melancholy rhythm fills their ears. Before the first verse is sung, the light turns green and Eddie’s attention is back on the road while Y/N’s is on her lap. She can feel the blood pumping in her veins along the beat of the song
Lying in my bed, I hear the clock tick and think of you
Caught up in circles
Confusion is nothing new
Flashback, warm nights
Almost left behind
Suitcase of memories
Time after
Sometimes you picture me
I'm walking too far ahead
You're calling to me, I can't hear
What you've said
Then you say, "go slow"
And I fall behind
The second hand unwinds
But before Cyndi can sing the heartfelt lyrics, “If you're lost you can look and you will find me, time after time,” Y/N lowers the volume to silence.
She looks up at him, “That song is…”
Eddie nervously laughs, “Yeah, ha, I know.”
He awkwardly looks back onto the road before him.
Y/N’s a bit surprised he even knows the song. She guesses no one can escape the heartfelt words of Cyndi Lauper, but they just ring too close to home, in a car ride with Eddie no less.
In a matter of minutes, Eddie is pulling up to Y/N’s house. She’s simultaneously thankful this carride is almost over and disappointed that this is all the time she’ll get with Eddie.
She looks out the window and glances at the red brick home. This time with a noticeable lack of tension in her shoulders or heart rate that would alarm several doctors. This time, she feels nothing.
She turns over and looks at Eddie who is intently observing her reaction. “Everything okay?”
Y/N nods sullenly. Eddie looks at her, waiting to see what she’ll do next.
Y/N looks out the window again and sees a few of the neighborhood children out riding their bikes. She turns back to Eddie and curves her lips upward slightly.
“Thanks for the ride Eddie.”
Eddie looks at her puzzled, but more relieved than anything that she’s not ardently avoiding him.
“No problem,” he nods, “I’ll always have your back.”
Y/N cocks her head to the side before shaking it and unbuckling her seatbelt.
“Goodbye Eddie,” she sweetly says as she opens the door.
“Goodbye sweetheart,” Eddie says. Y/N freezes for a slight second, feeling her heart constrict in her chest. She recovers by climbing out of the vehicle and shoving her bag over her back. She closes the door behind her and smiles at Eddie. He nods and waits for her to enter the home.
She slowly walks to the door. There’s no reason to rush and avoid the risk of being caught. She already has been.
She opens the door to the house and turns over her shoulder to see Eddie wave and drive off.
She steps inside, embracing the welcomed heat.
“Hey honey, how was school?” Her mom calls from the kitchen. For a second, her brain is on red alert, worried that her mom might’ve seen Eddie’s car. But as quickly as the thought enters her head, it leaves. What’s the worst that could happen? She gets grounded again? Her parents put some restraining order on Eddie?
“Hey mom. School was fine,” Y/N neutrally responds.
“Learn anything exciting?”
“Not really,” Y/N responds truthfully before excusing herself to go upstairs and work on some homework before dinner.
At the back of her head, she worried her mom might’ve seen Eddie and was just waiting to bring it up later, but as the evening turned into night, nothing ever happened.
Either she didn’t know or she wasn’t bothered enough to say anything.
***
When Friday night rolled around, Y/N enjoyed the refuge of her own bedroom, as she had for the past several weeks. But this time, she felt more restless than usual.
None of the songs on her tape deck sounded right. None of her drawings were coming out quite right. Even when she went downstairs to rummage through the pantry, none of the snacks appealed to her despite the loud rumbling coming from her stomach.
She trudged back up the stairs and into her room and decided to do something she hadn’t done in a really long time. She closed the door and turned off all the lights. She walked over to the window and opened the curtain. For a second, she almost hoped to find Eddie down below, throwing rocks at her window once again.
She brought her desk chair near the window and sat on it. She closed her eyes and took in a deep breath. She sat in silence like that for a few breaths before opening her eyes and gazing out at the stars above her.
A lot of the streetlights were on, so it was hard to see, but the few she could, she decided to count them.
One. Two. Three. Four. Five Six. Seven.
She closed her eyes and pleaded to the stars, asking for answers as to what she should do.
The ritual began when she was a young girl, praying to God for an A on her test or for her parents to stop fighting. Over the years it turned into harder questions she couldn’t ask anyone else but the stars up above.
Something about starry skies was more comforting to her spirit than any church could ever be. Oftentimes, they had better answers too.
But tonight, there was only silence.
“Please, I need to know,” Y/N pleaded. She rubbed her palms over her face and rested her chin in her hands.
She wished the stars could tell her what to do. She wished they could give her an answer.
Ever since she’d spoken to Michelle and ran into Eddie, Y/N had been feeling conflicted. Once the heat simmered down and she served her sentence, Y/N kept laying low. School and drawing took up a majority of her time and she thought she would be fine with that. But Michelle and Eddie reminded her just how much she’d missed the people in her life.
She knows that Michelle and her other friends will always be in her corner. Sometimes she needs time alone to figure things out, but they’ll always be there when she comes back.
But Eddie… She almost lost him forever. Her car ride with him confirmed just how big that almost was, but she knows they’re on thin ice.
She looks out to the stars, hoping for an answer. They glimmer against the dark night sky, but say little else.
She wants Eddie back in her life, even if she can’t date him which she knows is impossible. But, since her parents don’t seem to be too upset anymore, Y/N’s willing to bet they might tolerate Eddie as a friend.
She knows it might take some begging and pleading, but she knows she’s earned it. And that Eddie would be worth fighting for.
But before she does any of that, maybe it would be a good idea to see Eddie and talk to him first. She knows she could call him up, but this is a conversation that needs to be had in person.
Maybe she could surprise him at the trailer tomorrow. She doesn’t know if it’ll go well, but it’s worth a shot.
***
The next morning Eddie and Y/N’s friends meet up at Michelle’s house.
“Glad you could finally show up,” Michelle greets Eddie as she lets him through the front door. “Even though you smell like an ashtray.”
Eddie huffs as he follows Michelle, “Excuse me for wanting to calm my jangled nerves.”
Michelle leads him to her room where the rest of the girls are hanging out. “Relax Eddie, we have your back. And with a few adjustments, you’ll be ready to go.”
Eddie cocks his eyebrow and looks over at the other girls milling about the room.
“Take a seat,” Michelle gestures toward her bed. Eddie cautiously sits at the edge and looks up at the other girls in confusion.
“Good to know you have a pair of pants without holes in them,” one of the girls quips as another starts working on his hair.
“Is it that hard to believe,” Eddie asks sarcastically.
“Little bit,” she winks and smiles. Eddie nervously chuckles and lets out a small sigh of relief.
“I’m not crazy about the Black Sabbath shirt though,” Michelle complains as one of the girls gently combs through Eddie’s hair.
“This is all I have. Sorry I can’t be Tom Cruise.”
“Well, you don’t need to be Tommy Lee either.”
Eddie scoffs and narrows his eyes, “You insult me.”
“Stop moving,” the girl doing his hair orders. She brings a hand to block his face and sprays water along his locks before combing through and applying a gel.
“And this jacket situation has got to go,” one of the girls comments as she glares at his leather jacket and jean vest.
Eddie rolls his eyes, “Cmon, it’s the only jacket I have. It’s a part of me.”
“Keep still,” The girl doing his hair orders as she scrunches at the damp locks, creating a more defined curl to his tresses.
“Not to worry, you can still be you even without your metal uniform. I bet there’s a jacket my brother left behind that you can borrow.”
“Huh?”
“He’s off at Indiana State, so what he doesn’t know won’t hurt him.”
Eddie shrugs as Michelle rummages through the coat closet down the hall.
“At least it covers your tattoos. Y/N’s parents… aren’t the most fond of those,” one of the other girls comments.
Michelle walks over with a maroon cable knit sweater and cream colored carpenter jacket.
“When your hair is done, put these on.”
Eddie reaches out and touches the knit fabric, masking a look of disgust in his face, “I feel like I should be on the cast of Happy Days.”
“Take off your shoes too.”
“What?”
“Take off your shoes.”
“Why?”
“So we can clean them. Muddy Reeboks are very punk rock but that won’t impress Y/N’s parents.”
“Punk? Please, you insult me,” Eddie snarls. “There’s a very big difference between punk and metal.”
“Why don’t you tell that to Y/N’s parents,” one of the girls sarcastically snickers.
“Why don’t you bite me,” Eddie snarls.
“Eddie,” Michelle gasps.
“And you,” Michelle looks pointedly at the girl, “Knock it off.”
“Girls, could I have a moment alone with Eddie,” Michelle pleads.
“Fine, okay,” the girls grumble.
“I’m done with your hair Eddie. I kept it natural, but a little more defined at the curls. They’re gonna love it, and so will Y/N,” the last girl to leave pats Eddie on the shoulder and smiles.
Eddie’s shoulders relax and he smiles back at her as she leaves the room.
Michelle pulls the chair from her desk and sets it in front of Eddie. She takes a seat and tries to look Eddie in the eye despite his avoidant gaze.
“Eddie,” Michelle calls out to him. Eddie looks at her from the corner of his eye. “Look, it’s just us, okay?”
Eddie sighs exasperatedly. “What?”
“Eddie, relax okay. I know you’re nervous but–”
“I’m not nervous.”
“Then what are you Eddie? ‘Cause you’re acting really weird.”
Eddie widens his eyes and furrows his eyebrows. He turns away and reaches to scratch the back of his neck, “I don’t know man. Just feels weird.”
“What feels weird?”
“All of it. Feels like I’m about to take a test or something. I mean, this isn’t me. Changing my hair?”
“Well, your hair doesn’t look that different, just a little neater.”
“Changing my clothes?”
Michelle gazes at the sweater and jacket laid out next to him.
“Changing myself?”
Michelle’s eyes turn down.
“I know, we’re asking a lot of you. But we wouldn’t be asking this if we knew it wouldn’t make Y/N happy… We’re on your side.”
Eddie furrows his eyebrows and nods.
“What’s wrong Eddie?”
Eddie shakes his head, “I mean we’re doing all this, but what’s the point? What if I’m still not good enough for them?”
Or good enough for her.
Michelle sighs and pats his knee. “Eddie, look, I don’t know you that well, but what I do know is that you’re a fighter.”
“Bullshit,” Eddie laughs.
“I’m no fighter. See this guy?” Eddie points to himself. “Textbook runner. When the going gets tough I… always seem to run.”
Michelle takes a cold hard look at him. “What are you running from?”
“What?”
“You said you’re a runner right? So what exactly are you running from?”
Eddie shrugs, “I don’t know.”
“There’s gotta be something.”
Eddie stares at her blankly.
“I mean, do you even want us to do this anymore?”
Eddie nods and looks at her, in a way she can’t decipher.
“So, what is it Eddie?”
Eddie can’t tell her he runs away because he’s scared. He’s afraid to fight because he’s afraid he’ll lose. That the voice of his old man still looms in his head telling him so.
“What have you got to lose?” Michelle asks.
Eddie thinks about it for a moment. He supposes there’s nothing to lose at this point. The worst her parents could say is no, again. That he’d spend another excruciating day without Y/N.
“Look, you gotta promise this stays between us, alright?”
Michelle nods and takes a finger to make a cross motion over her chest. “Cross my heart.”
“You flap your lips about this to anyone and your ass is grass you hear that?”
Michelle stifles a laugh, sensing the seriousness in Eddie’s tone. “Okay.”
“I know what people in this no good town think of me. I know it’s not great. And as much as I hate to admit, it’s a lot harder to let it roll off my back than I’d like.”
Michelle nods in understanding.
“I want Y/N’s parents to… accept me. It’s stupid and ridiculous, but I do. But I don’t want it to come at the cost of conformity.”
“Eddie, I don’t think you give yourself enough credit. You’re a surprisingly likable person. In all your dorky metal loving glory.”
Eddie chuckles and rolls his eyes.
“I think that’s why Y/N probably likes you so much. You’re someone who isn’t afraid to be themselves. And I think she is, but you show her how not to be.”
Eddie’s eyes soften at the surprising observation.
“When you’re not so guarded or sarcastic or cocky, you’re not such a bad guy. And I think Y/N’s deserve a chance to see that side of you. They might even surprise you.” Michelle adds.
Eddie thinks about it. He wonders if Y/N’s parents could truly surprise him.
“But besides that, this isn’t all just about you, you know? I mean, I know your ass is on the line, but so is Y/N’s. This is a battle Y/N’s been fighting her parents forever on and she needs our help.”
Eddie purses his lips and furrows his brows.
“So what do you say, hot shot? Are you just gonna sit there or are you gonna stand up and fight for your girl?” Michelle roars
Eddie's eyes widen. He feels as though a literal fire has been sparked inside him.
His girl.
He doesn’t want to be a runner. Not anymore. He wants to be a fighter. If not for him, then for his girl.
“Alright. Okay,” Eddie nods.
“That’s not good enough. I need to hear you say it Eddie.”
“I’m gonna fight.”
“You’re gonna what?”
“I’m gonna fight,” Eddie exclaims.
“Who are you gonna fight for Eddie?”
“For Y/N!”
“And?”
“For us!”
“And?”
“And?”
“Who else are you fighting for?”
“Uh, love?”
“No silly,” Michelle pokes harshly at his chest, “You’re fighting for you too.”
----------------------------------------------
Tag list: @dotslabyrinth @aedicn @fancyghosttrashhero-blog @churchmuffins @urallidjits @delusionalbabe @astrolockley @ebueller @im-julessssss @kimmi-kat @protecteddiemunson4vr @littlestarfighter03
229 notes
·
View notes