anyways the brightheart graphic novel was…. ok. the cloudbright moments carried it. the backhanded attempts at justifying the ableism are uncomfortable and drag it down.
what confused me was like… the lack of the dog pack trauma? like its there, the opening and nightmare scenario show it, but theyre very short and dont really connect to the conflict besides “uhh tigerstar caused the attack, this guy breathed next to tigerstar, he might have his evil germs….. doing such sins like. taking food….. how horrible” like brightheart had half her faced ripped off and was given a cruel name by her former LEADER out of spite for something she wasnt involved in nor was her fault. she was near death and subjected to strange backhanded behavior from her peers. her best friend died extremely violently in front of her!!! she gets like one line about being afraid of her daughter growing up in this harsh world and. not much else?
idk if we were gonna get a brightheart centric story then i would have wanted it to focus on all that, maybe elaborate more on her fears for whitekit and also being paranoid of motherhood in general given what shes been through and what she may experience, instead of this weird narrative about “how useful she can be despite having only one eye”
10 notes
·
View notes
I love how in Sky you have Sunbeam and Nightheart just chilling, stealing fair food, dealing with simple issues like "oh no, my clan doesn't appreciate my horrible attitude" or "my best friend and crush got together and now everyone is pitying me + my mother's past trauma is causing her to hate my brother's girlfriend"
and Frostpaw is over there just Dying. Just casually falling apart with things like "I saw my mom be torn apart and now I have to pick someone else to be leader and walk them down this very same path and experience the trauma again every single time" and "I, a literal child, am being pressured into picking a new leader because I apparently have the skills to talk to dead cats and Oh No I don't think I can actually????"
I get the theme for each of them is being isolated in their own clans but Boy Howdy is one of these things not like the others!
18 notes
·
View notes
why should Lionblaze should get to pass off Russetfur’s death as “accidental” when he attacked her knowing full well he couldn’t lose any battle?
2 notes
·
View notes
you know that vision leafpool got of brambles surrounding the camp and she took it as meaning that brambleclaw should be deputy because he'd protect the clan
first of all, shout out to leafpool for being very mature and assuming the most positive outcome about that vision even though she fucking hated brambleclaw (rightfully)
but also what if she was wrong, what if she interpreted the sign wrong, what if the vision meant brambleclaw, like brambles, would ensnare, strangle, and cause HARM to thunderclan, not protect it
bramblestar's leadership has literally caused more harm than good to ANYONE in thunderclan (as well as outside of thunderclan, literally all of the clans (except skyclan i guess?), as well as the sisters have SUFFERED because of bramblestar being thunderclan's leader
and not to mention the individual cats who've suffered the most from him being leader, like him using his power to literally ABUSE squirrelflight, as well as his decisions actively causing leafpool's death, as well as the death of moonlight, killing a harmless group's leader and leaving three newborn kits as orphans, and ALMOST killing squirrelflight
not to mention brambleclaw literally had to STOP AND THINK about whether or not he should save firestar from the foxtrap like what the fuck man, and maybe if he hadn't literally hesitated firestar wouldn't have lost that life and then at the great battle firestar would have survived
what if starclan WAS sending a warning, and specifically sent it to leafpool because she was already suspicious of brambleclaw, but because she was still so young and less experienced, because she was so kindhearted and wanted to see the good in everyone, she WANTED her sister's mate to be a good person, a good leader, and was such a positive person, she thought, she wanted, she HOPED that it was a sign from starclan that brambles would protect her clan, her sister, her family
but it wasn't
2K notes
·
View notes
Tawnypelt should have had the arc Brambleclaw had in TNP. She had all the correct set up while he didn’t.
Bramblepaw outright rejected his father, Tawnypaw did not, she even joined his clan, it stands to reason that she would be more easily swayed by his spirit.
Tawnypelt had several cats actively doubting her loyalty in TNP, even saying things to her face, Brambleclaw did not.
It just feels the TNP Brambleclaw arc would have been a more natural progression of Tawnypelt’s character arc than his.
Also if Tawnypelt was faced with killing Blackstar then maybe the fact that Blackstar is a recent war criminal could play into her hesitancy to save him as well as ambition.
While Brambleclaw’s hesitancy is just purely driven by ambition, and it feels especially cold given the closeness he and Firestar had come to have at this point. Meanwhile Tawnypelt and Blackstar’s relationship was rocky in TNP.
478 notes
·
View notes