This is the first thing I’ve written for my AU. I wanted to showcase the nature of my interpretation of the characters, so forgive me if some parts come off as rushed or weird. I hope you enjoy!
The dead tend to forget.
That was something Springtrap came to learn. After being trapped in the same room, rotting, dying, already dead but still dying at the same time. How did that work? Then he remembered; the remnant was keeping his soul attached to his deceased body. But he could feel himself rotting still, his human body losing more life everyday day. If there was hardly any left. The feeling was unnatural. The whole situation was unnatural.
In that time his soul had been in agonizing turmoil. However, unlike his victims, he wasn’t able to lurk about to satisfy the restlessness growing within him. All he could do was writhe silently.
His memories had begun to slip in that time, lost to the unyielding anger and agony that was consuming him.
"Holy-GUYS COME LOOK AT THIS!"
He had forgotten what it was like to be in the presence of another person. If he could be considered a person anymore.
"Yeesh, the thing looks just as creepy in the light. Hurry up and wheel it into the attraction."
He had forgotten what the outside looked like. His senses overwhelmed with sights, smells and sounds that he hadn’t heard in decades.
"HAHAHA!!"
He had also forgotten that he had helped program the damned suits to follow the sounds of children.
No matter how hard he tried to get to the office, he couldn’t resist when audio played elsewhere in the building. He had already learned long ago-when he was still a person- that the souls were still bound to the programming of the machines they were bound in. The same very much applied to him.
[DING DONG DING DONG…DING DONG DING DONG]
He growled as he watched the nightgaurd rush out the exit. Lucky bastard escaped again.
Daytime mode used to be useful, now it was nothing more than a hinderance he wished he was rid of.
The suit controlled his movements now. It forced him to walk back to his usual starting position. The room wasn’t as blank as the safe room, filled with props of the previous pizzerias.
The irony; to be trapped in a horror attraction based on the murders he committed, as the main star.
Fazbear Entertainment was never known for having tact.
He was now bound to this room until the next night. With a frustrated sigh, he sat down -the suit creaking as he did so - and leaned against the wall.
That pesky guard. He kept toying with him using that damn voice. He clenched his moldy fists.
He’s been so angry ever since he woke up.
He wanted to break something.
More like someone.
He wanted to spill blood, watch the life drain from someone’s eyes.
He wanted to be in control for the first time since being trapped in this damned suit.
And what better way to feel in control than controlling the fate of some poor bloke?
That annoying guard would do just fine.
"Failed again?"
Speaking of annoyances…
"Go away," he growled, not even bothering to look up at her. He knew it was redundant. She wouldn’t leave. He could only hope this was one of their shorter interactions.
"It’s been three nights, do you really intend on continuing this little game of cat and mouse?" The Puppet asked, in an unamused tone that made him want to punch her in her stupid plastic face.
"I’ll do whatever I want to," he glared at the floor next to him. He hated how she continued to nag him like this.
"You have nothing to gain by killing him."
He scoffed. "I’ll gain some satisfaction from snapping his neck like a twig. The place is better off without that annoying rat."
"The annoying rat that is just trying to do his job," she replied, rolling her eyes. "You’re the annoying one in this situation."
He narrowed his eyes and finally turned to glare at her. The Marionette started right back. She was the only other possessed animatronic that remained. All the others he had dismantled. Though, he didn’t know why she wasn’t scrapped with the Toys long ago. Granted she was dirty and somewhat damaged, but she was in much better condition than he was.
"The satisfaction is only temporary you know. Even if you kill him, it won’t last. You won’t be satisfied." She stated, then she leaned forward. "I’ve seen it happen. You feel an uncontrollable rage and want to take it out on whoever is unfortunate enough to be around. But even after the blood is spilled, it’s not enough. It’ll only increase your bloodlust until it becomes habit. Then you’ll be reduced to nothing but a rabid animal."
Her voice was serene and clear, completely the opposite of his own deep and gravely voice. But she spoke with certain gravity in her tone. Warning, almost haunted even. She was clearly dead (no pun intended) serious. And he had a good idea of who she was referring to in this context, a certain golden bear popping to mind.
"Don’t you have somewhere else to be, Puppet?" He grumbled, changing the subject. He didn’t like how familiar her description was to his current situation.
"I told you to call me Charlie, William."
William. Yes, William Afton was his name. It had slipped his mind more than once. He would’ve forgotten long ago had the puppet not stuck around and kept interacting with him. He didn’t know why she insisted on talking to the man that killed her. The people who brought him here dubbed him Springtrap, and the name grew on him.
It was strange. He remembered some things clearly, like his wife’s death, drinking himself into a stupor at Jrs, and killing the missing children of course.
But others, he had a harder time recalling. Like his wedding day, the names and faces of his children, and…why he killed in the first place.
He hated how messy and unorganized his memories were, it was driving him nuts. Just trying to think of the past made him tremble with rage.
He remembered Charlie though. She was the first. Henry’s daughter. They knew each other when they were alive. If anything Charlie should despise him the most, given the obvious betrayal. But she didn’t.
"Fine, Charlie. Why do you insist on interacting with me? Why don’t you stay away like the other brats?"
He knew the others were still afraid of him. He didn’t really care. But Charlie clearly didn’t fear him, nor did she go out of her way to torment him in any capacity as he initially thought she would.
"Because someone has to keep you in line before you add another victim to your list." She answered cooly. That part was true, ever since they got here she’s tried to distract him from attacking the guard, and after he left she’d try to sway him from trying again, as she was doing moments ago.
"And also," she added. "I want to help you too, if possible."
He almost snorted. "Ah, yes. Because there’s good in everyone right? Of course you want to try and save my poor, broken soul." He put a hand where his now physically tattered heart would be, feigning vulnerability.
Though her face has very limited expression, he could tell she was unamused.
"I know you’re mocking me, but yes. I sense that there is still humanity in you. And besides, if I made you see the light, there’d be one less murderous rabbit in the world."
William dropped the facade and scowled, facing away from her again. "Why do you waste your time with this? You should despise me most of all."
"You already got what you deserved. Besides, I was never one to hold a grudge. I don’t have that kind of time." She responded. That rung a few bells in his head. Charlie never liked holding grudges.
Seemingly done with their daily chat, she turned to leave. Looks like this was one of the shorter conversations like he had hoped.
"See you next night William."
And she was gone, leaving the withered rabbit to his one thoughts once more.
————————————————————————
"I’m back." Charlie announced as she entered the room. As soon as she spoke, the various spirits made themselves known.
The children rushed up to her instantly. Though their ghostly feet made no sound. They gazed up at her with the dull but not quite lifeless eyes their spirit forms had since they were freed of their animatronic bodies. Though they still retain characteristics of said animatronics. Like the animal ears and tails and the various accessories. Their clothes had changed to match the color schemes of the animatronics as well.
"Charlie! Welcome back!" Susie greeted cheerfully, bouncing and throwing her hands in the air. Her bib flapping as she did.
"Tell Jeremy that 'hook' is totally valid in rock-paper-scissors!" Fritz exclaimed, rising his pirate hook for emphasis.
"It does not!" Jeremy argued, stomping his foot in frustration and his ears reeling back.
"Why? Hook can beat paper!"
"But it’s not part of the game!"
Charlie shook her head, if she could she'd have a fond smile on her face. This was a common occurrence. Fritz and Jeremy often bickered over silly things. She honestly enjoyed these moments because they got to act like kids again, not bound by the programming of their metal prisons.
She was beginning to wonder if putting them in the animatronics was the right move.
"Did you talk to him again?"
The bickering stopped immediately, and Charlie focused her gaze on Cassidy. She had her arms crossed and a disapproving glare. Evan stood beside her, looking away uncomfortably. They possessed Golden Freddy together, but their appearances were slightly different. With Evan having more attributes associated with Fredbear (purple hat and bowtie), and Cassidy with the current Golden Freddy (black hat and bowtie).
"What else would I be doing after 6 AM?"
"Why do you keep going to him? He’s bad and dangerous!" She exclaimed, throwing her hands in the air. Cassidy was the most hateful of all of them. When Charlie started interacting with William she was heavily against it, which was understandable. But Charlie wasn’t deterred. They’ve had this conversation many times.
"You know why." Charlie stated. She didn’t bother to explain herself again. They’ve had this conversation many times.
"Do you really think there might be good in him?" Gabriel asked timidly, shifting in place. Ironically, he was the most shy despite possessing the star of the band.
"He’s a bad person, but still a person. A person I knew. And I have a pretty good idea of why he did what he did in the first place." She said, eyes shifting to Evan momentarily. A grim expression crossed his face. "I want to try, at the very least."
Cassidy scoffed, "Good luck. He’s just a lousy murderer."
"You say that as if we aren’t murderers ourselves." Evan retorted, glancing back at her and crossing his arms. Cassidy twitched and glared at him.
"You-"
"What? You know it’s true."
The other children cringed and held various expressions of shame. Gabriel, Jeremy, and Fritz’s ears dropped and laid flat against their heads. In their rage and confusion they attacked innocent people, thinking they were their murderer. Some of the guards left after the second or first night. Others never left the building.
Though, Evan never killed anyone himself, neither did Charlie.
"Oh yeah? Well if you’re gonna take your dad’s side, why are you too scared to approach him huh?!" Cassidy shot back, poking his chest hard. Evan recoiled a bit, looking conflicted.
"Enough Cassidy." Charlie said, raising a placating hand. "As of right now William is in a state of rage and turmoil, as you all once were. It’s understandable why Evan would hesitate to approach his father in this state. He might not even recognize him."
"But he recognizes you…" Susie pointed out. "Why would he recognize you but not his son?"
"To put it simply; his memories are a mess. He remembers some things, others he’s all but forgotten, or is on the verge of forgetting. He would’ve forgotten his own name if not for me."
"Yeesh, the guy sounds like a piece of work."
Charlie sighed slightly at the new voice. Well, not so new unfortunately.
Kelsey walked in with his hands in his pockets, his usual relaxed grin on his face. He was the first to possess Fredbear, thus his appearance reflected more of Fredbear like Evan’s. He wasn’t a victim of William, unlike most of them. He died via springlock failure, when some bullies shoved him into one of the suits. He was also a teenager like herself. He died around 14.
Everyone had varying degrees of discomfort or annoyance on their faces, except Cassidy.
"Yeah, and Charlie still thinks she can redeem him somehow." Cassidy said with annoyance, rolling her eyes. Kelsey stopped beside her and smirked at Charlie. "Oh yeah? Heh. Pretty stubborn aren’t ya Charl?"
"Yes, I suppose I am." If she could she’d narrow her eyes at him. Despite his chill demeanor, everyone here knew his true nature. He was a despicable, manipulative, bloodthirsty maniac. He lured and killed kids similar to the ones that killed him. But along the way he decided that killing was fun and just became a murderer. Unfortunately, he groomed Cassidy to act similarly. She was attached to him, saw him as an older sibling.
Evan was glaring at him. Kelsey had tried to manipulate him at first too, but thankfully he didn’t fall for it. He wasn’t particularly wrathful anyway, so he couldn’t take advantage of that.
Honestly, the only reason they tolerated him was for Cassidy’s sake. Also because they were literally stuck with him.
"Hasn’t it been years? What makes you think he’ll change now if he hasn’t for the past decades?" Kelsey asked, more genuinely curious than teasing as he usually was.
"Being trapped in an unmoving suit with your own corpse will do that to you. He’s restless and angry. It will take time, but I’m sure I can get through to him eventually." Charlie assured calmly.
"If anyone can help him get better, it’s you Charlie!" Susie cheered with a bright grin.
"Yeah! You can help him like you helped us!" Fritz agreed, confident in her abilities. The others gave their encouragement. Charlie smiled.
"Thank you. And I’ll be able to set you all free too. We’re so close now." Everyone visibly brightened at that, even Cassidy. Soon, they would all be free.
Soon…
————————————————————————
It was night four now.
Another night, another chance to kill that nightgaurd.
Springtrap stalked towards the office with malicious anticipation. It was 3:00 AM and he wasn’t hearing the audio as often, the guard must be getting sloppy. Or the technology was failing him now more than ever.
Whatever, both scenarios meant victory for Springtrap.
He grinned wickedly. Finally, finally reached the office. He could see the red lights blaring inside, and the guard desperately trying to reboot the system. Poor fool hasn’t realize he’s lost.
He stood outside the window, waiting for the guard to take notice of him and freak out.
Then the guard looked up, and they both froze.
This…this wasn’t the same man who’s been here past three nights.
The previous guard had short black hair and green eyes, and he was sure he had a mole. This man had long brown hair tied into a ponytail, and blue eyes, with a scar across his left eye.
He felt like a thousand bells were ringing in his head. Something about this man was so familiar to him, yet he couldn’t grasp why.
His confusion distracted him long enough that the guard was able use the audio to lure him away from the office. The suit took control once more. He blinked and growled in frustration. Damn it! He missed his chance!
Though his frustration was overshadowed by his confusion. He couldn’t help but wonder about the sudden change. Perhaps the previous one quit? Still didn’t explain why he seemed so familiar.
Damn his unreliable memory.
————————————————————————
Mike let out the breath he had been holding. Though he didn’t really need to breath anymore did he?
"So, he really is here…" He muttered. It had been so long since he last saw the Springbonnie suit. Time had not been kind to it, or to him for that matter.
He pulled out a photo from his pocket and gazed at it. A family photo from 1980. Three years before disaster. He focused on the man on the left, standing tall and dignified beside his mother, with a hand on Mike’s shoulder.
Cassidy, Evan, and Dee were best friends prior to the bite
The Kennedys (the primary family in DSAF) play a large role in my Au
Dave Miller and William Afton are SEPARATE. William steals Dave’s identity as a disguise. Dave was accused of the Murders because of this.
Dave and Jack were framed and were imprisoned from 1985 to 1987, when a retrial proved them innocent
The order of restaurants goes
Fredbears family diner (1979-1983)
Circus Baby’s pizza (1984)
Freddy and friends (1984-1985)
Freddy Fazbear’s pizza (1986-1987)
Freddy Fazbear’s (1992-1993)
Chica’s party world (1997-2000)
Freddy JR’s (2006-2012)
Fazbear Frights (2023)
Freddy’s Rockstar Pizza (2023)
Freddy Fazbear’s Mega Pizza Plex (2024-)
Sammy Emily’s daughter June is is the current ceo of Freddy Fazbear’s pizza, she is the reason the company has gone to shit*
Micheal and Evan were given sleeping pills by William, this caused them to have hallucinations, causing the events of fnaf 4 play through
The series of murders that occurred at Freddy JR’s were done by a copycat killer named Miranda Sims, who did it as a act of revenge after being fired for misconduct
moot, could you please explain all your AUs?- like name + pic?
pls I wanna know *sobs*
Okay... so, I have 4 aus currently.
My main au (which this blog is for), the Connected AU (@ask-the-connected-au), Darkest Shadows Au (@my-darkest-shadow) and Trapped Au (which doesn't currently have a blog).
Main Au- I don't have a timeline for this yet. So, mainly canon timeline, although Michael (now a nonbinary cannibal corpse named Salem) and Jeremy (Fitzgerald) are ex-spouses, they have 4 kids (an older kid currently in college and triplets). Salem co-owns Fazbear Ent. with Sammy Emily (Charlie Emily's twin brother, who originated from the novel trilogy), owns the mega pizzaplex and made the Glamrocks, DJ MM, Daycare Attendant, etc. Henry and William are dead, Elizabeth and Evan live at Salem's house, and they also have a pet fox and a pet ferret. I can't really think of anything else.
Connected Au - Combination of Fazbear Frights stories + Canon. Michael's adopted (like, as a baby) by Pete and Chuck (Step Closer)'s parents and Fritz is also their brother. Still related to Aftons, but doesn't know it. Elizabeth and Evan are dead. Evan died recently. Very recently. Alec & Hazel (Lonely Freddy) and Gabriel are related, Jeremy, Connor & Toby (Hide and Seek) are related, Susie & Samantha (Coming Home) are related, and Kelsey (The New Kid), Andrew (Stitchwrath Epilogues), and Cassidy are related (Andrew and Cassidy are twins). All kids that'll be killed by Will are friends (Gabriel, Jeremy, Susie, Fritz, Charlie, Cassidy, Andrew) and also Sammy. Michael is friends with Connor, Samantha, Alec, and Kelsey. We are shipping Michael and Kelsey... for some reason (????).
Darkest Shadow Au - Michael and William caused the murders... and maybe killed Evan and Elizabeth (haven't worked this one out as much as the others).
Trapped Au - Ennard is controlled of Michael's body for long-term post-sister location (like, YEARS).
(Left to right: Salem, Connected!Michael, Darkest Shadows!Michael, and Trapped!Michael)
whats Cassidy like in your au? Is she friends with Evan?
She was his friend before the bite, and one of the only friends he had outside of Charlie and Elizabeth. Together, the three girls were like Evan’s protection squad. Cassidy really didn’t like Michael because of how he treated Evan and she spent a lot of time trying to get Evan out of the house away from his brother. She’s roughly three years older than him, so treats him like he’s her own little brother in a way.
1983:
Despite being quite young, she doesn’t really have much parental supervision as her mom, while loving, is often busy with work and struggles to look after her four kids: Kelsey (14, Freddy Bully), Gabriel (12), Cassidy (9) and Andrea (2). Because of this, Cassidy tends to wander the streets either with Gabriel or by herself and is almost guaranteed to knock on the Afton family’s door at least once a week, usually to be greeted by Clara, although on occasion it’s William. She prefers it when it’s William because he’s more likely to let her borrow Evan for the day.
She’s very mysterious at heart but is also very aware of how people feel, so knows when she has to stop with her pranks or jokes. But she isn’t blindly nice either, and you’re lucky to get out unscathed if you really piss her off. God forbid you insult her siblings. That’s HER job.
She’s not easily trusting of adults either, with there being a small list of those she does… one William is on. That won’t age well.”
She actually dies in late 1983 as well, the last of William’s victims alongside her brother.
After death:
She’s pissed off. She’s constantly experiencing moments of pure rage, and the only reason she isn’t consumed by them is because of Evan being there to calm her down.
She wants nothing more than to just lash out, scream to everyone that she’s still here - but she can’t.
She may be angry, and violent, but in the end she’s still just a scared kid who wants to go home and go to bed. She tries to hide that fact completely because both she and Charlie are looked up to into the group, and she can’t let them all know she’s weak. She refuses. Even if Evan tells her it’s okay.
But above everything, she just wants William to suffer for everything’s he’s done, because it’s the only thought that’s keeping her sane.
Thinking about her makes me feel sad things honestly, thinking about all the missing children does.
Helloo- I'ma type out au ideas I have made cause yes u-u
☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆☆▪︎☆☆☆☆☆☆☆
Wrenlilah: Delilah died by Springtrap pushing her into his suit, Getting springlocked, And now has spent many years with him. In the future, When William finally makes an illusion disc for him, Delilah asks for a "special" one, So she can appear as a twin sister of William, Wren. William agreed, And Delilah uses the illusion disc if she wants to roam around on her own
Random potential au ideas: Cassie is Elizabeth's soul - Gregory is a mix of CC and Michael's soul - Michael is still a corpse with only half of his soul still attached to it - Cassidy, Andrew, And Jeremy possess the Mimic - Vanessa is Clara's soul - Susie and Fritz are the princess - Vanny is Kerrigan - Glitchtrap/Burntrap is William, He gets an illusion disc to appear human, Gets back with Vanessa/Clara - Charlie and Henry possess Glamrock Freddy - Sammy possesses Glamrock Bonnie - Vanessa/Clara adopted Cassie/Elizabeth and Gregory/CC/Michael
1985 survival: William survived the springlock and Henry had to rush him to the hospital, Glitchtrap had infested by William at this time too because Cassidy created him to torture William since their plan to kill him failed. Glitchtrap ended up making William kill more people though so he was lured to the springlock suit and forced inside it by the spirits, Killed this time, Though Glitchtrap kept him just on the edge of life for this whole time
Future - It continues: William didn't change. Nor did Vanessa or Kerrigan. It's the same as my main just with the fact they kill.
Future - It continues (2): William didn't change. Nor did Vanessa or Kerrigan. It's the same as my main just with the fact they kill. Added Morra and Flare!
Future - Fighter kid: Mary was killed by Kerrigan. | 1983 - Fighter kid: Mary was the second victim of William's.
(SWAP) Future: Henry was the killer, He's changed. William doesn't forgive or like him. | (SWAP) Future - It continues: Henry didn't change, Nor Vanessa. William haunts Henry alongside Cassidy, Andrew, Elizabeth, Evan, Delilah, Cindy, Mary, And Kelsey
Mikevictim: Cassidy(Chica mask) was a very vengeful child, And always hated how Michael treated CC. So one day, She fought him, And had enough. So she brought him to Fredbear, And shoved his head in the mouth. Michael survived, Being the guard in SL, And CC died of a heartattack because of the nightmares seeing the event gave him. (Based on a cai rp)
(SWAP) Milevictim: Henry had 3 kids, Sammy(Foxybro), Michael(CC), And Charlie. Charlie died to Circus Baby, Michael died to Fredbear, Sammy became to SL guard
Vanbeth: (This most likely won't be used) ) If the hw2 Vanny ending is canon, Assuming that was Vanny getting rid of Glitchtrap from her life. Glitchtrap could look towards Elizabeth for "help", She'd agree, And the William and make her an illusion disc to appear as an adult, So she could work at the Pizzaplex, And go around as Vanny.
Millie Afton: Born either as Kerrigan's twin, Or the child Mrs. Dean had with a man she married after Michael died. She would have survived/escaped Funtime Freddy(Prototype) and survived untill she was 21, Dying on the job as a police officer.
Kerricent: Millie and Kerrigan at the same people. She survived Ft. Freddy(Prototype), Became a police officer, Had Vanessa, Before leaving the force and working alongside Vanessa in the future, Getting corrupted, And helping Glitchtrap while Vanessa was stuck as the princess.
Kerricent - The Quest: Everything is the same, Expect Vanessa isn't the princess and she is.
2006 - Fazbear Frights: Millie and Sarah are alive here, And it's really only them in this one. Millie survived Ft Freddy(Prototype) with the exchange of her parents life. Sarah had found Eleanor, But it won't be untill collage she wants to change her appearance fully. As of now, She has got Eleanor to change her body to be feminine (MTF) and that's it. Millie lives on her own, Her grandparents live nearby though and check on her every so often. Millie has a job and does mostly everything on her own, While her grandparents pay the bills to her parents house (They bought the house to Millie could stay there since she didn't want to leave and they worked out a solution). Millie would had died on duty, When she became a police (21 y/o), And Sarah would have died due to Eleanor (Used)
Clara = Funtime Chica: In this au, Clara possessed Funtime Chica after she died as Ballora wasn't created yet.
Clara = Funtime Chica & Ballora: Same thing, Expect after Ft Chica was decommissioned and Ballora was made, She went on to possess her
Past to future/Future to past: I was thinkin that Astrid could have orignally been in the past (2006), But since my world is connected with well, Magic n stuff, I could say she found a being with powers, And had them bring her and her family to the future (Where the story would actually take place)- BuT then I thought, Now I duno if this would somehow mess up the story cause Google is dumb and didn't tell if anything happened to Astrid due to Nexie- BuT- I was thinkin she could have been in the future orignally, And Nexie had powers, Bringing Astrid and her family to the past as some curse or somethin
Eleanor = Nexie (Future to past): Nexie is a form of Eleanor, Seeing as Eleanor "sort of" has powers? Even if it's just an illusion disc
Cassibeth: Elizabeth and Cassidy being the same people. Elizabeth died to Circus Baby and had her soul spilt so she also went onto possess Golden Freddy. And once she began seeing other souls, And found out their killer was her father, She became angry and vengeful towards him
Future to past (2): Nexie had a curse, And a few days after Astrid tried fixing Nexie, She was transported to the past !without! her family (2006). She was found by Millie and Millie took her in, Caring her for like an older sister would.
Marytrap: Mary(1983 AU) possesses Glitchtrap to get revenge for her death
MWD-trap: Mary, William, And Delilah possess Glitchtrap
fun fact about evan's survived verse: his whole family uses his wife's surname, kelsey! they decided against sticking with "afton" because evan felt like the name was a little bit. cursed. the only reason EVAN didn't change his name is because he'd already finished school and all the paperwork would be awful -- and a part of him felt like it was almost disrespectful, even though (as far as he was concerned) his entire family was either dead or MIA by his 23rd birthday
Have you heard of the theory that Golden Freddy is possessed by both Evan and Cassidy? I personally like the theory, what do you think? Also, I think the vengeful spirit is Kelsey because they are both both boys with blonde hair and blue eyes.
Im pretty sure we talked about this on deviantart but ill say It here why not.
I Do believe Golden has 2 souls, but I Don't Believe the second soul is Evan, but Andrew.
Andrew is literally TOYSHK and we Have Evan, William, Michael and probably Charlotte and Elizabeth so im 100% Andrew is not a parallel.
For me Evan is rather Resting and his emotional energy doing things or in the Limbo helping to give Cassidy Her happiest day.
About Kelsey we didnt solved him yet so I dunno but he seems related to Andrew