haha I wish sf9 made the cut but no. I watched the video to see how rough it'll be and wow they're treating this like a research project I'm??? Like it's not that deep. I promise.
Welp they looked at 4 groups (ateez, bt/s, monstax, exo) and ranked them like this.
First as a group stage presence??
4. Exo
3. Ateez
2. Monsta X
1. Bts
And in individual rankings (there's too much and my brain hurt when they were talking about overt/Covert, masculine/feminine, charismatic, sensual something else but I don't wanna go back lol) I'll give the top 10 which are:
10. Xiumin (masculine Covert charismatic sensual)
9. Kihyun (masculine overt charismatic)
8. Jungkook(masculine overt dominant charismatic)
7. Wooyoung(masculine overt dominate charismatic. developing a sensual side *idk what this even means*
6. Jimin(feminine overt dominant sensual)
5. Seonghwa(feminine overt sensual masculine overt dominant) doesn't fit in a box, depends on era
4. San(masculine feminine overt dominant sensual) I guess he also doesn't fit in a box either I dunno I forgot what they said
4. Jhope(masculine overt dominant charismatic) tied with san
3. Hongjoong(masculine overt dominant charismatic)
2. Jooheon(masculine overt dominant)
1. Kai( nothing bc she doesn't know he's too difficult to pin down, 3 dimensional)
My thoughts: ... why?? Why is there a need to place everyone in a cute little box??? They're performers they PERFORM
oh my fucking GOD LJDLKSJLKDJFLKSDJFLKDSFJLDKSFJDLSKFJ somehow it is SO much worse seeing it written out jesus fucking christ. sdlfkjdslfjdsljf she really just picked four popular groups that have no relation to each other huh. i'll give her a single point for recognizing that hongjoong is the best performer in ateez but this is actually insane. firstly, the gall to rank bts above mx for group presence like mx hasn't spent their entire career having the most distinctive stage presence of any 3rd gen group. and secondly, the gendered shit was bewildering the first time and now it's just infuriating and gross. like HOW do you not see the problem with unironically and enthusiastically gendering people's MOVEMENTS like this........ girl get fucking help.
4 notes
·
View notes