Hello.
You and gay-jesus-probably have successfully made me question everything with your view that Tears of the Kingdom is imperialist propaganda, so that's been fun.
Anyway, I decided to share this discussion with the Zelda fans on reddit, and perhaps unsurprisingly, a lot of them disagreed. Here is what they said (I'm Alarming_Afternoon44):
So what do you think? Have I and all these other people just been duped by the game's manipulative framing? Or do they actually have a point?
And if you'd rather not answer this, or would prefer if I censored the usernames, just tell me and I'll delete this.
Hey! Thanks a lot for reaching out, and I'm glad it made you think stuff through!!
Honestly, as I mentioned in this post, I am not super interested about in-world conversations about who oppresses who, because what can be assessed from the game is super vague and more vibes-based than evidence-based. Within the text, of course that the Good Zonais are good and the Bad Ganondorf is bad! But that's my whole point! The narrative has been deliberately crafted so that the zonais and Rauru (and Hyrule) are as blameless as possible (and it's not doing a great job at it overall to be frank; we would not be having these conversations about how offputting it all feels for a non-zero number of people if it did do a great job). More importantly, I want to focus on what sort of real-life narrative it all parallels. Because people make stories, and people live in the real world.
Not going after everyone's throat here, gamedev is hard and the hydras that are AAA game production do end up doing super weird stuff, especially since the thematic ramifications are absolutely never prioritized (and it's also always the same kind of people who make the final calls and push out what can and can't be talked about also). And as fans, we tend to have trouble stepping outside the lens of lore and take a look at the bigger picture sometimes; not as an attack on any individual part of that decision-making process but to just pause, stop, and question our standards, our priorities and the kind of reality (or skewing of reality) the stories we tell each other reflect.
Again: do we want to take videogames seriously or not? If we do, then we need to accept they are a vehicle for ideology, just like any other artform. And sometimes, you push out questionable ideology, sometimes without meaning to, because you didn't unpack your own biases as you did. And it's even fine to do it, nobody is perfect, a 300+ people team spread over 6 years certainly will not be that. But that it wasn't prioritized is, in my opinion, a problem. As a narrative designer, I want games (at least the narrative side) to be held to a higher standard than this. It's literally my job to work with the industry so it can hold itself to higher standards of quality --so the whole TotK situation is quite frustrating to witness from a very pragmatic, work perspective where I already spend my days trying to convince people that things mean things. I have a vested interest here in not having the companies I work for being given a free pass by gamers to do literally whatever as long as it's fun, especially when we're talking about a billion-dollars company suing its own fans left and right for any perceived slight. Nintendo are not underdogs here. It's fine to point out they cut corners and maybe promoted messy ideologies, voluntarily or not.
So long story short: no I don't believe anyone here has a point in regards to what I think is actually important, which is why these choices were made in the first place. If you look at an imperialist text expecting the text to tell you that it's imperialist instead of recognizing a framing used for propaganda by yourself, you're never gonna find any imperialist text ever, obviously not!! I'm sorry if I sound a little gngngn here, but I don't know why audiences have, at large, this feeling that lore and story beat decisions materialize themselves already formed and without any human bias, meddling, intervention, internal politics or approximations (it seems that people can only conceptualize this part if they have actual names to attach to the story, but without clear authors it's like there are no authors and so no bias, which is... a very strange bias in itself). I can promise you that it does not work that way in practice: every narrative department on every big game is a battlefield --some nicer than others, but all of them very emotionally draining either way.
So yeah, I guess that on these grounds, I disagree with every point raised here. Sorry Reddit :/
But thank you for the ask and sorry if I didn't go more into details as to why. The big Why I Dislike Rauru Post and the Gerudo Post might have some more specific rebuttals, but I am not super interested in debating small detail stuff tbh. I feel like it's no use if the frame of reference isn't being understood in the first place.
28 notes
·
View notes
I hate to ask, but I need to make rent next week and I'm dry. Bone dry. I had to quit my job two weeks ago due to progressively worsening health conditions that I still don't have a diagnosis for. I'm waiting for several medical tests (full sleep panel at a clinic, an IV ultrasound among other things) and now that my doctor has retired I need to wait for another GP.
My boyfriend is physically disabled and on the spectrum and has not been able to work for several years. I've applied for welfare for the both of us, but we have to go to an in-person meeting AFTER rent is due.
Currently at $30/$852, which is the sum for rent and utilities.
I would appreciate reblogs as much as possible.
Paypal @/ariel
I don't have Cashapp or anything else because I am french Canadian and they don't like that.
29 notes
·
View notes
hey guys real quick what do i do in this situation:
over the past year, my bipolar i symptoms have been worsening. my therapist observed that every 3 months or so, i cycle between extreme lows and then "getting better"/hypomania. i have not yet had a full manic episode, though it's been close.
my psychiatrist suspended all care until i go to inpatient residential care. she says i'm unstable and require a higher form of care. the residential program is 30-45 days, depending on treatment progress. new psychiatrists within my insurance policy have a 3 month waiting list.
i've used up all sick time due to 1) mental health and 2) physical health. my PTO currently stands only at 20 hours. i'm ineligible for an unpaid LOA or even disability since i haven't yet worked a year at this current company.
i'm barely functioning as it is. i can't quit my job, because then i won't have health insurance, and therefore be unable to go to residential. but i can't go to residential anyways because i can't take off work for it.
according to my therapist, i can't heal in this current environment because i'm constantly retriggered. so i need to move, but i won't be able to afford to do that if i go inpatient because the deductible is 50% of my savings, and the other 50% would be used to cover bills since i'd be unpaid.
what do i do. like. what do i do?????
8 notes
·
View notes