How to give good feedback on art (from an artist)
I often see people talk about how they want to leave good comments on art, but don’t know how/don’t know what to say. As an artist, here’s what I often look for to have something to say to other people!
The composition of the art – how different elements of the piece guide your eye, how certain parts are brighter against darker backdrop/darker against a bright backdrop. What catches your attention? How have they put the piece together to make this happen?
The lighting/shading – how have they rendered the piece? Do you like how the lighting is bright, harsh lines, or how it’s gently blended in? Do the shadows add extra depth that makes the whole piece look more 3D? Did they use funky, unconventional colours to shade?
The lineart – is it smooth? Sketchy? Are the lines thick or thin? Do they use lines at all? Are they in a colour other than black? How does it add to the piece? Do they just outline a piece, or add texture with lineart as well?
The colours – have they used a pallet of complimentary colours? Do they remind you of something specific – perhaps to the fandom, or to a season, an aesthetic, etc? Do they only use one colour? Do they use unconventional colours? Do they have one pop of contrasting colours against a monochrome background?
The anatomy – do they stick to exact proportions? Do they lean towards a more cartoon sizing? Is it like Powerpuff Girls, or like Tim Burton? 90s anime, or modern day anime? Do they make things very angular, or really smooth? What about it do you like specifically?
The texture – in the frame of digital art especially, have they used a specific brush to create a certain effect? Do you like how sketchy it all looks, or how they’ve blended the colours together? Does it look like watercolours bleeding, or a stamp/print made over the entire piece? Is it all rough, or super smooth?
The details – talk about how you love the tiny pattern on a blanket, or the multiple earrings in the characters ear. Talk about how you like how they’ve done the hair, or the little glint of light against a ring. Talk about the celtic patterns in the body, or the crooked teeth in their smile. Little things that jump out to you.
How it makes you feel – anything at all, but try to explain what in the piece evokes it strongest. Are you hit with isolation by the lonely figure in a wind-swept hill? Or joy, does that bright smile make your heart swell? Try and pick something out and babble about that.
Any meaning you can pick out – a little more tricky and often quite personal, but if you can pick something out that you think you can interpret, talk about it! I don’t think people ever get offended, even if you’re wrong – it’s interesting to see how other peoples brains work, and what they take away from something you’ve made.
Anything that stands out to you as a signature of Their Art – typically for artists you’ve followed for a long time – when you look at a piece, do you think ‘oh, this is by X’. How do you know? Is it how they draw the mouths? How they shade? The anatomy? The details? The colours? The composition? The expressions? Tell them!
I try to mix and match a few of these, focusing on things specific to the piece. Talking in depth about a piece helps an artist to know you haven’t just glanced it over and gone ‘oo cool!’ and moved on. If you want Tumblr to continue having a thriving art community, it’s beneficial to engage in and spread art around, as well as letting the artist know their work was seen and appreciated. They put the work out there for you to see for free! What can take you a few minutes of your day can make their entire week. Go support your artist friends!
128 notes
·
View notes
Some art from 5 months ago..! posted these on instagram. Haven't had the time to draw lately, but i havent really had time to do any of my hobbies in general.
pretty sure i grinded totk the week it came out and it died down as weeks passed not because of disinterest but because i've been occupied. especially since i'm in the middle of preparing for finals.. which right now is just a chunky take home essay exam
but anyway! ah zelink. some totk spoilers below:
part of me is disappointed zelda isnt playable but i knew deep down that wasn't gonna happen so i dont waste my time complaining... don't really know when tloz will deviate from its formula and make zelda a heroine instead of a damsel in distress. however part of me indulges in her absence in totk because of the zelink anecdotes in hyrule (not that. there was a lot, but i'm a little bit deranged over these two. like zelda's diary in hateno, link's hair tie) heehee. it's really hard for me to pinpoint the common trends and patterns of my favorite ships but i will always be a sucker for implicit and anecdotal romance. oh the YEARNING and sorrows and quiet intimacy. when i found out zelda was the light dragon i couldnt stop thinking about link touching his forehead with hers or lying down on her back clutching her golden mane eyes closed and yearning and apologetic and missing. etecetera. every time i think of a new situation i get chest pains. his princess and her knight. AUGH. do you know how lethal it was when i started out totk playing as link and zelda was moving RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME. THEY'RE TOGETHER. do you also know how lethal it was when we got separated and would remain separated for the rest of the game. man. havent finished the game yet but i hope for an epic cutscene of them together at some point. will probably die if(when? ;_;) that happens
zelink's relationship status is ambiguous and remains conceptual to me. not explicitly romantic, not friendship either. perhaps the most accurate label i can give them is qpr? not sure. i just enjoy these two a lot hahaha.
14 notes
·
View notes
Man. I love Pillowfort.
I love being able to have discussions with people where we don't really agree but it doesn't feel like a fight or a game of oneupmanship, and where there isn't the risk of things getting lost in the shuffle of threads and reblogs and tags.
I love being able to say everything I mean to say without having to limit my language or truncate anything and increase the risk of misunderstanding that's already inherent to text communication.
I love being able to go "No I get that, here's my reasoning, we're both right!" and not feel like I'm about to get told to kill myself.
I love being able to have a conversation without worrying about getting super triggered because ad-hominem aggression is the exact opposite of the tone of choice for users there.
I wish I knew how to get more interaction there, because it almost always feels like I'm the one starting and finishing conversations, but that's not something the platform itself can change. I wish I knew how to get more eyes on my art, because most of the people I've interacted with there with regard to my work are pretty cool and I think it'd be nice to build some deeper connections, but that's not something the platform itself can change either.
As a platform, Pillowfort is so good. It's just so sincere, it harbors such a clear opportunity to communicate with people, it doesn't reward bad actors with engagement-based boosts. The whole environment is just so good.
I really love Pillowfort.
7 notes
·
View notes
A silly little series of renders that I wanted to make because of the Face Mini-sis incident, where I found a model for Face Nemesis that was decidedly smaller than it should have been and proceeded to laugh about for rather a long time.
..The lighting was not playing nicely on this one and neither was recreating the text boxes from the game, but hopefully it's still alright! I'm not sure I've tried to do a "comic-style" set of renders before, but it was how I was envisioning the situation ^-^
(Comments on and reblogs of my work are always okay, and appreciated, but are never required!)
Also, for some extra context (and a closeup of the mini Face Nemesis) under the readmore:
The pink bracket on the left is meant to be Citri's height, sitting down. It only encompasses the torso part of Nemesis. So, considering that the entire thing now sits on the palm of her hand with room to spare, I think it's safe to say this is a rather small scale model =P
8 notes
·
View notes