"It's ok to kill elves because they respawn" and "death isn't serious for elves" will never not be a hilariously bad argument.
Respawn is hardly guaranteed. At least some individuals (Aegnor, Feanor, Finwe) will not be reborn, at least for the entire lifespan of the planet; death can be permanent. I think the various writings about Mandos and rebirth (plenty of juicy stuff in NoME in particular if you're looking) imply that it's not particularly uncommon for Elves not to return to life.
Mandos isn't a pleasant place to be nor is it where Elves are meant to be. Its name literally means "prison" - the word is related to "Angband" even (the "mandos" and "band" elements are cognate).
Death itself is pretty damn traumatic! Even if I pop back up in 15 minutes like a mob in an mmo, a sword through the gut's not fun.
All evidence suggests that Elves (and Valar) treat death very seriously and don't think it's unimportant. The Elves of Beleriand don't even sing songs about Fingolfin's death because the grief is too much.
For Elves of Middle-earth who are killed, go Mandos, and are reborn in Aman - they are sent somewhere that they may not willingly have chosen to go and can't leave. There's not really a great real world analogue to this (I'm intentionally avoiding the potential closest ones for reasons) but I don't think it's good and removing that choice - through violently murdering someone - is itself a crime.
276 notes
·
View notes
okay so I keep general politics off this blog (other than eat the rich, obviously) but I am so tired of hearing this shit from family members on facebook and am heated at the moment so:
this blog stands with palestine 🇵🇸
78 notes
·
View notes
the cleons really are just spoiled little pedigreed cats meowing for their fancy feast. even got collars on them.
50 notes
·
View notes
as much as I love wei wuxian and slander against him is banned from this house I Do sometimes think that people forget he's like. supposed to be a morally complex person who did things that were bad. like the whole point of him and his story is that he was a good man who was pushed to do terrible things, and when we fail to examine those terrible things/completely ignore them, we're sort of doing wei wuxian and the points being made by his arc a disservice
16 notes
·
View notes
I wish I could remember what nonfiction book it was, where young(er) Frederick Marryat makes a cameo appearance. It could have been about naval signal codes, battling smugglers in the 1810s-1820s, or his awful family idk.
But the primary source meets an obnoxiously young but still Captain Frederick Marryat, in a time of high unemployment among naval officers after the Napoleonic Wars. And he is basically like, "Nyah nyah my rich dad got me a boat." >:) which tbh sounds exactly like what I would expect for young Captain Marryat.
14 notes
·
View notes
i love that technically the adults qualify as "found family but they're all criminals". like look at this wholesome bunch of nerds. they love committing grand theft auto, identity fraud, forgery, and more
35 notes
·
View notes
Cried twice while reading morning son this acc crazy. Wdym my silly pulpy scifi novels got serious...
10 notes
·
View notes
My life advice is that you don't have to have a succinct and intellectually worded argument to counter every shitbag jacking off in your notes/asks/etc. They literally can't get smarter no matter how hard you try so you have full permission to troll them or tell them to get cucked or joke about fucking their mom. It is always morally correct to obliterate haters in the most degrading ways possible
22 notes
·
View notes