Punk, Etienne de la Boetie, and Chiara Bottici: A Discussion of Queer Activism and Free Will
By Brycen Beam for Bodies, Gender and Domination at The New School (2016)
G.L.O.S.S. is a genderqueer, feminist punk band from Olympia, Washington. The band’s name is an acronym: “Girls Living Outside Society’s Shit” which is an accurate depiction of its members’ feminist morale, with a specific intersectional lens. Their latest EP release, according to Bust on-line magazine, is a “manifesto against sexism, racism, and domestic violence” in a scene that is historically and presently dominated by heterosexual cis-men.
Recently, G.L.O.S.S. denied Epitaph Records’ offer of a $50,000 record deal. Epitaph Records has signed on monumentally influential bands, including Descendants and The Cramps. This denial of corporate advancement shows G.L.O.S.S.’s commitment to Do-It-Yourself (DIY) music and the importance of authenticity in playing their music without selling out.
G.L.O.S.S., considering the offer, ultimately rejects Epitaph’s $50,000 offer. The space in which G.L.O.S.S. and their supporters carve out of society, simultaneously via music and activism, aids in lending a voice to marginalized persons in working toward a revolution, according to a recent Bust interview. Epitaph Records is considered a corporate, mainstream record label for hardcore, punk and alternative music genres, and thus may be perceived to be what Etienne de la Boetie refers to as a tyrant, a leader of a system which perpetuates oppression and marginalization (of queer/trans people in this case).
Led by transwoman Sadie Switchblade, G.L.O.S.S., as well as other DIY punk musicians who reside outside of corrupt music production, have taken a stance to create a separate world of music. The space created by G.L.O.S.S. is a safe, though emotionally charged, atmosphere of human freedom of expression. As a defense of their freedom, G.L.O.S.S. collectively decided to deny a label that would inevitably taint their regained autonomy over free will. “Since freedom is our natural state, we are not only in possession of it but have the urge to defend it” (Boetie 51). As a tangential point from mainstream politics, G.L.O.S.S. represents the divergent servant of what Etienne de la Boetie describes as one who simply does not serve the tyrant to avoid furthering lack of free will.
Trying to overthrow overarching institutional racism, sexism and anti-feminism through the “brute beasts in the pulpit to throw light on their nature and condition” (Boetie 52), that is here G.L.O.S.S., a voice of marginalized implementations of anti-corruption, cease to submit to the single Tyrant of blind political injustice, white supremacy and anti-feminist ideals.
The Tyrant, as per Boetie’s perspective, would be undeniably difficult to adhere to, for G.L.O.S.S. and their message would be stifled by the contracted requirements of the corporation. An excerpt from G.L.O.S.S.’s album Trans Day of Revenge, song entitled Give Violence a Chance:
“Fuck the peace fuck the calm / The investigation is a fucking con /
The truth is known beneath the gun / Black lives don’t matter in the eyes of the law / Dead kids mean nothing to them / Left to rot in the street / Afforded rights when convenient / To protect the elite / Anti-racist doesn’t mean non-racist / Justice is a fucking joke, a trap, a fucking farce / Your calls for peace are ignorant and basic / Self-appointed community leaders / Who put you in charge?”
The lyrics would be reviewed, speculated and edited to the standard Epitaph Records and the industry sees fit. This speculation interferes with the intention to spread unfiltered and unheard lyricisms on account of the sick realities of today’s police brutality and institutionalized racism.
Boetie’s The Politics of Obedience: The Discourse of Voluntary Solitude refers to the idea of the “inhabitants themselves who permit, or, rather, bring about, their own subjection, since by ceasing to submit they would put an end to their servitude” (Boetie 46). The push against Epitaph is the band’s cease to submit to the objectification of realized issues of today; the rugged edges of G.L.O.S.S. would, if not instantly, over time be dulled down to incorporate their music into the mainstream, which defeats the purpose of the activism and honest discomfort located within the crux of the band.
Chiara’s Bodies in Plural speaks to the idea of intersectionality, and how iterations of thought contain (un)conscious implications within its absence, as well as its presence. This is applicable to G.L.O.S.S. and the acknowledged privilege held by the band members; though there is an absence of people of color in the band, the lyrics and purpose of the band is critically dependent on intersectional activism, taking class, race, sexuality and gender into consideration.
The band has an advantage of white privilege, but uses that platform as a means through which people of color and LGBTQ community members can ultimately voice their experiences and emotions. Intersectionality is crucial because G.L.O.S.S. uses the broad audience they reach as a means to express anti-racism, such as “Give Violence a Chance” available via Bandcamp, but also in representing marginalized voices and persons, the audience is more inclined to question their environment and witnessed interactions, much like Bottici expressed in the first page in Bodies in Plural.
(Re)presentations that are also images themselves are brought to question in Bottici’s piece on page 2; this idea of (re)presentation, a reorientation of present, speaks to the lengths of G.L.O.S.S.’s impact on communities of color and queerness. Though the band is an image of what DIY punk is presently, predominantly white, once performed and discussed, the band takes challenges a reiteration of political queerness, identity structure and the common understanding of what marginalization means.
Without the overlap of class, race, gender and sexuality, G.L.O.S.S. would be unable to write the music they produce, or reach the audiences they have touched. Please consider “that there is something specific about the oppression of women [and other marginalized groups] and that in order to fight it you have to fight all other forms of oppression” (Bottici 6). All sides must be heard in order for activism, intersectionality and queerness to be productive in overriding oppression and regaining free will in a world that is turning blind to reality. It means defending a position that is simultaneously feminist and anarchist.
1 note
·
View note
Military Reading List
1776: McCullough, David G.
A Companion to American Military History: Bradford, James C.
A History of Air Warfare: Olsen, John Andreas
A History of Modern Iran: Abrahamian, Ervand
A Savage War of Peace: Horne, Alistair.
Accidental Guerrilla: Kilcullen, David.
America the Last Best Hope: Bennett, William J.
American Soldiers: Kindsvatter, Peter S.
An Army at Dawn: Atkinson, Rick.
Beating Goliath: Record, Jeffrey.
Building the Trident Network: Mort, Maggie.
Caine Mutiny Court-martial: Wouk, Herman.-Avery, James-Hunter-Gualt, Chuma.-Lithgow, Ian.-Lowell, Scott.-Rivkin,
Cataclysm: Wolk, Herman S.
Clausewitz and Modern Strategy: Handel, Michael I.
Closing With the Enemy: Doubler, Michael D.
Command Culture: Muth, Jörg
Contemporary Military Innovation: Bjerga, Kjell Inge.-Adamsky, Dima.
Contemporary Nuclear Debates: Lennon, Alexander T.
Counterinsurgency Warfare: Galula, David.-Nagl, John A.
Credibility: Kouzes, James M.-Posner, Barry Z.
Critical Thinking: Paul, Richard.-Elder, Linda
Cyber Warfare: Andress, Jason.-Winterfeld, Steve.-Rogers, Russ.
Cyberdeterrence and Cyberwar: Libicki, Martin C.
Discourses on Livy: Machiavelli, Niccolò.-Bondanella, Julia Conaway.-Bondanella, Peter E.
Eisenhower: Wukovits, John F.
Eisenhower on Leadership: Axelrod, Alan
Elephant and the Dragon: Meredith, Robyn.
Erich Maria Remarque's All Quiet on the Western Front: Bloom, Harold.
Federalist Papers: Hamilton, Alexander-Madison, James-Jay, John-Goldman, Lawrence
Forgotten Continent: Reid, Michael.
From Babel to Dragomans: Lewis, Bernard.
George C. Marshall: Brower, Charles F.
Guardians of the Revolution: Takeyh, Ray.
History of Air Warfare: Olsen, John Andreas.
History of the Peloponnesian War: Thucydides.
Horse Soldiers: Stanton, Doug.
How: Seidman, Dov.
How Wars End: Reiter, Dan
Improving the Decision Making Abilities of Small Unit Leaders: National Research Council (U.S.).
Innovator's Dilemma: Christensen, Clayton M.
Inside Al Qaeda: Gunaratna, Rohan
John M. Schofield and the Politics of Generalship: Connelly, Donald B.
John Warden and the Renaissance of American Air Power: Olsen, John Andreas
Joseph Heller's Catch-22: Bloom, Harold.
Just and Unjust Warriors: Rodin, David.-Shue, Henry.
Knowing the Enemy: Habeck, Mary R.
Landscape of History: Gaddis, John Lewis.
Last Stand of Fox Company: Drury, Bob.-Clavin, Thomas.
Leadership: Ulmer, Walter F.-McCaffrey, Barry R.-Kolenda, Christopher D.
Leadership and the New Science: Wheatley, Margaret J.
Leading at the Edge: Perkins, Dennis N. T.-Murphy, Jillian B.-Holtman, Margaret P.
Lean Thinking: Womack, James P.-Jones, Daniel T.
Learning Large Lessons: Johnson, David E.
LeMay: Kozak, Warren
Lincoln and His Admirals: Symonds, Craig L.
Louis Johnson and the Arming of America: McFarland, Keith D.-Roll, David L.
Maneuver Warfare Handbook: Lind, William S.
Masters of the Air: Miller, Donald L.
Masters of War: Handel, Michael I.
Military Power: Biddle, Stephen D.
Modern War and the Utility of Force: Duyvesteyn, Isabelle-Angstrom, Jan.
On Becoming a Leader: Bennis, Warren G.
On Nuclear Terrorism: Levi, Michael.
On War: Clausewitz, Carl von.
Once an Eagle: Myrer, Anton.
Overcoming Post-deployment Syndrome: Cifu, David X.-Blake, Cory.
Overcoming the Five Dysfunctions of a Team: Lencioni, Patrick
Patton: Axelrod, Alan.-Clark, Wesley K.
Personal Memoirs of U.S. Grant: Grant, Ulysses S.
Power Mentoring: Ensher, Ellen A.-Murphy, Susan E.
Presidential Courage: Beschloss, Michael R.
Red Badge of Courage: Crane, Stephen.
Rivals: Emmott, Bill.
Sailor's History of the U.S. Navy: Cutler, Thomas J.
Sea Power and the Asia-Pacific: Bratton, Patrick.-Till, Geoffrey.
Secrets of Special Ops Leadership: Cohen, William A.
Six Frigates: Toll, Ian W.
Starship Troopers: Heinlein, Robert A.
Success Built to Last: Porras, Jerry I.-Emery, Stewart-Thompson, Mark
Team of Rivals: Goodwin, Doris Kearns.
Testing American Sea Power: Felker, Craig C.
The AEF Way of War: Grotelueschen, Mark E.
The Armed Forces Officer:
The Art of War: Sunzi-Calthrop, Everard Ferguson-Wu, Qi-Butler-Bowdon, Tom
The Face of Battle: Keegan, John
The Five Dysfunctions of a Team: Lencioni, Patrick
The Forgotten Soldier: Sajer, Guy.
The Global Achievement Gap: Wagner, Tony.
The Grand Strategy of the Byzantine Empire: Luttwak, Edward.
The Guns of August: Tuchman, Barbara Wertheim.
The Little Book of Economics: Ip, Greg
The Metal Life Car: Buker, George E.
The Myth of the Clash of Civilizations: Bottici, Chiara.-Challand, Benoît
The Naval Air War in Korea: Hallion, Richard P.
The Next Level: Eblin, Scott
The Origins of War: Guilaine, Jean.-Zammit, Jean.
The Peloponnesian War: Lazenby, J. F.
The Red Badge of Courage: Crane, Stephen-Sorrentino, Paul.
The Thousand-mile War: Garfield, Brian
The Warrior Ethos: Coker, Christopher.
Thinking About America's Defense: Kent, Glenn A.-Ochmanek, David A.-Spirtas, Michael.-Pirnie, Bruce
Transformation Under Fire: Macgregor, Douglas A.
Understanding Arabs: Nydell, Margaret K.
United States Coast Guard in World War II: Ostrom, Thomas P.
Victory on the Potomac: Locher, James R.
War to End All Wars: Coffman, Edward M.
What Went Wrong?: Lewis, Bernard.
Why Air Forces Fail: Higham, Robin D. S.-Harris, Stephen John.
Winged Defense: Mitchell, William
1 note
·
View note