the geekification of chrissy cunningham
phase one - weed and puppy love / phase two / phase three
8.2K words
warnings - weed smoking, internalized queerphobia of some form or another (polyamory wasn't a coined label in the 80s but yeah, internalized hatred of that), emotional cheating (on both ends for the same person)
summary - Following her public break-up with Jason Carver, Chrissy Cunningham finds comfort and affection in two of Hawkins' most renowned freaks. Coincidentally, you and your boyfriend, Eddie, both seem to have a crush on the poor girl.
~~
The news was out mere minutes after it happened. Chrissy Cunningham and Jason Carver broke up - for good. In the parking lot before school, the two called it splits and some freshmen from band overheard the whole thing; immediately spreading it like wildfire on dry grass.
“Did you hear?” Mike was staring at you and Eddie with eyes bugging from their sockets. Dustin and Lucas trailing after him, equally (if not more, depending on which one you looked at) shocked.
You and Eddie were in the secluded area of the theater room that was exclusive for set design - organizing for the campaign later that night.
“Hear what?” you turn to the boys, a brow raised.
“The queen of Hawkins High just broke up with her boyfriend,” Mike reaches out to shake you by the shoulders.
Eddie knocks the boy’s hands off you and shrugs, “Okay? I don’t know if you noticed, young paladin, but we aren’t exactly the audience to care for that.”
“But you do see how it’s insane, right?” Lucas stresses, stepping forward.
“I guess, if you didn’t know that Carver was a total dick,” you reach back so your hands support you against the table, “but we all did. Especially you, Sinclair, you were on the basketball team.”
“It’s just crazy that it finally happened,” Dustin looks between you and Eddie, “Isn’t it crazy?”
“Yeah, two people broke up, totally nuts,” you shake your head.
“We would never do that,” Eddie leans over to kiss your cheek, “We’re too powerful.”
“The freak power couple,” you take his hand in yours and squeeze, “I wouldn’t wanna be with anyone else.”
“I’m talking about real news here and you’re making it about yourselves,” Mike cringes, “You two are gross.”
…
“You two are gross.”
You remember muttering that about Chrissy and Jason. Not directly about Chrissy, she hardly looked like she’d been enjoying herself, but if you were referencing a couple then it would be more accurate to address both parties.
No. Now that you think about it, it’s entirely accurate to address solely Jason.
You sigh and flip your eyes up to the clock, a mere three minutes left of class. When you look up, though, you notice something actually bizarre.
Chrissy Cunningham herself - looking unnaturally stressed, and you can’t help the way your heart tugs at the sight of the poor girl.
“Uh, you okay?” what a dumb question.
Chrissy’s eyes widen before falling to you and she forces a grin, “Yeah, sorry… just spacing out, I guess.”
“My boyfriend,” you lean in closer to whisper to her, “I’m assuming you know because I’ve literally seen you buy from him but I’m just reminding you: he sells.”
“I don’t have much money on me today,” she murmurs.
“I can talk him into a discount,” you shrug and lean back before any student could get suspicious, “Just something to help you feel better after… you know.”
“You heard about that?” her eyes skip down to her hands. Fingers scratching at her rose pink nail polish.
“I think everyone in school has, to be honest,” you rub the back of your neck, “If it makes you feel better - I’m not one of the kids that thinks you’re crazy.”
She chuckles, but it feels absolutely hollow, “Right.”
“I’m serious,” you lean forward and rest your chin in the palm of your hand, “Even if I hadn’t sat next to you this entire year and learned what a sweetheart the queen of Hawkins High could be - I’d still just assume you were doing the right thing.”
“You mean that?” she looks up at you again, brows pinched and blue eyes less lively than you’ve ever seen.
“Duh,” maybe not the best way to phrase that, “I mean, even if it’s not for a specific reason, it isn’t like you can just stick around if you lose feelings or whatever. Plus, I’m more than 85% convinced Jason Carver is capable of murder.”
She gasps and slaps your arm, but it’s in good humor as she starts giggling, “Oh my God!”
“I’m just saying, man, he has - like - this Tom Cruise aura.”
“Tom Cruise?” she’s beaming at you now, broad-lipped and easygoing.
“Have you seen his movies and interviews?” she nods and you throw up your hands, “Does he not have a weird aura? Like, he’s got such an intense friendliness with nothing behind the eyes.”
Whether Chrissy actually links the two now or not, she’s laughing at your jokes and it’s got you feeling better than when you got to join Corroded Coffin. And that was saying something.
Chrissy’s smile slowly fades until it’s left completely faint, the corners not quite meeting the eyes, “Sorry if I worried you, I was just trying to think of what to do after school. Usually, when there’s no practice I stick around for basketball and get a ride home, but…”
Before you think out the logistics, you blurt out, “You can hang out with me and my boyfriend and we can drive you home,” then the reality of where you have to be hits you, “I mean, I have to sit in his Hellfire meeting and it’ll actually be my boyfriend driving, but - hey, it’s something.”
“Hellfire?” she thinks for a moment and then her eyes light up in recognition, “Oh, Dungeons and Dragons?”
“Yeah.”
“You play?”
“Nope,” when she shoots you a puzzled look, you shrug, “I don’t play, but Eddie and I make tapes and shit with sound effects and ambient music. I play them when I’m not doing a snack run. It sounds boring, but it won’t be that bad, I promise.”
You shouldn’t promise that because now that you say it out loud, the anxiety is realized that it actually might be worse than boring.
“Sorry, nevermind - I’m realizing how insane I sound.”
“No!” she croons, almost pitying (you’d rather just be outright rejected), “I’ll go.”
“You’re serious?”
“Yeah - why not?” she rolls her eyes good-naturedly, “You’re fun.”
“I am?” you pull back, “No way.”
“Yeah,” she nudges your shoulder with yours, “I like you. I’m glad I got to be your seat partner.”
“You’re talking like the year’s over,” you tease, “Plan on moving, Cunningham?”
“No,” the bell rings and she stands to swing her bag over her shoulders, “Now that I have an invitation to watch the Hellfire Club, the only way you’re getting rid of me is in a body bag.”
“Your dedication will surely be appreciated,” you nod, pulling your own bag over your shoulders to leave.
In the passing period between third and fourth hour, you and Eddie usually meet in the janitor’s closet right next to your U.S history because his economics class is directly across the hall. It’s always for a quick kiss that can’t be interrupted with cackles and whispers, but this time you’re almost suffocating him with the tight grip you have on the collar of his shirt.
“Remember that no-watchers rule?” you say as soon as the closet door shuts.
“Yeah,” he tilts his head, eyes narrowing in his confusion, “What’d you do?”
“I invited Chrissy Cunningham to hang out with me and she actually said yes.”
He’s silent - very peculiar behavior for Eddie Munson - for a while. Then, he shakes his head, screws his eyes shut and blanches, “You what?”
“Chrissy agreed to hang out with me during the Hellfire campaign,” you cross your arms, “I didn’t think she’d even take me up on it - she was just talking about having nothing to do and I felt really bad. Also, you have to give her a ride home,” when his jaw drops at your words you look away, “I’m sorry, I totally freaked.”
“Yes, you did,” he nods, laughing - actually laughing! - at you, “You freaked, sweet angel.”
“Please, just help me with this,” you sigh and bury your face in the crook of Eddie’s neck, “I wanna be her friend so bad, now.”
“Really?” his chest moves with his laughter and you have half a mind to swat him for it.
“Yeah, she laughed at all my jokes and now I can understand why you’re friends with freshmen.”
“You know what? I was going to help you, and then you said that.”
You mock gasp and whine, “Nooooo, wait. I’m sorry.”
“I have to go,” Eddie pulls away and leaves a kiss on your forehead, “And, yes, she can stay at Hellfire and I’ll give her a ride.”
“Thank you.”
“You knew I was gonna say yes,” he huffs, sending you a final smile before slipping out of the closet and towards his next class.
And it’s true. You ask to get it out there, but you already knew what his answer would be. Not out of entitlement, but because Eddie is Eddie and he does whatever he can to help you out of being awkward. Even if it means spending more on gas than usual because you accidentally volunteered him to drive a girl home without his knowledge.
Not that he’s complaining. He’s only spoken with Chrissy a handful of times, mostly when she's buying weed and she can’t help but be friendly. He thinks she's pretty. She's nice. He likes her in a more general way, though - duh. Where you have no reason to dislike a person and they’re too nice and you’ve known them too long for you to feel neutral about them. For a cheerleader, she’s pretty cool.
…
Eddie has a certain motion he makes when he needs the ambiance. His hand shoots up and he shakes a fist in the air to the vigor of his words and you hit play. It’s easy and it came from a guilt-ridden boyfriend who thought it cruel to make you focus from the sidelines when you could be doing something else (another thing you loved about him, he was always worried about you not being bored - despite his own hyperfixation on the game). So, he does that for you to see while reading or working, not that you do that too often when you can just let the overly theatrical party be your entertainment.
But now that you’ve got Chrissy sat beside you on a wood table at the far side of the room, you’re surprisingly grateful for the motion.
You two have to be quiet so as to not break the boys’ concentration, and your eyes dart to the table every so often just to make sure they didn’t overhear you.
“I hope Hellfire is everything you hoped for,” you whisper, feeling the stray hairs from her framing bangs tickle your cheeks.
“It definitely is,” she whispers back, eyes filled with genuine wonder despite your teasing, “I never thought there was a game like this,” then her gaze flicks to you, “Like, I knew that D&D existed, but not that it was so roleplay heavy.”
“What were you expecting?”
She seems hesitant until she registers your honest curiosity, “More board-game, I guess. Like a fantasy Monopoly.”
You press your lips to keep from laughing at the image, “Be sure you don’t say that to any of the guys - they’re insane.”
“Do you ever join?” she whispers and you shake your head in response, her brows draw worriedly, “Why not?”
“The guys don’t like me in their party ‘cuz I roll like shit and Eddie’s got a stage four case of favoritism,” she covers her mouth to prevent audibly giggling, “It’s fucking terminal. He lets me attack when I roll 1’s and those are literally the lowest you can go.”
Chrissy leans closer to you when she’s laughing - or rather, withholding her laughter. Her head tosses back and you feel that sense of pride from earlier resurface.
Eddie’s head comes up and he shakes his fist, “And thunder - " you hit play without even looking away from Chrissy, “crackles!”
You let the sound run through the theater room before pausing again, you angle yourself to whisper in Chrissy’s ear again, “Wanna hear a secret?”
“Of course.”
“I wanna get punched,” she immediately pulls back, eyes wide and mouth hanging open, “like, in a high school fight. I feel like it’s a vital high school experience.”
Chrissy returns to your side and slowly nods, “Not the weirdest thing I’ve ever heard.”
“What’s the weirdest thing you’ve ever heard?”
“My little brother tried explaining the reeking weed smell in his room on a burnt microwave dinner,” she grins, eyes shooting to the high ceiling before returning to you, “If it’ll help you fulfill your violent fantasy, I can definitely think of people who need beating up.”
“Wow, you think I could beat them up?” this time, your brows raise, “I look scary and talk big, but I don’t actually fight anymore, Chris.”
She seems to light up at the nickname, more so than the staged reaction you’d seen her give Jason.
“I believe in you,” her hand lays on your shoulder and you can see her pink nails glimmer in the dim lighting, “You’re tough.”
“I’m a poser, actually,” you admit, returning to your lean so you’re pressed against her, “I don’t even hate the world that much, just some of the people. Totally not the hardcore metal everyone expects.”
You’re disturbed by the fact that every time you lean in to whisper in her ear, you have the strong urge to lean just a little further and bite her neck. Not in the vampire way people would assume of you, but in a way you’re sure should be reserved for your boyfriend.
“I think it’s pretty metal,” her hand takes yours and she starts playing with the emerald ring Eddie got you for your first anniversary, “You’re pretty badass.”
“I’m nothing of the sort,” you murmur, “Haven’t even egged someone’s house and that’s, like, the right of passage to being cool. That and eventually getting lung cancer from all the chain-smoking.”
“Well,” her pink nails pick at your ripped black stockings, “I think you’re mighty metal, if it’s any consolation.”
“It absolutely is,” you bring your own fingers to drag gently across the hem of her cheer skirt, “As long as I can intimidate the general population while being a total wimp, I’m happy.”
“You’re not a wimp,” you see Eddie raise his fist again and you hit play until the silence of a finished track rings through the room, “I think you’re brave for not trying to be someone you’re not.”
“You do?”
“Yeah,” she grins and you two lean even closer, “Even cooler than your boyfriend.”
“Wow, that’s definitely something hard to be.”
“I think you’re both super cool. You’re just a little higher on the scale.”
You two grow closer. Her breath flutters faintly across your lips and she smells like the bubblegum you saw her chewing at lunch. You’re giggling - you both are.
And then Eddie claps from his throne at the head of the D&D table.
“Piss break, losers and dweebs,” Eddie stands and stretches, “Don’t need another accident.”
You and Chrissy have snapped apart by now, but you can see the way she’s staring at you - wide eyed and squirming.
She clears her throat and hops off the table, “Did he say ‘another accident’?”
“You don’t wanna know,” you follow her lead and wander over to Eddie.
“My sweet princess,” if he noticed the closeness between you and Chrissy, he doesn’t say anything. Instead, he cups your cheeks and squeezes them, kissing your squished lips, “Would you be an absolute doll and please get us snacks?”
“Who would I be if not the loyal snack squire?” you run your fingers up his sides and relish in the way he shivers, “Gonna give me money?”
“I taught you where to hit the glass,” he grins, pinching your cheek, “Have fun.”
You bat his hand away and begin out the door, pausing only to look at Chrissy - who’s nervously fiddling with the sleeve of her varsity jacket while staring at her shoes - and calling to her, “Hey, princess!”
She jumps and turns, “Me?”
It’s almost as though she doesn’t know how precious she is.
“Yeah,” your head jerks towards the hall, “wanna come get snacks for 9-year-olds with me?”
“Sure,” she cheers and bounces to your side, “Do you do this every time?”
“Not every time,” you shrug, “Just when I’m feeling charitable, I guess. Or when there’s a nice girl to keep me company.”
Chrissy’s lips pull up in a smile and you like the way her gloss shines under the dark hallway’s emergency lights.
“You and Eddie are cute,” she remarks. It’s soft. Tender.
“Thanks,” you stop in front of the vending machine, “We try,” you turn to her as you copy the specific hits to the frame and glass that Eddie had indeed taught you to get free snacks, “It’s actually a huge act to win cutest freaks in the yearbook.”
“Stop,” she protests quietly, a frown on her lips. Chrissy kneels on the hard linoleum and picks out what treats fall to the pit of the machine, “You guys aren’t freaks.”
“Well, you might be the only one who thinks so,” you join her and the two of you come to a stand with armfuls of student council approved junk food, “It’s okay, Chris. We’re definitely used to it by now.”
You don’t tell her about how long it took to get used to, though. You don’t wanna break her little heart - certainly not when she just got out of a relationship.
She doesn’t have to know about the fights you used to pick or the late nights Eddie spent clutching to you and tearfully asking if you thought he was a freak too. She doesn’t have to know about how you and Eddie used to pretend to laugh just so that nobody noticed the tears beginning to form.
Yes, you two got used to it, but it took time before the shell grew.
She doesn’t tell you that she used to find you two as intimidating as she did fascinating. With black clothes and shirts for bands she was told were sent by the Devil and heavy eyeliner for when you were feeling especially outgoing. She used to think you two were mean and scary, but neither of you are anything of the sort. She was as enamored as she was frightened.
The only scary thing about you and Eddie is the idea of never seeing you two again. And that realization terrifies her.
You and Chrissy dump your combined loot on the table and you look around the room to see everyone except your boyfriend at the table.
The boys amble to where you and Chrissy are stationed to grab something, Dustin looks at you as he snags a bag of chips, “Your boyfriend's taking a leak.”
“‘Cuz I totally didn’t gather that,” you roll your eyes and Chrissy snickers behind you. Dustin’s lips press thinly and you tousle his hair, “Thanks, Henderson.”
“Eddie seems like a good boyfriend,” Chrissy mumbles and you assume it to be a lament of her own past relationship.
You turn to the girl and sigh, “You know, he seems dreamy, but for my birthday, he got me kids’ 2-in-1 shampoo and conditioner.”
“I never would’ve guessed he was that kind of guy. With that hair?” she shakes her head, arms crossing over her chest, “I’m shocked and surprised.”
“Yeah? Stunned, even?”
“Aghast,” she steps closer and lays her hand over yours on the table, “Horrified, now that I think about it.”
Eddie claps a hand on your shoulder, “Thank you, my dear princesses.”
“Of course,” you meet his lips with yours and he retreats to his throne.
Chrissy’s hand slowly retracts from yours. Her hands clasp and you slide onto the table - an awkward exchange of tight-lipped smiles passes between you two.
Princess is a term of endearment Eddie reserved for you - and you alone - and you’re confused as to why him using it with Chrissy doesn’t make you jealous. If anything, it sweetens something inside you.
An ideal - where you and Chrissy and Eddie-
You shake your head. Brows pinching.
What the fuck?
“Are you okay?” Chrissy asks softly, hand hovering over your shoulder.
“Yeah,” you wave off her sweet concern, “I’m fine.”
Girls think girls are attractive - that just happens, but you’ve never had thoughts like that. Three people dating at once?
You’ve never seen that anywhere. Nowhere good anyway.
“Are you sure?” she leans in and you wanna brush the hanging hair behind her ears. You wanna smoothen the skin that wrinkles at her brows. You wanna make the frown on her lips disappear.
“Yeah,” you whisper as Eddie picks up his character as narrator, “totally.”
Totally.
…
“Shit,” Eddie huffs as you three come upon his van, replacing his keys into his pocket, “I’ve got deals. Shouldn’t be too long.”
Normally you go with him when he has to sell after school, but normally Chrissy isn’t hanging out with you two.
“Chrissy and I can just sit in the car.”
Eddie hums and shakes his head, already starting to walk towards the woods lining Hawkins High, “I think it’s illegal to leave babies in hot cars!”
“We’re both eighteen!” you grumble, but trail after him with Chrissy in tow.
“It’s also spring,” she points out.
“We never know what could happen,” Eddie says once you’re both on either side of him, “What if you magically transform into babies and the magic makes the van boil? Then what?”
“Then you’ve started taking hard drugs and are hallucinating,” you take Eddie’s hand in yours and grin when Chrissy laughs at your joke.
You and Chrissy end up leaning against one of the big trees while Eddie talks one of the jocks (that throws pencils at your head and calls you a witch) into overpaying for a gram of weed.
“I don’t mean to intrude,” Chrissy’s voice is light, just enough to where she could pretend to not have said anything if you didn’t hear, “but if you and Eddie don’t have anything going on, can we… hang out more tonight?”
Chrissy can feel her heart in her throat. She’s almost petrified at the knowledge of why she’s so desperate to cling to you both. When she’s with you and Eddie, she feels like herself. No, she feels bigger. Like a firework. Big and showy and demanding of attention, attention that you two gladly hand over in groves - certainly more than Jason ever did. But more than that, she knows what realization is swimming beneath the surface - she’s attracted to you. Both of you.
“Uh, might need to talk to Eddie, just to make sure there’s nothing else,” you watch the jock walk away fifty bucks out.
Your hand brushes her shoulder comfortingly as you pass and Chrissy’s heart thrums at the contact.
She’s known for a long while - that she isn’t like everyone else. She couldn’t tell a soul, but she surely knew. Girls don’t fantasize about Tanya Roberts while having sex with their boyfriend unless there’s something behind the straight and narrow persona. She doesn’t know exactly what to call herself - she likes girls and boys and she’s come to terms with that.
She’s come to terms with the fact that she has a crush on you and Eddie. It was easy to fall for you two despite your differing social status once she actually met you both, not that she ever cared for that bullshit in the first place.
You were easy to get along with and while you could be awkward, she found it endearing how earnest you were in trying to be friendly with her - not for her standing as “queen” but for her personality. Eddie was charming and boisterous and unafraid to be himself in a hellish place like Hawkins, jumping to make her comfortable when he noticed her getting nervous during their deals.
But while you and Eddie are talking, she sees how delusional she is.
You three can hang out, sure, but there’s barriers between her fantasy of joining your couple and real life. For one - she’s never seen anything good said about three people dating at once and it never seems to end well. And two - she doubts that you two would want to date someone like her. She’s part of the crowd that wounds you and your friends so deeply, no matter how different she may be, she’s still in that circle.
People would hate you two even more. Or call you charity cases. Either way, rumors would spread and she’d hate to ruin your lives even more.
“Good news, princess,” Eddie calls as you start walking back to the tree, “Council has decided that you can bum it with the freaks.”
“He’s being dramatic,” you whisper to her, “All I did was suggest you hang out and he agreed. Like immediately.”
Chrissy giggles as you roll your eyes.
A cheerleader pulls up to the bench this time. Her eyes bug out when she sees her dear captain standing by you.
“Chrissy?” the girl points as she sits, “You… with them?”
“Uh,” Chrissy freezes up and she feels your eyes slide from her to the floor - Eddie is silent for once as he gets a bag from his lunchbox. You’re both radiating disappointment.
Like you’re already expecting her to deny - to come up with an excuse.
It hurts her that you’ve both accepted this - and she wonders how many popular kids have done what she has, just to stab you in the back.
“Yeah,” she grins and her arm slithers over your shoulders, squeezing you close to her side (she likes the mix of your sweet perfume and Eddie’s cologne that clings to your skin, and she’s sure it’ll be distracting her when she’s alone in bed later), “I’m with them.”
The deal is quiet and the cheerleader walks away without anything other than weird stares.
“You’re committing social suicide, by the way,” you mutter.
“Huh?” Chrissy’s eyes search yours, “How?”
She knows exactly how, but maybe by pretending to be clueless, you two won’t feel so bad.
“Hanging out with us,” Eddie continues, he lays a gentle hand on her shoulder, “It’s nice ‘n’ all, but you don’t have to if you don’t want your buddies judging you.”
“Yeah, we get it,” you say that, but the way you start nervously twirling your ring around your finger tells her otherwise, “It’s fine.”
“No,” she takes Eddie’s hand and grabs yours, squeezing both, “I want to hang out with you guys. I’m having fun. I don’t care what the others think.”
“Then enough sap shit,” Eddie turns away and guides you and Chrissy to the van by your connected hands, “Some rich boy didn’t wanna be spotted at the bench, so we’ve gotta go to Lovers’ Lake.”
God loved teasing Chrissy Cunningham, she supposes.
Going to an infamous make-out spot with her two crushes - no matter how childish she feels calling you two that. It should be a dream come true. In another world, maybe it is.
It’s a quiet ride (aside from you and Eddie in the front seat arguing whether Ozzy Osbourne was better alone or with Black Sabbath) and once the van is parked, you and Eddie both get out. You pull open the back doors and motion for Chrissy to hop over the seats into the bed of the van. You climb onto the quilt laid down as Chrissy follows your instructions.
“Be back soon, dears,” Eddie grins wildly and pats the doors before wandering off.
The sky is beginning to wash in pink and orange and you look over at Chrissy. Her skin is shining in the sherbet hue and her hair has begun falling messy out of her ponytail. She sits with her legs tucked underneath her, green skirt falling over her smooth, soft-looking thighs.
You have to look away.
You regret doing so because as soon as you do, you see him. Andy Johnson - Jason’s best friend and your technical first boyfriend.
“Ew,” you huff and lean forward, slamming the van doors shut.
You press the bulb in the van’s roof to on and Chrissy is already looking at you. You can read the question on her lips before she even asks it.
“We’ve got…” you gesture loosely, “history…”
“Aw,” she leans in and places a perfectly manicured hand delicately over yours, “what happened?”
You try to laugh but it soaks in dismality, “He Pretty in Pink’d me - but without the cool, happy ending,” she only leans closer and raises a brow, “In middle school, he asked me out, and then after our date, he just avoided me completely. Then after school, he asked me to homecoming as an apology but would still totally avoid me in public. So, when I confronted him in the hall like a week later, he just acted like I was crazy and had no idea what I was saying.”
“Oh my God,” she cups a hand over her mouth, wildly offended on your behalf, “why would he do that?”
You two had gone to the same school - but even she never heard about that. She sat next to Andy for months. She laughed at his jokes. She spoke with him like a friend. She was a friend, to at least some degree. She never once heard your name out of his mouth.
“Because I was a freak. Am a freak.”
“No, you are not,” Chrissy sits up on her knees and takes your face into her hands, her eyes alight with passion, “You didn’t deserve that. It’s unfair what he did to you.”
“Yeah, well,” you swallow hard and try not to show how nervous she’s making you, “what can you do?”
“I’ll never let him do that again,” she promises, her palms press your face and you can feel your lips scrunch the way they do when Eddie’s trying to be funny before he kisses you, “Never again. Not to you, not to Eddie.”
“Thanks, princess,” your hands come over her shoulders, gently pushing her so she’s sitting again, “but we’ll be okay. Worst that’s happened to us has been someone throwing produce at the windshield while we’re driving.”
She gasps and you chuckle darkly.
You two are from opposite worlds and it shows in how she’s so troubled by what you’ve shared. You push the doors open and peek out at where Eddie now sits alone. He’s returning his lunchbox to order - something you insisted on making a routine after every deal so he doesn’t forget or lose track of supply.
You never imagined it’d be like this. With you and Chrissy Cunningham sitting in the back of your boyfriend’s van while he finishes up a deal. You never imagined she’d actually be tagging along with you two.
But it’s odd, she doesn’t feel like a third wheel. The tension isn’t there. It’s like she’s meant to fit into the fray - a part of a three-piece tux, the missing link in the chain, the longest fry found at the bottom of the box.
And under the shitty bulb light in the back of Eddie’s van - of which, flickers and dims at its own will - Chrissy looks simply divine.
Eddie returns, stuffing stray bills into his pockets as he watches you and Chrissy chat.
Something is there - deep in his chest. There’s no jealousy, oddly enough. Maybe it’s because he doesn’t see her as a threat - Chrissy isn’t the type to overstep.
And that’s fine.
But that doesn’t erase what is there.
It’s love, he knows that. Love for you, of course. His beloved girlfriend of just under two years, the only person who he’s ever felt really believed in him, the only girl he ever brought home that Wayne liked (not that he brought girls home a lot but still). The angel who stooped so low as to join his band of misfits and smile with the brightness of a thousand suns and beauty of a million moons while doing so. Deeper down, however, there’s more affection.
Not quite love, but not weak enough for mere friendship. And it’s for Chrissy Cunningham.
It terrifies him, the idea of feeling that for her. He’s never heard of liking two people at once (unless they were described as an asshole) and it makes him feel more freakish than usual. Like he’s worthy of the wary stares and the pointing fingers.
It also terrifies him because he’s scared that if it grows larger, he’ll lose you. There’s no way he could fall out of love for you and he’d cut off his own feet before cheating, he knows that like he knows the color of the sky, but he also knows that if it does grow, he would have to tell you.
Because there’s no way that three people could date at once, right? And you’ve never so much as whispered anything about being interested in girls.
He feels disgusted with himself.
It’s new. Freshly revived over the course of this afternoon. A crush from before you two started dating that maybe he didn’t stuff deep enough into his closet.
He just does what he does best and pretends nothing has changed.
Eddie coaxes you two from the back of the van, “What do you say, Chrissy? Sweet elvish queen; wanna go home or continue this night of convivial trouble?”
Chrissy looks up at Eddie and you watch her bat her eyes while clutching your hand, she grins and lifts her stone blue eyes from him to you, “Convivial trouble.”
“Bewitching the queen of Hawkins High,” you say aloud, “Never thought we’d be doing that, Eds.”
…
The three of you end up back at Eddie’s trailer. You and Chrissy are sitting thigh-to-thigh on the living room floor, a joint passed between you as Eddie finally sets out to undoing his chunky boots.
“I never get to smoke at home,” Chrissy admits, “My mom would literally murder me.”
“Where do you go?” you’re not nearly as buzzed as Chrissy, that much is evident by her slower movement speed and bloodshot eyes, but you still feel it beneath your skin. Gentle slugs that you’ve grown somewhat fond of.
“The woods.”
“That’s dangerous,” you shake your head.
“It is dangerous,” Eddie is quick to agree and steps closer to the two of you, he kisses your forehead and gestures around the cramped trailer, “You’re always welcome to my castle, Elvish queen.”
“Oh, I dunno…” she twists the hem of her skirt nervously.
“You should,” you insist, “It’s nicer than the woods. And safer.”
“Much safer,” Eddie stands and pats his pockets, “I’ll be right back.”
“Where’re you going?” Chrissy pouts and you snatch the blunt from her fingers to take your own hit.
“Just getting more stuff, Chris,” he pulls his pockets inside out, “Seems I’ve misplaced mine.”
“You can have this,” she points at the roll between your lips, “You gave it to us, ‘s only fair.”
“No, you two have fun, I won’t be long.”
“He’ll be an eternity,” you shake your head and pass Chrissy the joint as you exhale, “Sweet Eddie loses all his shit.”
“Aw, you call him ‘Sweet Eddie’,” she giggles and inhales the smoke, slowly sliding to the floor as she releases it, “That’s adorable.”
“Yeah?” you take the joint and snuff it out in a nearby ashtray. Already half gone - guess you two smoked more than you thought.
“Yeah,” she beams.
You slide to the floor with her - the two of you staring up at the dreary, mildew-spotted trailer ceiling. Only the sound of Eddie shuffling through the mayhem he calls a bedroom (not that said mayhem ever stops you from going in) can be heard.
Chrissy’s social consciousness is always shot when she’s high. It’s something Jason hated and picked on her about when he found out she smoked - absolutely leading to their break up.
Although, without that consciousness, her tongue’s free to blurt out questions she can only hurt herself by asking.
"How long have you and Eddie been dating?"
"Uhhh," your eyes narrow up at the ceiling, "God. Almost two years," you turn your head, cheek to carpet, "We started dating at the end of his first senior year. He was seventeen and I was sixteen and we were joking that I'd get popular after he graduated because I was dating someone in college," you press your lips, "When he got held back, he started joking that I would graduate before him. And then…" you gesture generally around the room, "here we are: third try. Both seniors."
She pouts but then it lifts and she's smiling as she asks, "Do you think he'll get it this year?"
"Fuck yeah!" you cheer, "Eddie is, like, the smartest guy alive. Do you know how smart you have to be to deal drugs?" then, as if you think she doesn't believe you, you begin to explain, "School grades don't fucking matter like that, it tests memorization, not intelligence. Eddie is a super genius who can create the most engaging and awesome narratives, who gives a fuck if he can't name all the U.S presidents? They're all dickheads anyway."
"You're a good girlfriend," she mumbles, eyes falling closed, "Eddie's really lucky to have you."
Normally when one of your mutual friends would say something like that, the response was always something simple.
"We're lucky to have each other."
Or
"Yeah, he is."
But this time you're not so compelled. This time you want her to know she's a catch, too.
"Jason was so lucky to have you, you know," you don't even know why you're saying this, but the words are flowing and won't stop, "I'm sorry he was so awful."
Her lips purse and she shrugs, "I'm happy now, so… it's fine."
"You can be pissed. Don’t hafta pretend with us."
"I'm pissed, but in, like, a 'why-did-I-date-him' way. Like now I'm realizing how much he sucked and I feel a lot better for when I wasn't super into him during the relationship."
"God, that is so cool of you."
“You really think so?”
“Hell yeah, it’s super cool.”
“You know what I think is super cool?” she grins and you just shoot her a quizzical stare, “You.”
“Ew.”
“Stop, I’m being serious,” she half-asses a swat to your arm, “I’ve actually been obsessed with you since seventh grade.”
“No way,” you gape, “Why would you do that to yourself?”
“I always just thought you were super cool, you always took what people said and didn’t let it bother you. I looked up to you.”
“We didn’t even talk…” you look at her skeptically.
“No, we didn’t,” her eyes - stone blue and filled with wonder - shoot to the ceiling, “September 30th, 1980, I remember it so clearly. You and I had lockers on opposite sides of the hallway and I was just coming out of art when I saw it. Do you remember?”
“From a specific date? Couldn’t recall if you paid me,” you shake your head.
“You opened your locker,” she’s whispering, and it’s somewhere just between melancholy and admiring, “and out fell animal guts and pelts and the word ‘witch’ was painted in blood on the back wall. And I remember feeling so bad and I was about to go over when I saw you whip around and sock two boys in the face for laughing. And then you asked who did it and started a fight with Sally White because she was behind it,” she sighs, almost dreamily, “Ever since then - I’ve been in complete awe at you.”
“Wow,” your hands come to rest on your tummy, “I didn’t know you were watching little ole me.”
“Yeah. I’ve always wanted to be more like you because of that. Because of how you didn’t take shit like that.”
“Well, if it makes you feel better, I thought you were cool, too. I still do, I mean.”
“What?” her eyes widen and you nod, “Why?”
“You’re cheer captain and the most popular girl in school and you can handle that so well. I don’t know how you could run those routines, I’d be so nervous I’d puke over myself. And you’re so genuine and you’ve never done anything like…” you shrug, “putting animal gore into people’s lockers.”
“I feel like that’s the standard, though.”
“Well that’s the thing, it is, but when kids get popular they forget that. You never did and you’ve been popular since freshman year. You’re the nicest person I’ve ever known. I really wanted to be your actual friend, not just the girl you talked to in U.S history.”
“What a coincidence,” she mutters, “I always wanted to be more than the girl you talked to in U.S history, too.”
“Good for us,” you hold up your fist and Chrissy meekly bumps her knuckles with yours.
Turning on your side, you lay down your hand and Chrissy copies the motion - her soft palm settling over yours.
“I had a dream in sixth period,” you rub your eyes, “that we met in, like, second grade.”
“What’d we do?”
“We played house,” Chrissy stares at you and you stare at her, you worry your lip between your teeth.
“Then what happened?” she rolls to lean herself up on her elbows and look down at you.
You roll onto your back and you can feel her arms brush against your side.
Then what happened?
You two grew up and started dating. You moved away from society to be gay in a cottage in the heart of the woods. Then a knight that, despite never clearly seeing his face, you knew was meant to be Eddie took refuge in your home. A night of refuge that did, in fact, end in long-term love-making.
But you can’t look Chrissy in her precious eyes and say that, so you lie instead.
“Your face melted off and I drank it,” you grin when she gasps.
Not technically a lie, it’s just that you actually had a dream like that about Nancy Wheeler in junior year.
“Oh my God, I didn’t know the mind could dream of stuff like that…”
“It’s all the Satanism music and dating the D&D kid.”
Chrissy leans forward and it’s almost dangerous how close your lips are, “Do you think I’ll start getting messed up dreams like that by association with you two?”
“Hmm, maybe,” you tilt your head so your faces are even closer together, “Better watch out, princess. We just might infect you.”
There’s a stiff silence. Tense but not in the awkward way you felt around other popular kids. You feel safer - appreciated, even. This tension is like the moments before a firework goes off.
Her eyes are half-lidded and you can just make out the way her pretty pink gloss shines under the orange fluorescents of Eddie’s trailer. For a split moment, you wonder what it’d be like to kiss her. Then, the thought returns and you let it linger.
Until you hear Eddie - the boy you swear you’re gonna marry - and his heavy footfalls root around his room. And you sit up as Chrissy scoots away.
What the fuck is your problem?
"So," Chrissy looks up at you through her lashes, "what's metal about?"
"Huh?"
"Your ‘Satanism music’,” she chuckles, as though you two weren’t about to kiss, “Like, what's the deal? What's it mean?"
"Honestly? No idea, I just like the way it sounds," you watch her lick her glossed lips, "Although - when you're in the middle of a crowd of rejects who feel just as angry about being rejects as you do and the music is so fucking loud you can feel it in your ribs? It's like you're on top of the world."
"Isn't that overwhelming?" she looks so concerned and your heart wrenches at the sight.
"Oh, absolutely, but I think that's what I like about it. When it feels like you're about to lose your mind because it's so loud and your whole body is vibrating, I like that."
"I guess I'll just have to go to one someday."
"Eddie and I can take you," you wanna reach out and hold her hands, but you stop yourself, "so you know the good one to go to. Going to concerts alone can be fucking awful anyway."
Her smile only widens at the proposition, "I'd love to."
Eddie doesn’t end up finding his weed.
…
Chrissy is passed out in the backseat of Eddie’s van. His radio is quiet - certainly much quieter than when the boys would pass out in his van.
“We tuckered her out,” you mutter, glancing in the rearview mirror.
“Yeah,” Eddie glances at the girl in his mirror, “I wasn’t expecting her to like us so much.”
“Me neither,” you lean your head back so it thunks the headrest of your boyfriend’s van.
“What’s your bet?”
“Huh?”
“C’mon, baby,” he smiles but it isn’t like the usual sweet ones he saves for you, it’s bitter, “people like her don’t hang out with people like us. It was nice to pretend, but really. What do you think it is?”
“I think she’s being serious,” you pout and tilt your head, “She’s really nice, Eds.”
“I know she is, but I’m just saying. Nobody that popular slums it with us.”
“Well, it can’t be a dare. The other cheerleader seemed surprised and there’s no way she’s that good an actress. And there’s no way she wants a discount, you already practically give it away. Your favoritism leaves no room for want.”
You two were used to that. You and Eddie actually bonded over it when you first met. Both of you are filled with stories of having people ask you out as a joke. Having kids insist on hanging out with Eddie only to find out they wanted free stuff from him. Jocks and preps inviting you out to things only to overhear their bet on who could sleep with you first.
Everyone wanted you two as a game. A twisted joke. And then they’d laugh and convince themselves you two deserved it and that you two were the evil ones in town. As if sitting in Eddie’s trailer all March and learning how to play Master of Puppets by Metallica was an act of the Devil himself.
But Chrissy seems different. Is different.
Eddie nods slowly, lips pressing, “Alright, sweetheart.”
“I’m serious,” you start playing with your ring out of nervous habit, and like the attentive boyfriend he is, Eddie notices immediately.
“Hey, I’m sorry,” he glances at you, swallowing the retorts he could spit, “If you believe her, then so do I, sweetheart.”
He flashes you a smile and before you even think about it - your lips are returning the gesture.
You love Eddie. He’s loud. He cares. He’s loyal almost to a fault. Where you go, he follows and where he runs, you run. You two are in it for the long haul. If not forever, then until one of you grows sick of the other - which, in total honesty, is just something you say to appease your parents that hate Eddie.
You’re in it forever.
And Chrissy complicates this. Not because you want to leave Eddie, not at all, but because you want her to join you two; you have no idea how to even begin bringing it up to him.
The van comes to a careful stop outside Chrissy’s house and you turn to wake her - only to find that she’s already coming to consciousness.
“We’re here, princess,” you coo.
“Did I really fall asleep?” she huffs, rubbing at her eyes, “I’m so sorry, guys.”
“Don’t even worry about it,” Eddie would’ve at least teased if it was one of the boys.
“Want someone to help you to your door?” you only offer because you’re not completely certain how sober she is at the moment.
That’s the only reason.
“Uhm,” she dry-swallows and nods, “yes, please.”
You end up with Chrissy’s arm in yours as you guide her to her front door. She only stumbles twice so you’re confident she can at least make it to her room without suspicion.
Before you can leave her at her door, Chrissy looks up at you with those big, sweet eyes, “Will you and Eddie really take me to a concert?”
“Of course, we will,” then, suddenly, the remembrance of what tomorrow is fills your head, “If you really want a metal concert experience, you should totally come see us,” you sardonically grin, “The Hideout. Tomorrow. Corroded Coffin: live and in person until ten.”
“Wow, really?” Chrissy plays along, “And what do you play?”
“Ah, only the most important part,” you say like it’s obvious, “I’m the very loved and very known bassist to our other three guitarists. It’s a real once-in-a-lifetime show you’d be missing out on.”
“You don’t sound so enthused about all this.”
“Corroded Coffin is great,” you relent, “I do think we’re, like, good. I just… you know,” you sigh, “Getting big in metal is like a one in a million thing and we’re in Nowhere, Indiana.”
“Well, how about I be your first number one fan?” she suggests, “I’ll go tomorrow.”
“For real?”
“Yeah, why not?”
“An angel in disguise,” you sing, stepping back to leave, “The Hideout, okay? Don’t forget!”
She waves you off as you go, “I won’t! Promise!”
You clamber back into the passenger seat of the van and kiss Eddie’s cheek, “I got us a fan for tomorrow’s gig.”
“Ah, my marketing genius,” he takes your cheek and pinches it, “You should be our manager.”
“As if. Now, take me home, Van Halen.”
“Anything for you, sweet princess.”
329 notes
·
View notes