A list of who and who should not be allowed into the Dream SMP 2 Writers Room (pretty much Do I Like Their Character/Think They’re Well Done).
I am also an Inniter. That says a lot I feel
Aimsey: Yes! Their lore at the start was very good. They pulled out Bangers for their first few lore streams and told a really good story that was ruined by the s4 curse.
Allowed
Antfrost: Don’t know much about his lore besides that he was in the eggpire. also bad tommy takes
Not Allowed (Bad Tommy Takes)
Awesamdude: Yes Absolutely! He’s one of the most consistent characters on the SMP, if not The most, and he plays three separate characters to boot. Very talented, very good lore
Allowed
BadBoyHalo: Nn. No. I loved the Eggpire arc but the s4 victim blaming towards c!Tommy was Not something I’m. comfortable with. So.
Not Allowed (Bad takes)
BoomerNA: Another person I don’t know the lore of too well. From what I Have seen, it was well made and had quite a bit of thought and effort into it. Joined very late into s3 so his potential hasn’t come to fruition.
Allowed
Callahan:
Allowed
CaptainPuffy: Her recent disrespect of lore, to be frank, didn't sit well with me. She’s making a different character for goofing off now, but her trend of droppings arcs before really starting them leads to a really inconsistent character. She also hopped on the c!Tommy Hate bandwagon, which makes zero sense since she was his therapist.
Not Allowed (Inconsistency)
ConnorEatsPants:
Allowed
Dream: He’s the literal owner of and titular character of the server who is tied to all lore. He also has not appeared in main s4, i miss him. I miss c!prime.
Allowed
Eret: Oh absolutely. Her lore is special and she deserves it.
Allowed
Eryn: Like Boomer, they joined very late into s3, but from what i’ve seen put in a lot of effort into their story. They utilize their character’s newness and chaotic nature well. Just needs more time to develop.
Allowed
Foolish Gamers: Absolute beast of a builder. As a writer as well, his character is interesting and his interactions with the egg arc were impactful and had huge consequences on his character. Really solid, though outside of egg lore and his Eret history I don’t know much.
Allowed
Fundy: A sparse character who doesn’t hop on often But Man when he does? He's an absolute treat and I adore his lore. So much effort is put in and he’s often swept to the side despite being a Lmanberg OG, so he gets this.
Allowed
GeorgeNotFound: it would be funny
Allowed
Hannahxxrose: From what I’ve seen of her lore? Yeah! It’s some cool stuff. I like her character. Not much else besides she absolutely was ready to murder Dream on multiple accounts and had nice bank lore.
Allowed
HBomb94: Haha cat maid. (also genuinely has a cool lore moment)
Allowed
ItsAlyssa: If she wants to
Allowed
JackManifoldTV: One of the only examples of a character who hates Tommy Well, because they used to be friends. Very good character.
Allowed
Jschlatt: Haha evil goat man. Seriously, a threatening yet comedic villain during Pogtopia.
Allowed
Karl Jacobs: Yes. His Tales stuff is absolutely phenomenal and expands on the lore so much. Absolutely impressive.
Allowed
LazarBeam and Vikkstar123: Their only lore to my knowledge is getting tortured by Dream and that qualifies them
Allowed
Michaelmcchill: He has some really cool stuff! His radio lore was super cool and I really wish he got to use it to interact more.
Allowed
Nihachu: Oh boy um. Niki’s character really isn’t one I’m too fond of? She’s in this really weird and really contradictory spot honestly. Earlier, it was great, but joining the Syndicate, trying to kill Tommy, and freeing Dream aren’t actions she seems to have reflected on or apologized for.
Not Allowed (Inconsistency)
Ph1LzA: Haha,, no. Terrible advice in s4, frees Dream with no consequences, kills his son and believes it’s justified, absolute mess. CC Phil is great but I Cannot stand his writing.
Not Allowed (Wtf is with this man)
Ponk: PONK! Yes. Really impactful stuff, and is ingrained in server history.
Allowed
Punz: So he’s one im on the fence for mostly because i really don’t like staged disc finale. It feels like a cheap twist for a cheap twist and it’s disappointing because I liked his character a lot before it. Disregarding it I Like his lore post breakout retcon with Dream but Man it sours me.
Not Allowed (On the fence)
Purpled: Really cool lore! Utilizes his lack of lore to actually better his character in the Las Nevadas Arc.
Allowed
Quackity: ABSOLUTELY! Las Nevadas is such an incredible arc and so much effort is put into his stuff. I could go on for ages but he’s such a good, consistent, and well written character.
Allowed
Ranboo: Mmmm. So, his decision to have irl time = smp time is just One of my many frustrations. I liked his lore in the start, but it’s been a year and a half and we’ve gotten basically no answers or payoff at all. His treatment of c!Tommy is also something that frustrates me a Lot looking back and it’s not intentional. I dunno. His character irritates me.
Not Allowed (Stagnation and c!Tommy treatment)
Sapnap: So I really liked his resolve to kill Dream and then. That arc died. But I Do really like his relationship with Dream and how that’s evolved. There’s some bits I am Eh on but nothing Too bad.
Allowed
Seapeekay: Another late addition but I really am intrigued by his stuff! It’s super neat. Deserves more time.
Allowed
Skeppy: Lol gem man. Honestly the table conversation alone should admit him but also his egg stuff was cool.
Allowed
Slimecicle: Yes! Such a good character oh wow. I really liked Slime/c!Charlie, his interactions with everyone were so amazing and I really wish he came back to life.
Allowed
Technoblade: No.
Not Allowed (Not in a million years.)
TinaKitten; Don’t know anything about their lore!
Not Allowed (Lack of knowledge)
TommyInnit: I’m an Inniter
Allowed
Tubbo: So even before he was a leading cause of my S4 distaste, he was kind of on the fence. Knocked it out of the Park with the L’MB anniversary stream, but Cookie Outpost was super Eh for me, and Saving Michael and Everything after was the nail in the coffin. Goodbye to 2/3 of Benchtrio, if only your writing was better.
Not Allowed (Ruined S4!)
Wilbur Soot: Last one, Wilbur! Yeah. Recent s4 mishap aside, such a solid character and writer especially. Should’ve stayed in written form but ultimately really good and deserves it.
Allowed
——————
All Unalloweds:
Tina (Don’t know enough)
Ant (bad tommy takes)
Tubbo (Ruined S4)
Puffy (Inconsistent and also soured S4)
Punz (Seemed to genuinely care about Tommy And Then Didn’t, plot twist bad)
BBH (Has Yikes takes on c!prime)
Everyone in Syndicate (minus connor)
195 notes
·
View notes