Green Light, Red Light
Request: Yes / No Hi can I please get a Spencer Reid x reader where if you’ve seen the 12 season where cat has his mom and tells him that she’s pregnant with his kids and tells him she did it because she Convince him that he was doing it with Maeve and reader over hears them and she starts to feel the she was just a rebound to him and they get in a fight about how she’s Insecure about their relationship and can it end in fluff please and if you can thank you 🙏🏼 sorry if this doesn’t make sense or sounds Messy Anon
Requests are open, but please read this! <3 Have a nice day/night
Spencer Reid x Fem!Reader
Word count: 8910
Warnings: Honestly not much I think.
Y/N: Your Name
PLEASE DO NOT STEAL MY WORK, I WORK HARD ON MY FICS AND IT’S NOT COOL TO STEAL SOMEONE ELSE’S WORK!
If you want to be on the tag list for anything (My series fics, specific character fics, or just all of them) All you have to do is send me an ask and I will add you!
Masterlist
(Not my photo, credit to whoever made it!)
Emily had just called me and told me to come to the office. I dropped everything immediately and rushed to work. I just knew it was something about Spencer. God I hope he’s okay… As soon as I got there I rushed into her office, Rossi was already in there.
“Emily, I came as fast as I could. What’s happened? Is Spencer okay?” I asked, worry clearly in my voice.
“Thank you for coming Y/N, Fiona and I went to see Reid.” She said.
“And? Is he okay?” I asked.
“He said his Mother was in trouble.” She said and I looked at her confused.
“Were Reid and Diana scheduled to have a visit?” Rossi asked.
“He didn’t think so, but it happened anyway.” Emily answered.
“What did Cassie say?” I asked.
“Cassie didn’t bring Diana. Another nurse did, a Carol Atkinson.” She answered and I looked at her confused.
“Cassie would never let another nurse take care of her.” I said.
“Garcia’s running a search on the name now, but it’s an alias.” She said.
“For who?” Rossi asked before I could.
“Lindsey Vaughn.” She said.
“Lindsey Vaughn? From that case in Chula Vista ten years ago?” Rossi asked.
“You remember it.” Emily said.
“But how could it be her now? And why?” He asked.
“I asked him the same thing.” She said.
“And how did that go?” He asked.
“He slammed the table and ended up being escorted out by guards.” She said and I bit my lip. My poor Spencer…
“Any chance he’s wrong?” Rossi asked.
“Well, Reid did smell Scratch’s drugs before the murder, and he said there was another woman in the room with them.” She said.
“No, there’s no way he could be wrong, this is Spencer we’re talking about!” I said and they sighed.
“Well, if Lindsey took Diana to visit, where’s Cassie?” Rossi asked.
“We don’t know. Her phone goes straight to voicemail, she’s not returning texts either. Y/N, when was the last time you talked to her?” She asked me.
“Um, a few weeks ago. She was giving me updates about Diana and said that I should come and visit, that it might help her.” I answered. I was now regretting not visiting her sooner, who knows what might be happening to her now…
“And Garcia pinged it?” Rossi asked.
“She tried, but the battery must be dead. The GPS was turned off. Walker and JJ are on their way to Reid’s apartment now.” Emily said.
“I should be going with them.” I said, but Emily shook her head.
“You’re too close to this Y/N.” She said.
“We’re all close to this Emily.” I said and she sighed.
“I know, but I can’t send you out there until we have something.” She said and I sighed. I understood why, but I just wanted to help Spencer and save Diana if she was really in trouble.
“So what if this has been a Scratch-Lindsey partnership this whole time?” Rossi asked.
“If that’s true, given his mental state, I’m not sure Reid makes it to trial.” Emily said and I felt my heart break.
“I-I need to see him.” I said and Emily shook her head.
“You can’t right now, he’s not being allowed visitors.” She said and I bit my lip to keep from crying.
“Hey, he’ll be alright.” Rossi said and I nodded.
“Here, take some paperwork to keep you distracted, I’ll call everyone in when we get news from JJ.” Emily said and I nodded. I took the papers and went to my desk. I needed to keep my mind off Spencer, but that was probably the hardest thing to do.
It was maybe ten minutes later when I heard someone walk up to my desk. I looked up and saw Garcia giving me a sad smile. I returned the smile and she pulled me in for a hug.
“Emily wants us in the round table room.” She said and I nodded.
“Is Diana okay?” I asked.
“We don’t know yet...” She answered and I bit my lip once again. We all sat down and everyone gave me a sad smile. I wanted this done with, I wanted the pitty looks to go away. I wanted everything to go back to normal.
“We first came across the Vaughns ten years ago when Lindsey Vaughn and her friend Katie Owen were abducted outside of a crowded movie theater by three men.” Emily said as Garcia handed us the files.
“Ryan Phillips, the traid’s dominant, tortured and strangled Katie.” Rossi said.
“Jack Vaughn then took matters into his own hands, using his skills to find Lindsey.” Emily said.
“It ended when Jack murdered Phillips in front of her and Reid.” Rossi said.
“They let him stay in the program after that?” Luke asked.
“Jack was too important a witness to cut loose.” Rossi said.
“And no one’s heard from either of them till now?” Tara asked.
“That’s right.” Emily said with a nod.
“Lindsey was posing as a nurse named Carol Atkinson, and was able to get Diana Reid in and out of the Millburn Correctional Facility.” Garcia said, pulling up the prison’s security video.
“And despite all the cameras, this is the only one that picked her up.” Rossi said.
“So she knew exactly where they were and how to avoid them.” I said. The phone started ringing and Garcia immediately answered it.
“Please tell me you have good news.” She said.
“Well, Diana and Cassie aren’t here.” JJ said.
“There’s no forced entry and no signs of struggle. And Cassie’s car is gone.” Walker answered.
“Garcia, where are we on that APB of her car?” Emily asked.
“I don;t have anything yet.” She answered.
“Okay. Also, search recent traffic in and out of Reid’s apartment. Lindsey probably entered as Carol.” Emily said.
“Copy, copy.” She said and got to work.
“I know Diana’s routen, I should go out there.” I said.
“No Y/N, you’re not allowed to investigate this outside of this office, not yet.” Emily said. I was growing desperate, I needed to help Spencer.
“I know her routen too, Stephen and I will hit up those places first.” JJ said and hung up.
“The rest of us need to find Lindsey ASAP.” Emily said.
“I know a marshal that can help cut through Witsec’s red tape.” Luke said and walked off.
“Yeah, I’m friendly with some people at Homeland Security.” Tara said, also walking off.
“I got a buddy at the DOJ, lost a lot of money to him at poker. He owes me.” Rossi said.
“Garcia, there was degraded female DNA and prints found at the crime scene. No matches in Codis, but there might be something in Witsec.” Emily said.
“I’ll pull every favor, turn every stone.” Garcia said and walked off.
“Are we gonna tell Spencer?” I asked.
“Not yet. I don’t want to add more stress for him.” Emily said. Rossi walked off to go see his friend.
“Emily, you need to give me something to do. I can’t just sit here and do nothing and we both know I can’t just go home.” I said following her into her office.
“Go help Garcia, I can’t let you go out there right now, I’m sorry.” She said and I nodded.
“I get it, I’m way too close to him, more than you guys are, but when it comes time to go out there and do something I need to be there too.” I said and she nodded.
“I wouldn’t keep you from that.” She said and I nodded.
I was helping Garcia with whatever she needed. I wasn’t as tech savvy as she is, but I was good enough to help out. We were working on anything that could give us a lead when her phone rang.
“Garcia.” Luke said.
“What do you need?” She asked.
“Metro P.D. found Cassie’s car and called it in immediately. No signs of her or DIana. No foul play. There are… There are three visible cameras. One nearby and two down the way.” Luke said.
“I can tap into them, see what I can find.” Garcia said getting to work.
“Oh, oh, oh, uh, Walker and JJ are calling in. You want me to patch you through?” She asked.
“Please.” He said and we were all in the call now.
“Walker, JJ, you’re on with Alvez, me, and Y/N.” She said when she answered.
“Hey guys, no luck finding Cassie or Diana.” Walker said and my heart sank.
“Alright, well, I’m at Cassie’s car right now. Forensically, it’s a dead end, but, us, behaviorally we might have something.” Luke explained. It’s parked down the block from a high school.” Luke said.
“A high school is where Jack Vaughn killed Lindsey’s abductor in front of her and Spencer.” JJ said.
“Well, placing the car there could be a taunt at us.” Walker said.
“That’s what I’m thinking.” Luke said.
“I can look into that. I can- Oh!” Garcia said cutting herself off. I looked over at her screen to see what was happening.
“Garcia?” JJ asked.
“Oh, uh, uh, per Emily, I was supposed to look at the recent foot traffic in and out of Reid’s building. There is no sign of Carol Atkinson, but a Jaime Lamantia keeps popping up. She lives in unit 26 down the hall from Ried. She paid six months of her rent up front in cash, and there’s been not a peep from her since.” She said and I looked at the document she pulled up with wide eyes.
“How’s Jaime connected to Lindsey?” Luke asked.
“Jaime is Lindsey…” I said shocked.
“I’m twenty minutes from Reid’s apartment.” Luke said.
“Yeah, we’re ten.” JJ said and they were on their way.
“I-I have to go out there…” I said.
“No, you can't, Emily said you can’t.” Garcai said.
“This is my boyfriend we’re talking about! I have to do something!” I said, tears threatening to fall. Garcia pulled me in for a hug and held me tightly.
“I know hun, but we’ll get her.” She said.
Emily came in and caught us up, Cassie was dead. Lindsey killed her and took Diana. Spencer was right. Emily went back to her office to have a meeting with Luke and his friend, but I followed and stayed in the bullpen.
“I’m going to the prison. Reid deserves to know everything.” Emily said walking out.
“I’m coming with you.” I said.
“Y/N, you know you-”
“Emily please, I need to see him. I need to know he’s okay.” I begged, cutting her off. She looked at me and sighed.
“Alright, let’s go.” She said and off we went to the prison.
“Wait here, I’ll give you two some time once I finish telling him okay?” She asked and I nodded. Emily was inside and they were talking. Spencer walked up to the door and banged on it. I stopped the guard from opening it and I opened it instead.
“Y-Y/N?” Spencer asked shocked. It’s the first time we’ve seen each other since he was arrested.
“Spencer, oh my God…” I said with tears in my eyes. I knew the rules, I knew I wasn’t allowed to touch him, but I didn’t care. I threw my arms around his neck and buried my head in his chest.
“Hey, no touching allowed.” The guard said.
“It’s alright.” Emily said walking over to us.
“You two have until I come back, then we leave Y/N.” She said and I nodded. Spencer and I walked back into the room and once again hugged him.
“I’ve missed you so much…” I said finally letting the tears I’ve been holding back for so long free. Spencer wrapped his arms around me and it felt like home.
“I’m so so sorry about your Mom Spence, but I swear to you that I will find her no matter what. Even if it costs me my job I will find her.” I said gently caressing his cheek.
“Does she know about us?” He asked referring to Lindsey.
“Yes…” I answered.
“You need to stay away from this.” He whispered.
“You know I can’t do that.” I whispered back.
“You need to, I can’t be the reason you get hurt.” He said.
“I’ll be find Spence, everything will be fine.” I said. I leaned up to kiss him, but he pulled away from me…
“You need to go. You need to stay off this case, you need to work on something else.” He said turning his back to me.
“You know I will not do that. I won’t stop until you’re free and your Mother is home safe!” I said. I stared at his back in shock, Spencer had changed… The door opened and Emily walked in.
“It’s time to go Y/N.” She said and I nodded.
“I promise Spence, we’ll find her and get you out of here.” I said before leaving the room with Emily.
“How’d it go?” She asked.
“Not as well as I hoped…” I quietly answered.
“He’ll come around.” She said and I just nodded. Why would he want me to stop? Why wouldn’t he want to kiss me? Why wouldn’t he be happy to see me?
We made it back to the office and Emily went straight for the roundtable room. I was still in a daze, but I followed her in. The team was there walking and Rossi looked up at us when we walked in.
“How’d it go with Reid?” He asked.
“As expected. He thinks Lindsey’s using her father’s gun as a way to carry on his legacy.” Emily said.
“Makes sense, given her Daddy issues.” Rossi said.
“And I spoke to the Warden about putting Reid in protective custody, but he said no.” Emily said and I sighed.
“Okay, more ballistics literally just came in on Jack Vaughn’s gun, and, oh my goodness, Lindsey has been a busy evil bee.” Garcia said.
“How busy?” Tara asked.
“That gun has been involved in fifteen murders in the last five years.” She answered.
“Single shot to the back of the head with a modified hollow-point.” JJ said.
“That’s our Lindsey.” Rossi said.
“You guys see the geographical pattern? All of the kills are along the U.S-Mexico border.” JJ said.
“And each of the victims have apparent Cartel ties.” Garcia.
“So, Lindsey’s been a Cartel hit woman ever since she left the program.” Tara said.
“Okay, but why is she using her Dad’s gun? That helps us, and it’s risky for her.” Garcia asked.
“It’s an impulse, not a choice.” I said. We continued talking, but we came up with nothing so we all went to get coffee.
“Why would Scratch choose Lindsey? I mean, her ties to Reid are distant.” Tara said.
“Walker and I, we kicked it around on the flight, and we imagine that Scratch was digging further into Reid’s past and he saw that Lindsey had become a contract killer. Realized she could get to him in a way that he couldn’t.” Luke said.
“It may be logistical, too. Scratch has never run out of drugs before, but now he’s a fugitive and might not be able to get them.” Walker said.
“Well, Lindsey knows the border. She’d be a good drug mule.” JJ said as I was making myself a second coffee.
“Good news, bad news.” Emily said walking up to us and I immediately turned towards her.
“I am on the books first thing tomorrow with Judge Frost and AUSA Martinez.” Emily said.
“But all we have is a theory and no support from the brass.” Rossi said.
“That’s never stopped us before.” She said.
“I guess we gave twelve hours to make an airtight case for you to bring to them.” I said.
“Yes. Not only that, we also need a paper trail.” Emily said.
“I’ll put on more coffee.” Rossi said.
“Excuse me.” Emily said and went to take a call.
“Y/N, you should go get some sleep.” Rossi said to me and I shook my head.
“There is no way I’m going home when Spencer is stuck in that prison and Diana is who knows where.” I said taking a sip of my coffee.
“I will inject coffee straight into my veins before I go to sleep.” I said and walked off to the round table room. Soon everyone followed and we were all looking for anything we could find.
“We leave no stone unturned.” Emily said walking in with Garcia and a box. She started handing out files and we got to work.
“Hey, guys.” Tara said after an hour and a half.
“Okay. I got Carol Atkinson crossing the border at Los Indios.” She said.
“There’s a factory nearby that manufactures non-FDA-approved seasickness tablets. Essentially, scopolamine pills.” She said walking over to the map.
“Los Indios is only a 40-minute drive to Matamoros.” Luke said.
“Looks like we’ve got Lindsey where we need her.” Rossi said.
“Now we put the knife in her hand.” Emily said. We continued working, trying to get anything to match with Lindsey and that would be able to set Spencer free. I must have drank at least six coffees, maybe more. It was light out now, but none of us cared.
“Rick, what have you got?” Luke asked, answering his phone.
“Well, okay, guys, Jack’s gun was used in Mexico the day before Nadie’s murder.” JJ said.
“What? Another Cartel hit?” I asked.
“No, the victim was a Victor Flores. He was a local real estate broker, a model citizen.” She said.
“Point-blank. Back of the head, with a modified hollow-point bullet. That’s Lindsey, alright.” Rossi said looking at the file.
“Why are we only hearing about it now?” Walker asked.
“Because it was in Monterrey. It’s a different jurisdiction.” JJ answered.
“Okay, so, she crosses the border at Los Indios, which is very close to Matamoros, drives three hours west to Monterrey, kills Victor, and then drives four hours east to Matamoros?” Tara asked confused.
“All possible within a day’s drive.” Walker said.
“Sure, but why go to all the trouble?” Tara asked.
“Why pick Victor Flores?” Emily asked.
“It sounds too random to be random…” I said shaking my head.
“Alright. Alright, thanks, Rick. I owe you.” Luke said and hung up.
“Mexican authorities found an abandoned truck last week that matches the one Reid described. It was dumped two states over.” Luke said.
“Did it belong to a Victor Flores?” JJ asked.
“Yeah, how’d you know that?” He asked.
“Lindsey killed him before Nadie. Must have stolen his truck too.” Rossi said.
“Alright, well, we’re making some real headway here.”Luke said.
“Yeah, it’s great guys, don’t get me wrong, but it’s all circumstantial. Garcia, any luck finding Lindsey’s prints from her Witsec file?” Emily asked.
“I called in every favor I can think of and then some. It’s gonna take me, like, five more hours to cut through all this red tape.” Garcia answered.
“I have to be at the courthouse in one.” Emily said and we continued to go back to work.
Emily left soon after and we all kept working. We hoped that we could get something in time, but the odds were against us. An hour later my phone rang and I saw Emily’s name pop up on my screen.
“Emily?” I answered confused and everyone’s eyes were on me.
“I need you to go to the prison that Reid is at and bring him home.” She said and my eyes started to water.
“A-Are you serious?” I asked.
“I am, bring him home Y/N.” She said and I hung up immediately.
“What’s going on?” Garcia asked.
“I have to go, I have to go get Spencer.” I said with a smile.
“He’s coming home?” JJ asked and I nodded.
“Yeah.” I nodded and everyone smiled.
“I’m coming with you.” JJ said.
“Me too, I gotta take care of something there.” Luke said.
“I’m coming too!” Garcia said and I just nodded at them. I quickly gathered my stuff and rushed to my car. My Spencer was finally coming home. They were driving in a separate car from me. I got to the prison as quickly as I could and soon after they brought me to a room with Spencer standing there. Spencer saw me and smiled slightly.
“We’re taking you home baby.” I said with a smile and a tear falling down my face. He looked relieved and I rushed over to hug him.
“You’re coming home Spence.” I whispered. He held me tightly and started sobbing. I held him tightly. He kissed the side of my head and everything just felt so right in that moment. Spencer got dressed in the suit we brought him and we walked out to see Garcia standing there waiting. He went up and hugged her and I smiled.
“Let’s get my Mom back.” He said.
“Yeah.” Garcia said and we all left. We got back to the office and we were catching Spencer up on everything.
“So we know Lindsey convinced Scratch to run drugs across the border.” Luke said.
“And that Lindsey’s been operating from to locations- An apartment next to Reid and a house in southeast D.C.” Rossi said.
“That’s where we think she’s keeping your Mom.” Walker said.
“Scratch isn’t afraid to plot an elaborate trap. I want a full breakdown of that house before we set one foot inside.” Emily said and everyone walked off, except for Spencer and I.
“Um… Spencer…” Emily said stopping us and closing the door.
“You can’t officially go until you’re reinstated.” She said.
“So that includes going to my apartment, since it’s a crime scene.” Spencer said.
“That’s right. It’s sealed and guarded by Metro P.D. But you are the resident. You got it?” She said.
“Got it.” He said and she left. Spencer took a step up to the closed door, but just stared at it.
“Are you alright?” I asked and he looked at me.
“Um… it’s, uh, it’s open.” I said and he looked back at the door.
“Of course.” He said and opened the door. We went to Spencer’s place and I had to show the guard my badge.
“He’s the resident. He’s just gonna grab a few things.��� I said and the cop nodded. Spencer sat on his couch and started looking at an open photo album.
“What is it?” I asked.
“This picture was on a different page.” He said and picked it up. He flipped it over and on the back in red it said XX-XY.
“Does that mean anything to you?” I asked.
“Only the obvious, male and female chromosomes, Lindsey’s way of telling us she’s with Scratch.” He said and I sighed.
“Let’s grab some things and you can stay at my place.” I said.
“Yeah…” He said. We grabbed a bag of clothes and dropped them off at my apartment. Emily had called me and told me all about what was going on. Spencer had to go back to prison to see Cat Adams. I was going with him. We got on the jet and made our way to Car Adams. We walked into the other side of the interview room, we saw Cat sitting at the table. I saw Spencer was comfortable, but this was the only option to find his mother right now.
“I’ll be here the whole time, promise.” I said and gently grabbed his hand. He nodded and walked inside, I followed, but stayed in the back.
“Spencie.” Cat said with a smile.
“Where’s my Mother?” He asked.
“I missed you.” She said.
“What did you and Lindsey do to her?” He asked, ignoring her.
“How did you-”
“No stop! You don’t get to walk in here and hiss at me like I’m the criminal.” She said cutting him off.
“Now, we do this my way.” She said and kicked the chair in front of her. Spencer caught it as she told him to sit. Spencer sat as I stayed on the side watching.
“How was Prison? Did you like it?” She asked.
“No.” He answered.
“It’s not fun, is it?” She asked.
“Unlike you, I didn’t deserve to be there.” He said.
“How did you stay sane?” She asked leaning closer. I was confused as to who she was or what her and Spencer’s past connection was. Her case was before I was even on the team. I had only joined three years ago and Spencer and I have only been together for two.
“A brain like yours needs stimulation in such a gray place.” She said.
“I worked in the laundry room and I played chess.” He answered.
“That’s three, maybe four hours, tops. What about the other twenty?” She asked.
“I read.” He answered.
“That’s still not enough. You have to… go someplace. Up here.” She said looking at me for a split second.
“Or else you go crazy.” She said with a slight laugh.
“Do you want to see where I go? I’ll show you. Com here.” She said, motioning him to come closer. Spencer leaned in closer and she went to touch his face.
“No touching.” I said and she stopped. Spencer looked at me then back at her and she smirked at me.
“Close your eyes.” She said and moved his eyes to close them.
“Good. Now keep them shut. Sit back and relax.” She said leaning back in her chair. Spencer also leaned back.
“Now, when you open your eyes, I want you to look at me like I’m the first woman you’ve seen after being in prison for three month.” She said and my heart clenched at this. She looked at me and smirked then looked back at him.
“Now… Open.” She said and he did.
“Hello Cat.” He said with a smile.
“You’re here!” She giggled.
“You’re really here.” She said.
“There’s nowhere else I would rather be.” Spencer said and I took a deep breath, this is what he needs to do to get the information.
“You’re good at this. You’re so good at this, I almost believe you don’t want to kill me.” She said crossing her arms.
“I don’t want to kill you.” He said.
“No?” She asked.
“No.” He said, shaking his head.
“What if I let your Mother die? Then would you kill me? Or would you just… hurt me? Would you pin me down and leave bruises that don’t go away?” She asked with a very sexual tone.
“Is that what you want?” He asked and my eyes widened slightly.
“I guess I just want to know if you would.” She said and glanced at me with a smirk.
“If you could.” She said looking back at him.
“No.” He said.
“No?” She asked.
“That’s not the kind of man I am.” He said.
“Do me a favor and tell your girlfriend over there to step aside, because we’re gonna play another game. And this time, we’re going to find out exactly what kind of man you are. I’m sure she’ll love to watch that.” She said. Spencer looked over at me and gave me a nod. I didn’t feel comfortable leaving Spencer alone with her, but I left anyway and she gave me a wave goodbye. I was now watching from behind the glass, luckily I could still hear them.
“Let’s play.” He said.
“Let’s!” She said excitedly.
“Are you hungry?” She asked him.
“No.” He answered.
“Me neither.” She said.
“So, the same game as last time?” He asked leaning back in the chair.
“I answer every question you ask honestly?” He asked.
“No, this time you get to ask the questions.” She said.
“About what?” He asked.
“Well, I know a secret. About you. And you can ask me as many questions as you like to figure it out. But you only get one guess as to what it is.” She said leaning forward.
“Now, guess correctly, I take your phone, I call our friend Lindsey, and I tell her to release your Mother unharmed. If you don't…” She said and put her fingers into a gun shape and stuck it in her mouth. She then mimed like she was getting shot and giggled.
“Is there a clock?” Spencer asked.
“There’s always a clock.” She said and put her hand out.
“Give it to me.” She said. Spencer took off his watch and handed it to her.
“You’ll have four hours.” She said and he went to ask a question, but she stopped him.
“Not yet.” She said.
“You have to wait till the second hand comes around.” She said.
“You want to give me a hint before we start?” Spencer asked.
“Do I look like a girl that gives hints?” She asked.
“Actually you do.” He said.
“Okay, how about this? It’s a secret you’ll never admit to.” She said and I furrowed my brow.
“Go.” She said. It’s been half an hour, I told the team that we had four hours to find Diana or she’s dead.
“I know what the secret is.” Spencer said.
“You do?” She asked.
“Why else would you put me through all this?” He asked.
“Ooo. Phrasing it in the form of a question. That way it doesn’t count as a guess. Very smart, Doctor.” She said.
“I’m gonna walk you through a scenario and your face is gonna tell me how close I am.” He said.
“From the moment I arrested you, you watched and waited for the right time to take your revenge. When you learned I was going to Mexico, you took it. You and Lindsey framed me for murder so I’d be in prison and treated like a criminal, and then you kidnapped my Mother so I would know how it feels to have a parent manipulated, because you wanted to prove that you and I are the same. Am I right?” He asked and she yawned.
“Sorry, I couldn’t hold that in any longer. What were you saying?” She asked.
“Psychopaths get bored easily.” He said.
“You’re right. Let’s speed this up.” She said getting up.
“Shall we?” She asked and sat on his lap. Jealousy raged through my body, but I kept watching.
“Why don’t you think about all the pain you’ve suffered in your life. What would I capitalize on, do you think? Is it the death of your mentor, SSA Jason Gideon? ” She asked while touching his chest and face.
“No. Because we caught the man who killed him.” Spencer said.
“What about Agent Morgan? And your guilt over not visiting his little boy.” She said.
“I was in prison.” He said.
“Yeah, but you had time before that.” She said moving her face closer to his. I was feeling so uncomfortable and jealous, but I had to stay perfectional and Spencer was just playing into her fantasies to get what we needed, right?
“Why didn’t you go?” She asked.
“Truthfully, I got distracted. I was trying to figure out a way to help my Mom. She didn’t have time. Morgan, Savannah, and little Bobby did. So there’s absolutely no shame in admitting that. Morgan would understand.” He answered as she nipped at his ear. That wasn't Morgan's son…
“I agree. That’s why that’s not the secret.” She whispered and got off him. He looked back at me and I smiled.
“Good job baby.” I said and pulled out my phone.
“Go ahead, Y/N.” Rossi answered.
“So Cat has deep background on Spence. She knew about Gideon’s death and Morgan leaving the team for his family.” I said.
“She’s throwing him off-balance.” He said.
“Yeah, but Spence also purposely gave the wrong name of Morgan’s son, and she didn’t correct him.” I said.
“She must have gotten her hands on Reid’s confidential FBI file. It would mention relevant team information but wouldn’t name Morgan’s baby because of confidentiality reasons.” Emily said.
“We were thinking she’s been getting help from someone inside the prison. This goes deeper than that.” Rossi said.
“I’ll keep you guys updated.” I said and hung up.
“Working deductively, the secret wouldn’t be any of the topics you’ve already volunteered, because you wouldn’t want to make it that easy on me.” Spencer said after a few minutes of silence.
“Genius, truly.” Cat said, playing with his watch.
“So what is left that I wouldn’t want to admit?” He asked and they stared at each other in silence for a moment.
“Love.” Spencer finally said and my eyes widened. My heart rate picked up and I gulped. Cat stopped playing with his watch and just stared at him.
“Is that what this is all about, love?” He asked leaning forward.
“For my Mother?” He asked and she just stared.
“No. For you.” He said and I felt a pain in my chest.
“You want me to admit that I am actually in love with you.” He said.
“Don’t get me wrong, I love my fairy tales, clearly, as much as the next girl, but I’m not delusional.” She said.
“Are you sure about that?” He asked.
“Very sure. So sure, in fact, that I had Lindsey leave a clue for you in your little scrapbook in your house.” She said with a smirk. XX-XY.
“I couldn’t have you come all the way down here and make a guess until I was positive. That is…” She said looking down at her stomach and my eyes widened.
“Until I tested positive.” She said placing her hands on her stomach.
“What, you’re pregnant?” Spencer asked.
“We’re pregnant.” She said and it felt like my heart leaped out of my chest. No. No it couldn’t be possible…
“No.” Spencer said, shaking his head.
“Oh, yes. Mazel tov.” She said. I needed to know. The team needed to know. I asked one of the guards for her records and waited for them.
“Here you are ma’am.” A guard said, handing me the files.
“Thank you.” I said and immediately checked them. She was pregnant. Her due date was November 15th 2017… I looked up in complete shock.
“It’s not possible. Even if you are pregnant, the baby’s not mine.” Spencer said, now standing.
“Except for the part where it is.” She said.
“That’s completely preposterous. You’ve been in prison.” He said sitting back down.
“So have you.” She said.
“And we’ve never had-”
“I know. We’ve never…” She said.
“Ask me how I did it. Come on, ask me.” She said.
“Ask her…” I whispered.
“How did you do it?” He asked.
“I had Lindsey dose you in Mexico. You lost time. And I gave her very specific instructions to get you in the mood.” She said with a little laugh.
“What, did she pretend to be you?” He asked and I bit my lip.
“Why, would that have worked?” She asked.
“No.” He answered leaning closer to her.
“Yeah, I know, I know. Believe me, I know exactly where I stand on the Spencer Reid hot or not list.” She said.
“So you told her to pretend to be Y/N.” He said.
“No. I told her to pretend to be Maeve.” She said and my eyes widened.
“Maeve Donovan. The love of your life.” He said and my heart broke. I knew Spencer loved her at one point, she was his first and she was taken from him. But when we met he said he was over her, that it was in the past…
“Who had her brains blown out right in front of you before you two could even kiss. So dark… Yet, so useful.” She said.
“You’re lying.” He said, slightly shaking his head.
“Spencer, it’s Maeve. It’s okay. Spencer, Spencer… Spencer, it’s Maeve. It’s okay. Come here. Shh. You want this. It’s okay. You want this.” She said in a soft voice.
“It didn’t happen.” Spencer said.
“Hey, I was thinking, if it’s a boy, we should definitely call him Spencie junior.” She said and spencer got up to leave.
“But if it’s a girl, I think we should call her Maeve.” She said and Spencer walked out.
“I mean, after all she played such a huge role in her own conception.” She said and Spencer stood next to me.
“Spence, we might have something.” I said and he took the files from me.
“She’s three months.” I said and Spencer threw the files at the window.
“I’m sorry, it’s not you.” He said and I nodded.
“I just need a minute.” He said and I bit my lip.
“Is she right?” I asked quietly and he turned to look at me.
“What?” He asked.
“That Maeve is the love of your life?” I asked. I knew I should wait, Spencer had so much to deal with right now, but I needed to know. I needed to know if our whole relationship was just a lie for him to get over Maeve, or if it was real.
“I told you about this already.” He said and I nodded.
“But are we just together because you can’t be with her?” I asked and he looked at me with wide eyes.
“No, no of course not!” He said, but a part of me didn’t believe him.
“I don’t believe you Spencer…” I said.
“Now’s not the time for this!” He shouted and I flinched. Spencer has never raised his voice before.
“I’m gonna go call the team…” I said and walked off. I took out my phone to call the team, but my phone rang first.
“Y/N, you there?” Emily asked when I picked up.
“Uh, yeah. Yeah, go ahead.” I said trying to compose myself.
“So far we don’t have anything on the prison employees. Somebody in there is helping her, but nobody jumps out as the obvious culprit, and it doesn’t help that they’re blocking us at every turn.” Luke said.
“We have something, but, uh, it’s out there.” Tara said.
“I’ll take out there.” Emily said.
“The gun store owner was more of a libertarian than you would think. He talked about how he never judged his customers or who they love.” Walker said.
“That’s weird.” JJ said.
“Yeah, not as weird as when he mentioned Obergefell.” Tara said.
“The supreme court decision that legalized gay marriage.” Emily said.
“You said we were missing something in the relationship between these two women. What if it’s this?” Walker said.
“The risks that Lindsey’s taking, the bond she has with Cat, it’s not professional. It’s romantic.” Tara said.
“This casts a big shadow over Lindsey’s next move. By exposing their plan to us, she knows there’s no happy ending, no future with Cat.” Walker said.
“And she’s going to take Reid’s Mother with her. And that’s the ultimate act of revenge against the guy who took her lover away.” JJ said.
“Y/N, what do you have?” Emily asked.
“Can you take me off speaker?” I asked.
“Okay, it’s just us now.” She said.
“Cat is three months pregant and she’s claiming it’s Reid’s…” I said.
“Are you kidding me? Are you kidding?” She asked.
“Well, here’s where it gets tricky. Do we believe her or not?” I asked.
“On the one hand, getting pregnant is a power control move straight out of the female psychopath handbook. On the other hand-”
“If her story is true, it meant she sent her lesbian lover down to Mexico to get Reid to- Ugh.” Emily said, finishing my thought.
“Yeah… Either way, she is pregnant. I just refuse to believe it belongs to Spence…” I said choking up a little.
“It could be the person inside the prison who’s been helping her. Getting pregnant serves two purposes- Gasslighting Reid and emotional blackmail against that employee.” She said.
“Yeah, but, Emily, we don’t know who that guy is yet. And Luke and Rossi aren’t going to in the time we have left.” I said.
“Y/N, I gotta call you back.” She said and hung up. I sighed and walked back to Spencer, he had gone back inside.
“Let’s pretend you’re telling the truth. That means I guessed it, right? The secret, the one I don’t want to admit to? It’s my child?” Spencer said.
“Is that your guess? You only get one, remember?” Cat asked.
“No. it’s too easy.” He said.
“Believe me, getting pregnant with your baby was not easy.” She said.
“You misunderstand. It’s too easy emotionally. Because I can take your child from you. The child I had absolutely no role in creating, but a child that I would care for better than you.” He said and I gulped.
“That’s rude.” She said.
“It’s true. You can’t be a Mother, Cat. I’m not trying to insult you. It’s your psychological makeup. You literally do not have the emotional skills to care for another human being. You’d lose interest in your own baby the way a six year old loses interest in a pet hamster. This baby is simply a means to an end, which is to keep me here playing your game, guessing like a fool, assuming something I never should have assumed in the first place.” He said.
“And what would that be?” She asked.
“My Mother’s already dead.” He said and I shook my head. No. That can’t be right.
“She was dead before I walked in here.” He said.
“She’s not dead.” Cat shook her head.
“Yes she is.” Spencer said getting up.
“No, because that would be cheating and I don’t cheat! You cheat!” She said.
“I’m done playing.” Spencer said.
“Get back here!” She said.
“Goodbye, Cat.” He said opening the door.
“I’ll let you talk to her!” She said which made him stop in the doorway. He looked at me and I looked at him in shock. He smiled and walked back in. I quickly called Garcia.
“Yes, I’m here.” She answered.
“Garcia, get ready to trace a call on Spence’s phone.” I said.
“Fired up, plugged in. Ready to go.” She said. Spencer handed her his phone and she called Lindsey.
“You’re early.” Lindsey answered.
“Yeah, I know.” Cat said.
“Did he guess?” She asked.
“No, not yet. We need proof of life.” Cat said.
“Alright. Hold on.” She said.
“Spencer!” Diana said scared, only a moment later. Spencer grabbed the phone out of Cat’s hand so fast.
“Mom! Mom, are you okay?” He asked.
“I don’t… know.” She answered and then there was a gunshot.
“Mom!” Spencer called.
“Gotta go.” Lindsey said and hung up.
“Mom! What the hell was that?” Spencer asked and I quickly rushed inside.
“I don’t know.” Cat answered.
“Spence…” I said trying to calm him.
“Lindsey said you were early. Was that a signal?” He asked.
“No.” She answered and Spencer slammed the table.
“Was that a prearranged signal to kill my Mother!?” He shouted.
“No!” She shouted.
“Spencer-”
“Tell me the truth!” He shouted.
“I am!” She shouted back.
“Tell me the truth!” He shouted again.
“I am!” She shouted back.
“You wanna know the truth? Your Mother is an alzheimer’s-ridden moron who’s getting dumber day by day, and if she’s dead, it’s your fault.” Cat said. Spencer shoved the table away and grabbed Cat. He shoved her up against the wall and wrapped his hands around her neck.
“Spence!” I shouted and tried to pull him off her.
“I’m going to kill you.” He whispered to her.
“Spence!”
“I’m going to kill you.” He said again.
“Spence, she’s pregnant. She’s pregnant Spencer! Stop it! Come on!” I said and finally pulled him off her.
“Come on.” I said and pushed him to the other side of the room. He walked out. I made sure she was alright and ignored her teasing comments about how she was having his baby and how I was protecting their baby.
“How does it feel knowing he really only loves Maeve and you’re just her replacement?” She asked and I took a deep breath and walked out of the room. My phone rang and it was Garcia. She told me about what the explosion was. I walked into the hall where Spencer was sitting with his head against his knee.
“Richmond County police just reported a gas station explosion. One victim, a male. Whatever Lindsey did, we have to assume your Mom’s still alive.” I said and he just looked up at me.
“Hey.” I said and sat down next to him.
“I’m really scared this is who I am now.” He said.
“No, don’t say that.” I said.
“Y-Y/N, you don’t know…” He trailed off.
“I do know. I know two inmates, Frazier and Duerson, killed your friend Delgado in front of you. And I know they wanted you to move their heroin, and I also know that if you didn't you would have been next, right?” I asked and he looked down at the floor in shame. He nodded, but still didn’t look at me.
“Spence, anyone in your spot would have done the same thing.” I said.
“You wouldn’t have.” He said.
“Yeah. Yeah, I would have, Spence. Because if someone was threatening my life, You bet your ass I would. I would do it a million times if it meant I got to eventually come home to you. It doesn’t make you a bad person.” I said and he looked at me for a second before looking back down.
“Because you know who does think like that, that- that doing what you had to do to survive somehow makes you a psychopath? She does.” I said and realization hit me. I looked over at Spencer and he had the same look on his face.
“She does. She does. Because she- she knows.” I said quietly.
“That’s the secret.” He said getting up.
“What I don’t want to admit about myself.” He said and I got up as well.
“Hold on, let’s play this out, because she will not lose to you twice. She already said that this wasn’t about you two being the same.” I said.
“And she’s all about the game. She thinks that I cheated last time because I lied about her dad, so it’s integral to her that she beats me by following the rules.” He said.
“Yeah, but, Spence, she controls the rules, and she will change them to ensure that she wins.” I said.
“Which means that I’m locked in.” He said.
“Like she is.” I said.
“And she needs me locked in, playing by her rules a game I can’t win, so she-” He cut himself off and looked at me.
“I got it.” He said and went to turn around, but I stopped him.
“Wait.” I said and he turned back to me.
“I’m sorry…” I said and he looked at me confused.
“For before, I shouldn’t let her get in my head.” I said and he pulled me to him.
“Y/N, I love you, but we both know that there will alway still be some love for Maeve in my heart. That doesn’t mean that you’re a rebound or that I’m using you as a way to replace Maeve, because I’m not. I love you. Everything we have together, is real.” He said and I looked up at him. I pulled him down for a kiss and put all the love I have for this man in it. We pulled away and we were both smiling. I was on the phone calling the team to get everything ready.
“Let’s get your Mom back.” I whispered and he nodded. Spencer Walked back inside and Cat was sitting down playing with his watch again.
“Guess that’s one way to get you to put your hands on me.” She said.
“Dance with me.” He said and she looked up at him.
“Why?” She asked.
“Because I don’t want the people watching us to hear what I’m going to say next.” He said and offered her his hand. They started dancing.
“You guys got this up?” I asked.
“Streaming now.” Garcia said.
“Okay, uh, listen, you’re gonna hear a lot of weird stuff, like Spence saying he is the Father of Cat’s baby. Don’t let that distract you.” I said.
“I’m sorry. Full stop. Why would he say he’s the Father-”
“Quiet.” Emily said cutting Garcia off.
“You had eyes on me while I was in prison, didn’t you?” Spencer asked.
“Spencie, don’t ruin the moment.” Cat said.
“I don’t want to, but I’m on the clock. Answer my question. Am I right?” He asked.
“Yes, you’re right. I wanted to make sure things were just as uncomfortable for you as they were for me.” She answered.
“That’s what we missed, the inside man that’s been helping them.” Luke said.
“He didn’t just work at Cat’s prison, he worked at hers and Reid’s.” Rossi said.
“Garcia, look for any overlap.” Emily said.
“Compiling now.” Garcia said.
“Here’s something. Lionel Wilkins. He worked at both Mount Pleasant and The Millburn Correctional Facility.” She said.
“Okay look, this guy could have gotten her pregnant, but there’s no way he could have gotten his hand on Reid’s file.” JJ said.
“Well, not directly. He could have called in a favor from a friend at the bureau.” Walker said.
“So someone must have wanted to screw us this whole time.” Tara said.
“Someone who’s not gonna work for the bureau much longer.” Emily said.
“That’s how you timed everything so perfectly. Like sending my Mom and Lindsey to visit me when I thought was at my lowest.” He said.
“Thought? You sure you weren’t?” She asked.
“No, I wasn’t. Because I didn’t feel bad. I felt scared. At how much I enjoyed poisoning the other prisoners. I had a hundred ways of getting myself out of that situation, and I picked the one that would cause them the most pain.” He said.
“Well, look at that. You might end up saving your Mother’s life after all.” She said.
“Okay, Lionel Wilkins’ primary residence is in Fall Church, but I also have a second address. Uh, it’s a cabin off of the Rappahannock River.” Garcia said.
“Well the cabin is in Lindsey’s zone based on the gas station.” Walker said.
“Helos are on the roof warming up. Let’s go.” Emily said and hung up.
“They won’t get there in time. They must be on their way, right?” Cat asked.
“Your team is too good to wait around, but, you know me. I always have a contingency plan. So, they’re walking into a trap. And the only way out is if you give me your phone and your guess, right now.” She said. Spencer handed her his phone and she sat down.
“When we first sat down, you said you were going to show me what kind of man I am. And you have.” He said, sitting on the corner of the table.
“Every time I touch this, you’re getting warmer.” Cat said.Garcia was calling Emily to facetime her so she could show Lindsey everything.
“At first I was furious, because the secret had to be the baby inside you. How could it be anything else? But then I realized that somehow, you knew I liked hurting those men. But now I know it’s both things.” Spencer said.
“So which is it, Spence? Come on. Don’t fumble it now. You’re at the one-yard line.” Cat said.
“You’re not pregnant with my child. You got pregnant with Wilkins to put me in as compromised a position as possible. But it should be mine. I wish it were mine. Because you and I… We deserve each other. That is the real secret.” He said and she pressed the call button.
“Kill her.” Cat said.
“Lindsey, I said-” She said getting up, but stopped talking. Cat looked at the camera and glared slightly.
“Lindsey, sweetheart, it’s complicated, okay?” She said.
“Y/N, we got her.” Emily said.
“We’re clear.” I said walking into the room and Cat hung up. Spencer took his phone and turned back to me.
“Is my Mom okay?” He asked.
“Yeah, she’s fine.” I answered with a smile.
“We do deserve each other, by the way. You guessed right.” Cat said sitting back down.
“You lied, by the way. You were going to kill my Mother regardless.” He said.
“Yeah, I think you really liked hurting those men. And once you cross that line, you can’t ever go back.” She said. Spencer walked over to her and grabbed her arm. He took his watch back and looked her right in the eyes.
“Watch me.” He whispered and we left. We went back to the office and Spencer was so excited to see his mother again. We walked out of the elevator and the team with his Mother, she looked uncomfortable.
“Spencer’s here.” Emily whispered. Diana looked over at him and they both went to hug each other.
“Hi, Mom.” He said holding her close.
“Don’t leave me. Every again.” She pulled away to say.
“I won’t.” He said and I smiled at them. They pulled apart again and Spencer smiled at me.
“Y/N! You should come visit more.” His Mother said and came to hug me. I hugged her back and laughed slightly.
“I will, I promise.” I said. We pulled apart and we went back to his apartment. Everything was going to be okay.
Tag list: @les-bio-lie @tashy-bear @ashwarren32 @hollie-blogs @schisbro87 @lover-of-books-and-teas @nerdygaloresposts @teenwolfbitches2 @genius2050 @drw0301bieber @softgamerking @lady-of-lies @simonsbluee @ravenmoore14 @ravenempress101 @cillianchamp @reidssmile @currentfangirl-futuremedexaminer @braeleebradshaw @satans-0-spawn
293 notes
·
View notes