Easy Peasy
College AU
Summary: Friday night at the frat house means it’s time for a party. Besides booze, beer pong, and bro-nanigans, the brothers have something else up their sleeves to help get the party going.
Pairing: Steve Rogers x F!Reader
Word Count: ~13.2k (ummmm?)
Warnings: language, alcohol, sickness, slight injury, Captain kink, size kink-ish (muscles kink???), 18+ content
A/N: Hello! This has been a long time coming! About 2 years ago, I put out a fic called Oopsy Daisy. That fic was such a labor of love and is honestly one of my personal favorites. Well now, over 2 years later, I've come bearing this: a sequel! While I didn't originally intend to make a sequel for Oopsy Daisy, you all have the lovely @shythingstudentdragon to thank for this follow-up! They requested "A college au where Steve is showing off to reader. It starts with a push up contest between him Sam and Bucky, before he starts flexing for her and showing her what he can lift. Finally, it gets back to his room where reader questions if he can bench press her, which he does with ease." I changed the order of the events slightly, so I hope that’s ok. And one last thing to note: While technically a sequel, this fic works completely as a standalone (though I encourage you to read both ;p). As always, I hope you all enjoy!
Your heart thumps in time with the music, the heavy bassline resonating through your skin, shaking the very foundation of the house. The track is absolute garbage – some dubstep/techno/house music amalgamation you couldn’t be paid to listen to if given the choice. Under normal circumstances, you'd rather tear your own ears off than listen any longer.
Although it's truly God-awful, right now, it's all just background noise. No, you haven't a care for the monstrosity pounding away at your eardrums, not when your attention is directed miles and miles away.
You twine your fingers behind Steve’s head, keeping him firmly attached to you as your tongues dip into each other’s mouth. Something shatters in the distance, followed by the sound of drunken cheering, but you also pay it no mind. In this moment, it might as well just be you and Steve tucked away in your own little bubble – a small slice of heaven reserved just for you two.
Well… if only that were actually the case.
Just as you start to grind against Steve’s lap, his hands tighten on your hips, halting your movements. “Not now, dollface,” Steve breathes against your mouth.
“What? Why?” you practically whine between kisses. You try to rock your hips again, but are met by an even stronger resistance from Steve’s hands.
“We’re in the middle of the living room,” he grunts as he combats your movements, his fingers digging into the elastic material of your leggings.
Exasperated, you pull back from him and huff, “So? Steve, we have done way worse things on this very couch.”
“Yeah, but not when a rager was going on around us.”
At that, you quirk an amused brow, a specific memory from a few weeks back replaying in your mind. “Y’sure about that?” you smirk.
Steve takes a moment to think before he rolls his eyes, remembering the night in question. “Okay, I was blasted then, so that doesn’t count," he says. "But now I’m basically sober and definitely not in the mood to put on a show for the whole house to see.”
Retracting your hands from behind his neck, you gesture at the party around you. “Steve, look around.” You turn your head side to side, seeing dozens of students half-drunk off their asses as they aimlessly mill about. “Literally no one cares. They’re all focused on their own things and couldn't give a single shit about us.” You turn back to face him. “Maybe we just gotta get a few more beers in you before you stop caring as well,” you gibe, poking him in the pec.
Steve grabs your hand to stop you. “Let’s just wait a little longer until the party dies down, alright? And then we can have a little fun,” he teases. He gives your hand a gentle squeeze before relinquishing it, dropping his palms back to your waist.
You all but pout as you regard him – that steadfast look on his face that tells you his mind is made up. As much as you adore Steve, you hate that he can be such a hard-ass sometimes. You just want to have a good time with your man right now. Is that so bad? Apparently, it is to Steve since you know you'd have a difficult time trying to convince him to see things your way.
Damn him. Maybe if the damn captain of the damn football team wasn’t so used to getting his way on the field, he’d be more open to persuasion off the field as well.
You sigh. Well… come to think of it, there is one thing that renders Steve practically dumb with compliancy. While he doesn't prefer you to whip it out in public, you figure there's no harm in trying it out now. After all, a little teasing never hurt anybody, right?
With your mind made up, carefully, you tuck your face into the side of his neck, releasing slow, even breaths as you pretend you’re relenting to his wishes. But then, ever so delicately, you start nuzzling the underside of his jaw, peppering kisses along the smooth skin.
“Baby…,” Steve warns you, a slight edge to his voice as his fingers curl tighter into your flesh.
“I’m just kissing you,” you mumble against his neck. “Oh, am I not allowed to kiss you now?” your question is thick with sarcasm.
“You—” he starts to reprimand, but as your tongue darts out to taste his skin, he lets out a shaky breath. “Just… don’t try anything funny,” he sighs and softens his hold on you slightly.
“I won’t, I won’t,” you lie.
With a green light, you suck several faint bruises along his neck, feeling Steve gradually relax as the seconds tick by. He makes a choked noise as you hit that spot just under his ear, and it takes all you have not to laugh as you see how hypnotized he is by your ministrations. Amusing as it is, you haven't even started the real fun yet.
Slowly, you rake a hand down his chest, letting your fingertips graze the hard planes of muscle through his t-shirt. Steve shudders and tenses at your touch, his heartbeat picking up as you steadily descend. As he goes to still your wandering hand, you grin and start rocking your hips again, forcing him to keep both hands on your waist to inhibit your movements.
Trailing your mouth upwards, you tease his earlobe with your teeth, nipping carefully before soothing the flesh with your tongue. You moan softly under your breath, practically purring directly into his ear, and when you feel him shudder again, you finally whisper the nickname you know has a debilitating effect on Steve.
“Captain.”
Steve groans. “No, no, no, no,” he rushes the words out. “Don’t start with—”
“This is a party, Captain,” you cut him off, "and I want to have fun now. Isn’t that what you’re supposed to do at parties? Have fun? Not wait until after when everyone’s gone?” you let your faux pout seep into your voice, the sound nearly whiny with need.
“Dollface,” Steve grunts, struggling to simultaneously maintain his composure and get you to stop moving. “It’s just a few more hours. You can wait—”
“Please, Captain” you husk. “Let’s have some fun now. I feel like I’ve barely seen you because of practice. You’ve been so busy lately.” Your hand crawls down his stomach, teasing the waistband of his shorts.
“Oh, please don't remind me of that," he begs. "I know I've been a bit preoccupied, but—”
“I just wanna enjoy this time with you now…,” plucking at the elastic of his shorts, you croon, “Captain.”
Steve groans again. “Baby, you gotta stop with the ‘Cap—’”
“Captain, please,” you pretend to beg out of desperation. With your lips against his ear, you let out a series of breathy moans, your voice ascending in pitch with each, “Please, please, plea—”
“That better be apple juice in your cup, Parker!” The barking voice suddenly snaps you from your mischief.
Your words halt as your eyes flit over Steve’s shoulder, observing Sam cross his arms as he glares at something behind you. Craning your neck back, you see Peter chatting with a group of friends, red solo cup in hand. His eyes go wide at Sam’s accusation. Carefully, he places the beverage on the TV stand before putting his hands up in surrender. He backs around the corner – hands up the entire time – until he’s out of the room.
Just as quickly as you were distracted, you redirect your attention to Steve. You go to speak again, but before you can, Steve claps a large hand over your mouth to silence you.
Steve’s expression turns stony as he’s pulled from the near-trance you had him in. “Baby, I’m only gonna say this once so you better listen closely. You need to stop before—” his caution is interrupted as a drunken Scott bumps into the back of the couch, slurring an apology to the furniture as he stumbles away.
Steve watches Scott’s movements for a moment before looking back to you. He continues, “Before it’s too late. You might just do something you’ll regret.” He raises a brow in warning.
Slowly, he withdraws his hand to allow you to speak again. With your mouth uncovered, you lick your lips deliberately, letting your tongue make a lazy pass from corner to corner.
You smirk and narrow your eyes. “If I didn’t know any better, I’d say that almost sounded like a threat, Rogers.”
Steve purses his lips, giving you a similarly skeptical look. “Who said it wasn’t?”
Amused, you lean forward and drape your arms around his shoulders. “Well, baby, I’ve told you before that I like a little danger.” You nip at his bottom lip, gently tugging at it with your teeth. “So you’re only threatening me with a good time, Captain.”
A hint of a smile pulls at Steve’s lips as he rolls his eyes. “You are something else sometimes. Can’t you go one day without trying to pull some shit?” he admonishes, gently pinching your hip. “Must you always be such a tease?”
“Must you always be such a bore?” you retort and force an obviously fake reproachful look on your face.
Steve’s eyes darken almost imperceptibly at your words. His fingers tighten around your waist, gently divoting your flesh. “Oh, you’ve done it now, dollface. You want danger? I’ll give you da—” His eyes suddenly go wide as they focus on something over your shoulder. “Shit!” Steve unceremoniously lifts you from his lap, all but tossing you onto the empty cushion beside him as he lunges off the couch.
You gape as he dashes to the TV stand – Peter’s abandoned drink having been spilled onto the console, the liquid spreading rapidly. With no time to think, Steve’s reflexes take over and he lifts the impressive flatscreen off the table, protecting it from the expanding pool.
“Lang, what the fuck?!” Steve snaps at Scott standing beside him.
Scott teeters on his feet for a moment before he puts a hand on the wall to balance himself. “W-what?” he hiccups, totally unaware of his clumsy mishap.
Steve lets out a displeased breath and shakes his head. “Dude, just… go lay down before you pass out or something.”
Scott blinks in confusion for a few seconds. He looks between Steve and the puddle like he's trying to make sense of the scene, his face creasing as he thinks. Eventually, something must click in his inebriated brain because he nods. “‘Kay,” he agrees, then stumbles away to hopefully take Steve’s advice.
Steve sighs heavily before shifting on his feet, getting a better grip on the appliance in his hands. He mumbles something, though you don't catch it as you remain seated on the couch, enraptured by the sight before you.
Steve's back strains against his fitted shirt, the muscles shifting as he moves every now and then. He turns to the side slightly and mumbles something else, but again, you don't register his words – instead, watching on as he unintentionally flexes the cords of his arm.
Suddenly, your mouth feels incredibly dry. Not only did getting tossed around like a ragdoll stir something in your belly, but watching Steve lift that TV with ease – witnessing his strength on full display – makes your stomach flip in excitement.
You swallow thickly as the vein running along his bicep pulses against the skin, feeling a pressure similarly throb in your core. You know Steve is strong – for goodness’ sake, just look at him! – but seeing that strength firsthand does something unexplainable to you.
You wonder what it would be like if Steve showed you just how strong he really is. If he threw you around without a care in the world; manhandled you however he wanted; gripped you so fiercely, he left bruises on your hips as he dragged and pulled you onto his coc—
The sound of Steve yelling your name pulls you from your wandering thoughts.
“Huh? W-what?” You bring yourself back to the moment with a shake of your head.
“I asked if you could get something to clean this up.” He nods towards the spill.
“Oh. Y-yeah. Sure,” you mutter.
You run to the kitchen and grab a handful of paper towels before returning to the living room. Dutifully, you sop up the spilled beverage – something that definitely wasn’t apple juice just as Sam had suspected.
As you clean, you chance a peek from the corner of your eye, watching as Steve appears to be completely unfazed by the heavy load in his arm. You try to be covert as you ogle him with your peripheral vision, pretending to be totally focused on your task at hand.
Steve catches you anyway.
“Why do you keep looking at me like that?”
At his question, your attention is drawn up to Steve’s face, seeing him giving you a perplexed look. His brows knit more tightly together when you don't immediately respond, your hand paused mid-wipe as you think of what to say.
While you could be honest and say you were nearly drooling at the sight of his biceps bulging, you know Steve would never let you live that down, especially given the shenanigans you just pulled on the couch. Steve would have a field day if he knew he got you all tongue-tied like you frequently do to him. You don’t want to give him that satisfaction.
“What do you mean? I’m-I’m not looking at you,” you mutter, opting for good ol' denial.
He scoffs, unconvinced. “Yeah, you are. Pretty obviously, too.”
Damn it. Looks like that won’t work.
“I… I…,” you stutter as you scramble to think of an explanation. After a few moments of scatterbrained thinking – bingo! – an idea comes to mind. “I was just remembering how Sam once told me you think with your muscles and m—, well… your muscles before your mind. I guess he was right,” you chuckle.
“Oh, come on," Steve grumbles. "Would you have had a better idea than to lift the damn thing? What was I supposed to do? Whip out my emergency ShamWow I just happen to carry with me?” he asks rhetorically. “Or better yet, power slurp whatever drink that was before it spread to the TV?”
You turn to face him more directly, a smile inching your mouth up. “I mean… you do have a talented tongue, Steve. So that wouldn’t have been out of the question.”
Steve simply rolls his eyes before nodding at the puddle again. “Just finish cleaning, please.”
You give him a mock salute. “Aye, aye, Captain,” you say in a gruff voice, earning you a snort from Steve.
Having narrowly avoided being exposed, you soak up the rest of the drink in a hurry, only stopping to sneak one or two more peeks at Steve during the time. Afterwards, once you’ve discarded the dirtied towels, Steve drags you back to the couch you occupied earlier, plopping you down beside him.
"So… how ya been? How's practice been going?" you question, deciding to pass the time with something other than tonsil hockey.
"Ugh, let's not talk about that," Steve groans. He takes your hand and begins to fiddle with your fingers. "How about we talk about you instead."
As you let Steve play with your fingers, you shrug noncommittally. "Alright, shoot."
“Okay…,” he begins as he thinks of a topic to discuss. After a beat, he asks, “What was the real reason you were looking so intently at me?”
You blanch at his question. “I-I told you,” you insist. “I was remembering when Sam—”
“No, no, no,” Steve cuts your fake explanation short. “I said the real reason.”
Steve sets his jaw and locks his fingers with yours as he waits for your response. Under the weight of his gaze, you start to squirm and babble nonsense as you try to think of another explanation that sounds convincing. As you scour your brain for something – anything – to say, unfortunately, you end up coming short, a heavy sigh falling from your lips at the realization you can’t claw your way out of this.
Since Steve seems to be dead set on finding out the truth, you figure it's only a matter of time before he catches on, no matter how much you try to tell him otherwise. Hoping that maybe he'll take a little pity on you and not poke too much fun if you're upfront, you decide to be truthful.
"Okay, so… maybe I was, um… admiring your muscles not because of what Sam said, but because of my own volition."
"Why…?" Steve prods.
"Because… I like how they look?" your voice pitches up at the end, turning a would-be statement into a question. When Steve gives you a look saying “Go on”, you sigh, but ultimately yield. “Okay, I really like how they look,” you elaborate only just so.
“So, you were distracted and all fuzzy-brained because you were checking me out?” Steve arches a brow.
You sigh once more and drop your head in defeat. “Yes,” you nod.
A few seconds of silence pass as Steve lets your words sink in. Then, a sudden, boisterous laugh bubbles out of his throat, making you snap your head back up at him.
“I knew it!” he chortles. “I just wanted to hear it from your mouth.”
You scoff and roughly pull your hand out of his. “Well… congrats," you say in as monotone of a voice as you can muster. "You got what you wanted. You happy now?”
Steve retakes your hand to briefly kiss the back of it. “Ecstatic,” he beams.
“Yeah, yeah, alright. Don’t get too used to it, Rogers,” you grumble and wave him off. “It’s like I said earlier, I haven’t seen you much the past couple of weeks, so I’m having to readjust a little. You’re a lot to process,” you snark.
“Sure, sure. Whatever you say,” Steve concedes, the sarcasm obvious in his tone. He grins widely as he settles back into the couch. “But I must admit, it’s nice being on the other side for once. I’m just so irresistible that you couldn’t help but be distracted by me,” he jokes, pretending to toss long hair over his shoulder.
“Alright, don’t get ahead of yourself, Narcissus.” You elbow him in the ribs.
Steve laughs and rubs his side for a moment, pretending to soothe his ribs after your assault. But then all of a sudden, he jolts forward in his seat, his face rapidly shifting into a serious expression. “Oh, what’s this?” he exaggerates his voice and movements, slipping into almost a caricature of himself. He stands and rounds the coffee table set before the couch, theatrically pointing at one of the legs. “I think this leg looks a little wobbly. Wouldn’t you agree, dollface?”
You roll your eyes dramatically. “What are you doi—”
Before you finish your question, Steve lifts the table several feet off the ground, jostling around the empty beer cans and various pieces of garbage lying atop. Carefully, he examines the leg in question, the muscles of his arms tensing and contracting as he turns it every which way.
“No, I think it’s okay actually,” he muses, setting the furniture back down with a smirk.
You can't help but chuckle at his antics. “You are such an idiot.”
“Hey,” he faux chastises, “I think the correct term is ‘himbo’, thank you very much.”
You nearly choke on your spit as you laugh. You didn't expect that to come out of his mouth. “I stand corrected. You are a huge idiot,” you guffaw.
“I don’t know what you mean.” Steve puts his hands on his hips and pushes his chest forward, power posing before you.
Shaking your head incredulously, you chuckle again, unable to keep a smile off of your face. “If you keep this shit up, I’ll just leave early. I've got a test on Tuesday I can be studying for,” you warn. Maybe if you threaten him a little – even though you don't really mean it – you can get him to stop acting like a dumbass.
Steve lifts his arm and bends his elbow at a 90 degree angle. “Well, the door’s that way,” he tells you, flexing his bicep as he points unnaturally at the door. “Or… is it that way?” He switches directions, mirroring the pose with the other arm. “I’m not sure. I think I might’ve had too much to drink tonight."
Though a small part of you wants to stop and admire Steve's physique, all you can do at the moment is laugh at how ridiculous he looks as he tries to show off. Steve, on the other hand, schools his own expression in order to play up his act and not break character.
"But you can leave whenever you want, especially if you’ve got stuff to do," he finally declares. "Though… you might want to stay for the show. I’ve heard it's quite an experience," he baits you.
Your eyes feel like they're about to pop out of your skull from how hard you're stifling the need to roll them. But, you decide to humor him. You cross your arms and lean into the couch. "And what show is that, Steve?" you ask.
He smirks and drops his voice an octave. "The gun show."
Steve swiftly raises both arms to put his muscles on full display, switching back and forth to flex each arm in turn. He leans side to side to give each bicep a loud, sloppy kiss, prompting an ungodly cackle to erupt from your mouth as you watch.
He gives you an intense look as he turns his attention back to you, keeping his voice at a low baritone to really sell his macho man act. “Welcome to the gun show, baby. You're in for a treat,” he croons. “It looks like you’ve got yourself a front row seat, so you better strap in and hold on tight before—”
"Man, what the hell are you doing?" Sam’s voice comes out of nowhere, interrupting the scene playing out before you.
Steve is quickly snapped from his tomfoolery as he's caught red-handed by Sam, his friend just so happening to wander into the room during the peacocking.
Steve drops his hands back down by his sides and returns his voice to its normal timbre. "I, uh, I was just… um…," he trails off, not having an excuse for his actions.
"Look, we get it," Sam says boredly. "The gym rat’s got muscles and wants to show them off. But this ain’t a Men’s Health magazine, so cut the shit, man,” he chides as he rounds the couch, coming to stand before Steve.
Steve shakes his head and goes to speak, likely to clarify that he was just fucking around for your amusement, but not before Sam adds, “I mean, it’s not like you see me parading around here showing off all of this," he gestures up and down at himself.
Steve’s mouth snaps closed, his expression twisting into a mix of amusement and incredulity. “Uh… well… maybe that’s because you haven’t worked out in two months,” he tries not to chuckle as he speaks.
Sam’s brows shoot up to his hairline. “Excuse me?” he asks, stunned. “I’ll have you know, I do 100 squats every. single. morning,” he states matter-of-factly, punctuating the words for emphasis. “And I know I can definitely outlift you, head quarterback or not.”
Steve snorts and reaches over to pat Sam on the shoulder. “Sure ya can, man. Sure ya can,” he encourages as if speaking to a child.
“Man, fuck you. Don’t patronize me,” Sam spits, stepping back out of arm’s reach. “Newsflash, Dorito Man. Strength doesn’t have to be confined to just your upper half.” He makes an upside down triangle in the air, mocking the shape of Steve’s body. “Ever heard of lifting with your legs, huh? You see these thighs?” He pats his quads. “They’re like tree trunks. Solid. Strong. A.K.A. can absolutely outlift your little slim-hipped ass.”
Steve’s mouth pops open at the boldness of Sam’s declaration. He goes to retort, but before he can, you speak first.
“Yeah, baby, I’m with Sam on this one. He’s got some pretty nice thighs… and ass for that matter. I think he can take you,” you smirk, fighting the urge to laugh as Steve’s face contorts with more shock.
While Steve had originally been worried about “putting on a show for the whole house to see”, for the past several minutes, he’s been doing just that. You’ve been getting a kick out of it – as well as a few other feelings – so you’re not ready to let the show come to an end just yet. And what better way to do that than by inciting a little brotherly competition between the two frat members.
“Thank you, sweetness,” Sam says smugly before sending Steve a shit-eating grin. “See, Rogers? Even your girl agrees with me.”
Steve looks at you in disbelief, putting his hands on his hips. “Whose side are you on?” he accuses.
You shrug nonchalantly as you sink deeper into the couch. “I just call ‘em like I see ‘em, baby,” you further egg him on, hoping to ignite that competitive nature in Steve.
As Steve’s eyes darken ever so slightly, you know you’ve done it.
“Alright, Tree Trunks,” Steve looks at Sam, voice devoid of humor. “Let’s see if you can take me.”
Sam cracks his knuckles and his neck, rolling his shoulders to warm up. “Oh, it’s on, Dorito Man.”
They settle on the living room furniture as the events for their impromptu strongman competition. Taking turns, they lift various objects around the room: the end table, the armchair, even going so far as to ask you to stand from the sofa so they can have a hand at that. And when they both miserably attempt to solo lift the three-seater, you can’t help the ugly laugh that watching their struggle elicits from you.
During the course of the theatrics, a crowd of onlookers gradually appears, watching on as the two idiots manhandle every object in sight. At some point, Natasha and Bucky also join the group of spectators.
“What are they doing?” Natasha asks, sidling up beside you along the wall.
“Trying to determine who’s stronger,” you snicker. This dick-measuring contest has been going better than expected, and you’re thoroughly amused by that fact.
You and Natasha exchange knowing looks before shaking your heads and rolling your eyes in sync. “Men,” you both mutter under your breaths.
“Well, remind me to call them when I need help moving. I won’t have to hire a service that way,” Natasha jokes.
“Hey, what about me?” Bucky questions her, sounding a little wounded that she didn’t mention his name. While Bucky may not be as burly as Sam or Steve, he could probably be of some assistance when helping his girlfriend move.
“Don’t worry, babe, you’ll be there, too,” she reassures him with a gentle rub to his bicep. When Bucky smiles and goes to thank her, she elaborates, “After all, your truck can hold a lot more than my Bug.”
Bucky’s face falls at her statement, realizing she means to use his truck rather than him for labor.
She continues before he gets a chance to voice his dejection. “But… that sucker’s gonna have to be deep cleaned at least twice before I put my stuff anywhere near it,” she winces, thinking about the filthy state of his vehicle.
While you’ve, thankfully, never had to endure a ride in Bucky’s truck, you’ve heard enough horror stories to last a lifetime. You’d be willing to bet that some yet undiscovered species of insect has made home in the pickup.
Bucky raises a finger in objection and opens his mouth to speak, looking as if he’s going to argue with Natasha’s statement. But, after a second of self-reflection, he closes his mouth and lets his hand fall back to his side, nodding in defeat as he knows she makes a valid point.
Natasha gives Bucky one more reassuring pat before turning back to you. “So… think they’re gonna be done anytime soon?” She indicates the still ongoing competition. “Because some of us want to use the living room not as a home gym.”
You shrug. "Beats me. I was just thinking of making some popcorn.” Dinner and a show. That’d be pretty nice.
Natasha lets out a deep sigh and leans against the wall, deciding to patiently wait for the men to finish up. She stands with you for several minutes, tapping her foot the whole time. But, as Sam and Steve try and fail to lift the sofa for a third time in a row – causing you to seriously consider making that popcorn – Natasha finally decides she’s had enough.
“Well, guys, congratulations. You did it,” she says, directing everyone’s attention towards her. “You proved you’re both equally as strong as each other… and equally as dumb,” she deadpans as she nods at the couch. “It looks like you’ve come to an impasse so, unless you want to move to the kitchen so you can try lifting the fridge,” she rolls her eyes, “I think there’s only one way to decide the winner of this… whatever it is.”
Steve and Sam look at each other – both slightly sweaty and out of breath from their deadlocked battle. After a moment of sizing each other up, Steve waves for Natasha to continue, telling them what she has in mind.
“A push-up contest,” she states plainly, drawing a few cheers from the crowd. “Whoever does the most push-ups in 60 seconds wins.”
As people start whooping in encouragement – numerous "Hell yeahs" and "Do its" being tossed around – Sam and Steve finally take note of the sheer size of the crowd they've attracted. They’d been so invested in their competition that they didn’t even notice how a majority of the party-goers had gathered around the scene, watching the two men go head-to-head.
With a crowd that size, the stakes of their competition has increased tenfold. Now, instead of one of them simply having to concede to the other, they'd have to lose in front of several dozens of people.
Talk about a blow to the ego.
The reluctance is obvious on both men’s faces as they eye the group of spectators. They start mumbling various excuses as to why they're unsure about Natasha's idea, trying to dissipate the crowd’s desires to avoid further embarrassing themselves. As they continue to show their hesitation, Natasha takes the opportunity to speak again.
"Like I said…," she draws their attention to her once more, "…there's always the fridge." She smirks and cocks her head to the side, raising a brow in challenge as she waits for their response.
Natasha knows it's an impossible task, but she also knows the two frat members are too stubborn to end their competition in a stalemate. Thus, whether they move to some other room of the house or take part in the contest Natasha proposed, no matter what, the living room will soon be freed up for her use. Win-win for her either way.
The crowd starts cheering even louder, making Steve and Sam more and more uncomfortable as they fidget in their spots. As the noise crescendos into a frenzied cacophony, both men finally put their hands up in surrender.
“Alright, fine. A push-up contest to determine the winner,” Sam relents. “But… uh…," he looks around the crowd, his eyes widening in delight as his gaze suddenly focuses on Bucky. "Buck, you’re joining us, too.” He waves Bucky over with two fingers.
“What?” Bucky blinks in confusion at the command. “I don’t want to be involved. Don’t drag me into this.” He shakes his head firmly.
“C’mon, man. You can… act as the control,” Sam says, seemingly making up the excuse on the spot.
Bucky gives Sam a confused look and raises his palms to the ceiling. “What is that supposed to mean?” He looks around the room exasperatedly, as if he’ll find the answer written on the walls.
“He wants to juxtapose his strength to yours,” MJ pipes up, her and Peter having entered the room just as the contest was announced. “So, win or lose, he'll still look good in comparison.”
Bucky sends an accusatory look at Sam. “Screw you! No, I’m not doing that,” he pouts and crosses his arms over his chest.
“Look, you do this and I’ll call off the debt from when something bit me in your truck,” Sam narrows his eyes, tempting Bucky to take the offer.
Bucky cringes as he remembers the incident in question. He slowly uncrosses his arms, letting a none too pleased look overtake his face. “Okay, fine,” he grits and reluctantly walks over to join the two men in their contest.
The crowd backs up to allow ample space for the competition. The men lower themselves and plant their hands on the ground, waiting as Natasha readies everyone for the countdown.
“On my mark,” she begins.
Steve suddenly looks up from his place on the floor, catching your eye as you stand before him.
"Get set."
You wink and give him a thumbs up, mouthing, “You got this."
"Go!"
Right out of the gate, Sam and Steve start pounding out push-ups, already leaving Bucky behind in the dust. Per Natasha's orders, you're Steve's spotter, counting out loud along with each of his movements. The crowd grows rambunctious as the seconds quickly tick by, watching and listening as the counts climb higher and higher.
"Eighteen, 19, 20…," you keep time with Steve, barely able to hear the sound of your own voice above the din.
"Seventeen, 18, 19…," Wanda counts beside you as she spots for Sam.
Though he stands only a couple of feet away, you can only just discern Clint counting, “Seven, eight, nine…,” for Bucky – the wall of sound surrounding you too noisy to be able to think through, let alone hear.
But none of those distractions matter anyway as your attention is focused on Steve and Steve alone.
Sweat glistens his hairline as numerous droplets slide down his temples and the bridge of his nose, dripping onto the wood floor below. You watch over and over again how he extends his arms to raise up, only to rapidly descend as he lowers himself once more, his chest nearly brushing the floor with each bend of his elbows. The harder and further Steve pushes himself, the more his muscles strain against the fabric of his shirt, his biceps threatening to tear right through his sleeves.
As you watch on, an unbidden warmth starts to slowly spread in your belly, growing hotter and needier by the second. The adrenaline and endurance and excitement of the scene almost reminds you of something you know all too well, and it nearly distracts you from the task at hand.
You're forced to press your thighs together as you continue to spot Steve, feebly attempting to quell the throbbing in your core. It's all but totally unsuccessful. But, thankfully, someone saves you from the torture of having to watch this display of virility any longer than necessary.
"Ten…," Natasha starts counting down, alerting everyone that the competition is about to come to a close.
It seems to kick the men into overdrive, encouraging them to give strong last-ditch efforts to try coming out on top. They push themselves more and more, their faces becoming flushed and ruddy from exertion, their breaths coming out in harsh puffs.
"Seven…."
As the clock winds down and the men give it their all, Steve’s panting quickly turns to grunting, his muscles on fire as they protest what he’s subjecting them to.
The sound of his groans shoots straight to your core, making you choke on your words, your count faltering for a beat. You dig your nails into your palms, trying to get yourself to focus.
"Three…."
The crowd goes into an uproar in the final seconds. The sound of their cheering is nearly deafening, filling up every square inch of the frat house, almost drowning out the sound of Natasha finally yelling, "Stop!"
At her command, the participants drop to the ground like flies, heaving like they just ran a marathon. While you weren't even one amongst the now-exhausted competitors, you feel similarly winded to them, several shallow breaths falling from your mouth.
Wearily, Steve and Sam rise off the ground to sit back on their heels, leaving Bucky to lie face-down on the floor alone. Dripping in sweat and panting heavily, Steve looks at you for assurance. The sight of him makes you bite your lip, a small voice in your head telling you to jump on him right then and there.
You fight the urge to pounce, though, and instead flash him a thumbs up in response. While it was difficult to concentrate with all of the activity around you – as well as the inner buzzing you were experiencing – with the number you ended on, you figure you know who the winner is.
"Well, I think we all know who won," Natasha agrees with the internal remark you just made. "But, to make it official, let's have our spotters call out the final tallies," she announces, gesturing for the crowd to calm down and give you all the metaphorical mic.
"Bucky's final count was 19," Clint states, drawing a few "Awws" from the crowd.
Sam reaches over and claps Bucky's prone form on the back – Bucky not even having the energy to wave him off or grumble some kind of angry remark for being strong-armed into this competition.
"Sam's was 46," Wanda declares, being met with several "Whoops" from the party-goers.
As all eyes then turn to you, it seems like a hush rapidly takes over the crowd, the party silent for the first time this evening. You look over the spectators in turn before facing Steve once again. Ever so slowly, a smile grows on your face as you gaze directly into his eyes.
"Steve did…," you pause for dramatic effect, drawing out the palpable tension in the atmosphere, "…53."
A similarly wide grin spreads on Steve's face – the winner of this ridiculous but impressive competition. With the cocksure smile still plastered on, he raises his hands in victory, ready to welcome the inevitable flood of congratulations he's about to receive; ready to bask in the praise about to rain down on him; ready to—
"Sixty-eight," a voice calls from the corner.
All heads immediately snap towards the voice in question, seeing MJ leaning against the wall nonchalantly. "Peter did 68," she states again, nodding at Peter who stands beside her – looking slightly breathless and a faint flushed, but otherwise normal.
Your jaw drops in shock. You'd been so distracted by the commotion that you hadn't even noticed Peter was also participating just a few feet away. Apparently, Sam and Steve didn't notice either as their mouths also slacken in astonishment.
Peter shrugs and looks bashfully around the crowd. "I-I started a little late," he says, sounding almost embarrassed for not having done more.
Natasha smiles and shakes her head. "It’s okay, Peter, you did great,” she reassures him. “So, like I said, I think we have a clear winner on our hands." She brings one hand up to her mouth to mime holding a microphone while the other extends towards Peter. “Your winner, ladies and gentlemen: Peter Parker!”
The crowd once again erupts into cheers as dozens of people suddenly swarm Peter to congratulate him. While everyone else celebrates, Steve and Sam appear to be less than pleased that the underclassman won – both sulking and grumbling under their breaths.
“What’s that, gentlemen? Have something to say?” Natasha asks them, cupping her ear in a dramatic manner.
Sam raises a shoulder as if he's unbothered – though, that doesn’t keep the pettiness from seeping into his voice. “Just don’t think it was very fair,” he mumbles.
Natasha raises a skeptical brow at his words, putting a hand on her hip. “And why’s that? He did the competition, didn’t he? Did more push-ups than both of you? In less time, might I add,” she emphasizes, a smirk slanting her lips. “So how is that unfair?”
“Well, uh, we… we were… we were tired from all of the earlier lifting we did,” Steve offers, giving an excuse for why they’d been bested by the freshman.
“Yeah,” Sam nods vigorously. “I-I think I threw my back out trying to lift the couch. Ooh, ouch,” he hisses, contorting his face into a pained expression as he rubs at his lower back. “Yeah, that’s gonna be sore tomorrow.”
Natasha simply raises her brows as if to say, “You can do better than that.” At her sardonic expression, the men begin to spout more excuses for their loss. Natasha purses her lips and nods exaggeratedly as they talk, her motions drenched in sarcasm. After a solid minute of terrible justifications, the men eventually fade to a quiet lull, seeing she remains unconvinced.
“Mm-hm. Yeah. Of course,” Natasha says, continuing to nod along as if they're still speaking. When the men simply look at her in silence, only then does she stop the charade and let her expression return to normal. "Oh, are you finished? I don't want to interrupt you or anything."
Sam and Steve give her a guilty look before nodding gently, telling her they’re done with the bullshit.
"We can’t all be winners. You guys lost. Just accept it," she states, somehow managing to not roll her eyes as she speaks. "And while you might wanna sit on the floor and pout all night, I'd suggest getting up before you get trampled by the stampede." She gestures at the rowdy party-goers still floundering about, clumsily bumping into one another. She then turns to you and points to Bucky still splayed out on the floor. "Pumpkin, a hand?"
You nod and make your way over to help her. As you go about trying to pick up Bucky, you see Sam and Steve shoot each other disgruntled looks – brows furrowed and mouths downturned as they come to terms with what just happened. When Steve turns that grumpy look to you, you find that all you can do is hold his gaze in response.
Should you comfort him or give him some tough love like Natasha? Soothe him or scoff? Honestly, you’re not sure what to say in this moment, so you decide to say nothing at all, opting for a simple shrug instead.
You'll deal with Steve later. Right now, the only thing you're concerned with is how you're going to peel Bucky's limp, sweaty body off the living room floor.
~~~~~
“There you are! I was wondering where you wandered off to.”
You smile as you find Steve in the kitchen, leaning against the counter as he nurses a beer. After you and Natasha successfully got Bucky off the ground and over to the couch to recover, you’d found that Steve had slinked away somewhere. You've been searching the house for him the past 20 minutes, only to just now stumble upon him in the kitchen.
You expect he's been taking the time to decompress and mellow out, but as you near him, your smile falls when you get a closer look at his expression – looking as crabby and brooding as ever.
“What’s wrong?” you ask, tilting your head as you look him over.
Steve shrugs a shoulder and brings the bottle up to his lips, ignoring your question in favor of taking another swig of his beer.
You narrow your eyes and study him more closely. You haven’t seen Steve this annoyed since a certain bucket incident all that time ago – though, that same scenario is obviously not the cause of his current chagrin.
Well, given the unexpected turn of events from the night, you figure that likely has something to do with his demeanor. But that alone seems a bit petty if you’re being honest. Sure, Steve might understandably be a bit upset about losing the competition, but you highly doubt he’d throw a whole hissy fit because of it, and especially not almost half an hour after the fact.
Come to think of it, Steve’s been acting a little off all night. Could there be a reason for that besides losing a dumb, drunken competition? You wonder if perhaps there is.
“This isn’t just about the push-up contest, is it?” you ask in a delicate tone, trying to carefully broach the topic.
He shrugs again and takes another heavy gulp of his drink – not directly answering you, but nevertheless all but confirming your suspicions. There is something deeper at play that’s souring Steve’s mood.
You sigh and lean a hip against the counter beside him. “You wanna talk about it? You seem pretty upset,” you note, watching as he downs the rest of the beer.
He shakes his head as he pushes off the counter with a grunt. He discards the empty bottle before reaching into the fridge for a new one, popping off the cap and coming to lean back against the counter again.
“Y’sure? We can talk. I’m all ears,” you offer once more.
Unlike after ‘The Incident’ where Steve was left to silently stew in his thoughts all afternoon, you’d rather him get whatever this is off his chest here and now before it has a chance to boil over later.
Steve shakes his head again before tipping it back, guzzling the new beer in his hand. As he gulps and gulps and gulps without coming up for air – seemingly going to finish the bottle in one breath – you suddenly reach for the drink, pulling it from his hand and earning you a disgruntled look.
“What the hell?” Steve finally speaks, his empty hand outstretched.
“That’s enough of that,” you say before bringing the bottle up to your own lips, downing the remainder of the beer. Once you’ve finished, you set the bottle down with a grimace, the bitter taste of the cheap liquor coating your tongue. “Now, talk to me. What’s the matter? What’s going on?”
Steve blows out an exasperated breath and tosses both hands up in the air. “Shit, I don’t know. It’s… it’s just a lot of things, I guess.”
Okay, he’s willing to talk. That’s a good thing; that means you’re making some progress. You nod for him to continue, encouraging him to speak his mind.
He lets out another breath and shakes his head before beginning. “This whole week's been shit, really,” he sighs, his chin dipping to watch as he traces his palm with his thumb. “First, Coach has been on my ass relentlessly. All ‘Pick up the slack, Rogers. We’re only as strong as our weakest link’. And then tonight, I just wanted to kick back and forget about all that shit, only to get showed up by some punk freshman in a fucking push-up contest.”
“Hey,” you say, the sharpness in your tone drawing Steve’s eyes back up to you. “Don’t blame Peter. This isn’t his fault.”
Steve tucks his chin again as he nods guiltily. “No, yeah. You’re right, you’re right,” he agrees. “It’s just… I’ve been getting berated all week in front of my team, and so now to embarrass myself in front of the whole house, it’s…,” he trails off with a sigh, his eyes falling shut. “It’s a lot.”
A frown overtakes your face as you regard his sulking form. So that’s what this all stems from. Not just some ridiculous competition, but a much deeper-seated feeling of inadequacy. That explains a lot. The way he avoided talking about practice, the gloomy or otherwise abnormal behavior he’s had all night, the showboating he did to try to overcompensate… It all makes sense now.
“Baby, look at me.” You bring your hand up to his cheek, encouraging him to lift his head and open his eyes.
He takes a moment, but eventually, he relents, carefully bringing his attention back to you. You smile when his gaze once again connects with yours and you rub your thumb over his cheekbone.
“You… are incredible,” you say slowly; deliberately. “You are smart. Strong. Kind. You’re a damn great leader if I’ve ever seen one,” you emphasize, drawing a small, amused huff out of him. “You are worth so much more than what a contest, or Coach Phillips, or anyone says of you, alright? Fuck all of ‘em,” you gesture vaguely towards the doorway, indicating not only the party going on a room over, but anyone else who’d criticize Steve.
You bring your hand down to rest over his heart. “You. Are. Incredible. And you should never forget that.”
As you press your palm against the center of his chest, you see Steve slowly process your words, the sincerity in your voice hopefully having its intended effect on him. To your delight, a small smile gradually brightens his face, replacing that somber look he just had.
“Thank you, baby.” He takes your hand from his chest to place a kiss across your knuckles, then drops your intertwined hands down to your sides. “But I’m afraid it’s not that simple.”
His rejection surprises you, making you blink in confusion. “Wha—”
“Even if I tried to ignore what everyone thinks of me, I can’t help that there’s still one person whose opinion I care about,” he says, some vaguely playful expression on his face.
You let the tension leave your body as you realize Steve isn’t completely disregarding everything you’d just said to him. That would’ve been discouraging to have your words tossed aside like they were useless.
And his latest statement in conjunction with the look on his face. Does he mean…? Is he really about to say…?
“You,” he admits, confirming your suspicions.
“Me?” Your brow quirks in question.
“Mm-hm,” he nods. “You’re right that it doesn’t matter what those drunks or that drill sergeant thinks. But you… well, your opinion matters greatly to me. I think sometimes it’s even more important than my opinion of myself,” he chuckles.
You smile with him and squeeze his hand a little tighter in yours. “I’m flattered. It’s nice that someone holds me in such high esteem,” you say, partially joking and partially earnest. While you know he’s being a bit hyperbolic when he says your opinion is the only one that matters to him, it’s still endearing to know that he thinks so highly of you.
“So… what do you think of me? Honestly,” Steve probes.
You tilt your head in slight perplexity. “I just told you. You’re incredible, and smart, and—”
“Well, those are just facts,” he jokes, a smirk curving the side of his mouth. “What do you think of me?”
You take a moment to search your brain, trying to come up with a succinct answer to appease him. “I… think you’re pretty great,” you remark.
“Just 'great'?” He raises a taunting brow. He steps closer to you and wraps his arms around your lower back, enveloping you within his embrace. “Just a step up above ‘good’? That’s all?”
You roll your eyes in jest. While you’re glad he’s obviously in a much better mood than he was just a few minutes ago, his cheekiness leaves something to be desired. Still, you'll humor him for a bit.
“I think you’re absolutely amazing.”
“‘Amazing’?" He winces in faux pain. "Ouch, you wound me."
You sigh and shake your head, biting the insides of your cheeks to keep from smiling too widely. He’s really milking this for everything he can, isn’t he?
Bringing your hands up to his chest, you rest your palms across his pecs, leaning into him slightly. “Steve, I think you are the sweetest, strongest, sexiest man I’ve ever had the pleasure of knowing.”
“‘Knowing’ as in a… Biblical sense?” he grins devilishly.
You can't help the derisive tsk that involuntarily leaves your mouth. "Uh… I was thinking more of a general sense, but… sure. We can go with that," you chuckle, shaking your head in feigned admonishment. "Hmm, but… now that you mention it,” you start walking your index and middle fingers along his chest, dancing on the planes of muscle. “You know what, Captain?"
The sound of his nickname makes Steve squeeze you a little tighter in his arms, his pupils dilating marginally. “What?”
“Of all the men I’ve ever 'known'," you emphasize, telling him you're still talking about that kind of 'knowing', "by far, you have got the absolute biggest… thickest… most gorgeous-looking co—”
“Bleeeegh!”
Yours and Steve's attentions are rapidly drawn towards the sink, finding Scott bent over the counter puking his guts up.
"Bluuuuh! Blaaargh!" he vomits, the sound violent and entirely unpleasant.
You and Steve untangle yourselves from each other as the moment’s now unfortunately been ruined. You grimace as Scott continues to blow chunks just a few feet away, counting your blessings that you’re too far to be able to see or smell anything that’s coming up out of him. When he pauses for a moment to catch his breath, you call out to him to check up on how he's doing.
"Scott, are y—"
"BLEEEEGH!"
"—ou okay?"
Even as he continues to hurl, Scott manages to put a thumb up in the air, signaling that he's alright. Or… as alright as can be expected.
When there's another cease in the vomiting, Steve carefully approaches Scott at the sink. As Steve reaches the basin and looks down, he retches, his hand coming up to cover his mouth. His Adam's apple bobs as he pushes back a gag, forcing himself to hold his breath as he gently pats Scott on the back.
"You good, man?" Steve asks him, looking upwards at the ceiling instead of at the mess below.
Scott nods like his head is made of lead, his movements slow and heavy. "I-I think so," he slurs, the alcohol lacing every drop of his blood.
"Okay. Good." Steve nods, trying to sound pleased. "Now, why don't you—?"
"BLUUUUH!"
"Oh, come on!" Steve jumps back to avoid the splash zone. "I can't. I can't do this. I’m a sympathy vo—" he heaves, nearly joining Scott in the dramatics by spewing his guts across the kitchen tile. He takes a few deep breaths to collect himself before looking to you. “Dollface, can you…?”
“Me?” Your eyes go wide at the unspoken question. “No, no, no. He’s one of your brothers. And as such, you should take care of him.”
At that moment, some poor, unsuspecting underclassman walks into the kitchen, making Steve's eyes immediately light up.
"Luis, c’mere. I’ve got a job for you,” Steve waves him over, swallowing back another gag. When Luis is within arm’s reach, Steve grabs him by the collar and shoves him beside Scott. “Watch Scott and make sure he finishes up here. Then, go make him lie down. Okay?"
Luis nods vigorously. “Yeah, man, whatever you say. You know, one time back in highschool, I looked after this one sick kid. A week before, I was practicing my trick shots on my hoop in my yard. I’m normally more of a point guard, but I had just gotten some new Jordans and didn’t wanna crease ‘em, you know? My sister saw me and was like, ‘Wow, nice J’s, Luis. I think Daniel has a cousin with a pair just like them.’ Daniel had been my sister’s boyfriend at the time, but they broke up after he cheated with this girl who had a mole the size of a nickel on her—”
“Yeah, that’s great,” Steve cuts him off with a clap to his shoulder. He swiftly grabs your hand and ushers you towards the door. "Make sure you put him on his side!" he adds as he pulls you after him, taking you far away from the disgusting scene still playing out in the kitchen.
Your arm nearly feels like it’s going to be ripped out of its socket as Steve whisks you up the stairs towards his room. Once you’re pulled inside, Steve kicks the door shut behind you, muting the sound of the party still going on below.
Finally secluded from the chaos and mess of the night, you let out an airy breath as you turn around to face him. It’s just you and him now, and you’ll be damned if anything else tries to get in the way of you finally having a good time with Steve.
You take a step closer to him, hoping to backpedal to when you'd been interrupted in the kitchen. “Now… where were we?” you muse, letting your hands drift up his arms, across his shoulders, behind his neck.
Steve mirrors your sentiment by placing his hands on your hips. Luckily for you, he seems to be on the same page of picking up right where you last left off.
“Ah, I think I remember,” you say. “We were right… about… here.” You tug him down to you, connecting your mouths in a heated kiss, your tongue instantly lashing against his, tasting the alcohol still lingering on his taste buds.
“Mmm, mmm,” Steve mumbles against your lips, his fingers tightening on your waist. He pulls back a smidge, breaking the kiss but still keeping his hold on you. “I don’t think we were quite there yet, actually,” he teases. “I believe you were saying something about me having the biggest, thickest… what exactly?”
You roll your eyes and sigh, letting your hands come down to his shoulders. If he wants to continue to be a goof, then two can play at that game.
“Heart, Steve. You have the biggest, thickest, juiciest heart of anyone I’ve ever met," you smile innocently, knowing you both know that wasn't what you'd originally meant to say.
"Whoa, slow your roll there, Hannibal. Don’t go whipping out the steak knife just yet," he laughs. "But is there anything else about me that's particularly well endowed?"
"There is," you nod, still grinning. "That wonderful brain of yours, Steve." You touch his temple lightly, earning you an amused snort. "And don’t forget your big, bright smile, your larger than life charisma, your out of this world leadership skills—”
“Okay, now you’re just giving me a big head.”
“—and… I guess… your muscles aren’t too shabby either,” you say with mock indifference, squeezing his impressive biceps beneath your fingers.
“Oh, what’s this now?” he asks, voice piquing with his curiosity. “Weren’t you the one that was shamelessly ogling me earlier in the night? Practically objectifying me in front of everyone?”
You pull your brows together as if deep in thought, pursing your lips as you pretend to reflect for a second. “No, I don’t recall doing that.” You shake your head.
Steve scoffs and rolls his eyes. “Okay, sure,” he says sarcastically. “But weren’t you the one who, once upon a time, remarked that I could probably ‘throw you around like you weigh nothing’?” He raises a daring brow, reminding you of your words from long ago.
“No, I don’t recall that either,” you lie and shake your head again. “But, if I had said something like that, I’d also note that you’ve yet to prove it to me. I’ve experienced an utter lack of manhandling in our time together,” you faux pout, donning your best ‘wounded puppy’ look. “Maybe you’re not as strong as I thought you were.”
Steve all but groans as he shakes his head incredulously, his expression rapidly clearing of all humor. “What, do you want me to suplex you? Would that do it for ya?” He pulls you closer to him, nodding to his bed over in the corner.
Seeing the way his demeanor switches from silly to sober has you quickly putting a hand up in defense. “Okay, no, I don't actually want to get tossed around like the ol' pigskin,” you snap from your feigned sadness, shifting away from him slightly. Despite how you might joke, that doesn’t sound very fun. It sounds more like a recipe for disaster.
"Then what? What do you want me to do?" Steve releases you and places his hands on his hips. His face reads entirely serious as he stares you down expectantly.
Uh-oh. Now you've done it. You just had to go running your mouth. Now that you've brought it up, you know Steve won't simply let it go; he never does. You've just lit a fire under Steve's ass, and it won't be extinguished until he thinks he's finally proven how strong he is.
"I… I don't know…," you murmur under your breath. You’ve never really thought it through before, and being put on the spot now doesn’t help.
"You want me to rip a phonebook in half? Crush a watermelon with my bare hands?” he offers, taking a step in your direction.
“No, I— Well…” you stop and consider. Can he really do that? Is that even possible?
“Then something else? Cagefighting? Mud wrestling?” He takes another step, another few inches closer.
You step back. “Steve, I don’t know—”
“Then what?” He's right in front of you, practically breathing on you. “What?”
“Bench press,” you say, blurting out the first random thing that comes to mind.
He halts. “Bench press?” he repeats as if he didn't hear you correctly, his brows pinching together. Honestly, you don't blame him for being confused. Where did that come from?
You nod, albeit stiffly.
Steve's eyes rove your form for a moment, his head tilting inquisitively. "You mean you? You want me to bench press you?" he clarifies.
You swallow a sudden lump in your throat. “Mm-hm,” you confirm, though it doesn't sound confident at all.
Seriously, where did that idea come from? Bench pressing? You don't know where or how you got that in your head. Maybe it was because of the competition from earlier, or maybe it was something you overheard someone say, or hell, maybe it's a secret, unconscious desire of yours that Freud would love to psychoanalyze…
Either way, as soon as the words left your mouth, you immediately regretted them.
The second guessing only worsens as you watch Steve lower himself with zero hesitation, drawing his knees up as his back and feet rest against the carpet. You stay firmly rooted to your spot as he gets himself situated on the ground, the uncertainty curdling in your gut.
This is a fucking terrible idea. This is a rush to the ER waiting to happen. This is your fault if – no, when – things go badly.
You’re such an idiot. Why’d you have to spew the first dumb idea that entered your thick skull? Or rather, why’d you have to poke the bear in the first place?
Though you know you won’t be able to sway his mind entirely, maybe you can still suggest something a little less precarious. But what? What should you say? What would be an equal challenge that not only proves Steve's strength, but doesn't involve you cracking your head open as you inevitably tumble to the—
“Well?” Steve prompts, stopping your train of thought.
Fuck. Too late. You're out of time.
He stares up at you, eager to proceed. “What are you waiting for?”
It looks like your bed is made. Now you have to lie in it.
Cautiously, you take small steps as you round Steve, eyeing him as he lays by your feet. Are you really going to do this? Are you really this crazy? This stupid?
Just as the tips of your shoes come to his flank, you find yourself stopping. It's like you're completely frozen – unable to move or even speak.
What's the matter with you? Why are you so scared? You trust Steve, right? He wouldn't let anything happen to you, correct? So really, what do you have to worry about?
A vision of you riding in the back of an ambulance flashes across your mind, and you're quick to whisk it away. Oof.
“C’mon, I don’t bite,” Steve gibes, either not noticing or not caring about your unease. “That is, not unless you—”
“Alright, alright,” you cut him off before he gets a chance to finish the cliché. This was your idea anyway; you might as well get it over with.
You go to lower yourself, but before getting too far, you pause once more. “Just… don’t drop me. Please,” you beg, sending him an anxious look.
“I’ll try not to,” he says genuinely, though that smirk on his face gives his words a teasing edge.
Releasing a pointed breath, you carefully lower yourself into a crab position, your torso hovering over the expanse of Steve’s shoulders. Steve brings his hands up to your body – one high up between your shoulder blades and the other to your upper thighs.
“You ready?” he asks from below you.
Staring up at the wood-paneled ceiling, you nod once, feeling your palms start to sweat as they rest against the shag carpet.
“Okay, on the count of three,” he tells you.
You hold your breath, your heart practically beating out of your chest.
“One… two…”
You yelp as Steve suddenly lifts you into the air, completely ignoring the last number in favor of catching you off guard. He laughs at the surprised noise you make, his hands firmly planted on your body, perfectly confident as they hold you high.
“See? All fine,” he snarks as he begins to lower you to his chest. “Easy peasy.”
You swallow raggedly, your stomach flipping. “Alright, don’t get too coc—” you yelp again as Steve lifts you once more in the air, only to lower you back down not a moment later.
“I’m sorry, what was that? I couldn’t quite hear you,” Steve’s devilish grin bleeds into his voice.
Your nerves fray as shock and fear course through you, the adrenaline streaming through your veins. You want to snap at Steve for toying with you so, for purposefully frightening you, but instead find you can't say anything at all, your lips parted in silent disbelief.
That… wasn't too bad. Of course, you could've done without those initial scares since you didn't find them as funny as he did. But as you catch your breath now, you feel the anxiety slaking away from your body, being replaced by something else entirely. Something akin to warmth. Excitement. Thrill.
Maybe you'll enjoy this more than you thought.
“Again,” you chirp, a grin cresting your mouth. “Keep going!” you urge and reach down to tap Steve’s thigh in encouragement.
“Whoa, careful!” Steve’s hold on you quivers for a moment as your fingers brush a little higher than you expected. “I don’t wanna drop you.”
“You won’t, just keep going!” You give him one more slightly lower tap before bringing your hand back up. Crossing your arms over your chest and extending your legs into a straight line, you wait for Steve to proceed, practically giddy with anticipation.
With an amused ‘hmph’ at your eagerness, Steve obliges and continues with his reps – this time, raising and lowering you in quick succession, not bothering to snark in between.
He maintains a brisk pace as he effortlessly lifts you again and again, showing no sign of slowing down or tiring out. In fact, the only indication that Steve is exerting any real energy is the sound of his breathing – a solitary harsh breath pushed out every time you’re raised up, followed by a deep inhale during your descent.
It's hard to contain your excitement as you let him show off. Why were you so apprehensive about this before? This is exhilarating, damn near electrifying. This might be the most fun you've ever had.
As you hear his breathing start to rasp more, you try to remain as still as possible, wanting to ease his task so you can draw this out for every second available. That, in turn, ends up being a feat all on its own – your legs trembling as you keep them upright, your abdomen tensing in time with his pants, your thighs clenching as his touch gradually inches higher and higher.
A shiver runs through you as Steve’s fingers suddenly curl around your inner thigh, his grip readjusting so he has a better hold on you. The heat of his palm seeps through the thin barrier separating your skin from his, and you feel a similar warmth bloom in your core, his caress igniting something deep within.
Blood pounds in your ears as your focus centers on his hold, his hand wandering dangerously high. You gasp as his fingers suddenly brush the apex of your thighs and your breathing picks up the pace to match Steve's.
You're unsure if he even registers the placement of his hand – those thick digits pressed firmly against you, practically cupping your most intimate area – but fuck if it doesn't feel good. If he does notice how he's touching you, if he feels the way your panties slicken, he makes no move to stop. He just goes on and on and on and on, and it's almost too much to bear.
Your throat constricts as a knot forms in your belly. As much as you're enjoying yourself, you feel like you should say something. You're getting feverishly worked up, and you're not quite sure that's a good thing. The sounds, the sensations, even the smells you're experiencing… It's nearly overwhelming your circuits.
Perhaps you should tell him to stop; tell him you need a break; tell him that if he continues to touch you like that any longer, if he doesn't move his hand away right now, you're afraid you're gonna c—
"Hey, man, do you still have those— Christ!"
Startled, Steve's hold on you slips, Sam's sudden arrival surprising you both. You teeter in the air for a moment before the ground is rapidly coming up to meet you, your head narrowly missing Steve's bed as you tumble. The carpet absorbs little of the impact as you come crashing back down to earth, your hip taking the brunt of the fall. You groan and roll onto your back as Steve quickly sits up, running a hand through his messy hair.
"Damn," Sam says, averting his eyes from you two. "You guys could at least put a sock on the door or something. This room is half mine, you know." The corners of his mouth downturn in disgust, his gaze directed to the upper corner of the bedroom.
"That's not— We weren't—" Steve mutters.
"I don't wanna know," Sam declares with a sweeping hand motion. He sighs deeply through his nose like he's trying to muster up courage. Then carefully, as if he's afraid to look, he peeks back at you two. He relaxes when he realizes you're both decent, and turns to face you more fully. "I just wanted to see if you still have those waxing strips from last year," he says.
Steve's brow furrows in confusion. "I— Why?" That's an odd request.
At the question, a mischievous smirk curves the president's mouth. He leans against the doorway, crossing one arm over the other. "A certain someone might be passed out drunk on the stairs right now, and that someone might wake up with one less eyebrow tomorrow morning."
You can't help the snort that catches in your nose. Oh, that is evil. Hilarious, but evil.
Steve, on the other hand, doesn't seem to find it nearly as amusing. After all, he's had a first-hand encounter with those sticky bastards. "Who?" he asks.
"Don't worry about it," Sam supplies.
"Who?"
Sam rolls his eyes, but relents to Steve's insistence to know. "Let's just say they'll be languishing for weeks to come." His eyes twinkle wickedly.
Steve sighs and shakes his head. For a second, you think he isn't going to be an accomplice to Sam's scheme, especially since he knows how painful those strips are. But after a beat, he says, "Bucky had them last. Go check with him."
Satisfied, Sam nods and quickly backs out of the room. As he pulls the door behind him, he adds, "Make sure you guys air out the room this time. I don't wanna be smelling your funk after you're done."
"We weren't—" Steve tries to explain again, but is cut off by the snap of the door closing.
He sighs again, annoyed, and then turns to you. His eyes narrow as he takes in your disheveled figure, his focus zeroing in on the hand cradling your hip. Sam's interruption apparently made him forget all about dropping you on your ass because his eyes go wide as he finally remembers.
He springs into action, crawling over to you to ghost his fingers over your side. "Shit! Are you alright? Does it hurt?" He touches a particularly tender spot, making him retract his hands as you hiss.
Despite a lingering throb, honestly, it's not too bad. It's definitely not as horrific as you had imagined beforehand. It'll probably just be a minor bruise that'll greet you tomorrow, nothing too serious.
"I've had worse," you say, shifting to lean on the opposite hip.
Steve shakes his head, drawing his lips into a thin line. "Let me get you some ice." He's on his feet in an instant, rapidly making his way to the door.
"No, it's okay," you try to reassure him. You feel fine. You don't need him to go out of his way to fetch you anything.
Unfortunately, your words seem to go in one ear and out the other.
"We should have some in the freezer," Steve notes, more to himself than you. He's just about reached the door when you call out to him.
"Steve," you stress, making him stop dead in his tracks.
As he turns back to face you, you see the concern etched in his brows, the lines framing either side of his mouth. He's worried for you, and it's clear in his tense expression.
"I'm fine," you promise. For emphasis, you sit up a bit, hardly even feeling the dull pain that hammers in your side.
You can tell he doesn't quite believe you, though – his body still poised to run out the door – so you repeat yourself, a little firmer. "I'm fine. Really." You smile tenderly, affectionately, and emit the truth through your eyes.
That seems to do the trick.
Cautiously, Steve takes a small step towards you. "You sure?" he checks one more time.
You nod. "Positive."
Steve breathes a relieved sigh as he returns to you, kneeling beside you on the carpet. "I'm so sorry, baby. I didn't mean to drop you."
Looking into his eyes, you see how remorse streaks his irises, the emotion running deep and wholly earnest. The sight tugs on your heart.
"It's okay. I know," you tell him gently.
You know he would never mean to hurt you, and you know he feels awful for unintentionally doing so. But you're not upset with him; not even a little. Even though you did get a little banged up in this instance, it was technically your fault for suggesting it in the first place. So really, you're not mad.
"Besides," you begin, lounging back down on the rug, "I actually had a lot of fun." Well… right up until the end that is. But that's besides the point.
Steve cocks an intrigued brow, slightly wary of your words. "Really?"
You bite the edge of your lip and nod. "Yeah. While I was a little nervous at first, by the end, I just… I don't know, I…" you trail off, diverting your eyes from his as the memories flash in your mind.
That free feeling as you were suspended in the air, weightless but grounded at the same time; that comforting reassurance of his hands on you, strong and sturdy against your body; that delicious warmth burning in your stomach, hot and hopelessly needy.
You press your thighs together.
"I really liked it," you conclude, meeting his gaze again.
Steve's eyes flit down to your legs before rising once more to your face. A knowing smirk pulls at his lip. "I'll bet," he taunts, a dimple forming in his cheek. He leans closer. "So, does this mean you're convinced? Was that enough manhandling to satisfy you?" he reminds you of the reason you got into this predicament in the first place.
"Mmm…," you hum, feigning timidity that you both know is a ruse. After a beat, you shrug. "I suppose."
"You 'suppose'?" His smirk deepens at your poor attempt to seem indifferent. He huffs and sits back. "Well, I'd be happy to do it again… and again… and again. As long as it takes until you're satisfied," his intonation hints at a double meaning behind his words.
At his innuendo, you quickly shake your head in dissent, and Steve's smile immediately falls.
"As much as I had fun and wouldn't mind trying again in the future," you say, telling him this isn't the last time, "I think, at least for the time being," you husk and bat your lashes, "it'd be better if you’re on top."
Now it's your turn to smirk as you let your own double entendre sink in. It doesn't take Steve long to get it, and when he does, his mouth similarly curls at the corners.
Steve seems to be right in line with you as he extends his hand to help you to your feet. Glad to see his enthusiasm, you reach for him, excitement tingling in your fingertips.
Your hand grazes his, but before you can grab on, Steve reaches past you to plunge his arm under the bed.
Your face twists in confusion. "What the hell?" you gasp as you watch him root around under his bed, apparently in search of something.
After a moment, Steve pulls his arm back out, a discarded gym sock clenched in his grasp. He stands and makes his way to the door. "Sam told us to put a sock on the door, so I’m grabbing the one for 'special time'," he explains. Quickly, he ties the fabric around the outside handle, closing and locking the door once finished.
You roll your eyes as he turns back to face you. You thought that only happened in movies.
"Hey, just be glad I didn’t grab Sam’s ‘special time’ sock," Steve says, reapproaching you. "That has an entirely different purpose."
Before you have time to cringe at the thought, Steve lifts you around the waist and tosses you on the bed, knocking the wind from you. He crawls up after you and covers your body with his, eyes smoldering as he nestles between your legs.
"Me on top, huh?" he repeats your words back to you. Brazenly, he lowers his hips so they rest snug against yours, rocking gently so that fire is quickly stoked inside you again.
The action makes your voice catch in your throat. Rendered mute, you find all you can do is nod in response, watching as he grins and dips his head closer.
With his lips a hair’s breadth away, fingers sliding up your sides, Steve whispers, "Sounds easy enough to me."
__________
A/N: You know what else is easy, Steve? *points both thumbs at self* This girl…
Anyway, I'd love to know what you thought! Thank you for reading, and I hope you enjoyed!
111 notes
·
View notes